Kim's Reviews > The Narrow Road to the Deep North
The Narrow Road to the Deep North
by
Although Richard Flanagan has been on the edge of my consciousness for years, this is the first of his novels I've read and I may not have read it at all (or at least not so soon after publication) if it hadn't been given to me as a gift.
The novel is about .... what? Life, death, despair, loneliness, love, connection, redemption, poetry. It’s a grim work, centred on the experiences of the Australian prisoners of war who were used as slave labour in the construction of the Thailand-Burma railway during World War II. In writing the novel, Flanagan drew on the experiences of his father, a survivor of that horrific ordeal, and the public life of his central protagonist is clearly inspired by that of the legendary Weary Dunlop.
The narrative moves back and forward in time and is mostly from the point of view of Dorrigo Evans, an Australian surgeon whose life is shaped by a love of literature, by an early, passionate affair with his uncle’s wife and by his wartime experiences. There are other perspectives as well: those of fellow prisoners, of Japanese guards, of Evans’ wife and of his lover. The prose is poetic but unflinching in its description of the unspeakable horrors faced by prisoners of war who worked on “the Line”.
This is a grim tale, with few light moments. It’s not an enjoyable book to read, but it is a powerful one. For me, though, the emotional effect of the work came not from developing a connection with the characters, from whom I felt a certain distance, but from the situation they found themselves in. That said, this is a novel which will haunt me for some time. I’ve given it five stars for that reason alone.
ETA: Readers interested in what inspired this work may like to read this article by the author.
by
Although Richard Flanagan has been on the edge of my consciousness for years, this is the first of his novels I've read and I may not have read it at all (or at least not so soon after publication) if it hadn't been given to me as a gift.
The novel is about .... what? Life, death, despair, loneliness, love, connection, redemption, poetry. It’s a grim work, centred on the experiences of the Australian prisoners of war who were used as slave labour in the construction of the Thailand-Burma railway during World War II. In writing the novel, Flanagan drew on the experiences of his father, a survivor of that horrific ordeal, and the public life of his central protagonist is clearly inspired by that of the legendary Weary Dunlop.
The narrative moves back and forward in time and is mostly from the point of view of Dorrigo Evans, an Australian surgeon whose life is shaped by a love of literature, by an early, passionate affair with his uncle’s wife and by his wartime experiences. There are other perspectives as well: those of fellow prisoners, of Japanese guards, of Evans’ wife and of his lover. The prose is poetic but unflinching in its description of the unspeakable horrors faced by prisoners of war who worked on “the Line”.
This is a grim tale, with few light moments. It’s not an enjoyable book to read, but it is a powerful one. For me, though, the emotional effect of the work came not from developing a connection with the characters, from whom I felt a certain distance, but from the situation they found themselves in. That said, this is a novel which will haunt me for some time. I’ve given it five stars for that reason alone.
ETA: Readers interested in what inspired this work may like to read this article by the author.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Narrow Road to the Deep North.
Sign In »
Quotes Kim Liked
“A good book ... leaves you wanting to reread the book. A great book compels you to reread your own soul.”
― The Narrow Road to the Deep North
― The Narrow Road to the Deep North
Reading Progress
September 23, 2013
– Shelved
October 19, 2013
–
Started Reading
November 1, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Michael
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Nov 02, 2013 05:10PM
Well said on the 5 star qualities of the book. Good to hear such good favor about a book I hadn't heard of by an author I am pursuing. Loved Gould's Book of Fish, coving madness, art, and fighting the erasure of history at a colonial prison camp in Tasmania. Just got his "Death of a River Guide."
reply
|
flag
Michael wrote: "Well said on the 5 star qualities of the book...."
Thanks, Michael. Chances are that you haven't heard of this book because it was published so recently. You may be interested in reading an article Flanagan wrote about the process of writing the novel. I've added a link to it in my review.
I've planned to read both "Gould's Book of Fish" and "Death of a River Guide" for years and never got around to it. Now might just be the time!
Thanks, Michael. Chances are that you haven't heard of this book because it was published so recently. You may be interested in reading an article Flanagan wrote about the process of writing the novel. I've added a link to it in my review.
I've planned to read both "Gould's Book of Fish" and "Death of a River Guide" for years and never got around to it. Now might just be the time!
I like to think books that shake readers as some sort of miraculous atonement for the suffering and injustice endured by others. Their lives wont ever be restored to them, but at least with each new reader, another testimony is born, making their voices eternal.
Your review reminded me of my own sensations when I turned the last page of Morrison's "Beloved." Only for that reason, I am adding the novel to my TBR pile on the spot. Thanks for bringing it to my attention, Kim.
Your review reminded me of my own sensations when I turned the last page of Morrison's "Beloved." Only for that reason, I am adding the novel to my TBR pile on the spot. Thanks for bringing it to my attention, Kim.
Thank you for your comment, Dolors. What you say is very insightful and a beautiful way to characterise the importance of the kind of fiction that keeps history alive.
I can highly recommend The Sound of One Hand Clapping by Richard. I read it many years ago and it was a compelling heartfelt emotional and beautiful read. I wept with such emotion at the end....
