×

Parametric studies of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on a naval ship using CFD. (English) Zbl 1177.76174

Summary: The prediction of flow path of exhaust plume from the ship funnels is extremely complicated since the phenomenon is affected by a large number of parameters like wind velocity and direction, level of turbulence, geometry of the structures on ship’s deck, efflux velocity of smoke etc. To complicate the matters, the entire turbulent flow field is subject to abrupt changes as the yaw angle changes. In order to understand how the smoke is brought down to ship’s deck, it is necessary to have a knowledge of the funnel exhaust behavior very early in the design spiral of the ship by undertaking parametric investigation of the interaction effect between exhaust smoke and the ship superstructure. This paper presents such a parametric investigation on representative topside configurations of a generic frigate using computational fluid dynamics (CFD). The results presented have been analysed for a total of 112 different cases by varying velocity ratios and onset wind direction for four superstructure configurations. Use of both experimental and computational approaches has been made so that they become complementary to each other. The CFD simulation has been done using the computational code FLUENT version 6.0. Closure was achieved by using the standard \(k-\varepsilon \) turbulence model. The parametric study has demonstrated that CFD is a powerful tool to study the problem of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on ships and is capable of providing a means of visualising the path of the exhaust under different operating conditions very early in the design spiral of a ship.

MSC:

76G25 General aerodynamics and subsonic flows
76F60 \(k\)-\(\varepsilon\) modeling in turbulence

Software:

