What do you think?
Rate this book
Whispering Key #3
Off Key
I’m about to sing you the saddest song in the universe, and it’s called “The Man of My Dreams Married My Sister.”
It’s kinda my theme song. And trust me when I tell you, it’s heavy on the violins.
Because the man in question? He’s not just any guy, he’s Rafe freakin’ Goodman.
My former best friend.
The boy who made my summers on Whispering Key magical. The guy who inspired every love song that led to the chart-topping music career I have today. The man I always sort of figured would wait for me, while I pursued my dreams and finally found a way to tell the world I was gay…
But instead of waiting, he married Aimee.
Rafe and Aimee’s marriage has been over for a while now, but it doesn’t really matter. He doesn’t love me even though I feel like I’ll love him until the day I die. Trying to be “just friends” would tear me apart.
We’re a broken chord. A blue note. Hopelessly out of tune.
Or so I thought.
But when circumstances throw us back together on a crazy cross-country road trip, suddenly all kinds of secrets come to light that make it seem like maybe our show’s not over yet.
If I want a life with the man of my dreams, though, I’ll have to be honest--with Rafe and the rest of the world, too--and find the courage to write us a new song.
One that’s exactly like us: perfectly imperfect… and a little off key.
It’s kinda my theme song. And trust me when I tell you, it’s heavy on the violins.
Because the man in question? He’s not just any guy, he’s Rafe freakin’ Goodman.
My former best friend.
The boy who made my summers on Whispering Key magical. The guy who inspired every love song that led to the chart-topping music career I have today. The man I always sort of figured would wait for me, while I pursued my dreams and finally found a way to tell the world I was gay…
But instead of waiting, he married Aimee.
Rafe and Aimee’s marriage has been over for a while now, but it doesn’t really matter. He doesn’t love me even though I feel like I’ll love him until the day I die. Trying to be “just friends” would tear me apart.
We’re a broken chord. A blue note. Hopelessly out of tune.
Or so I thought.
But when circumstances throw us back together on a crazy cross-country road trip, suddenly all kinds of secrets come to light that make it seem like maybe our show’s not over yet.
If I want a life with the man of my dreams, though, I’ll have to be honest--with Rafe and the rest of the world, too--and find the courage to write us a new song.
One that’s exactly like us: perfectly imperfect… and a little off key.
344 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 14, 2021
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 273 reviews
May 16, 2021
5 “you and me, partners in crime” stars
“It came to my attention that if you want to grow something, you can’t keep it in the shadows. And you and I are meant for sunshine, Rafe Goodman.”
I will be honest, I very much struggle with writing my review for this book, I have no clue how to gather my thoughts in a way that will make sense. I also have no clue how to explain how I spent 60% of a book wanting to yell at one of the two characters (as in the two main characters kept doing things that did not make any sense) but i’m still madly in love with the book.
I started this book at 1 am last night and told myself I would only read a little before bed, I got really into the book and forgot to look at the time and when I thought about checking the time, it was suddently 6 am and I had almost read the entire book. There is something about the books in this series that is really addictive and it pulls me in each time.
I was very much waiting for this one since book 1 in the series and I am happy to report that it was exactly what I wanted it to be.
Brief summary:
Jay and Rafe were best friends when they were younger. Jay is a popular musician and he is gay but he had never told anyone and he doesn’t want to come out publicly. Jay has been in love with Rafe for ages but he never told him and he cut all contact with Rafe when Rafe married Jay’s sister. Rafe was also in love with Jay before. So now they’re both bitter and hate each other but they go on a roadtrip together and they confess their feelings for the other and they get together.
Special mention to the best friends to enemies to lovers trope, I just love this trope so much.
First, I still adore Whispering Key so much. We don’t spend the entire book in town, which is a shame, but I liked that we meet a lot of characters from other towns that are exactly like the residents of Whispering Key, so I didn’t miss my dear meddling residents too much. I just love how fleshed out the town is and all of the residents on it, it’s just the best. I really love how vivid everything was and how nicely described their surroundings were, it just felt like I was on their adventure with them. Also I love Chet, he’s just the best. And Oak too, Oak badly heeds a book and I will riot if he doesn’t get one.
Second, the pining in this book was just fantastic. I loved how much Jay was pining for Rafe. Jay’s first album was all about Rafe and how he loves him and damn it was the sweetest thing ever. And Rafe did a lot of things that showed how much he loves Jay and just wants to be with him. I loved how much these two wanted to be together.
Third, now on to why I wanted to yell at these characters. This entire book could have been avoided if these people sat down and had a conversation. The entire plot of the book and why they hated each other could have easily been avoided if they talked to each other. At one point I wanted to throw my kindle at the wall every 2 seconds because these guys just never talked to each other and explained their feelings, they just got mad at the other over assumptions. But for some reason, I still madly adored this book. Even when I wanted them to just talk to each other and fix their issues, I still had so much fun reading the book. These guys were fools but they were lovable fools and I loved them very much for it. Also I really liked that it was shown that they were so blinded by their hate of the other that they couldn’t see what was in front of them, that felt really realistic to me and helped explain a lot of why they just didn’t communicate and fix their issues before that moment.
Fourth, I loved the relationship progression so much. I loved how they went to hating each other, to tolerating each other, to admitting that they love the other and have for years, to being in love to being a forever couple. I also really enjoyed how their friendship didn’t come back easily and how it was awkward for them at first. There was just enough time spent exploring every phase of their relationship for me and everything about it how progressed just worked for me.
Special mention to the character progression, I just loved how they went from grumpy because they didn’t have the other in their life, to sunshine because they had in other in their life, that was just so perfect.
Fifth, I have been experiencing a problem where I am not able to stop crying over books. This book absolutely wrecked me, I swear I shed 1 or 1342353 tears at least once during every chapter.
Sixth, I often struggle with books where characters have a connection and have been in love with the other character before the book because it’s often hard for me to see their connection and why they love that character but it wasn’t the case here. I how strongly their connection from before was built, it was easy to tell that they both were in love woth the other and it showed everything they did. I also loved that even when they hated each other, you could feel how much they loved each other under the hate.
Seventh, I just loved these guys together, so much. They were such a good pair and they fit together perfectly. They also just worked so well together. I loved their banter too, it was lovely. I also loved how Jay opened up about how lonely he is and how rafe just wanted to show him he’s in his corner and that he’ll never be alone again, it was just the sweetest thing. I also loved how they competed against the other, it was just so good.
Also special mention to their love of stargazing and watching the stars together, that was such an important theme in the book and I absolutely loved it.
Eight, I just loved how it they got together, so much. Everything about it was perfect. I loved how it was made up of a couple of moments that resulted in them realizing that the other loves them too. Special mention to Rafe singing the song that Jay wrote about him, to Jay, to show him that he loves him too. That was such a perfect scene, I just loved it so much. I very much loved that when they got together and started talking, and realized how communication is important (which thank god they realized because I would have ripped my hair out of these two didn’t communicate one more time) they were all in, that was in, nothing could break it. Also special mention to when Jay realized what he wants out of life, that moment was so so perfect and so worth the journey it took to get there.
This wasn’t just a moment; it was the moment. The one I’d been working for my whole life. The one I was supposed to tell my grandkids about someday. But when I closed my eyes, all I saw were white sand beaches and swaying palm trees, busybody residents toting spaghetti casseroles, and the broad, capable shoulders of the man I loved.
