PorshaJo's Reviews > Lilac Girls

Lilac Girls by Martha Hall Kelly
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5464046
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: audio, challengereads, challengereads-2017

I tend to gravitate to books on WWII and the holocaust, but I have never read a book about Ravensbrück, the Nazi concentration camp for women. I had never heard of the 'rabbits'. I was shocked by this book, not expecting it to be as good as it was.

The Lilac Girls tells the story of three *very* different women, whose lives eventually intersect. Caroline Ferriday, a socialite and former actress works for the French Consulate in NYC and she works tirelessly for children who have been impacted or displaced by the war. Kasia Kuzmerick, a young Polish girl who eventually is taken by the Germans to Ravensbrück, and is one of the rabbits. Finally, Herta Oberheuser, a young german doctor who is really striving to get herself noticed as a female doctor and shows her unwaivering support for the Reich. The story rotates in chapters between the points of view of each of these women. Telling their stories before, during, and after the war. The rabbits were a group of young, healthy, women who the germans performed ruthless, unnecessary operations on them, debilitating them for life, and sometimes just killing them outright. Herta is the doctor who performs those operations. She is such an evil person who shows no remorse for what she does as it's done for the good of Germany.

The story is quite intense. At times, it becomes hard to listen to. Caroline and Herta are based on real life people who did these things that are described in the book. Kasia, is a story based on many of the rabbits. It can be a difficult read at times, but no book on this time period is an easy read. Initially, Caroline seemed to be quite shallow to me, and her 'romance' with Paul just seemed odd. But eventually, she accomplishes some amazing things.

I do have to get this out - WORST BOOK COVER!!! It is quite a lovely picture but this shows no representation of what is INSIDE the book. To be honest, when the book came out, I knew it was a story based around WWII. But looking at the cover, I thought it was some book about a bunch of wealthy girls and how they living during this time, but thinking it would be a fluff book. In fact, I returned it to the library initially. The book is so much more and the cover has nothing to do with it other than there are three main female characters.

I listened to this one via audio and it was wonderful. Three different female narrators, one for each character. All did a fabulous job and really immersed me in to the story. I would suggest the audio version for those that enjoy audios. Overall, a great story about three different women that should not be missed.
166 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Lilac Girls.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 3, 2017 – Started Reading
March 3, 2017 – Shelved
March 3, 2017 –
page 0
0.0% "My new audio - so excited to finally pick this one up."
March 22, 2017 – Shelved as: audio
March 22, 2017 – Shelved as: challengereads
March 22, 2017 – Shelved as: challengereads-2017
March 22, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 67 (67 new)


message 1: by Trudie (new)

Trudie Oh good I have this one to read soon and had not seen it reviewed much - looking forward to your review


PorshaJo Trudie wrote: "Oh good I have this one to read soon and had not seen it reviewed much - looking forward to your review"

Oh it's sooo good Trudie! I can't believe there are not more reviews and praise for this one. Hope you get to it soon and that you enjoy it.


message 3: by Anushree (new)

Anushree Great fab review PorshaJo!!!! Sounds really good.... :) :D


message 4: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Great review, as ever, PorshaJo.
I do agree about the cover giving out the wrong message. It looks really cutesy and promises a saccharine story of lifelong friends reminiscing about their lives and loves over a nice cup of tea.


message 5: by Kelli (new)

Kelli What Kevin said! Fantastic review and agree abt the cover, too. Adding!


Maureen ( NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS) Wonderful review PorshaJo.


PorshaJo Anushree :) :) wrote: "Great fab review PorshaJo!!!! Sounds really good.... :) :D"

Thanks Anushree! It's very good, hope you get a chance to check it out.


PorshaJo Kevin wrote: "Great review, as ever, PorshaJo.
I do agree about the cover giving out the wrong message. It looks really cutesy and promises a saccharine story of lifelong friends reminiscing about their lives an..."


Thanks Kevin! EXACTLY! I figured a few spoiled, rich girls just reminiscing about the war. And the book is nothing like it. Glad I'm not alone on that one.


PorshaJo Kelli wrote: "What Kevin said! Fantastic review and agree abt the cover, too. Adding!"

