Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies's Reviews > The Strangely Beautiful Tale of Miss Percy Parker

The Strangely Beautiful Tale of Miss Percy Parker by Leanna Renee Hieber
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4527753
The title is a misnomer. I would have titled this The Twistingly Tangential Tale of Miss Percy Parker instead. Good lord, how this story wandered.

I'm going to be quoting a lot from this book in this review. The quotes are too priceless not to be used, and they give a pretty good impression of the entirety of the book and the writing...which is not a good thing. The writing tries too hard to be poetic and 19th century, and instead sounds like an author's flowery rendition instead of actual, believable prose and speech. The result is a laughable, melodramatic arrangement of prose that is even more absurd given the clichéd characters and the confoundingly confusing plot.

The story takes place in the Victorian Era and revolves around a group of six people who are summoned to meet each other through mysterious means. They each have special "strengths," for example, the Intuition, the Artist, the Heart (...by your powers combined, I am Captain Planet! Oops, wrong group of people). They see spirits, and are awaiting a foreseen Seventh power, that will either enhance them if they choose the correct person, or destroy them and the world if they choose wrongly. From then on, they begin working together, and two of them work together at the Athens Academy, an institution of enlightened learning that also accepts women, a fairly rare thing given the time period.

Twenty years later, a young woman comes to Athens Academy. She is an orphan, with "...deathly pale skin, the whole of her white as snow. Glasses shaded her pale eyes, which, through their glass, appeared almost violet." Persephone Parker is as Mary Sue as they come. She believes she is sooooooooo ugly and hideous, due to her appearance. Naturally, anyone with pale, flawless skin, a "fine-featured face," "pearlescent hair", and "opalescent eyes" has got to be hideous. Am I right? And me with my brown hair and eyes. It's a wonder that people look at me without turning to stone.

Percy is the special snowflake. The Chosen One. The Prophecied One. You see where this is going, right? As clearly as my palm is going to my forehead.

Percy still doesn't believe how pretty she is, even when heads turn at her entrance, no matter what she's repeatedly told...
"...I think it is lovely, your face. You are like a doll—I do not know the name...one of those that break if you drop them."
She also speaks any number of languages, except Mandarin (it's one of her weaker languages). She picks up languages easily, and even speaks Aramaic. Freaking Aramaic. But she's not altogether flawless, for example: she sucks at math.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR REINFORCING YET ANOTHER STEREOTYPE THAT GIRLS ARE BAD IN THE MATHS AND SCIENCES. THIS FUCKING BOOK.

***Aside to the author: if you're going to have your main character be a language specialist who picks up any dialect at the drop of a pin, it's best not to have her make stupid grammatical errors in a simple language such as French. Even in French 101, we know better than to say "ma amie." It's mon amie.***

I cannot enjoy Percy's character. She's supposed to be the prophesied one, but she is so simple-minded. She does not act like someone who will bring about change. She does not act like someone who can inspire. She does not act like one who is remotely capable of anything besides breathing and eating. I didn't mention pooping, because this Mary Sue of a fluff certainly does not do anything so basic as taking a shit like the rest of us. I cannot believe Percy is supposed to be who is, and I find it completely reasonable that the other characters in the book have their doubts, as well.

Percy is also hopelessly infatuated with her teacher. Alexi Rychman is the professor, the love interest, the head honcho of this entire ultra-secretive. He's twice her age, not to mention her instructor. Her very, very personal instructor and tutor. In this day and age, we call that an abuse of power. And ugh, what a stereotype Mr. Rychman is...
Lustrous dark hair hung loosely to broad shoulders. A few locks turned out in an unkempt manner contrary to the rest of his appearance, while a few strands clung to his noble, chiseled features—a long nose, high cheekbones, defined lips like a Grecian sculpture and impossibly dark eyes.
Their relationship is quite limited, to the extent that he growls at her constantly in anger (yet is inexplicably attracted to this strange young woman half his age), and she simpers and blushes prettily in response.
“No need for apologies,” he replied. “I was the one asking the questions.”
“Thank you, sir.”
“And there’s no need to thank me!” the professor snapped.
“I’m sorry---Oh dear!” Percy murmured, biting her lip and yearning to retreat into her corset.
That pretty much sums up the entirety of their entire relationship.

