Glenn Russell's Reviews > The Other Name: Septology I-II
The Other Name: Septology I-II
by
CONGRATULATIONS TO JON FOSSE FOR WINNING THE 2023 NOBEL PRIZE FOR LITERATURE
"I already have ten or so big paintings finished plus four or five small ones, something like that, fourteen paintings in all in two stacks next to each other by the kitchen door, since I'm about to have a show, most of the paintings are approximately square..."
So Asle tells us on the opening page of The Other Name.
Asle is a painter living alone on the southwest coast of Norway. I can imagine one of his paintings in the stacks might look something like the artwork above. Or, perhaps this bold diagonal brushstroke can be likened to a section of his largest canvas, the one Asle is working on now, the one on the easel in his studio, a large rectangular painting, wider than it is high, one thick diagonal line painted in brown, the other thick diagonal line painted in purple, the two thick dripping lines crossing in the middle.
Jon Fosse relates his daily schedule when writing this, his longest work: while living in an apartment outside Vienna in Austria, he would wake up at four in the afternoon, start writing at five and continuing through the night until nine the next morning (that's sixteen straight hours of writing!). As the Norwegian author acknowledges, it was a very strange experience. And since he always has written shorter novels, the length of Septology surprised him. Note: Septology is a 667-pager and contains seven parts in three volumes: I-II The Other Name, III-V I Is Another and VI-VII A New Name.
When speaking of his own writing process, Jon Fosse notes he doesn't have a set plan when writing a novel. He just sits down and listens. The novel is fully formed somewhere in his subconscious, and all he has to do is write it down before it disappears – and the hearing happens as he's writing. For Jon, it's too boring to plan things out in advance; rather, it's all about the excitement of the journey into the unknown where something comes into existence that he didn't know before. That is to say, Jon would never write in an autobiographical way. Worth underscoring: Jon Fosse is not writing autofiction a la fellow Norwegian Karl Ove Knausgård or Kjersti Skomsvold.
The action of the novel is straightforward enough: Asle does things like speak with his neighbor Åsleik who clears his driveway when it snows, drives from his home in Dylgja to the small city of Bjørgvin, and, one time while in Bjørgvin, comes to the rescue of another painter by the name of Asle who collapsed dead drunk out in the snow. This second Asle brings up a key question: what is the narrator's relationship with his namesake and how close are their individual identities entwined? After all, both Asle and Asle are unmarried painters with long grey hair, are of similar age, have the same build, and have, or had, an issue with being an alcoholic.
Or, is their relationship more subtle? What's happening to the narrator, Asle? Is he imagining or dreaming or even hallucinating a second self? Or, more plausibly, the second Asle is actually the narrator in his past life, a time when he had way too much to drink, passed out in the snow and required hospitalization.
And the novel's language itself - hypnotic, repetitive, what Jon Fosse terms “slow prose” where he circles back in describing a simple happening or feeling or observation or reflection in ways that are reminiscent of classical music in minimalist mode played on piano or cello or xylophone. Speaking of Septology, Jon said, "I wanted to give each and every moment the time I felt it needed. I wanted the language to flow in a peaceful way."
It's time to shift to an aspect of Jon's novel that is critically important: mystical transformation via direct experience of the divine light. In an interview, Jon relates: “This mystic side has to do with when I was seven years old and close to dying. It was an accident. I saw myself from outside, in a kind of shimmering light, peaceful, a very happy state, and I’m quite sure that accident, that moment, that close-to-death experience formed me as a writer. Without that, I doubt I would have even been one. It’s very fundamental for me.” It's not for nothing that Åsleik says Asle strikes him as a Russian monk. Again, Jon is definitely not writing autofiction but there's an undeniable spiritual kinship between Jon the writer and Asle the painter, as per this snip of Asle's musing on art and life:
“...but in summer too I try to cover the windows and make it as dark as possible before looking at where and how much a picture is shining, yes, to tell the truth I always wait until after I've seen a picture in pitch blackness to be sure I'm done with it, because the eyes get used to the dark in a way and I can see the picture as light and darkness, and see if there's a light shining from the picture, and where, and how much, and it's always, always the darkest part of the picture that shines the most, and I think that that might be because it's in the hopelessness and despair, in the darkness, that God is closest to us...”
