Player
Medals
Seasons
John Nicholls
5
1959, 1963, 1965, 1966, 1967
Patrick Cripps ^
5
2015, 2018, 2019, 2022, 2024
Bruce Doull
4
1974, 1977, 1980, 1984
Craig Bradley
3
1986, 1988, 1993
John James
3
1955, 1960, 1961
Chris Judd
3
2008, 2009, 2010
Stephen Kernahan
3
1987, 1989, 1992
Brett Ratten
3
1995, 1997, 2000
Bob Chitty
2
1941, 1944
Bruce Comben
2
1957, 1958
Mickey Crisp
2
1934, 1938
Jim Francis
2
1935, 1940
Ern Henfry
2
1947, 1949
Jack Howell
2
1946, 1948
Wayne Johnston
2
1983, 1986
Trevor Keogh
2
1976, 1978
Anthony Koutoufides
2
2001, 2005
Justin Madden
2
1985, 1991
Marc Murphy
2
2011, 2017
Sergio Silvagni
2
1962, 1968
Stephen Silvagni
2
1990, 1996
Geoff Southby
2
1971, 1972
Jacob Weitering ^
2
2020, 2023
General
Specific
^ "AFL Best and Fairest winners 2017: Who won your team's club champion award?" . Fox Sports Australia . News Corp Australia. 3 September 2017. Retrieved 3 September 2017 .
^ "Koutoufides named Blues' best" . ABC Online . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 9 September 2005. Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ "Whitnall named best Blue" . ABC Online . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 9 September 2006. Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Phelan, Jason (11 September 2008). "Judd is Blues' B&F" . AFL.com.au . Bigpond . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Boulton, Martin (29 September 2009). "Judd best of the Blues" . The Age . Fairfax Media . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Cullen, Mic (28 September 2010). "Judd wins Carlton's B&F again" . AFL.com.au . Bigpond . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Edmund, Sam (5 October 2011). "Marc Murphy beats Chris Judd to Carlton's best and fairest" . Herald Sun . News Corp Australia . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Collins, Ben (2 October 2012). "Scotland the top Blue" . AFL.com.au . Bigpond . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Edmund, Sam (1 October 2013). "Kade Simpson caps a career year by winning his first Jon Nicholls Medal" . AFL.com.au . Bigpond . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Edmund, Sam (17 September 2014). "Bryce Gibbs nets Carlton best and fairest after outstanding season ahead of Marc Murphy" . Herald Sun . News Corp Australia . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Pierik, Jon (17 September 2015). "Patrick Cripps wins Carlton best and fairest" . The Age . Fairfax Media . Retrieved 8 August 2016 .
^ Pierik, Jon (9 September 2016). "Carlton's Sam Docherty claims maiden John Nicholls Medal" . The Age . Fairfax Media . Retrieved 10 September 2016 .
^ McGowan, Marc (22 September 2017). "Skipper recognised as best of the Blues" . AFL.com.au . Bigpond. Retrieved 22 September 2017 .
^ Beveridge, Riley (5 October 2018). "Cripps a runaway winner of Blues' B&F" . AFL.com.au . Telstra. Retrieved 5 October 2018 .
^ Beveridge, Riley (4 October 2019). "Superstar Blue joins club greats with third B&F in thrilling count" . AFL.com.au . Telstra. Retrieved 4 October 2019 .
^ Beveridge, Riley (19 February 2021). "No.1s quinella Blues' B&F count, top five surprises" . AFL.com.au . Retrieved 19 February 2021 .
^ Beveridge, Riley (14 October 2021). "Blues jet pips defending champion to win first John Nicholls Medal" . AFL.com.au . Retrieved 14 October 2021 .
^ Media, Carlton (30 September 2022). "Four-time Cripps reaches new chapter of Carlton history" . Carltonfc.com.au . Carlton. Retrieved 30 September 2022 .