Chantel's Reviews > Itzel and the Ocelot
Itzel and the Ocelot
by
by
Chantel's review
bookshelves: edelweiss, folktale, el-salvador, livres-d-images, perspectives-autochtones
Nov 23, 2022
bookshelves: edelweiss, folktale, el-salvador, livres-d-images, perspectives-autochtones
Our story begins sometime in the past, though it certainly could have been the yesterday that just passed; there is no telling when this tale took place & that is part of its charm. Itzel lives near the jungle with her grandmother. During a dry spell, Itzel is made aware of the devastating consequences of drought. In a bid to try & see the return of rain & water, Itzel journeys through the jungle in search of the giant snake; said to be the carrier of the river—the being who sheds water across the lands.
This story is based on a folktale & for that alone, I am glad to have read it. I appreciate how vast our literary journeys might take us; across the globe while sitting at home. However, in this story, there was something missing that I might attribute to the essence of the story itself. Itzel & the other jungle animals find their way rather simply to the origins of the river, where the giant snake is meant to be. After crying, the waters flow & everyone is gifted what they needed most.
At a surface level, & should you be a guardian reading this to an audience who might not care to question the moral implications of whatever is happening within the book, this conclusion is rapid & settled. Itzel & her companions tried their best to have hope but it was dashed, regardless of their efforts. This leaves them with exactly what they were hoping to get, but, how? I think perhaps the inclusion of a bit more of the giant snake or why the snake granted them water might have been great.
After all, the giant snake was allegedly never seen because no one believed in him. The group had one, maybe two, actual believers in their company. Everyone else was simply along for the ride hoping to get water. What part of that fraction might encourage the snake to feel that he was something others had returned to in their thoughts & beliefs?
I am, perhaps, reading too much into this. The book is a retelling of an old folktale for a culture of which I am not a member. Therefore it is probable that some of this story might be better told & appreciated; the nuance clear & identifiable, by those to whom this story rings close to the heart. Therefore, I will leave off my review here by simply stating that this is a cute story, a cute book with cute illustrations & something that would be a nice added dimension to a personal library.
Thank you to Edelweiss+, Kids Can Press, & Rachel Katstaller for the free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
This story is based on a folktale & for that alone, I am glad to have read it. I appreciate how vast our literary journeys might take us; across the globe while sitting at home. However, in this story, there was something missing that I might attribute to the essence of the story itself. Itzel & the other jungle animals find their way rather simply to the origins of the river, where the giant snake is meant to be. After crying, the waters flow & everyone is gifted what they needed most.
At a surface level, & should you be a guardian reading this to an audience who might not care to question the moral implications of whatever is happening within the book, this conclusion is rapid & settled. Itzel & her companions tried their best to have hope but it was dashed, regardless of their efforts. This leaves them with exactly what they were hoping to get, but, how? I think perhaps the inclusion of a bit more of the giant snake or why the snake granted them water might have been great.
After all, the giant snake was allegedly never seen because no one believed in him. The group had one, maybe two, actual believers in their company. Everyone else was simply along for the ride hoping to get water. What part of that fraction might encourage the snake to feel that he was something others had returned to in their thoughts & beliefs?
I am, perhaps, reading too much into this. The book is a retelling of an old folktale for a culture of which I am not a member. Therefore it is probable that some of this story might be better told & appreciated; the nuance clear & identifiable, by those to whom this story rings close to the heart. Therefore, I will leave off my review here by simply stating that this is a cute story, a cute book with cute illustrations & something that would be a nice added dimension to a personal library.
