×

Operational research and ethics: a literature review. (English) Zbl 1317.90005

Summary: Any human activity raises ethical questions, questions about ‘good’ and ‘right’ ways to act and to live; or to put it differently, questions of values and responsibility. From its inception operational research (OR) has engaged with such questions in terms of professional behavior, the handling of preferences in OR, the societal role of OR, the process of OR intervention and the content of OR analysis. As a result, analytical methods and processes have been developed to help clients explore the ethical dimension of their decisions. The paper reviews the literature published in selected OR journals (Management Science; Operations Research; Interfaces; the European Journal of Operational Research; the Journal of the Operations Research Society; Omega; International Transactions in Operational Research; the Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis), organizing it along the lines of OR’s core competences. The review identifies a number of significant research programmes that are well established and are being energetically pursued; the research findings are being applied to a wide range of important issues. Ethical questions lie at the heart of the great governmental and commercial issues of the day: economic growth and instability; inequality and injustice; environmental degradation and sustainability. They also lie at the heart of the more mundane decisions of day-to-day OR. ‘Ethics’ therefore provides a useful focus for OR both in terms of raising the awareness of all concerned and in providing a theme for research. As a result of the review some research questions are suggested. There is much of interest, much to do.

MSC:

90-02 Research exposition (monographs, survey articles) pertaining to operations research and mathematical programming
90B99 Operations research and management science

Software:

DYNAMO; ELECTRE
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Ackoff, R. L., The development of operational research as a science, Operations Research, 4, 265-295 (1956) · Zbl 1414.90005
[2] Ackoff, R. L., Education issues in management sciences and operational research, Management Science, 17, 2, B37-B53 (1970)
[3] Ackoff, R. L., Redesigning the Future (1974), Wiley: Wiley New York
[4] Ackoff, R. L., The social responsibility of operational research, Operational Research Quarterly, 25, 361-371 (1974)
[5] Ackoff, R. L., A reply to the comments of Keith Chesterton, Robert Goodsman, Jonathan Rosenhead, and Colin Thunhurst, Operational Research Quarterly, 26, 96-99 (1975)
[6] Ackoff, R. L., The Art of Problem Solving (1978), Wiley: Wiley New York
[7] Ackoff, R. L., The future of operational research is past, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 30, 93-104 (1979)
[8] Ackoff, R. L., Resurrecting the future of operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 25, 361-371 (1979)
[9] Ackoff, R. L., Creating the Corporate Future (1981), Wiley: Wiley New York
[10] Ackoff, R. L., The art and science of mess management, Interfaces, 11, 1, 20-26 (1981)
[11] Ackoff, R. L., Higher education and social stratification, Interfaces, 24, 4, 73-82 (1994)
[13] Allen, P.; Bennett, B.; Carrillo, M.; Goeller, B.; Walker, W., Quality in Policy Modeling, Interfaces, 22, 4, 70-85 (1992)
[14] Allett, E. J., Environmental impact assessment and decision analysis, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 37, 901-910 (1986)
[15] Allison, J.; Charnes, A.; Cooper, W. W.; Sueyoshi, T., Use of modeling in science and society, (Wallace, W. A., Ethics in Modelling (1994), Pergamon: Pergamon Oxford, UK), 11-36
[16] Bayraktar, B. A.; Cherniavsky, E. A.; Laughton, M. A.; Ruff, L. E., Energy Policy Planning (1979), Plenum Press: Plenum Press New York
[17] Becker, H. A., Social impact assessment, European Journal of Operational Research, 128, 311-321 (2001) · Zbl 1043.91523
[18] Beer, S., Diagnosing the System of Organizations (1985), Wiley: Wiley Chichester
[19] Bell, S.; Morse, S., Problem structuring methods: theorizing the benefits of deconstructing sustainable development projects, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 58, 576-587 (2007) · Zbl 1175.90214
[20] Belton, V., Emotionally intelligent MCDA?, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 159-160 (2005)
[21] Belton, V.; Stewart, T. J., DEA and MCDM: competing or complementary approaches, (Meskens, N.; Roubens, M., Advances in Decision Analysis (1998), Kluwer: Kluwer Dordrecht), 87-104 · Zbl 0951.90028
