×

Modelling distributed decision-making in command and control using stochastic network synchronisation. (English) Zbl 1441.91022

Summary: We advance a mathematical representation of Command and Control as distributed decision makers using the Kuramoto model of networked phase oscillators. The phase represents a continuous Perception-Action cycle of agents at each network node; the network the formal and informal communications of human agents and information artefacts; coupling the strength of relationship between agents; native frequencies the individual decision speeds of agents when isolated; and stochasticity temporal noisiness in intrinsic agent behaviour. Skewed heavy-tailed noise captures that agents may randomly ‘jump’ forward (rather than backwards) in their decision state under time stress; there is considerable evidence from organisational science that experienced decision-makers behave in this way in critical situations. We present a use-case for the model using data for military headquarters staff tasked to drive a twenty-four hour ‘battle-rhythm’. This serves to illustrate how such a mathematical model may be used realistically. We draw on a previous case-study where headquarters’ networks were mapped for routine business and crisis scenarios to provide advice to a military sponsor. We tune the model using the first data set to match observations that staff performed synchronously under such conditions. Testing the impact of the crisis scenario using the corresponding network and heavy-tailed stochasticity, we find increased probability of decision incoherence due to the high information demand of some agents in this case. This demonstrates the utility of the model to identify risks in headquarters design, and potential means of identifying points to change. We compare to qualitative organisational theories to initially validate the model.

MSC:

91B06 Decision theory
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Acebrón, J. A.; Bonilla, L. L.; Vicente, C. J.P.; Ritort, F.; Spigler, R., The Kuramoto model: A simple paradigm for synchronization phenomena, Reviews of Modern Physics, 77, 1, 137 (2005)
[2] Afifi, W. A.; Weiner, J. L., Introduction. information seeking across contexts, Human Communication Research, 28, 2, 207-212 (2002)
[3] Aguilar-Saven, R. S., Business process modelling: Review and framework, International Journal of Production Economics, 90, 2, 129-149 (2004)
[4] Albert, R.; Barabási, A.-L., Statistical mechanics of complex networks, Reviews of Modern Physics, 74, 1, 47 (2002) · Zbl 1205.82086
[5] Alberts, D.; Garstka, J.; Stein, F., Network Centric Warfare (1999), Command and Control Research Program, USA
[6] Arenas, A.; Díaz-Guilera, A.; Kurths, J.; Moreno, Y.; Zhou, C., Synchronization in complex networks, Physics Reports, 469, 3, 93-153 (2008)
[7] Ashworth, M. J.; Carley, K. M., Can tools help unify organization theory? perspectives on the state of computational modeling, Computational and Mathematical Organization Theory, 13, 1, 89-111 (2007) · Zbl 1112.90357
[8] Bag, B. C.; Petrosyan, K.; Hu, C.-K., Influence of noise on the synchronization of the stochastic Kuramoto model, Physical Review E, 76, 5, 056210 (2007)
[9] Beekun, R. I.; Glick, W. H., Development and test of a contingency framework of coupling: Assessing the covariation between structure and culture, The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 37, 4, 385-407 (2001)
[10] Berger, C. R.; Calabrese, R. J., Some explorations in initial interaction and beyond: Toward a developmental theory of interpersonal communication, Human Communication Research, 1, 2, 99-112 (1974)
[11] Bharathy, G. K.; Silverman, B., Validating agent based social systems models, Simulation conference (wsc), proceedings of the 2010 winter, 441-453 (2010), IEEE
[12] Boyd, J. R., Organic design for command and control: A discourse on winning and losing, Slide set (1987)