Thanks Kelli! Yup, that is why I avoided the book for so long. The cover led me to believe it was something totally different. Hope you get a chance to read it.


PorshaJo Maureen wrote: "Wonderful review PorshaJo."

Thank you Maureen!


message 11: by Kristin (KC) (new) - added it

Kristin (KC) Great review! Glad you enjoyed, and I'm with you on the cover - i never would have guessed what this book is about based off the cover. Time period, maybe. But not content.


message 12: by Norma (new) - added it

Norma Wonderful review, PorshaJo! I will see if I can get the audio version of this book! :-)


PorshaJo Kristin (KC) wrote: "Great review! Glad you enjoyed, and I'm with you on the cover - i never would have guessed what this book is about based off the cover. Time period, maybe. But not content."

Thanks Kristin! It's horrible right! Sometimes I pick up books based on the cover alone. This was one time that I skipped a book based on the cover. Glad some folks here on GR said to read it and I gave it a shot as it's very good.


message 14: by PorshaJo (last edited Mar 23, 2017 10:34AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

PorshaJo Norma wrote: "Wonderful review, PorshaJo! I will see if I can get the audio version of this book! :-)"

Thanks Norma! I think you will like this one, the audio is very good. I really enjoyed each of the voices and the accents were great too. I hope you get a chance to try it and like it.


message 15: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Fantastic review, PorshaJo!


PorshaJo Deanna wrote: "Fantastic review, PorshaJo!"

Thanks Deanna!


Lindsay L Excellent review PorshaJo! I loved this book! Great point about the cover - I hadn't thought of that - it really doesn't match with the story, does it? It is a beautiful cover, but unrelated to the book - strange! Glad you enjoyed this novel!! :-)


Cheri Loved your review, PorshaJo, and am so glad you addressed the cover! When I first saw the cover it looked like a story about the women left back at home in the US waiting for the soldiers to return, something far lighter than the story is.


message 19: by Candi (new)

Candi Terrific review, PorshaJo. The cover initially threw me off too - until I read some reviews like yours that shed more light on this, I had hesitated to add to my TBR. It's there now!


Iris P Enjoyed your review Porshajo, great job at recapping this fascinating but disturbing story. I don't believe that I ever wrote a review but this was one of my favorite historical fictions novels in the last couple of years.


Brenda ~The Book Witch at Witch Words Excellent review, PorshJo! I loved this one. So glad to see you enjoyed the audio version and the story.


message 22: by Susanne (new)

Susanne Fantastic review Porshajo! I am going to add this to the list. :)


Canadian Jen Wonderful review - lol on the cover - I kind of like it but doesn't truly reflect what the story is about for sure


message 24: by Lara xoxo (new)

Lara xoxo fabulous review as always never disappoints xoxo


PorshaJo Lindsay wrote: "Excellent review PorshaJo! I loved this book! Great point about the cover - I hadn't thought of that - it really doesn't match with the story, does it? It is a beautiful cover, but unrelated to the..."

Thanks Lindsay! Exactly! I would have thought some fluffy book inside about ladies luncheon, nothing to compared to the actual story. Glad you loved this one too Lindsay.


PorshaJo Cheri wrote: "Loved your review, PorshaJo, and am so glad you addressed the cover! When I first saw the cover it looked like a story about the women left back at home in the US waiting for the soldiers to return..."

Thanks Cheri! I had to address the cover as I know I kept putting this one off thinking it was something else entirely. I'm sure others may do the same. I'm glad I finally read this one.


PorshaJo Candi wrote: "Terrific review, PorshaJo. The cover initially threw me off too - until I read some reviews like yours that shed more light on this, I had hesitated to add to my TBR. It's there now!"

Thanks Candi! Glad my tip on the cover helps. It really is a great book....just ignore the cover completely. Hope you like it when you get to it.


PorshaJo Iris P wrote: "Enjoyed your review Porshajo, great job at recapping this fascinating but disturbing story. I don't believe that I ever wrote a review but this was one of my favorite historical fictions novels in ..."

Thanks Iris! I'm so glad you loved this one too. I could write so much more on this wonderful book as it packs a lot in and it's great story.


