Dolors's Reviews > Othello

Othello by William Shakespeare
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: read-in-2015, getting-to-know-shakespeare, best-ever
Read 2 times. Last read June 7, 2015 to November 14, 2015.

“The trust, the office I do hold of you
Not only take away, but let your sentence
Even fall upon my life.”
Act I, Scene 3.

This is the Othello the reader meets at the beginning of this tragedy. The Renaissance ideal, an archetypal hero, sure of himself, valiant and honorable, in complete self-control when falsely accused of forcing fair Desdemona, the daughter of a nobleman, to marry him. When confronted by the Duke, his defense plea shines with splendid poetry, calm dignity and the voice of reason, charming everybody who listens to his refined soliloquy.
But Othello is also a black African, known as The Moor, a General in the Venetian Army and a Christian. He is the epitome of many stereotypical paradoxes that coexist in him that somehow anticipate disaster, for there are evil forces that lure the gullible man to give way to the savage instincts of his double nature.
Ironically, Othello’s word is taken at face value in Act I, no sentence is imposed on him and his life is spared but his vows become darkly prophetic when he doesn’t grant innocent Desdemona the same just treatment in the brutal Act V.

“O perjured woman! Thou dost stone my heart,
And mak’st me call what I intend to do
A murder, which I thought a sacrifice.”
Act V, Scene 2.

This is the other Othello, the barbarous beast that possesses the man and transforms him into a “civil monster”, into his opposite image, the good Christian “turning Turk”, the “forked-animal”, who blinded by rage and jealousy, kills his wife Desdemona believing she has been unfaithful to him with lieutenant Cassio.
At the root of such violent development, there is the malignant Iago, the most villain of villains whose whole “raison d’être” is wickedness. Never a character was so duplicitous in his machinations, his “direct and honest” glib moralizing so overtly treacherous and his misanthropy so sublimely revealed in the perpetual flow of verbal splendor that blooms in his lines, where there is place for rhymed oaths, sexual puns and degrading animal imagery.

“To show the love and duty that I bear you
With franker spirit. Therefore, as I am bound,
Receive it from me. I speak not yet of proof.
Look to your wife; observe her well with Cassio.”
Act III, Scene 3.

“Love and duty” are at odds and radically confronted in this strangely powerful yet moving tragedy. One can locate them between father and daughter, husband and wife, General and official. But as it’s usual in Shakespeare’s plays, the dramaturge’s main intention remains elusive, for beyond the Christian myth of the temptation scene and the ploys of the devil that influenced centuries of sermons, legends and fables, beyond the crime of passion, there is a pattern of interacting opposites; black vs white, Christian vs Pagan, civilized vs dehumanized, honest vs two-faced; that denotes a superb psychological realism, which echoes with racial prejudice and the inequality in gender relations.

Making virtuous use of symbols, an allegoric storm that separates Othello and Desdemona at sea anticipating Iago’s “foul ad violent” designs, or the macabre incantation of Emilia’s summoning of the General “My Lord, my lord!” when she enters the bedchamber where Desdemona has just pleaded for her life screaming “O Lord, Lord, Lord!” before being mercilessly smothered to death, Shakespeare’s language mesmerizes with stylistic brilliance, intricate syntax and inner rhythms. It is this sumptuous style, which oscillates between majestic control and wild rage, that reflects Othello’s double nature and his tormented love for noble-hearted Desdemona, giving imaginative veracity to the action that won’t fail to moisten the eyes of the most detached of audiences when the fallen hero consumed by “pure grief” seals his own fate with anguished lines that will pierce through the heart of anyone whose love has topped extremity, enough to temporally madden the most lucid of minds. Words never felt more unjust and sublime than in Shakespeare's tragedies:

“Cold, cold, my girl,
Even like thy chastity.
O cursed, cursed slave! Whip me, ye devils,
From the possession of this heavenly sight!
Blow me about in winds! Roast me in sulphur!
Wash me in steep-down gulf of liquid fire!
O Desdemon! Dead Desdemon! Dead! O! O!”

81 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Othello.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
April 5, 2015 – Shelved
April 6, 2015 –
page 34
23.13% "Iago sneers at Othello and deliberately chooses evil:

"The Moor is of a free and open nature,
That thinks men honest that but seem to be so,
And will as tenderly be led by th' nose
As asses are.
I have't. It is engendered. Hell and night
Must bring this monstrous birth to the world's light.""
April 8, 2015 –
page 111
75.51% ""Othello: A hornèd man's a monster and a beast. Iago: There's many a beast then in a populous city, And many a civil monster.""
April 9, 2015 –
page 147
100.0% ""I kissed thee, ere I killed thee: no way but this,
Killing myself, to die upon a kiss.""
June 7, 2015 – Started Reading
November 14, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-34 of 34 (34 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lynne (last edited Nov 15, 2015 03:16AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynne King Bravo Dolors,

Such fire in your review. I love it and also the aspects of symbolism!