[22] Belton, V.; Stewart, T. J., Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: An Integrated Approach (2002), Kluwer: Kluwer Dordrecht
[23] Belton, V.; Vickers, S. P., Demystifying DEA - a visual interactive approach based on multi criteria analysis, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 44, 883-896 (1993) · Zbl 0800.90012
[24] Bennett, P. G., Hypergames: developing a model of conflict, Futures, 12, 489-507 (1980)
[25] Bennett, P. G., Mixing methods: combining conflict analysis, SODA, and strategic choice, (Eden, C.; Radford, J., Tackling Strategic Problems (1990), Sage: Sage London), 99-109
[26] Bennett, P. G.; Bryant, J.; Howard, N., Drama theory and confrontation analysis, (Rosenhead, J.; Mingers, J., Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited (2001), Wiley: Wiley Chichester), 225-248
[27] Bennett, P. G.; Cropper, S.; Huxham, Modelling interactive decisions: the hypergame focus, (Rosenhead, J., Rational Analysis for a Problematic World (1989), Wiley: Wiley Chichester), 283-314
[28] Blackett, P. M.S., Operational Research Quarterly, 1, 3-6 (1950)
[29] Boothroyd, H., Articulate Intervention: The Interface of Science, Mathematics and Administration (1978), Taylor and Francis: Taylor and Francis London
[30] Botts, T.; Brooks, D. L.; Edie, L. C.; Compton, T. E.; Garwin, R. L.; Hoeber, A. M.; Gass, S. I.; Golomski, W. A.; Gottfried, P.; Kaiser, R. D.; Kistiakowsky, G. B.; LaVallee, R. S.; McGarvey, D. C.; Miser, H. J.; Scoville, H.; Morse, P. M.; Sikes, T. W.; Strope, W. E.; Symonds, G. H.; White, M. J.; York, H. F., Letters to the editor, Operations Research, 20, 205-246 (1972)
[31] Bowen, K., On ethics, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 45, 965 (1994)
[32] Brailsford, S.; Vissers, J., OR in healthcare: a European perspective, European Journal of Operational Research, 212, 223-234 (2011)
[34] Brans, J. P., Ethics and decision, European Journal of Operational Research, 136, 340-352 (2002) · Zbl 1002.90520
[35] Brans, J. P., OR ethics and decisions: the OATH of PROMETHEUS, European Journal of Operational Research, 140, 191-196 (2002) · Zbl 1001.90002
[36] Brans, J. P., The management of the future. Ethics in operational research: respect, multicriteria management: happiness, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 466-467 (2004) · Zbl 1079.90549
[38] Brans, J. P.; Gallo, G., Ethics in OR/MS: past, present and future, Annals of Operations Research, 153, 165-178 (2007) · Zbl 1157.90301
[39] Brans, J. P.; Kunsch, P. L., Ethics in operations research and sustainable development, International Transaction in Operational Research., 17, 427-444 (2010)
[40] Brans, J. P.; Kunsch, P. L.; Mareschal, B., Management of the Future. Management of the Future, A System Dynamics and MCDA Approach, Special volume dedicated to Bernard Roy (2001), Kluwer: Kluwer Dordrecht. pp. 483-502 · Zbl 1090.91518
[41] Brans, J. P.; Macharis, C.; Kunsch, P. L.; Chevalier, A.; Schwaninger, M., Combining MCDA and system dynamics for the control of socio-economic processes. An iterative real-time procedure, European Journal of Operational Research, 109, 428-441 (1998) · Zbl 0937.90039
[42] Brans, J. P.; Mareschal, B., The PROMETHEE-GAIA decision support system, Decision Support Systems, 12, 4, 297-310 (1994)
[44] Brans, J. P.; Mareschal, B.; Vincke, Ph., How to select and how to rank projects: the PROMETHEE method, European Journal of Operational Research, 24, 228-238 (1986) · Zbl 0576.90056
[45] Brans, J. P.; Vincke, Ph., A preference ranking organisation method: the PROMETHEE method for MCDM, Management Science, 31, 6, 647-656 (1985) · Zbl 0609.90073
[46] Brocklesby, J., Ethics beyond the model: how social dynamics can interfere with ethical practice in operational research/management science, Omega, 37, 1073-1082 (2009)
[47] Brugha, C. M., Emotional intelligence in MCDA: comments on mindsets, rationality and emotion in multi-criteria decision analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 173-176 (2005)
[48] Bryant, J., The plot thickens: understanding interaction through the metaphor of drama, Omega, 25, 255-266 (1997)
[49] Campbell, G. M., Using game theory to introduce ethics in decision sciences, Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education, 2, 2, 229-234 (2004)
