Henry Avila's Reviews > A Room with a View

A Room with a View by E.M. Forster
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5431458
's review

really liked it

The Pensione (pension) Bertolini in Florence, Italy has everything for the visiting tourists, Miss Lucy Honeychurch and her older poorer cousin Charlotte Bartlett a rather overbearing chaperon, fine food, (not really) wines not too bad this is Italy and a room with a view. Unfortunately not for the cousins, their promised accommodations went to Mr.Emerson and his quiet gloomy son George. If you can't trust the Signora Bertolini, the Italian owner of this establishment more English than one in London, the late Queen Victoria's picture is still on the wall, with a strange Cockney accent who can you? But chivalry is not quite dead, in the early 20th century the ill mannered Mr.Emerson, offers in front of all the other British tourists while they consume their dinner, to exchange rooms two for two , the men don't care as long as they have a good bed, after hearing Charlotte's complaints. Of course Miss Bartlett turned it down, the unseemly idea such a vulgar man, he is not a gentleman no English reserve . Looking around, she sees that confirmed on the faces of the other boarders. Then again, Florence is so beautiful the Arno River flowing nearby, (not too dirty ) the Apennine Mountains, Cypress trees of San Miniato, she will never be here again ... A half- hour later the two cousins open the windows, ( the British love to do this) in the new rooms... with a view. A great country to stare at the exotic attractions, if only the Italians were more civilized Charlotte thinks, but all is well with the world now. Miss Eleanor Ravish a new flighty friend, at the pension and future bad novelist, takes Lucy on a sightseeing trip of the real Italy. And promptly deserts her for an old friend, on the streets of the city, she enters the church alone, they both were to view. How is she to get back to Bertolini ? Not to worry the Emerson's are there, Mr. Emerson the old "Gentleman" quickly annoys, then disrupts a visiting British clergyman's lecture inside with his loud disagreeing voice, the unhappy perturbed flock leaves, yet Lucy does get back home safely. Feeling brave and wanting independence and excitement, she receives more than Lucy can handle, Miss Honeychurch goes out by herself. While looking at a palace tower, she is a witness to a gruesome murder, the stabbing of one Italian man against another at close range, blood on her photographs, she just had bought in a shop and faints ...George in love and in the same vicinity, spying ... Picks Lucy up, revives her and takes the lady to safety, the Arno river is near, throwing the messy photos in the stream. She can't believe he did it ... At a later date, descending a mountain road after viewing gorgeous Florence from above, the weather turns bad, the two carriages full of the British visitors from the pension, including Lucy, Charlotte and the old Mr.Emerson, even Miss Lavish. George the cad had kissed Lucy, when she fell on the ground full of exquisite violets, Charlotte luckily comes to the rescue before who knows what George would do next. He runs away the coward and vanishes, nobody knows where. But soon Lucy will meet the perfect, ideal, respectable man, Cecil Vyse... In the wet darkness, the rains heavy, lightning strikes, women scream, slowly the party travels, more flashes of lightning, the clouds coming down, the road a liquid mess, the storm gets more violent, they stop for a short rest. A lightning bolt hits the road just below them ...
168 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Room with a View.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 31, 2013 – Shelved
October 31, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read
June 23, 2014 – Started Reading
June 30, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 54 (54 new)


message 1: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Great review.

My next Forster has to be Howard's End. Maybe next to Dickens that I am reading now.


message 2: by Henry (last edited Jul 01, 2014 09:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Thanks K.D.My first of the author's ,but not my Last!


Lisa Good review. Forster's style changes from book to book, always good but keeps you guessing.


message 4: by Henry (last edited Jul 01, 2014 10:15PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Sounds like a very interesting writer ,must read other of his books,Lisa.Glad that you enjoyed my review.


message 5: by Aditi (new)

Aditi A very classic tale and Henry, your review justifies it completely.


message 6: by Henry (last edited Jul 01, 2014 11:19PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Thanks Aditi,the writer is entertaining.Will get more of his books.Liked the film also.


Dolors "the road a liquid mess" beautifully put Henry, even more visual than falling amongst exquisite violets! :)


Paul Must read this again; thanks for reminding me Henry


Kalliope I am thankful for this, Henry, because you remind me with your cinematic style thst I want to read this again. I will soon have a room with such a view.


Henry Avila Dolors wrote: ""the road a liquid mess" beautifully put Henry, even more visual than falling amongst exquisite violets! :)"
Dolors,I really appreciate your nice words.Surprised how good the novel was.


Henry Avila Paul wrote: "Must read this again; thanks for reminding me Henry"
Paul as always thanks, it is a pleasure reading about the Delightful British...


Henry Avila Kalliope wrote: "I am thankful for this, Henry, because you remind me with your cinematic style thst I want to read this again. I will soon have a room with such a view."
But be careful walking on the violets,Kalliope.Thanks again.


message 13: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Henry wrote: "Thanks K.D.My first of the author's ,but not my Last!"

Go, Henry!!!


message 14: by Henry (last edited Jul 02, 2014 07:48AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Thanks,K.D. since I seen all the films made of his books,I was curious to read the original material...


message 15: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Henry wrote: "Thanks,K.D. since I seen all the films made of his books,I was curious to read the original material..."

