JimZ's Reviews > The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating

The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating by Elisabeth Tova Bailey
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
99765491
's review

really liked it

I became aware somewhere in the middle of this book that I was saying, out loud, “geez”, over and over again. If it wasn’t an astounding thing I had never heard before about snails, it was reading what this poor woman had to go through with her viral, neurological illness (an acquired mitochondrial/metabolic disease) that nearly killed her.

I bet you didn’t know that:
• Snails cannot hear and they can barely see (they can make out light and dark); they have an acute sense of smell and also do pretty good regarding tasting and touching.
• They have eyes on top of their 2 tentacles (that sprout from their head), and they have one foot.
• They have 2,640 teeth, 80 rows, and the author likened the teeth to a rasp (a coarse file or similar metal tool with a roughened surface for scraping, filing, or rubbing down objects of metal, wood, or other hard material).

The author was ill for nearly 2 decades and for the longest time doctors were clueless as to what she had—but there was no doubt she was very sick. Her autonomic nervous system was seriously screwed up. She had severe hypotension and could not stand for any extended period of time (minutes!). During most of the writing of this book she was confined to bed where it was a tremendous effort to roll over. Good God…A tremendous effort to roll over? 😦

Her whole life for a while was keeping tabs on a snail that came from her garden and placed in a terrarium near her bed where she could watch it. So she became quite the expert on its behaviors and its anatomy and physiology. A good deal of the book we learned about snails and the rest was her reflections on her illness and on time which was really interesting. I think if the book was only about snails it would have been “just alright”, but her telling us how she felt and what she thought about her illness made for fascinating reading (for me at least).

One thing early on in the reading that bothered me was how she wrote about the snail using anthropomorphic language. The snail was contented, curious, pondering its circumstances, slowly waving its tentacles with apparent delight, etc. etc. But after awhile I said “Oh what the hell…” It made for interesting reading. If she were to have written about her observations using language reserved for a scientific journal I would have been bored. And I learned a lot about snails, and her book was carefully written with a number of reference works at the end. And she consulted with malacologists during the writing of this book (zoologists specializing in the study of mollusks). So I came to accept the anthropomorphizing, and enjoyed the rest of the ride.

Many of her reflections really hit home with me. These are just a couple:
• We are all hostages of time. We each have the same number of minutes and hours to live within a day, yet to me it didn’t feel equally doled out. My illness brought me such an abundance of time that time was nearly all I had. My friends had so little time that I often wished I could give them what time I could not use. It was perplexing how in losing health I had gained something so coveted but to so little purpose.
• I could never have guessed what would get me through this past year—a woodland snail and its offspring; I honestly don’t think I would have made it otherwise. Watching another creature go about its life…somehow gave me, the watcher, purpose too. If life mattered to the snail and the snail mattered to me, it meant something in my life mattered, so I kept on…

- When I read the above passage on the meaning that she got from life when she was very ill, it’s like I read it before in another book. And I thought for a while and it hit me…this was similar in thought to a passage that resonated with me from a fantastic book I read last November called Sweet Bean Paste (Durian Sukegawa). In it, a woman was reflecting on her life when she had been living in a leper colony, a virtual outcast from society. Was life worth living? And she said the following:
- I can’t tell you how many times I wish I were dead. Deep down, I believed that a life has no value if a person is not a useful member of society. I was convinced that humans are born to be of service to the world and to others.
- But there came a time when that changed, because I changed.
- I remember it clearly. It was a night of the full moon, and I was walking alone in the woods. … On this night, the moon cast its pale, brilliant light on everything around me, and energy seemed to radiate from trees swaying in the wind. … And oh, what a wonderful moon it was! I was enchanted. It made me forget everything I had suffered because of the illness, about being shut up in here and never getting out. Then next thing, I thought I heard a voice that sounded very much like the moon whispering to me. It said: I wanted you to see me. That’s why I shine like this.
- From then on, I began to see everything differently. If I were not here, this full moon would not be here. Neither would the trees. Or the wind. If my view of the world disappears, then everything that I see disappears. It’s as simple as that. ..- I began to understand that we were born in order to see and listen to the world. And that’s all this world wants of us. It doesn’t matter that I was never a teacher or a member of the workforce, my life had meaning.

Note:
• Winner of the 2010 John Burroughs Medal, the Natural History Literature category of the 2010 National Outdoor Book Award (joint award), and the non-fiction category of the 2012 William Saroyan International Prize for Writing.

