Self-governance in generalized exchange. A laboratory experiment on the structural embeddedness of peer punishment. (English) Zbl 1479.91280
Summary: Peer punishment is widely lauded as a decentralized solution to the problem of social cooperation. However, experimental evidence of its effectiveness primarily stems from public good structures. This paper explores peer punishment in another structural setting: a system of generalized exchange. In a laboratory experiment, a repeated four-player prisoner’s dilemma is arranged either in a public good structure or in a circular network of generalized exchange. The experimental results demonstrate that the merits of peer punishment do not extend to generalized exchange. In the public good, peer punishment was primarily altruistic, was sensitive to costs, and promoted cooperation. In generalized exchange, peer punishment was also altruistic and relatively frequent, but did not increase cooperation. While the dense punishment network underlying the public good facilitates norm enforcement, generalized exchange decreases control over norm violators and reduces the capacity of peer punishment. I conclude that generalized exchange systems require stronger forms of punishment to sustain social cooperation.
Keywords:
generalized exchange; peer punishment; cooperation; social networks; embeddedness; laboratory experimentReferences:
| [1] | Fehr, E.; Gintis, H.; Human Motivation and Social Cooperation: Experimental and Analytical Foundations; Annu. Rev. Sociol.: 2007; Volume 33 ,43-64. |
| [2] | Horne, C.; Collective Benefits, Exchange Interests, and Norm Enforcement; Soc. Forces: 2004; Volume 82 ,1037-1062. |
| [3] | Yamagishi, T.; The Provision of a Sanctioning System as a Public Good; J. Personal. Soc. Psychol.: 1986; Volume 51 ,110-116. |
| [4] | Wu, J.-J.; Zhang, B.-Y.; Zhou, Z.-X.; He, Q.-Q.; Zheng, X.-D.; Cressman, R.; Tao, Y.; Costly Punishment Does Not Always Increase Cooperation; Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA: 2009; Volume 106 ,17448-17451. |
| [5] | Dreber, A.; Rand, D.G.; Fudenberg, D.; Nowak, M.A.; Winners Don’t Punish; Nature: 2008; Volume 452 ,348. |
| [6] | Simpson, B.; Willer, R.; Beyond Altruism: Sociological Foundations of Cooperation and Prosocial Behavior; Annu. Rev. Sociol.: 2015; Volume 41 ,43-63. |
| [7] | van Miltenburg, N.; Przepiorka, W.; Buskens, V.; Consensual punishment does not promote cooperation in the six-person prisoner’s dilemma game with noisy public monitoring; PLoS ONE: 2017; Volume 12 . |
| [8] | Bornstein, G.; Weisel, O.; Punishment, Cooperation, and Cheater Detection in “Noisy” Social Exchange; Games: 2010; Volume 1 ,18-33. · Zbl 1311.91068 |
| [9] | Boyd, R.; Gintis, H.; Bowles, S.; Coordinated Punishment of Defectors Sustains Cooperation and Can Proliferate When Rare; Science: 2010; Volume 328 ,617-620. · Zbl 1226.91014 |
| [10] | Diekmann, A.; Przepiorka, W.; Punitive Preferences, Monetary Incentives and Tacit Coordination in the Punishment of Defectors Promote Cooperation in Humans; Sci. Rep.: 2015; Volume 5 ,10321. |
