Emily May's Reviews > The Three-Body Problem
The Three-Body Problem (Remembrance of Earth’s Past, #1)
by
I have friends who thought this was one of the deepest cleverest books they’ve ever read, and other friends who thought it was an overlong, dull stream of exposition.
The difficulty I have is that I think they’re both kinda right.
Some people said the beginning was slow, but this was the part I found most gripping. I was fascinated by all the parts about the Chinese Cultural Revolution and I thought it was very tense when Wang began seeing an inexplicable countdown in the photographs he took. What happens when the timer gets to zero? I was desperate to know.
I also love books that are like looking up into the vast expanse of space and feeling just how infinitesimal you are. It can be literal or metaphorical, but I think some of the best sci-fi concepts are ones that make me feel tiny. Blake Crouch also does it effectively for me, though his books are a lot lighter than Liu's. That feeling of being stood at the centre of something way bigger and more complex than you will ever understand is so powerful (look at me being deep!)
The story unfolds slowly, creating a sense of foreboding and just... wrongness. It was effective. There were moments in the first third or so where I felt deeply unsettled, almost scared.
The hardest part for me was in the middle. There was a lot of technical language that I had to struggle through with the help of google. I am one of those people who will profess an interest in science but, truthfully, I am most acquainted with simply-explained easily digestible science. I gotta be honest.. start talking about nanoparticles and molecular construction and my eyes typically glaze over. But I don’t mind doing the work. Google was my friend. I tried my best to follow it.
I think, though, worse than the technical language and never-ending exposition, was playing the game. In the middle of this book, the characters spend a lot of time playing a video game called Three-Body. I get that it serves a bigger purpose than simple game-playing, but also it is in fact just a game, and I found it mind-numbing to sit through Wang's adventures into each new Trisolaris civilization.
I've never been into books about playing games, never got the Ready Player One thing. I like playing games myself, but don't understand the appeal of watching others do it. And that's what it felt like I was doing for a big chunk of this book.
Add to this the fact that characterization suffers in favour of exploring the sci-fi concept, and my interest peaked somewhere in the first half.
My husband just finished the second book and liked it more than this one, so I will give it a go. I'm hoping for a little less conversation, a little more action and a lot more in the way of characters I can become invested in. Here's hoping!
by
One night, Ye was working the night shift. This was the loneliest time. In the deep silence of midnight, the universe revealed itself to its listeners as a vast desolation.
I have friends who thought this was one of the deepest cleverest books they’ve ever read, and other friends who thought it was an overlong, dull stream of exposition.
The difficulty I have is that I think they’re both kinda right.
Some people said the beginning was slow, but this was the part I found most gripping. I was fascinated by all the parts about the Chinese Cultural Revolution and I thought it was very tense when Wang began seeing an inexplicable countdown in the photographs he took. What happens when the timer gets to zero? I was desperate to know.
I also love books that are like looking up into the vast expanse of space and feeling just how infinitesimal you are. It can be literal or metaphorical, but I think some of the best sci-fi concepts are ones that make me feel tiny. Blake Crouch also does it effectively for me, though his books are a lot lighter than Liu's. That feeling of being stood at the centre of something way bigger and more complex than you will ever understand is so powerful (look at me being deep!)
The story unfolds slowly, creating a sense of foreboding and just... wrongness. It was effective. There were moments in the first third or so where I felt deeply unsettled, almost scared.
The hardest part for me was in the middle. There was a lot of technical language that I had to struggle through with the help of google. I am one of those people who will profess an interest in science but, truthfully, I am most acquainted with simply-explained easily digestible science. I gotta be honest.. start talking about nanoparticles and molecular construction and my eyes typically glaze over. But I don’t mind doing the work. Google was my friend. I tried my best to follow it.
I think, though, worse than the technical language and never-ending exposition, was playing the game. In the middle of this book, the characters spend a lot of time playing a video game called Three-Body. I get that it serves a bigger purpose than simple game-playing, but also it is in fact just a game, and I found it mind-numbing to sit through Wang's adventures into each new Trisolaris civilization.
I've never been into books about playing games, never got the Ready Player One thing. I like playing games myself, but don't understand the appeal of watching others do it. And that's what it felt like I was doing for a big chunk of this book.
Add to this the fact that characterization suffers in favour of exploring the sci-fi concept, and my interest peaked somewhere in the first half.
My husband just finished the second book and liked it more than this one, so I will give it a go. I'm hoping for a little less conversation, a little more action and a lot more in the way of characters I can become invested in. Here's hoping!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Three-Body Problem.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 12, 2024
–
Started Reading
March 12, 2024
– Shelved
March 19, 2024
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Robin
(new)
-
added it
Mar 22, 2024 07:56PM
Did you like it?
reply
|
flag
That is sort of indeed my thoughts on it. I read it a year ago and was excited to continue but I never did and I am not keen on picking up the next one. I will at some point, probably.
I actually really liked the game part... but I agree on the characterization, that what made it boring for me. there was the potential for one of the most interesting villain, and they where just meh .
Kate wrote: "I actually really liked the game part... but I agree on the characterization, that what made it boring for me. there was the potential for one of the most interesting villain, and they where just m..."
I've heard the second book is very different to the first, so I am hopeful we will get better characterization. I know some people can ignore the characters if the rest of the book is strong enough, but I find that hard :(
I've heard the second book is very different to the first, so I am hopeful we will get better characterization. I know some people can ignore the characters if the rest of the book is strong enough, but I find that hard :(
Rob wrote: "My inclination to read this soon has waned. Thanks for the review, maybe I’ll try the show first."
I just watched the first episode. Seems like they made a LOT of changes... can't decide if that's good or bad yet.
I just watched the first episode. Seems like they made a LOT of changes... can't decide if that's good or bad yet.
Actually I found the gaming parts quite exciting, and was looking forward to the characters exploring the rest of Three Body. The scientific jargon did not bother me, since I have a scientific background myself, but I agree that there were some boring parts in the story. The other thing I didn't like initially about all 4 books (there's a fourth part written by a different author) is how the main character changes from book to book, and you need to get used to them, and learn to empathize with them again. But I believe this was intentionally done by the author to create the sense of smallness in time and space as you described. This is the story of humanity and its struggle in the universe, and not of a particular individual.
ⵎⵓⵏⵉⵔ wrote: "Actually I found the gaming parts quite exciting, and was looking forward to the characters exploring the rest of Three Body. The scientific jargon did not bother me, since I have a scientific back..."
Is there any gaming in the second book? I think this aspect was just not for me and affected my enjoyment a lot.
Is there any gaming in the second book? I think this aspect was just not for me and affected my enjoyment a lot.
Emily May wrote: "ⵎⵓⵏⵉⵔ wrote: "Actually I found the gaming parts quite exciting, and was looking forward to the characters exploring the rest of Three Body. The scientific jargon did not bother me, since I have a s..."
It's been a while since I read the books, but I believe that the gaming was only in the first book.
It's been a while since I read the books, but I believe that the gaming was only in the first book.
I felt very similar to you after reading the book. I'm watching the series right now and I find a lot of the scenes translate better on screen, especially the 3-body game ones, which I struggled through while reading. Also, I adore Benedict Wong!
Unfortunately, you will find that the characterizations are lacking across all of Liu's writing. Compelling characters and emotions are definitely not his strong suit, hahaha.
Like your husband, I thought the second book was better than this one. Thank you for your well thought out review, I found it really interesting.