liv ❁'s Reviews > She Had Some Horses: Poems

She Had Some Horses by Joy Harjo
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
44731563
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: bipoc, collection, indigenous, blown-away, poetry, favorites

This is some of the first poetry I’ve sat down and read in my life and now I’m mourning the time lost with years of my life filled with a weird aversion to poetry because this is one of the best things I have ever read. Harjo has such an incredible way of using words to convey such strong emotions. I picked this up on a whim today and sat, reading it aloud to myself, until I finished it. There were multiple times where I had to stop because I was so amazed that I couldn’t find the words to keep reading for a moment. The introduction on Harjo’s connection to horses was such a beautiful way to start this collection as well.

I’m not too well-versed (ha ha) in writing reviews for poetry yet, so I’ll let the collection speak for itself through some of my favorites; maybe after poetry summer I’ll be able to convey my awe with proper words.

Vision
The rainbow touched down
“somewhere in the Rio Grande,”
we said. And saw the light of it
from your mother’s house in Isleta.
How it curved down between earth
and the deepest sky to give us horses
of color
horses that were within us all of this time
but we didn’t see them because
we wait for the easiest vision
to save us.
In Isleta the rainbow was a crack
in the universe. We saw the barest
of all life that is possible.
Bright horses rolled over
and over the dusking sky.
I heard the thunder of their beating
hearts. Their lungs hit air
and sang. All the colors of horses
formed the rainbow,
and formed us
watching them.



She Remembers The Future
“We are closer than
blood,” Noni Daylight
tells her. “It isn’t
Oklahoma or the tribal
blood but something more
that we speak.”

(The otherself knows
and whispers
to herself.)

The air could choke, could
Kill, the way it tempts
Noni to violence, this
morning. But she needs
the feel of danger,
for life.

She feels the sky
tethered to the changing
earth, and her skin
responds, like a woman
to her lover.
It could be days, it could
be years, White Sands
or Tuscon.
She asks,
“Should I dream you afraid
so that you are forced to save
yourself?”

Or should you ride colored horses
into the cutting edge of the sky
to know

that we’re alive
we are alive.”



II. Two Horses

I thought the sun breaking through Sangre de Cristo
Mountains was enough, and that
wild musky scents on my body after
long nights of dreaming could
unfold me to myself.
I thought my dance alone through worlds of
odd and eccentric planets that no one else knew
would sustain me. I mean
I did learn to move
after all.
and how to recognize voices other than the most familiar.
But you must have grown out of
a thousand years dreaming
just like I could never imagine you.
You must have
Broke open from another sky
to here, because
now I see you as a part of the millions of
other universes that I thought could never occur
in this breathing.
And I know you as myself, traveling.
In your eyes alone are many colonies of stars
and other circling planet motion.
And then your fingers, the sweet smell
of hair, and
your soft, tight belly.
My heart is taken by you
and these mornings since I am a horse running towards
a cracked sky where there are countless dawns
breaking simultaneously.
There are two moons on the horizon
and for you
I have broken loose.



4.5/5
36 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read She Had Some Horses.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 5, 2024 – Started Reading
May 5, 2024 – Shelved
May 5, 2024 – Shelved as: bipoc
May 5, 2024 – Shelved as: collection
May 5, 2024 – Shelved as: indigenous
May 5, 2024 – Shelved as: blown-away
May 5, 2024 – Shelved as: poetry
May 5, 2024 – Finished Reading
June 7, 2024 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ i also have an aversion to poetry and never know if it’s just me or what because it sounds beautiful but i cannot appreciate it like i should


liv ❁ len ❀ wrote: "i also have an aversion to poetry and never know if it’s just me or what because it sounds beautiful but i cannot appreciate it like i should"

OKAY I honestly think part of it for me was that my brain reads so fast that it's hard for me to fully digest something so short, but reading it aloud was incredibly helpful and life-changing for me? I don't know. I also feel like sometimes it's hard to know if poetry is going to be really good or like... the instagram poetry vibes. I picked this one first because she was the Poet Laureate so I was like... this has to be good, right? And it was! But I was really scared I wouldn't enjoy it. Hahah I have a lot of thoughts about this.