[13] Brede, M., Locals vs. global synchronization in networks of non-identical Kuramoto oscillators, European Physical Journal B, 62, 1, 87-94 (2008)
[14] Burns, T.; Stalker, G., The management of innovation (1961), Tavistock, London
[15] Buzna, L.; Lozano, S.; Diaz-Guilera, A., How does network topology determine the synchronization threshold in a network of oscillators?, (Helber, S., Operations research proceedings, 2012 (2014), Gesellschaft fuer Operations Research (GOR), Springer), 135-140 · Zbl 1305.90096
[16] Cooper, D. F.; Holt, J.; Klein, J. H., Models of naval command and control systems, European Journal of Operational Research, 26, 2, 217-228 (1986)
[17] Coyle, R., A model for assessing the work processing capabilities of military command and control systems, European Journal of Operational Research, 28, 1, 27-43 (1987)
[18] Crombez, C., Minority governments, minimal winning coalitions and surplus majorities in parliamentary systems, European Journal of Political Research, 29, January, 1-29 (1996)
[19] Dargam, F. C.C.; Passos, E. P.L.; Pantoja, F. D.R., Decision support systems for military applications, European Journal of Operational Research, 55, 3, 403-408 (1991)
[20] Dekker, A., Studying organisational topology with simple computational models, Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation, 10, 4, 6 (2007)
[21] Dekker, A. H., C2, networks, and self-synchronization, (Grant, T. J.; Janssen, R. H.P.; Monsuur, H., Network topology in command and control: Organization, operation, and evolution (2014), IGI Global), 135-140
[22] del-Castillo-Negrete, D., Anomalous transport in the presence of truncated Lévy flights, Fractional dynamics: Recent advances, 129-157 (2012), World Scientific · Zbl 1308.82054
[23] DeVille, L., Transitions amongst synchronous solutions in the stochastic Kuramoto model, Nonlinearity, 25, 5, 1473 (2012) · Zbl 1252.34061
[24] DiFonzo, N.; Hantula, D. A.; Bordia, P., Microworlds for experimental research: Having your (control and collection) cake, and realism too, Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers, 30, 2, 278-286 (1998)
[25] Dockery, J., Mathematics of command and control (C2) analysis, European Journal of Operational Research, 21, 2, 172-188 (1985)
[26] Dodd, L.; Moffat, J.; Smith, J., Discontinuity in decision-making when objectives conflict: A military command decision case study, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 57, 6, 643-654 (2006) · Zbl 1121.90349
[27] Donaldson, L., The contingency theory of organizations (2001), Sage
[28] Dörfler, F.; Bullo, F., Synchronization in complex networks of phase oscillators: A survey, Automatica, 50, 6, 1539-1564 (2014) · Zbl 1296.93005
[29] Dorogovtsev, S. N.; Goltsev, A. V.; Mendes, J. F., Critical phenomena in complex networks, Reviews of Modern Physics, 80, 4, 1275 (2008)
[30] Endsley, M. R.; Garland, D., Theoretical underpinnings of situation awareness: A critical review, Situation Awareness Analysis and Measurement, 1, 24 (2000)
[31] Esfahani, R. K.; Shahbazi, F.; Samani, K. A., Noise-induced synchronization in small world networks of phase oscillators, Physical Review E, 86, 3, 036204 (2012)
[32] Gómez-Gardeñes, J.; Moreno, Y.; Arenas, A., Synchronizability determined by coupling strengths and topology on complex networks, Physical Review E, 75, 6, 066106 (2007)
[33] Grabchak, M., Does value-at-risk encourage diversification when losses follow tempered stable or more general Lévy processes?, Annals of Finance, 10, 4, 553-568 (2014) · Zbl 1319.91143
[34] Grechuk, B.; Zabarankin, M., Direct data-based decision making under uncertainty, European Journal of Operational Research, 267, 1, 200-211 (2018) · Zbl 1403.91113
[35] Griffin, P. S.; Maller, R. A.; Roberts, D., Finite time ruin probabilities for tempered stable insurance risk processes, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 53, 2, 478-489 (2013) · Zbl 1304.91106