With Asle's vision here, the author's following words carry added power: “When I manage to write well, there is a second, silent language. This silent language says what it is all about. It’s not the story, but you can hear something behind it — a silent voice speaking.”
A silent voice speaking. Like Asle, Jon Fosse converted to Catholicism but we shouldn't think of religion in the conventional form. Not at all. Both men read Meister Eckhart and both men's reflections bring to mind not faith so much as a Gnostic knowing, particularly in terms of art and aesthetic experience as a revealer of light.
According to Jon Fosse, writing is a mystery, and painting is a mystery that can't be explained in words. Asle can't explain his paintings and he as author can't explain his writing. Thus, as readers, we are well to open ourselves to the language behind the language – the underlying music.
Coda: A special call-out to translator Damion Searls for rendering Jon Fosse into fluid, clear English.
Norwegian author Jon Fosse, born 1959
by
CONGRATULATIONS TO JON FOSSE FOR WINNING THE 2023 NOBEL PRIZE FOR LITERATURE
"I already have ten or so big paintings finished plus four or five small ones, something like that, fourteen paintings in all in two stacks next to each other by the kitchen door, since I'm about to have a show, most of the paintings are approximately square..."
So Asle tells us on the opening page of The Other Name.
Asle is a painter living alone on the southwest coast of Norway. I can imagine one of his paintings in the stacks might look something like the artwork above. Or, perhaps this bold diagonal brushstroke can be likened to a section of his largest canvas, the one Asle is working on now, the one on the easel in his studio, a large rectangular painting, wider than it is high, one thick diagonal line painted in brown, the other thick diagonal line painted in purple, the two thick dripping lines crossing in the middle.
Jon Fosse relates his daily schedule when writing this, his longest work: while living in an apartment outside Vienna in Austria, he would wake up at four in the afternoon, start writing at five and continuing through the night until nine the next morning (that's sixteen straight hours of writing!). As the Norwegian author acknowledges, it was a very strange experience. And since he always has written shorter novels, the length of Septology surprised him. Note: Septology is a 667-pager and contains seven parts in three volumes: I-II The Other Name, III-V I Is Another and VI-VII A New Name.
When speaking of his own writing process, Jon Fosse notes he doesn't have a set plan when writing a novel. He just sits down and listens. The novel is fully formed somewhere in his subconscious, and all he has to do is write it down before it disappears – and the hearing happens as he's writing. For Jon, it's too boring to plan things out in advance; rather, it's all about the excitement of the journey into the unknown where something comes into existence that he didn't know before. That is to say, Jon would never write in an autobiographical way. Worth underscoring: Jon Fosse is not writing autofiction a la fellow Norwegian Karl Ove Knausgård or Kjersti Skomsvold.
The action of the novel is straightforward enough: Asle does things like speak with his neighbor Åsleik who clears his driveway when it snows, drives from his home in Dylgja to the small city of Bjørgvin, and, one time while in Bjørgvin, comes to the rescue of another painter by the name of Asle who collapsed dead drunk out in the snow. This second Asle brings up a key question: what is the narrator's relationship with his namesake and how close are their individual identities entwined? After all, both Asle and Asle are unmarried painters with long grey hair, are of similar age, have the same build, and have, or had, an issue with being an alcoholic.
Or, is their relationship more subtle? What's happening to the narrator, Asle? Is he imagining or dreaming or even hallucinating a second self? Or, more plausibly, the second Asle is actually the narrator in his past life, a time when he had way too much to drink, passed out in the snow and required hospitalization.