message 3: by s.penkevich (last edited May 05, 2024 05:01PM) (new)

s.penkevich Yessssssssssss! Ahhh I’m so glad Harjo was your introduction into poetry and that you loved this so much. Great selections too! Wait, definitely check out her jazz band if you can too, she plays sax and recites her poems over the music it’s kind of rad
youtu [dot] be/NCBGQ85gIKs?si=7JxyhMl1qH5hkRdy

And wonderful review too! Ha I have no idea how to review poetry either, it’s such a tricky format to like…review especially when the words of the poem already says the ideas the best way possible. There’s a Charles Simic line that haunts me whenever I try to review—“everyone wants to explain the poem except the poet. The poem has already done it.”


liv ❁ s.penkevich wrote: "Yessssssssssss! Ahhh I’m so glad Harjo was your introduction into poetry and that you loved this so much. Great selections too! Wait, definitely check out her jazz band if you can too, she plays sa..."

Yes!! Me too, she's so good! I ended up grabbing this because I had a vague memory of our Poet Laureate convo haha, so thank you! Okay yeah that's so rad, I love it.

And thank you! Yeah it's so hard because I feel like there's so much of an emotional response to it? Also it feels weird to get up here and try to explain poetry haha. What am I supposed to say? That it was really moving and cool? I guess that is what I said. Ohhh that's a great quote! In her introduction, Harjo also mentioned how personal reading poetry is.


message 5: by cameron (new) - added it

cameron I also found myself disliking poetry because it gave me second hand embarrassment for some reason. but i really enjoyed some of Richard Sikens works, and have picked up Robert Frost, Louise Gluck, and some others and it's enjoyable! it really makes me feel something and think.


message 6: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich liv ❁ wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Yessssssssssss! Ahhh I’m so glad Harjo was your introduction into poetry and that you loved this so much. Great selections too! Wait, definitely check out her jazz band if you c..."

Hahah true its like uhhhh this line made me like things this poems are about...living I guess? Ooo yea, definitely such a uniquely personal experience. There was...I want to say its in Ben Lerner's The Hatred of Poetry but this whole discussion on how poetry works best when it feels very personal but also universal at the same time.

Glad you loved this!


liv ❁ cameron wrote: "I also found myself disliking poetry because it gave me second hand embarrassment for some reason. but i really enjoyed some of Richard Sikens works, and have picked up Robert Frost, Louise Gluck, ..."

Sorry, I somehow just saw this, but ooh I just picked up Crush, which has an introduction by Louise Gluck and that made me want to pick her up the next time I pick up some poetry! It really is hit or miss sometimes, but this one made me feel a lot.


message 8: by cameron (new) - added it

cameron Yes! i found louise gluck at b&n and really enjoy her work, and Litany in Which Certain Things Are Crossed Out has lived in my head rent free for nearly a decade. i'm glad you enjoyed it🥰


liv ❁ cameron wrote: "Yes! i found louise gluck at b&n and really enjoy her work, and Litany in Which Certain Things Are Crossed Out has lived in my head rent free for nearly a decade. i'm glad you enjoyed it🥰"

okay, yes I just finished the collection and "Litany in Which Certain Things Are Crossed Out" was incredible. My favorite from the collection, definitely a new favorite poem in general too


message 10: by cameron (new) - added it

cameron i want "you will be alone always and then you will die" tattooed on me, it's already tattooed on my brain


liv ❁ cameron wrote: "i want "you will be alone always and then you will die" tattooed on me, it's already tattooed on my brain"

that and then I dropped the book when he said "actually, you said Love, for you, is larger than the usual romantic love. It's like a religion. It's terrifying. No one will every want to sleep with you." I just want the whole poem stamped into my brain forever.


back to top