[50] Carpio, D.; Cohen, B.; Eldred, J.; Gangavane, G.; Greiner, J.; Hall, J.; Jayaraman, L. L.; Joglekar, P.; Levine, R.; Noad, A.; Prasow, S.; Sagasti, F.; Smith, F., A student appraisal of the proposed guidelines for operations research, Management Science, 18, 10, B618-B625 (1972)
[51] Caywood, T. E.; Berger, H. M.; Engel, J. H.; Magee, J. F.; Miser, H. J.; Thrall, R. M., Guidelines for the practice of operations research, Operations Research, 19, 1127-1137 (1971)
[52] Checkland, P., Systems Thinking, Systems Practice (1981), Wiley: Wiley Chichester
[53] Checkland, P., From optimizing to learning: a development of systems thinking for the 1990’s, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 36, 757-767 (1985)
[54] Cherniavsky, E. A., Multiobjective energy analysis, (Bayraktar, B. A.; Cherniavsky, E. A.; Laughton, M. A.; Ruff, L. E., Energy Policy Planning (1979), Plenum Press: Plenum Press New York), 399-421
[55] Chesterton, K.; Goodsman, R.; Rosenhead, J.; Thunhurst, C., A comment on “The social responsibility of operational research”, Operational Research Quarterly, 26, 91-95 (1975)
[56] Churchman, C. W., Prediction and Optimal Decision: Philosophical Issues of a Science of Values (1961), Prentice-Hall: Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
[57] Churchman, C. W., Challenge to Reason (1968), McGraw-Hill: McGraw-Hill New York
[58] Churchman, C. W., Operations research as a profession, Management Science, 17, 2, B37-B53 (1970)
[59] Churchman, C. W., The Design of Inquiring Systems (1971), Basic Books: Basic Books New York
[60] Churchman, C. W., Preface to the discussion of the ORSA guidelines, Management Science, 18, 10, B608-B609 (1972)
[61] Churchman, C. W., Morality as a value criterion, (Cochrane, J. L.; Zeleny, M., Multiple Criteria Decision Making (1973), University of South Carolina Press: University of South Carolina Press Columbia SC), 3-8
[62] Churchman, C. W., The Systems Approach and Its Enemies (1979), Basic Books: Basic Books New York
[63] Churchman, C. W., Management science: science of managing and managing of science, Interfaces, 24, 4, 99-110 (1994)
[64] Churchman, C. W.; Schainblatt, A. H., Researcher and manager: a dialectic of implementation, Management Science, 11, 4, B69-B87 (1965)
[65] Churchman, C. W.; Schainblatt, A. H., Commentary on the “Researcher and manager: a dialectic of implementation”, Management Science, 12, 2, B2-B42 (1965)
[66] Clı´maco, J. C.N., A critical reflection on optimal decision, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 506-516 (2004) · Zbl 1137.90539
[67] Clı´maco, J. C.N.; Craveirinha, J., On the role of operations research practice in strategic environmental impact assessment, International Transaction in Operational Research., 17, 445-456 (2010)
[68] Cook, S. L., Purposes and quality of education in the management sciences, Management Science, 17, 2, B5-B12 (1970)
[69] Cooper, A. K.; Ittman, H. W.; Stylianides, T.; Schmitz, P. M.U., Ethical issues in tracking cellular telephones at an event, Omega, 37, 1063-1072 (2009)
[70] Cooper, W. W., Origins, uses of, and relations between goal programming and data envelopment analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 3-11 (2005) · Zbl 1205.90006
[72] Cropper, S., Varity, formality, and style: choosing among decision support methods, (Eden, C.; Radford, J., Tackling Strategic Problems (1990), Sage: Sage London), 92-98
[73] Daellenbach, H. G., Comments on Mindsets, Rationality and Emotion in Multi-criteria Decision Analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 177-178 (2005)
[74] Dando, M. R.; Bennett, P. G., A Kuhnian crisis in management science, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 32, 91-103 (1981)
[75] Dekker, R.; Bloemhof, J.; Mallidis, I., Operations Research for green logistics - an overview of aspects, issues, contributions and challenges, European Journal of Operational Research, 219, 671-679 (2012)
[76] DeTombe, D., Copram: a method for handling complex societal problems, European Journal of Operational Research, 128, 266-281 (2001) · Zbl 1043.91521
[77] DeTombe, D., Complex societal problems in operational research, European Journal of Operational Research, 140, 232-240 (2002) · Zbl 1001.90047
[79] Dror, Y., Design for Policy Analysis (1971), Elsevier: Elsevier New York
[80] Eden, C., Cognitive mapping: a review, European Journal of Operational Research, 36, 1-13 (1988)
[81] Eilon, S., On education in management science, Management Science, 17, 2, B15-B19 (1970)
[82] Eilon, S., The role of management science, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 31, 17-28 (1980)
