s.penkevich's Reviews > This is Amiko, Do You Copy?
This is Amiko, Do You Copy?
by
by
s.penkevich's review
bookshelves: japan, childhood, mental_health, novella, translation
Nov 28, 2023
bookshelves: japan, childhood, mental_health, novella, translation
The world is rarely kind to those who are different, those who stand out from what society has deemed “acceptable” behavoir. And that can make the world a lonely place. This is Amiko, Do You Copy? by Natsuko Imamura, author of The Woman in the Purple Skirt, positions the reader into this sort of isolated existence as the story follows Amiko, a girl who seems to float through life as equally unaware of the bullying she receives as she is to how her own actions set her apart from others. Tender yet ultimately tragic, this is a story of the spreading consequences from misconceptions all seen through the eyes of a girl who can’t quite follow the thread of emotions and events. The story is best emphasized in a pivotal scene where Amiko speaks into her walkie-talkie, calling out to the world and receiving no response beyond, at one point when she hears ‘what sounded like a faint voice amid all the grating noise.’ Addressing neurodivergence and the ways people are misunderstood even by those closest to them, This is Amiko, Do You Copy? is a moving and rather heartbreaking story beautifully presented in a simplistic style (translated here by Hitomi Yoshio) that subtly implies far more than its own words.
I had enjoyed the way Imamura’s The Woman in the Purple Skirt left a lot unsaid but managed to make those omissions speak the loudest and found that this is a talent she carries over into This Amiko, Do You Copy?. The whole novella is overflowing in dramatic irony where the reader is far more aware of the interpersonal dynamics and emotional currents than Amiko herself, through whom the story is told. It is written in third person, though only offers Amiko’s perspective, and the prose is rather simplistic in order to capture the impressions of the world the way a child would (Amiko goes from being a young child to a teenager over the course of the story). Being third person instead of first gives us a sense that Amiko’s own life feels at a remove from herself.
‘She wanted to be kind. But the more she wanted to be kind, the sadder she got. She couldn’t find the words. She couldn’t say a word.’
Many of the events of the story simply pass by without much special emphasis or investigation in order to embody the way that, for Amiko, even the most dramatic of moments don’t seem to register as such to her. Aside from her brief moments with Nori, a classmate for whom she has developed a strong affection despite not reading his social cues of utter annoyance at her presence, Amiko is rather unaffected by everything around her. And, initially, rather blissfully so. ‘It’s like you’re free,’ a classmate admits before adding, ‘well, it’s also why you get bullied…’ The tragedy of the novella is that, because Amiko doesn’t pick up on social cues or socially acceptable behavior, some of her actions cause great offense and sadness to her own family. There are some deeply uncomfortable scenes, though we also recognize how Amiko meant no offense and doesn't even realize that she has offended.
While a revelation about her family comes quite late in the novella, it is almost brushed aside in the text which can feel a bit frustrating as it feels underexplored. And this feeling of frustration the reader may feel should hopefully be eye opening as to why the people around Amiko act so cruelly towards her instead of stopping to think about how that is just the way she is. They misunderstand her and are cold to her instead of accommodating, they mock her behavior, and even her extremely protective brother eventually finds her to be too much for him. I also found the presentation of the narrative, winding around itself and weaving back and forth across the timeline, to not only be a great way to tease out the story but also represent the way Amiko processes her experience in roundabout ways.
This is Amiko, Do You Copy? is a heartfelt yet heartbreaking story that serves as an expression on neurodivergence in a society that is not equipped to be accommodating. I'd be curious to read how those with more experience on the subject matter find the representation, and I'm also curious how the conversation around neurodivergence has changed since this was originally published in 2011. The book has been compared to Convenience Store Woman, though the two novels take fairly different approaches but both still become rather tragic social criticisms. Short, moving, and rather powerful, this book is a good reminder to have patience and understanding with others, and to show kindness instead of the cruelty Amiko finds here.
3.5/5
I had enjoyed the way Imamura’s The Woman in the Purple Skirt left a lot unsaid but managed to make those omissions speak the loudest and found that this is a talent she carries over into This Amiko, Do You Copy?. The whole novella is overflowing in dramatic irony where the reader is far more aware of the interpersonal dynamics and emotional currents than Amiko herself, through whom the story is told. It is written in third person, though only offers Amiko’s perspective, and the prose is rather simplistic in order to capture the impressions of the world the way a child would (Amiko goes from being a young child to a teenager over the course of the story). Being third person instead of first gives us a sense that Amiko’s own life feels at a remove from herself.