Reviews
• This is a long but informative review from the Journal of The Institute for the Medical Humanities [Volume 30, Number 1, Spring 2012]: http://www.elisabethtovabailey.net/fi...
https://www.ecolitbooks.com/2016/01/0...
https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-en...
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti... (a review from the editor of the Canadian Medical Association Journal)
125 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 2, 2021 – Started Reading
January 2, 2021 – Shelved
January 2, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Momo Thanks for your awesome and very detailed review. Especially for providing insight into the authors life. Now I got curious and really would like you read it. It has been a pleasure to read your review.


message 2: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Very interesting review Jim, especially your unusual facts about snails ...... wow 2640 teeth eek !


Sherril Hello again Jim. I became aware of this book from Elyse and by association, Dov, in 2018, so I added the book to my TBR list and Dov as a Goodreads’s friend. I also bought the book on kindle.

Then today I got a comment from another GR friend, JimZ, you, telling me how much you liked the book and encouraging me to read it. Then I saw your very good review of it.
Perhaps today is the day to finally get to it. Thanks 🙏🏻


message 4: by Alan (aka The Lone Librarian) (last edited Jan 02, 2021 04:37PM) (new)

Alan (aka The Lone Librarian) Teder Lovely review to start off the year Jim! I was curious to find out how Elizabeth Tova Bailey was doing and listened to an interview on NPR from earlier this year where she talks about how her experience is applicable to those of us in lockdown situations now and about how snails are the original social distancing creatures. Bailey didn't talk about her own health, but her voice sounded strong so presumably she is doing ok. https://www.npr.org/2020/03/27/822731...

Bailey also did a short film introduction to the book on YouTube back in 2012. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbjCq...


message 5: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes I loved this book Jim. You tube has a film and sound effects of an actual wild snail eating. It's mesmerizing to watch.


Lagobond Jim, you wrote: "Good God…A tremendous effort to roll over?" and this comment reminded me of two occasions in my life when rolling over was so difficult as to be almost impossible. The first was when I had a very painful infection that made every move excruciating. The other was when I was seasick in the middle of the ocean, and any kind of movement brought on unimaginable waves of nausea. We take so much for granted in life, until it is taken from us. Thank you for this reminder. I'm glad you enjoyed the book!


message 7: by Anne (new)

Anne Jim, thank you for a very interesting review. I imagine that her anthropomorphizing the snail gave her a sense that she could understand the snail which is probably what helped her to feel less alone. Glad you said, "Oh what the hell," and just read on. I love your candor about that. Geez, I think I need a snail. :))


message 8: by Judith (new)

Judith E Very interesting about time and “seeing” in this world. I’m sure I would have to hurdle over the humanizing of the snail, but it seems it was very worth it.


message 9: by Alwynne (new)

Alwynne Sounds interesting Jim, although being typically contrary not sure about the ethics of trapping a wild snail.


message 10: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Alwynne wrote: "Sounds interesting Jim, although being typically contrary not sure about the ethics of trapping a wild snail."

Sorry Alwynne I forgot to mention: she released it into the woods after the snail had its clutch of baby snails.


message 11: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Sandra wrote: "Very interesting review Jim, especially your unusual facts about snails ...... wow 2640 teeth eek !"

That's why I was saying 'geez' so often when turning the pages of this book. She made it very interesting.


message 12: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Edwina wrote: "Thanks for your awesome and very detailed review. Especially for providing insight into the authors life. Now I got curious and really would like you read it. It has been a pleasure to read your re..."
Thanks for your kind words Edwina. It was a nice, unique, and interesting read. There were several black and white pen and ink drawings of snails scattered throughout the book.


message 13: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Sherril wrote: "Hello again Jim. I became aware of this book from Elyse and by association, Dov, in 2018, so I added the book to my TBR list and Dov as a Goodreads’s friend. I also bought the book on kindle.

The..."

Thank you Sherrill. Let me know what you think of it when/if you get to it!


message 14: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Lagobond wrote: "Jim, you wrote: "Good God…A tremendous effort to roll over?" and this comment reminded me of two occasions in my life when rolling over was so difficult as to be almost impossible. The first was wh..."

I agree with you 100%. When reading the book, I realized the author was not used to being bed-bound but there was nothing she could do about it. Meanwhile all her friends bustled about her...and she wished she could do that. But it really does speak to how we spend the allotted time we have on this earth. And how we perceive things. She was able to realize that appreciating the snail's life was not trivial.


message 15: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Diane wrote: "I loved this book Jim. You tube has a film and sound effects of an actual wild snail eating. It's mesmerizing to watch."

I should go watch it, thanks for alerting me to that.


message 16: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Anne wrote: "Jim, thank you for a very interesting review. I imagine that her anthropomorphizing the snail gave her a sense that she could understand the snail which is probably what helped her to feel less alo..."