And the novel's language itself - hypnotic, repetitive, what Jon Fosse terms “slow prose” where he circles back in describing a simple happening or feeling or observation or reflection in ways that are reminiscent of classical music in minimalist mode played on piano or cello or xylophone. Speaking of Septology, Jon said, "I wanted to give each and every moment the time I felt it needed. I wanted the language to flow in a peaceful way."
It's time to shift to an aspect of Jon's novel that is critically important: mystical transformation via direct experience of the divine light. In an interview, Jon relates: “This mystic side has to do with when I was seven years old and close to dying. It was an accident. I saw myself from outside, in a kind of shimmering light, peaceful, a very happy state, and I’m quite sure that accident, that moment, that close-to-death experience formed me as a writer. Without that, I doubt I would have even been one. It’s very fundamental for me.” It's not for nothing that Åsleik says Asle strikes him as a Russian monk. Again, Jon is definitely not writing autofiction but there's an undeniable spiritual kinship between Jon the writer and Asle the painter, as per this snip of Asle's musing on art and life:
“...but in summer too I try to cover the windows and make it as dark as possible before looking at where and how much a picture is shining, yes, to tell the truth I always wait until after I've seen a picture in pitch blackness to be sure I'm done with it, because the eyes get used to the dark in a way and I can see the picture as light and darkness, and see if there's a light shining from the picture, and where, and how much, and it's always, always the darkest part of the picture that shines the most, and I think that that might be because it's in the hopelessness and despair, in the darkness, that God is closest to us...”
With Asle's vision here, the author's following words carry added power: “When I manage to write well, there is a second, silent language. This silent language says what it is all about. It’s not the story, but you can hear something behind it — a silent voice speaking.”
A silent voice speaking. Like Asle, Jon Fosse converted to Catholicism but we shouldn't think of religion in the conventional form. Not at all. Both men read Meister Eckhart and both men's reflections bring to mind not faith so much as a Gnostic knowing, particularly in terms of art and aesthetic experience as a revealer of light.
According to Jon Fosse, writing is a mystery, and painting is a mystery that can't be explained in words. Asle can't explain his paintings and he as author can't explain his writing. Thus, as readers, we are well to open ourselves to the language behind the language – the underlying music.
Coda: A special call-out to translator Damion Searls for rendering Jon Fosse into fluid, clear English.
Norwegian author Jon Fosse, born 1959
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Other Name.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 31, 2023
–
Started Reading
March 31, 2023
– Shelved
April 5, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
David
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 05, 2023 10:37AM
Weird, the second review I read of this book today. Seeing that it deals with art I am intrigued. Thanks for this, Glenn.
reply
|
flag
David wrote: "Weird, the second review I read of this book today. Seeing that it deals with art I am intrigued. Thanks for this, Glenn."
Thanks, David. Two reviews of this book in one day - that is weird since it has been out for a number of years and there are only 200 reviews here on Goodreads. I thought you would be interested in this novel since the main character is a painter and he spends a good chunk of the book reflecting on his being an artist and his artwork, especially his larger painting featuring two crossing diagonal lines.
Thanks, David. Two reviews of this book in one day - that is weird since it has been out for a number of years and there are only 200 reviews here on Goodreads. I thought you would be interested in this novel since the main character is a painter and he spends a good chunk of the book reflecting on his being an artist and his artwork, especially his larger painting featuring two crossing diagonal lines.
It was a pleasure to read your review, Glenn. Thanks in particular for the info about how Fosse wrote this book. Marathon sessions for sure! The writing does indeed feel like it rolled out uninterrupted.
I also appreciated very much your paragraph on Meister Eckhart and aesthetic experience as a revealer of light.
I also appreciated very much your paragraph on Meister Eckhart and aesthetic experience as a revealer of light.
Fionnuala wrote: "It was a pleasure to read your review, Glenn. Thanks in particular for the info about how Fosse wrote this book. Marathon sessions for sure! .The writing dies indeed feel like it rolled out uninter..."