Also another special mention to the ending of this book. My heart was melting so much, I don’t think I have ever swooned this much in my life. The ending was all I wanted out of this book. The ending was just so satisfying and worth every minutes I spent wanting to yell at the characters.
This book was pure fun, ridiculous and way over the top and I absolutely adored every seconds I spent reading it. I cannot stop thinking about this book and I probably will think about it for weeks. And i’m so excited for Gage’s book and I really really hope he ends up with a certain someone with a neck tattoo.
“It came to my attention that if you want to grow something, you can’t keep it in the shadows. And you and I are meant for sunshine, Rafe Goodman.”
I will be honest, I very much struggle with writing my review for this book, I have no clue how to gather my thoughts in a way that will make sense. I also have no clue how to explain how I spent 60% of a book wanting to yell at one of the two characters (as in the two main characters kept doing things that did not make any sense) but i’m still madly in love with the book.
I started this book at 1 am last night and told myself I would only read a little before bed, I got really into the book and forgot to look at the time and when I thought about checking the time, it was suddently 6 am and I had almost read the entire book. There is something about the books in this series that is really addictive and it pulls me in each time.
I was very much waiting for this one since book 1 in the series and I am happy to report that it was exactly what I wanted it to be.
Brief summary:
Jay and Rafe were best friends when they were younger. Jay is a popular musician and he is gay but he had never told anyone and he doesn’t want to come out publicly. Jay has been in love with Rafe for ages but he never told him and he cut all contact with Rafe when Rafe married Jay’s sister. Rafe was also in love with Jay before. So now they’re both bitter and hate each other but they go on a roadtrip together and they confess their feelings for the other and they get together.
Special mention to the best friends to enemies to lovers trope, I just love this trope so much.
First, I still adore Whispering Key so much. We don’t spend the entire book in town, which is a shame, but I liked that we meet a lot of characters from other towns that are exactly like the residents of Whispering Key, so I didn’t miss my dear meddling residents too much. I just love how fleshed out the town is and all of the residents on it, it’s just the best. I really love how vivid everything was and how nicely described their surroundings were, it just felt like I was on their adventure with them. Also I love Chet, he’s just the best. And Oak too, Oak badly heeds a book and I will riot if he doesn’t get one.
Second, the pining in this book was just fantastic. I loved how much Jay was pining for Rafe. Jay’s first album was all about Rafe and how he loves him and damn it was the sweetest thing ever. And Rafe did a lot of things that showed how much he loves Jay and just wants to be with him. I loved how much these two wanted to be together.
Third, now on to why I wanted to yell at these characters. This entire book could have been avoided if these people sat down and had a conversation. The entire plot of the book and why they hated each other could have easily been avoided if they talked to each other. At one point I wanted to throw my kindle at the wall every 2 seconds because these guys just never talked to each other and explained their feelings, they just got mad at the other over assumptions. But for some reason, I still madly adored this book. Even when I wanted them to just talk to each other and fix their issues, I still had so much fun reading the book. These guys were fools but they were lovable fools and I loved them very much for it. Also I really liked that it was shown that they were so blinded by their hate of the other that they couldn’t see what was in front of them, that felt really realistic to me and helped explain a lot of why they just didn’t communicate and fix their issues before that moment.
Fourth, I loved the relationship progression so much. I loved how they went to hating each other, to tolerating each other, to admitting that they love the other and have for years, to being in love to being a forever couple. I also really enjoyed how their friendship didn’t come back easily and how it was awkward for them at first. There was just enough time spent exploring every phase of their relationship for me and everything about it how progressed just worked for me.
Special mention to the character progression, I just loved how they went from grumpy because they didn’t have the other in their life, to sunshine because they had in other in their life, that was just so perfect.
Fifth, I have been experiencing a problem where I am not able to stop crying over books. This book absolutely wrecked me, I swear I shed 1 or 1342353 tears at least once during every chapter.
Sixth, I often struggle with books where characters have a connection and have been in love with the other character before the book because it’s often hard for me to see their connection and why they love that character but it wasn’t the case here. I how strongly their connection from before was built, it was easy to tell that they both were in love woth the other and it showed everything they did. I also loved that even when they hated each other, you could feel how much they loved each other under the hate.
Seventh, I just loved these guys together, so much. They were such a good pair and they fit together perfectly. They also just worked so well together. I loved their banter too, it was lovely. I also loved how Jay opened up about how lonely he is and how rafe just wanted to show him he’s in his corner and that he’ll never be alone again, it was just the sweetest thing. I also loved how they competed against the other, it was just so good.
Also special mention to their love of stargazing and watching the stars together, that was such an important theme in the book and I absolutely loved it.
Eight, I just loved how it they got together, so much. Everything about it was perfect. I loved how it was made up of a couple of moments that resulted in them realizing that the other loves them too. Special mention to Rafe singing the song that Jay wrote about him, to Jay, to show him that he loves him too. That was such a perfect scene, I just loved it so much. I very much loved that when they got together and started talking, and realized how communication is important (which thank god they realized because I would have ripped my hair out of these two didn’t communicate one more time) they were all in, that was in, nothing could break it. Also special mention to when Jay realized what he wants out of life, that moment was so so perfect and so worth the journey it took to get there.
This wasn’t just a moment; it was the moment. The one I’d been working for my whole life. The one I was supposed to tell my grandkids about someday. But when I closed my eyes, all I saw were white sand beaches and swaying palm trees, busybody residents toting spaghetti casseroles, and the broad, capable shoulders of the man I loved.
Also another special mention to the ending of this book. My heart was melting so much, I don’t think I have ever swooned this much in my life. The ending was all I wanted out of this book. The ending was just so satisfying and worth every minutes I spent wanting to yell at the characters.
This book was pure fun, ridiculous and way over the top and I absolutely adored every seconds I spent reading it. I cannot stop thinking about this book and I probably will think about it for weeks. And i’m so excited for Gage’s book and I really really hope he ends up with a certain someone with a neck tattoo.
May 21, 2021
~4.5~
Welcome back to Whispering Key where hot men come to find love.
In Off Key, we meet Jay (or Jayd as his fans call him), a former summer townie turned popular musician. Jay hasn't visited the island in years, not since his best friend and teenage crush, Rafe, betrayed him by marrying his sister, Aimee.
When I first read the blurb, I died a little inside, because as much as I love this series, I hate the "sloppy seconds" trope more. But one of my friends reassured me that it wasn't like that at all. Hallelujah!
If Jay and Rafe had just been honest from the very beginning, they could have saved each other a lot of heartache and resentment. I wasn't sure who was the biggest culprit: Jay, Rafe, or Aimee. Regardless, the lack of communication about killed me.
Even so, I adored this friends-to-enemies-to-lovers story, which features:
- kidnapping, complete with an unmarked van (just like in the movies)
- impromptu road trip (because Rafe is scared of flying)
- pancakes vs. waffles debate (I'm Team Waffle all the way!)
- friends impersonating cops and cops with ridiculous names
- humor and friendship
- forgiveness and passion
- sexiversary
- HEA for the ages
It was fun visiting with the previous MCs, and the locals always crack me up.
In closing, let me present my fave words of wisdom courtesy of Lorenna McKetcham:
Cheap dicks work as well as expensive ones.
Amen, sister, AMEN.
Welcome back to Whispering Key where hot men come to find love.
In Off Key, we meet Jay (or Jayd as his fans call him), a former summer townie turned popular musician. Jay hasn't visited the island in years, not since his best friend and teenage crush, Rafe, betrayed him by marrying his sister, Aimee.
