Chelsea Humphrey's Reviews > A History of Wild Places

A History of Wild Places by Shea Ernshaw
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
47207032
2.5

Well, I think I'm going to keep my thoughts on this one short, as it's really just personal reasons and expectations as to why this didn't work for me, and most of those reasons are spoiler filled fodder. If you're planning on reading this book, I humbly recommend the audio version if you enjoy that format, as the narration was a splendid production.

The beginning of the book really hooked me, so much so that I thought this would result in an easy 5 stars for me to give. We follow Travis as he is using his special sense of connecting with objects that people have touched to track down missing author Maggie, who seemingly fell off the earth at a certain point. His POV goes abruptly dead, and we don't hear from Travis's narration again after.

Next, we jump to an off the grid community called Pastoral that is led by a man named Levi, and we follow the POV of Theo, his wife Calla (I think this was her name?), and Bee, Calla's sister. Bee is blind and can hear unborn baby's heartbeats and other things that help the community, as they cannot leave to go to town because of a disease from the surrounding forest called The Rot. Also, the rain is bad and you don't want to get caught out in it.

I can't really give anything else without spoiling, but once we hit the Pastoral transition, I guessed one of the major plot twists immediately, because it was just so obvious from the set up and clues immediately given. Maybe if we'd had a little time to separate the beginning portion from the next section, our brains would have forgotten what had just happened and it would have been more surprising? Also, the big twist as to what's going on in Pastoral and the mystery surrounding it all was not what I was hoping for at all. I was expect layers of fantasy, horror, or at least magical realism, and the explanation behind everything felt like a let down for me. If you can keep an open mind and are ok with the pieces not quite fitting together, you should give this one a try for yourself.

*Many thanks to the publisher for providing my review copy.
278 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A History of Wild Places.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 30, 2021 – Shelved
December 12, 2021 – Started Reading
December 12, 2021 –
37.0%
December 16, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) LOL Chelsea!!


message 2: by TL (new)

TL Haha:)


Elle tell me how it goes!!


Chelsea Humphrey Holly wrote: "LOL Chelsea!!"

I'm nothing if not predictable. 🤣

Elle wrote: "tell me how it goes!!"

I will for sure!


message 5: by TMR (new) - added it

TMR Intriguing sneak peek to your review eh.


C.  (Comment, never msg). I can't wait to hear. It looks original. It might have a thriller vibe which is not my bag but the mysterious mystery might make up for it.


message 8: by A.P. (new) - added it

A.P. Taber Oh, Lawd I just got it


Chelsea Humphrey Anna at A Wondrous Bookshelf wrote: "Oh, Lawd I just got it"

I think I'm the outlier on this one, so I hope you enjoy it! <3


Aliyah B I felt the exact same way


message 11: by Leah (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leah This is pretty much exactly how I felt about this book. Now that I've read it, I don't know why I expected some sort of magic to be involved, but I did. I think the world in this story is just too realistic for Bee's ability and the explanation in the end to work for me (although somehow I had no problem accepting Travis's ability). I still liked the book a lot, but the end was underwhelming.


Katie Keller Marquez Yep. I was way more invested in Travis compared to the community.


message 13: by B (new) - rated it 2 stars

B I’m sharing your thoughts with this one. Travis was the best.


Sandra Grauschopf I think there was definitely magical realism in the book. Travis' talents were magical, and Levi's talent doesn't work in real life the way it was portrayed in the book.


Alexandria *spoilers*
Exactly how I felt. I think the ending and the big reveal felt a little rushed and she sort of explained it but then didn’t touch on it again. Would’ve liked a little more about Bee’s time after the fight and how they approached the whole situation with the community.


Chelsie Jensen I just finished this and completely agree with your take.


Natasha Morgan I absolutely agree about the beginning being way more original and compelling. The original premise of Travis finding a missing person by seeing flashbacks of her life was such a good hook. Really did not like the way part 2 switched to cult mode all of a sudden, especially since by doing so, I was able to figure out the twist.


Emily Wright My thoughts exactly.


NicoleWReads Completely agree with your review


Suzanne Renaghan Completely agree with your assessment


Megan Reilly I just finished this book today and am completely with you.


message 22: by Gia (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gia Lib Totally agree, beginning hooked me but things got kind of jumbled and flat for me, personally. Great assessment!


message 23: by Jenn (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jenn Completely agree! This was exactly my take.


adrienne 30% in and struggling with the horrifically boring commune slog— it’s not going to get better, is it?


Calla Stinson Yes! This book had so much potential. The author’s writing was superb in part 1 with great descriptions and intricate details that kept me hooked.
Part 2 felt like just another cult story which was really too bad - I wish it had taken a fantasy, thriller or magical approach to the plot and I would have loved it!


Calla Stinson However quite nice seeing my name as a story book character for the first time in my life!


Lindsey Agreed! An easy twist to guess imo


back to top