‘She wanted to be kind. But the more she wanted to be kind, the sadder she got. She couldn’t find the words. She couldn’t say a word.’
Many of the events of the story simply pass by without much special emphasis or investigation in order to embody the way that, for Amiko, even the most dramatic of moments don’t seem to register as such to her. Aside from her brief moments with Nori, a classmate for whom she has developed a strong affection despite not reading his social cues of utter annoyance at her presence, Amiko is rather unaffected by everything around her. And, initially, rather blissfully so. ‘It’s like you’re free,’ a classmate admits before adding, ‘well, it’s also why you get bullied…’ The tragedy of the novella is that, because Amiko doesn’t pick up on social cues or socially acceptable behavior, some of her actions cause great offense and sadness to her own family. There are some deeply uncomfortable scenes, though we also recognize how Amiko meant no offense and doesn't even realize that she has offended.
While a revelation about her family comes quite late in the novella, it is almost brushed aside in the text which can feel a bit frustrating as it feels underexplored. And this feeling of frustration the reader may feel should hopefully be eye opening as to why the people around Amiko act so cruelly towards her instead of stopping to think about how that is just the way she is. They misunderstand her and are cold to her instead of accommodating, they mock her behavior, and even her extremely protective brother eventually finds her to be too much for him. I also found the presentation of the narrative, winding around itself and weaving back and forth across the timeline, to not only be a great way to tease out the story but also represent the way Amiko processes her experience in roundabout ways.
This is Amiko, Do You Copy? is a heartfelt yet heartbreaking story that serves as an expression on neurodivergence in a society that is not equipped to be accommodating. I'd be curious to read how those with more experience on the subject matter find the representation, and I'm also curious how the conversation around neurodivergence has changed since this was originally published in 2011. The book has been compared to Convenience Store Woman, though the two novels take fairly different approaches but both still become rather tragic social criticisms. Short, moving, and rather powerful, this book is a good reminder to have patience and understanding with others, and to show kindness instead of the cruelty Amiko finds here.
3.5/5
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
This is Amiko, Do You Copy?.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
November 28, 2023
– Shelved
November 28, 2023
– Shelved as:
japan
November 28, 2023
– Shelved as:
childhood
November 28, 2023
– Shelved as:
mental_health
November 28, 2023
– Shelved as:
novella
November 28, 2023
– Shelved as:
translation
Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Amina
(new)
Nov 28, 2023 06:21PM
I always admire how even a small book can teach us so many important lessons of being good human beings and treating others kindly - something that even a self-guide book doesn't capture as well, as when it's a story that you can relate and care for, instead. Lovely review, S. 🤍
reply
|
flag
Amina wrote: "I always admire how even a small book can teach us so many important lessons of being good human beings and treating others kindly - something that even a self-guide book doesn't capture as well, a..."
Thank you so much! Agreed, I tend to find the shortest of books can manage to pack the most impact sometimes, I really love when so many big ideas can get folded in so tidily.
Thank you so much! Agreed, I tend to find the shortest of books can manage to pack the most impact sometimes, I really love when so many big ideas can get folded in so tidily.
Alex wrote: "Excellent review. Really interested in getting some more novellas on my TBR list."
Thank you so much! Ooo novellas are my favorite, especially in you have an interest in Latin American or Japanese literature there are a LOT of good options
Thank you so much! Ooo novellas are my favorite, especially in you have an interest in Latin American or Japanese literature there are a LOT of good options
Your review is amazing! I'm definitely going to read this one when I can, you persuaded me! Being neurodivergent myself, I'm very curious:)
Sylvie wrote: "Your review is amazing! I'm definitely going to read this one when I can, you persuaded me! Being neurodivergent myself, I'm very curious:)"
Thank you so much! I’ll be interested to hear what you think, and I hope you enjoy. I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has progressed in the 12 years since the book was written.
Thank you so much! I’ll be interested to hear what you think, and I hope you enjoy. I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has progressed in the 12 years since the book was written.
"I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has progressed in the 12 years since the book was written."
It hasn't progressed much in Japan. Interestingly enough, Japanese youth culture has arguably been presenting neurodivergent coded characters- even as mains- for decades on end (Two words: Kamille Bidan) but as far as the way society, as a whole, perceives actual neurodivergent people- let alone the hell they tend to endure in Japanese school- it is probably in the dark ages, as many things tend to be in Japan, as far as societal issues go.