When I first read the blurb, I died a little inside, because as much as I love this series, I hate the "sloppy seconds" trope more. But one of my friends reassured me that it wasn't like that at all. Hallelujah!
If Jay and Rafe had just been honest from the very beginning, they could have saved each other a lot of heartache and resentment. I wasn't sure who was the biggest culprit: Jay, Rafe, or Aimee. Regardless, the lack of communication about killed me.
Even so, I adored this friends-to-enemies-to-lovers story, which features:
- kidnapping, complete with an unmarked van (just like in the movies)
- impromptu road trip (because Rafe is scared of flying)
- pancakes vs. waffles debate (I'm Team Waffle all the way!)
- friends impersonating cops and cops with ridiculous names
- humor and friendship
- forgiveness and passion
- sexiversary
- HEA for the ages
It was fun visiting with the previous MCs, and the locals always crack me up.
In closing, let me present my fave words of wisdom courtesy of Lorenna McKetcham:
Cheap dicks work as well as expensive ones.
Amen, sister, AMEN.
May 20, 2021
3,5 stars
I liked this book.
It has a lot of qualities I enjoy: some cracking banter, a nice second chance romance, some enemies to lovers vibes, some good chuckles and nice feels.
So, how come it never totally grabbed me or my heart?
Was it that the 'rock star' trope felt a little 'the same old'?
Was it that the two MCs sounded very similar to me?
Or that the plot is a teeny mad and contrived (and best not taken seriously)?
Saying that - the scene in which Rafe and Jay find out their true feelings via is absolutely brilliantly written! Never read anything like it. Very clever, imo!
This is, no doubt, good fun and a pleasant read, suitable for anyone looking for an angst-free, light romance. But it reminded me very much of another series by this author I never really took to.
I liked this book.
It has a lot of qualities I enjoy: some cracking banter, a nice second chance romance, some enemies to lovers vibes, some good chuckles and nice feels.
So, how come it never totally grabbed me or my heart?
Was it that the 'rock star' trope felt a little 'the same old'?
Was it that the two MCs sounded very similar to me?
Or that the plot is a teeny mad and contrived (and best not taken seriously)?
Saying that - the scene in which Rafe and Jay find out their true feelings via is absolutely brilliantly written! Never read anything like it. Very clever, imo!
This is, no doubt, good fun and a pleasant read, suitable for anyone looking for an angst-free, light romance. But it reminded me very much of another series by this author I never really took to.
May 16, 2021
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5/5 Stars
I generally know what to expect when I pick up a May Archer book. Light and fun, not too heavy on the angst, sexy with a good balance of steam to plot, likable characters and quirky, nosy townsfolk that can try my patience because that’s not really my thing. She doesn’t go full on Lucy Lennox, except when she’s writing with Lucy Lennox, but her towns can be too much for me. Still, they have a lot of heart so I can sometimes enjoy the little busybody weirdos. It really depends on my mood, how much I like that particular element of her books.
This book didn’t spend too much time in Whispering Key. But never fear, a tiny town called Dry Hump was there to fill the void. Yes really. Which was basically a hybrid of Whispering Key and O’Leary. Only less gay guys so I don’t see a spin-off happening there and that is fine by me.
Ok I got majorly distracted there. So. I’ve been waiting for Rafe and Jay’s book. I tried to not to let my expectations run wild, given my last experience of hyping a couple up in advance. It didn’t really work but I did try. 😂🤷🏻♀️
My thoughts? While I can’t say that I LOVED it, I did like it. The reason I didn’t love it was due to communication. Or rather the lack of it. Every hurdle, obstacle and argument these two had could have been solved with a few conversations. Not even long conversations either. Just giving each other a heads up on a few decisions would have worked wonders. A text message even. 😂 I knew when I read the first books that Rafe and Jay weren’t speaking. I expected the reason or reasons to be bigger. Ones that made sense.
The above paragraph is making it seem like I am bashing the book. Which is not my intention. Just wanted to explain why this was a like not love. That being said, there were many things I did like.
The writing flowed nicely. It held my interest. Sweet but not saccharine and fun! May Archer has this easy, breezy style that I can’t help but fall into. While they initially couldn’t communicate to save lives, Rafe and Jay had a love I believed in. And once they did get their acts together, they were all in and I loved that.
I guess now I’ll have to read the upcoming spin-off with Rafe’s brother Gage. It involves some kind of lumberjacks and an apple orchard because of course it does. I’m ready to both complain and gush over it.
I generally know what to expect when I pick up a May Archer book. Light and fun, not too heavy on the angst, sexy with a good balance of steam to plot, likable characters and quirky, nosy townsfolk that can try my patience because that’s not really my thing. She doesn’t go full on Lucy Lennox, except when she’s writing with Lucy Lennox, but her towns can be too much for me. Still, they have a lot of heart so I can sometimes enjoy the little busybody weirdos. It really depends on my mood, how much I like that particular element of her books.
This book didn’t spend too much time in Whispering Key. But never fear, a tiny town called Dry Hump was there to fill the void. Yes really. Which was basically a hybrid of Whispering Key and O’Leary. Only less gay guys so I don’t see a spin-off happening there and that is fine by me.
Ok I got majorly distracted there. So. I’ve been waiting for Rafe and Jay’s book. I tried to not to let my expectations run wild, given my last experience of hyping a couple up in advance. It didn’t really work but I did try. 😂🤷🏻♀️
My thoughts? While I can’t say that I LOVED it, I did like it. The reason I didn’t love it was due to communication. Or rather the lack of it. Every hurdle, obstacle and argument these two had could have been solved with a few conversations. Not even long conversations either. Just giving each other a heads up on a few decisions would have worked wonders. A text message even. 😂 I knew when I read the first books that Rafe and Jay weren’t speaking. I expected the reason or reasons to be bigger. Ones that made sense.
The above paragraph is making it seem like I am bashing the book. Which is not my intention. Just wanted to explain why this was a like not love. That being said, there were many things I did like.
The writing flowed nicely. It held my interest. Sweet but not saccharine and fun! May Archer has this easy, breezy style that I can’t help but fall into. While they initially couldn’t communicate to save lives, Rafe and Jay had a love I believed in. And once they did get their acts together, they were all in and I loved that.
I guess now I’ll have to read the upcoming spin-off with Rafe’s brother Gage. It involves some kind of lumberjacks and an apple orchard because of course it does. I’m ready to both complain and gush over it.
May 16, 2021
Best one yet - laugh out loud funny and super sweet
I LOVED this book. Big time loved it, from start to finish, there wasn't a part of the story that didn't work for me.
I alternated between laughing my head off and heart-warming expressions of happiness as perennially grumpy Rafe and Jay went through the wringer.
Honestly, I'm not sure which elements I loved most, Chet and the kidnap van theft, Rafe's determination to wind Jay up over another singing sensation or how Big Rafe seemed to have had it all planned out beforehand!
The whole Whispering Key series is just a complete delight and I'm intrigued to see where the spin off with Gage will go.
I LOVED this book. Big time loved it, from start to finish, there wasn't a part of the story that didn't work for me.
I alternated between laughing my head off and heart-warming expressions of happiness as perennially grumpy Rafe and Jay went through the wringer.
Honestly, I'm not sure which elements I loved most, Chet and the kidnap van theft, Rafe's determination to wind Jay up over another singing sensation or how Big Rafe seemed to have had it all planned out beforehand!
