flo's Reviews > The Overcoat

The Overcoat by Nikolai Gogol
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
21575078
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: russian, favorites

My first contact with Gogol, and certainly not my last.
This little book tells the story of Akakiy Akakievitch, a certain official in a certain department where nobody showed him any sign of respect, being mocked by his coworkers. I believe that must be one of the worst things that may happen to a human being: realising that high school did not end (it doesn't bring back good memories to many people). The bullying, the bad jokes, the embarrassing moments that make you gently ask the ground to eat you alive, the psychological and emotional harm, all of that now at your workplace? You have to love the irony.

The Overcoat is, well, a story about an overcoat. It seems to have more importance than Akakiy himself, the responsible guy with the unfortunate name. That's another thing: mothers, what are you thinking about when you give your children ridiculous names? Please, spare them a lot of trouble, save yourselves a lot of money in psychologists and start naming your kids properly. I don't know why they don't change their own name into some fruit, weird magicians, comic superheroes, cars, cardinal points or anything else they seem to love. Especially you, celebrity people who don't know I exist and won't read this in your entire life.
Rant officially over. (If you search for "Akakiy Akakievitch", you'll understand. I had to do that because I wanted to know why the author spent several lines explaining how he got his name and, of course, I don't speak Russian.)

As I was saying, this book is about (view spoiler) And then something happened...

I loved this short story; it contains some beautiful and heartfelt lines...
...and many a time afterwards, in the course of his life, shuddered at seeing how much inhumanity there is in man, how much savage coarseness is concealed beneath delicate, refined worldliness, and even, O God! in that man whom the world acknowledges as honorable and noble.

...that reflect society, then and now. Everything seems to change but the most significant things don't change that much. That's one of the reasons I love literature. Books written hundreds of years ago talking about situations, attitudes, emotions, ways of thinking that we still see, experience and feel nowadays. The responses of the general population towards routine, overbearing bureaucracy, discrimination, injustice, exploitation or alienation haven't changed so much throughout history. Not all writers have what it takes to explore these universal emotions and write something you can immediately relate to. But Gogol seems to be one of them. He had that keen eye meant to observe individuals and humanity as a whole and could write about it so vividly (I could totally see my previous boss in some passages).

Gogol's influence on Russian literature is unquestionable. Dostoyevsky, Bulgakov, even Kafka, so my favourite authors are all connected here.
The Overcoat is a short story that speaks volumes. Do not miss it.



Sep 7, 2013
* Also on my blog.
135 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Overcoat.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 23, 2013 – Shelved
September 3, 2013 – Started Reading
September 4, 2013 –
page 48
84.21% ""We all come out from Gogol's 'Overcoat'.""
September 4, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Garima (new)

Garima Loved this story and loved your review too, Florencia. One just can't get enough of Gogol and even though it's been some time since I read his collected stories, most of them are imprinted on mind may be because I come across their relevancy in our messed up society day after day.


message 2: by Nazmul (new)

Nazmul Hasan Have you read his short stories and if so, would you recommend them?
Thanks


Soycd Amazing review. I've just finished reading this book and it was my first time reading Gogol too. Have you read anything else by him in this time?


message 4: by Alejandro (new)

Alejandro Wooow! Superb review, Florencia!!!


message 5: by PGR (new)

PGR Nair I read this grim and grotesque story long ago and it has always been one of my favorites. Well written review Flore.


message 6: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Your enthusiasm is contagious Florencia! I still have to meet Gogol but I can't think of a better reader to have introduced me to his works while drawing a smile from ear to ear. Loved your rants about "impossibily-to-pronounce-names" and the relfective tone of that last paragraph. Another fantastic review with the unmistakable Florencia-tradesmark! :)


message 7: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Garima wrote: "Loved this story and loved your review too, Florencia. One just can't get enough of Gogol and even though it's been some time since I read his collected stories, most of them are imprinted on mind ..."

Very true... Thank you for reading this, Garima!


message 8: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Elham wrote: "I loved this short story very much and now love your beautiful review Florencia! What would Russian literature do without Gogol?!"