FLUENT
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Seshadri V, Singh SN. Wind tunnel studies to obviate the problem of unwarranted rise in air intake temperatures of gas turbines in naval ship. Technical Report, Applied Mechanics Department, IIT Delhi, 2000.; Seshadri V, Singh SN. Wind tunnel studies to obviate the problem of unwarranted rise in air intake temperatures of gas turbines in naval ship. Technical Report, Applied Mechanics Department, IIT Delhi, 2000.
[2] Seshadri, V.; Singh, S. N.; Kulkarni, P. R., A study of the problem of ingress of exhaust smoke into the GT intakes in naval ships, J Ship Technol, 2, 1, 22-35 (2006)
[3] Sherlock, R. H.; Stalker, E. A., Control of gases in the wake of smoke stacks, Mech Eng, 62, 455-458 (1940)
[4] Sherlock, R. H.; Stalker, E. A., A study of flow phenomenon in the wake of smoke stacks, Eng Res Bull, Univ Michigan, 44 (1941)
[5] Nolan, R. W., Design of stacks to minimise smoke nuisance, Trans SNAME, 54, 42-82 (1946)
[6] Acker, H. G., Stack design to avoid smoke nuisance, Trans SNAME, 60, 566 (1952)
[7] Ower, E.; Third, A. D., Superstructure design in relation to the descent of funnel smoke, Trans Inst Marine Eng (London), 1, 109-138 (1959)
[8] Third, A. D.; Ower, E., Funnel design and smoke plume, Trans Inst Marine Eng (London), 72, 245-272 (1962)
[9] Burge, C. H.; Ower, E., Funnel design and smoke abatement, Trans Inst Marine Eng (London), 62, 119 (1950)
[10] Micheal K, Johns; Val Healy, J., The airwake of a DD 963 class destroyer, Naval Eng J, ASNE, May, 36-42 (1989)
[11] Kulkarni, P. R.; Singh, S. N.; Seshadri, V., Experimental study of the flow field over simplified superstructure of a ship, Int J Maritime Eng, IJME Part A3, 19-42 (2005)
[12] Kulkarni, P. R.; Singh, S. N.; Seshadri, V., Flow visualisation studies of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on naval ships, Naval Eng J, ASNE, 117, 1, 41-56 (2005)
[13] Davies, M. E.; Cole, L. R.; O’Neill, P. G.G., Wind tunnel investigation of the temperature field due to the hot exhaust of power generation plants on offshore platforms (1979), National Maritime Institute: National Maritime Institute UK
[14] Baham, G. J.; Mc Cullum, D., Stack design technology for naval and merchant ships, Trans SNAME, 85, 324-349 (1977)
[15] Taylor, K.; Smith, A. G., CFD prediction of exhaust plumes and interaction with superstructures. CFD prediction of exhaust plumes and interaction with superstructures, Application of fluid dynamics in the safe design of topsides and superstructures (1997), Institute of Marine Engineers: Institute of Marine Engineers London, p. 56-61
[16] Jin E, Yoon J, Kim Y. A CFD based parametric study on the smoke behaviour of a typical merchant ship. PRADS’01, Shanghai, 2001. p. 459-65.; Jin E, Yoon J, Kim Y. A CFD based parametric study on the smoke behaviour of a typical merchant ship. PRADS’01, Shanghai, 2001. p. 459-65.
[17] Camelli F, Löhner R. Sandberg WC, Ramamurti R. VLES study of ship stack gas dynamics. AIAA paper 2004-0072. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibition, Reno (NV), January 2004.; Camelli F, Löhner R. Sandberg WC, Ramamurti R. VLES study of ship stack gas dynamics. AIAA paper 2004-0072. In: 42nd AIAA aerospace sciences meeting and exhibition, Reno (NV), January 2004.
[18] Sandberg WC, Camelli F, Ramamurti R, Lohner R. Ship topside air contamination analysis: unsteady computations and experimental validation. In: ASNE annual meeting, 2004.; Sandberg WC, Camelli F, Ramamurti R, Lohner R. Ship topside air contamination analysis: unsteady computations and experimental validation. In: ASNE annual meeting, 2004.
[19] Moctar El, Gatchell Scott, Bertram Volker. RANSE simulations for aerodynamic flows around ship superstructures, 2001. In: 4th Num. towing tank symposium, Hamburg.; Moctar El, Gatchell Scott, Bertram Volker. RANSE simulations for aerodynamic flows around ship superstructures, 2001. In: 4th Num. towing tank symposium, Hamburg.
[20] Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Behaviour of a ship funnel in the wake of a bluff body MARINE CFD-2005. In: RINA’s 4th int conference on marine hydrodynamics, Southampton, UK, 30-31 March 2005. p. 115-24.; Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Behaviour of a ship funnel in the wake of a bluff body MARINE CFD-2005. In: RINA’s 4th int conference on marine hydrodynamics, Southampton, UK, 30-31 March 2005. p. 115-24.
[21] Ramamurti, R.; Sandberg, W. C., Unstructured grids for ship unsteady airwake on the LPD-17: a successful validation, Naval Eng J, ASNE, 114, 4, 41-53 (2002)