[84] Feng, Y. J.; Lu, H.; Bi, K., An AHP/DEA method for measurement of the efficiency of R&D management activities in universities, International Transactions in Operations Research, 11, 181-191 (2004)
[85] Flood, R.; Jackson, M., Creative Problem Solving: Total Systems Intervention (1991), Wiley: Wiley London
[86] Foster, C. D., Social welfare functions in cost-benefit analysis, (Lawrence, J. R., Operational Research and the Social Sciences (1966), Tavistock Publications: Tavistock Publications London), 305-318
[87] French, S., Decision theory. Decision theory, An Introduction to the Mathematics of Rationality (1988), Wiley: Wiley Chichester, UK · Zbl 0667.90004
[88] Friend, J.; Hickling, A., Planning Under Pressure: the Strategic Choice Approach (1987), Butterworth-Heinemann: Butterworth-Heinemann Oxford
[89] Friend, J.; Hickling, A., Planning Under Pressure: the Strategic Choice Approach (2005), Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann Oxford
[90] Friend, J.; Jessop, W. N., Local Government and Strategic Choice; an Operational Research Approach to the Process of Public Planning (1969), Tavistock Publications: Tavistock Publications London
[91] Gallo, G., Operations research and ethics: responsibility, sharing and cooperation, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 468-476 (2004) · Zbl 1137.90609
[93] Gass, S. I., Validation and assessment issues of energy, (Bayraktar, B. A.; Cherniavsky, E. A.; Laughton, M. A.; Ruff, L. E., Energy Policy Planning (1979), Plenum Press: Plenum Press New York), 421-443
[94] Gass, S. I., Decision-aiding models: validation, assessment and related issues for policy analysis, Operations Research, 31, 603-631 (1983)
[95] Gass, S. I., Documenting a computer-based model, Interfaces, 14, 3, 84-93 (1984)
[96] Gass, S. I., Managing the model process: a personal perspective, European Journal of Operational Research, 31, 1-8 (1987)
[97] Gass, S. I., The many faces of OR, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 42, 3-15 (1991)
[98] Gass, S. I., Models at the O.K. Coral, Interfaces, 21, 6, 80-86 (1991)
[99] Gass, S. I., On ethics in operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 45, 965-966 (1994)
[100] Gass, S. I., Ethical guidelines and codes in operational research, Omega, 37, 1044-1050 (2009)
[101] Geurts, J. L.A.; Joldersma, C., Methodology for participatory policy analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, 128, 300-310 (2001) · Zbl 1043.91524
[102] Gregory, R.; Keeney, R. L., Creating policy alternatives using stakeholder values, Management Science, 40, 1035-1048 (1994)
[103] Guitouni, A.; Martel, J-M., Tentative guidelines to help choosing an appropriate MCDA method, European Journal of Operational Research, 109, 501-521 (1998) · Zbl 0937.90042
[104] Häfele, W., Energy in a Finite World: A Global Systems Analysis (1981), Ballinger: Ballinger Cambridge MA
[105] Holling, C. S., Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management (1978), Wiley: Wiley Chichester
[106] Hore, P., Patrick Blackett: Sailor, Scientist. Scientist, Socialist (2003), Cass: Cass London
[107] Horner, P., History in the making, OR/MS Today, 29, 5, 30-39 (2002)
[108] Howard, N., Paradoxes of Rationality: Theory of Metagames and Political Behaviour (1971), MIT Press: MIT Press Cambridge MA
[109] Howard, N., The present and future of metagame analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, 32, 1-25 (1987)
[110] Howard, N., The manager as politician and general: the metagame approach to analyzing cooperation and conflict, (Rosenhead, J., Rational Analysis for a Problematic World (1989), Wiley: Wiley Chichester), 239-262
[111] Howard, R. A., Management science education: nature and nurture, Management Science, 17, 2, B23-B24 (1970)
[112] Hwang, C.; Yoon, K., Multi Attribute Decision Making (1981), Springer: Springer Berlin · Zbl 0453.90002
[113] Ishizaka, A.; Balkenborg, D.; Kaplan, T., Does AHP help us make choices? An experimental evaluation, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 62, 1801-1812 (2011)
[114] Jackson, M., Systems Approaches to Management (2000), Kluwer: Kluwer Dordrecht
[115] Keeney, R. L., Decision analysis: an overview, Operations Research, 30, 803-838 (1982)
[116] Keeney, R. L., Structuring objectives for problems of public interest, Operations Research, 36, 396-405 (1988)
[117] Keeney, R. L., Using values in operations research, Operations Research, 42, 793-813 (1994)