[36] Hainaut, D.; Devolder, P., Mortality modelling with Lévy processes, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 42, 1, 409-418 (2008) · Zbl 1141.91516
[37] Hasík, J., Beyond the briefing: Theoretical and practical problems in the works and legacy of John Boyd, Contemporary Security Policy, 34, 3, 583-599 (2013)
[38] Hollenbeck, J. R.; Spitzmueller, M., Team-structure: Tight versus Loose coupling in task-oriented groups, in The Oxford Handbook of Organizational Psychology Vol 2. (2012), Oxford
[39] Hong, H.; Choi, M.-Y.; Kim, B. J., Synchronization on small-world networks, Physical Review E, 65, 2, 026139 (2002)
[40] Ichinomiya, T., Frequency synchronization in a random oscillator network, Physical Review E, 70, 2, 026116 (2004)
[41] Kalloniatis, A. C., A new paradigm for dynamical modelling of networked C2 processes, 13TH International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium, Seattle, USA, 17-19 June, 2008 (2008)
[42] Kalloniatis, A. C., Testing AI watch-keepers in a mathematical model of networked OODA loops, 21st International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium, London, 6-8 September, 2016 (2016)
[43] Kalloniatis, A. C.; Ali, I.; Neville, T.; La, P.; Macleod, I.; Zuparic, M.; Kohn, E., The Situation Awareness Weighted Network (SAWN) model and method: theory and application, Applied Ergonomics, 61, 178-196 (2017)
[44] Kalloniatis, A. C.; Roberts, D. O., Synchronisation of networked Kuramoto oscillators under stable Lévy noise, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 466, 476-491 (2017) · Zbl 1400.60079
[45] 99-3
[46] Khoshbakht, H.; Shahbazi, F.; Samani, K. A., Phase synchronization on scale-free and random networks in the presence of noise, Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2008, 10, P10020 (2008)
[47] Kirkpatrick, S.; Delatt, C. D.; Vecchi, M. P., Optimization by simulated annealing, Science, 220, 4598, 671-680 (1983) · Zbl 1225.90162
[48] Klein, G. A., Sources of power: How people make decisions (2017), MIT press
[49] Kopell, N.; Ermentrout, G. B., Coupled oscillators and the design of central pattern generators, Mathematical Biosciences, 90, 1-2, 87-109 (1988) · Zbl 0649.92009
[50] Koponen, I., Analytic approach to the problem of convergence of truncated Lévy flights towards the gaussian stochastic process, Physical Review E, 52, 1, 1197 (1995)
[51] Kullberg, A.; del-Castillo-Negrete, D., Transport in the spatially tempered, fractional Fokker-Planck equation, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical, 45, 25, 255101 (2012) · Zbl 1250.82032
[52] Kuramoto, Y., Chemical waves, Chemical oscillations, waves, and turbulence, 89-110 (1984), Springer · Zbl 0558.76051
[53] Lambert, N. J., Analysis and evaluation of the command and control concept of the NATO immediate reaction task force (land), Journal of the Operational Research Society, 55, 4, 375-389 (2004) · Zbl 1095.90581
[54] Lewis, B.; Swarup, S.; Bisset, K.; Eubank, S.; Marathe, M.; Barrett, C., Scenario play workshops - Co-design of emergency response scenarios for information technology design in collaboration with emergency response personnel, J Public Health Manag Pract., 19, Suppl 2, S42-8 (2013)
[55] Liao, S.-h., Case-based decision support system: Architecture for simulating military command and control, European Journal of Operational Research, 123, 3, 558-567 (2000) · Zbl 0991.90544
[56] Liu, B.; Zhou, Q.; Ding, R.-X.; Palomares, I.; Herrera, F., Large-scale group decision making model based on social network analysis: Trust relationship-based conflict detection and elimination, European Journal of Operational Research, 275, 2, 737-754 (2019) · Zbl 1431.91114
[57] Lovaglia, M. J.; Skvoretz, J.; Willer, D.; Markovsky, B., Negotiated exchange in social networks, Social Forces, 74, 1, 123-155 (1995)