[22] Docton MKR, Underhill Richard, Morrison Elizabeth. Improving carrier operation through the application of CFD to the CVF design process. In: MARINE CFD-2005, RINA’s 4th int conference on marine hydrodynamics, Southampton, 30-31 March 2005. p. 125-31.; Docton MKR, Underhill Richard, Morrison Elizabeth. Improving carrier operation through the application of CFD to the CVF design process. In: MARINE CFD-2005, RINA’s 4th int conference on marine hydrodynamics, Southampton, 30-31 March 2005. p. 125-31.
[23] Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Comparison of CFD simulation of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on a ship with experimental data. In: Proc of naval platform technology seminar - 2005 (NPTS-05), Singapore, 17-18 May 2005. p. 150-72.; Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Comparison of CFD simulation of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on a ship with experimental data. In: Proc of naval platform technology seminar - 2005 (NPTS-05), Singapore, 17-18 May 2005. p. 150-72.
[24] Kulkarni PR. An aerodynamic study of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on naval ships. PhD Thesis, IIT Delhi, India, 2004.; Kulkarni PR. An aerodynamic study of exhaust smoke-superstructure interaction on naval ships. PhD Thesis, IIT Delhi, India, 2004.
[25] Tai, T. C.; Carico, D., Simulation of DD-963 ship airwake by Navier-Stokes method, J Aircraft, 32, 6, 1399-1401 (1995)
[26] Tai TC. Effect of ship motion on DD-963 ship airwake simulated by multizone Navier-Stokes solution. In: 21st Symposium on naval hydrodynamics 2001. p. 1007-17.; Tai TC. Effect of ship motion on DD-963 ship airwake simulated by multizone Navier-Stokes solution. In: 21st Symposium on naval hydrodynamics 2001. p. 1007-17.
[27] Landsberg AM, Sandberg WC, Young TR. DDG 51 Flight II A airwake study: hangar interior flow. Naval Research Laboratory Memorandum Report 96-7898, 1996.; Landsberg AM, Sandberg WC, Young TR. DDG 51 Flight II A airwake study: hangar interior flow. Naval Research Laboratory Memorandum Report 96-7898, 1996.
[28] Landsberg AM, Sandberg WC. DDG 51 Flight II A airwake study: temperature field analysis for baseline and upgrade configurations. Naval Research Laboratory Memorandum Report 6401-00-8432, 2000.; Landsberg AM, Sandberg WC. DDG 51 Flight II A airwake study: temperature field analysis for baseline and upgrade configurations. Naval Research Laboratory Memorandum Report 6401-00-8432, 2000.
[29] Reddy, K. R.; Toffoletto, R.; Jones, K. R.W., Numerical simulation of ship airwake, Comput Fluids, 29, 451-465 (2000) · Zbl 1047.76518
[30] Landsberg AM, Boris J, Sandberg WC, Young TR. Analysis of the nonlinear coupling of a helicopter downwash with an unsteady air-wake. AIAA Paper, American Institute of Aeronanautics and Astronautics 1995-0047, Washington, DC, 1995.; Landsberg AM, Boris J, Sandberg WC, Young TR. Analysis of the nonlinear coupling of a helicopter downwash with an unsteady air-wake. AIAA Paper, American Institute of Aeronanautics and Astronautics 1995-0047, Washington, DC, 1995.
[31] Ramamurti R, Sandberg WC. LPD-17 topside aerodynamic study: FEFLO. NRL Memorandum Report NRL/MR/6410-00-8498, Center for Reactive Flow and Dynamical Systems, Laboratory for Computational Physics and Fluid Dynamics - Naval Research Laboratory, October 2000.; Ramamurti R, Sandberg WC. LPD-17 topside aerodynamic study: FEFLO. NRL Memorandum Report NRL/MR/6410-00-8498, Center for Reactive Flow and Dynamical Systems, Laboratory for Computational Physics and Fluid Dynamics - Naval Research Laboratory, October 2000.
[32] Guillot MJ, Walker MA, Reader K, Ramamurti R, Sandberg WC. LPD-17 topside aerodynamic study. Final Technical Report, Naval Research Laboratory, 2000.; Guillot MJ, Walker MA, Reader K, Ramamurti R, Sandberg WC. LPD-17 topside aerodynamic study. Final Technical Report, Naval Research Laboratory, 2000.
[33] Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Study of exhaust smoke ingress into GT intake on ships MAHY-06. In: Int conference on marine hydrodynamics, NSTL, Visakhapatnam (India), January 2006.; Kulkarni PR, Singh SN, Seshadri V. Study of exhaust smoke ingress into GT intake on ships MAHY-06. In: Int conference on marine hydrodynamics, NSTL, Visakhapatnam (India), January 2006.
[34] Jensen, A. G.; Sondergaard, T.; Livesey, F., Wind comfort for cruise/passenger vessels (1997), Cruise and Ferry
[35] Kulkarni, P. R.; Singh, S. N.; Seshadri, V., Study of smoke nuisance problem on ships – a review, Int J Maritime Eng, IJME Part A2, 27-50 (2005)
[36] Gosman, A. D., Developments in CFD for industrial and environmental applications in wind engineering, J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn, 81, 21-39 (1999)
[37] Murakami, S., Comparison of various turbulence models applied to a bluff body, J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn, 46-47, 21-36 (1993)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.