Alexi is the rough, blunt, angry, dark Heathcliff of a man, resistant as all hell to the finer emotions, with whom Percy, that twit of a simpering schoolgirl inexplicably loves. And how she loves him, sighs over him, swoons over him...Alexi is her math teacher, and she's more obsessed with looking at him than focusing on her lessons: no wonder she's failing.
Percy groaned. “Oh, that class remains my bane! I pay attention, take countless notes, but all I remember is the sound of Professor Rychman’s voice. Every syllable he speaks is like a hypnotic delicacy, like dark velvet. I try to grasp his explanations, but all I can see is how his robe sweeps as he moves, how his presence commands the room, how his brow furrows in thought, how his eyes blaze, how he calmly brushes a lock of dark hair from his noble face...'
Did you hear that? That's the sound of me gagging. Percy makes Bella's mooning over Edward seem rational and reasonable.

But that's enough of how much I despised the main characters. But wait, there's not just two characters. Noooooo. That would be too easy. We are introduced to six characters in the original group, and rest assured, we are constantly informed of them and their various enterprises. There's also your supporting cast of various girlfriends, ghosts, and a false Seventh. The massive cast, the minor investigative plots, the barely-controlled and infuriating student-teacher sexual tension all adds up to one thing: a massive headache for the reader.
144 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Strangely Beautiful Tale of Miss Percy Parker.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 25, 2013 – Shelved as: to-review
May 25, 2013 – Shelved
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: boarding-school
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: alpha-male
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: ghosts
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: magic
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: tstl
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: uk
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: why-do-i-hate-myself
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: victorian
Started Reading
September 1, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies BWAHAHAHA. Oh man, two 1-star books in as many days. I'm having an awesome run of luck here.


aimee (aimeecanread) Sounds like a typical, boring book. Probably won't ever pick this up.


message 3: by Mizuki (new) - added it

Mizuki Persephone Parker is as Mary Sue as they come
Even the name screams Mary Sue.XD


Angélica Oh my gosh. I remember this one. I was in the minority when I first reviewed this. I studied languages (Spanish, German, and a wee bit of French) back in Uni and so I was more critical about Percy's knack for languages. It comes off as Mary Sue-ish than interesting. And the grammatical errors! Also, I was not convinced by the Alexi/Percy romance bit. Alexi reminds me too much of Romanticized!Snape to take seriously.


message 5: by Tandie (new) - added it

Tandie Awww, I was really hoping this would be a winner. I sometimes like the hot for teacher trope if it doesn't smack of pedophilia. Judging from some of the quotes, the prose seems a bit purple. What did you think of the writing style, lame storyline & characters aside?


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies Tandie wrote: "Awww, I was really hoping this would be a winner. I sometimes like the hot for teacher trope if it doesn't smack of pedophilia. Judging from some of the quotes, the prose seems a bit purple. What d..."

The writing is very, very descriptive, but stops just short of being painfully purple prosy. A lot of showing, a lot of background information given. The prose runs a little bit overdramatic and the dialogue quite archaic, but given the time in which it's set, it's not too out of place, even if the dialogue can be a little awkward at times.


Liz* Fashionably Late Alexi Rychman in my head:
description


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies Liz* wrote: "Alexi Rychman in my head:
"


NOOOOOOO. I love Snape ;_;

I'd climb that like a tree


message 9: by Basuhi (last edited Sep 01, 2013 05:18AM) (new)

Basuhi Is there a stereotype that Girls are bad at math and science ? I didn't know that :/
It's so untrue. Well, this "snow white" surpasses Bella, as you said.
Nice review, Khanh. And sorry you've had such bad luck :( On the plus side, I think nothing can be worse than this :P
But I do hope you're next read is much much better.


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies Basuhi wrote: "Is there a stereotype that Girls are bad at math and science ? I didn't know that :/
It's so untrue. Well, this "snow white" surpasses Bella, as you said.
Nice review, Khanh. And sorry you've had s..."