Thanks so much, Fionnuala. I find that phenomenon of Jon Fosse taking dictation from his subconscious fascinating - and if his muse gave him his story in 16-hour stretches, he wouldn't leave his writing desk but faithfully take down the story. Remarkable.
And for me, that aspect of art and aesthetic experience as a revealer of divine light makes all the difference. I couldn't get into his Trilogy or Melancholy I & II but Septology has captivated me. I look forward to reading and posting reviews on both I Is Another and A New Name.
Thanks so much, Fionnuala. I find that phenomenon of Jon Fosse taking dictation from his subconscious fascinating - and if his muse gave him his story in 16-hour stretches, he wouldn't leave his writing desk but faithfully take down the story. Remarkable.
And for me, that aspect of art and aesthetic experience as a revealer of divine light makes all the difference. I couldn't get into his Trilogy or Melancholy I & II but Septology has captivated me. I look forward to reading and posting reviews on both I Is Another and A New Name.
This to say, Jon would never write in an autobiographical way. Worth underscoring: Jon Fosse is not writing autofiction
Glad to hear it. We need art to explain things.
Glad to hear it. We need art to explain things.
Nick wrote: "This to say, Jon would never write in an autobiographical way. Worth underscoring: Jon Fosse is not writing autofiction
Glad to hear it. We need art to explain things."
So true, Nick. My quoting Jon Fosse is taken from a discussion Jon had with translator Damion Searls and critic Dustin Illingworth I found on YouTube.
As you can see, a good number of perceptive readers have posted reviews on Fosse's novel. Once I got into his rhythm (I both read the book and listened to the audio book), I was propelled into the realm of "aesthetic light". I know, I know...sounds cheezy. But in this case it was true.
Glad to hear it. We need art to explain things."
So true, Nick. My quoting Jon Fosse is taken from a discussion Jon had with translator Damion Searls and critic Dustin Illingworth I found on YouTube.
As you can see, a good number of perceptive readers have posted reviews on Fosse's novel. Once I got into his rhythm (I both read the book and listened to the audio book), I was propelled into the realm of "aesthetic light". I know, I know...sounds cheezy. But in this case it was true.
Nice that you found some Fosse quotes on the writing of the book. His process mirrors the book, which looks deceivingly simple due to the stream of consciousness (subconsciousness) approach. Interesting to read (finished today) and someday, Vol. 2.
Ken wrote: "Nice that you found some Fosse quotes on the writing of the book. His process mirrors the book, which looks deceivingly simple due to the stream of consciousness (subconsciousness) approach. Intere..."
Thanks, Ken. Yes, Fosse's writing process of this novel is, indeed, fascinating. I think the key for readers is clicking into his slow, revolving artistic stream-of-consciousness. BTW - I also listened to the audio book which was quite enjoyable.
Thanks, Ken. Yes, Fosse's writing process of this novel is, indeed, fascinating. I think the key for readers is clicking into his slow, revolving artistic stream-of-consciousness. BTW - I also listened to the audio book which was quite enjoyable.
I need to try audio again. I tried years ago in the car and couldn't seem to focus on the book while driving. Plus, I hear the reader's voice on those things is hugely important.
In reading books on writing novels (apparently by authors who've had little success writing novels of any import), the term they use for writing without an outline or plan is "pantsing."
Frankly, I'm allergic to outlines, and when and if I dive into trying to write a novel again, I'll be pantsing all the way. Fosse only proves that, for the right writers, that's the only way!
In reading books on writing novels (apparently by authors who've had little success writing novels of any import), the term they use for writing without an outline or plan is "pantsing."
Frankly, I'm allergic to outlines, and when and if I dive into trying to write a novel again, I'll be pantsing all the way. Fosse only proves that, for the right writers, that's the only way!
Go for it, Ken!
