A receding parallelism: Husserl and Peirce from the perspective of logic of probability. (English) Zbl 1451.03012
Shafiei, Mohammad (ed.) et al., Peirce and Husserl: mutual insights on logic, mathematics and cognition. Cham: Springer. Log. Epistemol. Unity Sci. 46, 139-174 (2019).
Summary: The adequate point of view to evaluate if Husserl and Peirce’s philosophy are compatible or not, diverging or not, is clearly indicated by Husserl and Peirce themselves: interpreting their apparently common and opposite statements from their respective guiding principles. In order to do so, it is important, first, to list and understand their reciprocal cross-references in order to see if obvious or possible divergences do not rest on bare misunderstandings. Secondly, one should discern common theoretical issues, concepts and methods. It seems that they focus on the setting-up and reform of logic and, in close connection with it, the development of a logic of probability. Lastly those parallel projects must be related their leading principles, which are, respectively, the pragmatic maxim and the paradoxical presupposition-less principle of transcendental phenomenology.
For the entire collection see [Zbl 1429.03007].
For the entire collection see [Zbl 1429.03007].
MSC:
| 03A05 | Philosophical and critical aspects of logic and foundations |
References:
| [1] | Baldwin, J. M. (1901-1902). Dictionary of philosophy and psychology: Vol. 1 (1901), Vol. 2 (1902), Vol. 3 (1905). London, New York: Macmillan & Co. |
| [2] | Becker, O. (1930). Zur Logik der Modalitäten. In Jahrbuch für Philosophie und phänomenologische Forschung. Halle: de Husserl. Max Niemeyer Verlag. · JFM 56.0037.09 |
| [3] | Becker, O. (1952). Untersuchungen über den Modalkalkül. Meisenheim am Glan: Westkulturverlag Anton Hain. · Zbl 0046.00502 |
| [4] | Belussi, F. (1990). Modaltheoretischen Grundlagen der Husserlschen Phänomenologie. Freiburg: Alber Verlag. |
| [5] | Boole, G. (1854). The laws of thoughts. New York: Dover. |
| [6] | Boole, G. (2004). Studies in logic and probability. NY: Dover. · Zbl 0049.00802 |
| [7] | Brentano, F. (1977). Lehre vom Richtigen Urteil. Hamburg: F. Meiner. |
| [8] | Clifford, W. (1877). Ethics of belief, contemporary review. Trans. French, L’éthique de la croyance, L’immortalité de la croyance religieuse, Agone, Paris. 2018. |
| [9] | Deledalle, G. (1964). Perspectives sur la philosophie Nord-Américaine (I), Les Études philosophiques (Vol. 2, pp. 283-294). Nouvelle Série, 19e Année. (Avril-Juin P 1964). |
| [10] | Deledalle, G. (1990). Charles S. Peirce, An Intellectual Biography. Translated from French and introduced by Susan Petrilli. Amsterdam/Philadephia: John Benjamins Publishing Company. · Zbl 0732.01037 |
| [11] | Dougherty, C. J. (1980). Peirce’s phenomenological defense of deduction. The Monist,63(1980), 364-374. · doi:10.5840/monist198063322 |
| [12] | Fioretti, G. (2001). Von Kries and the other German logicians: Non-numerical probabilities before Keynes. Economics and Philosophy, 17, 245-273. · doi:10.1017/S0266267101000268 |
| [13] | Haaparanta, L. (1993). Peirce and the logic of logical discovery. In E.C. Moore (Ed.), Charles S. Peirce and the philosophy of science: Papers from the harvard sesquicentennial congress (pp. 105-118). Tuscaloosa and London: The University of Alabama Press. |
| [14] | Haaparanta, L. (1994). Intentionality, intuition and the computational theory of mind. In L. Haaparanta (Ed.), Mind, meaning and mathematics: Essays on the philosophical views of husserl and frege (pp. 211-233). Dordrecht: Kluwer. · Zbl 0921.03001 · doi:10.1007/978-94-015-8334-3_8 |
| [15] | Haaparanta, L. (2001), On Peirce’s methodology of logic and philosophy. In P. Ylikoski, & M. Kiikkeri (Eds.), Explanatory connections. Electronic essays dedicated to Matti Sintonen.http://www.valt.Helsinki.fi/kfil/matti/. |
