What do you think?
Rate this book
Las chicas de Manhattan
Nueva York, 1921. La vida nocturna y cultural de la ciudad es más frenética que nunca y el alcohol de contrabando circula de forma clandestina a pesar de la Ley Seca. En este ambiente se cruzan los destinos de cuatro mujeres extraordinarias.Dorothy Parker, una mente brillante que esconde su fragilidad detrás de comentarios mordaces. Jane Grant, primera mujer reportera de The New York Times y The New Yorker. La actriz de Broadway Winifred Lenihan, en busca del papel de su vida. Y Peggy Leech, secretaria durante el día y brillante novelista por la noche.Las cuatro comparten experiencias, se consuelan y se apoyan en los contratiempos. Pero su mayor reto será mantener a su querida amiga Dorothy a salvo de sí misma.
440 pages, Paperback
First published August 16, 2022
About the author
Gill Paul
52 books1,729 followersGill Paul is the international bestselling author of thirteen novels, many of them reevaluating extraordinary twentieth-century women whom she believes have been marginalized or misjudged. Her novels have reached the top of the USA Today, Wall Street Journal, and Toronto Globe & Mail charts, and have been translated into twenty-three languages.
Her latest novel, Scandalous Women (2024), is about trailblazing authors Jackie Collins and Jacqueline Susann battling their way to the top in the misogynous boys' club of 1960s publishing. A Beautiful Rival (2023) is about the infamous feud between beauty tycoons Elizabeth Arden and Helena Rubinstein. Jackie and Maria (2020) was longlisted for the Historical Writers’ Association Gold Crown. The Collector’s Daughter (2021) was named a Times ‘historical novel of the month’ and The Manhattan Girls (2022), was reviewed in The Sun as a “sweeping, evocative tale” and in The Book List as “Witty, emotional and intelligent”.
Gill also writes historical non-fiction, including A History of Medicine in 50 Objects and a series of Love Stories. Published around the world, this series includes Royal Love Stories, World War I Love Stories and Titanic Love Stories.
Gill lives in London where she swims year round in a wild pond, and speaks at libraries and literary festivals on topics ranging from Tutankhamun to the Romanovs.
Her latest novel, Scandalous Women (2024), is about trailblazing authors Jackie Collins and Jacqueline Susann battling their way to the top in the misogynous boys' club of 1960s publishing. A Beautiful Rival (2023) is about the infamous feud between beauty tycoons Elizabeth Arden and Helena Rubinstein. Jackie and Maria (2020) was longlisted for the Historical Writers’ Association Gold Crown. The Collector’s Daughter (2021) was named a Times ‘historical novel of the month’ and The Manhattan Girls (2022), was reviewed in The Sun as a “sweeping, evocative tale” and in The Book List as “Witty, emotional and intelligent”.
Gill also writes historical non-fiction, including A History of Medicine in 50 Objects and a series of Love Stories. Published around the world, this series includes Royal Love Stories, World War I Love Stories and Titanic Love Stories.
Gill lives in London where she swims year round in a wild pond, and speaks at libraries and literary festivals on topics ranging from Tutankhamun to the Romanovs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews
August 17, 2022
Sometimes we all need to escape into a book. It’s a plus when you also have the possibility to go back in time and get acquainted with people you hadn’t heard about before. Gill Pauls latest novel made that happen!
I was transported to the 1920’s in New York, and met four interesting woman who belonged to the Algonquin Round table. We get acquainted with Jane Grant, first female reporter for The New York Times, who is determined to launch a new magazine. The Broadway actress Winifred Lenihan, beautiful, talented, and a casting-couch target. And Peggy Leech, magazine assistant by day, brilliant novelist by night. Dorothy Parker, poet and famous for her wit.
They gossip, they comfort each other, they offer support through the setbacks. But their biggest challenge is keeping their dear friend Dottie safe from herself.
I thoroughly enjoyed myself when reading this novel, and even stopped to look at pictures from the characters so that I really felt connected to them. The four woman came alive and felt real to me. Paul’s writing style is as always easy to follow. I never felt bored or disappointed by the book. The extra drama with Dottie made the book even more interesting, and I’m impressed by Paul’s ability to create a life based on the few facts she found when researching the book. I think he must have captured how it was to live in the 1920’s, the sexism seemed very real and I can imagine that it must have been hard to navigate in a culture where you had to just take men treating women badly (off course there are also descriptions of different men too).
I’m glad I got my escape and will continue to look for it in her next books!
Thanks to Avon books and netgally for this arc!
I was transported to the 1920’s in New York, and met four interesting woman who belonged to the Algonquin Round table. We get acquainted with Jane Grant, first female reporter for The New York Times, who is determined to launch a new magazine. The Broadway actress Winifred Lenihan, beautiful, talented, and a casting-couch target. And Peggy Leech, magazine assistant by day, brilliant novelist by night. Dorothy Parker, poet and famous for her wit.
They gossip, they comfort each other, they offer support through the setbacks. But their biggest challenge is keeping their dear friend Dottie safe from herself.
I thoroughly enjoyed myself when reading this novel, and even stopped to look at pictures from the characters so that I really felt connected to them. The four woman came alive and felt real to me. Paul’s writing style is as always easy to follow. I never felt bored or disappointed by the book. The extra drama with Dottie made the book even more interesting, and I’m impressed by Paul’s ability to create a life based on the few facts she found when researching the book. I think he must have captured how it was to live in the 1920’s, the sexism seemed very real and I can imagine that it must have been hard to navigate in a culture where you had to just take men treating women badly (off course there are also descriptions of different men too).
I’m glad I got my escape and will continue to look for it in her next books!
Thanks to Avon books and netgally for this arc!
July 4, 2022
New York City in 1921, America women are wearing flapper dresses, having their hair cut into shingle bobs, dancing to jazz music, and drinking hooch in speakeasies and during probation. Four friends decide to start a bridge club and have regular catch ups, Dorothy, Jane, Winifred, Peggy, and they will be nicknamed The Manhattan Girls.
Dorothy Parker is a poet, a member of the Algonquin Round Table, when her marriage to Eddie ends, and she struggles with her mental health. Jane Grant is the first female reporter for the New York Times, she’s determined to launch her own magazine, and her husband Howard has been keeping secrets from her. Winifred Lenihan is a beautiful actress, after growing up in a large Irish Catholic family, she likes her privacy, and has to constantly fight off seedy men trying to hit on her. Peggy Leech is a magazine assistant, she’s busy writing a novel, and her mother wonders if she will ever get married?
An unlikely group of friends, who are there for each other through thick and thin. They help each other and give advice, from what to wear to an important business meeting or on a hot date, when a relationship breaks down, on opening nights and book releases, making sure Dottie eats, and stopping her from hurting herself.
I received a copy of The Manhattan Girls by Gill Paul from NetGalley and Avon Books UK in exchange for an honest review. A well written and interesting novel about the challenges women faced during the 1920’s in New York City and in a male dominated world. The women had to juggle their careers and life at home, and fight to be respected at work. The story follows the ups and downs of their romantic relationships, friendships with each other, and their vulnerabilities.
