Kalliope's Reviews > A Hora da Estrela

A Hora da Estrela by Clarice Lispector
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3593962
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction-portuguese, latam




Interstellar Heap of Dust


Sim.

This is how Clarice Lispector chose to finish her book: with the same word as Joyce did. His famous Yes. But she began with it too. For as she says in her opening line, everything in the world began with a Yes.

And so she unfolds her story. Or lets her male narrator unfold it. Several barriers are thus created between her and us and her story – his story. And the Hour of the Star, not one of those in heaven, but the Star as a celebrity, is the title for the story of someone who is as notorious as a speck of dust.

The banality of the fable is not matched by the sophistication of the novella. This short fiction reads like an astute laboratory on writing. Defending simplicity of language and reminding that the basic element of writing is the word, Lispector’s narrator recognizes that writing is an effort in self-knowledge. This is what we then ask. What did she find when building the writing self--when she is writing about another. An object. (view spoiler)

The speck of dust is a woman who does not acquire her name, Macabéa, for several pages. She first is a lassie from the northeast, a nordestina. She was first also a girl with no name. For the first year in her life she was not named, and she preferred to remain unnamed to being incorrectly named and wrongly identified. Ah, identities forged by words.

May be that is why words are tiring and Lispector’s narrator, afraid of words and literature, seeks silence since writing is a way of whiling away one’s life until the end arrives.

And so it does for Macabéa: her celebrity moment, her hora da estrela.

The final affirmative however does not close the narration. It waits for an answer.

As open and loose as interstellar dust.





57 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Hora da Estrela.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 1, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
December 1, 2015 – Shelved
December 1, 2015 – Shelved as: fiction-portuguese
December 1, 2015 – Shelved as: latam
December 22, 2015 – Started Reading
December 26, 2015 –
page 48
54.55%
December 27, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Tantalising review, Kalliope.


Kalliope Marita wrote: "A magnificent picture to match your excellent review, Kalliope."

Thank you, Marita... I always try to think of an image that will match or encapsulate the impression I got out of my reading.


Kalliope Ilse wrote: "Tantalising review, Kalliope."

Thank you, Ilse.


message 4: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Your review is a bit like interstellar dust, Kalliope, colorful, effervescent, impossible to pin down - but having read Lispector's Near to the Wild Heart recently, I understand where it's coming from....I think ;-]


Kalliope Fionnuala wrote: "Your review is a bit like interstellar dust, Kalliope, colorful, effervescent, impossible to pin down - but having read Lispector's Near to the Wild Heart recently, I understand where it's coming f..."

This was my first Lispector.. I have a couple more waiting.... I wonder whether with more reading, her interstellar dust will settle down.


message 6: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Done in style, Kall! A sharp teaser, this review is. I, especially, liked the words you deployed to describe her narrative style; translucent perhaps. I am reading Lispector this year; affirmative!


Kalliope Seemita wrote: "Done in style, Kall! A sharp teaser, this review is. I, especially, liked the words you deployed to describe her narrative style; translucent perhaps. I am reading Lispector this year; affirmative!"

I look forward to your impression of Lispector... I plan to read a couple more by her. YES.


Junta I like the image! Interesting to hear about the Yes here, as No is a word that frequents Near to the Wild Heart. This might be my next Lispector.


message 9: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King I like this author Kall but I haven't read this book. I must rectify that.

What fabulous colours with the "Interstellar Heap of Dust".


Lizzy Wonderful review of a book that I love by a cherished author, Kalliope!


Kalliope Lizzy wrote: "Wonderful review of a book that I love by a cherished author, Kalliope!"

Lizzy, I had not seen this comment. I came back to this review, as Lispector has cropped up again, and saw your comment. I am glad you like her writing so much.


Katia N Wonderful review and the picture! I did like it as much as you did, mainly because I felt the male narrator/writer is manipulating by his creation of a character. But the idea, the language and the transience of it was brilliant and you convey it very well in your review!


Kalliope Katia wrote: "Wonderful review and the picture! I did like it as much as you did, mainly because I felt the male narrator/writer is manipulating by his creation of a character. But the idea, the language and the..."

Yes, I can understand. For me it was not a five stars, but very close. I have been given a couple more books by her - but translated in Italian. I read this one in Portuguese...


Monique I just reread the book... Your reveiw is beautiful, Kalliope .


Kalliope Monique wrote: "I just reread the book... Your reveiw is beautiful, Kalliope ."

Thank you, Monique. I am not surprised you read this twice.. I would like to read more by her.


back to top