Sally's Reviews > The Woman in Me
The Woman in Me
by
by
** spoiler alert **
First of all, I would like to say that, being a 90s kid, I loved Britney Spears growing up. That being said, I am not an undying Britney stan who will ignore all the problematic behaviors she exhibits, simply because of who she is. If her IG wasn't proof enough of her instability, this book does her absolutely no favors. The writing comes off as disjointed, almost manic at times--the naïve, childlike, angry ramblings of someone with no insight into her behavior. It does very little to counter the claims of her mental instability and inability to govern herself.
For example, she admits to using Adderall and OTC caffeine/energy supplements, and with the way she rambles in her own writing, it doesn't take much to believe that she did indeed abuse them, which is what she says her doctors and her father was accusing her of multiple times in the book. Her own thought process in the book just makes her come across as a speed freak in denial. It's also very clear that she has the mentality of a child. There's a part in the book where she says she went through a battery of cognitive testing and was told by her father that she failed, and I don't doubt that was true and not just something that her father said to her. With the way she presents her thoughts in this book and the level of naïveté that comes across, you end up wondering if there is some sort of intellectual deficiency going on, or if it's just an extreme failure in her education, due to working in the entertainment business since she was a child and likely nobody prioritizing that for her. Either way, it's very clear that she doesn't possess the thought processes one would expect of someone her age.
To be clear, I believe that assertion that she makes in this book that the conservatorship was about money and control by her family. That fact is very clear. There were egregious abuses committed against her by the people involved. That being said, it is also very clear that she is extremely mentally ill, and I can very easily see how she could've been kept in that situation for so long because she displays no insight into her own problematic behaviors, and she does not present the way a sane 40 year old adult should.
I honestly think she is permanently broken, and I'm sad for her and especially for her kids. I don't think she's particularly interested in getting help, because I don't think she thinks there's anything wrong with her; which, is her prerogative now, I guess. At the very least, I hope she finds some semblance of peace and happiness.
At the end of the day, this book wasn't worth the read. While I wasn't expecting award-winning writing, I find it hard to believe that she wrote this book by herself, and I have no idea why the ghost writers, the editors, and her lawyers didn't do a better job cleaning up this book and at least helping her to present her side of the story in a way that doesn't end up making you wonder if the conservatorship was justified and is, in someways, maybe still needed--albeit, without her family's involvement.
For example, she admits to using Adderall and OTC caffeine/energy supplements, and with the way she rambles in her own writing, it doesn't take much to believe that she did indeed abuse them, which is what she says her doctors and her father was accusing her of multiple times in the book. Her own thought process in the book just makes her come across as a speed freak in denial. It's also very clear that she has the mentality of a child. There's a part in the book where she says she went through a battery of cognitive testing and was told by her father that she failed, and I don't doubt that was true and not just something that her father said to her. With the way she presents her thoughts in this book and the level of naïveté that comes across, you end up wondering if there is some sort of intellectual deficiency going on, or if it's just an extreme failure in her education, due to working in the entertainment business since she was a child and likely nobody prioritizing that for her. Either way, it's very clear that she doesn't possess the thought processes one would expect of someone her age.
To be clear, I believe that assertion that she makes in this book that the conservatorship was about money and control by her family. That fact is very clear. There were egregious abuses committed against her by the people involved. That being said, it is also very clear that she is extremely mentally ill, and I can very easily see how she could've been kept in that situation for so long because she displays no insight into her own problematic behaviors, and she does not present the way a sane 40 year old adult should.
I honestly think she is permanently broken, and I'm sad for her and especially for her kids. I don't think she's particularly interested in getting help, because I don't think she thinks there's anything wrong with her; which, is her prerogative now, I guess. At the very least, I hope she finds some semblance of peace and happiness.
At the end of the day, this book wasn't worth the read. While I wasn't expecting award-winning writing, I find it hard to believe that she wrote this book by herself, and I have no idea why the ghost writers, the editors, and her lawyers didn't do a better job cleaning up this book and at least helping her to present her side of the story in a way that doesn't end up making you wonder if the conservatorship was justified and is, in someways, maybe still needed--albeit, without her family's involvement.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Woman in Me.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
October 26, 2023
–
Started Reading
October 26, 2023
– Shelved
October 31, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Melynda
(new)
Nov 03, 2023 02:38PM
Agree with everything.
reply
|
flag
I very much agree. She still has so much (at times warranted) anger, and so much denial. She wasn’t ready to write this memoir. She needs help. The yes-men now review bombing and telling her Yass Queen aren’t helping her.
I am.just starting the book and frankly, deciding whether to continue. The writing is just beyond awful and I cannot beleive her management team allowed it to be published as it is. Since I am still in the early part of her life, I can already see failures in the adults around her to turn a blind eye to her obvious emotional amd psychological issues even at that age. When she returned to Louisiana to "try to live a slow normal.life," that is when all the stops should have been pulled out, to keep her in a safe space emotionally and physically. The outcome for a child star such as Britney is more often disastrous than not, even when they have the most stable of families behind them (which she did not.) I'm.not sure if this affected her sister's decision later to pull.back, or if her parents had any influence in that choice, but I can't help but wonder how differently things would have turned out for Britney if she had done the same. Such a sad story, and one that I hope other parents will.take note of if they are tempted to push their young children into the spotlight.
Agree with every word. So many are quick to ignore that she suffers from mental illness and sadly no one around her can help her if she doesn’t believe she needs the help.
Glad to see these comments. It was clear almost immediately that this book had a manic undertone. I will say I have felt sorry for her for many years and this book amplified that feeling. I just hope she gets the help she needs.
As a mental health professional reading this book, I felt exactly the same. you worded it way better than I. She is not okay. She needs help. Its sad her team let this book be published. She didnt deserve any of what happened to her, but she also has zero insight whatsoever into her mental health issues. It was very sad to read.
You had me until you said the conservatorship was justified or should be continued. That is not what a conservatorship is for. As someone with a family member who is far more mentally ill but would still never qualify for a conservatorship, I can tell you that if she can work, take her children on vacation, etc, she should not be controlled by a conservatorship.