Healthy, wealthy, and wise? Tests for direct causal paths between health and socioeconomic status. (With commentaries and responses). (English) Zbl 1038.62121
Summary: This paper provides statistical methods that permit the association of socioeconomic status and health to be partially unraveled in panel data by excluding some postulated causal paths, or delimiting their range of action. These methods are applied to the Asset and Health Dynamics of the Oldest Old (AHEAD) Panel to test for the absence of causal links from socioeconomic status (SES) to health innovations and mortality, and from health conditions to innovations in wealth. We conclude that in this elderly American population, where Medicare covers most acute care and pension income is not affected by ability to work, the evidence supports the hypothesis of no direct causal link from SES to mortality and to incidence of most sudden onset health conditions (accidents and some acute conditions), once initial health conditions are controlled, but there is some association of SES with incidence of gradual onset health conditions (mental conditions, and some degenerative and chronic conditions), due either to causal links or to persistent unobserved behavioral or genetic factors that have a common influence on both SES and innovations in health.
There is mixed evidence for an association of health conditions and innovations in wealth. The death of a spouse appears to have a negative effect on the wealth of the survivor; this is plausibly a direct causal effect. There is evidence for some association of health conditions with increased dissaving from liquid wealth for intact couples and singles. From these findings, we conclude that there is no evidence that SES-linked therapies for acute diseases induce mortality differentials. The question of whether SES-linked preventative care influences onset of chronic and mental diseases remains open. The appendix to this paper containing the detailed model estimates, the data, and the programs used for data preparation and estimation, can be found at http://elsa.berkeley.edu/wp/hww/hww202.html.
There is mixed evidence for an association of health conditions and innovations in wealth. The death of a spouse appears to have a negative effect on the wealth of the survivor; this is plausibly a direct causal effect. There is evidence for some association of health conditions with increased dissaving from liquid wealth for intact couples and singles. From these findings, we conclude that there is no evidence that SES-linked therapies for acute diseases induce mortality differentials. The question of whether SES-linked preventative care influences onset of chronic and mental diseases remains open. The appendix to this paper containing the detailed model estimates, the data, and the programs used for data preparation and estimation, can be found at http://elsa.berkeley.edu/wp/hww/hww202.html.
MSC:
| 62P25 | Applications of statistics to social sciences |
| 91B99 | Mathematical economics |
| 62P10 | Applications of statistics to biology and medical sciences; meta analysis |
| 62N03 | Testing in survival analysis and censored data |
References:
| [1] | Adler, N., Ostrove, J., 1999. Socioeconomic status and health: what we know and what we don’t. In: Adler, N. et al. (Eds.), Socioeconomic Status and Health in Industrialized Nations. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 896, 3-15.; Adler, N., Ostrove, J., 1999. Socioeconomic status and health: what we know and what we don’t. In: Adler, N. et al. (Eds.), Socioeconomic Status and Health in Industrialized Nations. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 896, 3-15. |
| [2] | Alessie, R.; Lusardi, A.; Kapteyn, A., Savings after retirementevidence from three different surveys, Labour Economics, 6, 2, 277-310 (2000) |
| [3] | Angrist, J.; Imbens, G.; Rubin, D., Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 91, 444-472 (1996) · Zbl 0897.62130 |
| [4] | Attanasio, O., Hoynes, H., 1995. Differential mortality and wealth accumulation. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 5126.; Attanasio, O., Hoynes, H., 1995. Differential mortality and wealth accumulation. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 5126. |
| [5] | Backlund, E.; Sorlie, P.; Johnson, N., A comparison of the relationships of education and income with mortalitythe national longitudinal mortality study, Social Science and Medicine, 49, 1373-1384 (1999) |