[58] Lundberg, J.; Granlund, R.; Fredang, A., Scenario play workshops - co-design of emergency response scenarios for information technology design in collaboration with emergency response personnel, Iscram2012, 9th international conference on information systems for crisis response and management. vancouver, canada (2012)
[59] Luoma, J., Model-based organizational decision making: A behavioral lens, European Journal of Operational Research, 249, 3, 816-826 (2016) · Zbl 1346.90437
[60] Mantegna, R. N.; Stanley, H. E., Scaling behaviour in the dynamics of an economic index, Nature, 376, 6535, 46 (1995)
[61] Meerschaert, M. M.; Roy, P.; Shao, Q., Parameter estimation for exponentially tempered power law distributions, Communications in Statistics-Theory and Methods, 41, 10, 1839-1856 (2012) · Zbl 1271.62109
[62] Metropolis, N.; Rosenbluth, A. W.; Rosenbluth, M. N.; Teller, A. H., Equation of state calculations by fast computing machines, Journal of Chemical Physics, 21, 6, 1087-1092 (1953) · Zbl 1431.65006
[63] Metzler, R.; Klafter, J., The random walk’s guide to anomalous diffusion: A fractional dynamics approach, Phys. Rep., 339, 1 (2000) · Zbl 0984.82032
[64] Metzler, R.; Klafter, J., The restaurant at the end of the random walk: recent developments in the description of anomalous transport by fractional dynamics, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General, 37, 31, R161 (2004) · Zbl 1075.82018
[65] Miller, C. A., The risks of discretization: What is lost in (even good) levels-of-automation schemes, Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making, 12, 1, 74-76 (2018)
[66] Mizumoto, T.; Otsuka, T.; Nakadai, K.; Takahashi, T.; Komatani, K.; Ogata, T.; Okuno, H. G., Human-robot ensemble between robot thereminist and human percussionist using coupled oscillator model, Ieee/rsj int. conf. on intelligent robots & systems. taipei, taiwan, 1957-1963 (2010), IEEE
[67] Moffat, J., Representing the command and control process in simulation models of conflict, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 51, 4, 431-439 (2000) · Zbl 1055.91554
[68] Moffat, J.; Witty, S., Bayesian decision making and military command and control, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 53, 7, 709-718 (2002) · Zbl 1130.90344
[69] Moon, T.; Kruzins, E.; Calbert, G., Analyzing the OODA cycle, Phalanx, 35, 2, 9-35 (2002)
[70] Moreau, L., Stability of multiagent systems with time-dependent communication links, IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 50, 2, 169-182 (2005) · Zbl 1365.93268
[71] Morewedge, C. K.; Kahneman, D., Associative processes in intuitive judgment, Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14, 10, 435-440 (2010)
[72] Moynihan, D. P., The network governance of crisis response: Case studies of incident command systems, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 19, 4, 895-915 (2009)
[73] Moynihan, P.; Bowen, K., A research study of human decision-making in higher level military command and control, European Journal of Operational Research, 31, 3, 284-291 (1987)
[74] Néda, Z.; Ravasz, E.; Vicsek, T.; Brechet, Y.; Barabási, A. L., Physics of the rhythmic applause, Physical Review E, 61, 6, 6987-6992 (2000)
[75] Neisser, U., Cognition and reality. Principles and implications of cognitive psychology (1976), San Francisco: WH Freeman and Company
[76] Oh, E.; Lee, D.; Kahng, B.; Kim, D., Synchronization transition of heterogeneously coupled oscillators on scale-free networks, Physical Review E, 75, 1, 011104 (2007)
[77] Osinga, F., “Getting“ A discourse on winning and losing: A primer on Boyd’s “Theory of Intellectual Evolution”, Contemporary Security Policy, 34, 3, 603-624 (2013)
[78] Paley, D. A.; Leonard, N. E.; Sepluchre, R.; Grunbaum; Parrish, J. K., Oscillator models and collective motion, IEEE Control Systems Magazine, 27, 4, 89-105 (2007)
