Margitte's Reviews > Circling the Sun

Circling the Sun by Paula McLain
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7481492
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2017-read, american-author, africa, biographical-fiction, fiction, history, reviewed

Circling The Sun caught my eye with its beautiful cover, first and foremost. I had this book for so long now, never got to it. It was time.

Oh the chain of events. Or sometimes also called fate or destiny, right? I first read about Beryl Markham in Almost Famous Women : Stories by Megan Mayhew Bergman.

Beryl Markham piqued my interest then, especially when this remarkable women wrote an autobiography, West With The Night, which had Ernst Hemingway glowing from head to toe.

In 1925 Ernest Hemingway, in a letter to California restaurateur George Gutekunst, wrote:
"Did you read Beryl Markham's book, West with the Night? ...She has written so well, and marvelously well, that I was completely ashamed of myself as a writer. I felt that I was simply a carpenter with words, picking up whatever was furnished on the job and nailing them together and sometimes making an okay pig pen. But this girl, who is to my knowledge very unpleasant and we might even say a high-grade bitch, can write rings around all of us who consider ourselves as writers ... it really is a bloody wonderful book."


After reading Circling The Sun a fictional biography of Beryl Markham(born Clutterbuck), I understood why Hemingway did this. This kind gentleman in part wanted to help a struggling independent woman to get on her feet. However, the book did not stir too many pots in the 1940s, but changed Markham's final years when it was republished in the 1980s and hailed as the masterpiece Hemingway thought it to be. She could enjoy the final years of her life in comfort.

And what a life she lived in Kenya.
"Softness and helplessness got you nothing in this place. Tears only emptied you out."


Abandoned by her mother as a young girl, growing up on a horse farm, getting married several times, and trying to make it on her own in a man's world, and in 1936, became the first woman to fly solo and nonstop from east to west across the Atlantic. Britain's Amelia Earhart. Although she was born a Brit, she was Kenyan in heart and soul.

“I learned to watch, to put my trust in other hands than mine. And I learned to wander. I learned what every dreaming child needs to know—that no horizon is so far that you cannot get above it or beyond it. These I learned at once. But most things came harder.” —BERYL MARKHAM, West with the Night

“We must leave our mark on life while we have it in our power.” —KAREN BLIXEN


Circling The Sun brought this unconventional woman's story alive in the most beautiful contemporary prose. The author borrowed characters from Out of Africa by Isak Dinesen, Karen Blixen, to populate Beryl's story and establish the connection between Karin Blixen and Beryl: Denys Finch Hatton, Lord Delamere, Berkeley Cole, Karin Blixen and her husband baron van Blixen, and a few more.

Not keen on a proper education, Beryl would ultimately be schooled by the men in her life instead.

First it was her father who taught her everything she would ever need about horse training. She would become the youngest licensed horse trainer, and first women in the world, at the age of eighteen.

Her childhood friend, Kibii, a child of the Kikuyu tribe, taught her how to hunt, to understand the rules of nature, and to survive in the African bush. He would remain her truest friend throughout her life.

Denys Finch Hatton and Berkely Cole inspired her to read, and become the Schezerehade of her own life story.

Before Kenya was Kenya, Green Hills was alive and my father loved me. I could jump as high as Kibii and walk through the forest without making a sound. I could bring a warthog out of its hole by crinkling paper. I could be eaten by a lion and live. I could do anything, for I was in heaven still.

Before Kenya was Kenya, I threw a spear and a rungu club. I loved a horse with wings. I never felt alone or small. I was Lakwet.


Their story evenings would result in her eloquent autbiography several years later.

Tom Campbell Black taught her everything about flying, airplanes, machines, reading maps. Denys Finch Hatton who was her lover, was also her mentor in conquering the skies.

The nostalgia of the tough but idyllic life on the African savannas are so vividly described in this book. A fine balance was established between background and story. A perfect balance to be exact.
The author portrayed the private Beryl. The person nobody really understood. The one who hid her pain and disappoinments. She captured the emotions and thoughts of a scared young girl, a gutsy young woman, and a pioneering survivor of a challenging life.

The book is written in the same spirit as Kuki Gallman's books: I Dreamed of Africa AND African Nights . Many authors captured this magic of the African landscape. Africa still has that allure, always will have it.

Circling The Sun also settles comfortably into the same nostalgia as Alexandra Fuller's Cocktail Hour Under the Tree of Forgetfulness , AND Don't Let's Go to the Dogs Tonight , although the two authors experienced two different periods in colonial history. However, the ambiance of the British settlers's often promiscuous lifestyle, with debauchery thrown into the social mix, and the almost vulgar exploitation of wildlife, mineral resources and African people, were (lightly) mimicked in this book. Very lightly, compared to Doris Lessing who did not mince words in destroying the settlers' delusional self-importance and grandeur. But in this book, the Brits's African lifestyle, away from England's rigid society, was still treated with understanding and even compassion. They were spared. :-)

(A different view, but a wonderful read is: The Poisonwood Bible by Barbara Kingsolver. There's no comparison between the two books, of course. It's just another excellent book which captures the soul of Africa very well.)

