Are non-contingent incentives more effective in motivating new behavior? Evidence from the field. (English) Zbl 1478.91060
Summary: Organizations and policymakers increasingly rely on economic incentives to prompt participation in activities amongst those who were previously not engaged. We ran a field experiment with a recycling program to examine incentives’ effectiveness to motivate new behavior – i.e., attract non-recyclers. We compared standard contingent incentives (payment contingent on recycling) to non-contingent incentives (upfront unconditional payment) of different sizes. A high contingent incentive was as effective as a non-contingent incentive (of any size) in attracting people to the program, but this masked differences in who participated. Across incentive sizes, people who had never recycled were 5.8 times more likely to begin recycling with the program when given a non-contingent incentive (20.2%) than when offered a contingent one (3.5%). A second experiment conceptually replicated this effect in an online job market, showing that non-contingent incentives were substantially more effective in attracting previous non-compliers.
MSC:
| 91B06 | Decision theory |
| 91-05 | Experimental work for problems pertaining to game theory, economics, and finance |
Keywords:
non-contingent incentives; prosocial behavior; sorting; selection; behavior change; recyclingReferences:
| [1] | Adams, Paul; Guttman-Kenney, Benedict; Hayes, Lucy; Hunt, Stefan; Stewart, Neil, Financial conduct authority increasing credit card payments using choice architecture: the case of anchors and prompts the FCA occasional papers (2018) |
| [2] | Allcott, Hunt; Rogers, Todd, The short-run and long-run effects of behavioral interventions: experimental evidence from energy conservation, Am. Econ. Rev., 104, 10, 3003-3037 (2014) |
| [3] | Araya, Sebastian; Elberg, Andres; Noton, Carlos; Schwartz, Daniel, Identifying food labeling effects on consumer behavior, SSRN Electron. J. (June 2018) |
| [4] | Ariely, Dan; Bracha, Anat; Meier, Stephan, Doing good or doing well? Image motivation and monetary incentives in behaving prosocially, Am. Econ. Rev., 99, 1, 544-555 (2009) |
| [5] | Ashraf, Nava; Bandiera, Oriana; Lee, Scott, Losing prosociality in the quest for talent? Sorting, selection, and productivity in the delivery of public services, Am. Econ. Rev. (2019) |
| [6] | Bénabou, Roland; Tirole, Jean, Incentives and prosocial behavior, Am. Econ. Rev., 96, 5, 1652-1678 (2006) |
| [7] | Birnholtz, Jeremy P.; Horn, Daniel B.; Finholt, Thomas A.; Bae, Sung Joo, The effects of cash, electronic, and paper gift certificates as respondent incentives for a web-based survey of technologically sophisticated respondents, Soc. Sci. Comput. Rev., 22, 3, 355-362 (2016) |
| [8] | Borg, Kim; Curtis, Jim; Lindsay, Jo, Social norms and plastic avoidance: testing the theory of normative social behaviour on an environmental behaviour, J. Consum. Behav., 19, 6, 594-607 (2020) |
| [9] | Cassar, Lea, Job mission as a substitute for monetary incentives: benefits and limits, Manag. Sci., 65, 2, 896-912 (2019) |
| [10] | Charness, Gary; Cobo-Reyes, Ramón; Sánchez, Ángela, The effect of charitable giving on workers’ performance: experimental evidence, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 131, 61-74 (November 2016) |
| [11] | Charness, Gary; Gneezy, Uri, Incentives to exercise, Econometrica, 77, 3, 909-931 (2009) |
| [12] | Cox, James C.; Friedman, Daniel; Gjerstad, Steven, A tractable model of reciprocity and fairness, Games Econ. Behav., 59, 1, 17-45 (2007) · Zbl 1271.91044 |
| [13] | Dillman, Don; Smyth, J. D.; Christian, L. M., Internet, Phone, Mail, and Mixed-Mode Surveys: The Tailored Design Method (2014), John Wiley & Sons |