I don't know if it's that way in India, Basuhi, but in the West, there is definitely a stereotype that women and girls are poor at math. We're very, very underrepresented in the math and science field here.


message 11: by ☼Bookish (new)

☼Bookish in Virginia☼ If I was going to retreat, it would be further than my corset.

Thanks for the warning. "Bites pale, opalescent lips, and retreats to underwear drawer."


message 12: by Yzabel (new)

Yzabel Ginsberg Somehow, I'm having visions of my albino Hermetist mage character in a pen & paper RPG... She was quite a a language Mary Sue as well (also being one of the, uh, 10 or so people in the world who could read and speak the legendary Hyperborean?), but at least I do think I played her better than that. And she could ace her way through math, contrary to her player. XD


message 13: by inga (new) - added it

inga I read this back in 2011 when I was a lot less critical than I am now and gave it three stars, but in retrospect, it truly is awful. I also read the second one, and although I do not recall what happens in it at all, I still remember it being mentioned that Alexi stayed a virgin his whole life because Percy's appareance was prophesied when he was a kid or something, and it made me lol. So much wish fullfillment in one book.


message 14: by Megan (new)

Megan Great review. You're hilarious! :)


message 15: by Emily (new)

Emily soo, i don't want to read this? :D


message 16: by Jenna (new)

Jenna Loesch inga wrote: "I read this back in 2011 when I was a lot less critical than I am now and gave it three stars, but in retrospect, it truly is awful. I also read the second one, and although I do not recall what ha..."

I just had a case of the shudders. That's seriously pedophilic. I just can't. Eww. How old is this girl, anyways?


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Do not want.


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies She is in her late teens :\


message 19: by Jenna (new)

Jenna Loesch That could still mean underage. Ugh. Gross.


message 20: by TL (new)

TL Great review Khan, will be skipping this one.. sorry you didn't enjoy it *hugs*


message 21: by Gabi (new)

Gabi It's funny someone would title their novel "The Strangely Beautiful" anything. Very unbiased and modest, right?


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

Awesome review but this pikachu looks more entertaining than this book:




message 23: by Müni (new)

Müni Hahahaa this review is priceless :)))


message 24: by Nina (new)

Nina Kat Stark wrote: "Awesome review but this pikachu looks more entertaining than this book:

"


I can't resume it better :)

Excellent review Khan! It seems that the author took the most annoying clichés of YA books and put all them together in this book.


message 25: by [deleted user] (last edited Jul 03, 2014 07:17PM) (new)

Opalescent eyes? That would scare the hell out of me. But the writing. Ugh, I can't believe she described him like that. That could have been shorted. Where was the editor?


message 26: by Annathea (new)

Annathea "while a few strands clung to his noble, chiseled features—a long nose, high cheekbones, defined lips like a Grecian sculpture and impossibly dark eyes."

And I see him with hair stuck all over his face. You know, like when it's hot and windy and your hair get constantly in your face ;)


message 27: by Jilly (new)

Jilly "his noble, chiseled features"?
I already want to gag. Definitely not going on my to-read list! It sounds almost like it would provide a good laugh, but the gag-potential is too high!
Thanks for the great review as usual!


message 28: by Ons (new)

Ons that sounds really bad anyway thanks for the warning.


hpboy13 Aw, I'm bummed you didn't like this one, I quite enjoyed it! I didn't see Percy as a Mary Sue - I can see why she'd have issues with her appearance, being albino in the rigid Victorian times. And I thought the book did a good job combining Jack the Ripper and the Persephone myth into a gaslight romance.


message 30: by Yzabel (new)

Yzabel Ginsberg Hpboy13 wrote: "I can see why she'd have issues with her appearance, being albino in the rigid Victorian times."