| [11] | Harrell, A.; Simpson, B.; The Dynamics of Prosocial Leadership: Power and Influence in Collective Action Groups; Soc. Forces: 2016; Volume 94 ,1283-1308. |
| [12] | Takahashi, N.; The Emergence of Generalized Exchange; Am. J. Sociol.: 2000; Volume 105 ,1105-1134. |
| [13] | Uehara, E.; Dual Exchange Theory, Social Networks, and Informal Social Support; Am. J. Sociol.: 1990; Volume 96 ,521-557. |
| [14] | Molm, L.D.; Collett, J.; Schaefer, D.; Building Solidarity Through Generalized Exchange: A Theory of Reciprocity; Am. J. Sociol.: 2007; Volume 113 ,205-242. |
| [15] | Lawler, E.J.; Thye, S.R.; Yoon, J.; Social Exchange and Micro Social Order; Am. Sociol. Rev.: 2008; Volume 73 ,519-542. |
| [16] | Simpson, B.; Harrell, A.; Melamed, D.; Heiserman, N.; Negraia, D.V.; The Roots of Reciprocity: Gratitude and Reputation in Generalized Exchange Systems; Am. Sociol. Rev.: 2018; Volume 83 ,88-110. |
| [17] | Leibbrandt, A.; Ramalingam, A.; Sääksvuori, L.; Walker, J.M.; Incomplete Punishment Networks in Public Goods Games: Experimental Evidence; Exp. Econ.: 2015; Volume 18 ,15-37. |
| [18] | Boosey, L.; Isaac, M.R.; Asymmetric Network Monitoring and Punishment in Public Goods Experiments; J. Econ. Behav. Organ.: 2016; Volume 132 ,26-41. |
| [19] | Carpenter, J.; Kariv, S.; Schotter, A.; Network Architecture, Cooperation and Punishment in Public Good Experiments; Rev. Econ. Des.: 2012; Volume 16 ,93-118. · Zbl 1282.91073 |
| [20] | Egas, M.; Riedl, A.; The Economics of Altruistic Punishment and the Maintenance of Cooperation; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2008; Volume 275 ,871-878. |
| [21] | Nikiforakis, N.; Normann, H.-T.; A Comparative Statics Analysis of Punishment in Public-Good Experiments; Exp. Econ.: 2008; Volume 11 ,358-369. · Zbl 1163.91356 |
| [22] | Kollock, P.; Social Dilemmas: The Anatomy of Cooperation; Annu. Rev. Sociol.: 1998; Volume 24 ,183-214. |
| [23] | Yamagishi, T.; Cook, K.S.; Generalized Exchange and Social Dilemmas; Soc. Psychol. Q.: 1993; Volume 56 ,235-248. |
| [24] | Cook, K.S.; Cheshire, C.; Rice, E.; Nakagawa, S.; Social Exchange Theory; Handbook of Social Psychology: New York, NY, USA 2013; ,53-76. |
| [25] | Kuwabara, K.; Cohesion, Cooperation, and the Value of Doing Things Together: How Economic Exchange Creates Relational Bonds; Am. Sociol. Rev.: 2011; Volume 76 ,560-580. |
| [26] | Baker, W.E.; Levine, S.S.; Mechanisms of Generalized Exchange: Towards an Integrated Model (1 October 2013); Work. Pap. Ser.: 2013; . |
| [27] | Willer, R.; Flynn, F.J.; Zak, S.; Structure, Identity, and Solidarity: A Comparative Field Study of Generalized and Direct Exchange; Adm. Sci. Q.: 2012; Volume 57 ,119-155. |
| [28] | Buchan, N.R.; Croson, R.T.A.; Dawes, R.M.; Swift Neighbors and Persistent Strangers: A Cross-Cultural Investigation of Trust and Reciprocity in Social Exchange; Am. J. Sociol.: 2002; Volume 108 ,168-206. |
| [29] | Axelrod, R.; ; The Evolution of Cooperation: New York, NY, USA 1984; . · Zbl 1225.92037 |
| [30] | Raub, W.; Buskens, V.; Corten, R.; Social Dilemmas and Cooperation; Handbuch Modellbildung und Simulation in den Sozialwissenschaften: Wiesbaden, Germany 2015; ,597-626. |