[79] Palmer, K. J.; Ridout, M. S.; Morgan, B. J., Modelling cell generation times by using the tempered stable distribution, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series C (Applied Statistics), 57, 4, 379-397 (2008) · Zbl 1409.62225
[80] Penson, K.; Górska, K., Exact and explicit probability densities for one-sided Lévy stable distributions, Physical Review Letters, 105, 21, 210604 (2010)
[81] Perrow, C., Normal Accidents: Living with High Risk Technologies-Updated Edition (2011), Princeton university press
[82] 5-1
[83] Pluchino, A.; Boccaletti, S.; Latora, V.; Rapisarda, A., Opinion dynamics and synchronization in a network of scientific collaborations, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 372, 2, 316-325 (2006)
[84] Ratcliff, R.; McKoon, G., The diffusion decision model: theory and data for two-choice decision tasks, Neural Computation, 20, 4, 873-922 (2008) · Zbl 1147.68720
[85] Rittel, H. W.; Webber, M. M., Dilemmas in a general theory of planning, Policy Sciences, 4, 2, 155-169 (1973)
[86] Roberts, D.; Kalloniatis, A. C., Synchronisation under shocks: The Lévy Kuramoto model, Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 368, 10-21 (2018) · Zbl 1381.34054
[87] Rykiel Jr., E. J., Testing ecological models: the meaning of validation, Ecological modelling, 90, 3, 229-244 (1996)
[88] Salmon, P. M.; Stanton, N. A.; Walker, G. H.; Jenkins, D.; Baber, C.; McMaster, R., Representing situation awareness in collaborative systems: a case study in the energy distribution domain, Ergonomics, 51, 3, 367-384 (2008)
[89] Sargent, R. G., A tutorial on verification and validation of simulation models, Proceedings of the 16th conference on winter simulation, 114-121 (1984), IEEE Press
[90] Schreiber, D., Validating agent-based models: From metaphysics to applications, Annual conference of the midwestern political science association, chicago, il: April (2002)
[91] Strogatz, S. H., From Kuramoto to Crawford: exploring the onset of synchronization in populations of coupled oscillators, Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 143, 1-4, 1-20 (2000) · Zbl 0983.34022
[92] Strogatz, S. H.; Abrams, D. M.; McRobie, A.; Eckhardt, B.; Ott, E., Theoretical mechanics: Crowd synchrony on the Millennium Bridge, Nature, 438, 7064, 43-44 (2005)
[93] Tönjes, R., Synchronization transition in the Kuramoto model with colored noise, Physical Review E, 81, 5, 055201 (2010)
[94] Traxl, D.; Boers, N.; Kurths, J., General scaling of maximum degree of synchronization in noisy complex networks, New Journal of Physics, 16, 11, 115009 (2014)
[95] United States Army, Field Manual 101-5 Staff Organization and Operations (1997), Washington, DC: Headquarters, Department of the Army
[96] United States Army, Field Manual 3-0 Operations (2008), Washington, DC: Headquarters, Department of the Army
[97] Wasserman, S.; Faust, K., Social network analysis: Methods and applications (1994), Cambridge University Press
[98] Watts, D. J.; Strogatz, S. H., Collective dynamics of âsmall-worldâ networks, Nature, 393, 6684, 440 (1998) · Zbl 1368.05139
[99] Weick, K. E., Educational organizations as loosely coupled systems, Administrative Science Quarterly, 21, 1-19 (1976)
[100] Wickens, C., Automation stages & levels, 20 years after, Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making, 12, 1, 35-41 (2018)
[101] Wright, G.; Cairns, G.; O’Brien, F.; Goodwin, P., Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: pitfalls and potential, European Journal of Operational Research (2018)
[102] Wyłomańska, A.; Żak, G.; Kruczek, P.; Zimroz, R., Application of tempered stable distribution for selection of optimal frequency band in gearbox local damage detection, Applied Acoustics, 128, 14-22 (2017)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.