The whole Whispering Key series is just a complete delight and I'm intrigued to see where the spin off with Gage will go.
May 17, 2021
this was everything i didn��t know i needed.
sunshine and grumpy trope? ✅
sunshine and grumpy are also childhood best friends secretly in love with one another? ✅
mutual pining?✅
best friends turned enemies?✅
said enemies on a road trip and forced to confront a decade’s worth of unresolved feelings?✅
sign me the fuck up.
the snide remarks, petty bickering and banter, paralleled to the undertones of vulnerability and softness were just so intense. they goaded the shit out of each other while also being so helplessly in love with each other. both of them also pretending that they still didn’t love each other was hilariously cute— i mean, Jay wrote an entire ALBUM about his love for Rafe. even his goddamn phone password was Rafe’s birthday... even after all these years. god. and Rafe knew all of Jay’s songs word for word despite ‘hating’ him. he even SANG it at a shitty karaoke bar FOR Jay. if that’s not true love folks then idk what is. and when Rafe figures out the songs are all about him, i was teary-eyed af. these two were such big idiots for being so blind to how much they loved each other. just everything was *chef’s kiss*
the simmering slow burn from enemies to lovers was soooo satisfying too. i was afraid it’d be too quick and be unsatisfying. but their stubbornness proved for some top-tier, slow-burn pining and chemistry. and it made me root for them SO hard. i was on the edge of my seat (or sofa) desperately waiting for them to finally be together. when you’re so anxious and too impatient, i think that’s a sign of a really fucking good romance.
i think this quote sums up how beautiful this book was:
“It came to my attention that if you want to grow something, you can’t keep it in the shadows. And you and I are meant for sunshine, Rafe Goodman.”
the whole point of this is review is that best friends to enemies to lovers is god tier romance. thank u for coming to my Ted Talk.
sunshine and grumpy trope? ✅
sunshine and grumpy are also childhood best friends secretly in love with one another? ✅
mutual pining?✅
best friends turned enemies?✅
said enemies on a road trip and forced to confront a decade’s worth of unresolved feelings?✅
sign me the fuck up.
the snide remarks, petty bickering and banter, paralleled to the undertones of vulnerability and softness were just so intense. they goaded the shit out of each other while also being so helplessly in love with each other. both of them also pretending that they still didn’t love each other was hilariously cute— i mean, Jay wrote an entire ALBUM about his love for Rafe. even his goddamn phone password was Rafe’s birthday... even after all these years. god. and Rafe knew all of Jay’s songs word for word despite ‘hating’ him. he even SANG it at a shitty karaoke bar FOR Jay. if that’s not true love folks then idk what is. and when Rafe figures out the songs are all about him, i was teary-eyed af. these two were such big idiots for being so blind to how much they loved each other. just everything was *chef’s kiss*
the simmering slow burn from enemies to lovers was soooo satisfying too. i was afraid it’d be too quick and be unsatisfying. but their stubbornness proved for some top-tier, slow-burn pining and chemistry. and it made me root for them SO hard. i was on the edge of my seat (or sofa) desperately waiting for them to finally be together. when you’re so anxious and too impatient, i think that’s a sign of a really fucking good romance.
i think this quote sums up how beautiful this book was:
“It came to my attention that if you want to grow something, you can’t keep it in the shadows. And you and I are meant for sunshine, Rafe Goodman.”
the whole point of this is review is that best friends to enemies to lovers is god tier romance. thank u for coming to my Ted Talk.
January 9, 2022
“You claimed you hated it.”
“I did hate it, because I thought you’d written it for someone else. I was angry as fuck that you’d felt that way for someone who didn’t deserve it. For someone who wasn’t me.”
I little too much information dumb for me. But was still fun. A best friends - enemies - friends read I didn’t know I wanted.
I loved playful Jay. It was easily one of my top five favorite Jays, along with melty-hearted Jay, and intense-sex-face Jay, emoting-with-his-eyes-closed Jay, and the lemon-sucking Jay who appeared when I mentioned Ari Friedrich.
“I did hate it, because I thought you’d written it for someone else. I was angry as fuck that you’d felt that way for someone who didn’t deserve it. For someone who wasn’t me.”
I little too much information dumb for me. But was still fun. A best friends - enemies - friends read I didn’t know I wanted.
I loved playful Jay. It was easily one of my top five favorite Jays, along with melty-hearted Jay, and intense-sex-face Jay, emoting-with-his-eyes-closed Jay, and the lemon-sucking Jay who appeared when I mentioned Ari Friedrich.
May 27, 2022
Time of Death: 43%
Just bored out of mind waiting for a mature plot to take shape. Both MCs are super childish and maybe the author thought that that level of juvenile behavior was cute ; but I'm finding it unbearable. I didn't want to give up because the other stories in this series had piqued my interest in at least one of the MCs.. but..I can't take it anymore..😬 I've had enough. 😡
Not recommended! 👎
Just bored out of mind waiting for a mature plot to take shape. Both MCs are super childish and maybe the author thought that that level of juvenile behavior was cute ; but I'm finding it unbearable. I didn't want to give up because the other stories in this series had piqued my interest in at least one of the MCs.. but..I can't take it anymore..😬 I've had enough. 😡
Not recommended! 👎
May 16, 2021
The only thing better than a chill weekend with a new May Archer book is the announcement of a new series at the end 😌
June 1, 2022
I adored book 1, LOVED book 2 and... liked book 3 well enough, but not as much as I was prepared to.
I mean - there's nothing wrong wit it, for the most part, it was nice and a worthy conclusion to the series, even if it could be read on its own. But compared to the other 2 books, it's almost a bit stale.
Maybe it's because I'm not really into second-chance romances. Everyone who read the first books knows that "Young Rafe" has a history with Jay, who at one time has been his best friend. And who we know from book 2 isn't as straight as the world (and Rafe) believed him to be. So this book here tells the story of their friendship, and how ther friendship broke. It provided the background to Rafe's marriage to Aimeé, Jay's sister, and why she left him. And it's been ... nice... to see Rafe and Jay together, because they never stopped loving each other, even when they pretended to dislke each other.
We had a lot of funny and cute scenes in this book - my favourite still is the kidnapping orchestrated by Officer Oak Rainscent :D And I loved all the cameos of former couples and all the people who live in Whispering key .
But the relationship between Rafe and Jay felt a bit... idk. Lame? Despite the sweet romcom-like ending. That's why, with a heavy heart, I'll rate it with "only" 3 stars.
Would I recommend it? Yes, definitely, it you read book 1 and 2. On it's own - maybe, for a quick read in between. But it didn't leave me quite as happy auf swoony as I expected to be swooned ;)
I mean - there's nothing wrong wit it, for the most part, it was nice and a worthy conclusion to the series, even if it could be read on its own. But compared to the other 2 books, it's almost a bit stale.
Maybe it's because I'm not really into second-chance romances. Everyone who read the first books knows that "Young Rafe" has a history with Jay, who at one time has been his best friend. And who we know from book 2 isn't as straight as the world (and Rafe) believed him to be. So this book here tells the story of their friendship, and how ther friendship broke. It provided the background to Rafe's marriage to Aimeé, Jay's sister, and why she left him. And it's been ... nice... to see Rafe and Jay together, because they never stopped loving each other, even when they pretended to dislke each other.