[118] Keeney, R.; Raiffa, H., Decision with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs (1976), Wiley: Wiley Chichester · Zbl 0488.90001
[119] Keeney, R. L.; Von Winterfeldt, D.; Eppel, T., Eliciting public values for complex policy decisions, Management Science, 36, 9, 1011-1030 (1990)
[121] Kirby, M. W., ’A festering sore’: the issue of professionalism in the history of the Operational Research Society, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 57, 1161-1172 (2006) · Zbl 1121.90300
[122] Koch, T., We live in the city not in a study, ORMS Today, 27, 2, 16-17 (2000)
[123] Kunsch, P. L.; Kavathatzopoulos, I.; Rauschmayer, F., Modelling complex ethical decision problems with operations research, Omega, 37, 1100-1108 (2009)
[124] Labys, W. C.; Weyant, J. P., Integrated models, Energy, 15, 341-344 (1990)
[125] (Lawrence, J. R., Operational Research and the Social Sciences (1966), Tavistock Publications: Tavistock Publications London)
[127] Le Menestrel, M., A comment on rationality, ethical values and emotion in MCDA, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 179-182 (2005)
[128] Le Menestrel, M.; Van Wassenhove, L. N., Ethics outside, within, or beyond OR models?, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 477-484 (2004) · Zbl 1137.90610
[129] Le Menestrel, M.; Van Wassenhove, L. N., Ethics in operations research and management sciences: a never-ending effort to combine rigor and passion, International Journal in Operational Research, 37: 1030-1043 (2009)
[130] Lev, B., Energy Models and Studies (1983), North-Holland: North-Holland Amsterdam
[131] Lichfield, N., Cost-benefit analysis in town planning, (Lawrence, J. R., Operational Research and the Social Sciences (1966), Tavistock Publications: Tavistock Publications London), 337-346
[132] Linares, P.; Romero, C., A multiple criteria decision making approach for electricity planning in Spain: economic versus environmental objectives, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 51, 736-743 (2000) · Zbl 1055.90557
[133] Luce, R. D.; Raiffa, H., Games and Decisions (1957), Wiley: Wiley New York · Zbl 0084.15704
[134] Macharis, C.; Springael, J.; De Brucker, K.; Verbeke, A., PROMETHEE and AHP: the design of operational synergies in multicriteria analysis. Strengthening PROMETHEE with ideas of AHP, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 307-317 (2004) · Zbl 1053.90071
[135] Machol, R., The ORSA guidelines report: a retrospective, Interfaces, 12, 3, 20-28 (1982)
[136] Maclagan, P., Methodology choice and consulting ethics in management science, Omega, 17, 397-407 (1989)
[137] Mason, R. O., A dialectical approach to strategic planning, Management Science, 15, 8, B403-B414 (1969)
[138] Mason, R. O., Morality and models, (Wallace, W., Ethics in Modelling (1994), Pergamon: Pergamon Oxford, UK), 183-194
[139] Mason, R. O.; Mitroff, I. I., Challenging Strategic Planning Assumptions (1981), Wiley: Wiley New York
[140] Meadows, D. H.; Meadows, D. L.; Randers, J.; Behrens, W. W., The Limits to Growth: A Report of the Club of Rome’s Project on the Predicament of Mankind (1972), Universe Books: Universe Books New York
[141] Midgley, G.; Munlo, I., The theory and practice of boundary critique: developing housing services for older people, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 49, 467-478 (1998) · Zbl 1131.90418
[142] (Midgley, G.; Ochoa-Arias, A. E., Community Operational Research (2004), Kluwer: Kluwer New York)
[144] Mingers, J., Multi-paradigm multimethodology, (Mingers, J.; Gill, A., Multimethodology: Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies (1997), Wiley: Wiley Chichester), 1-20
[145] Mingers, J., Ethics and OR: operationalising discourse ethics, European Journal of Operational Research, 210, 114-124 (2011)
[146] (Miser, H. J., Handbook of Systems Analysis: Volume Three - Cases (1995), Wiley: Wiley Chichester)
[147] (Miser, H. J.; Quade, E. S., Handbook of Systems Analysis: Volume One - Overview of Uses. Handbook of Systems Analysis: Volume One - Overview of Uses, Procedures and Practice (1985), Wiley: Wiley Chichester)
[148] (Miser, H. J.; Quade, E. S., Handbook of Systems Analysis: Volume Two - Craft Issues and Procedural Choices (1988), Wiley: Wiley Chichester)
[149] Mitroff, I. I., The myth of objectivity and why science needs a new psychology of science, Management Science, 18, 10, B613-B618 (1972)
[150] Müller-Merbach, H., The cultural roots linking Europe, European Journal of Operational Research, 140, 212-224 (2002) · Zbl 1010.00504
