The pacing is definitely better than the first volume, It's so refreshing how Sasaki just accepts his feelings for Miyano without questionVol. 1 ★★★☆☆
The pacing is definitely better than the first volume, It's so refreshing how Sasaki just accepts his feelings for Miyano without question. I love that he makes such an effort getting to know him. The way Miyano starts questioning his sexuality is also well-done and realistic....more
Meh about (view spoiler)[the amnesia chapter (hide spoiler)]. There's such a drastic tonal difference with the rest of the series so I know it can't be real, but it still made my stomach drop. Now, onto everything else: I absolutely adore these characters and it's a delight to see how much they've grown over the course of the story. As much as I want to see (view spoiler)[Aoki and Ida's college life (hide spoiler)], I understand why it ends here. The series is first and foremost about their high school years, a super formative period of time where you're not sure what you want but you still have to make all these decisions. While college and adult life can be just as confusing, they have a different flavor to it. That said, would still kill for a sequel/spin-off....more
I love Chapter 29. It shows how comfortable they've gotten with each other, to the point where they have a good idea of how the other person feels even when he's not saying it out loud. I don't usually have strong reactions to the stuff I'm reading, but I was jumping up and down when I got to (view spoiler)[the kissing scene (hide spoiler)]. It's very much earned and the buildup is just perfect. Really enjoyed the rest of the volume as well. It drives home how fond they are of each other....more
A good start! I love watching Sasaki pines his little heart out. My one complaint is how the story keeps jumping back and forth from the past and preseA good start! I love watching Sasaki pines his little heart out. My one complaint is how the story keeps jumping back and forth from the past and present; it's confusing and doesn't add more to the story than if it's told chronologically. ...more
One of my favorite volumes so far. Aoki spends so much time agonizing over wheVol. 1 ★★★★☆ Vol. 2 ★★★★☆ Vol. 3 ★★★☆☆ Vol. 4 ★★☆☆☆ Vol. 5 ★★★☆☆ Vol. 6 ★★★☆☆
One of my favorite volumes so far. Aoki spends so much time agonizing over whether Ida is dating him out of pity so it's a nice change of pace to have Ida realize how much he has fallen for Aoki instead. Also, the chapter where Aida meets Hashimoto's parents is so good and funny. While I haven't thought much about what her parents are like, the reveal makes perfect sense and totally explains why she is the way she is....more
Cute as always. At first, I was confused as to why Aoki work part-time for weeks if he's gVol. 1 ★★★★☆ Vol. 2 ★★★★☆ Vol. 3 ★★★☆☆ Vol. 4 ★★☆☆☆ Vol. 5 ★★★☆☆
Cute as always. At first, I was confused as to why Aoki work part-time for weeks if he's going to pick out that present but he probably just want to give himself more options....more
I love how Aoki's friends are so ready to stick up for him after what happened with the tutor. Also, wVol. 1 ★★★★☆ Vol. 2 ★★★★☆ Vol. 3 ★★★☆☆ Vol. 4 ★★☆☆☆
I love how Aoki's friends are so ready to stick up for him after what happened with the tutor. Also, we always see Aoki agonizing over their relationship so it's nice to see Ida jealous for once....more
The story kind of loses steam in this volume. It's just Aoki going back and forth on whether Ida actually likes hiVol. 1 ★★★★☆ Vol. 2 ★★★★☆ Vol. 3 ★★★☆☆
The story kind of loses steam in this volume. It's just Aoki going back and forth on whether Ida actually likes him and why they're even dating. Just feels repetitive when he's already been doing that for the past couple of chapters. That bit finally got resolved so I'm excited to see how the story will evolve going forward....more
Less plot than the last two volumes if possible, but still enjoyable. Aoki and Hashimoto are more honest to their crushes abouVol. 1 ★★★★☆ Vol. 2 ★★★★☆
Less plot than the last two volumes if possible, but still enjoyable. Aoki and Hashimoto are more honest to their crushes about their feelings, with mixed results. The class ski trip has some of the funniest moments of the series so far....more
Kind of surprised that the misunderstanding got cleared up so soon. I thought for sure it'd drag it out for 20 more chapters and get reveaVol. 1 ★★★★☆
Kind of surprised that the misunderstanding got cleared up so soon. I thought for sure it'd drag it out for 20 more chapters and get revealed at the worst possible moment for dramatic effect. Not complaining though, because I hate that trope. The leads are great as usual but I also like Hashimoto and Aida. Their friendships with Aoki really add to the story and I enjoy them just as much as the main romance....more