Re pantsing, one of the kings of this way of writing is Serbian author Zoran Zivkovic. I noted this as part of a review I wrote for one of his novels (I wrote a review for each of ZZ's 24 novels) -
Also worth noting: Zoran Živković wrote non-fiction for many years and came to writing fiction in the first place at age forty-five: "The fact I was writing fiction quite astonished me, but what amazed me even more was my lack of any rational control over it. Somewhere beneath my conscious level, quite unknown to my rational self, a critical mass was gathering." And that part of the author's mind that is non-rational dictates his stories as he sits at his computer and types out what he is being told. Occasionally, he confesses, he becomes frustrated since the voice will speak at a faster speed than he can type. Poor Zoran Živković - he can only type tap-tap-tap with the index finger of his right hand. On further reflection, no so poor; I mean, what some writers would give to have such inspiration.
I can hear readers thinking: yeah, yeah, yeah, great to have your subconscious dictate your stories but surely the author must go back to revise and polish. Remarkably, the answer is 'no' - Zoran Živković does zero revision, his first draft is his final draft.
-------
Re audio books, I hear you. Some people can focus and for some, their mind wanders. For me, once I click into an audio book, my attention can remain on the story for hours without once being pulled off.
Re pantsing, one of the kings of this way of writing is Serbian author Zoran Zivkovic. I noted this as part of a review I wrote for one of his novels (I wrote a review for each of ZZ's 24 novels) -
Also worth noting: Zoran Živković wrote non-fiction for many years and came to writing fiction in the first place at age forty-five: "The fact I was writing fiction quite astonished me, but what amazed me even more was my lack of any rational control over it. Somewhere beneath my conscious level, quite unknown to my rational self, a critical mass was gathering." And that part of the author's mind that is non-rational dictates his stories as he sits at his computer and types out what he is being told. Occasionally, he confesses, he becomes frustrated since the voice will speak at a faster speed than he can type. Poor Zoran Živković - he can only type tap-tap-tap with the index finger of his right hand. On further reflection, no so poor; I mean, what some writers would give to have such inspiration.
I can hear readers thinking: yeah, yeah, yeah, great to have your subconscious dictate your stories but surely the author must go back to revise and polish. Remarkably, the answer is 'no' - Zoran Živković does zero revision, his first draft is his final draft.
-------
Re audio books, I hear you. Some people can focus and for some, their mind wanders. For me, once I click into an audio book, my attention can remain on the story for hours without once being pulled off.
Interesting about Zoran Živković. First draft as final draft sounds wonderful, too.More than wonderful, actually. Amazing, if it's quality work.
I had a writing teacher who said the first 50 pages of beginning writers' novels amount to "clearing the throat." Page 51 may be the real beginning, in other words. I wonder how he'd explain the ZZ phenomenon.
I had a writing teacher who said the first 50 pages of beginning writers' novels amount to "clearing the throat." Page 51 may be the real beginning, in other words. I wonder how he'd explain the ZZ phenomenon.
Your writing teacher is, in the main, spot-on, especially with a young, first-time novelist. I suspect novelists who start in their mid-40s and beyond, Raymond Chandler and P.D. James come immediately to mind, can write where every page counts. As for ZZ, he was an editor for 25 years prior to turning to fiction. And his novels are quality works, for sure. You might want to check out a review I wrote for one of his novels.
Cesar Aira seems to do something similar by not revising the story once it moves forwards. I've not read enough to know if he edits.
I think, Glenn, the one finger on the typewriter must surely allow much thinking about each sentence that will emerge out of it.
I think, Glenn, the one finger on the typewriter must surely allow much thinking about each sentence that will emerge out of it.
That's right - Cesar Aria relates the 'constant move forward'. And both Jon Fosse and Zoran talk about hearing the story sentence by sentence in their subconscious and they sit at the keyboard and simply take it all down. What magic. Truly phenomenal! Unlike Nabokov who said he maintains complete control and his characters have no more freedom than slaves on a galley ship.