| [31] | Corriveau, L.; Game Theory and the Kula; Ration. Soc.: 2012; Volume 24 ,106-128. |
| [32] | Ekeh, P.P.; ; Social Exchange Theory: The Two Traditions: Cambridge, MA, USA 1974; . |
| [33] | Bearman, P.; Generalized Exchange; Am. J. Sociol.: 1997; Volume 102 ,1383-1415. |
| [34] | Malinowski, B.; ; Argonauts of the Western Pacific: London, UK 1922; . |
| [35] | Greiner, B.; Vittoria Levati, M.; Indirect Reciprocity in Cyclical Networks: An Experimental Study; J. Econ. Psychol.: 2005; Volume 26 ,711-731. |
| [36] | Seinen, I.; Schram, A.; Social Status and Group Norms: Indirect Reciprocity in a Repeated Helping Experiment; Eur. Econ. Rev.: 2006; Volume 50 ,581-602. |
| [37] | Sell, J.; Reese, B.; Chapter 10—Social Dilemma Experiments in Sociology, Psychology, Political Science, and Economics; Laboratory Experiments in the Social Sciences: San Diego, CA, USA 2014; ,225-245. |
| [38] | Voss, T.; Game-Theoretical Perspectives on the Emergence of Social Norms; Social Norms: New York, NY, USA 2001; ,105-136. |
| [39] | Balliet, D.; Mulder, L.B.; Van Lange, P.A.M.; Reward, Punishment, and Cooperation: A Meta-Analysis; Psychol. Bull.: 2011; Volume 137 ,594-615. |
| [40] | Chaudhuri, A.; Sustaining Cooperation in Laboratory Public Goods Experiments: A Selective Survey of the Literature; Exp. Econ.: 2011; Volume 14 ,47-83. |
| [41] | Elster, J.; Fehr on Altruism, Emotion, and Norms; Anal. Krit.: 2005; Volume 27 ,197-211. |
| [42] | Bowles, S.; Gintis, H.; Homo Reciprocans; Nature: 2002; Volume 415 ,125-127. |
| [43] | Fehr, E.; Fischbacher, U.; Gächter, S.; Strong Reciprocity, Human Cooperation, and the Enforcement of Social Norms; Hum. Nat.: 2002; Volume 13 ,1-25. |
| [44] | Ohtsuki, H.; Iwasa, Y.; Nowak, M.A.; Indirect Reciprocity Provides Only a Narrow Margin of Efficiency for Costly Punishment; Nature: 2009; Volume 457 ,79-82. |
| [45] | Gächter, S.; Renner, E.; Sefton, M.; The Long-Run Benefits of Punishment; Science: 2008; Volume 322 ,1510. |
| [46] | Engel, C.; Social Preferences Can Make Imperfect Sanctions Work: Evidence From a Public Good Experiment; J. Econ. Behav. Organ.: 2014; Volume 108 ,343-353. |
| [47] | Masclet, D.; Noussair, C.; Tucker, S.; Villeval, M.-C.; Monetary and Nonmonetary Punishment in the Voluntary Contributions Mechanism; Am. Econ. Rev.: 2003; Volume 93 ,366-380. |
| [48] | Guala, F.; Reciprocity: Weak or Strong? What Punishment Experiments Do (and Do Not) Demonstrate; Behav. Brain Sci.: 2012; Volume 35 ,1-59. |
| [49] | Pedersen, E.J.; Kurzban, R.; McCullough, M.E.; Do Humans Really Punish Altruistically? A Closer Look; Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci.: 2013; Volume 280 ,20122723. |
| [50] | Horne, C.; Cutlip, A.; Sanctioning Costs and Norm Enforcement: An Experimental Test; Ration. Soc.: 2002; Volume 14 ,285-307. |
| [51] | Anderson, C.M.; Putterman, L.; Do Non-Strategic Sanctions Obey the Law of Demand? The Demand for Punishment in the Voluntary Contribution Mechanism; Games Econ. Behav.: 2006; Volume 54 ,1-24. · Zbl 1129.91316 |
| [52] | Carpenter, J.; The Demand for Punishment; J. Econ. Behav. Organ.: 2007; Volume 62 ,522-542. |