Is she specifically described as albino, or does she simply have white hair and clear eyes because it'd make her "speshul"?
(Just asking. Albino people are often not so well-portrayed in fiction, with authors conveniently forgetting things like the vision impairments that come with that condition.)


message 31: by Niquie (new)

Niquie I remember in high school there were these sisters who were albino. I remember overhearing that the older sister was going to go blind. What's funny is they looked nothing like how Percy was described, to be fair they were black so their skin just looked light brownish and their hair was a sort of blond. I wonder what happened to them.


hpboy13 Yzabel wrote: "Hpboy13 wrote: "I can see why she'd have issues with her appearance, being albino in the rigid Victorian times."

Is she specifically described as albino, or does she simply have white hair and cle..."


Yeah, she is actually albino, not just pale. I don't recall anything about her vision; but to be fair, there is a lot of fantasy stuff going on.


message 33: by Yzabel (new)

Yzabel Ginsberg OK. I guess I'm just growing tired with albino people being used "because they look like great villains", "because white hair is cool", etc... but it's mostly the "cool factor", and all the rest is conveniently swept aside.

(As a matter of fact, albinism seriously affects one's vision, to the point of making them considered as legally blind. Any albino character would have to wander around with glasses, at the very least, and take serious care when they go outside. Stuff like the uber-skilled albino sniper in The DaVinci Code is just not believable.)

Being specifically albino in Victorian times, there's indeed reason for a young woman to have issues with her appearance, since a lot of people would likely have made it an issue for her. (Which is bull as well, but, hey, judgemental and hypocritical society and all that.) But if albinism is only used for that, and other characteristics aren't mentioned, it'd definitely bother me.

At least she doesn't have red eyes! ;)


message 34: by K.P. (new)

K.P. Merriweather another albino special snowflake? argh. people never get it right. -_- another bad book avoided due to awesome kahnh taking the bullet first! geh i dont see how you tolerate it!! much stronger than i am sure. i'd be roasting these books right now grilling my brats...


Jennifer Your review made me snicker and roll my eyea


Jennifer (Sorry for the double post!) Your review made me snicker and roll my eyes at how clichéd it all sounds. I haven't read it yet but I might just to have a laugh. Has to be better than some fanfic I've read.... right?

As soon as I saw the professor's name in this story, I didn't even have to be prompted to see a certain Potions Professor in the role.


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies I don't care if his hair is greasy. Snape>>>>>all


message 38: by Kaitlyn (new)

Kaitlyn I know this is an old review, but I've been stuck at home with a stomach bug and your "why do I hate myself" bookshelf has been cracking me up! Persephone's mushiness over her prof reminds me of Helga from "Hey Arnold!" More than anything.


message 39: by Kaitlyn (new)

Kaitlyn I know this is an old review, but I've been stuck at home with a stomach bug and your "why do I hate myself" bookshelf has been cracking me up! Persephone's mushiness over her prof reminds me of Helga from "Hey Arnold!" More than anything.


Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies Such kind words, thank you!


message 41: by Christine (new) - added it

Christine Thank you, Your Grinchliness, for saving me from this book. Your review simultaneously alarmed and amused me.


message 42: by Reborn (new)

Reborn "The List of 7" is probably my all-time favorite book. A blogger I follow and thought I could trust recommended this book (her favorite) and sold it in a way that made it sound a lot like "List." Boy, was it not like that at all. I couldn't finish this one.


Heather Clawson To be fair, the book is a Gothic Romance, and that genre is built on old-fashioned stereotypes of men and women. It's also built on pale, delicate heroines, and brooding, intense heroes. I didn't think it was a literary gem by any stretch of the imagination, but there is a portion of the reading populace that goes in for just those kinds of characters.

That being said, 100% to everything in this review. :D


message 44: by Amber (new)

Amber Ray This book is a lot like the movie "The Eternals" to me. A big group of superbeings that Know Better Than Everyone and have a Special Power Each. God forbid people are able to do more than one thing! The book and the movie (in my opnion) take just too long to get going and neither made me give a damn about these Powerful Beings. The scene where the Powerful Beings honestly sounds more like a possession...and a not entirely benign one really. They basically hijack these people's lives even though they don't take over their minds....entirely. But...the owners of the bodies didn't invite them in! And yes, the age thing plays as squickly here to me! Ok...yet another problem in the "born again lovers trope"--if you don't get the ages lined up right it's gross!


back to top