Lisa's Reviews > Persuasion
Persuasion
by
by
Lisa's review
bookshelves: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die, favorites, jane-austen, persuasive
Feb 04, 2018
bookshelves: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die, favorites, jane-austen, persuasive
to persuade (verb)
“to make someone do or believe something by giving them a good reason to do it or by talking to that person and making them believe it”
Jane Austen delivers a PERSUASIVE analysis of the concept of PERSUASION, slowly PERSUADING the reader that being of a PERSUADABLE temper, commonly regarded as a virtue in young women of her time, is a weakness and a barrier to personal happiness.
Why?
The answer is quite simple, and still as valid as two centuries ago: more often than not, the kind, caring and sensitive characters tend to be PERSUADABLE, whereas the egotistical, narcissistic, and stubborn bullies tend to be PERSUASIVE.
Anne Elliot, the classical Cinderella in a vain, ambitious and superficial family, sacrifices her love to accommodate the pride and prejudice of those who call themselves her friends and allies. Eight years pass during which she PERSUADES herself that her role is that of a supporting member of the family, patiently attending to the tantrums of her sisters and accepting the disregard of her conceited father.
When her former love unexpectedly enters the stage again, they both remain PERSUADED that the other one is lost forever, and play a PERSUASIVE game of dissimulation before finally reaching the PERSUASION that love conquers all - even society’s coercive directives.
The lesson learned from this social study is that there is hardly a case in which PERSUASION is unbiased and truly beneficial. The moment a person needs to be convinced to do something against his or her natural inclination, all kinds of complications, sacrifices and frustrations are likely to follow.
Listen to yourself before you listen to PERSUASIVE bullies, is my PERSUASION, after reading Jane Austen.
I was thus a PERSUADABLE reader.
“to make someone do or believe something by giving them a good reason to do it or by talking to that person and making them believe it”
Jane Austen delivers a PERSUASIVE analysis of the concept of PERSUASION, slowly PERSUADING the reader that being of a PERSUADABLE temper, commonly regarded as a virtue in young women of her time, is a weakness and a barrier to personal happiness.
Why?
The answer is quite simple, and still as valid as two centuries ago: more often than not, the kind, caring and sensitive characters tend to be PERSUADABLE, whereas the egotistical, narcissistic, and stubborn bullies tend to be PERSUASIVE.
Anne Elliot, the classical Cinderella in a vain, ambitious and superficial family, sacrifices her love to accommodate the pride and prejudice of those who call themselves her friends and allies. Eight years pass during which she PERSUADES herself that her role is that of a supporting member of the family, patiently attending to the tantrums of her sisters and accepting the disregard of her conceited father.
When her former love unexpectedly enters the stage again, they both remain PERSUADED that the other one is lost forever, and play a PERSUASIVE game of dissimulation before finally reaching the PERSUASION that love conquers all - even society’s coercive directives.
The lesson learned from this social study is that there is hardly a case in which PERSUASION is unbiased and truly beneficial. The moment a person needs to be convinced to do something against his or her natural inclination, all kinds of complications, sacrifices and frustrations are likely to follow.
Listen to yourself before you listen to PERSUASIVE bullies, is my PERSUASION, after reading Jane Austen.
I was thus a PERSUADABLE reader.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Persuasion.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 2, 2018
–
Started Reading
February 2, 2018
– Shelved
February 2, 2018
–
23.69%
""She had given him up to oblige others. It had been the effect of over-persuasion. It had been weakness and timidity."
"
page
59
"
February 3, 2018
–
55.82%
""The worst of Bath was, the number of its plain women. He did not mean to say that there were no pretty women, but the number of the plain was out of all proportion. He had frequently observed, as he walked, that one handsome face could be followed by thirty, or five and thirty frights..."
Oh horror! Beware of frightful Bath!"
page
139
Oh horror! Beware of frightful Bath!"