[151] Mulvey, J. M., Strategies in modeling: a personnel scheduling example, Interfaces, 9, 3, 66-76 (1979)
[152] Munro, I., An exploration of three emancipatory themes within OR and systems thinking, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 48, 576-584 (1997) · Zbl 0882.90096
[153] Munro, I.; Mingers, J., Response to Richard Ormerod, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 55, 90-93 (2004)
[154] Murphy, F. H., Policy analysis in a political environment, Interfaces, 21, 6, 87-91 (1991)
[155] Nagel, S. S.; Neef, M., Policy Analysis in Social Science Research (1979), Sage: Sage Beverly Hills CA
[156] O’Brien, F. A., Scenario planning - lessons for practice for teaching and learning, European Journal of Operational Research, 152, 709-722 (2004) · Zbl 1043.90516
[157] O’Brien, F. A., Supporting the strategy process: a survey of UK OR/MS practitioners, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 62, 900-920 (2011)
[158] Oliveira, C.; Antunes, C. H., A multiple objective model to deal with economy-energy-environment interactions, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 370-385 (2004) · Zbl 1137.90657
[159] Omkarprasad, V.; Sushil, K., Analytic hierarchy process: an overview of applications, European Journal of Operational Research, 169, 1-29 (2006) · Zbl 1077.90542
[160] Ormerod, R. J., Energy models for decision making, European Journal of Operational Research, 5, 366-377 (1980)
[161] Ormerod, R. J., On the nature of OR: entering the fray, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 47, 1-17 (1996)
[162] Ormerod, R. J., The design of organisational intervention: choosing the approach, Omega, 25, 415-435 (1997)
[163] Ormerod, R. J., On the nature of OR: taking stock, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 53, 475-491 (2002) · Zbl 1130.90362
[164] Ormerod, R. J., The history and ideas of pragmatism, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 57, 892-909 (2006) · Zbl 1114.90301
[165] Ormerod, R. J., The ethics of pragmatism: a response to Werner Ulrich, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 58, 1113-1117 (2007)
[166] Ormerod, R. J., The transformation competence perspective, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 59, 1435-1448 (2008)
[167] Ormerod, R. J., The history and ideas of Marxism, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 59, 1573-1590 (2008)
[168] Ormerod, R. J., Articulate intervention revisited, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 61, 1078-1094 (2010)
[169] Ormerod, R. J., OR as rational choice: a decision and game theory perspective, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 61, 1761-1776 (2010)
[171] Papadopoulos, A.; Karagiannidis, A., Application of the multi-criteria analysis method Electre III for the optimisation of decentralised energy systems, Omega, 36, 766-776 (2008)
[172] Parry, R.; Mingers, J., Community operational research: its context and its future, Omega, 19, 577-586 (1990)
[173] Paucar-Caceras, A.; Espinosa, A., Management science methodologies in environmental management and sustainable development: discourses and applications, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 62:1601-1620 (2011)
[174] Peters, P.; Nelson, J.; Kim, C.; Rathswohl, E., Reflections on the ORSA guidelines, Management Science, 18, B619-B625 (1972)
[175] Picavet, E., Opportunities and pitfalls for ethical analysis in operations research and the management sciences, Omega, 37, 1121-1131 (2009)
[176] Quade, E. S., Analysis for Public Decisions (1989), North-Holland: North-Holland New York
[177] Rauschmayer, F., Reflections on ethics and MCA in environmental decisions, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 10, 65-74 (2001) · Zbl 0979.90076
[178] Rauschmayer, F., Linking emotions to needs: a comment on mindsets, rationality and emotion in multi-criteria decision analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 187-190 (2005)
[179] Rauschmayer, F.; Kavathatzopoulos, I.; Kunsch, P. L.; Le Menestrel, M., Why good practice is not enough - ethical challenges for the OR practitioner, Omega, 37, 1089-1099 (2009)
[180] Rees, R. A., On “The social responsibility of operational research”, Operational Research Quarterly, 27, 265-266 (1976)
[181] Robinson, S., Simulation: The Practice of Model Development and Use (2004), Wiley: Wiley Chichester, UK
[182] Rosenhead, J., Some further comments on “The social responsibility of operational research”, Operational Research Quarterly, 27, 266-272 (1976)