| [6] | Baker, M., Stabile, M., Deri, C., 2001. What do self-reported objective measures of health measure? National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 8419.; Baker, M., Stabile, M., Deri, C., 2001. What do self-reported objective measures of health measure? National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 8419. |
| [7] | Barsky, R.; Juster, T.; Kimball, M.; Shapiro, M., Preference parameters and behavioral heterogeneityan experimental approach in the health and retirement survey, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112, 537-579 (1997) |
| [8] | Bosma, H.; Marmot, M. G.; Hemingway, H.; Nicholson, A. C.; Brunner, E.; Stansfeld, S. A., Low job control and risk of coronary hear disease in Whitehall II (prospective cohort) study, British Medical Journal, 314, 558-565 (1997) |
| [9] | Chandola, T., Social inequality in coronary heart diseasea comparison of occupational classifications, Social Science and Medicine, 47, 525-533 (1998) |
| [10] | Chandola, T., Social class differences in mortality using the new UK National Statistics Socio-Economic Classification, Social Science and Medicine, 50, 641-649 (2000) |
| [11] | Chapman, K.; Hariharran, G., Controlling for causality in the link from income to mortality, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 8, 1, 85-93 (1994) |
| [12] | Chay, K., Greenstone, M., 2000. Does air quality matter? Evidence from the housing market. Journal of Political Economy, forthcoming.; Chay, K., Greenstone, M., 2000. Does air quality matter? Evidence from the housing market. Journal of Political Economy, forthcoming. |
| [13] | Davey-Smith, G.; Blane, D.; Bartley, M., Explanations for socio-economic differentials in mortalityevidence from Britain and elsewhere, European Journal of Public Health, 4, 131-144 (1994) |
| [14] | Dawid, A., Causal inference without counterfactuals, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 95, 407-448 (2000) · Zbl 0999.62003 |
| [15] | Dohrenwend, B., Socioeconomic status and psychiatric disordersthe causation-selection issue, Science, 255, 946-952 (1992) |
| [16] | Drever, F.; Whitehead, M., Health Inequalities (1997), ONS: ONS London |
| [17] | Ecob, R.; Smith, G., Income and healthwhat is the nature of the relationship?, Social Science and Medicine, 48, 693-705 (1999) |
| [18] | Elo, I.; Preston, S., Educational differentials in mortalityUnited States, 1979-85, Social Science and Medicine, 42, 1, 47-57 (1996) |
| [19] | Engle, R.; Hendry, D.; Richard, J., Exogeneity, Econometrica, 51, 277-304 (1983) · Zbl 0528.62093 |
| [20] | Ettner, S., New evidence on the relationship between income and wealth, Journal of Health Economics, 15, 67-85 (1996) |
| [21] | Evans, A., Causation and diseasea chronological journey, American Journal of Epidemiology, 108, 249-258 (1978) |
| [22] | Feigl, H., Notes on causality, (Feigl, H.; Brodbeck, M., Readings in the Philosophy of Science (1953), Appleton-Century-Crofts: Appleton-Century-Crofts New York) |
| [23] | Feinstein, J., The relationship between socioeconomic status and healtha review of the literature, The Millbank Quarterly, 71, 2, 279-322 (1992) |
| [24] | Felitti, V., Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction of many of the leading causes of death in adults, American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 14, 145-158 (1998) |
| [25] | Fitzpatrick, J.; Dollamore, G., Examining adult mortality rates using the National Statistics Socio-Economic Classification, Health Statistics Quarterly, 2, 33-40 (1999) |
| [26] | Fitzpatrick, R.; Bartley, M.; Dodgeon, B.; Firth, D.; Lynch, K., Social variations in health: relationship of mortality to the interim revised social classification, (Rose, D.; O’Reily, K., Constructing Classes (1997), ESRC/ONS: ESRC/ONS Swindon) |
| [27] | Fox, A.; Goldblatt, P.; Jones, D., Social class mortality differentialsartifact, selection, or life circumstances?, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 39, 1-8 (1985) |
| [28] | Freedman, D., Statistics and the scientific method, (Mason, W.; Fienberg, S., Cohort Analysis in Social Research: Beyond the Identification Problem (1985), Springer: Springer New York), 343-390 |
| [29] | Freedman, D., 2001. On specifying graphical models for causation and the identification problem. Working Paper, Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley.; Freedman, D., 2001. On specifying graphical models for causation and the identification problem. Working Paper, Department of Statistics, University of California, Berkeley. · Zbl 1120.62003 |
