How Green Was My Valley (film)

How Green Was My Valley
Theatrical release poster
Directed by	John Ford
Screenplay by	Philip Dunne
Based on	How Green Was My Valley 1939 novel by Richard Llewellyn
Produced by	Darryl F. Zanuck
Starring	Walter Pidgeon Maureen O'Hara Donald Crisp Anna Lee Roddy McDowall
Cinematography	Arthur C. Miller
Edited by	James B. Clark
Music by	Alfred Newman
Production company	Twentieth Century Fox
Distributed by	Twentieth Century Fox
Release date	October 28, 1941 (1941-10-28)
Running time	118 minutes
Country	United States
Languages	English Welsh
Budget	$800,000[1]
Box office	$2.4 million[2]

How Green Was My Valley is a 1941 American drama film directed by John Ford, adapted by Philip Dunne from the 1939 novel of the same title by Richard Llewellyn. It stars Walter Pidgeon, Maureen O'Hara, Anna Lee, Donald Crisp, and a young Roddy McDowall.

It tells the story of the Morgans, a hard-working Welsh mining family, from the point of view of the youngest child Huw, who lives with his affectionate and kind parents as well as his sister and five brothers, in the South Wales Valleys during the late Victorian era. The story chronicles life in the South Wales coalfields, the loss of that way of life and its effects on the family.

The fictional village in the film is based on Gilfach Goch,^[3] where Llewellyn spent many summers visiting his grandfather, and it served as the inspiration for the novel.^[3] The author had claimed that he based the book on his own personal experiences but this was found to be untrue after his death; Llewellyn was English-born and spent little time in Wales, though he was of Welsh descent.^[4] Llewellyn gathered material for the novel from conversations with local mining families in Gilfach Goch.^[4]

It was nominated for ten Academy Awards, winning five,^[5] famously beating Citizen Kane, Sergeant York and The Maltese Falcon for Best Picture, while Ford won for Best Director, Donald Crisp for Best Supporting Actor, Arthur Miller for Best Cinematography, and Richard Day, Nathan H. Juran and Thomas Little for Best Black-and-White Art Direction-Interior Decoration. In 1990, the film was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry of the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant".^[6][7] The Academy Film Archive preserved How Green Was My Valley in 1998.^[8]

The Morgans are a mining family in the South Wales Valleys during the late Victorian era. Huw, the youngest son of Gwilym Morgan, walks home with his father to meet his mother, Beth. His older brothers, Ianto, Ivor, Davy, Gwilym Jr., and Owen all work in the coal mines with their father, while sister Angharad keeps house with their mother. Huw's childhood is idyllic; the town, not yet overrun with mining spoil, is beautiful, the household is warm and loving, and the miners sing as they walk home (in this case "Cwm Rhondda"). Huw is smitten with Bronwyn, a girl engaged to be married to his eldest brother, Ivor. At the boisterous wedding party Angharad meets the new preacher, Mr. Gruffydd, and there is an obvious mutual attraction.

Trouble begins when the mine owner decreases wages, and the miners strike in protest. Gwilym's attempt to mediate by not endorsing a strike estranges him from the other miners as well as his older sons, who leave home. Beth interrupts a late night meeting of the strikers, threatening to kill anyone who harms her husband. She and Huw head across the fields in a snowstorm in the dark to return home. On their way home the strikers hear Huw calling for help. They rescue Beth and Huw from the river. Beth has temporarily lost the use of her legs and the doctor fears that Huw, who has also lost the use of his legs, will never walk again. He eventually recovers with the help of Mr. Gruffydd, which further endears the latter to Angharad.

The strike is eventually settled, and Gwilym and his sons reconcile, yet many miners have lost their jobs. The exceptionally beautiful Angharad is courted by the mine owner's son, Iestyn Evans (Marten Lamont), though she loves Mr. Gruffydd. Mr. Gruffydd loves her too, to the malicious delight of the gossipy townswomen, but cannot bear to subject her to the hard, spartan life of an impoverished minister of religion. Angharad submits to a loveless marriage to Evans, and they relocate out of the country.

Huw begins school at a nearby village. Abused by other boys, he is taught to fight by boxer Dai Bando and his crony, Cyfartha. After a beating by the cruel teacher Mr. Jonas, Dai Bando avenges Huw with an impromptu boxing display on Mr. Jonas to the delight of his pupils.

Bronwyn learns Ivor has been killed in a mine accident. The shock causes her to go into labor and she gives birth to a son. Later, two of Morgan's sons are dismissed in favor of less experienced, cheaper laborers. With no job prospects, they leave to seek their fortunes abroad. Huw is awarded a scholarship to university, but to his father's dismay he refuses it to work in the mines. He relocates with Bronwyn, to help provide for her and her child.

When Angharad returns without her husband, vicious gossip of an impending divorce spreads through the town. It is eventually announced there will be a meeting of the Deacons - the governing council of the local Calvinistic Methodist chapel - to discuss, denounce and excommunicate Angharad. This prospect enrages Mr. Gruffydd, for he knows she has done nothing other than return home from Cape Town without her husband. After condemning the Deacon's small-mindedness, he storms out before the meeting intent on leaving the town.