I'm glad I said 'what the hell' too. I realized she was an excellent writer and intelligent and knew that she knew she was anthropomorphizing. So I just stopped my internal whining!!!


message 17: by Robyn (new) - added it

Robyn Great review! Really interesting. Happy New Year


message 18: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Judith wrote: "Very interesting about time and “seeing” in this world. I’m sure I would have to hurdle over the humanizing of the snail, but it seems it was very worth it."

It was Judith. If this was a scholarly tome on snails I would have been critical of the writing. It did introduce me to snails but was more than that, and so the book succeeded I felt.


message 19: by Emmkay (new) - added it

Emmkay What a thought-provoking review, Jim. I loved Sweet Bean Paste - you made a very interesting connection there!


message 20: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Emmkay wrote: "What a thought-provoking review, Jim. I loved Sweet Bean Paste - you made a very interesting connection there!"
It was weird...when I read what she was writing it was like I had read what she was saying, slightly different, somewhere else. Luckily my brain functioned enough so i could remember where I had seen the writing in question.


message 21: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ JimZ wrote: "Alwynne wrote: "Sounds interesting Jim, although being typically contrary not sure about the ethics of trapping a wild snail."

Sorry Alwynne I forgot to mention: she released it into the woods aft..."


And also, a friend brought the potted flower inside from outside and nobody knew there was a snail hiding in the flower pot.


message 22: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Wow, Jim, this review really spoke to me. The quote you've shared about time is quite moving, as is the selection from Sweet Bean Paste. I'll read this one for sure, and now I'm off to see if I have Sukegawa's novel marked as well!


message 23: by Alwynne (new)

Alwynne Thanks Jim!


ClareT What a fabulous review. I had seen this book reviewed on and off and was never sure whether I would enjoy it. You have made me look at it again and it will be going on my birthday wishlist.


Linda Fantastic review Jim!


message 26: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ ClareT wrote: "What a fabulous review. I had seen this book reviewed on and off and was never sure whether I would enjoy it. You have made me look at it again and it will be going on my birthday wishlist."
Good - I really think you will like it. A GR friend alerted me to a NPR podcast (it's free) in which she talks with the host about the pandemic and the fact that people are sequestered as she was sequestered when she was ill. From her voice, she seems to be OK now but I shouldn't presume that...


message 27: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Elyse wrote: "Fabulous review Jim... so thoughtful.
I still own this small book—
captivating—
... it means lot to be —
I have a friend who spends 80% of their life in bed. A terrible sickness my friend has — edu..."

Wow...what a compliment from you. All I can say is thank you. Your friend from MIT...is that a permanent situation in which she will always be in bed for 80% of the time?


message 28: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Candi wrote: "Wow, Jim, this review really spoke to me. The quote you've shared about time is quite moving, as is the selection from Sweet Bean Paste. I'll read this one for sure, and now I'm off to see if I hav..."

I think both are worthy of reading. :)


message 29: by Elena (new)

Elena Sala I must read Sweet Bean Paste!! It's on my shelves already. I also use antromorphic language when referring to animals and I KNOW I am not the only one but I don't know if I could use it with snails... Loved your review.


message 30: by Baba (new)

Baba Fab review Jim, thanks for sharing. The info on snails; I love books that widen my knowledge with information I didn't know I needed :)

Baba


message 31: by PattyMacDotComma (new)

PattyMacDotComma What a terrific, thoughtful review, Jim. Life at a snail's pace. Who knew?


message 32: by Licha (new) - added it

Licha Great review, and the quotes you included here are quite profound.


message 33: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ PattyMacDotComma wrote: "What a terrific, thoughtful review, Jim. Life at a snail's pace. Who knew?"

Very clever!!!!


message 34: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Licha wrote: "Great review, and the quotes you included here are quite profound."

Thanks Licha!


message 35: by Q (new) - added it

Q Wonderful reviews Jim - snail and sweet bean. And lovely quotes. Thank-you. Touched the heart. Both of these have been on my reading list for a while. Two different friends recommended them. And now you. I think its a good time to read both. Be well.


message 36: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Q wrote: "Wonderful reviews Jim - snail and sweet bean. And lovely quotes. Thank-you. Touched the heart. Both of these have been on my reading list for a while. Two different friends recommended them. And no..."

Hi Q, Did you get around to reading either of the books (The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating or Sweet Bean Paste)?


Orsolya Toth I'm reading this book and love it so much already


message 38: by Ann (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ann Samford Great review! Thank you for sharing!


~☆~Autumn NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS) Great review. I had this illness also. My rheumatologist called it CFS but now I know it is partly EI (Environmental Illness). I did mostly recover Thank God.


back to top