| [30] | Fuchs, V., Poverty and health: asking the right questions, (Rogers, D.; Ginzberg, E., Medical Care and the Health of the Poor (1993), Westview press: Westview press Boulder), 9-20 |
| [31] | Geweke, J., Inference and causality in economic time series models, (Griliches, Z.; Intriligator, M., Handbook of Econometrics, Vol. 2 (1984), North-Holland: North-Holland Amsterdam), 1101-1144 · Zbl 0587.62197 |
| [32] | Gill, R., Robins, J., 2001. Causal inference of complex longitudinal data: the continuous case. Annals of Statistics, forthcoming.; Gill, R., Robins, J., 2001. Causal inference of complex longitudinal data: the continuous case. Annals of Statistics, forthcoming. · Zbl 1043.62094 |
| [33] | Goldblatt, P. O., Longitudinal study, Mortality and Social Organization (1990), HMSO: HMSO London |
| [34] | Goldman, N., Social factors and healththe causation-selection issue revisited, Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 91, 1251-1255 (1994) |
| [35] | Goldman, N., 2001. Social inequalities in health: disentangling the underlying mechanisms. In: Weinstein, M., Hermalin, A. (Eds.), Strengthening the Dialogue between Epidemiology and Demography. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.; Goldman, N., 2001. Social inequalities in health: disentangling the underlying mechanisms. In: Weinstein, M., Hermalin, A. (Eds.), Strengthening the Dialogue between Epidemiology and Demography. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. |
| [36] | Granger, C., Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods, Econometrica, 37, 424-438 (1969) · Zbl 1366.91115 |
| [37] | Haynes, R., Inequalities in health and health service useevidence from the General Household Survey, Social Science and Medicine, 33, 361-368 (1991) |
| [38] | Heckman, J., Causal parameters and policy analysis in econometricsa twentieth century retrospective, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 105, 45-97 (2000) · Zbl 1054.91566 |
| [39] | Heckman, J., 2001. Econometrics counterfactuals and causal models. International Statistical Institute, Working Paper, University of Chicago.; Heckman, J., 2001. Econometrics counterfactuals and causal models. International Statistical Institute, Working Paper, University of Chicago. |
| [40] | Hendry, D.; Mizon, G., The pervasiveness of Granger causality in econometrics, (Engle, R.; White, H., Cointegration, Causality, and Forecasting (1999), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford) |
| [41] | Hertzman, C., Population Health and Human Development, (Keating, D.; Hertzman, C., Developmental Health and the Wealth of Nations (1999), Guilford Press: Guilford Press New York) |
| [42] | Herzog, R.; Wallace, R., Measures of cognitive functioning in the AHEAD study, Journal of Gerontology, Series B, 52B, 37-48 (1997) |
| [43] | Holland, P., Statistics and causal inference, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 81, 945-960 (1986) · Zbl 0607.62001 |
| [44] | Holland, P., Causal inference, path analysis, and recursive structural equation models, (Clogg, C., Sociological Methodology (1988), American Sociological Association: American Sociological Association Washington), (Chapter 14) |
| [45] | Hoover, K., Causality in Macroeconomics (2001), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge |
| [46] | Humphries, K.; van Doorslaer, E., Income related health inequality in Canada, Social Science and Medicine, 50, 5, 663-671 (2000) |
| [47] | Hurd, M., Savings of the elderly and desired bequests, American Economic Review, 77, 298-312 (1987) |
| [48] | Hurd, M.; McGarry, K., Evaluation of the subjective probabilities of survival in the health and retirement survey, Journal of Human Resources, 30, S268-S292 (1997) |
| [49] | Hurd, M.; Wise, D., Wealth depletion and life cycle consumption by the elderly, (Wise, D., Topics in the Economics of Aging (1989), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago) |
| [50] | Hurd, M.; McFadden, D.; Gan, L., Subjective survival curves and life cycle behavior, (Wise, D., Inquiries in the Economics of Aging (1998), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago) |