Five stars from me, a brilliant narrative about four unique and real women, I enjoyed every single page, and it’s my favorite book by Gill Paul.
Dorothy Parker is a poet, a member of the Algonquin Round Table, when her marriage to Eddie ends, and she struggles with her mental health. Jane Grant is the first female reporter for the New York Times, she’s determined to launch her own magazine, and her husband Howard has been keeping secrets from her. Winifred Lenihan is a beautiful actress, after growing up in a large Irish Catholic family, she likes her privacy, and has to constantly fight off seedy men trying to hit on her. Peggy Leech is a magazine assistant, she’s busy writing a novel, and her mother wonders if she will ever get married?
An unlikely group of friends, who are there for each other through thick and thin. They help each other and give advice, from what to wear to an important business meeting or on a hot date, when a relationship breaks down, on opening nights and book releases, making sure Dottie eats, and stopping her from hurting herself.
I received a copy of The Manhattan Girls by Gill Paul from NetGalley and Avon Books UK in exchange for an honest review. A well written and interesting novel about the challenges women faced during the 1920’s in New York City and in a male dominated world. The women had to juggle their careers and life at home, and fight to be respected at work. The story follows the ups and downs of their romantic relationships, friendships with each other, and their vulnerabilities.
Five stars from me, a brilliant narrative about four unique and real women, I enjoyed every single page, and it’s my favorite book by Gill Paul.
July 5, 2022
Dorothy Parker and Manhattan: A Must Read for Me
When I saw this book on NetGalley, I knew I had to read it.
As a teenager, I discovered the humorous writings of Dorothy Parker, and became
her admirer (and perhaps sensed a kindred spirit in her).
I'm a lifelong New Yorker. I'm familiar with many of the venues in the book (the Algonquin Hotel, etc.), and many of the writers, artists, and actors featured in the book. Also, I'm fascinated by New York City History.
So there was no doubt that an historical novel about Dorothy Parker and her circle was one I had to read.
A Different Kind of Book that Took a While to Get Into
I've been reading so much science fiction, fantasy, and even historical adventure stories like The Lymond Chronicles that I've gotten used to a fast paced story with lots of action, battles, chase scenes, plot twists, violence, cliff hangers, etc. Also, there are often advanced AIs, computer games, space ships, magic, strange creatures, etc.
This book had none of those things. The story went at a much slower pace than what I've normally been reading. So that took a bit of getting used to.
But once I got into it, I got really wrapped up in the story. This is primarily a character study and the characters are really engaging.
The Algonquin Round Table in the Roaring Twenties
The book features the writers, artists, journalists, critics, actors, and theater people involved in the Algonquin Round Table (and their friends, associates, and hangers on).
Wikipedia Entry about the Algonquin Round Table
These folks met for lunch at the famed Algonquin Hotel which still exists on Manhattan's Upper West Side.
Dorothy Parker was a prominent member of the group, which also included such luminaries as Robert Benchley, Tallulah Bankhead, Noel Coward, Harold Ross, Harpo Marx, Eva Le Gallienne, Neysa McMein, etc.
The "Manhattan Girls" and Their Bridge Club
The book mainly focuses on a small subset of this group, four women who formed a bridge club that met in their various apartments: Dorothy Parker, humorist and author; Jane Grant (journalist and cofounder of the New Yorker magazine), Margaret "Peggy" Leech (sales person at Conde Nast and author); and Winifred Lenihan (actress).
These women, none of whom played bridge very well, became good friends over the years.
Dorothy Parker
I must admit that I cringed reading about Dorothy Parker, who reminded me in some ways of a younger version of myself.
I've changed and become, as an older woman, self sufficient, diplomatic, and reserved.
But when I was younger I was like her in many respects. Unlike her, I wasn't an alcoholic nor did I attempt suicide.
But like her, I was vulnerable, often depressed, and invariably chose terrible men and then drove them away because of my codependence and anxiety.
I also hadn't learned to control my mouth, so I often said cringeworthy and impulsive things.
She was luckier than I was though, in some respects. She certainly had really good friends.
The Fascinating and Fun Roaring Twenties
It was great fun to read about the Roaring Twenties, with its fun loving New Yorkers who loved to dance, frequent speakeasies, and drank like fish in spite of Prohibition.
I enjoyed the fashions of the times too. Parker and her buddies had great taste in clothing.
Personal Problems
We also find out about the difficulties all these women deal with: Winifred having to fend off the unwanted advances of directors, agents, and gangsters; Parker's inner pain and alcoholism, perhaps caused by an unhappy childhood and losing her mother at age five; Peggy's lack of confidence and difficulty finding men; and Jane's marital difficulties in spite of what seemed to others an ideal marriage.
I was at times astonished what some of these people tolerated in their friends and associates.
I never quite understood why Jane Grant and her husband Harold Ross put up with Alexander Woollcott, the theater critic, who moved in to the building they'd purchased in Hell's Kitchen, and was a generally nasty and malicious piece of work whose only pleasures in life seemed to be humiliating his associates and driving wedges between them. Jane perhaps tolerated Woollcott because he was suppposed to be a good friend of her husband Harold, although he didn't seem to be anyone's friend.
Minor Quibble
There were times when I wasn't entirely certain whether the language of the present day was also used in the 20's.
For example, actress Eva LeGallienne exclaims "Spot-on" when Winifred says her accent seems a combination of American, French, and English. Would that phrase have actually been used then?
Summary: Recommended Book
I recommend this book. It highlights the struggles of creative New York women in the 1920s, but a lot of what they go through seems timeless and can apply to our times.
I think women will particularly relate to this novel.
I also enjoyed the history at lot.
Thanks for the ARC
Thanks to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for this ARC (Advanced Review Copy) in exchange for an honest review.
I will note that although I am American and live in New York, I inadvertently requested the British edition of this ebook instead of the American version.
It will be published on August 18, 2022.
The American version comes out August 16, 2022.
#NetGallley
When I saw this book on NetGalley, I knew I had to read it.
As a teenager, I discovered the humorous writings of Dorothy Parker, and became
her admirer (and perhaps sensed a kindred spirit in her).
I'm a lifelong New Yorker. I'm familiar with many of the venues in the book (the Algonquin Hotel, etc.), and many of the writers, artists, and actors featured in the book. Also, I'm fascinated by New York City History.
So there was no doubt that an historical novel about Dorothy Parker and her circle was one I had to read.
A Different Kind of Book that Took a While to Get Into
I've been reading so much science fiction, fantasy, and even historical adventure stories like The Lymond Chronicles that I've gotten used to a fast paced story with lots of action, battles, chase scenes, plot twists, violence, cliff hangers, etc. Also, there are often advanced AIs, computer games, space ships, magic, strange creatures, etc.
This book had none of those things. The story went at a much slower pace than what I've normally been reading. So that took a bit of getting used to.
But once I got into it, I got really wrapped up in the story. This is primarily a character study and the characters are really engaging.
The Algonquin Round Table in the Roaring Twenties
The book features the writers, artists, journalists, critics, actors, and theater people involved in the Algonquin Round Table (and their friends, associates, and hangers on).