| [14] | Dohmen, Thomas; Falk, Armin, Performance pay and multidimensional sorting: productivity, preferences, and gender, Am. Econ. Rev., 101, 2, 556-590 (2011) |
| [15] | Dufwenberg, Martin; Kirchsteiger, Georg, A theory of sequential reciprocity, Games Econ. Behav., 47, 2, 268-298 (2004) · Zbl 1077.91007 |
| [16] | Dufwenberg, Martin; Kirchsteiger, Georg, Modelling kindness, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 167, November, 228-234 (2019) |
| [17] | Dur, Robert; Fleming, Dimitry; van Garderen, Marten; van Lent, Max, A social norm nudge to save more: a field experiment at a retail bank, J. Public Econ., 200, Article 104443 pp. (August 2021) |
| [18] | Englmaier, F.; Grimm, S.; Schindler, D.; Schudy, S., The effect of incentives in non-routine analytical team tasks-evidence from a field experiment (2018), CESifo Working Paper Series No. 6903 |
| [19] | Eriksson, Tor; Villeval, Marie Claire, Performance-pay, sorting and social motivation, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 68, 2, 412-421 (2008) |
| [20] | Esteves-Sorenson, Constança, Gift exchange in the workplace: addressing the conflicting evidence with a careful test, Manag. Sci., 64, 9, 4365-4388 (2018) |
| [21] | Falk, Armin, Gift exchange in the field, Econometrica, 75, 5, 1501-1511 (2007) · Zbl 1133.91037 |
| [22] | Fehr, Ernst; Kirchsteiger, Georg; Riedl, Arno, Gift exchange and reciprocity in competitive experimental markets, Eur. Econ. Rev., 42, 1, 1-34 (1998) |
| [23] | Fiske, Alan Page, The four elementary forms of sociality: framework for a unified theory of social relations, Psychol. Rev., 99, 4, 689-723 (1992) |
| [24] | Fröber, Kerstin; Dreisbach, Gesine, The differential influences of positive affect, random reward, and performance-contingent reward on cognitive control, Cogn. Affect. Behav. Neurosci., 14, 2, 530-547 (2014) |
| [25] | Gallus, Jana, Fostering voluntary contributions to a public good: a large-scale field experiment at Wikipedia, (Academy of Management Proceedings, vol. 13280 (2016), Academy of Management Briarcliff: Academy of Management Briarcliff Manor, NY), 10510 |
| [26] | Gallus, Jana; Jung, Olivia; Lakhani, Karim R., Managerial Recognition as an Incentive for Innovation Platform Engagement: A Field Experiment and Interview Study at NASA (2019), Harvard Business School Technology & Operations Mgt. Unit Working Paper, No. 20-059 |
| [27] | Gneezy, Uri; List, John A., Putting behavioral economics to work: testing for gift exchange in labor markets using field experiments, Econometrica, 74, 5, 1365-1384 (2006) · Zbl 1138.91522 |
| [28] | Gneezy, Uri; Meier, Stephan; Rey-Biel, Pedro, When and why incentives (don’t) work to modify behavior, J. Econ. Perspect., 25, 4, 191-210 (2011) |
| [29] | Gneezy, Uri; Rey-Biel, Pedro, On the relative efficiency of performance pay and noncontingent incentives, J. Eur. Econ. Assoc., 12, 1, 62-72 (2014) |
| [30] | Gneezy, Uri; Rustichini, Aldo, Pay enough or don’t pay at all*, Q. J. Econ., 115, 3, 791-810 (2000) |
| [31] | Guthrie, Joanne; Mancino, Lisa; Lin, Chung-Tung Jordan, Nudging consumers toward better food choices: policy approaches to changing food consumption behaviors, Psychol. Mark., 32, 5, 501-511 (2015) |
| [32] | Heyman, James; Ariely, Dan, Effort for payment. A tale of two markets, Psychol. Sci., 15, 11, 787-793 (2004) |
| [33] | Imas, Alex, Working for the ‘warm glow’: on the benefits and limits of prosocial incentives, J. Public Econ., 114, 14-18 (June 2014) |
| [34] | Imas, Alex; Loewenstein, George, Is altruism sensitive to scope? The role of tangibility, (AEA Papers and Proceedings, vol. 108 (2018)), 143-147 |
| [35] | Isoni, Andrea; Sugden, Robert, Reciprocity and the paradox of trust in psychological game theory, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 167, 219-227 (2019) |
