Cav's Reviews > Some People Need Killing: A Memoir of Murder in the Philippines

Some People Need Killing by Patricia Evangelista
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
73029907
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: asia, biography, crime, culture, politics, real-life-saga

"What I want to do is instill fear."
—Mayor Rodrigo Roa Duterte

"This is a book about the dead, and the people who are left behind. It is also a personal story, written in my own voice, as a citizen of a nation I cannot recognize as my own. The thousands who died were killed with the permission of my people. I am writing this book because I refuse to offer mine..."

Some People Need Killing sounded interesting enough and covering this subject matter is an important historical record. However, the delivery left much to be desired for me... For such rich source material, the final product was not up to scratch. More below.

Author Patricia Chanco Evangelista is a Filipina journalist and documentary filmmaker based in Manila, whose coverage focuses mostly on conflict, disaster and human rights. She is a multimedia reporter for online news agency Rappler and is a writer-at-large for Esquire magazine.

Patricia Evangelista:
download

Unfortunately, and despite the attention-grabbing title, this one just did not meet my expectations. I am admittedly extremely picky about how interesting and/or engaging the books I read are, and I just did not enjoy the overall formatting of this book.

The author writes in a very long-winded, verbose fashion that makes the book really drag on. She layers on many unnecessary literary accouterments here; there are extensive descriptions of trees, surroundings, and other irrelevant assorted minutia that take away from the bigger picture. It was also just a very long book to begin with - the audio version I have clocked in at a hefty almost 12 hours. The PDF; well over 400 pages. Way too long. There are many long-winded tangents that the author goes off on that manage to effectively lose the forest for the trees. I am really not a fan of writing styles like this...

She talks about the background of the book in this quote:
"From the beginning of the Duterte era, recording these deaths became my job. As a field correspondent for Rappler in Manila, I was one of then reporters covering the results of the president’s pledge to destroy anyone— without charge or trial—whom he or the police or any of a number of vigilantes suspected of taking or selling drugs. The volume of Duterte’s dead was at times overwhelming, as was covering the powerful in a country nwhere the powerful refuse to be held to account."

The author is a disaster journalist by trade, and drops this quote about the nature of her job:
"My job is to go to places where people die. I pack my bags, talk to the survivors, write my stories, then go home to wait for the next catastrophe. I don’t wait very long.
I can tell you about those places. There have been many of them in the last decade. They are the coastal villages after typhoons, where babies were zipped into backpacks after the body bags ran out. They are the hillsides in the south, where journalists were buried alive in a layer cake of cars and corpses. They are the cornfields in rebel country and the tent cities outside blackened villages and the backrooms where mothers whispered about the children that desperation had forced them to abort.
It’s handy to have a small vocabulary in my line of work. The names go first, then the casualty counts. Colors are good to get the description squared away. The hill is green. The sky is black. The backpack is purple, and so is the bruising on the woman’s left cheek.
Small words are precise. They are exactly what they are and are faster to type when the battery is running down..."
"...Kill, for example. It’s a word my president uses often. He said it at least 1,254 times in the first six months of his presidency, in a variety of contexts and against a range of enemies. He said it to four-year-old Boy Scouts, promising to kill people who got in the way of their future. He said it to overseas workers, telling them there were jobs to be had killing drug addicts at home. He told mayors accused of drug dealing to repent, resign, or die.
He threatened to kill human rights activists if the drug problem worsened. He told cops he would give them medals for killing. He told journalists they could be legitimate targets of assassination.
“I’m not kidding,” he said in a campaign rally in 2016. “When I become president, I’ll tell the military, the police, that this is my order: find these people and kill them, period.”
I know only a few dozen of the dead by name. It doesn’t matter to the president. He has enough names for them all. They are addicts, pushers, users, dealers, monsters, madmen."


********************

I did not enjoy the presentation of this book. For such an important historical record, I felt like the telling needed to be more coherent. A subjective take; to be sure.
It was also too long; in general. The writing got tedious and long-winded quite often here. The final product is in dire need of a more rigorous editing. There's far too much superfluous writing here. IMO, ~half of the book could have been edited out without a loss to the finished product.
2 stars.
25 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Some People Need Killing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 3, 2023 – Started Reading
November 3, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
November 3, 2023 – Shelved
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: asia
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: biography
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: crime
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: culture
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: politics
November 13, 2023 – Shelved as: real-life-saga
November 13, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Almira Porta The suggestion to cut down a memoir dedicated to the numerous murders and their bloody aftermath is frankly ridiculous. The know the gravity of the situation, the length of detail and count of bodies are required.

If you want short books, I suggest Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark? Might be more your speed.


message 2: by Cav (last edited Dec 11, 2023 06:25PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Cav Almira wrote: "The suggestion to cut down a memoir dedicated to the numerous murders and their bloody aftermath is frankly ridiculous. The know the gravity of the situation, the length of detail and count of bodies are required.

If you want short books, I suggest Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark? Might be more your speed."


Hi there,
Thank you for taking the time to drop by and bump my review with your righteous indignation. I appreciate it!

You've made some interesting assumptions. Don't you know what Mama said about assumptions??
"The know the gravity of the situation, the length of detail and count of bodies are required."
Unedited incorrect grammar aside, you are assuming that it is this that I took issue with. That was not my complaint. My complaint was the tedium and long-winded irrelevant tangents that the author goes off on numerous times here. I mean, I literally said as much in my review. Do you have trouble with basic comprehension??

Finally; thank you kindly for your book recommendations. However, a cursory glance at your bookshelf suggests that it is you who might feel more comfortable with books of that caliber. I mean, you've literally only read 17 books, and from what I can tell, a large number of them are no more than campy fictional romances. You've even got a Hunger Games book. LMAO.
Have you also not heard of what they say about people who live in glass houses?

Anyhow, thanks again for taking the time to drop by, and feel free to complain about me more here, or even in your own review. That's what Goodreads is for, after all.
Ciao


message 3: by Victoria (new) - added it

Victoria Was it really necessary to take a dig at someone else's shelf to make your point? Get off your high horse, white man.


message 4: by Cav (last edited Sep 11, 2024 07:04AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Cav Victoria wrote: "Was it really necessary to take a dig at someone else's shelf to make your point? Get off your high horse, white man."

Hi there, random outraged woman. Yes, it was necessary. But thanks for asking me, tho. Nice little bit of vitriolic racial commentary there. You should talk to someone about that... Angry racism is not a good look you know,
Anyhow, thanks for adding a comment and bumping my review. Feel free to screech some more at me. I always appreciate the bumps to my reviews.


back to top