×

The role of venture capitalists in reward-based crowdfunding: a game-theoretical analysis. (English) Zbl 07881794

Summary: Most entrepreneurs seek VC funding after the reward-based crowdfunding campaign succeeds, and venture capitalists (VCs) can contribute to the project in two aspects: investment and operational expertise. With a game-theoretical model, we find that entrepreneurs face twelve possible scenarios contingent on the mass market revenue and revenue share, including the six scenarios wherein neither side exerts effort to complete the project. To attract VC funding and ensure the project completion after a campaign success, entrepreneurs should set the funding goal above a certain threshold. Specifically, we identify three ranges of the revenue share and derive the lower bound for the funding goal in each range. However, we notice that entrepreneurs prefer a low funding goal to promise the campaign success and the optimal goal will be the lower bound in each range. Moreover, we show that the revenue share is decisive to the role of VCs in the project. If the entrepreneur’s share exceeds a high threshold, the venture capitalist becomes a pure investor with no incentive to exert effort, similar to the role of banks; if the share is less than a low threshold, the entrepreneur won’t follow up but transfers the project, and the VC investor will be a project owner; if the share stays medium, the VC investor acts as a partner and there may exist “free-riding”. In the extension, we consider the revenue share an endogenous and analyse the role of VCs further. Interestingly, the VC investor prefers to own the project and occupy all revenue in mass market, while the entrepreneur treats the inefficient venture capitalist as a pure investor and the efficient one as a partner. In addition, when cooperating with efficient VCs, the entrepreneur is more likely to enlarge her share as the mass market revenue increases.

MSC:

91G50 Corporate finance (dividends, real options, etc.)
91A80 Applications of game theory
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Agrawal, A. K., Catalini, C., & Goldfarb, A. (2014). Some simple economics of crowdfunding. Innovation Policy and the Economy,14, 63-97.
[2] Vergara, M.; Bonilla, CA; Sepulveda, JP, The complementarity effect: Effort and sharing in the entrepreneur and venture capital contract, European Journal of Operational Research, 254, 3, 1017-1025, 2016 · Zbl 1346.91137
[3] Alaei, S., Malekian, A., & Mostagir, M. A. (2016). Dynamic model of crowdfunding. Working paper, Ross School of Business, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Available at SSRN: doi:10.2139/ssrn.2737748
[4] Amit, R.; Glosten, L.; Muller, E., Entrepreneurial ability, venture investment, and risk sharing, Management Science, 36, 10, 1232-1245, 1990 · Zbl 0707.90010
[5] Archibald, TW; Possani, E., Investment and operational decisions for start-up companies: A game theory and Markov decision process approach, Annals of Operations Research, 299, 317-330, 2021 · Zbl 1480.91303
[6] Babich, V.; Marinesi, S.; Tsoukalas, G., Does crowdfunding benefit entrepreneurs and venture capital investors?, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 23, 2, 508-524, 2020
[7] Belavina, E.; Marinesi, S.; Tsoukalas, G., Rethinking crowdfunding platform design: Mechanisms to deter misconduct and improve efficiency, Management Science, 66, 11, 4980-4997, 2020
[8] Belleamme, P.; Lambert, T.; Schwienbacher, A., Crowdfunding: Tapping the right crowd, Journal of Business Venturing, 29, 5, 585-609, 2014
[9] Bender, M.; Gal-Or, E.; Geylani, T., Crowdfunding as a vehicle for raising capital and for price discrimination, Journal of Interactive Marketing, 46, 1-19, 2019
[10] Bi, GB; Geng, BT; Liu, LD, On the fixed and flexible funding mechanisms in reward-based crowdfunding, European Journal of Operational Research, 279, 168-183, 2019 · Zbl 1430.90356
[11] Burtch, G.; Ghose, A.; Wattal, S., An empirical examination of the antecedents and consequences of contribution patterns in crowd-funded markets, Information Systems Research, 24, 3, 499-519, 2013
[12] Burtch, G.; Ghose, A.; Wattal, S., The hidden cost of accommodating crowd funder privacy preferences: A randomized field experiment, Management Science, 61, 5, 949-962, 2015
[13] Caldbeck, R. (2013). Crowdfunding-Why angels, venture capitalists and private equity investments all may benefit. In Forbes (August 7). Retrieved from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/ryancaldbeck/2013/08/07/crowdfunding-why-angels-venture-capitalists-and-private-equity-investors-all-may-benefit/
[14] Casamatta, C., Financing and advising: Optimal financial contracts with venture capitalists, Journal of Finance, 58, 5, 2059-2086, 2003
[15] Chakraborty, S.; Swinney, R., Signaling to the crowd: Private quality information and rewards-based crowdfunding, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 23, 1, 155-169, 2021
[16] Chemla, G.; Tinn, K., Learning through crowdfunding, Management Science, 66, 5, 1783-1801, 2020
[17] Chen, Y.; Chung, SH; Guo, S., Franchising contracts in fashion supply chain operations: Models, practices, and real case study, Annals of Operations Research, 291, 83-128, 2020
[18] Colombo, MG; Shafi, K., Swimming with sharks in Europe: When are they dangerous and what can new ventures do to defend themselves?, Strategic Management Journal, 37, 2307-2322, 2016
[19] Corbett, CJ; DeCroix, GA; Ha, AY, Optimal shared-savings contracts in supply chains: Linear contracts and double moral hazard, European Journal of Operational Research, 163, 3, 653-667, 2005 · Zbl 1071.90504
[20] Cornelius, PB; Gokpinar, B., The role of customer investor involvement in crowdfunding success, Management Science, 66, 1, 452-472, 2020
[21] Cumming, DJ; Leboeuf, G.; Schwienbacher, A., Crowd funding models: Keep-it-all vs all-or-nothing, Financial Management, 49, 331-360, 2020
[22] Dang, VA, Optimal financial contracts with hidden effort, unobservable profits and endogenous costs of effort, The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 50, 1, 75-89, 2010
[23] De Bettignies, JE; Brander, JA, Financing entrepreneurship: Bank finance versus venture capital, Journal of Business Venturing, 22, 6, 808-832, 2007
[24] Deutsch, Y.; Golany, B., Multiple agents finitely repeated inspection game with dismissals, Annals of Operations Research, 237, 7-26, 2016 · Zbl 1339.91018
[25] Drover, W.; Wood, MS; Zacharakis, A., Attributes of angel and crowdfunded investments as determinants of VC screening decisions, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 41, 3, 323-347, 2017
[26] Du, SF; Peng, J.; Nie, TF; Yu, YG, Pricing strategies and mechanism choice in reward-based crowdfunding, European Journal of Operational Research, 284, 951-966, 2020 · Zbl 1441.91020
[27] Elitzur, R.; Gavious, A., A multi-period game theoretic model of venture capital investment, European Journal of Operational Research, 144, 2, 440-453, 2003 · Zbl 1049.91023
[28] Elitzur, R.; Gavious, A., Selection of entrepreneurs in the venture capital industry: An asymptotic analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, 215, 3, 705-712, 2011 · Zbl 1238.91073
[29] Ellman, M.; Hurkens, S., Optimal crowdfunding design, Journal of Economic Theory, 184, 2019 · Zbl 1426.91295
[30] Fairchild, R., An entrepreneur’s choice of venture capitalist or angel financing: A behavioral game-theoretic approach, Journal of Business Venturing, 26, 3, 359-374, 2011
[31] Fu, H.; Yang, J.; An, TB, Contracts for venture capital financing with double-sided moral hazard, Small Business Economics, 53, 129-144, 2019
[32] Grant, R. (2013). Crowdfunding vs. seed funding: All money is not created equal. In Venturebeat (June 24). Retrieved from: http://venturebeat.com/2013/06/24/crowdfunding-vs-seed-funding-all-money-is-not-created-equal/2/
[33] Guan, X.; Deng, WJ; Jiang, ZZ; Huang, M., Pricing and advertising for reward-based crowdfunding products in Ecommerce, Decision Support Systems, 133, 2020
[34] Hildebrand, T.; Puri, M.; Rocholl, J., Adverse incentives in crowdfunding, Management Science, 63, 3, 587-608, 2016
[35] Hogg, S. (2014). How venture capital and crowdfunding can be mutually beneficial. In Entrepreneur (December 23). Retrieved from: http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/239177
[36] Hu, M.; Li, X.; Shi, M., Product and price decisions in crowdfunding, Marketing Science, 34, 3, 331-345, 2015
[37] Jeffries, A. (2013). How Kickstarter stole CES: The rise of the indie hardware developer. In The Verge (January 12). Retrieved from: http://www.theverge.com/2013/1/10/3861406/kickstarter-at-ces
[38] Kanniainen, V., & Keuschnigg, C. (2003). The optimal portfolio of start-up firms in venture capital finance. Journal of Corporate Finance,9(5), 521-534.
[39] Kim, J. H., Newberry, P., & Qiu, C. (2015). An empirical analysis of a crowd funding platform. Working paper, NET Institute. Available at SSRN: doi:10.2139/ssrn.2672075
[40] Kulkarni, A. U., & Wernz, C. (2020). Optimal incentives for teams: A multiscale decision theory approach. Annals of Operations Research,288, 307-329. · Zbl 1437.91148
[41] Kumar, P.; Langberg, N.; Zvilichovsky, D., Crowdfunding, financing constraints, and real effects, Management Science, 66, 8, 3561-3580, 2020
[42] Kuppuswamy, V., & Bayus, B. L. (2013). Crowdfunding creative ideas: The dynamics of project backers in kickstarter. SSRN Electronic Journal. . Available at SSRN: doi:10.2139/ssrn.2234765
[43] Li, C.; Zhang, F., Advance demand information, price discrimination, and pre-order strategies, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 15, 1, 57-71, 2013
[44] Li, H.; Cao, E., Competitive crowdfunding under asymmetric quality information, Annals of Operations Research, 2021 · Zbl 1530.91602 · doi:10.1007/s10479-021-03939-y
[45] Mahbub, N.; Le, A.; Zhuang, J., Online crowdfunding strategy: a game-theoretical approach to a Kickstarter case study, Annals of Operations Research, 315, 1019-1036, 2022
[46] Massolution. (2015). 2015 CF crowdfunding industry report. Los Angeles: Crowdsourcing. Retrieved from: http://reports.crowdsourcing.org/index.php?route=product/product &product_id=54.
[47] Metrick, A.; Yasuda, A., Venture capital and the finance of innovation, 2009, Wiley
[48] Mollick, E. (2013). Swept away by the crowd? Crowdfunding, venture capital and the selection of entrepreneurs. Working paper, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. Available at SSRN: doi:10.2139/ssrn.2239204
[49] Mollick, E., The dynamics of crowdfunding: An exploratory study, Journal of Business Venturing, 29, 1, 1-16, 2014
[50] Mollick, E.; Nanda, R., Wisdom or madness? Comparing crowds with expert evaluation in funding the arts, Management Science, 62, 6, 1533-1553, 2016
[51] Nie, TF; Wang, XX; Zhu, YG; Du, SF, Crowdfunding mechanism comparison when product quality is uncertain, International Transactions in Operational Research, 27, 2616-2657, 2020 · Zbl 07767644
[52] Osintsev, Y., Venture financing of start-ups: A model of contract between VC fund and entrepreneur, Economic Annals, 55, 187, 61-86, 2010
[53] Prasad, A.; Stecke, KE; Zhao, X., Advance selling by a newsvendor retailer, Production & Operations Management, 20, 1, 129-142, 2011
[54] Repullo, J.; Suarez, J., Venture capital finance: A security design approach, Review of Finance, 8, 1, 75-108, 2004 · Zbl 1106.91334
[55] Roma, P.; Gal-Or, E.; Chen, R., Reward-based crowdfunding campaigns: Informational value and access to venture capital, Information Systems Research, 29, 3, 679-697, 2018
[56] Roma, P.; Messeni Petruzzelli, A.; Perrone, G., From the crowd to the market: The role of reward-based crowdfunding performance in attracting professional investors, Research Policy, 46, 9, 1606-1628, 2017
[57] Ryu, SH; Kim, YG, Money is not everything: A typology of crowdfunding project creators, Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 27, 4, 350-368, 2018
[58] Schmidt, KM, Convertible securities and venture capital finance, Journal of Finance, 58, 3, 1139-1166, 2003
[59] Scott-Briggs, A. (2017). Crowdfunding grows up as VC activity declines. In TechBullion (January 30). Retrieved from: https://www.techbullion.com/crowdfunding-grows-vc-activity-declines/
[60] Segarra, M. (2013). How venture capital and crowdfunding can coexist. In CFO (April 24). Retrieved from: http://ww2.cfo.com/credit-capital/2013/04/how-venture-capital-and-crowdfunding-can-coexist
[61] Shane, S. (2013). Why equity crowdfunding isn’t a threat to venture capital. In Entrepreneur (October 13). Retrieved from: http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/228738
[62] Silveira, R.; Wright, R., Venture capital: A model of search and bargaining, Review of Economic Dynamics, 19, 232-246, 2016
[63] Snow, S. (2014). The secret to Kickstarter’s success isn’t what you think. In Contently (April 30). Retrieved from: http://contently.com/strategist/2014/04/30/the-secret-to-kickstarters-success
[64] Stanko, MA; Henard, DA, Toward a better understanding of crowdfunding, openness and the consequences for innovation, Research Policy, 46, 4, 784-798, 2017
[65] Steinberg, S. (2012). Need more crowdfunders? Try these lures. In Inc (May 17). Retrieved from: http://www.inc.com/scott-steinberg/the-crowd funding-bible-how-to-reward-investors.html
[66] Strausz, R., A theory of crowdfunding: A mechanism design approach with demand uncertainty and moral hazard, American Economic Review, 107, 6, 1430-1476, 2017
[67] Tang, CS; Wang, YL; Zhao, M., The implications of utilizing market information and adopting agricultural advice for farmers in developing economies, Production & Operations Management, 24, 8, 1197-1215, 2015
[68] World Bank. (2013). Crowdfunding’s potential for the developing world (Report), Finance and Private Sector Development Department, Washington, DC: World Bank. Available online: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/17626.
[69] Zhang, Y.; Tian, Y., Choice of pricing and marketing strategies in reward-based crowdfunding campaigns, Decision Support Systems, 144, 2021
[70] Zeng, K.; Xu, XH; Gong, YM; Groh, A., Joint inventory and rationing decisions in reward-based crowdfunding, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 72, 6, 1259-1278, 2021
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.