You must have had a good weekend!


message 2: by Deea (new)

Deea The fact that you love Shakespeare's writing can be no secret to anyone who reads your reviews. Your passion transpires through the lines. How many more do you have left?


message 3: by David (new)

David Gustafson I have not seen Othello for many years. Your wonderful review brought the characters back on stage.


message 4: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Its good, its so good to come back to a Dolors' review after a painful, forced hiatus. Much like your review though, I feel able to bear the dualities of life a little better, if not with the same bravado as of Shakespeare's Othello. You bring out the dichotomies of this much-loved-much-hated protagonist to light with your quintessential prodding pen, also granting him some farewell dignity for remnant guilt. Beautifully done, dearie... you remind of a the good and the bad with a soothing balm of words.


message 5: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo I haven't read the play yet, but it sounds one of the most complete of all. A controversial piece with the characteristic beauty of Shakespeare's writing. I personally wouldn't like to feel that kind of blinding love, if we can really call it love.
Your depiction of Othello's dual character is sublime, and your words on Iago left me perplexed, for one can't understand such vileness, not even in literature.
Words make a difference, and yours, Dolors, those words filled with magic, humble erudition and passion for literature, make of my stay in GR a delightful experience. :)


Dolors Lynne wrote: "Bravo Dolors,

Such fire in your review. I love it and also the aspects of symbolism!

You must have had a good weekend!"


The weekend didn't start off on the right foot due to the tragic news of the terrorist attacks in Paris, but I took refuge in words and music, and as usual, they offered the best company and soothing comfort. Thanks for reading Lynne, glad you enjoyed my musings on this tragedy! :)


message 7: by Dolors (last edited Nov 15, 2015 09:43AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Deea wrote: "The fact that you love Shakespeare's writing can be no secret to anyone who reads your reviews. Your passion transpires through the lines. How many more do you have left?"

A bunch of thanks for reading, Deea. I still have all the historical plays to go through. I recently read Julius Caesar and hope to continue with Antony and Cleopatra before the year ends. I envision re-reading the plays I covered this year very often though, there is so much to discover with every new read of the Bard's elusive plays!:))


Dolors David wrote: "I have not seen Othello for many years. Your wonderful review brought the characters back on stage."

Glad your memories were rekindled by my personal ramblings, David. Shakespeare is an author I expect to visit and re-visit in years to come.


message 9: by Dolors (last edited Nov 15, 2015 09:48AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Seemita wrote: "Its good, its so good to come back to a Dolors' review after a painful, forced hiatus. Much like your review though, I feel able to bear the dualities of life a little better, if not with the same ..."

Oh Seemita...welcome back! I was wondering just the other day where you where hiding (view spoiler). There is no dichotomy, no duality or contradiction in the comfort and bliss that your presence brings to this page, my dearest friend. I hope you might be able to settle down for a while to post one of your otherworldly reviews that will caress my spirit and prickle my unquenchable curiosity sometime soon, Seemita. You've been acutely missed and I am thrilled to listen to the sound of your pristine, melodic prose once again! :)


message 10: by Dolors (last edited Nov 15, 2015 10:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Florencia wrote: "I haven't read the play yet, but it sounds one of the most complete of all. A controversial piece with the characteristic beauty of Shakespeare's writing. I personally wouldn't like to feel that ki..."

Florencia, your comments bring me burst of sheer joy. Your remark about a blinding love that oppresses the beloved hits Shakespeare's moral dilemmas on its head. Underneath the drama, the lyrical dialogues that read almost like stanzas in a sonnet, the obscure motivation of the characters; there is the core of the clashing parcels that constitute the human mind, which are shrewdly represented in The Bard's plays, maybe most overtly in his tragedies.
As weird as it might sound, I sympathized with the bestial Othello, who swept off his feet by an extreme, unbearable jealousy, which is nothing but a twisted, defective form of love, commits the biggest mistake of his life and sentences not only Desdemona's but also his noble spirit to unredeemable condemnation.
I guess I enjoy Shakespeare so much because he blends the existentialist and the romantic with such ease that it's very difficult to draw the line between the two in his plays... that smudged result is so akin to our flawed nature that it feels like home.
Thank you as always for your unfaltering supportive comments and for contributing into making every reading experience more wholesome and significant with your careful remarks.