Not much, that's for sure :P Thank you very much, Elham!


message 9: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Nazmul wrote: "Have you read his short stories and if so, would you recommend them?
Thanks"


I haven't read many. Besides this short story, I only read The Night Before Christmas, which I really liked. And then his masterpiece, Dead Souls.


message 10: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Soycd wrote: "Amazing review. I've just finished reading this book and it was my first time reading Gogol too. Have you read anything else by him in this time?"

Thank you very much, Soycd. I only read Dead Souls and The Night Before Christmas. But I have The Collected Tales (translated and annotated by Pevear and Volokhonsky) to read next.


message 11: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Alejandro wrote: "Wooow! Superb review, Florencia!!!"

Thank you very much, Alejandro!


message 12: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo PGR wrote: "I read this grim and grotesque story long ago and it has always been one of my favorites. Well written review Flore."

Thank you, PGR!


message 13: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Dolors wrote: "Your enthusiasm is contagious Florencia! I still have to meet Gogol but I can't think of a better reader to have introduced me to his works while drawing a smile from ear to ear. Loved your rants a..."

Thank you for that lovely comment, Dolors! I always say I will avoid my annoying, little rants and write a proper review. I try. Not very good at it, apparently :P


Martin Godinez Wow, amazing review! I look forward to reading over reviews about books I enjoyed so much. So much said, in not so many words. The overcoat is sad, it is heat warming, it is a wrenching of some heart strings, it is a great story. Thank you for your review


message 15: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Martin wrote: "Wow, amazing review! I look forward to reading over reviews about books I enjoyed so much. So much said, in not so many words. The overcoat is sad, it is heat warming, it is a wrenching of some hea..."

Indeed, you mentioned all the ingredients a great book is supposed to have. This was my first Gogol, so this short story is very special to me. Thank you very much for reading and commenting!


message 16: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Makes me happy to see you love this one, too! A nose, an overcoat - anything can be the topic for a masterpiece when a true storyteller waves his magic wand...


Ana-Maria Petre This little story was so sad.


message 18: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Lisa wrote: "Makes me happy to see you love this one, too! A nose, an overcoat - anything can be the topic for a masterpiece when a true storyteller waves his magic wand..."

I couldn't agree more! A mundane object becomes an extraordinary piece of writing thanks to this writer's genius.


Ana-Maria wrote: "This little story was so sad."

It is. Gogol's writing is full of wit but behind some humorous remarks lies a remarkably sad story - life itself.


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

Your first contact with Gogol confirms mine. I very much enjoyed your witticism, empathy, introspection, and deconstruction of Gogol's fleeting tale. A remarkable review.


message 20: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Waqas wrote: "Your first contact with Gogol confirms mine. I very much enjoyed your witticism, empathy, introspection, and deconstruction of Gogol's fleeting tale. A remarkable review."

I think I drank a lot of coffee before writing this review. :P Thanks so much for always finding something positive in these scribbles of mine. I sincerely hope you enjoy this brilliant short story!


Fernando I've just have finished "Dead Souls", and in my review (why I invite you to read) I define why Gógol (and Puskhin) is the father of russian literature.


message 22: by Gaurav (last edited Oct 07, 2016 09:54PM) (new) - added it

Gaurav An enthralling review, Florencia :)

Gogol was an outstanding author, I read just Dead Souls but that's enough to confirm his authority over human psychology, in fact, I think all major Russian authors- Dostoevsky, Tolstoy, Gogol, Turgenev, Bulgakov and others- have captured the absurdness of life, its anxiety/ angst perfectly; the penetration of their works, which are, to me, the quintessential psychological portraits of Human, into deep recesses of human emotions-death, murder, suicide, God, sin, good/ evil, rage, insanity, destruction, crime etc.- have been so profound and accurate that, I feel, it won't be an exaggeration to call them as the true psychologists of world literature.


message 23: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Fernando wrote: "I've just have finished "Dead Souls", and in my review (why I invite you to read) I define why Gógol (and Puskhin) is the father of russian literature."

Good, thanks for letting me know.


message 24: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Gaurav wrote: "An enthralling review, Florencia :)

Gogol was an outstanding author, I read just Dead Souls but that's enough to confirm his authority over human psychology, in fact, I think all major Russian a..."