Wikipedia Entry about the Algonquin Round Table
These folks met for lunch at the famed Algonquin Hotel which still exists on Manhattan's Upper West Side.
Dorothy Parker was a prominent member of the group, which also included such luminaries as Robert Benchley, Tallulah Bankhead, Noel Coward, Harold Ross, Harpo Marx, Eva Le Gallienne, Neysa McMein, etc.
The "Manhattan Girls" and Their Bridge Club
The book mainly focuses on a small subset of this group, four women who formed a bridge club that met in their various apartments: Dorothy Parker, humorist and author; Jane Grant (journalist and cofounder of the New Yorker magazine), Margaret "Peggy" Leech (sales person at Conde Nast and author); and Winifred Lenihan (actress).
These women, none of whom played bridge very well, became good friends over the years.
Dorothy Parker
I must admit that I cringed reading about Dorothy Parker, who reminded me in some ways of a younger version of myself.
I've changed and become, as an older woman, self sufficient, diplomatic, and reserved.
But when I was younger I was like her in many respects. Unlike her, I wasn't an alcoholic nor did I attempt suicide.
But like her, I was vulnerable, often depressed, and invariably chose terrible men and then drove them away because of my codependence and anxiety.
I also hadn't learned to control my mouth, so I often said cringeworthy and impulsive things.
She was luckier than I was though, in some respects. She certainly had really good friends.
The Fascinating and Fun Roaring Twenties
It was great fun to read about the Roaring Twenties, with its fun loving New Yorkers who loved to dance, frequent speakeasies, and drank like fish in spite of Prohibition.
I enjoyed the fashions of the times too. Parker and her buddies had great taste in clothing.
Personal Problems
We also find out about the difficulties all these women deal with: Winifred having to fend off the unwanted advances of directors, agents, and gangsters; Parker's inner pain and alcoholism, perhaps caused by an unhappy childhood and losing her mother at age five; Peggy's lack of confidence and difficulty finding men; and Jane's marital difficulties in spite of what seemed to others an ideal marriage.
I was at times astonished what some of these people tolerated in their friends and associates.
I never quite understood why Jane Grant and her husband Harold Ross put up with Alexander Woollcott, the theater critic, who moved in to the building they'd purchased in Hell's Kitchen, and was a generally nasty and malicious piece of work whose only pleasures in life seemed to be humiliating his associates and driving wedges between them. Jane perhaps tolerated Woollcott because he was suppposed to be a good friend of her husband Harold, although he didn't seem to be anyone's friend.
Minor Quibble
There were times when I wasn't entirely certain whether the language of the present day was also used in the 20's.
For example, actress Eva LeGallienne exclaims "Spot-on" when Winifred says her accent seems a combination of American, French, and English. Would that phrase have actually been used then?
Summary: Recommended Book
I recommend this book. It highlights the struggles of creative New York women in the 1920s, but a lot of what they go through seems timeless and can apply to our times.
I think women will particularly relate to this novel.
I also enjoyed the history at lot.
Thanks for the ARC
Thanks to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for this ARC (Advanced Review Copy) in exchange for an honest review.
I will note that although I am American and live in New York, I inadvertently requested the British edition of this ebook instead of the American version.
It will be published on August 18, 2022.
The American version comes out August 16, 2022.
#NetGallley
August 26, 2022
Thanks to the publisher for an advanced copy of this book to read,
A look at 1920s New York, through the eyes of 4 very different women who form life long friendships after the war. The world is changing and they are starting to have more rights than ever. Things are not easy though, being a woman they still need to try to juggle a marriage, a career and babies
These women bond through their experiences, and are there for each other no matter what. Dorothy, Peggy, Winnie and Jane make their way through a new world, they are strong and powerful.
It was a fascinating look at a different kind of life to the one that we live these days. If it hadn’t been for women like these then we may not have some of the freedoms that we are lucky to have now. Thankfully, things have changed a lot.
A look at 1920s New York, through the eyes of 4 very different women who form life long friendships after the war. The world is changing and they are starting to have more rights than ever. Things are not easy though, being a woman they still need to try to juggle a marriage, a career and babies
These women bond through their experiences, and are there for each other no matter what. Dorothy, Peggy, Winnie and Jane make their way through a new world, they are strong and powerful.
It was a fascinating look at a different kind of life to the one that we live these days. If it hadn’t been for women like these then we may not have some of the freedoms that we are lucky to have now. Thankfully, things have changed a lot.
August 23, 2022
I received an advance reader copy of this book to read in exchange for an honest review as part of the book tour hosted by Random Things Tours.
The Manhatten Girls is an amazing novel set in the 1920s and follows Dorothy "Dotty" Parker and three of her closest friends. Set in New York, this book had the perfect backdrop for such a well written story. The book starts at the round table at the Gonk. We meet Dotty and her friends and each chapter that follows is about one of the four women and their life, problems, ups and downs. Dotty is known for her sharp whit and longs to be loved. Peggy is a magazine assistant who can't find a man due to being intimidating with her intelligence. Jane is the first ever female reporter for The New York Times and married to Harrold - they dream of launching their own newspaper one day. And Winnifred is a talented and beautiful Broadway actress who despises men especially men in the showbiz industry. There is so much I could say about this book but I don't want to spoil it any way for future readers. The story flowed really smoothly and I felt like I knew each woman really well personally and that I was right there with them! The four women go through so much together, some more than others, and I loved how they supported and helped each other, comforted each other and looked out for each other. I really didn't want the book to end but I enjoyed reading the "what happened next" paragraphs for each character. I was confused with Alec as a character as to what his game was with Jane and Harold as this wasn't exposed by the end of the book. This is my first Gill Paul book and I've been desperate to read one of her books for absolutely ages and I'm so glad I got to read this. I will now be looking for all her other books to devour!
The Manhatten Girls is an amazing novel set in the 1920s and follows Dorothy "Dotty" Parker and three of her closest friends. Set in New York, this book had the perfect backdrop for such a well written story. The book starts at the round table at the Gonk. We meet Dotty and her friends and each chapter that follows is about one of the four women and their life, problems, ups and downs. Dotty is known for her sharp whit and longs to be loved. Peggy is a magazine assistant who can't find a man due to being intimidating with her intelligence. Jane is the first ever female reporter for The New York Times and married to Harrold - they dream of launching their own newspaper one day. And Winnifred is a talented and beautiful Broadway actress who despises men especially men in the showbiz industry. There is so much I could say about this book but I don't want to spoil it any way for future readers. The story flowed really smoothly and I felt like I knew each woman really well personally and that I was right there with them! The four women go through so much together, some more than others, and I loved how they supported and helped each other, comforted each other and looked out for each other. I really didn't want the book to end but I enjoyed reading the "what happened next" paragraphs for each character. I was confused with Alec as a character as to what his game was with Jane and Harold as this wasn't exposed by the end of the book. This is my first Gill Paul book and I've been desperate to read one of her books for absolutely ages and I'm so glad I got to read this. I will now be looking for all her other books to devour!
February 16, 2022
There were many positives to this book. I loved the setting, the vibrant city, the quirky characters, and learning about how The New Yorker came to be. How much of the story was real and how much was fictionalized for the sake of the plot line is never clear.