message 11: by [deleted user] (last edited Nov 15, 2015 05:11PM) (new)

Blow me about in the winds of your words! Dolors, your review mirrors the evolution of Othello's temperament: at first, calm; at the end, a maelstrom of passion. Your own plea on behalf of this book shines with poetry. Despite the terrible horror of this tale, this is one of my favorite plays. It is the private tragedy of character--Othello's swift descent into jealousy and rage and Iago's dazzling display of villainy--rather than a tragedy that affects the affairs of state. With horror, we realize how often we turn against and hate those who love us most. With horror, we realize how our perception is deluded by a mere stolen handkerchief and a few words, strategically delivered. Upon such flimsy information, we make our worst choices. I choose to read Shakespeare, so that I might better recognize myself, my Desdemona, and my Iago. Your review, so well constructed and detailed, makes me want to drop what I am doing to race back to the honey words of Shakespeare that pierce me to the quick and bestow upon me the wisdom needed to live the examined life.


Dolors Steve wrote: "Blow me about in the winds of your words! Dolors, your review mirrors the evolution of Othello's temperament: at first, calm; at the end, a maelstrom of passion. Your own plea on behalf of this boo..."

Only you could have drawn a picture where the reader recognizes Desdemona, Iago and Othello in himself at once, Steve. Your words are so fitting to Shakespeare's multilayered tragedies that they even give the impression to rhyme, in sound and in substance.
Also, your remark about the detailed psychological portrait of the characters as individuals and their evolution is incredibly timely when compared to other of Shakespeare's plays like Macbeth, King Lear and, of course, even more obvious in his historical works like Julius Caesar (which I recently finished), where the private persona and the public image of the iconic Roman ruler collide incessantly, finding a bizarre equilibrium in the last act.
Steve, your commentaries are a joy to read, without exception, for you don't only read, you comprehend the subtleties that remain veiled in-between the lines and you elevate them high enough for others to marvel at their importance. Thank you for doing that ALL the time, with grace and intellect, in and out of this page.


message 13: by Alan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alan "The TRUST.." not "Thrust"


message 14: by Henry (last edited Nov 16, 2015 07:56AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Henry Avila It is a maxim that people are blind , they only see what their hearts want to believe. .. the truth is ignored. A delicate, shining review, into human nature, Dolors.


Dolors Alan wrote: ""The TRUST.." not "Thrust""

Thanks for your contribution.


Dolors Henry wrote: "It is a maxim that people are blind , they only see what their hearts want to believe. .. the truth is ignored. A delicate, shining review, into human nature, Dolors."

Glad you enjoyed the review, Henry. Othello is my favorite tragedy next to King Lear, a work I expect to revisit many times in the future.


message 17: by Ted (new)

Ted A review to come back and re-read, Dolors. The comments from your fans and friends are beautiful too, showing as they do the best of the circle of perceptive readers that are connected together here - expressing such warm feelings for one another's writings and persons. ;)


message 18: by Dolors (last edited Nov 16, 2015 09:43AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Ted wrote: "A review to come back and re-read, Dolors. The comments from your fans and friends are beautiful too, showing as they do the best of the circle of perceptive readers that are connected together her..."

People are the best thing of GR, Ted (view spoiler), and I think the best people tend to be good readers! ;P
Thanks for reading and always finding a moment to drop a kind line. I would have never expected to learn so much and have such great fun at once.


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

Exquisite review, Dolors. Loved your analysis of Othello's character.


Dolors Thanks again for reading and dropping such a generous comment, Sidharth! I was enthralled by the tragic passion that consumed Othello and blinded his rationality, one of my fav plays do far!:)


message 21: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Pure class again, this review, Dolors, I love the agonizing end quote and your poignant view on Iago, the fascinating villain. How Evil can triumph by the poisonous, destructive power of some softly muttered words about a handkerchief! I haven’t read the play yet, but attended the gorgeous opera adaptation by Verdi. Verdi, always looking to world literature for inspiration, admired Shakespeare above any other dramatist and called him the master of the human heart, two copies of his plays being next to his bed. On Shakespeare he wrote He is a favorite poet of mine whom I have had in my hands from earliest youth, and whom I read an reread constantly’. I imagine you and Verdi having marvelous conversations on the Bard:-).


message 22: by Lily (new)

Lily Your reviews of Shakespeare are always so fascinating and thoughtful! :) I really enjoyed your analysis of the dualities here.


Dolors Ilse wrote: "Pure class again, this review, Dolors, I love the agonizing end quote and your poignant view on Iago, the fascinating villain. How Evil can triumph by the poisonous, destructive power of some softl..."