Thanks so much for reading, Gaurav! I'm glad you liked this review and thrilled to hear that you enjoyed Dead Souls, a real masterpiece. I agree, those writers were able to capture all the elements inherent to our nature, even the most elusive of them, creating timeless works of art. Their ability to explore the human psyche has impressed me completely. Thank you for your thoughtful comment. I hope you also enjoy this short story when you get to it. :)


Djakhongir you must read it in Russian, its not readable in any other language. All russian classic books must be read in russian language to be understood, otherwise it is a waste of time.


message 26: by flo (last edited Mar 31, 2018 06:55AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Djakhongir wrote: "you must read it in Russian, its not readable in any other language. All russian classic books must be read in russian language to be understood, otherwise it is a waste of time."

Oh sure, it happens with all books. A waste of time to read them if they're not in their original language... After I'm done deepening my knowledge of Italian, Portuguese, Japanese and French, and learning German, Chinese, Polish, Slovakian - oh, let's cover all Europe and Asia for starters. I'll definitely try to get my hands on Russian textbooks. Let's end the useless art of translation right now...


Kathryn Ha, nice reply to the previous comment!


Cecily What an eloquent and sensitive review of this powerful little story. And I agree with your rant about names (mine was a burden, growing up: named after my grandmother, who died when my father was only 16, but I've made my peace with it now).


message 29: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Cecily wrote: "What an eloquent and sensitive review of this powerful little story. And I agree with your rant about names (mine was a burden, growing up: named after my grandmother, who died when my father was o..."

Thanks, Cecily. A brilliant short story.
Actually, when I wrote this, I had in mind names such as Apple, Pilot Inspektor, Banjo, Blanket. After several years, even weirder names come to mind. By the way, yours is lovely. Whenever that name came up, friends and I would think of music (Cecily, patron saint of music).


message 30: by Junta (new) - added it

Junta I was quite amused with The Nose; starting with the protagonist's name, this one sounds like it might be an enjoyable read, too. Lovely thoughts on how things don't change, I felt the same with Rumi! I'll have to read this at some point so I can see what's hidden as a spoiler...


message 31: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Junta wrote: "I was quite amused with The Nose; starting with the protagonist's name, this one sounds like it might be an enjoyable read, too. Lovely thoughts on how things don't change, I felt the same with Rum..."

Gogol's witty writing is such a treat--fun, stimulating, always giving us food for thought. And yes, exceptional writers like him or Rumi make us ponder how nothing changes in our constantly changing lives. :) I hope you enjoy this book when you give it a try.


TBV (on hiatus) Thanks for tempting me with your lovely review, Florencia.


message 33: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo TBV (on semi-hiatus) wrote: "Thanks for tempting me with your lovely review, Florencia."

Thanks for your kind words, TBV!


Adina (way behind) I enjoyed your rant. Elon Musk idiotic name for his new son (X Æ A-Xii) is the most recent one I remember. I am currently reading a collection of short stories by Gogol. My first contact was The Nose but I have to admit I did not like it too much. I hope to feel differently about this one. I will check again your review after I read the story.


message 35: by P.E. (new)

P.E. Not all writers have what it takes to explore these universal emotions and write something you can immediately relate to. But Gogol seems to be one of them. He had that keen eye meant to observe individuals and humanity as a whole and could write about it so vividly (I could totally see my previous boss in some passages).

Haha! :D Tell us more about the passages and the boss? :D


message 36: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Adina wrote: "I enjoyed your rant. Elon Musk idiotic name for his new son (X Æ A-Xii) is the most recent one I remember. I am currently reading a collection of short stories by Gogol. My first contact was The No..."

Musk's choice is definitely at the top of the list!
I just read your review of The Nose, sorry to hear you didn't enjoy it. I've only read a couple of his short stories so I'm not sure about the rest; it seems the collection includes some less interesting stories.
Thanks for reading and commenting, Adina.


message 37: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo P.E. wrote: "Not all writers have what it takes to explore these universal emotions and write something you can immediately relate to. But Gogol seems to be one of them. He had that keen eye meant to observe in..."

I read this story and wrote this review in 2013, so sadly, I can't recall those particular passages, and luckily, I barely remember that boss. :P


message 38: by P.E. (new)

P.E. @Florencia:
Might not be that bad a thing, regarding your boss, eh? ;)


message 39: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo P.E. wrote: "@Florencia:
Might not be that bad a thing, regarding your boss, eh? ;)"


True :P


back to top