I would have loved an afterword explaining what happened to them all after that one small pocket of their lives. What became of Dorothy, did Harold and Jane stay together, did Winifred find her happy ever after.
I have read other Gill Paul novels and very much enjoy the use of real historical events to weave a story around. Looking forward to reading more,
Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.
I would have loved an afterword explaining what happened to them all after that one small pocket of their lives. What became of Dorothy, did Harold and Jane stay together, did Winifred find her happy ever after.
I have read other Gill Paul novels and very much enjoy the use of real historical events to weave a story around. Looking forward to reading more,
Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.
September 5, 2022
I did not expect to love this book as much as I did!! Set in 1920s Manhattan, we get to know four friends as they navigate life and love in the city during the time of prohibition and increasing levels of women's freedoms. Very much a Sex in the city vibe, I loved each of the characters and really enjoyed reading about the origins of the New Yorker magazine. The author doesn't shy away from tough topics either, covering suicide attempts, depression, alcoholism, abortion, rape and more! Highly recommended for fans of Fiona Barton and great on audio.
August 22, 2022
Gill Paul takes us back to 1920s Manhattan where we meet 4 distinctly different women trying to make it in a male dominated world. The Manhattan Girls is a character study. Its a book that takes it's time and envelopes us in the atmosphere of New York City - back to the time when jazz was hip, bootleg booze was free flowing and womens fashion was a must.
This book has been compared with Sex and the City and I would agree with that statement. Dorothy, Jane, Winifred and Peggy are the Manhattan Girls. Dorothy is a writer, Jane is the first female reporter for the New York Times, Winifred is an actress and Peggy is an assistant at a magazine. The ladies have different backgrounds and opinions, but they are steadfast in their friendship for each other. The issues they faced are not unlike the ones for women today. We watch them as they develop their careers, navigate society's expectations and sexism. And they support each other as they search for love.
Paul takes 4 woman, puts their very different lifestyles together, and comes out with a pleasant story of friendship and loyalty. The story left me noting that even 100 years later we have not changed so very much.
Many thanks to NetGalley, William Morrow and Gill Paul introducing me to all aspects of twenties Manhattan - from the flapper culture to Prohibition to speakeasies to gangsters and bootlegging. From Fifth Avenue to the Algonquin hotel to Central Park and Broadway, this one is surely for NYC fans. And I have to admit after reading, I did a little googling to take another look at these fascinating women (a true sign of an engaging historical fiction book).
This book has been compared with Sex and the City and I would agree with that statement. Dorothy, Jane, Winifred and Peggy are the Manhattan Girls. Dorothy is a writer, Jane is the first female reporter for the New York Times, Winifred is an actress and Peggy is an assistant at a magazine. The ladies have different backgrounds and opinions, but they are steadfast in their friendship for each other. The issues they faced are not unlike the ones for women today. We watch them as they develop their careers, navigate society's expectations and sexism. And they support each other as they search for love.
Paul takes 4 woman, puts their very different lifestyles together, and comes out with a pleasant story of friendship and loyalty. The story left me noting that even 100 years later we have not changed so very much.
Many thanks to NetGalley, William Morrow and Gill Paul introducing me to all aspects of twenties Manhattan - from the flapper culture to Prohibition to speakeasies to gangsters and bootlegging. From Fifth Avenue to the Algonquin hotel to Central Park and Broadway, this one is surely for NYC fans. And I have to admit after reading, I did a little googling to take another look at these fascinating women (a true sign of an engaging historical fiction book).
August 18, 2022
The roaring 20s, but the issues in this book really could have been set in any time.
This book is definitely a girls club (bridge style) that is full of drama. It follows 4 different women that all fit into classic personalities. Dottie the drama queen, Winifred the gorgeous actress, Jane the feminist, and Peggy the smart one brought a TV drama like quality to this book.
Overall this book was just a drama, but so tough women's issues like abortion, rape, and suicide were touched on.
Even though I enjoyed the drama, I just wanted more substance from the plot. If you like TV dramas or sitcoms this book is for you.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me a copy of this ARC for my honest review.
This book is definitely a girls club (bridge style) that is full of drama. It follows 4 different women that all fit into classic personalities. Dottie the drama queen, Winifred the gorgeous actress, Jane the feminist, and Peggy the smart one brought a TV drama like quality to this book.
Overall this book was just a drama, but so tough women's issues like abortion, rape, and suicide were touched on.
Even though I enjoyed the drama, I just wanted more substance from the plot. If you like TV dramas or sitcoms this book is for you.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me a copy of this ARC for my honest review.
February 29, 2024
Flojillo, me esperaba mucho más, la verdad es que casi todo se centra en sus amores, pasa de puntillas por temas mucho más interesantes…
September 18, 2022
“Four things I am wiser to know: idleness, sorrow, a friend and a foe.” -Dorothy Parker
The Manhattan Girls by Gill Paul is based on four well known women of 1920’s New York City; Dorothy Parker, a member of the Algonquin Round Table, a poet and writer known for her sharp wit; Jane Grant, reporter and cofounder of the The New Yorker magazine; broadway actress Winifred Lenihan; and novelist Peggy Leech; and tells the story of the friendship that sustained them during a particular period of their lives.
When the men of the Algonquin Round Table decide to form a Saturday night poker club, Jane Grant suggests some of the women instead meet for Bridge, inviting Dottie, Peggy and Winnie to join her. The game, hosted round robin style, quickly becomes a lifeline for the four women as they exchange confidences, hopes, failures and hardships, and provide each other with encouragement and support when it’s needed.
From what I’m able to tell, Paul draws heavily on public records and other factual sources that inform the characters personality’s and events in the novel. While the line between fact and fiction is blurred, Gill’s portrayal of these women, and their relationships, feels genuine.
Though this is very much a character driven novel as the friends face challenges in their personal and professional lives, Gill touches on several serious issues that affect the women, including sexism, self-harm, domestic violence, sexual assault, abortion, gambling, and alcoholism.
Gill ably conveys the spirit of the Roaring Twenties in New York City, capturing the hedonism among the ‘arts’ crowd, epitomised by the notorious members of the Algonquin Round Table, and the changes in society brought about by the end of WWI, the introduction of Prohibition, and the increasing opportunities for women.
Well-written, I enjoyed The Manhattan Girls as a story that explores friendship, loyalty and ambition, and as a glimpse into the private lives of four women whose influence on the arts lingers a century later.
The Manhattan Girls by Gill Paul is based on four well known women of 1920’s New York City; Dorothy Parker, a member of the Algonquin Round Table, a poet and writer known for her sharp wit; Jane Grant, reporter and cofounder of the The New Yorker magazine; broadway actress Winifred Lenihan; and novelist Peggy Leech; and tells the story of the friendship that sustained them during a particular period of their lives.
When the men of the Algonquin Round Table decide to form a Saturday night poker club, Jane Grant suggests some of the women instead meet for Bridge, inviting Dottie, Peggy and Winnie to join her. The game, hosted round robin style, quickly becomes a lifeline for the four women as they exchange confidences, hopes, failures and hardships, and provide each other with encouragement and support when it’s needed.