Margi wrote: "I can highly recommend The Sound of One Hand Clapping by Richard. I read it many years ago and it was a compelling heartfelt emotional and beautiful read. I wept with such emotion at the end...."
Thanks for that suggestion, Margi. I vaguely remember when "The Sound of One Hand Clapping" was published, but I didn't seek it out. I'll add it to the list now!
Thanks for that suggestion, Margi. I vaguely remember when "The Sound of One Hand Clapping" was published, but I didn't seek it out. I'll add it to the list now!
Thank you for rhat article. Halfway through and I think it will be a wonderful, important book. The back story makes it more poignant.
I have five of his novels (and read three of them so far). He is a great writer and I'm keeping my fingers crossed he'll win this year's Booker...
Marialyce wrote: "Just starting this one. Loved your review"
Thanks Marialyce. I hope you like it. It's rather a tough read.
Thanks Marialyce. I hope you like it. It's rather a tough read.
Booklovinglady wrote: "... He is a great writer and I'm keeping my fingers crossed he'll win this year's Booker..."
Me too!
Me too!
Tracey wrote: "Thank you for rhat article. Halfway through and I think it will be a wonderful, important book. The back story makes it more poignant."
Sorry I missed your comment, Tracey. I can see you rated it five stars, so I guess you do think it's an important book.
Sorry I missed your comment, Tracey. I can see you rated it five stars, so I guess you do think it's an important book.
What author's fans would you recommend this to? Could you draw parallels with anyone in particular?
This did win the Booker prize, by the way.
This did win the Booker prize, by the way.
Booklovinglady wrote: "I have five of his novels (and read three of them so far). He is a great writer and I'm keeping my fingers crossed he'll win this year's Booker..."
He won!! :-)
He won!! :-)
Bob wrote: "What author's fans would you recommend this to? Could you draw parallels with anyone in particular?"
I'm not well placed to answer that question, Bob. I don't read all that much literary fiction written by contemporary writers and I've only read two of Flanagan's novels (this one and The Sound of One Hand Clapping). So if you read this, like it and can compare Flanagan to another writer, I'd love it if you could let me know. And if anyone who reads this thread has an answer to your question, please feel free to chip in!
I'm not well placed to answer that question, Bob. I don't read all that much literary fiction written by contemporary writers and I've only read two of Flanagan's novels (this one and The Sound of One Hand Clapping). So if you read this, like it and can compare Flanagan to another writer, I'd love it if you could let me know. And if anyone who reads this thread has an answer to your question, please feel free to chip in!
I'm adding this since it won the Man Booker, even though it doesn't sound very appealing to me. Loved your review, though! I've put it on hold at the library and estimate about 2-3 weeks before I get it.
Kim, thank you for this wonderful review. The story you linked to was so moving that I'm afraid I'm going to have to read this book, despite the dark topic.
Jane wrote: "I'm adding this since it won the Man Booker, even though it doesn't sound very appealing to me. Loved your review, though! I've put it on hold at the library and estimate about 2-3 weeks before I g..."
Thanks, Jane. "Appealing" isn't a word I'd use to describe this book. As I said in my review, it's very grim, Also, it takes a while to get into. But almost a year later, I can still see images from it in my head, which is a pretty good indication that it's had a lasting impact on me.
Thanks, Jane. "Appealing" isn't a word I'd use to describe this book. As I said in my review, it's very grim, Also, it takes a while to get into. But almost a year later, I can still see images from it in my head, which is a pretty good indication that it's had a lasting impact on me.
Hana wrote: "Kim, thank you for this wonderful review. The story you linked to was so moving that I'm afraid I'm going to have to read this book, despite the dark topic."
Thanks, Hana. How Flanagan came to write this book is a very moving story. I'm glad that he's been recognised for his work by being awarded the Man Booker.
Thanks, Hana. How Flanagan came to write this book is a very moving story. I'm glad that he's been recognised for his work by being awarded the Man Booker.
Wonderful review of a book I came to love much. And thanks for the link to that article in the end... beautiful.
Karen wrote: "great review, you say what I felt"
Erwin wrote: "Loved your review! Can't wait to start this myself. Thank you."
Sorry I missed your comments, Karen and Erwin. Thank you for dropping by!
Erwin wrote: "Loved your review! Can't wait to start this myself. Thank you."
Sorry I missed your comments, Karen and Erwin. Thank you for dropping by!
Seemita wrote: "Wonderful review of a book I came to love much. And thanks for the link to that article in the end... beautiful."
I'm glad you also loved the book, Seemita. It's such a moving piece of writing and a wonderful tribute to Flanagan's father.
I'm glad you also loved the book, Seemita. It's such a moving piece of writing and a wonderful tribute to Flanagan's father.
Seemita's review brought me here... and so I am grateful to you both for focusing your attention to what sounds like a very edifying book to read.
Kalliope wrote: "Seemita's review brought me here... and so I am grateful to you both for focusing your attention to what sounds like a very edifying book to read."
You are welcome, Kall! Let me go ahead and thank you on my and Kim's behalf for giving weight to this book which truly deserves every bit of the appreciation it has garnered.
You are welcome, Kall! Let me go ahead and thank you on my and Kim's behalf for giving weight to this book which truly deserves every bit of the appreciation it has garnered.