| [53] | Rand, D.G.; Nowak, M.A.; The Evolution of Antisocial Punishment in Optional Public Goods Games; Nat. Commun.: 2011; Volume 2 ,434. |
| [54] | Abbink, K.; Gangadharan, L.; Handfield, T.; Thrasher, J.; Peer Punishment Promotes Enforcement of Bad Social Norms; Nat. Commun.: 2017; Volume 8 ,609. |
| [55] | Kitts, J.A.; Collective Action, Rival Incentives, and the Emergence of Antisocial Norms; Am. Sociol. Rev.: 2006; Volume 71 ,235-259. |
| [56] | Herrmann, B.; Thöni, C.; Gächter, S.; Antisocial Punishment Across Societies; Science: 2008; Volume 319 ,1362-1367. |
| [57] | Irwin, K.; Horne, C.; A Normative Explanation of Antisocial Punishment; Soc. Sci. Res.: 2013; Volume 42 ,562-570. |
| [58] | Horne, C.; Irwin, K.; Metanorms and Antisocial Punishment; Soc. Influ.: 2016; Volume 11 ,7-21. |
| [59] | Parks, C.D.; Stone, A.B.; The Desire to Expel Unselfish Members from the Group; J. Personal. Soc. Psychol.: 2010; Volume 99 ,303-310. |
| [60] | Nikiforakis, N.; Noussair, C.; Wilkening, T.; Normative Conflict and Feuds: The Limits of Self-Enforcement; J. Public Econ.: 2012; Volume 96 ,797-807. |
| [61] | Cinyabuguma, M.; Page, T.; Putterman, L.; Can Second-Order Punishment Deter Perverse Punishment?; Exp. Econ.: 2006; Volume 9 ,265-279. |
| [62] | Molm, L.D.; Is Punishment Effective? Coercive Strategies in Social Exchange; Soc. Psychol. Q.: 1994; Volume 57 ,75-94. |
| [63] | Molm, L.D.; ; Coercive Power in Social Exchange: Cambridge, UK 1997; . |
| [64] | Kurzban, R.; DeScioli, P.; O’Brien, E.; Audience Effects on Moralistic Punishment; Evol. Hum. Behav.: 2007; Volume 28 ,75-84. |
| [65] | Raihani, N.J.; Bshary, R.; The Reputation of Punishers; Trends Ecol. Evol.: 2015; Volume 30 ,98-103. |
| [66] | Ule, A.; Schram, A.; Riedl, A.; Cason, T.N.; Indirect Punishment and Generosity Toward Strangers; Science: 2009; Volume 326 ,1701-1704. |
| [67] | Homans, G.C.; ; Social Behavior and its Elementary Form: New York, NY, USA 1974; . |
| [68] | Blau, P.M.; ; Exchange and Power in Social Life: New York, NY, USA 1964; . |
| [69] | Fischbacher, U.; z-Tree: Zurich Toolbox for Ready-made Economic Experiments; Exp. Econ.: 2007; Volume 10 ,171-178. |
| [70] | Greiner, B.; Subject Pool Recruitment Procedures: Organizing Experiments with ORSEE; J. Econ. Sci. Assoc.: 2015; Volume 1 ,114-125. |
| [71] | Fehr, E.; Gächter, S.; Altruistic Punishment in Humans; Nature: 2002; Volume 415 ,137-140. |
| [72] | Simpson, B.; Willer, D.; The Structural Embeddedness of Collective Goods: Connection and Coalitions in Exchange Networks; Sociol. Theory: 2005; Volume 23 ,386-407. |
| [73] | Fehr, E.; Fischbacher, U.; Social Norms and Human Cooperation; Trends Cogn. Sci.: 2004; Volume 8 ,185-190. |
| [74] | Mashima, R.; Takahashi, N.; The Emergence of Generalized Exchange by Indirect Reciprocity; New Issues and Paradigms in Research on Social Dilemmas: Boston, MA, USA 2008; ,159-176. |
| [75] | Baker, W.E.; Bulkley, N.; Paying It Forward vs. Rewarding Reputation: Mechanisms of Generalized Reciprocity; Organ. Sci.: 2014; Volume 25 ,1493-1510. |
| [76] | Tsvetkova, M.; Macy, M.W.; The Social Contagion of Generosity; PLoS ONE: 2014; Volume 9 . |
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.