From what I’m able to tell, Paul draws heavily on public records and other factual sources that inform the characters personality’s and events in the novel. While the line between fact and fiction is blurred, Gill’s portrayal of these women, and their relationships, feels genuine.
Though this is very much a character driven novel as the friends face challenges in their personal and professional lives, Gill touches on several serious issues that affect the women, including sexism, self-harm, domestic violence, sexual assault, abortion, gambling, and alcoholism.
Gill ably conveys the spirit of the Roaring Twenties in New York City, capturing the hedonism among the ‘arts’ crowd, epitomised by the notorious members of the Algonquin Round Table, and the changes in society brought about by the end of WWI, the introduction of Prohibition, and the increasing opportunities for women.
Well-written, I enjoyed The Manhattan Girls as a story that explores friendship, loyalty and ambition, and as a glimpse into the private lives of four women whose influence on the arts lingers a century later.
October 6, 2023
“Las chicas de Manhattan” ha sido una auténtica delicia y, al terminarlo, tuve la sensación de que con mucho gusto hubiese seguido leyendo acerca de las vidas de estas fantásticas mujeres. Ofrece la posibilidad de echar la vista atrás al Manhattan de los años 20 a través de los ojos de cuatro mujeres muy diferentes entre sí, pero que entablarán una profunda amistad que les ayudará a hacer frente a las adversidades.
La historia relata las vidas de Dorothy “Dottie” Parker y tres de sus amigas, pertenecientes todas ellas a la famosa Mesa Redonda del Algonquin, una tertulia formada por periodistas, críticos, escritores y personajes relacionados con el mundo del espectáculo en Broadway, que se reunían en el famoso hotel. Conoceremos a Jane Grant, primera mujer reportera de The New York Times, y decidida a lanzar una nueva revista junto a su marido Harold; Peggy Leech, asistente en una revista durante el día y novelista que sueña con publicar su primera novela; Winifred Lenihan, una bella y talentosa actriz de teatro que deberá hacer frente a las insinuaciones y abusos de un difícil mundo, mucho antes de la era del #metoo; y, por supuesto, Dottie Parker, poetisa, escritora y crítica teatral, famosa por su ingenio y su lengua afilada. Las cuatro deciden formar un club de bridge que servirá de excusa para reunirse y cotillear, servir de consuelo las unas a las otras o de apoyo en los malos momentos. Lo que no imagina es que su mayor desafío será salvar a Dottie de sí misma.
La autora consigue capturar a la perfección cómo era la vida en esa época, el sexismo y el machismo imperantes, los cuales contrarresta al presentar cuatro protagonistas fuertes, decididas a cambiar las cosas, pero sin miedo a mostrar sus vulnerabilidades.
Me resultó muy interesante ver algunos de los desafíos a los que debían enfrentarse las mujeres en el Nueva York de los años 20, un mundo dominado por hombres en el que ellas debían luchar con uñas y dientes para ser respetadas, haciendo auténticos malabarismos para poder conjugar sus carreras con su vida personal. Me encantó esa sororidad que se establece entre las cuatro, ese apoyo mutuo que estaba siempre ahí a pesar de sus diferencias.
Es particularmente interesante el retrato que hace de Dottie. La que aparentemente da imagen de ser la más fuerte es, en realidad, la más frágil de todas ellas, revelándose esa acidez que muestra al mundo como una coraza para evitar que le hagan daño, pues lo único que desea es ser querida.
La novela presenta un estilo narrativo sencillo y fácil de seguir. La historia fluye a la perfección y, el hecho de ir alternando capítulos entre las cuatro protagonistas, hace que la lecture resulte muy ágil, no existiendo un solo momento en que la historia se estanque. Conforme avances en la lectura tendrás la necesidad de investigar más acerca de todas ellas en Google, lo que me ayudó a conectar aún más sin cabe con todos los personajes. Es impresionante cómo, a partir de apenas un puñado de datos históricos, Gill Paul ha conseguido ficcionar sus vidas, convirtiéndolas de nuevo en personas de carne y hueso que cobran vida ante tus ojos a medida que las vas descubriendo.
Este es solo el segundo libro que leo de la autora pero, después de la experiencia tan fantástica que ha supuesto su lectura, estoy deseando ponerme al día con sus novelas anteriores.
La historia relata las vidas de Dorothy “Dottie” Parker y tres de sus amigas, pertenecientes todas ellas a la famosa Mesa Redonda del Algonquin, una tertulia formada por periodistas, críticos, escritores y personajes relacionados con el mundo del espectáculo en Broadway, que se reunían en el famoso hotel. Conoceremos a Jane Grant, primera mujer reportera de The New York Times, y decidida a lanzar una nueva revista junto a su marido Harold; Peggy Leech, asistente en una revista durante el día y novelista que sueña con publicar su primera novela; Winifred Lenihan, una bella y talentosa actriz de teatro que deberá hacer frente a las insinuaciones y abusos de un difícil mundo, mucho antes de la era del #metoo; y, por supuesto, Dottie Parker, poetisa, escritora y crítica teatral, famosa por su ingenio y su lengua afilada. Las cuatro deciden formar un club de bridge que servirá de excusa para reunirse y cotillear, servir de consuelo las unas a las otras o de apoyo en los malos momentos. Lo que no imagina es que su mayor desafío será salvar a Dottie de sí misma.
La autora consigue capturar a la perfección cómo era la vida en esa época, el sexismo y el machismo imperantes, los cuales contrarresta al presentar cuatro protagonistas fuertes, decididas a cambiar las cosas, pero sin miedo a mostrar sus vulnerabilidades.
Me resultó muy interesante ver algunos de los desafíos a los que debían enfrentarse las mujeres en el Nueva York de los años 20, un mundo dominado por hombres en el que ellas debían luchar con uñas y dientes para ser respetadas, haciendo auténticos malabarismos para poder conjugar sus carreras con su vida personal. Me encantó esa sororidad que se establece entre las cuatro, ese apoyo mutuo que estaba siempre ahí a pesar de sus diferencias.
Es particularmente interesante el retrato que hace de Dottie. La que aparentemente da imagen de ser la más fuerte es, en realidad, la más frágil de todas ellas, revelándose esa acidez que muestra al mundo como una coraza para evitar que le hagan daño, pues lo único que desea es ser querida.
La novela presenta un estilo narrativo sencillo y fácil de seguir. La historia fluye a la perfección y, el hecho de ir alternando capítulos entre las cuatro protagonistas, hace que la lecture resulte muy ágil, no existiendo un solo momento en que la historia se estanque. Conforme avances en la lectura tendrás la necesidad de investigar más acerca de todas ellas en Google, lo que me ayudó a conectar aún más sin cabe con todos los personajes. Es impresionante cómo, a partir de apenas un puñado de datos históricos, Gill Paul ha conseguido ficcionar sus vidas, convirtiéndolas de nuevo en personas de carne y hueso que cobran vida ante tus ojos a medida que las vas descubriendo.
