Lisa's Reviews > Othello

Othello by William Shakespeare
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: drama, favorites, so-good-it-hurts, unforgettable, shakespeare

“O, beware, my lord, of jealousy;
It is the green-ey'd monster, which doth mock
The meat it feeds on."

This famous quote made my 14-year-old son, reading Othello for the first time (it was his first Shakespeare ever), come into my room to complain. He was deeply frustrated with the sweet tongue of the evil Iago, speaking in one way and acting in another, spreading fake news and rumours while pretending to be supportive and unselfish.

"Iago is even worse than Uriah Heep", he said, referring to a controversy we had about David Copperfield some time ago. "I begin to believe that being 'umble is the most treacherous thing in the world, hiding evil purposes!"

I of course had to go back and reread Othello in a haste to be able to answer properly, and I realised that my son has a point. The truly honest people are not humble, and do not claim to be. They show their strengths, weaknesses and intentions clearly, and play with open cards, only to lose to the characters they consider most 'onest, for being so very 'umble.

It was interesting for me to see that my son reads Othello not so much as a passionate drama based on jealousy, but rather as a political post-truth play, with the most wicked players on stage winning.

Shakespeare certainly put both jealousy and politics into the plot, and young people who begin their path towards political understanding of the world now, post-2016, feel more strongly about the lying, the manipulation, the slander than about the unreasonable reaction to the suspicion of faithlessness.

For me, reading Shakespeare with more pleasure now than ever, it is proof that his voice is universal and timeless, and that he speaks to yet another generation of readers, just like Dickens.

Unfortunately, we can't write our villains into prisons in the end like Dickens and Shakespeare!
155 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Othello.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 25, 2014 – Shelved
January 16, 2017 – Shelved as: drama
January 16, 2017 – Shelved as: favorites
January 16, 2017 – Shelved as: so-good-it-hurts
January 16, 2017 – Shelved as: unforgettable
April 17, 2018 – Shelved as: shakespeare

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Dolors A 14 year-old reading Shakespeare and raising such questions is something to celebrate... Congratulations for that, Lisa!!


Lisa Dolors wrote: "A 14 year-old reading Shakespeare and raising such questions is something to celebrate... Congratulations for that, Lisa!!"

Update: He just stormed in five minutes ago, asking me in the doorway if I had finished rereading the play. He had got to Act 5 on the train (commuting with classics is a family tradition as well), and considered Iago more and more "obvious" now. Teenagers always have to "figure it out for themselves".


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Your children are indeed most privileged, what a joy to read about your Shakespearian discourse with your fourteen year old son. Love the “umble” and the “onest” ;-) Thank you Lisa for this lovely review.


Dolors Lisa wrote: "Dolors wrote: "A 14 year-old reading Shakespeare and raising such questions is something to celebrate... Congratulations for that, Lisa!!"

Update: He just stormed in five minutes ago, asking me in..."


Heh, but isn't it great when they reach the right conclusion on their own? You must be very proud, Lisa!


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "What lucky children to grow up in such a learned environment. You never cease to amaze me, Lisa!"

It is just the way we live, Jean-Paul. In books we trust ;-)
The funny thing is that I always see it the other way round. It's me being lucky to have children around to share the imagination. That is the one thing I miss sorely from my old job: daily talk to kids about history and literature. The rest was soul destroying...


Lisa Heidi wrote: "Your children are indeed most privileged, what a joy to read about your Shakespearian discourse with your fourteen year old son. Love the “umble” and the “onest” ;-) Thank you Lisa for this lovely ..."

Thank you, Heidi! It is a two-way road. Sharing, talking, discussing is my privilege as well. I try to keep the spirit alive, and sometimes now, they give me suggestions. That is the greatest joy!


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Jean-Paul wrote: "What lucky children to grow up in such a learned environment. You never cease to amaze me, Lisa!"

It is just the way we live, Jean-Paul. In books we trust ;-)
The fu..."

Yes, dear friend, you are absolutely right. Thank you for your kind words, well needed!


message 8: by Ken (new)

Ken Many moons since I read this. Many...


Lisa Ken wrote: "Many moons since I read this. Many..."

When you were 14 maybe? Great age to start, according to my boy...


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lada wrote: "You raise problems in your wonderful reviews Lisa of pertinence of litterary thought and creation.Lovely review. Shakespeare and Dickens , two great literary individuals with their particular langu..."