We had a lot of funny and cute scenes in this book - my favourite still is the kidnapping orchestrated by Officer Oak Rainscent :D And I loved all the cameos of former couples and all the people who live in Whispering key .
But the relationship between Rafe and Jay felt a bit... idk. Lame? Despite the sweet romcom-like ending. That's why, with a heavy heart, I'll rate it with "only" 3 stars.
Would I recommend it? Yes, definitely, it you read book 1 and 2. On it's own - maybe, for a quick read in between. But it didn't leave me quite as happy auf swoony as I expected to be swooned ;)
May 24, 2021
3.5 Stars!
Nice addition to the series.
This one dragged a bit for me at about the mid-way point on through about 75%. But then I really enjoyed the ending.
This one ticked a lot of my boxes:
--good laughs
--good steam
--no ridiculous drama
I'm thinking Gage and Oak next?
Nice addition to the series.
This one dragged a bit for me at about the mid-way point on through about 75%. But then I really enjoyed the ending.
This one ticked a lot of my boxes:
--good laughs
--good steam
--no ridiculous drama
I'm thinking Gage and Oak next?
July 15, 2021
This should not have worked... hell, this probably shouldn't even have been a full length novel. But it really did.
Half of this book is Rafe and Jay not talking to each other. Both living in their own heads. Having their own truths about what's happened to make them fall apart. HALF of the book. I should've hated that. I probably would've hated that from anyone else, but May Archer delivered. Instead of getting annoyed by their lack of communication, I slowly fell in love with them. And the second part? Well it was exactly the kind of sugary sweet, hilarious read I needed right now. Looking back, maybe the first part made me love the second part much more than I would've if the whole book had been like that.
Half of this book is Rafe and Jay not talking to each other. Both living in their own heads. Having their own truths about what's happened to make them fall apart. HALF of the book. I should've hated that. I probably would've hated that from anyone else, but May Archer delivered. Instead of getting annoyed by their lack of communication, I slowly fell in love with them. And the second part? Well it was exactly the kind of sugary sweet, hilarious read I needed right now. Looking back, maybe the first part made me love the second part much more than I would've if the whole book had been like that.
May 16, 2021
3.50 ⭐️⭐️⭐️
No thoughts, just vibes fun from start to finish. May Archer knows her lane, and knows it well my friends. She’s giving entertainment, laughs, and sexy goodness in every story (including this one). I enjoyed this and was happy to be back in the Whispering Key universe.
That being said....I know, I know it’s like a knife in my heart writing this... this was my least favorite in the series thus far (*ducks* 😬). May’s books are Hallmark romances and I know this, and I know what I’m getting with the plot, but there was just something Key (ha) missing for me. Bad puns aside, not being in Whispering Key the majority of the book made it fall a little flat for me at times. A big reason I like these books is for the band of lovable, animated weirdos in these small towns bringing comedy and ridiculousness to the story. I loved Jay and Rafe, and there was nothing in particular that I disliked, it was just lacking the je ne sais quoi the other books had.
Anyway, May is an always-read author for me and that hasn’t changed. This book was still fun and I had a good time reading. I’ll be looking forward to Gage’s (and Oak’s?) book next.
No thoughts, just vibes fun from start to finish. May Archer knows her lane, and knows it well my friends. She’s giving entertainment, laughs, and sexy goodness in every story (including this one). I enjoyed this and was happy to be back in the Whispering Key universe.
That being said....I know, I know it’s like a knife in my heart writing this... this was my least favorite in the series thus far (*ducks* 😬). May’s books are Hallmark romances and I know this, and I know what I’m getting with the plot, but there was just something Key (ha) missing for me. Bad puns aside, not being in Whispering Key the majority of the book made it fall a little flat for me at times. A big reason I like these books is for the band of lovable, animated weirdos in these small towns bringing comedy and ridiculousness to the story. I loved Jay and Rafe, and there was nothing in particular that I disliked, it was just lacking the je ne sais quoi the other books had.
Anyway, May is an always-read author for me and that hasn’t changed. This book was still fun and I had a good time reading. I’ll be looking forward to Gage’s (and Oak’s?) book next.
January 23, 2023
3.8⭐
This was Young Rafe and Jay's book.
Rafe and Jay were teenage best friends who spent their summers together on Whispering Key.
Jay was in love with Rafe , but officially straight, so Rafe, being bisexual and having a crush on his best friend himself, never ever imagined that something could potentially happen between them.
They parted their ways when Rafe married Jay's sister , because she had health problems and needed health insurance, but none of them ever let Jay know this was a marriage of convenience , because Jay's music career started to take off and they wanted him living out his dreams.
Which was kinda weird Rafe didn't tell him, honestly, I mean if it's your best friend... communication is key.
Rafe and Jay became enemies, ending all contact and never seeing each other again.
They met again 3 years after Rafe's wedding (and then divorce), because Jay's sister went missing and they went looking for her and looking for answers.
🔵 I think this story had so much more potential as best friends-enemies-lovers story and I liked the suspense until the time came for revelations, when they finally got the clue where the other was coming from. I think that was poorly done.
🟡 I wanted a little more angst, more pining when they were on that roadtrip , not just a few looks in the car, I wanted them spilling their hearts out that first night at the bar.
🟢 What I didn't see coming was Chet. That just took 1 star away right there. It was pointless and instead of reading about a hillbilly and his missus, I'd rather read about Jay and Rafe talking to each other .
🟣 They rekindled their friendship in 4 short days. Had a bit of sex. The end. That was not nearly enough for more that a decade of pining and time lost.
What I did like?
💗 Rafe. If it's a character I like the most in this series, it's him. A grown man, responsible, hard worker, generous, loyal, loving. Doesn't hurt that he's hot.
🌅 Whispering Key - finally there's an insight into what's changing on this island, what it's like, what's different. I love the island and its people and I'm disappointed the series is not continued.
❓ My question is - where's Oak? Now there's a character that's really intriguing and I for one thought that he was going to be Gage's love interest in the next book, but no such luck.
Even though in this series it was only the first book I really loved , I like all the characters (maybe still not sold on Toby) and I love this place. I think this could have been a longer series, there's so much that could happen on this island in the future and I wanted to see that future with Young Rafe being the mayor.
Sad to see it end.
This was Young Rafe and Jay's book.
Rafe and Jay were teenage best friends who spent their summers together on Whispering Key.
Jay was in love with Rafe , but officially straight, so Rafe, being bisexual and having a crush on his best friend himself, never ever imagined that something could potentially happen between them.
They parted their ways when Rafe married Jay's sister , because she had health problems and needed health insurance, but none of them ever let Jay know this was a marriage of convenience , because Jay's music career started to take off and they wanted him living out his dreams.
Which was kinda weird Rafe didn't tell him, honestly, I mean if it's your best friend... communication is key.
Rafe and Jay became enemies, ending all contact and never seeing each other again.
They met again 3 years after Rafe's wedding (and then divorce), because Jay's sister went missing and they went looking for her and looking for answers.
🔵 I think this story had so much more potential as best friends-enemies-lovers story and I liked the suspense until the time came for revelations, when they finally got the clue where the other was coming from. I think that was poorly done.
🟡 I wanted a little more angst, more pining when they were on that roadtrip , not just a few looks in the car, I wanted them spilling their hearts out that first night at the bar.
🟢 What I didn't see coming was Chet. That just took 1 star away right there. It was pointless and instead of reading about a hillbilly and his missus, I'd rather read about Jay and Rafe talking to each other .