Este es solo el segundo libro que leo de la autora pero, después de la experiencia tan fantástica que ha supuesto su lectura, estoy deseando ponerme al día con sus novelas anteriores.
October 13, 2023
"Algunos hombres se sienten muy ineptos cuando están con mujeres inteligentes"
Una novela brillante y ambiciosa que muestra las vivencias de cuatro mujeres viviendo en Manhattan en los años 20.
Con su gran potencial desafiaban las leyes en un mundo dominado por hombres.
Estas 4 mujeres forjaron un vínculo de amistad a trav��s de la decisión de organizar su propio club de bridge para aprender el juego y sentirse acompañadas en sus propias luchas, pudiendo así hablar abiertamente sobre sus miedos, anhelos y aspiraciones.
Conoceremos cada una de las perspectivas de las chicas a través de los caps: Jane es reportera del New York Times cuyo sueño es crear una revista, Peggy es una puritana historiadora y escritora, Winifred es actriz de Broadway y la querida Dottie es una escritora de cuentos y poesía.
Me ha parecido una novela maravillosa con una cuidada ambientación envuelta en la era del jazz, bares clandestinos y prohibiciones junto a un buen equilibrio entre la melancolía y momentos muy divertidos junto a diálogos mordaces.
Muestra un retrato vívido de los desafíos de las chicas por forjarse una carrera e intentar conseguir una relación de respeto mutuo con la Ley Seca como telón de fondo.
El prólogo es minucioso con datos de rigor histórico junto al reparto de los personajes, ya que estas mujeres existieron en la vida real y la autora mediante una exhaustiva búsqueda de información noveló ciertas partes de la novela.
"Las mujeres y los elefantes 🐘 nunca olvidan"
Una novela brillante y ambiciosa que muestra las vivencias de cuatro mujeres viviendo en Manhattan en los años 20.
Con su gran potencial desafiaban las leyes en un mundo dominado por hombres.
Estas 4 mujeres forjaron un vínculo de amistad a trav��s de la decisión de organizar su propio club de bridge para aprender el juego y sentirse acompañadas en sus propias luchas, pudiendo así hablar abiertamente sobre sus miedos, anhelos y aspiraciones.
Conoceremos cada una de las perspectivas de las chicas a través de los caps: Jane es reportera del New York Times cuyo sueño es crear una revista, Peggy es una puritana historiadora y escritora, Winifred es actriz de Broadway y la querida Dottie es una escritora de cuentos y poesía.
Me ha parecido una novela maravillosa con una cuidada ambientación envuelta en la era del jazz, bares clandestinos y prohibiciones junto a un buen equilibrio entre la melancolía y momentos muy divertidos junto a diálogos mordaces.
Muestra un retrato vívido de los desafíos de las chicas por forjarse una carrera e intentar conseguir una relación de respeto mutuo con la Ley Seca como telón de fondo.
El prólogo es minucioso con datos de rigor histórico junto al reparto de los personajes, ya que estas mujeres existieron en la vida real y la autora mediante una exhaustiva búsqueda de información noveló ciertas partes de la novela.
"Las mujeres y los elefantes 🐘 nunca olvidan"
August 30, 2022
I've been a fan of Gill Paul's books for a few years now, and I honestly think that her books get better and better. I love the fact that she takes well-known women from history and creates fictional stories around them. It is clever and entertaining and in The Manhattan Girls we are introduced to four amazing, colourful and fascinating women, headed up by the witty and acid-tongued Dorothy Parker.
I adore the 1920s setting, it's my favourite era in historical fiction, along with the 1960s, probably because although they are forty years apart, they were so similar. Women were beginning to think for themselves, to go out and enjoy themselves, to drink and to have affairs, they certainly were swinging times.
Gill Paul excels in her descriptive writing, with the fashions of the time so brilliantly explored, along with the glamour of the hotel settings, the speakeasys and the general air of hard work and very hard play.
The story centres around a Bridge club started by the four lead characters; Jane Grant, a New York Times reporter who has dreams of starting her own magazine, Winifred Lenihan, Irish immigrant and now an upcoming Broadway star, Peggy Leech; novelist in waiting and of course, Dorothy Parker, best known for her witty poetry and short stories. Four very different women, all at varying times in their lives, careers and relationships but all brought together by their love of gossip, illicit gin and a game of cards.
The Manhattan Girls is glorious, I lapped it up in almost one sitting. Totally losing myself in the Jazz Age and the unfolding dramas of each of the women. It's wonderfully researched, making reference to names that remain well known, and not always for the best reasons. Gill Paul excels in bringing her characters to life, as we follow them through joyous times and also their most desperate moments.
A wonderful read, it is fascinating, glitzy, heartbreaking and utterly entertaining. Highly recommended.
I adore the 1920s setting, it's my favourite era in historical fiction, along with the 1960s, probably because although they are forty years apart, they were so similar. Women were beginning to think for themselves, to go out and enjoy themselves, to drink and to have affairs, they certainly were swinging times.
Gill Paul excels in her descriptive writing, with the fashions of the time so brilliantly explored, along with the glamour of the hotel settings, the speakeasys and the general air of hard work and very hard play.
The story centres around a Bridge club started by the four lead characters; Jane Grant, a New York Times reporter who has dreams of starting her own magazine, Winifred Lenihan, Irish immigrant and now an upcoming Broadway star, Peggy Leech; novelist in waiting and of course, Dorothy Parker, best known for her witty poetry and short stories. Four very different women, all at varying times in their lives, careers and relationships but all brought together by their love of gossip, illicit gin and a game of cards.
The Manhattan Girls is glorious, I lapped it up in almost one sitting. Totally losing myself in the Jazz Age and the unfolding dramas of each of the women. It's wonderfully researched, making reference to names that remain well known, and not always for the best reasons. Gill Paul excels in bringing her characters to life, as we follow them through joyous times and also their most desperate moments.
A wonderful read, it is fascinating, glitzy, heartbreaking and utterly entertaining. Highly recommended.
July 16, 2022
Gill Paul does, in this book, what she does best - immerse readers in the setting. She takes readers back to 1920s New York city and introduces us to 4 women, Dorothy Parker, Peggy Leech, Jane Grant and Winifred Lenihan, who become fast friends - The Manhattan Girls. These career women have little in common, yet become a great support system for each other in a male dominated world. Stepping back in time, Paul meticulously recreates the backdrop of the ‘Lost Generation’ - a generation who’d lost the values of their past and were at a pivotal time and place, questioning mortality, defying social norms, and learning to live in the moment.
Paul masterfully offers 4 different points of view. It was a big step, and was, for the most part, successful. I did struggle with connecting to these women and wondered if it was because I didn’t ‘walk’ far enough in their shoes as I was taking them off to exchange them for another ‘pair’ just as I was getting comfortable with them.
Regardless, I enjoyed learning about the Algonquin Round Table and came to the conclusion that a century later, we’re still the same; climbing the corporate ladder, struggling to be noticed and appreciated, sacrificing way too much to get ahead, and throwing our arms up at the never ending battle.