| [51] | Hurd, M.; McFadden, D.; Gan, L.; Merrill, A.; Roberts, M., Consumption and savings balances of the elderly: experimental evidence on survey response bias, (Wise, D., Frontiers in the Economics of Aging (1998), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago), 353-387 |
| [52] | Kaplan, J., Manuck, S., 1999. Status, stress, and arteriosclerosis: the role of environment and individual behaviour. In: Adler, N. et al. (Eds.), Socioeconomic Status and Health in Industrialized Nations. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 896, 145-161.; Kaplan, J., Manuck, S., 1999. Status, stress, and arteriosclerosis: the role of environment and individual behaviour. In: Adler, N. et al. (Eds.), Socioeconomic Status and Health in Industrialized Nations. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 896, 145-161. |
| [53] | Karasek, R. A.; Theorell, T.; Schwartz, J.; Schnell, P.; Peiper, C.; Michela, J., Job characteristics in relation to the prevalence of myocardial infarction in the US Health Examination Survey (HES) and the Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), American Journal of Public Health, 78, 910-918 (1988) |
| [54] | Kelley, S.; Hertzman, C.; Daniels, M., Searching for the biological pathways between stress and health, Annual Review of Public Health, 18, 437-462 (1997) |
| [55] | Kitagawa, E., Hauser, P., 1973. Differential mortality in the United States: a study. In: Socioeconomic Epidemiology. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.; Kitagawa, E., Hauser, P., 1973. Differential mortality in the United States: a study. In: Socioeconomic Epidemiology. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. |
| [56] | Kunsch, H.; Geman, S.; Kehagias, A., Hidden Markov random fields, Annals of Applied Probability, 5, 577-602 (1995) · Zbl 0842.60046 |
| [57] | Lewis, G.; Bebbington, P.; Brugha, T.; Farell, M.; Gill, B.; Jenkins, R.; Meltzer, H., Socioeconomic status, standard of living and neurotic disorder, Lancet, 352, 605-609 (1998) |
| [58] | Marmot, M., Health inequalities among British civil servantsthe Whitehall II study, Lancet, 337, 1387-1393 (1991) |
| [59] | Marmot, M.; Bobak, M.; Davey-Smith, G., Explanations for social inequalities in health, (Amick, B.; etal., Society and Health (1995), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press Oxford) |
| [60] | Marmot, M.; Bosma, H.; Hemingway, H.; Brunner, E.; Stansfeld, S., Contribution of job control and other risk factors to social variations in coronary heart disease incidence, Lancet, 350, 235-239 (1997) |
| [61] | McDonough, P.; Duncan, G.; Williams, D.; House, J., Income dynamics and adult mortality in the United States, American Journal of Public Health, 87, 1476-1483 (1997) |
| [62] | Meer, J., Miller, D., Rosen, H., 2001. Exploring the health-wealth nexus. Princeton University Working Paper.; Meer, J., Miller, D., Rosen, H., 2001. Exploring the health-wealth nexus. Princeton University Working Paper. |
| [63] | Leigh, J.; Dhir, R., Schooling and frailty among seniors, Economics of Education Review, 16, 1, 45-57 (1997) |
| [64] | Luft, H., Poverty and Health: Economic Causes and Consequences of Health Problems (1978), Ballinger: Ballinger Cambridge, MA |
| [65] | Martin, L.; Preston, S., Demography of Aging (1994), National Academy Press: National Academy Press Washington, DC |
| [66] | Martin, L.; Soldo, B., Racial and Ethnic Differences in the Health of Older Americans (1997), National Academy Press: National Academy Press Washington, DC |
| [67] | McEwen, B.; Stellar, E., Stress and the individualmechanisms leading to disease, Archives of Internal Medicine, 153, 2093-2101 (1993) |
| [68] | Murray, C.; Yang, G.; Qiao, X., Adult mortality levels: patterns and causes, (Feachem, R.; etal., The Health of Adults in the Developing World (1992), Oxford University Press: Oxford University Press New York) |
| [69] | Newey, W.; Powell, J.; Walker, J., Semiparametric estimation of selection modelssome empirical results, American Economic Review, 80, 324-328 (1990) |
| [70] | Nozick, R., Invariance: The Structure of the Objective World (2001), Harvard University Press: Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA |
| [71] | Pearl, J., Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference (2000), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge, MA · Zbl 0959.68116 |
| [72] | Power, C.; Matthews, S., Accumulation of health risks across social groups in a national longitudinal study, (Strickland, S.; Shetty, P., Human Biology and Social Inequality (1998), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge) |