It was a tough life, demanding great sacrifice and creativity to survive.

Like your quinine for malaria,” Berkeley added. “A measure of good champagne helps, too. I don’t know what it is about Africa, but champagne is absolutely compulsory here.”


This was an excellent read. Now fate will take its course. I will have to read West With The Night by Beryl Markham herself.

Paula McClain says in her author's note:

From the moment I read even a few sentences, West with the Night took powerful hold of my imagination. Beryl’s descriptions of her African childhood, colonial Kenya in all its seasons, and her extraordinary adventures fairly leap off the page—but more striking to me is the spirit behind the words. She had so much nerve and pluck, plunging fearlessly into vast gaps between the sexes, and at a time when such feats were nearly unthinkable. I hadn’t ever encountered anyone quite like her—a woman who lived by her own code instead of society’s, though that cost her much. Who would have fit perfectly into Hemingway’s muscular fiction, but she actually lived!

Beryl was undoubtedly complicated—a riddle, a libertine, a maverick. A sphinx.


I rest my case. I love Africa. I love this book.
82 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Circling the Sun.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
September, 2017 – Finished Reading
September 15, 2017 – Shelved
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: 2017-read
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: american-author
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: africa
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: biographical-fiction
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: fiction
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: history
September 15, 2017 – Shelved as: reviewed

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Diane Barnes Beautiful review. What I loved about Beryl Markham was her insistence on living life on her own terms, society and it's rules be damned. You will love "West With the Night". Hemingway was right.


message 2: by Theresa (new)

Theresa Alan Well, I did love Poisonwood Bible, so maybe . . . Nice review!


Canadian Jen Awesome review! I loved poisonwood too -one of my all time faves and I, too, am mesmerized by African stories.


Angela M is taking a break. Lovely review, Margitte . Great selection of quotes . I totally agree about the balance "between background and story ."


Jeannie Great review! I loved this one too.


Michael Outstanding review. Perfect highlighting of the elements that worked and selection of quotes. No matter how hopeless it is for fiction to capture the "real" Beryl, her love of Africa stands true regardless. As does yours in much that you write. Your past mention of monkeys or hyenas in your garden captures my imagination on that score.


Candi A stunning review, Margitte. I adored this book and reading your lovely thoughts brought it all back to me.


message 8: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Terrific review!!


message 9: by Sue (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sue Excellent review Margitte. Love the way you tied this novel about Markham in with other works by authors who have written about their experiences in Africa.


Margitte Diane wrote: "Beautiful review. What I loved about Beryl Markham was her insistence on living life on her own terms, society and it's rules be damned. You will love "West With the Night". Hemingway was right."

Thanks, Diane. She was kind of forced to be independent, right? Her parents out of her life, no social standing, no where to go. That makes her even more remarkable, right?


message 11: by Margitte (last edited Sep 16, 2017 10:58PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Margitte Theresa wrote: "Well, I did love Poisonwood Bible, so maybe . . . Nice review!"

Thanks, Theresa. A biography in fictional form is an enjoyable read. This one was, for sure. The Out Of Africa elements in the book were very strong though. It was as though the book was centered around Out Of Africa - taking one of the peripheral characters in Karin Blixen's book and build a new story around her, with several of the same characters fleshed out.


message 12: by Margitte (last edited Sep 16, 2017 11:01PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Margitte Jen wrote: "Awesome review! I loved poisonwood too -one of my all time faves and I, too, am mesmerized by African stories."

Thanks, Jen. In a reply to Angela's comment on my review of Leopard At The Door I listed some books which are similar in ambiance than Circling The Sun
Perhaps there are a book or two that might grab your interest, if you haven't read them already :-)
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


Margitte Angela M wrote: "Lovely review, Margitte . Great selection of quotes . I totally agree about the balance "between background and story .""
Thanks, Angela. It is such an enjoyable read. Love the contemporary style of the book, right?


Margitte Jeannie wrote: "Great review! I loved this one too."

Thanks, Jeannie! :-)


Margitte Michael wrote: "Outstanding review. Perfect highlighting of the elements that worked and selection of quotes. No matter how hopeless it is for fiction to capture the "real" Beryl, her love of Africa stands true re..."

Thanks, Michael. WE only have two of the Big Five as neighbors - buffalo and Rhino, and then leopards, lynxes monkeys, baboons, kudus, elande, and a few hundred others gracing my garden when they feel like it. lol. No lions in our area, thank goodness. :-)


Margitte Deanna wrote: "Terrific review!!"
Candi wrote: "A stunning review, Margitte. I adored this book and reading your lovely thoughts brought it all back to me."

Thanks, Deanna and Candi. Really appreciate it.


Margitte Sue wrote: "Excellent review Margitte. Love the way you tied this novel about Markham in with other works by authors who have written about their experiences in Africa."

Thank you, Sue. I have read so many African authors before I joined GR. I wish I have listed them all.


message 18: by Sue (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sue Margitte wrote: "Sue wrote: "Excellent review Margitte. Love the way you tied this novel about Markham in with other works by authors who have written about their experiences in Africa."

Thank you, Sue. I have rea..."