I’ll be honest and admit that I had no idea about who these women were or their significance prior to reading this book. What I do love about Gil Paul’s approach to writing is that she gives readers enough to whet their appetite, but still leads us to the computer to research some more. What happened to these women? What legacy did they leave? A sign of a good historical fiction book is one that leaves me fulfilled but still drives me to find out more. Paul delivered. As I knew she would.
I was gifted this advance copy by Gill Paul, Avon Books UK, and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Paul masterfully offers 4 different points of view. It was a big step, and was, for the most part, successful. I did struggle with connecting to these women and wondered if it was because I didn’t ‘walk’ far enough in their shoes as I was taking them off to exchange them for another ‘pair’ just as I was getting comfortable with them.
Regardless, I enjoyed learning about the Algonquin Round Table and came to the conclusion that a century later, we’re still the same; climbing the corporate ladder, struggling to be noticed and appreciated, sacrificing way too much to get ahead, and throwing our arms up at the never ending battle.
I’ll be honest and admit that I had no idea about who these women were or their significance prior to reading this book. What I do love about Gil Paul’s approach to writing is that she gives readers enough to whet their appetite, but still leads us to the computer to research some more. What happened to these women? What legacy did they leave? A sign of a good historical fiction book is one that leaves me fulfilled but still drives me to find out more. Paul delivered. As I knew she would.
I was gifted this advance copy by Gill Paul, Avon Books UK, and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
August 28, 2022
3.5 stars. I usually love Gill Paul's historical fiction but this one fell flat. I think it tried to do too much. All 4 of these women are icons in their own right so trying to fit all of their stories into one book just scratched the surface. I understand from the historical note that there was really only a lot of information on Dottie and she had to embellish the other stories. The book didn't read like that though and I found myself distracted at times and wanting more information about other characters. It didn't hole my attention although this is a fascinating time period.
April 12, 2023
What do all these things have in common?
They are all works of women who participated in the Algonquin "Round Table" back in the '20s when booze was prohibited and gangsters were recognized on the street of Manhattan. I didn't really know anything about any of the women profiled here--Dorothy Parker, wit and poet, Jane Grant NYTimes reporter and co-founded of The New Yorker, Winifred Lenihan, Broadway actress voted in McCalls as one the most beautiful women in the world and Margaret Leech, winner of not one but two Pulitzer prizes (and married a Pulitzer!).
So, I realized that Dottie was a real piece of work and I don't think we would have been friends at all. The other women were so striven and ambitious they really didn't have time for friends, much less hob-nobbing at the club. I can't say I was impressed by any of the men at the Algonquin ("Gonk") even though they included playwrights, critics and writers. They talked the talk but didn't walk the walk. Other women were Edna Ferber (who wrote ShowBoat) and Helen Hayes.
Even though the book is over 400 pages, it read quickly and I never had a problem remembering who was who. (And there's a helpful list of characters at the front.) So much research had to have gone in this, from playing bridge to codewords for booze all within the real framework of the women featured.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
They are all works of women who participated in the Algonquin "Round Table" back in the '20s when booze was prohibited and gangsters were recognized on the street of Manhattan. I didn't really know anything about any of the women profiled here--Dorothy Parker, wit and poet, Jane Grant NYTimes reporter and co-founded of The New Yorker, Winifred Lenihan, Broadway actress voted in McCalls as one the most beautiful women in the world and Margaret Leech, winner of not one but two Pulitzer prizes (and married a Pulitzer!).
So, I realized that Dottie was a real piece of work and I don't think we would have been friends at all. The other women were so striven and ambitious they really didn't have time for friends, much less hob-nobbing at the club. I can't say I was impressed by any of the men at the Algonquin ("Gonk") even though they included playwrights, critics and writers. They talked the talk but didn't walk the walk. Other women were Edna Ferber (who wrote ShowBoat) and Helen Hayes.
Even though the book is over 400 pages, it read quickly and I never had a problem remembering who was who. (And there's a helpful list of characters at the front.) So much research had to have gone in this, from playing bridge to codewords for booze all within the real framework of the women featured.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
August 15, 2022
Discover the locations in The Manhattan Girls
A novel to transport you deep in the heart of Dorothy Parker’s circle
What a wonderfully fresh and fascinating novel! Oh this isn’t your usual novel, it’s a visit with four new friends, drinkingcocktails, plyaing cards, eating good food, hooking up with dubious men and just loving life!
I was immediately thrust into bustling and glamourous New York. With a cocktail in my hand and my flapper dress blowing in the wind, I ran from one speakeasy to the next before finding my way back to the Alconquin Club to play cards with four new friends. One of these friends is Dorothy Parker – a poet and wit. I knew nothing about this woman to be honest but I feel I really got to know her during this novel. I was there sitting beside her playing cards, laughing at her jokes, hugging her friends and I had a great time!
The Manhattan Girls of the title are Dorothy, Jane, Winifred and Peggy. Jane is the first female reporter for the New York Times, Winifred is an actress and Peggy is an assistant at a magazine. Quite an unikely bunch you might think, but what fun getting to know them! This is the kind of group you really want as friends. Different, but always there for you. They always have your back even if you share different opinions or even morals. What happens in these meetings, stays in these meetings – it’s a bit like Fight Club but with glitz and glamour of the 1920s.
As well as a really good time with some very iconic women, this was a spotlight on the life and times of women in 1920s New York. Whatever your status or wealth, women at this time had struggles. They fought for equality at work and, indeed at home.
What I love about Gill Paul, is the way she takes a real event or person from history and then gives them a voice. Some of this might be imagined but it’s as if she went back in time and sat with Dorothy Parker and had her whisper in her ear. It’s evocative, fresh and fun. A rolicking good read and I need to see this on the big screen!
August 2, 2022
Ah, the roaring twenties (she says with a transcontinental accent). Art deco fabulousness. Beauty and opulence shimmer in my mind from the very beginning. Truly a decadent read, book friends. From the cadence - to the decision to add watermark art at the beginning of each chapter, The Manhattan Girls gives us everything a book romantic needs and wants in a tome centered around the 1920's. My mind's eye shimmers in black and white becoming technicolor with the words created by Gill Paul. Simply wonderful!
~Tanja
*Thank you to William Morrow and Harper Collins for sharing this title with me.
Follow me on
Instagram✿Twitter✿Facebook✿Pinterest✿TikTok
~Tanja
*Thank you to William Morrow and Harper Collins for sharing this title with me.
Follow me on
Instagram✿Twitter✿Facebook✿Pinterest✿TikTok
July 21, 2022
Thank you goodreads & the publishing company for my advanced reader's copy in exchange for an honest review.
It's 1921 & four friends in New York bond through bridge and frequenting the Algonquin Round Table.
Jane & her husband have dreams of having their own magazine. Margaret "Peggy" Leech wants to be an author & wants to find love & marriage. Winifred Lenihan is a Broadway actress who is modest & doesn't really talk much about herself or her past. Dorothy "Dottie" Parker is a writer who is known for being witty & sometimes careless with her choice of words. All friends have goals & are supportive of each other; often out to rescue Dottie from crisis. The story is powerful, full of booze, fun times and bad, and has humor to it. Not to mention sensitive topics of the 1920's still sensitive to the present.
