Jordan Price's Reviews > Grave Peril

Grave Peril by Jim Butcher
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2709426
's review


I loved aspects of this story and hated others. I adored the magic, the description of how power worked, how Harry created his spells. I also loved how he got put through the wringer and had to really be willing to sacrifice himself for the survival of the people he loved.

I hated the female characters. I hated that their breasts were described at every available opportunity, particularly the villains. During a climactic fight scene, a female villain was "distracted" by a vampire sliding his hands under her top, and I thought, "Yes, of course the story had to go there." Susan, the girlfriend character, walks into danger and puts everyone else in danger with such willfully ignorant and selfish motives I could scream. (She is supposed to be smart, so why does she do something so moronic?) I feel like the women are all selfish sex objects.

The writing technique is mostly clean and conversational with a few dips into purple prose, but I noticed the tendency to hurtle up to a tipping point, end the chapter, and then draw way, way back into a philosophical musing at the beginning of the next chapter rather than continuing with the action. I would have liked that on occasion, but not chapter after chapter.

So even though I rated it a three (because of the icky representation of women), I really loved certain elements of the book, and reading the way it was worded and constructed helped me wrap my head around the way I approach writing myself, what works for me and what doesn't.
32 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Grave Peril.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
July 27, 2010 – Shelved
July 27, 2010 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jordan (new) - added it

Jordan Price I went to the author's website and it looks like he's happily married and has all kinds of interests in common with his wife, so no, I don't think he dislikes women per se either! A fellow author has suggested maybe this is just the way he's characterizing Harry Dresden, but even so...given the way Harry gets all blubbery about telling Susan "I love you," it doesn't seem like an intentional character train.


message 2: by Ryan (new)

Ryan it's actually explained that susan survived a tangle with werewolves so she thought (oh I can survive vampires.) the problem was that the reds were a whole different breed and because harry neglected to tell her out of arrogance she had no way of knowing. It's also explained that he has no real experience. Most of his life was spent with ONE girl, who he thought betrayed him (he didn't know the truth til later


Jenny Ow yes, I love the series but for the love of the blue sky it would be wonderful if he stopped making every woman incredibly hot. Its really annoying. I'm not entirely sure if this is a characterization of Harry or just a kink from the author. Besides that, its a good read.


Andrew Loughridge The Dresden Files is written from a first person, past tense perspective. You get the full Harry experience, and that means describing whatever he happens to notice or focus on. Harry also happens to be a man and is, by self description, very old fashioned about women.

So, of course we're going to be taken along for a little bit of boob-noticing. I also have no idea what you mean about the general portrayal of females in the books. Karin Murphy and later on Molly Carpenter are some of the best female characters I've experienced in a book. Hell, give me my own series about EITHER one of those characters, I will gladly read it.


message 5: by Kristy (new)

Kristy Gilham I am late to the party on these books but this one drove me crazy! Susan put HERSELF in danger but Harry kept blaming himself. Murphy does the same thing. It's like the author doesn't know how to write a strong female so just makes her arrogant and quite frankly stupid. Why wouldn't either female listen to this wizard - who obviously knows what he is talking about??
The martyr complex better leave or I'm not sure I'm going to make it through. No Harry you are not to blame for every bad thing ever. Enough already. These females need to be strong but not selfish and self righteous. He told Susan not to go - she went anyway and then it's his fault? Same with Murphy - she always wants him to come up with the answer on the case and he better do it right now - oh but then get out of her way. Really hope these books get as good as everyone is saying.


back to top