Thank you to Edelweiss+, Kids Can Press, & Rachel Katstaller for the free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Itzel and the Ocelot.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
November 23, 2022
– Shelved
November 23, 2022
– Shelved as:
edelweiss
November 23, 2022
– Shelved as:
folktale
November 23, 2022
– Shelved as:
el-salvador
November 23, 2022
– Shelved as:
livres-d-images
November 23, 2022
–
Finished Reading
November 24, 2022
– Shelved as:
perspectives-autochtones
Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)
date
newest »
Hope kids don't notice all those inconsistencies lol. A cute review by a cute Chantel! And a super cute ocelot <3
Nice review, Chantel! Glad to see you found a cute book on a culture you're not too familiar with. Always nice to learn about different cultures through literature.
oh my god wait. central american AND indigenous?? i need to add this now. im not indigenous but i am central american. the fact that i’m salvadoran makes this better. every time i see a book with representation it’s hardly ever central american. thank you for bringing this to my attention. i’m very curious because i’ve never heard about the traditional story with the snake so that’ll be new to me. lovely review! 💙
Nika wrote: "Wonderful and honest review, Chantel! The point you made about the giant snake and water sounds persuasive.
Stories that are based on folktales usually intrigue me. I love learning about them, even..."
Thanks very much for your comment, Nika! :) This book taught me something new about a different part of the world so, overall I am thankful for that! You can live vicariously through my reviews haha
Stories that are based on folktales usually intrigue me. I love learning about them, even..."
Thanks very much for your comment, Nika! :) This book taught me something new about a different part of the world so, overall I am thankful for that! You can live vicariously through my reviews haha
Federico wrote: "Hope kids don't notice all those inconsistencies lol. A cute review by a cute Chantel! And a super cute ocelot <3"
Gosh, I'm sure they won't haha It's just me, being me lol
Thanks so much for your kind comment xxx
Gosh, I'm sure they won't haha It's just me, being me lol
Thanks so much for your kind comment xxx
Derek wrote: "Nice review, Chantel! Glad to see you found a cute book on a culture you're not too familiar with. Always nice to learn about different cultures through literature."
Thanks so much, Derek! :) I agree! I think that's another reason why I enjoy reviewing Children's Fiction - the little books can hold so much information & it's such a nice way to keep in tune with the world.
Thanks so much, Derek! :) I agree! I think that's another reason why I enjoy reviewing Children's Fiction - the little books can hold so much information & it's such a nice way to keep in tune with the world.
elena ❀ wrote: "oh my god wait. central american AND indigenous?? i need to add this now. im not indigenous but i am central american. the fact that i’m salvadoran makes this better. every time i see a book with r..."
Ah! I didn't realize it was an Indigenous story - thank you for pointing that out! I've adjusted my shelves to reflect that :) I would be interested in your perspective given you're Salvadoran would leave your review with so much intimate insight on the story - I feel :)
I'm glad I could bring this book to your timeline! That's part of the reason why I enjoy reviewing Children's Fiction - it gives me a rounded perspective of the world in so few words. I'm always happy to see people & places represented....the reason why I have shelves for every country; to keep myself accountable to read as many stories from as many places as possible & it's just cool to see haha
Thanks so much for your kind comment!! I hope that you get the chance to read through this <3
Ah! I didn't realize it was an Indigenous story - thank you for pointing that out! I've adjusted my shelves to reflect that :) I would be interested in your perspective given you're Salvadoran would leave your review with so much intimate insight on the story - I feel :)
I'm glad I could bring this book to your timeline! That's part of the reason why I enjoy reviewing Children's Fiction - it gives me a rounded perspective of the world in so few words. I'm always happy to see people & places represented....the reason why I have shelves for every country; to keep myself accountable to read as many stories from as many places as possible & it's just cool to see haha
Thanks so much for your kind comment!! I hope that you get the chance to read through this <3
Nilguen wrote: "Lovely review, Chantel! 💜💜💜 I love the diversity in this book 🤗"
Thanks so very much, Nilguen <3 <3 I agree with you!! :)
Thanks so very much, Nilguen <3 <3 I agree with you!! :)
I do love books based on folktales and different cultures, it is a shame this was a little lacking but I am glad it was still a cute read! Wonderful review Chantel! 🧡xx
Stories that are based on folktales usually intrigue me. I love learning about them, even if I rarely read them myself. :)