While the premise is a bit cliche, the story is so fun and cute that I didn't mind in the slightest. Both leads are super endearing and got me rootingWhile the premise is a bit cliche, the story is so fun and cute that I didn't mind in the slightest. Both leads are super endearing and got me rooting for them even though I've known them for a few chapters. I love how sincere and considerate Ida is and can totally understand why Aoki likes him. Also appreciate that Aoki doesn't get hung up on how he's falling for a guy. As for the art, Aruko is great at drawing expressions and her reaction shots are absolutely hilarious. Strong first volume, couldn't ask for more....more
This volume has a lot of rakugo scenes. Unfortunately, they're just not as engaging as the ones in the anime. Other than that, this volumeVol. 1 ★★★★☆
This volume has a lot of rakugo scenes. Unfortunately, they're just not as engaging as the ones in the anime. Other than that, this volume is still good. Bon and Shin have a great dynamic together. Also, I love how young Bon is already such a grumpy old man....more
I loved Let's Go Karaoke! by the same author but wasn't all that impressed with this short story comic collection. The stories are funny at times I loved Let's Go Karaoke! by the same author but wasn't all that impressed with this short story comic collection. The stories are funny at times and can get a little bizarre but overall lack purpose and leave me wanting for more. It took me almost a month to finish because I completely forgot I was reading it. Definitely prefer the stories with Hayashi over the ones with Nikaidou because they have a bit more plot.
One of my favorite comics read this year. Wayama has a knack for comedic timing and capturing emotions. The story has such a wacky premise but managesOne of my favorite comics read this year. Wayama has a knack for comedic timing and capturing emotions. The story has such a wacky premise but manages to stay consistently delightful from start to finish. Even though this is an oneshot, I was surprisingly invested in the characters and really enjoyed their interactions with one another....more
Cute, if a little predictable. Their backstories are well-done and I enjoy the trio's relationship dynamic. That said, I wish the story is longer so tCute, if a little predictable. Their backstories are well-done and I enjoy the trio's relationship dynamic. That said, I wish the story is longer so the romance has more room to develop....more
I appreciate that Higashimura is upfront about not remembering how certain things happen. Even though it breaks the flow of the story, it's more honesI appreciate that Higashimura is upfront about not remembering how certain things happen. Even though it breaks the flow of the story, it's more honest than if she had just made something up. In the end, there's no cathartic ending because life is messy and most things remain unresolved. Still, sensei has undeniably been a massive influence in her life and this series is a beautiful tribute to his memory....more
Funny, but also poignant. Higashimura looks back at the start of her career with fondness and regret. What I like about this series is that way she neFunny, but also poignant. Higashimura looks back at the start of her career with fondness and regret. What I like about this series is that way she never holds back on her older self and is able to look back at her past actions with clarity....more
Last time I started this series, I kept comparing it to the anime and couldn't enjoy it for what it is. This time around, I like it a lot more. The prLast time I started this series, I kept comparing it to the anime and couldn't enjoy it for what it is. This time around, I like it a lot more. The premise is ridiculous and there are tons of funny moments. Right off the bat, you get an idea of what these characters are like as well as their relationship dynamics. On top of that, Kumota's art is fantastic. She's great at capturing emotions, especially smirks: I've never seen a character look so smug. Yotaro is such a goofy guy and it really comes through in his mannerisms. So far, a solid start.
5/29/2022: ★★★☆☆ To be honest, it's hard for me to be objective about this series when I absolutely adore the anime adaptation. While the rakugo scenes definitely translate better when animated, I still think this is a solid first volume and hints just enough at the underlying conflict to keep someone who's new to the story reading. As for the art, Kumota's drawings are expressive and so fun to look at....more
Perfectly captures that period in life when you've just graduated and had to scramble to figure out what you want to do so well. As someone who's goinPerfectly captures that period in life when you've just graduated and had to scramble to figure out what you want to do so well. As someone who's going through the same, I found this volume reassuring....more
![消えた初恋 9 [Kieta Hatsukoi 9]](https://cdn.statically.io/img/i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1658857093l/60738806._SY75_.jpg)
![消えた初恋 8 [Kieta Hatsukoi 8]](https://cdn.statically.io/img/i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1648931113l/59523093._SY75_.jpg)
![消えた初恋 7 [Kieta Hatsukoi 7]](https://cdn.statically.io/img/i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1635883025l/58884395._SY75_.jpg)
Loading...