| [16] | Halmos, P. (1956). The basic concepts of algebraic logic. American Mathematical Monthly,63, 363-387. · Zbl 0070.24506 · doi:10.1080/00029890.1956.11988821 |
| [17] | Halmos, P. R. (1962). Algebraic logic (p. 1962). NY: Chelsea. · Zbl 0101.01101 |
| [18] | Hausdorff, F. (2005). Beiträge zur Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung (1901). In J. Bemelmans, Ch. Binder, S. D. Chatterji, S. Hildebrand, W. Purkert, F. Schmeidler, & E. Scholz (Eds.), Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 5, Astronomie, Optik und Wahrscheinlichkeitstheorie. Berlin-Heidelberg: Springer. · JFM 32.0223.04 |
| [19] | Heidelberger, M. (2001). Origins of the logical theory of probability: Von Kries, Wittgenstein, Waismann. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science,15(2), 177-188. · Zbl 1027.01007 · doi:10.1080/02698590120059040 |
| [20] | Husserl, E. (1950a). In W. Biemel (Ed.), Ideen zur einer reine Phänomenologie und phänomenologische Philosophie, Husserliana, Band III/1. Den Haag: Martinus Nijhoff. |
| [21] | Husserl, E. (1950b). Die Krisis der europäischen Wissenschaften un, die transzendentale Phänomenologie, Eine Einleitung in die phanomenologische Philosophie. In W. Biemel (Ed.), Husserliana (Vol. VI). The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff. |
| [22] | Husserl, E. (1959). Erste Philosophie, 1, Husserliana (Vol. VII). La Haye: M. Nijhoff. |
| [23] | Husserl, E. (1969). Formal and Transcendental logic. English trans. Dorion Cairn, Den Haag: Martinus Nijhoff. |
| [24] | Husserl, E. (1970). The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology: An introduction to phenomenology, trans. David Carr. Evanston: Northwestern University Press. |
| [25] | Husserl, E. (1975). Prolegomena, Logische Untersuchungen, Erster Band, Husserliana (pp. 234 and 235). Band XVII, ed. Elisabeth Ströcker, M. Nijhoff. |
| [26] | Husserl, E. (1976). Ideen zu einer reinen Phänomenologie und phänomenologischen Philosophie, Erstes Burch, Allgemeine Einführung in die reine Phänomenologie. K. Schuhmann: Martinus Nijhoff. |
| [27] | Husserl, E. (1979). Aufsätze und Rezensionen, (1890-1910), Husserliana 22, 1979, B. Rang. Nijhoff: The Hagues. |
| [28] | Husserl, E. (1980). Phantasia, Erinnerung, Bildbewußtsein, Husserliana XXIII. Dordrecht: Kluwer. |
| [29] | Husserl, E. (1982). Logical investigations. Translated by J. N. Findlay from the Second German edition of, Edited by Dermot Moran, New York: Routledge. · Zbl 1073.01026 |
| [30] | Husserl, E. (1984). Logische Untersuchungen, Zweiter Band, Erster Teil, Text der 1 und der 2 Auflage, hsg. Ursula Panzer, Husserliana Band XIX/1, Martinus Nijhoff Pub., Boston: The Hague. |
| [31] | Husserl, E. (1988). Vorlesungen über Ethik und Wertlehre, 1908-1914, Ulrich Melle (Ed.), Husserliana XXVIII, Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer. |
| [32] | Husserl, E. (1993). Die Krisis der europäischen Wissenschaften un, die transzendentale Phänomenologie. In R. N. Smid (Ed.), Erganzungsband: Texte aus dem Nachlaß (pp. 1934-1937). Dordrecht: Springer. |
| [33] | Husserl, E. (1994a). Early writings in the philosophy of logic and mathematics (1859-1938). Edited by Dallas Willard. Collected works (Vol. 5). Dordrecht: Springer. |
| [34] | Husserl, E. (1994b). In E. Schuhmann & K. Schuhmann (Eds.), Briefwechsel, Die Freibürger Schüler, Husserliana Dokumente (Vol. IV). Dordrecht: Kluwer. |
| [35] | Husserl, E. (1996). Logik und allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie. Vorlesungen Wintersemester 1917/18. Mit ergänzenden Texten aus der ersten Fassung von 1910/11. Husserliana Band XXX, Hrsg. von Ursula Panzer. Berlin: Springer. |