February 4, 2018
– Shelved as:
1001-books-to-read-before-you-die
February 4, 2018
– Shelved as:
favorites
February 4, 2018
– Shelved as:
jane-austen
February 4, 2018
– Shelved as:
persuasive
February 4, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Manybooks
(new)
-
added it
Feb 04, 2018 10:05AM
Most of the time, men who comment about "plain women" are pretty much the same if not actually downright ugly both inside and out.
reply
|
flag
Als ich "Persuasion" vor einigen Jahren las, verstörte es mich im positiven Sinne, weil es anders ist als seine berühmten Geschwister wie "Pride & Prejudice", "Emma" etc. Ich empfand es als recht melancholisch, was mir gefiel. - Vielleicht sollte ich es ein zweites Mal zur Hand nehmen ...
Shamefully admitting persuasion is at the core of my profession, you have persuaded me to read this, Lisa (as long as books are concerned, we can shamelessly cherish our persuasibility).
You've thoroughly parsed the lesson in this book, Lisa!
But it's strange that what I remember about it is how solid Anne Elliot was in spite of all the strong forces seeking to persuade her.
But it's strange that what I remember about it is how solid Anne Elliot was in spite of all the strong forces seeking to persuade her.
Manybooks wrote: "Most of the time, men who comment about "plain women" are pretty much the same if not actually downright ugly both inside and out."
Couldn't agree more, Gundula! It is a scene of comical power - Anne's vain father counting frights in Bath!
Couldn't agree more, Gundula! It is a scene of comical power - Anne's vain father counting frights in Bath!
Lisa wrote: "Manybooks wrote: "Most of the time, men who comment about "plain women" are pretty much the same if not actually downright ugly both inside and out."
Couldn't agree more, Gundula! It is a scene of..."
I need to reread this.
Couldn't agree more, Gundula! It is a scene of..."
I need to reread this.
Antje wrote: "Als ich "Persuasion" vor einigen Jahren las, verstörte es mich im positiven Sinne, weil es anders ist als seine berühmten Geschwister wie "Pride & Prejudice", "Emma" etc. Ich empfand es als recht m..."
Es ist ziemlich melancholisch, genau wie du sagst - im positiven Sinn!
Es ist ziemlich melancholisch, genau wie du sagst - im positiven Sinn!
Ilse wrote: "Shamefully admitting persuasion is at the core of my profession, you have persuaded me to read this, Lisa (as long as books are concerned, we can shamelessly cherish our persuasibility)."
I hadn't thought of it that way, but you are of course right, Ilse! Both lawyers and teachers have to know the art of PERSUASION more than anything :-)
I hadn't thought of it that way, but you are of course right, Ilse! Both lawyers and teachers have to know the art of PERSUASION more than anything :-)
Fionnuala wrote: "You've thoroughly parsed the lesson in this book, Lisa!
But it's strange that what I remember about it is how solid Anne Elliot was in spite of all the strong forces seeking to persuade her."
I agree, Fionnuala! She was solid, and in the end, she listened to the most persuasive voice - her own!
But it's strange that what I remember about it is how solid Anne Elliot was in spite of all the strong forces seeking to persuade her."
I agree, Fionnuala! She was solid, and in the end, she listened to the most persuasive voice - her own!
Jaline wrote: "I loved this book, but your review just might have PERSUADED me into a re-read! 😊"
So glad to hear that, Jaline!
So glad to hear that, Jaline!
Eleanor wrote: "Lovely review of my favourite Austen, much as I love the other books also!"
I still have two to go before I can say which is my favourite, but it seems like it is similar to my Dickens favourite system - the last I read is the one I like best...
I still have two to go before I can say which is my favourite, but it seems like it is similar to my Dickens favourite system - the last I read is the one I like best...
Dolors wrote: "You've persuaded me that I should re-read this novel, Lisa..."
I am persuaded you will have a good time, Dolors!
I am persuaded you will have a good time, Dolors!
Kevin wrote: "Perched on a chair, I personally purred all the way through your perfect peroration, Lisa!"
As an alliteration afficionada - I loved your comment, Kevin!
As an alliteration afficionada - I loved your comment, Kevin!
Steven wrote: "A persuasive review Lisa, may persuade me to read Persuasion someday!"
I hope you will, Steven!
I hope you will, Steven!
Ghost of the Library wrote: "my favorite J.A book and one of my top 10 ...lovely review, you do it full justice."
Thank you, Ghost of the Library!
Thank you, Ghost of the Library!