I'm remembering that I have Triomf on my shelf at your recommendation. At the rate I'm going, I hope I will read that next year!


message 19: by Margitte (last edited Sep 17, 2017 02:19AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Margitte Sue wrote: "'m remembering that I have Triomf on my shelf at your recommendation. At the rate I'm going, I hope I will read that next year! ..."

Oh it is a very difficult read. I struggled with it. Tried 5 times, and finally just bit the bullet. Similar in ambiance than Tobacco Road by Erskine Caldwell. Hard to swallow.


message 20: by Bianca (new) - added it

Bianca Great review. I confess I hadn't heard of Beryl Markham. but I've had this book on my TBR for a while now.


Margitte Bianca wrote: "Great review. I confess I hadn't heard of Beryl Markham. but I've had this book on my TBR for a while now."

Thanks, Bianca. :-)


message 22: by L (new) - rated it 5 stars

L F I loved this book. It was the vehicle which sent me to obsessive Happy Valley set and the many books about the iconic British Rhodesia. Good stuff.


message 23: by L (new) - rated it 5 stars

L F Btw. I forgot to mention the novel written by Beryl Markham, WEST WITH THE NIGHT. I read this many years back. Certainly worth a read.


message 24: by Margitte (last edited Sep 18, 2017 05:34AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Margitte L wrote: "Btw. I forgot to mention the novel written by Beryl Markham, WEST WITH THE NIGHT. I read this many years back. Certainly worth a read."

If you can remember which books reflected the lives of the Happy Valley set, I will be very happy to know, L. Those were great authors. Yes, I would love to read Beryl's own book.


message 25: by Jess (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jess The Bookworm Glad you enjoyed it, great review!


Margitte Jess wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it, great review!"

Thanks, Jess.


message 27: by Amy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amy I adore this reading and gave it five full stars. It was in my top 10 last year.


Margitte Amy wrote: "I adore this reading and gave it five full stars. It was in my top 10 last year."

Thanks for your comment, Amy. Yes, this book was a good experience.


message 29: by Katie (new)

Katie Terrific review, Margitte.


Margitte Katie wrote: "Terrific review, Margitte."

Thank you, Katie! :-)


message 31: by Marialyce (new) - added it

Marialyce Sounds great, Margitte and of course I added it to my TBR.


Margitte Marialyce wrote: "Sounds great, Margitte and of course I added it to my TBR."

Hope you enjoy it, Marialyce :-)


message 33: by Paula (new)

Paula K Beautiful review, Margitte.


Margitte Paula wrote: "Beautiful review, Margitte."

Thanks, Paul :-)


message 35: by Sunny (new) - added it

Sunny Shore I have this on my kindle. Thanks for the 5 star review


Margitte Sunny wrote: "I have this on my kindle. Thanks for the 5 star review"

You're most welcome, Sunny :-)


message 37: by Debbie (new) - added it

Debbie Excellent review! I read Let’s Not Go to the Dogs Tonight age ago, and completely loved it. Might have to move this one up.


message 38: by Beth (new) - rated it 4 stars

Beth You certainly make me want to read it. I have put a hold on it at the library! Thank you for the reviews you do. They inspire me!


message 39: by Anna (new) - added it

Anna Beautiful review Margitte. I can not think of a better or more convincing recommendation. Thank you for this, and the other titles that you mentioned, I added them promptly to my TBR list.
There is something in Africa, if it’s the vastness of landscapes, or the endless starry skies, or the cacophony of utterly unfamiliar sounds at night, I don’t know, but it is easy to lose your heart, and it affects visitors too :-)


Margitte Debbie wrote: "Excellent review! I read Let’s Not Go to the Dogs Tonight age ago, and completely loved it. Might have to move this one up."

Thanks, Debbie. I really enjoyed this book. Just returned from a private game reserve in the Karroo, which 'mimicked' the charm of Out of Africa, and this book.

It felt like walking into Karen Blixen and Beryl Markham's lives. The woman who established the private game reserve is British herself and has done a remarkable job on the reserve. I appreciated her efforts to capture the charm and grace of that era and combine it with a traditional South African ambiance.


Margitte Beth wrote: "You certainly make me want to read it. I have put a hold on it at the library! Thank you for the reviews you do. They inspire me!"

So happy to know, Beth. This book is absolutely worth a read.


Margitte Anna wrote: "Beautiful review Margitte. I can not think of a better or more convincing recommendation. Thank you for this, and the other titles that you mentioned, I added them promptly to my TBR list. ..."

Thanks,Anna. You're so right about Africa. It's a magic so hard to describe. I hope you enjoy this book just as much.


Lilac Bookworm Wow! Five stars! I thought so too! Terrific review. So glad you loved it too. Definitely 5 stars.


Margitte Lilac wrote: "Wow! Five stars! I thought so too! Terrific review. So glad you loved it too. Definitely 5 stars."

Thanks, Lilac🐘🐘🌺


Lilac Bookworm Lilac wrote: "Wow! Five stars! I thought so too! Terrific review. So glad you loved it too. Definitely 5 stars."

😊😚🌾 💐 🌷 🌹 🌺 🌸 🌼 🌻


back to top