[183] Rosenhead, J., From management science to workers science, (Jackson, M.; Keys, P., New Directions in Management Science (1987), Gower: Gower Aldershot)
[184] Rosenhead, J., Operational research at the crossroads: Cecil Gordon and the development of post-war OR, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 40, 3-28 (1989)
[185] Rosenhead, J.; Mitchell, G. H., Report of the commission on the future practice of operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 37, 831-886 (1986)
[186] Rosenhead, J.; Thunhurst, C., A materialist analysis of operational research, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 33, 111-122 (1982)
[187] Roy, B., Classement et choix en présence de points de vue multiples (la méthode ELECTRE), RIRO, 8, 57-75 (1968)
[188] Roy, B., ELECTRE III: Un algorithme de classement fondé sur une représentation floue des préférences en présence de critéres multiples, Cahiers du Centre d’Études Recherche Opérationnelle, 20, 3-24 (1978) · Zbl 0377.90003
[190] Roy, B., Meaning and validity of interactive procedures as tools for decision making, European Journal of Operational Research, 31, 297-303 (1987)
[191] Roy, B., Decision-aid and decision-making, European Journal of Operational Research, 45, 324-331 (1990)
[192] Roy, B., The outranking approach and the foundations of ELECTRE methods, Theory and Decision, 31, 49-73 (1991)
[193] Roy, B., Decision science or decision-aid science?, European Journal of Operational Research., 66, 184-203 (1993)
[194] Roy, B., Multicriteria Methodology for Decision Aiding (1996), Kluwer: Kluwer Dordrecht · Zbl 0893.90108
[195] Roy, B.; Vanderpooten, D., The European school of MCDA: emergence, basic features and current works, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 5, 22-38 (1996)
[196] Saaty, T. L., A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structures, Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 15, 234-281 (1977) · Zbl 0372.62084
[197] Saaty, T. L., The Analytic Hierarchy Process (1980), McGraw-Hill: McGraw-Hill New York · Zbl 0587.90002
[198] Saaty, T. L., How to make a decision? The analytic hierarchy process, Interfaces, 24, 6, 19-34 (1994)
[199] Sadler, P., OR and the transition to a post-industrial society, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 29, 1-7 (1978)
[200] Sarrico, C. S.; Dyson, R. G., Restricting virtual weights in data envelopment analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, 159, 17-34 (2004) · Zbl 1067.90086
[201] Sinuany-Stern, Z.; Mehrez, A.; Hadad, Y., An AHP/DEA methodology for ranking decision making units, International Transactions in Operational Research, 7, 109-124 (2000)
[202] Stewart, T. J., Relationships between data envelopment analysis and multicriteria decision analysis, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 47, 654-665 (1996) · Zbl 0863.90006
[203] Taket, A. R., Undercover agency? - ethics, responsibility and the practice of OR, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 45, 123-132 (1994)
[204] Taket, A. R., Mad, bad and dangerous to know?, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 45, 966-969 (1994)
[205] Taket, A. R., Ethics in practice - continuing the debate, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 46, 548-549 (1995)
[206] Taket, A. R.; White, L., After OR: an agenda for post modernism and poststructuralism in OR, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 44, 867-881 (1993)
[207] Theys, M.; Kunsch, P. L., The importance of co-operation for ethical decision-making with OR, European Journal of Operational Research, 153, 485-488 (2004) · Zbl 1053.90072
[208] Tomlinson, R. C., OR Is?, Operational Research Quarterly, 25, 347-360 (1974)
[209] Tomlinson, R. C.; Quade, E. S.; Miser, H. J., Implementation, (Miser, H. J.; Quade, E. S., Handbook of Systems Analysis: Volume One - Overview of Uses, Procedures and Practice (1985), Wiley: Wiley Chichester), 249-280
[210] Tsoukiás, Some comments on the paper mindsets, rationality and emotion in multi-criteria decision analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 183-185 (2005)
[212] Ulrich, W., Critical heuristics of social systems design, European Journal of Operational Research, 31, 228-276 (1987)
[213] Ulrich, W., Systems thinking, systems practice, and practical philosophy: a program of research, Systems Practice, 1, 137-163 (1988)
[214] Ulrich, W., Can we secure future-responsive management through systems thinking and design?, Interfaces, 24, 4, 26-37 (1994)