| [36] | Husserl, E. (2003). Alte und Neue Logik, 1908/1909, Husserliana Dokumente, Materialien VI, Ed. E. Schuhmann. Berlin: Springer. |
| [37] | Husserl, E. (2005). In H. Peucker (Ed.), Einleitung in die Ethik, Husserliana (Vol. XXXVII). Dordrecht: Springer. |
| [38] | Husserl, E. (2009). Leçons sur l’éthique et la théorie de la valeur, French. Trans. P. Ducat, P. Lang, & C. Lobo. Épiméthée: P.U.F. |
| [39] | James, William, (1897) The Will to Belief, edition, Longmans, Green & Co. Trans. French, “L’éthique de la croyance”, in L’immortalité de la croyance religieuse, Agone, Paris. 2018. |
| [40] | James, W. (1907). Pragmatism: A new name for some old ways of thinking. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. |
| [41] | Jaynes, E. T. (2003). Probability theory: Logic of science. Cambridge University Press. · Zbl 1045.62001 |
| [42] | Kamlah, A. (1987). The decline of the Laplacean theory of probability: A study of Stumpf, von Kries, and Meinong. In L. Krüger, L. Daston, & M. Heidelberger (Eds.), The probabilistic revolution (Vol. 1, pp. 91-110)., Ideas in history Boston: M.I.T. Press. |
| [43] | Keynes, J. M. (1921). A treatise on Probability. Cambridge: MacMillan. · JFM 48.0615.08 |
| [44] | Lanciani, A. (2012). Analyse phénoménologique du concept de probabilité. Hermann. · Zbl 1319.60001 |
| [45] | Laplace, P.-S. (1921). Essai philosophique sur les probabilités (1814), Tome 1 & Tome 2. Paris: Gauthiers-Villars & Cie. · JFM 48.0008.05 |
| [46] | Lobo, C., Bastos, C. L., & de Carvalho Vargas, C. E. (2014). On essentialism and existentialism in the Husserlian platonism: A reflexion based on modal logic. In Collaboration with C. L. Bastos & C. E. de Carvalho Vargas from the Pontifical Catholic University of Parana, School of Education and Humanities, Brazil, in Axiomathes, Received 22 July 2014. Accepted: 29 September 2014, Science+Business Media, Springer: Dordrecht. |
| [47] | Lobo, C. (2006). L’a priori affectif (I). Prolégomènes à une phénoménologie des valeurs (pp. 35-68). Paris: Alter. |
| [48] | Lobo, C. (2008). Phénoménologie de la réduction et réduction éthique. Lectures de la Krisis, (ed F. de Gandt & C. Majolino) (pp. 123-159). Vrin. |
| [49] | Lobo, C. (2010). The Husserlian project of reform of logic and individuation. In Proceedings of the 41st Annual Husserl Circle Meeting (pp. 86-102). NY: New School for Phenomenological Research. www.husserlcircle.org/HC_NYC_Proceedings.pdf. |
| [50] | Lobo, C. (2011). L’idée platonicienne d’eidos selon Husserl (éd. A. Mazzu et S. Delcomminette). Les interprétations des Idées platoniciennes dans la philosophie contemporaine (pp. 161-186). Vrin (Collection Tradition de la pensée classique, 2011). |
| [51] | Lobo, C. (2017a). Le projet husserlien de réforme de la logique et ses prolongements chez G-C. Rota. Revue de synthèse, N° 138, 2017, Brill, pp. 105-150. |
| [52] | Lobo, C. (2017b). Husserl’s reform of logic. An introduction. New Yearbook for Phenomenology and Phenomenological Philosophy,2017, 16-48. |
| [53] | Lobo, C. (2018). Some reasons to reopen the question of foundations of probability theory following the Rota way. The Philosophers and Mathematics. In Honour of Prof. Roshdi Rashed, Ed. Hassan Tahiri. Dordrechti: Springer. · Zbl 1436.60005 |
| [54] | Peirce, C. S. (1931-1935). In C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss (Eds.), Collected papers, Vols. I-VI. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. · JFM 58.1000.02 |
| [55] | Peirce, C. S. (1958). Collected papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, Vol. I-VI. ed. by C. Hartshorne amp; P.Weiss. Cambridge: Harvard University Press 1931-1935, and Vols. VII-VIII, ed. by Arthur Burks. Cambridge: Harvard University Press (Referred to as CP.). · Zbl 0081.00410 |
| [56] | Peirce, C. S. (1976). In Charles S. Peirce & Vols. 1-4, C. Eisele, Mouton, (Eds.), The Hague. (Referred to as NE.). |
