Summary: Let \(U\) be a smooth connected complex algebraic variety, and let \(f\colon U\to \mathbb C^*\) be an algebraic map. To the pair \((U,f)\) one can associate an infinite cyclic cover \(U^f\), and (homology) Alexander modules are defined as the homology groups of this cover. In two recent works, the first of which is joint with Geske, Maxim and Wang, we developed two different ways to put a mixed Hodge structure on Alexander modules. Since they are not finite dimensional in general, each approach replaces the Alexander module by a different finite dimensional module: one of them takes the torsion submodule, the other takes finite dimensional quotients, and the constructions are not directly comparable. In this note, we show that both constructions are compatible, in the sense that the map from the torsion to the quotients is a mixed Hodge structure morphism.