That evening, the alarm whistle sounds, signaling another mine disaster. Several men are injured, and Gwilym and others are trapped in a cave-in. Mr Gruffydd catches sight of Angharad, who has rushed to the mine for word of her father. As she looks pleadingly at him, he calls, "Who is for Gwilym Morgan and the others?" Young Huw, Mr. Gruffydd, and Dai Bando descend with other volunteers to rescue the remaining miners. Gwilym and his son are briefly re-united before he succumbs to his injuries.

Above, in the cold of light dawn, the women of the family - Angharad, Bronwyn and Beth Morgan - have stood vigil all night; the sound of the pulley announces the lift is returning from the depths of the mine. Huw is cradling his father's body, his coal-blackened face devoid of youthful innocence.

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

The script was written by Philip Dunne. He later recalled reading the original novel "in horror, turgid stuff, long speeches about Welsh coal miners on strike."^[9]

William Wyler, the original director, saw the screen test of McDowall and chose him for the part. Wyler was replaced by John Ford. Fox wanted to shoot the movie in Wales in Technicolor, but it was impossible to do so during World War II. Instead, Ford had the studio build an 80-acre authentic replica of a Welsh mining town at Brent's Crags^[10] (subsequently Crags Country Club) in the Santa Monica Mountains near Malibu, California.^[11]

John Ford originally hired Rhys Williams, the film's Welsh dialect coach, to record the film’s narration as Older Huw. Shortly before release, he had the narration re-dubbed by Irving Pichel, afraid that audiences might recognize Williams’ voice from his onscreen role as Dai Bando and be confused.^[12] Williams’ narration was still used in some prints of the film, including the original British release, and he’s credited as such on some secondary sources.^[10]

On review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, How Green Was My Valley held, as of August 2023^[update], an approval rating of 93% based on 87 reviews, with an average rating of 7.9/10. The site's critics consensus reads: "Nostalgic without becoming maudlin, this working-class drama is enlivened by a terrific cast and John Ford's ineffable directorial eye."^[13] On Metacritic, the film holds a weighted average score of 88 out of 100 based on 17 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".^[14] Tim Dirks of Filmsite lauded the film as "one of John Ford's masterpieces of sentimental human drama."^[15]

While the opinion among the Academy Awards committee that it was 1941's Best Picture has been disputed by some later critics,^[16][17] How Green Was My Valley continues to be well received in its own right and, in 1990, was added to the American National Film Registry. Academy Award-winning actor and director Clint Eastwood named it as one of his favorite movies.^[18] The film has been criticized in the UK for the actors' poor accents.^{[19][20][21][22]}

Award	Category	Nominee	Result
Academy Awards[23]	Outstanding Motion Picture	Darryl F. Zanuck	Won
	Best Director	John Ford	Won
	Best Supporting Actor	Donald Crisp	Won
	Best Supporting Actress	Sara Allgood	Nominated
	Best Screenplay	Philip Dunne	Nominated
	Best Art Direction-Interior Decoration – Black-and-White	Richard Day, Nathan H. Juran and Thomas Little	Won
	Best Cinematography – Black-and-White	Arthur Miller	Won
	Best Film Editing	James B. Clark	Nominated
	Best Scoring of a Dramatic Picture	Alfred Newman	Nominated
	Best Sound Recording	Edmund H. Hansen	Nominated
Argentine Film Critics Association Awards[24]	Best Foreign Film	John Ford	Won
National Film Preservation Board	National Film Registry		Inducted
New York Film Critics Circle Awards[12]	Best Director	John Ford	Won

• AFI's 100 Years...100 Movies - Nominated^[25]
• AFI's 100 Years...100 Movie Quotes:
  • "Men like my father cannot die. They are with me still -- real in memory as they were in flesh, loving and beloved forever. How green was my valley then." - Nominated^[26]
• AFI's 100 Years of Film Scores - Nominated^[27]
• AFI's 100 Years...100 Movies (10th Anniversary Edition) - Nominated^[28]

How Green Was My Valley was adapted as a half-hour radio play on the March 22, 1942, broadcast of The Screen Guild Theater, with Sara Allgood, Donald Crisp, Roddy McDowall, Maureen O'Hara and Walter Pidgeon.^[29][30]

It was also adapted for three one-hour broadcasts of the Lux Radio Theatre: on September 21, 1942, with Allgood, Crisp, O'Hara, McDowall and Pidgeon;^[31] on March 31, 1947, with Crisp and David Niven;^[32] and on September 28, 1954, with Crisp and Donna Reed.^[33]

• How Green Was My Valley (novel)
• The Proud Valley
• The Stars Look Down
• 1926 United Kingdom general strike
• English-language accents in film – Welsh
• How Black was My Valley (novel)

Footnotes

Citations

• How Green Was My Valley at IMDb 
• How Green Was My Valley at the TCM Movie Database
• How Green Was My Valley at AllMovie
• How Green Was My Valley at the AFI Catalog of Feature Films
• How Green Was My Valley at Rotten Tomatoes
• How Green Was My Valley at Reel Classics
• How Green Was My Valley at Film Site web site; contains plot detail.
• Eagan, Daniel (2009). "How Green Was My Valley". America's Film Legacy: The Authoritative Guide to the Landmark Movies in the National Film Registry. New York: Continuum. pp. 339–341. ISBN 978-1-4411-1647-5. OCLC 676697377.