Shawna's Reviews > The Diamond Eye

5++ stars – WWII Historical Fiction/Mystery/Romance

Wow! What a terrific surprise this was! I often find books that I love the hardest to review. I have so much that I want to say about it, but I think The Diamond Eye is one of those books that’s even better because of how unexpected it is.

The Diamond Eye is based on the remarkable true life story of Lyudmila Mikhailovna Pavlichenko. She was a bookish history student and librarian, a single mother turned soldier in order to defend her homeland who longed to be a historian, and a fierce, deadly sniper with over 300 kills who became a close friend to First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt. The author used Mila’s actual memoir as her inspiration and “concrete original source” with some artistic license to fill in the “gaps and silences.”

The Diamond Eye is historical fiction at its best and a biography of sorts, but it’s so much more than that. It’s a wartime story with political intrigue, mystery/suspense, and romance. Mila is a fascinating, complex heroine with a fierce, persistent, fighting spirit who never backs down. Her transformation from a quiet, bookish, abused single mother to a courageous, determined, strong-willed soldier who endures doubts and sexism from her fellow soldiers and superiors to be become a fierce, revered sniper feared by Germans known as Lady Death is truly amazing. I loved her.

The alternating timeline of Mila’s past and present was handled really well. The mystery woven into Mila’s goodwill tour visit to America was intriguing and suspenseful, and I enjoyed the present scenes with Eleanor Roosevelt and Mila. But I preferred the past sections because I liked reading about Mila’s wartime experiences, interactions, and relationships. There are so many interesting (real) characters that I loved: her medical orderly friend, Lena, her platoon mates, Fyodor and Vartanov, her superior officer, Lyonya, and of course, her sniper partner and shadow, Kostia.

I’m a romance lover/reader at heart, so my favorite part of The Diamond Eye is the romantic elements. There are actually two love stories in this book, and they’re both beautiful and moving. And trust me that it’s not a love triangle. Lyonya and Kostia are both amazing, swoonworthy heroes, and I loved them as much as Mila.

I highly recommend this book to fans of extraordinary women, WWII history, historical fiction, historical mystery/suspense, and historical romance. Big unforgettable 5 stars!

“I had a belly full of vodka, a heart full of hatred, and a soul full of grief—but my hand was steady as a rock.”

“We are glad to visit your beautiful country. It is prosperous—you all live far from the struggle. Nobody destroys your towns, cities, fields. Nobody kills your citizens, your sisters and mothers, your fathers and brothers. I come from a place where bombs pound villages into ash, where Russian blood oils the treads of German tanks, where innocent civilians die every day. An accurate bullet fired by a sniper like me, Mrs. Roosevelt, is no more than a response to an enemy.”

I’ve seen some comments from readers on GR and Amazon saying they were concerned about the timing or that they had a hard time with the book given Russia’s current invasion of Ukraine. But the USSR, Soviet Union, during WWII is not the same as Russia today. They fought against Hitler and fascism and fended off the German invasion long before Americans joined the fight, and the Red Army provided the largest land force in the Allied victory of WWII. The Soviet Union also suffered the highest casualties of the war with around 20-27 million deaths.

From the Author’s Note of The Diamond Eye:

“It’s sometimes said that World War II was won with British Intelligence, American steel, and Soviet blood. This sweeping generalization bears a kernel of truth. Since the USSR became America’s enemy in the Cold War so soon after WWII’s end, it’s easy to forget that without them, the war against the Axis powers might have been lost. Of all Hitler’s mistakes, his colossal Napoleonic error in taking on the USSR was perhaps the most pivotal: without the eastern front soaking up so much of Germany’s manpower, the Allies might never have prevailed. The cost of that victory was millions of Red Army dead as Soviet blood gave American steel and British Intelligence time to turn the tide. The Diamond Eye is seen through the lens of Soviet blood—one woman’s fight to stanch its flow, first with her rifle and then with her voice as she crossed an ocean to bring American steel home to help her countrymen.”

My personal opinion/note:

It’s tragic to me that governments (including the U.S.) haven’t learned from history and keep repeating the same mistakes of war resulting in the suffering of innocent people. So much money is spent on the military-industrial complex that could be used for education, healthcare, protecting and improving the environment, and helping the poor, homeless, children, elderly, and veterans. Sadly, companies who produce oil, gas, weapons, bombs, tanks, attack drones, and fighter planes and their politicians want wars because they get richer.