Thanks a bunch for that sumptuous comment, Ilse. My mouth was salivating only to imagine the sonorous texture of the Bard's lines adapted to a Verdi opera in live. Two geniuses looking each other in the eye and understanding that art, be it through words, music or brush, is the means to express the complexities of the human nature. Heh, it wouldn't be the first time I envision myself speaking to dead writers or composers, and so your kind remark about a possible meet-up with Verdi to debate The Bard makes me soar cloud high with pleasure. Thanks for your elevating works, Ilse! :)


Dolors Lily wrote: "Your reviews of Shakespeare are always so fascinating and thoughtful! :) I really enjoyed your analysis of the dualities here."

Thrilled that you were piqued enough to read this review, Lily. Othello is one of my fav tragedies precisely because the personal dualities are most obvious than in other plays by the Bard. Thanks a bunch for your lovely words here! :)


message 25: by Himanshu (new)

Himanshu Exquisite, this review, Dolors. After finishing reading your review with that last piercing verse, I feel as if I just came out of a theater after watching an engrossing play of one of the Bard's most famous. I see that this is your second read, so I assume, this time it was more like a sumptuous second date and a glass of that perfect wine making it a riveting experience.


Dolors Himanshu wrote: "Exquisite, this review, Dolors. After finishing reading your review with that last piercing verse, I feel as if I just came out of a theater after watching an engrossing play of one of the Bard's m..."

It's your comment that is exquisite, Himanshu, more than the best of wine! ;P
I have fallen hard for Shakespeare, he's been the greatest literary discovery of the year (yeah, I know, I would be a lousy investigator) and I am trying to catch all the performances of his plays that are planned to show in Barcelona (went to a musical adaptation of "Much Ado About Nothing" last Saturday and "Hamlet" is scheduled for next April), but while I wait I am slowly catching up with his most famous works. I read "Othello" before the summer, but I was called again to revise it because of some footnotes of the edition of T.S. Elliot's collected poetry that I recently read. I also plan on re-reading "Macbeth" and "King Lear" sometime soon. Thanks for the generous words, my friend, I hope things are going at full blast in all possible senses at your end! :))


message 27: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Ah, Othello… Dear, dear, Othello. It was he who made me fall in love with this control and rage balance that you speak about in Shakespearean plays, this balance of the tortured soul. Later, I was also lured by this in Hamlet. Everything is at odds in this play, even Othello is at odds with himself. What an arousing review, Dolors. I'm glad he stole your heart as he did mine. I echo Himanshu's response.


message 28: by Dolors (last edited Nov 18, 2015 10:50PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Cheryl wrote: "Ah, Othello… Dear, dear, Othello. It was he who made me fall in love with this control and rage balance that you speak about in Shakespearean plays, this balance of the tortured soul. Later, I was ..."

What a great recapitulation of the opposites that coexist in this particular tragedy, that strikes at a most personal level in comparison to the others, you paint in that commentary Cheryl. I was also torn between the fierce passion and the bestial tantrums that divided Othello in two individuals that could also represent metaphorical stereotypes about race, gender and religion (some of Othello's lines reminded me of the subjugated Caliban in "The Tempest"). Thanks for your validating words, Cheryl, I hope life is regaining its balance at your end.


message 29: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Thank you, Dolors. If you ever consider attending the opera, there will presumably be performances of Verdi’s Otello all over the world in 2016, in commemoration of the 400th anniversary of Shakespeare's death.


Dolors Ilse wrote: "Thank you, Dolors. If you ever consider attending the opera, there will presumably be performances of Verdi’s Otello all over the world in 2016, in commemoration of the 400th anniversary of Shakesp..."

Thrilled to hear that, Ilse. I didn't see a performance scheduled for this season in the Barcelona Opera House, but I will double check in other spots around the city.


message 31: by Gautam (new)

Gautam Stellar review, Dolors! :)


Dolors Thanks for your energetic and supportive words, Gautam!:)))


Edward Fantastic review, Dolors. There is so much in this play that can be analysed and broken apart, and interpreted in so many different ways.


Dolors Edward wrote: "Fantastic review, Dolors. There is so much in this play that can be analysed and broken apart, and interpreted in so many different ways."

Thanks for reading Edward. I found your triple analysis of the motives behind the fated actions of his unorthodox heroes Hamlet, Macbeth and Othello that you compare in your review tremendously spot-on. Glad to see the Bard is consistent in keeping you entertained, but I hope he will eventually surprise you when you least expect it! ;P


back to top