[216] Ulrich, W., Beyond methodology choice: critical systems thinking as critically systemic discourse, Journal of Operational Research Society, 54, 325-342 (2003) · Zbl 1088.90534
[217] Ulrich, W., Critical pragmatism: a new approach to professional and business ethics, (Zsolnai, L., Interdisciplinary Yearbook of Business Ethics, vol. I (2006), Peter Lang Academic Publishers: Peter Lang Academic Publishers Oxford, UK, and Bern, Switzerland), 53-85
[218] Ulrich, W., Rethinking critically reflective research practice: beyond Popper’s critical rationalism, Journal of Research Practice, 2, 2 (2006), Article P1
[219] Ulrich, W., Philosophy for professionals: towards critical pragmatism, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 58, 1109-1113 (2007)
[220] Ulrich, W., Operational research and critical systems thinking-an integrated perspective. Part 1: OR as applied systems thinking, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 63, 1228-1247 (2012)
[221] Ulrich, W., Operational research and critical systems thinking-an integrated perspective. Part 2: OR as argumentative practice, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 63, 1307-1322 (2012)
[222] Van Wassenhove, L. N., Blackett Memorial Lecture. Humanitarian aid logistics: supply chain management in high gear, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 57, 475-489 (2006) · Zbl 1113.90026
[223] Vargas, L., An overview of the analytic hierarchy process and its applications, European Journal of Operational Research, 48, 2-8 (1990)
[225] Wagner, H. M., Commentary on ORSA guidelines, Management Science, 18, 10, B603-B609 (1972)
[226] Walker, W. E., Responsible policy modeling, (Wallace, W. A., Ethics in Modeling (1994), Pergamon: Pergamon Oxford, UK), 226-241
[227] Walker, W. E.; Rahman, S. A.; Cave, J., Adaptive policies, policy analysis, policy analysis, and policy-making, European Journal of Operational Research, 128, 282-289 (2001) · Zbl 1043.91525
[228] Walker, W. E., Does the best practice of rational-style model-based policy analysis already include ethical consideration?, Omega, 37, 1051-1062 (2009)
[229] (Wallace, W. A., Ethics in Modeling (1994), Pergamon: Pergamon Oxford, UK)
[230] Watson, S. R., Modelling acid deposition for policy analysis, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 37, 893-900 (1986)
[231] Weber, M.; Borcherding, K., Behavioural influences on weight judgements in multiattribute decision making, European Journal of Operational Research, 67, 1-12 (1993)
[232] Wenstøp, F., Mindsets, rationality and emotion in multi-criteria decision analysis, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 161-172 (2005)
[233] Wenstøp, F., Rejoinder: some viewpoints on emotion, consequentialism and multicriteria decision making, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 13, 191-198 (2005)
[234] Wenstøp, F., Operations research and ethics: development trends 1996-2009, International Transactions in Operational Research, 17, 413-426 (2010)
[235] Wenstøp, F.; Koppang, H., On operations research and value conflicts, Omega, 37, 1109-1120 (2009)
[236] Wenstøp, F.; Seip, K., Legitimacy and quality of multi-criteria environmental policy analysis: a meta analysis of five MCE studies in Norway, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 10, 53-64 (2001) · Zbl 0979.90080
[237] White, D. J., A bibliography on the application of mathematical programming multiple-objective methods, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 41, 669-691 (1990) · Zbl 0707.90083
[238] White, L.; Bourne, H., Voices and values: linking values with participation in OR/MS in public policy making, Omega, 35, 588-603 (2007)
[239] White, L.; Lee, G. J., Operational research and sustainable development: tackling the social dimension, European Journal of Operational Research, 193, 683-692 (2009) · Zbl 1179.90002
[240] Wiek, A.; Walter, A. I., A transdisciplinary approach for formalized integrated planning and decision-making in complex systems, European Journal of Operational Research, 197, 360-370 (2009) · Zbl 1157.90467
[241] Yang, T.; Kuo, C., A hierarchical AHP/DEA methodology for the facilities layout design problem, European Journal of Operational Research, 147, 128-136 (2003) · Zbl 1011.90025
[242] Zahedi, F., The analytic hierarchy process: a survey of the method and its applications, Interfaces, 16, 4, 96-108 (1986)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.