🟣 They rekindled their friendship in 4 short days. Had a bit of sex. The end. That was not nearly enough for more that a decade of pining and time lost.
What I did like?
💗 Rafe. If it's a character I like the most in this series, it's him. A grown man, responsible, hard worker, generous, loyal, loving. Doesn't hurt that he's hot.
🌅 Whispering Key - finally there's an insight into what's changing on this island, what it's like, what's different. I love the island and its people and I'm disappointed the series is not continued.
❓ My question is - where's Oak? Now there's a character that's really intriguing and I for one thought that he was going to be Gage's love interest in the next book, but no such luck.
Even though in this series it was only the first book I really loved , I like all the characters (maybe still not sold on Toby) and I love this place. I think this could have been a longer series, there's so much that could happen on this island in the future and I wanted to see that future with Young Rafe being the mayor.
Sad to see it end.
May 18, 2021
I have been waiting for this book to come out for months and I was not disappointed. This series is my favourite by May Archer and I have loved all three books.
The mystery of their relationship had been hinted at in both of the books so I was really curious how their romance would work. I think the author did a really good job of framing Rafe's marriage to Jayd's sister in a palatable way (so for those who are hesitant because of the married-to-the-sister thing, it does get explained in a way that makes it understandable). I loved how much both of them loved each other so deep that despite years apart, both were so affected by the other. Their change from grumpy guys to full-on happy in love was so sweet. I loved how once Jayd understood what was really making him happy he decided to completely change his life and prioritize Rafe. I like that the story included the crazy residents of Whispering Key and Dry Hump (lol) but it didn't overtake the story.
My one gripe was that I don't think the story did enough to explain Aimee disappearing on them ( I know it was kind of a plot device to force them together but I felt like it needed more). I haven't seen anyone mention that so I think it was just a me thing 😅.
I really loved this couple, Beale and Toby still rule my heart but this was a wonderful addition to the series. I can't wait for the spin-off series with Gabe!
The mystery of their relationship had been hinted at in both of the books so I was really curious how their romance would work. I think the author did a really good job of framing Rafe's marriage to Jayd's sister in a palatable way (so for those who are hesitant because of the married-to-the-sister thing, it does get explained in a way that makes it understandable). I loved how much both of them loved each other so deep that despite years apart, both were so affected by the other. Their change from grumpy guys to full-on happy in love was so sweet. I loved how once Jayd understood what was really making him happy he decided to completely change his life and prioritize Rafe. I like that the story included the crazy residents of Whispering Key and Dry Hump (lol) but it didn't overtake the story.
My one gripe was that I don't think the story did enough to explain Aimee disappearing on them ( I know it was kind of a plot device to force them together but I felt like it needed more). I haven't seen anyone mention that so I think it was just a me thing 😅.
I really loved this couple, Beale and Toby still rule my heart but this was a wonderful addition to the series. I can't wait for the spin-off series with Gabe!
May 16, 2021
This was a perfect friends to enemies to lovers. It killed me that there was no kissing until the latter half of the book but that’s just me liking steam 24/7 haha.
ALSO: Gage is leaving the Key?! And starts off his own series?! I CANT DECIDE IF IM HEARTBROKEN OR EXCITED. Also 👀 who is his love interest? I must know this…
ALSO: Gage is leaving the Key?! And starts off his own series?! I CANT DECIDE IF IM HEARTBROKEN OR EXCITED. Also 👀 who is his love interest? I must know this…
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 5, 2024
Do I love Rafe and Jay the most out of all the Whispering Key couples?! I fear I might? 😧 (I actually love them all equally)
Childhood best friends? Check! ✔️
Mutual Pining for 15 years but each one thinks the other would never feel the same? Check! ✔️
Hot, intense chemistry and even hotter sex? 🥵 Check!! Check!! Check!! ✔️✔️✔️
These fools really had me annoyed!! I truly hate a miscommunication trope but I adored Jay and Rafe so much individually that I could give them a pass, this once 🙄 and certainly only once. I’m so glad these two finally stopped being dummies 🤗 and when they did? Damnnnn they were sexy af! And sooo sweet and understanding and apologetic, it was super worth it for how frustrating it was to get there. I love how their banter and competitiveness didn’t stop once they got together, it only got better. 😈 I’m sad there won’t be other books in the series because I love Whispering Key, but I have so many more May Archer books to read! Can’t wait to see about Gage 🙆🏾♀️🤗
Childhood best friends? Check! ✔️
Mutual Pining for 15 years but each one thinks the other would never feel the same? Check! ✔️
Hot, intense chemistry and even hotter sex? 🥵 Check!! Check!! Check!! ✔️✔️✔️
These fools really had me annoyed!! I truly hate a miscommunication trope but I adored Jay and Rafe so much individually that I could give them a pass, this once 🙄 and certainly only once. I’m so glad these two finally stopped being dummies 🤗 and when they did? Damnnnn they were sexy af! And sooo sweet and understanding and apologetic, it was super worth it for how frustrating it was to get there. I love how their banter and competitiveness didn’t stop once they got together, it only got better. 😈 I’m sad there won’t be other books in the series because I love Whispering Key, but I have so many more May Archer books to read! Can’t wait to see about Gage 🙆🏾♀️🤗
May 12, 2021
Have you been like “I’m so over the grumpy/sunshine trope, give me two grumpy MCs!”? Then do I have a book for you! Rage and Jayd are carrying around so much hurt and resentment and it bleeds into their everyday life until they walk around being such grumpy-pants people you die to just scream at them to wake up! Instead, you get a wonderful, funny, charming story where these two get out of their heads and into bed (sorry, couldn’t resist), and find a love so true. And it’s such a turn around! Have you also been thinking “I’m so over the grumpy/sunshine trope, give me two sunshine MCs”? Then do I have a book for you! The latter portion of this book has so much love that it bleeds into everything these two do. This book will take you on a roller coaster of emotions, have you in stitches, and leave you swooning. Whispering Key is a magical place that you don’t want to miss out on!
May 14, 2021
May Archer has done it again.
I fell so deeply in love with these characters! Jayd and Rafe are the quintessential friends-to-enemies-to-lovers couple, and I adore them for it.
Off Key features May's trademark humor, familiar friends on the Key, road-tripping with new kooky characters, hot sex and swoon-worthy romance.
While it's possible you could read this as a standalone, you'll enjoy it more if you read the other books in the series first. They're fun, hot, and swoonworthy, too, so you'll be glad you did.
Can't wait for the next one!
I fell so deeply in love with these characters! Jayd and Rafe are the quintessential friends-to-enemies-to-lovers couple, and I adore them for it.
Off Key features May's trademark humor, familiar friends on the Key, road-tripping with new kooky characters, hot sex and swoon-worthy romance.
While it's possible you could read this as a standalone, you'll enjoy it more if you read the other books in the series first. They're fun, hot, and swoonworthy, too, so you'll be glad you did.
Can't wait for the next one!
May 24, 2022
Time of death: ~70%.