Two of my favourites for sure. And I am working on the next generation. Uriah Heep certainly is well-known to my younger children as well.


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Lada wrote: "Uriah Heap and Othello'-Iago True characters of uncommon originality raising equivocal questions of lias and truth Certainly very attractive for new and young readers"

Yes, I try to pick books with captivating, timeless characters to make sure my kids stay engaged!


message 12: by Steve (new)

Steve Your son's insights are evidently a heritable trait, Lisa. That must be gratifying (and please don't deflect the compliment to you both by playing 'umble). :-) I liked the bit about fake news, as well as your joint thoughts on Iago and Uriah Heep.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Steve wrote: "Your son's insights are evidently a heritable trait, Lisa. That must be gratifying (and please don't deflect the compliment to you both by playing 'umble). :-) I liked the bit about fake news, as w..."

I will 'umbly accept the 'onest compliment then, as you outwitted me with my own argument...


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

How does Shakespeare manage to be so profound so often in so many, if not all, of his plays? Thank you for that insightful review


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Joudy wrote: "How does Shakespeare manage to be so profound so often in so many, if not all, of his plays? Thank you for that insightful review"

Thank you, Joudy! I couldn't agree more! And even when I expect a "problem play", like in The Winter's Tale, I am completely overwhelmed with the contemporary relevance of his characters!


message 16: by Michael (new)

Michael Tolle Review; und wie schön, dass Literatur für deinen Sohn nichts Abgehobenes ist, sondern etwas, womit man sich auseinandersetzt und was man diskutiert. Wo er das wohl her hat?
Hat er schon einen GR-Account?


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Michael wrote: "Tolle Review; und wie schön, dass Literatur für deinen Sohn nichts Abgehobenes ist, sondern etwas, womit man sich auseinandersetzt und was man diskutiert. Wo er das wohl her hat?
Hat er schon einen..."


Er ist ein begeisterter Leser, aber ich möchte, dass er bis 16 oder 17 wartet, einen GR-Account aufzumachen. Zu Hause wird aber kräftig diskutiert, vor allem am Mittagstisch! Und oft ziehe ich gegen die drei den Kürzeren...


Kevin Ansbro Love this review, Lisa.
Iago is one of literature's greatest characters, without a shadow of a doubt!


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Kevin wrote: "Love this review, Lisa.
Iago is one of literature's greatest characters, without a shadow of a doubt!"


Oh yes - such a snake!


message 20: by Dimitri (new)

Dimitri Smart kid, I was stuck in YA at that age :-(


message 21: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Dimitri wrote: "Smart kid, I was stuck in YA at that age :-("

He's definitely more into quality than I was that age as well. Very nice for me to have him to discuss things...


Yaaresse Wait..what? Wow.
Now I need to revisit Othello with this new POV in mind.


message 23: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Yaaresse wrote: "Wait..what? Wow.
Now I need to revisit Othello with this new POV in mind."


The beauty of Shakespeare lies in the fact that he offers new points of view to readers of all generations!


Chris Chapman Indeed congratulations to your son for his intellectual curiosity Lisa! And his anger at dishonesty. This is what gives me hope despite the times. It may be so that we are in a post-truth world where emotions are more important in politics. But if that is the case I do believe the days of the populists will eventually be numbered. Because the young future voters have a very strong emotional reaction against dishonesty. And rejecting lies is where we can combine an emotional response and a demand for truth. Maybe this was also the case in Shakespeare’s time; at the beginning of the play he seems to predict Iago’s downfall when he says “for when my outward action doth demonstrate / the native act and figure of my heart / in compliment extern, ‘tis not long after / but I will wear my heart upon my sleeve / for daws to peck at: I am not what I am.”


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Chris wrote: "Indeed congratulations to your son for his intellectual curiosity Lisa! And his anger at dishonesty. This is what gives me hope despite the times. It may be so that we are in a post-truth world whe..."

Love the quote you picked there, Chris! Shows how deeply Shakespeare saw into human personalities - long before we had medical terms to describe our inner messes!!


Chris Chapman Yes and you can never tell if he invented these expressions or not. He Invented so many, but I guess some may have been around at the time. In my Brewster‘s book of phrase and fable, when I look up ‘wear your heart on your sleeve’ it quotes this one from Othello...


back to top