It hasn't progressed much in Japan. Interestingly enough, Japanese youth culture has arguably been presenting neurodivergent coded characters- even as mains- for decades on end (Two words: Kamille Bidan) but as far as the way society, as a whole, perceives actual neurodivergent people- let alone the hell they tend to endure in Japanese school- it is probably in the dark ages, as many things tend to be in Japan, as far as societal issues go.
Nocturnalux wrote: ""I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has progressed in the 12 years since the bo..."
Ah yea that makes sense. And interesting point how even in the US there will be main characters in shows and books who are neurodivergent coded, and even super emphasize that, while as a society are still pretty dismissive or non-accommodating (though I think online discourse has at least tried to push forward). Huh, putting it that way it is almost like using people's neurodivergence. This one seemed well done enough, but I'm also not...versed enough to make that claim?
Ah yea that makes sense. And interesting point how even in the US there will be main characters in shows and books who are neurodivergent coded, and even super emphasize that, while as a society are still pretty dismissive or non-accommodating (though I think online discourse has at least tried to push forward). Huh, putting it that way it is almost like using people's neurodivergence. This one seemed well done enough, but I'm also not...versed enough to make that claim?
Southern Lady Reads wrote: "I always enjoy books where neurodivergence is discussed!!"
I think you'll like this one! It's short and too the point but also seems to present a lot of ideas in ways that leaves you to think about them long after the book is done.
I think you'll like this one! It's short and too the point but also seems to present a lot of ideas in ways that leaves you to think about them long after the book is done.
s.penkevich wrote: "Nocturnalux wrote: ""I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has progressed in the 1..."
Japan has been doing this longer, I think. If only because anime has had a reputation for both catering and being produced by people on the spectrum (how true this is, would require actual studies but it is a common enough assumption). Gundam Zeta aired in 1985 and you see hints of this even in the original one, from 1979. The fandom has more or less universally decided that Kamille is neurodivergent. Interestingly enough, Tomino also seems to be so it'd be a case of actual representation as opposed to turning people into a fetish of sorts.
If you're curious to see how this representation is done in more contemporary works, I recommend The Witch from Mercury (the newest Gundam title, some fans also think the lead in the preceding one also qualifies), and Violet Evergreen.
Neither is identified as neurodivergent.
For an actual identification as such, there is the manga "Hikari to Tomo ni". It's less recent, published between 2000-2009 and it's told from the POV of a parent; based on the mangaka's own experiences. I have not read it but it is surely a rarity, as far as manga goes.
Japan has been doing this longer, I think. If only because anime has had a reputation for both catering and being produced by people on the spectrum (how true this is, would require actual studies but it is a common enough assumption). Gundam Zeta aired in 1985 and you see hints of this even in the original one, from 1979. The fandom has more or less universally decided that Kamille is neurodivergent. Interestingly enough, Tomino also seems to be so it'd be a case of actual representation as opposed to turning people into a fetish of sorts.
If you're curious to see how this representation is done in more contemporary works, I recommend The Witch from Mercury (the newest Gundam title, some fans also think the lead in the preceding one also qualifies), and Violet Evergreen.
Neither is identified as neurodivergent.
For an actual identification as such, there is the manga "Hikari to Tomo ni". It's less recent, published between 2000-2009 and it's told from the POV of a parent; based on the mangaka's own experiences. I have not read it but it is surely a rarity, as far as manga goes.
Nocturnalux wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Nocturnalux wrote: ""I’m…curious what other people make of the representation here (which is never really labeled but seems pretty assumed?) and how the overall conversation has..."
Ah that is super interesting. Makes sense, and that is cool it tends more towards honest representation rather than fetishizing. I’ve heard Violet Evergreen is good, I’ll definitely check that out too thank you!
Ah that is super interesting. Makes sense, and that is cool it tends more towards honest representation rather than fetishizing. I’ve heard Violet Evergreen is good, I’ll definitely check that out too thank you!
What an impressive and thought-provoking commentary! I love a concise but moving read… you’ve convinced me to check this one out! The Convenience Store Woman comparison was a hook indeed. Awesome, as usual!
MJG wrote: "What an impressive and thought-provoking commentary! I love a concise but moving read… you’ve convinced me to check this one out! The Convenience Store Woman comparison was a hook indeed. Awesome, ..."
Thank you so much! This was really worth the read—I hope you enjoy! Yea it’s a…loose comparison I guess but it’s definitely valid? If that makes sense. Nice quick and tight, though sad, read
Thank you so much! This was really worth the read—I hope you enjoy! Yea it’s a…loose comparison I guess but it’s definitely valid? If that makes sense. Nice quick and tight, though sad, read