| [36] | James, Katherine M.; Ziegenfuss, Jeanette Y.; Tilburt, Jon C.; Harris, Ann M.; Beebe, Timothy J., Getting physicians to respond: the impact of incentive type and timing on physician survey response rates, Health Serv. Res., 46, 1p1, 232-242 (2011) |
| [37] | Jayaraman, Rajshri; Ray, Debraj; de Véricourt, Francis, Anatomy of a contract change, Am. Econ. Rev., 106, 2, 316-358 (2016) |
| [38] | Johnson, Richard P.; Geller, E. Scott, Contingent versus noncontingent rewards for promoting seat belt usage, J. Community Psychol., 12, 2, 113-122 (1984) |
| [39] | Jones, Damon; Molitor, David; Reif, Julian, What do workplace wellness programs do? Evidence from the Illinois workplace wellness study, Q. J. Econ., 134, 4, 1747-1791 (2019) |
| [40] | Kamenica, Emir, Behavioral economics and psychology of incentives, Annu. Rev. Econ., 4, 1, 427-452 (2012) |
| [41] | Lacetera, Nicola; Macis, Mario; Slonim, Robert, Rewarding volunteers: a field experiment, Manag. Sci., 60, 5, 1107-1129 (2014) |
| [42] | Lazear, Edward P., Salaries and piece rates, J. Bus., 405-431 (1986) |
| [43] | Lazear, Edward P.; Malmendier, Ulrike; Weber, Roberto A., Sorting in experiments with application to social preferences, Am. Econ. J. Appl. Econ., 4, 1, 136-163 (2012) |
| [44] | Macey, Susan M.; Brown, Marilyn A., Residential energy conservation, Environ. Behav., 15, 2, 123-141 (1983) |
| [45] | Martorell, Paco; Miller, Trey; Santibañez, Lucrecia; Augustine, Catherine H., Can incentives for parents and students change educational inputs? Experimental evidence from summer school, Econ. Educ. Rev., 50, 113-126 (February 2016) |
| [46] | Mehta, Shivan J.; Pepe, Rebecca S.; Gabler, Nicole B.; Kanneganti, Mounika; Reitz, Catherine; Saia, Chelsea; Teel, Joseph; Asch, David A.; Volpp, Kevin G.; Doubeni, Chyke A., Effect of financial incentives on patient use of mailed colorectal cancer screening tests: a randomized clinical trial, JAMA Netw. Open, 2, 3, e191156 (2019) |
| [47] | Netzer, Nick; Schmutzler, Armin, Explaining gift-exchange-the limits of good intentions, J. Eur. Econ. Assoc., 12, 6, 1586-1616 (2014) |
| [48] | Pacto Global, El Reciclaje: Las Cifras En Chile (2015), Red Pacto Global Chile |
| [49] | Peer, Eyal; Brandimarte, Laura; Samat, Sonam; Acquisti, Alessandro, Beyond the turk: alternative platforms for crowdsourcing behavioral research, J. Exp. Soc. Psychol., 70, 153-163 (May 2017) |
| [50] | Purnell, Jason Q.; Thompson, Tess; Kreuter, Matthew W.; McBride, Timothy D., Peer reviewed: behavioral economics: ‘nudging’ underserved populations to Be screened for cancer, Prev. Chron. Dis., 12, 1 (2015) |
| [51] | Rabin, Matthew, Incorporating fairness into game theory and economis, Am. Econ. Rev., 83, 5, 1281-1302 (1993) |
| [52] | Romano, Alessandro; Sotis, Chiara, Odi et amo: a nudge to reduce the consumption of single-use carrier bags, Waste Manag., 120, 382-391 (February 2021) |
| [53] | Schwartz, Daniel; Fischhoff, Baruch; Krishnamurti, Tamar; Sowell, Fallaw, The hawthorne effect and energy awareness, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 110, 38, 15242-15246 (2013) |
| [54] | Schwartz, Daniel; Keenan, Elizabeth A.; Imas, Alex; Gneezy, Ayelet, Opting-in to prosocial incentives, Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process., 163, 132-141 (March 2021) |
| [55] | Schwartz, Daniel; Loewenstein, George, The chill of the moment: emotions and proenvironmental behavior, J. Public Policy Mark., 36, 2, 255-268 (2017) |
| [56] | Schwartz, Daniel; Loewenstein, George; Agüero-Gaete, Loreto, Encouraging pro-environmental behaviour through green identity labelling, Nat. Sustain., 3, 746-752 (2020) |
| [57] | Singer, Eleanor; Ye, Cong, The use and effects of incentives in surveys, Ann. Am. Acad. Polit. Soc. Sci., 645, 1, 112-141 (2013) |
| [58] | US EPA, Recycling basics (2020) |
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.