Where to start with this one? It started out very promising, with unrequited love from both MCs and a series of misunderstandings that were meant to drive the angst pretty high, something I personally enjoy. And yet, the misunderstandings were so many, so incredibly stupid, so convoluted, that even I couldn't take it. We start with Jay not telling his best friend, who'd already come out as bi, that he's gay, because he wants to make a career in music and being gay will be an obstacle. So, he doesn't trust his "best friend" to keep the secret? Ooookaaaay. And he doesn't tell his sister, whom he loves above all else. And he doesn't go to his sister's and best friend's wedding and he thinks they wouldn't notice his absence. And he doesn't call his "best friend" for his birthdays like he used to, stops speaking to him on the phone, and is still confident that his disappearance wouldn't be noticed, because he obvs only cares for his sister now (boohoohoo). And somehow, in the end of all this, he comes out as the injured party in this friendship ??? He also hasn't had contact with his beloved sister for 16 months, and we have to believe that that's normal and that he loves her to death anyway.
Still, I persevered. Until at 70%, when supposedly those two talk and solve the misunderstandings, deciding to be boyfriends, only to have Jay deny his relationship with Rafe, almost 30 seconds later, because "he wants his private life to remain private". This is AFTER Jay's picture in a gay bar, supposedly getting a blowjob, has been made public and thus, rumors of his sexuality are already going rampant and everyone, even his manager, insists he comes out publicly and be done with it. But poor Rafe goes with it, because he understands Jay's need for privacy! Well, Rafe is certainly way more understanding (or heads over heels in love) than me. Personally, I think if Jay took an IQ test, he's come out as way below average, since his reasoning only makes sense to him. And he's certainly coming out as way too selfish for MY liking.
Plus, till 70%, only 20-30 pages take place in Whispering Key. The rest is a road trip, with crazy shenanigans, which I strongly disliked. However, with Jay's easy dismissal of Rafe as his boyfriend, after theoretically pining for him all his life, there's no reason for me to go on.
Where to start with this one? It started out very promising, with unrequited love from both MCs and a series of misunderstandings that were meant to drive the angst pretty high, something I personally enjoy. And yet, the misunderstandings were so many, so incredibly stupid, so convoluted, that even I couldn't take it. We start with Jay not telling his best friend, who'd already come out as bi, that he's gay, because he wants to make a career in music and being gay will be an obstacle. So, he doesn't trust his "best friend" to keep the secret? Ooookaaaay. And he doesn't tell his sister, whom he loves above all else. And he doesn't go to his sister's and best friend's wedding and he thinks they wouldn't notice his absence. And he doesn't call his "best friend" for his birthdays like he used to, stops speaking to him on the phone, and is still confident that his disappearance wouldn't be noticed, because he obvs only cares for his sister now (boohoohoo). And somehow, in the end of all this, he comes out as the injured party in this friendship ??? He also hasn't had contact with his beloved sister for 16 months, and we have to believe that that's normal and that he loves her to death anyway.
Still, I persevered. Until at 70%, when supposedly those two talk and solve the misunderstandings, deciding to be boyfriends, only to have Jay deny his relationship with Rafe, almost 30 seconds later, because "he wants his private life to remain private". This is AFTER Jay's picture in a gay bar, supposedly getting a blowjob, has been made public and thus, rumors of his sexuality are already going rampant and everyone, even his manager, insists he comes out publicly and be done with it. But poor Rafe goes with it, because he understands Jay's need for privacy! Well, Rafe is certainly way more understanding (or heads over heels in love) than me. Personally, I think if Jay took an IQ test, he's come out as way below average, since his reasoning only makes sense to him. And he's certainly coming out as way too selfish for MY liking.
Plus, till 70%, only 20-30 pages take place in Whispering Key. The rest is a road trip, with crazy shenanigans, which I strongly disliked. However, with Jay's easy dismissal of Rafe as his boyfriend, after theoretically pining for him all his life, there's no reason for me to go on.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 28, 2022
3-3.5 stars
Compared to the other two books this book wasn’t as good. I don’t think I liked Jay as much… but I did love the Whispering Key town so much still!
This makes me want to read Gages book again since it brought the Apple orchard!!
Compared to the other two books this book wasn’t as good. I don’t think I liked Jay as much… but I did love the Whispering Key town so much still!
This makes me want to read Gages book again since it brought the Apple orchard!!
May 13, 2021
This book is everything you should expect from May Archer: epic romance, genuine character growth and ridiculous supporting characters/settings.
I laughed a lot, highlighted so many gorgeous passages. There is a lot of beautiful history and a lot of terrible communication between Rafe and Jay and the way they work through it all has been perfectly orchestrated by the author.
What a beautiful end to the Whispering Kay series (I believe Gage Goodman's story is book 1 of a new series).
I received a copy of this book from the author and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
I laughed a lot, highlighted so many gorgeous passages. There is a lot of beautiful history and a lot of terrible communication between Rafe and Jay and the way they work through it all has been perfectly orchestrated by the author.
What a beautiful end to the Whispering Kay series (I believe Gage Goodman's story is book 1 of a new series).
I received a copy of this book from the author and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
July 14, 2022
I Lurve these folks! This one made eyes do crocodile leaking. :^)
Whispering Keys is like The Thicket's doppelganger.
Whispering Keys is like The Thicket's doppelganger.
April 7, 2023
This is my 3rd May Archer and probably my least favorite. 2.5 rounded down. This didn't work for me because the 2 MCs are already in love before the book starts (even though they pretend to "hate each other" no one is fooled) so I saw/felt them fall in love and don't know why they love each other. Both MCs remained shallow to me, something was missing in characterization. I also didn't like the whole "we hate each other because of secrets". The secret thing was dragged out for WAY too long, on both sides (mostly Rafe's side) and once they wanted to have a talk to reveal it all they kept being interrupted by useless delays when this was long overdue. Besides . I adding 0.5 star for the last third. Once the secret is revealed things were better but since we don't get to know the MCs well or understand where all the sappiness comes from it is wasn't enough to add more than 0.5 star.
May 11, 2021
[I received a digital arc for an honest review]
Is it really a surprise to anyone that I gave Off Key by May Archer 5 stars? No ? I didn't think so. It was everything I wanted from a Whispering Key novel, and it honestly exceeded my expectations.
At age 15, aspiring musician Jay Rollins made the decision to keep his sexuality in the closest in order to achieve his career goals. Keeping it secret from his best friend and crush Rafe, even though Rafe was publicly out as bisexual. Cue them growing up and his dreams coming true while back at home Rafe marries his sister, and he cuts ties because of jealousy and heartbreak. Fast-forward to the present and there is a lot of secrets, miscommunication, and animosity built up between them. The two are thrown together for Whispering Keys Labor Day Extravaganza, but plans change when Jay's sister needs help. The result is a fake kidnapping, an impromptu road trip, uncovering secrets, and two best reconnecting more than they ever imagined they could.
"The guy made me feel warm all over when he looked at me like that." Made me think thoughts and dream dreams...and write songs that were all about him..."
Rafe Goodman is happy enough while trying to wrangle his dad, keep an eye on his brothers and cousin and manage the town of lunatics he loves. His unhappiness shines through when his ex-best friend and the man who crushed him, Jay Don Rollins is brought up. All bets are off as he rants and raves about the man who left him behind. Rafe is forced to face his past with Jay when Aimee needs them both. Rafe cracks almost immediately when he feels the raw loneliness coming off of Jay and wants to help him, even knowing that he will be left again at the end. Once he opens to Jay all bets are off because Rafe is a man who deserves to be loved and just wants to love Jay in whatever way he can. He is a planner and takes the opportunity to put the past in the past and embrace the future whatever that may look like.
“My teammate. My constant. My rock. My North Star, guiding me home. My Love. Always.”