The author Gill Paul is a historical fiction master. This is the 3rd book I have read of hers. I found this book entertaining & beautifully put together. It is not my favorite book she has written, (maybe I just wasn't familiar with any of the characters in real life. When I think of the 1920's I think of F. Scott Fitzgerald), but I did enjoy this one & can't wait to read all of her books. Once again, I'm so glad I won an advanced copy!
It's 1921 & four friends in New York bond through bridge and frequenting the Algonquin Round Table.
Jane & her husband have dreams of having their own magazine. Margaret "Peggy" Leech wants to be an author & wants to find love & marriage. Winifred Lenihan is a Broadway actress who is modest & doesn't really talk much about herself or her past. Dorothy "Dottie" Parker is a writer who is known for being witty & sometimes careless with her choice of words. All friends have goals & are supportive of each other; often out to rescue Dottie from crisis. The story is powerful, full of booze, fun times and bad, and has humor to it. Not to mention sensitive topics of the 1920's still sensitive to the present.
The author Gill Paul is a historical fiction master. This is the 3rd book I have read of hers. I found this book entertaining & beautifully put together. It is not my favorite book she has written, (maybe I just wasn't familiar with any of the characters in real life. When I think of the 1920's I think of F. Scott Fitzgerald), but I did enjoy this one & can't wait to read all of her books. Once again, I'm so glad I won an advanced copy!
November 3, 2023
Novela ambientada en la década de 1920, donde tendremos de protagonistas a cuatro mujeres, cuatro mujeres que son totalmente diferentes entre ellas y que cada una intenta triunfar en su campo en un mundo dominado por hombres.
Es un libro de personajes, donde todas las mujeres son mujeres reales, Dorothy escritora, Jane primera reportera del New York Times ( de hecho conoceremos como se formó), y sueña junto a su marido en formar su propio periódico, Winifred actriz muy famosa que desprecia a los hombres, y por ultimo a Peggy asistente de revista que no encuentra al chico perfecto debido a su inteligencia.
Como veis casi todo gira en torno al amor y encontrar un marido o mantener una relación, cada una tienen opiniones diferentes pero son firmes en la amistad que les une. Los problemas a los que se enfrentan en esa época, son perfectamente a los que se enfrentan día a día muchas mujeres de hoy.
El autor retrata muy bien la época, diría que es de lo que mas me ha gustado, ese Manhattan de los años 20 con su cultura, con los bares clandestinos, las gánsteres, el contrabando… La Quinta Avenida que todos conocemos, Central Park y Brodway…
Por último, añadir que estas cuatro mujeres fueron reales, cosa que hace que me guste un poco más la novela, es cierto que me esperaba otra cosa, y que no se centrara tanto en los problemas maritales, pero me quedo con esa amistad tan fiel entre ellas, y que incluso después de cien años la sociedad, por desgracia no ha cambiado demasiado
Es un libro de personajes, donde todas las mujeres son mujeres reales, Dorothy escritora, Jane primera reportera del New York Times ( de hecho conoceremos como se formó), y sueña junto a su marido en formar su propio periódico, Winifred actriz muy famosa que desprecia a los hombres, y por ultimo a Peggy asistente de revista que no encuentra al chico perfecto debido a su inteligencia.
Como veis casi todo gira en torno al amor y encontrar un marido o mantener una relación, cada una tienen opiniones diferentes pero son firmes en la amistad que les une. Los problemas a los que se enfrentan en esa época, son perfectamente a los que se enfrentan día a día muchas mujeres de hoy.
El autor retrata muy bien la época, diría que es de lo que mas me ha gustado, ese Manhattan de los años 20 con su cultura, con los bares clandestinos, las gánsteres, el contrabando… La Quinta Avenida que todos conocemos, Central Park y Brodway…
Por último, añadir que estas cuatro mujeres fueron reales, cosa que hace que me guste un poco más la novela, es cierto que me esperaba otra cosa, y que no se centrara tanto en los problemas maritales, pero me quedo con esa amistad tan fiel entre ellas, y que incluso después de cien años la sociedad, por desgracia no ha cambiado demasiado
August 1, 2022
I'm thankful I do not live in the 1920's, being a woman back then and our rights and how we were treated was horrible. However, I found it fascinating how these group of women kept their friendship and spirits up and creativity despite all of this.
September 24, 2022
This is the first book I've read by Gill Paul and I'm so excited to check out her other work! I absolutely loved 'The Manhattan Girls'. I've long been fascinated by the Algonquin set and Paul brings 1920s New York, and its many talented residents, to life vividly. I listened to the audiobook, which is brilliantly narrated by Lisa Flanagan. I thoroughly enjoyed the escapism, and learning more about the women who were trailblazers in a bygone era. I also particularly appreciated seeing the more vulnerable side to sassy wordsmith, Dorothy Parker. A superb read. Highly recommend!
March 6, 2024
i enjoyed every single page of this book. i love women and i love friendship and i love stories where not a single character lets me down
July 20, 2022
This book is touted as the 1920s Sex and the City and I would definitely agree! I loved everything about it, especially the friendship between Dottie, Jane, Winifred , and Peggy. If you like a bit of history with your glitz and glamour, you’ll love this one.
January 1, 2023
Honestly so boring and the only reason I finished it was to get my year reading challenge done. Just a bunch of women complaining with no suspense. Too many sub plots with lots of things that deserve a trigger warning.
September 24, 2022
Another insightful and very enjoyable historical fiction novel by this very talented author.
Having devoured Gill’s previous two books (and I very highly recommend them) I was looking forward to her take on the famous Dorothy Parker, Dottie to her friends.
The novel is set in 1920’s Manhattan, post First World War, during prohibition and at the time female actors were expected to do anything for an acting role.
We meet Dottie and her three friends Jane, Winifred and Peggy as they get together to learn to play bridge, each taking turns to host their bridge nights.
The women become close and supportive of each other, this being very obvious after one of Dottie’s suicide attempts as they joined together to visit her in the hospital.
I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know each woman, with their life’s ups and downs, their different personalities and their determination to succeed in life albeit with different life goals.
It would have been a pleasure to have joined in one of those bridge nights!
Gill is one of my auto read authors and I look forward to her next book.
Having devoured Gill’s previous two books (and I very highly recommend them) I was looking forward to her take on the famous Dorothy Parker, Dottie to her friends.
The novel is set in 1920’s Manhattan, post First World War, during prohibition and at the time female actors were expected to do anything for an acting role.
We meet Dottie and her three friends Jane, Winifred and Peggy as they get together to learn to play bridge, each taking turns to host their bridge nights.
The women become close and supportive of each other, this being very obvious after one of Dottie’s suicide attempts as they joined together to visit her in the hospital.
I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know each woman, with their life’s ups and downs, their different personalities and their determination to succeed in life albeit with different life goals.
It would have been a pleasure to have joined in one of those bridge nights!
Gill is one of my auto read authors and I look forward to her next book.
September 23, 2022
The Manhattan girls was a very good book. I really enjoyed the characters. The plot was very well done.
Read
October 30, 2022I got really absorbed in this book about the people in the literary circle in NYC based 100 years ago. Quick and fun read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews