×

Multiplicity of equilibria in conjectural variations models of natural gas markets. (English) Zbl 1346.91138

Summary: Spatial partial equilibrium models incorporating conjectural variations are widely used to analyze the development of oligopolistic multi-agent markets, such as international energy and raw material markets. Although this model type can produce multiple equilibria under commonly used assumptions, to the best of our knowledge, the consequences for the interpretation of the model results have not yet been explored in detail. To this end, we derive a linear complementarity model for the gas market and discuss under which assumptions on the model structure a component of the solution is unique. In particular, we find that the gas flow between a trader and a consumer is unique whenever the trader is modeled to exert market power in the consumer’s market. We demonstrate our findings by computing the extreme points of the polyhedral solution space and show that erroneous conclusions could be drawn whenever only one (arbitrary) point in the solution space is picked for interpretation. Furthermore, we discuss whether economically meaningful parameter value changes exist which would enforce uniqueness in all components of the solution.

MSC:

91B50 General equilibrium theory
90C33 Complementarity and equilibrium problems and variational inequalities (finite dimensions) (aspects of mathematical programming)
91B74 Economic models of real-world systems (e.g., electricity markets, etc.)

References:

[1] Abolhassani, M.; Bateni, M.; Hajiaghayi, M.; Mahini, H.; Sawant, A., Network Cournot competition, (Liu, T.-W.; Qi, Q.; Ye, Y. (2014), Springer: Springer Cham), 15-29, . arXiv:1405.1794v1 · Zbl 1406.91243
[2] BP, BP statistical review of world energy June 2013, Technical Report (2013)
[3] Carvalho, R.; Buzna, L.; Bono, F.; Masera, M.; Arrowsmith, D. K.; Helbing, D., Resilience of natural gas networks during conflicts, crises and disruptions., PLoS One, 9, e90265 (2014)
[4] Chyong, C. K.; Hobbs, B. F., Strategic Eurasian natural gas market model for energy security and policy analysis: Formulation and application to South Stream, Energy Economics, 44, 198-211 (2014)
[5] Cottle, R. W.; Pang, J.-S.; Stone, R. E., The linear complementarity problem (1992), Academic Press: Academic Press Philadelphia · Zbl 0757.90078
[6] Díaz, C. A.; Villar, J.; Campos, F. A.; Reneses, J., Electricity market equilibrium based on conjectural variations, Electric Power Systems Research, 80, 1572-1579 (2010)
[7] Dieckhöner, C.; Lochner, S.; Lindenberger, D., European natural gas infrastructure: The impact of market developments on gas flows and physical market integration, Applied Energy, 102, 994-1003 (2013)
[8] Egging, R., Benders decomposition for multi-stage stochastic mixed complementarity problems - applied to a global natural gas market model, European Journal of Operational Research, 226, 341-353 (2013) · Zbl 1292.90186
[9] Egging, R.; Gabriel, S. A.; Holz, F.; Zhuang, J., A complementarity model for the European natural gas market, Energy Policy, 36, 2385-2414 (2008)
[10] Egging, R.; Holz, F.; Gabriel, S. A., The world gas model: A multi-period mixed complementarity model for the global natural gas market, Energy, 35, 4016-4029 (2010)
[11] Egging, R. G., Multi-period natural gas market modeling: Applications, stochastic extensions and solution approaches (2010), University of Maryland: University of Maryland (Ph.D. thesis) College Park
[13] ENTSO-G, The European natural gas network: Capacities at cross-border points on the primary market, Technical Report (2012)
[16] Gabriel, S. A.; Kiet, S.; Zhuang, J., A mixed complementarity-based equilibrium model of natural gas markets, Operations Research, 53, 799-818 (2005) · Zbl 1165.91449
[17] Gabriel, S. A.; Rosendahl, K. E.; Egging, R.; Avetisyan, H. G.; Siddiqui, S., Cartelization in gas markets: Studying the potential for a “gas OPEC”, Energy Economics, 34, 137-152 (2012)
[18] Gabriel, S. A.; Zhuang, J.; Egging, R., Solving stochastic complementarity problems in energy market modeling using scenario reduction, European Journal of Operational Research, 197, 1028-1040 (2009) · Zbl 1176.90438
[20] GSE, Storage map, Technical Report (2012)
[21] Huppmann, D., Endogenous production capacity investment in natural gas market equilibrium models, European Journal of Operational Research, 231, 503-506 (2013) · Zbl 1317.91058
[22] Huppmann, D.; Egging, R., Market power, fuel substitution and infrastructure. A large-scale equilibrium model of global energy markets, Energy, 75, 483-500 (2014)
[25] IEA, IEA statistics: Natural gas information, Technical Report (2013)
[29] GIIGNL (2012)
[30] de Joode, J.; Özdemir, O., Demand for seasonal gas storage in northwest Europe until 2030: Simulation results with a dynamic model, Energy Policy, 38, 5817-5829 (2010)
[31] Kamiński, J., Market power in a coal-based power generation sector: The case of Poland, Energy, 36, 6634-6644 (2011)
[32] Lise, W.; Hobbs, B. F., Future evolution of the liberalised European gas market: Simulation results with a dynamic model, Energy, 33, 989-1004 (2008)
[33] Lise, W.; Hobbs, B. F.; van Oostvoorn, F., Natural gas corridors between the EU and its main suppliers: Simulation results with the dynamic GASTALE model, Energy Policy, 36, 1890-1906 (2008)
[34] Lochner, S., Identification of congestion and valuation of transport infrastructures in the European natural gas market, Energy, 36, 2483-2492 (2011)
[35] Lochner, S., Modeling the European natural gas market during the 2009 Russian-Ukrainian gas conflict: Ex-post simulation and analysis, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 3, 341-348 (2011)
[36] Lochner, S.; Dieckhöner, C., Civil unrest in North Africa-Risks for natural gas supply?, Energy Policy, 45, 167-175 (2012)
[37] Moryadee, S.; Gabriel, S. A.; Avetisyan, H. G., Investigating the potential effects of U.S. LNG exports on global natural gas markets, Energy Strategy Reviews, 2, 273-288 (2014)
[38] Moryadee, S.; Gabriel, S. A.; Rehulka, F., The influence of the panama canal on global gas trade, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 20, 161-174 (2014)
[39] Neuhoff, K.; Barquin, J.; Boots, M. G.; Ehrenmann, A.; Hobbs, B. F.; Rijkers, F. A.M.; Vázquez, M., Network-constrained Cournot models of liberalized electricity markets: The devil is in the details, Energy Economics, 27, 495-525 (2005)
[41] Perloff, J. M.; Karp, L. S.; Golan, A., Industry models of market power, Estimating market power and strategies, 42-73 (2007), Cambridge University Press
[43] Schwimmbeck, R. G., LNG and pipeline, 3rd pipeline technology conference (2008)
[46] Tremblay, V. J.; Tremblay, C. H., New perspectives on industrial organization: With contributions from behavioral economics and game theory (2012), Springer: Springer New York
[51] Zhuang, J.; Gabriel, S. A., A complementarity model for solving stochastic natural gas market equilibria, Energy Economics, 30, 113-147 (2008)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.