| [73] | Power, C.; Matthews, S.; Manor, O., Inequalities in self-rated health in the 1958 birth cohortlife time social circumstances or social mobility?, British Medical Journal, 313, 449-453 (1996) |
| [74] | Preston, S.; Taubman, P., Socioeconomic differences in adult mortality and health status, (Martin, L.; Preston, S., Demography of Aging (1994), National Academy Press: National Academy Press Washington), 279-318 |
| [75] | Robins, J., Association, causation, and marginal structural models, Synthese, 121, 151-179 (1999) · Zbl 1078.62523 |
| [76] | Rodgers, B., Socio-economic status, employment and neurosis, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 26, 104-114 (1991) |
| [77] | Ross, C.; Mirowsky, J., Does medical insurance contribute to socioeconomic differentials in health?, The Millbank Quarterly, 78, 291-321 (2000) |
| [78] | Schnall, P.; Landsbergis, P.; Baker, D., Job strain and cardiovascular disease, Annual Review of Public Health, 15, 381-411 (1994) |
| [79] | Seeman, T., Singer, B., Love, G., Levy-Storms, L., 2002. Social relationships, gender, and allostatic load across two age cohorts. Psychosomatic Medicine 64, 395-406.; Seeman, T., Singer, B., Love, G., Levy-Storms, L., 2002. Social relationships, gender, and allostatic load across two age cohorts. Psychosomatic Medicine 64, 395-406. |
| [80] | Shorrocks, A., The age-wealth relationshipa cross-section and cohort analysis, Review of Economics and Statistics, 57, 155-163 (1975) |
| [81] | Sims, C., Money, income, and causality, American Economic Review, 62, 540-552 (1972) |
| [82] | Smith, J., Socioeconomic status and health, American Economic Review, 88, 192-196 (1998) |
| [83] | Smith, J., Healthy bodies and thick walletsthe dual relation between health and economic status, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 13, 145-166 (1999) |
| [84] | Smith, J.; Kington, R., Race, socioeconomic status, and health in late life, (Martin, L.; Soldo, B., Racial and Ethnic Differences in the Health of Older Americans (1997), National Academy Press: National Academy Press Washington), 106-162 |
| [85] | Smith, J.; Kington, R., Demographic and economic correlates of health in old age, Demography, 34, 1, 159-170 (1997) |
| [86] | Sobel, M., Measurement, causation, and local independence in latent variable models, (Berkane, M., Latent Variable Modeling and Applications to Causality (1997), Springer: Springer Berlin) · Zbl 1067.62589 |
| [87] | Sobel, M., Causal inference in the social sciences, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 95, 647-651 (2000) |
| [88] | Soldo, B.; Hurd, M.; Rodgers, W.; Wallace, R., Asset and health dynamics among the oldest oldan overview of the AHEAD study, Journal of Gerontology, Series B, 52B, 1-20 (1997) |
| [89] | Staiger, D.; Stock, J., Instrumental variables regression with weak instruments, Econometrica, 64, 556-586 (1997) · Zbl 0871.62101 |
| [90] | Stern, J., Social mobility and the interpretation of social class mortality differentials, Journal of Social Policy, 12, 27-49 (1983) |
| [91] | Swert, W., Tests of causality, (Brunner, K.; Meltzer, A., Three Aspects of Policy and Policymaking (1979), North-Holland: North-Holland Amsterdam), 55-96 |
| [92] | U.S. Census, 1999. National Vital Statistics Reports. United States Life Tables, 1997. Vol. 47 (28).; U.S. Census, 1999. National Vital Statistics Reports. United States Life Tables, 1997. Vol. 47 (28). |
| [93] | Wadsworth, M., The Imprint of Time: Childhood, History, and Adult Life (1991), Clarendon Press: Clarendon Press Oxford |
| [94] | Whitehead, M., The Health Divide (1988), Penguin: Penguin London |
| [95] | Wilkinson, R., Equity, social cohesion, and health, (Strickland, S.; Shetty, P., Human Biology and Social Inequality (1998), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge University Press Cambridge) |
| [96] | Woodward, J., Causal interpretation in systems of equations, Synthese, 212, 199-247 (1999) |
| [97] | Woodward, M.; Shewry, M.; Smith, C.; Tunstall-Pedoe, H., Social status and coronary heart diseaseresults from the Scottish Heart Health Study, Preventive Medicine, 21, 136-148 (1992) |
| [98] | Zellner, A., Causality and econometrics, (Brunner, K.; Meltzer, A., Three Aspects of the Policy and Policymaking (1979), North-Holland: North-Holland Amsterdam), 9-54 |
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.