Really? I only saw one maybe 20 years ago.


Henry Avila Very classy movies, see this one, A Room etc, my favorite, they made money but not huge hits, no explosives or building being destroyed.Maggie Smith is great in it, as are all the cast members...


message 17: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Ok, I will. I have Howard's End movie adaptation. Also Great Expectations. Two unforgettable movie adaptation of a classic novel that I will forever like are Gone With the Wind and Doctor Zhivago. I hope they do remakes of those.


Henry Avila Too expensive now,K.D.


message 19: by Arah-Lynda (new) - added it

Arah-Lynda Blood on the photographs, wet darkness, exquisite violets, roads a liquid mess.......Tell me more. Excellent Henry.


Henry Avila Thanks again Arah-Lynda.A very good book to read and enjoy, I did.


message 21: by Jareed (new)

Jareed Wonderful Henry, as always!


Henry Avila Jareed, I thank you sincerely,it was a fun book to read.


message 23: by Sheryl (new)

Sheryl Tribble Have you read Howard's End, Henry? I haven't read any Forster but was considering that one, however now I'm thinking "A Room with a View" would be a better choice for me....


Henry Avila This is my first book from the author, but now, will read others, Sheryl.


message 25: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Henry wrote: "This is my first book from the author, but now, will read others, Sheryl."

Henry, what will be your next Forster?


Henry Avila He only wrote six, quit doing novels early,so a limited selection K.D.Probably Howard's End or a Passage to India.


message 27: by K.D. (new) - added it

K.D. Absolutely Henry wrote: "He only wrote six, quit doing novels early,so a limited selection K.D.Probably Howard's End or a Passage to India."

I liked Passage. I will go for Howard's. I'll look forward to discussing the book with you. When do you plan to read it?


Henry Avila It will be a while, have so many unread books at home,K.D.


message 29: by Lynne (last edited Aug 13, 2014 03:49AM) (new)

Lynne King Henry, What a delightful review!

And as for " A half - hour later, the two cousins open the windows ( the British love to do this), the new rooms with a view!" How do you know that we love to do this? Have you made a study on it or read about it?


Henry Avila From books and films Lynne,Americans don't care.As long as it's a good room...


message 31: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King Henry, A view is indeed very important. Can you imagine a super room and with the most awful view!

I think that I would rather have a mediocre room with a fabulous view!


Henry Avila Very English of you .


Henry Avila Thank you, Sabah, I needs to read more of his books.


message 34: by Ellie (last edited Jan 12, 2017 07:13AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ellie Favorite line (one of them) in your review: "a new flighty friend, at the pension, and future bad novelist"

You are such a good writer, Henry, and your reviews are always a delight.

I like this novel a lot but find it amusing but also, somehow (I'm not sure why), a little sad.

I strongly recommend his work A Passage to India, brilliant. One of my favorite works.


message 35: by Supratim (new)

Supratim Good review, Henry!


Henry Avila Ellie wrote: "Favorite line (one of them) in your review: "a new flighty friend, at the pension, and future bad novelist"

You are such a good writer, Henry, and your reviews are always a delight.

I like this n..."
Thank you very much, Ellie, I read , A Passage to India , in August, I think next will be Howards End, even with the missing apostrophe, in Howards....


message 37: by Henry (last edited Jan 12, 2017 06:00PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Supratim wrote: "Good review, Henry!"I am Glad you liked it, Supratim, always hope, people do...


Henry Avila Yes indeed, such fun to read...


message 39: by Jessica's (new)

Jessica's Totally Over The Top Book Obsession Great review sweetie :)


Henry Avila Jessica, I thank you so very much.......


Henry Avila Hello, Alessandra, good to hear from you....


message 43: by Sketchbook (new)

Sketchbook Note : the title is Howards End. Not Howard's.


message 44: by Henry (last edited Jan 15, 2017 07:03PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Henry Avila Thank you Sketchbook, I knew that, but it doesn't look right ,and the hidden reason the author wrote it , is still a mystery... I must admit , I write it both ways, in my comments...


message 45: by Sketchbook (new)

Sketchbook GRs make the error, not you. It's lack of reader observation. Same as on review of the book itself.


message 46: by Sketchbook (new)

Sketchbook K.D. wrote: "Ok, I will. I have Howard's End movie adaptation. Also Great Expectations. Two unforgettable movie adaptation of a classic novel that I will forever like are Gone With the Wind and Doctor Zhivago. ..."

One should only remake bad movies.


message 47: by Sketchbook (last edited Jan 15, 2017 09:00PM) (new)

Sketchbook Lynne wrote: "Henry, A view is indeed very important. Can you imagine a super room and with the most awful view!

I think that I would rather have a mediocre room with a fabulous view!"


I go for comfort, One is usually only in room to sleep, no ? :)


Ellie No-I love a beautiful view. Such a great way to begin (and end) a day. Sets up the whole day for dreaming.


Henry Avila A great title for a book...


Sharon Barrow Wilfong I like the way you formulated your review into a story about a story. Great review! It was fun to read. If I hadn't already read it, I'd want to based on your review.


« previous 1
back to top