| [57] | Peirce, C. S. (1984). Philosophical Writings of C. S. Peirce, Volume 2: 1867-1871, Bloomington and Indianapolis: Harvard University Press; Indiana University Press. |
| [58] | Peirce, C. S. (1986). Writings of Charles S. Peirce: A Chronological Edition, Vols. 2, 3 and 4, Indiana University Press, Indiana. Vol. 2, ed. by E. Moore et al., 1984; Vol. 3, ed. by J.W. Kloesel et al., 1986; Vol. 4, ed. by J. W. Kloesel et al., 1989. |
| [59] | Peirce, C. S. (1986). Philosophical writings of C. S. Peirce, Dover, First ed. 1940. Dover Publications Inc., Édition. New edition. |
| [60] | Peirce, C. S. (1986). Philosophical Writings of C. S. Peirce, Volume 3: 1872-1878, Bloomington and Indianapolis: Harvard University Press; Indiana University Press. |
| [61] | Peirce, C. S. (1989). Philosophical Writings of C. S. Peirce, Volume 4: 1879-1884, Bloomington and Indianapolis: Harvard University Press; Indiana University Press. |
| [62] | Peirce, C. S. (1993). Philosophical Writings of C. S. Peirce, Volume 5: 1884-1886, Bloomington and Indianapolis: Harvard University Press; Indiana University Press. |
| [63] | Peirce, C. S. (2010). Philosophy of Mathematics Selected Writings Charles S. Peirce Edited by Matthew E. Moore. · Zbl 1253.01037 |
| [64] | Peirce, C. S., & Baldwin’, J. M. (Ed.). (1901). Dictionary of philosophy and psychology (Vol. 1-4). New York: The MacMillan Co. |
| [65] | Pietarinen, A.-V. (2006). Peirce and Husserl in Professor Stjernfelt’s Diagrammatology, U. Helsinki. |
| [66] | Rosenthal, J. (2010). The natural-range conception of probability. In G. Ernst & A. Hüttemann (Eds.), Time, chance, and reduction: Philosophical aspects of statistical mechanics (pp. 71-91). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. · doi:10.1017/CBO9780511770777.005 |
| [67] | Shafiei, Mohammad. (2018). Meaning and intentionality, A Dialogical Approach. Dialogues and Games of Logic.: · Zbl 1468.03001 |
| [68] | Spiegelberg, H. (1956). Husserl’s and Peirce’s phenomenologies: Coincidence or interaction. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 17(2), 164-185. · doi:10.2307/2104214 |
| [69] | Stjernfelt, F. (2007). Diagrammatology: An investigation on the borderlines of phenomenology, ontology, and semiotics. Dordrecht: Springer. · doi:10.1007/978-1-4020-5652-9 |
| [70] | Stjernfelt F. (2009). Diagrams and categorial intuition—parallels between late Peirce and early Husserl. In 2009, Conference held in Helsinki—conference published in Chap 6 of Diagrammatology; An investigation of the borderlines of phenomenology, ontology and semiotics (pp. 141 sq.). |
| [71] | Van Atten, M. (2007). Brouwer meets Husserl, On phenomenology of choice sequence, Synthese Library (Vol. 335, pp. 43-52). Berlin: Springer. · Zbl 1119.03001 |
| [72] | Weyl, H. (1949). Philosophy of mathematics and natural science. Princeton: Princeton University Press (see also, Introduction Françoise Balibar and Carlos Lobo, Translation from English and German, MétisPresse, Genève, 2017). · Zbl 0033.24209 |
| [73] | Weyl, H. (1940), “The Ghost of modalities”, Philosophical Essays in Memory of Edmund Husserl (pp. 278-303). Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Gesammelte Abhandlungen (vol. III, pp. 684-709). Berlin: Springer. |
| [74] | Wiegand, O. (1998). Interpretatinen der Modallogi: ein Beitrag zur phänomenologischen Wissenschaftstheorie. Springer. · Zbl 0922.03007 |
| [75] | Zabell, S. (2016). Johannes von Kries’s principien: A brief guide for the perplexed. Journal of General Philosophy of Science. |
| [76] | Zalamea, F. (2012). Synthetic philosophy of Mathematics. Urbanomic. · Zbl 1401.03014 |
| [77] | Zalamea, F. · doi:10.4000/ejpap.593 |
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.