PorshaJo Brenda wrote: "Excellent review, PorshJo! I loved this one. So glad to see you enjoyed the audio version and the story."

Thanks Brenda! So glad you loved this one too.


PorshaJo Susanne wrote: "Fantastic review Porshajo! I am going to add this to the list. :)"

Thanks Susanne! I hope that you love this book. Looking forward to your review on it when you get a chance to read it.


PorshaJo Jen wrote: "Wonderful review - lol on the cover - I kind of like it but doesn't truly reflect what the story is about for sure"

Thanks Jen! Yup. It's a lovely picture on the cover.....just gives a totally different impression of what's inside.


PorshaJo Tania Stevenson-Noyes wrote: "fabulous review as always never disappoints xoxo"

Thanks Tania Stevenson-Noyes! You are so kind.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Love your review and loved this book, PorshaJo!


PorshaJo Jennifer wrote: "Love your review and loved this book, PorshaJo!"

Thanks Jennifer! And thanks for giving me the push to bump this one up. So glad you loved it too - it's a great book.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader PorshaJo wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "Love your review and loved this book, PorshaJo!"

Thanks Jennifer! And thanks for giving me the push to bump this one up. So glad you loved it too - it's a great book."


Aww, I am excited you loved the audio! That gives me an excuse to listen to it down the road when I've forgotten "some" of the details - some of the details will be too hard to forget though! :)


Marilyn C. Wonderful review on a great book!! You heard the saying "Never judge a book by it's cover" - it really applies to this one!


Angela M is taking a break. Excellent review, PorshaJo! I've read s number of Holocaust books but this was the first I really learned about Ravensbruk. Heartbreaking but I loved this book.


message 38: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol Enticing review PorshaJo! I definitely need to move this one up.


PorshaJo Jennifer wrote: "Aww, I am excited you loved the audio! That gives me an excuse to listen to it down the road when I've forgotten "some" of the details - some of the details will be too hard to forget though! :) ."

Oh I know. At the end, about Kasia's mother...I wanted to go back and read the earlier part all over again. Don't want to give anything away here. But I can see doing a re-read on this one.


PorshaJo Marilyn wrote: "Wonderful review on a great book!! You heard the saying "Never judge a book by it's cover" - it really applies to this one!"

Thanks Marilyn! How true! I'm glad I finally got over that saying and read the book. Was worth it.


PorshaJo Angela M wrote: "Excellent review, PorshaJo! I've read s number of Holocaust books but this was the first I really learned about Ravensbruk. Heartbreaking but I loved this book."

Thanks Angela! I've never read a book on the Holocaust specifically about women, so this was an eye opening experience. And I agree....heartbreaking, but such a great book. Glad you loved this one too.


PorshaJo Carol wrote: "Enticing review PorshaJo! I definitely need to move this one up."

Thanks Carol! It's a great historical fiction read. I hope you get a chance to read this one and enjoy it just as much.


message 43: by Dana (new)

Dana Wonderful review, PorshaJo! I need to get to this book soon. I'm late to the party.


PorshaJo Dana wrote: "Wonderful review, PorshaJo! I need to get to this book soon. I'm late to the party."

Thanks Dana! Oh I felt like I was late to the part also, but just so many books to read. I hope you like it when you do read it. And the audio is worth the use of credits too. :-)


message 45: by Melissa (new)

Melissa I've never heard of the 'rabbits' before either. I'm so curious about this one now. Thanks for putting it on my radar and lovely review. :)


PorshaJo Melissa wrote: "I've never heard of the 'rabbits' before either. I'm so curious about this one now. Thanks for putting it on my radar and lovely review. :)"

Thanks Melissa! I had not heard of them either. I hope you get a chance to read this one and like it.


message 47: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura It is now on my to read list thanks to you... great review!


PorshaJo Laura wrote: "It is now on my to read list thanks to you... great review!"

Thanks Laura! I hope you like it when you get to it.


message 49: by Carol (new)

Carol Wonderful review, Porshajo. I love it when audios work well!


PorshaJo Carol wrote: "Wonderful review, Porshajo. I love it when audios work well!"

Thanks Carol! I sometimes worry about multiple narrators, but this was done very well.


« previous 1
back to top