Jay Rollins has struggles with people’s perceptions since a young child, first trying to please a father who would never accept his dreams, then playing straight for the music industry and lying to those he’s closest to in order prevent his secret from getting out and finally to his fans and the media, so he can continue doing what he loves. But does he truly love it anymore knowing he’s pushing away anyone who cared about him? Rafe comes back into his life as a force of negativity towards his music and life not realizing that Rafe is hurting so deeply that lashing out is his way of self-preservation. Jay opening up about the loneliness of the rock star lifestyle broke my heart because he had so few people in his corner, although everyone claimed to love him. Jay deserves the happiness that Rafe, Aimee and the Keysters bring into his life. Once he realizes that his future is his to choose I was delighted to see what he pulled off for his family.
"In everything. You and me, partners in crime. Saving the world from all manner of birds."
Rafe and Jay were perfect together. Whether they are arguing over pancakes vs waffles, trying to one up each other, or declaring their feelings I never tired of the two of them together. Plus when they finally let down their walls and start communication the intimacy between them was off the charts! Their adventure was filled with ups, downs and chest clutching moments of both angst and joy. You couldn’t help but fall in love with both men and cheered every page as they got closer towards reconnecting. This wasn’t your run of the mill best friends to lovers story which I appreciated and it wasn’t an enemies to lovers story either. Falling in the middle ground made this a book I couldn’t put down. May Archer always has you falling for the side characters who support the story as much as the MCs and the addition of Oak and Chet just had me in stitches.
"Kissing Rafe Goodman was main stage, sellout crowd, it was holding a note and feeling the perfection of it resonate in my chest. In short, it was everything."
Overall Off Key is another top-notch 5 star addition to the Whispering Key series by May Archer. Filled with love, friendship, laughter, nosey but caring small town neighbors and happily ever afters.
Is it really a surprise to anyone that I gave Off Key by May Archer 5 stars? No ? I didn't think so. It was everything I wanted from a Whispering Key novel, and it honestly exceeded my expectations.
At age 15, aspiring musician Jay Rollins made the decision to keep his sexuality in the closest in order to achieve his career goals. Keeping it secret from his best friend and crush Rafe, even though Rafe was publicly out as bisexual. Cue them growing up and his dreams coming true while back at home Rafe marries his sister, and he cuts ties because of jealousy and heartbreak. Fast-forward to the present and there is a lot of secrets, miscommunication, and animosity built up between them. The two are thrown together for Whispering Keys Labor Day Extravaganza, but plans change when Jay's sister needs help. The result is a fake kidnapping, an impromptu road trip, uncovering secrets, and two best reconnecting more than they ever imagined they could.
"The guy made me feel warm all over when he looked at me like that." Made me think thoughts and dream dreams...and write songs that were all about him..."
Rafe Goodman is happy enough while trying to wrangle his dad, keep an eye on his brothers and cousin and manage the town of lunatics he loves. His unhappiness shines through when his ex-best friend and the man who crushed him, Jay Don Rollins is brought up. All bets are off as he rants and raves about the man who left him behind. Rafe is forced to face his past with Jay when Aimee needs them both. Rafe cracks almost immediately when he feels the raw loneliness coming off of Jay and wants to help him, even knowing that he will be left again at the end. Once he opens to Jay all bets are off because Rafe is a man who deserves to be loved and just wants to love Jay in whatever way he can. He is a planner and takes the opportunity to put the past in the past and embrace the future whatever that may look like.
“My teammate. My constant. My rock. My North Star, guiding me home. My Love. Always.”
Jay Rollins has struggles with people’s perceptions since a young child, first trying to please a father who would never accept his dreams, then playing straight for the music industry and lying to those he’s closest to in order prevent his secret from getting out and finally to his fans and the media, so he can continue doing what he loves. But does he truly love it anymore knowing he’s pushing away anyone who cared about him? Rafe comes back into his life as a force of negativity towards his music and life not realizing that Rafe is hurting so deeply that lashing out is his way of self-preservation. Jay opening up about the loneliness of the rock star lifestyle broke my heart because he had so few people in his corner, although everyone claimed to love him. Jay deserves the happiness that Rafe, Aimee and the Keysters bring into his life. Once he realizes that his future is his to choose I was delighted to see what he pulled off for his family.
"In everything. You and me, partners in crime. Saving the world from all manner of birds."
Rafe and Jay were perfect together. Whether they are arguing over pancakes vs waffles, trying to one up each other, or declaring their feelings I never tired of the two of them together. Plus when they finally let down their walls and start communication the intimacy between them was off the charts! Their adventure was filled with ups, downs and chest clutching moments of both angst and joy. You couldn’t help but fall in love with both men and cheered every page as they got closer towards reconnecting. This wasn’t your run of the mill best friends to lovers story which I appreciated and it wasn’t an enemies to lovers story either. Falling in the middle ground made this a book I couldn’t put down. May Archer always has you falling for the side characters who support the story as much as the MCs and the addition of Oak and Chet just had me in stitches.
"Kissing Rafe Goodman was main stage, sellout crowd, it was holding a note and feeling the perfection of it resonate in my chest. In short, it was everything."
Overall Off Key is another top-notch 5 star addition to the Whispering Key series by May Archer. Filled with love, friendship, laughter, nosey but caring small town neighbors and happily ever afters.
May 20, 2021
This was another enjoyable story in the series. For Rafe and Jay pining, lies, anger, regrets, and an uncomfortable, but eventually fun road trip, all bring these two former best friends back together again. It was a nice change of pace to see them living life off the Key for most of the story too, and Jay getting to meet his "close personal friend" Chet had me laughing out loud.
I'm enjoying this series a lot more than the O'Leary books. While things can be a bit outlandish, these stories work well for fun, sweet reads, with a quirky but not overbearing small-town vibe.
I'm enjoying this series a lot more than the O'Leary books. While things can be a bit outlandish, these stories work well for fun, sweet reads, with a quirky but not overbearing small-town vibe.
May 22, 2021
The first half of this boon has promise. It’s starts out with a slow burn - no kissing until 60% - and then it feels like the author tries to cram a lot of sex and romance into the last 40% of the book. It took me a long time to finish this. I kept putting it down for lack of interest. The last 10 pages took me all day to read. I’ll read the next book by this author because I have enjoyed other books by her. This one just wasn’t for me.
March 25, 2023
Tags: Childhood friends to lovers, animosity to lovers, famous musician, going on a road trip, lack of communication / dingdongs
This was cute and fun in a lot of parts. Some of the small town-ness and public displays of affection got a bit too sweet and cringy / second hand embarrassing for me to completely enjoy. The audio was well done.
This was cute and fun in a lot of parts. Some of the small town-ness and public displays of affection got a bit too sweet and cringy / second hand embarrassing for me to completely enjoy. The audio was well done.
August 12, 2021
I love this series so much :')
May 10, 2021
If you've read Off Plan and On the Run, you may have wondered why Rafe hates his ex brother in law Jayd.
Here’s where we get all the answers, a load of banter and chemistry.
A lot of it doesn't happen in Whispering Key, but the residents to appear and it made me love the place more.
I adored Rafe and Jay so much and I think this one is my new favourite, I just couldn't put it down
Here’s where we get all the answers, a load of banter and chemistry.
A lot of it doesn't happen in Whispering Key, but the residents to appear and it made me love the place more.
I adored Rafe and Jay so much and I think this one is my new favourite, I just couldn't put it down
Displaying 1 - 30 of 273 reviews