A woman is forced to question her own identity in this riveting and emotionally charged thriller by the blockbuster bestselling author of The Good Girl, Mary Kubica
Jessie Sloane is on the path to rebuilding her life after years of caring for her ailing mother. She rents a new apartment and applies for college. But when the college informs her that her social security number has raised a red flag, Jessie discovers a shocking detail that causes her to doubt everything she’s ever known.
Finding herself suddenly at the center of a bizarre mystery, Jessie tumbles down a rabbit hole, which is only exacerbated by grief and a relentless lack of sleep. As days pass and the insomnia worsens, it plays with Jessie’s mind. Her judgment is blurred, her thoughts are hampered by fatigue. Jessie begins to see things until she can no longer tell the difference between what’s real and what she’s only imagined.
Meanwhile, twenty years earlier and two hundred and fifty miles away, another woman’s split-second decision may hold the key to Jessie’s secret past. Has Jessie’s whole life been a lie or have her delusions gotten the best of her?
Mary Kubica is a New York Times bestselling author of suspense thrillers including The Good Girl, The Other Mrs., and Local Woman Missing. Her books have been translated into over thirty languages and have sold over two million copies worldwide. She’s been described as “a helluva storyteller” (Kirkus) and “a writer of vice-like control” (Chicago Tribune), and her novels have been praised as “hypnotic” (People) and “thrilling and illuminating” (L.A. Times). She lives outside of Chicago with her husband and children.
KUBICA.... GIRL!! After all that?!! You've got to be kidding me!
Ok..... here we go. This was my first experience with this author and my goodness was it an experience. I have heard nothing but wonderful things about this author... so I can't compare anything since this was my first read by her. By all means.. please don't let MY own opinions stop you from reading this book... especially if you're a fan of this author. I tend to be on an outlier island like usual with all my books :).
Let me just put it this way... I didn't enjoy this novel. And that ending?! What the fuc........... that was some bull to my horns. NO way.... I can't haha. I threw my kindle across the room after finishing this one. I struggled to even get through this book because nothing was happening.
When the Lights Go Out is a very slow burn of a book. I usually don't do well with these kinds of books unless if the ending delivers. And.... this ending did not deliver at all.
I feel like this is going be a huge buzz... especially with a lot of her readers feeling disappointed in the ending.
2 stars
Thank you so much to Netgalley, Harlequin/Hanover Square Press for the opportunity to read this in exchange for my honest thoughts.
When 18-year-old Jessie’s mother Eden dies, her whole world collapses. She learns she might not be who she thought to be as she doesn’t have a social security number or birth certificate. She never knew her father, and wonders why her mother tried so hard to keep her identity a secret. She begins t piece together little clues about her true identity. At the same time, she is suffering both physically and mentally from her mother’s death. She hasn’t slept for days and her insomnia is causing her to hallucinate. She is stuck in a place where she cannot distinguish between reality and fantasy.
Jessie's story is juxtaposed with her mother's, which is recorded in a journal. The reader learns of Eden’s desperation to have a child and the extremes that she might go to get what she most desires.
Jessie and Eden’s narratives take the reader on a mysterious journey that slowly unfolds. I enjoyed Jessie’s narrative much more than Eden’s. There was something about Eden’s character that didn’t feel complete to me. When all was revealed, I was let down. Not so much by the BIG TWIST, but more so regarding Eden’s story. There were some other elements that left me with questions, but I am not going to nit-pick over each and every one.
I can’t say much more without giving too much away. I avoided reading this for a long time due to the number of negative reviews, but in the end, I am glad I gave it a shot as I found this to be a twisty and interesting read.
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley and HARLEQUIN - Hanover Square Press in exchange for an honest review.
My oh my, this was a compelling and heartbreaking read my friends! Mary Kubica is the master of suspense and sure knows how to keep the reader on their toes. Like a spider caught in a web, I couldn’t pull myself away from “When The Lights Go Out.”
1996: Eden and Aaron are happily married: they hold hands, sit outside and cuddle in each other’s arms, content. Eden, however is desperate for a baby. Completely consumed with need, she can’t eat or sleep. Fertility treatments, IVF, you name it - Eden will stop at nothing to accomplish her goal of having a child of her own.
Present Day: Jessie is all alone in this world. She hasn’t slept for days and is now having trouble functioning. To make matters worse, she discovers that her social security number is invalid and since she doesn’t have a driver's license or a birth certificate, she can’t get one. Therefore, Jessie, begins to question her own existence and the foundations upon which she was raised.
“When The Lights Go Out” gets a little crazy, my mind was spinning like a vinyl record. I couldn’t keep track (pun intended, ha ha) of everything Eden and Jessie were going through. My stomach was in knots and my nerves were on edge. Now, this is a novel I’d heard a lot about prior to diving in, you know why - that Ending!! Mary Kubica - you got people talking!!! While I was waiting for it, I had an inkling …perhaps because it made sense? Or well, maybe because I had recently had a conversation with my book buddy about another book we just read which we thought would have a similarly ending?! That said, I personally think this ending fit the story really well and I loved it folks! So there you have it - Mary Kubica’s tale grabbed me from the get go. It’s brilliant, captivating and downright heart-wrenching and I highly recommend it.
Thank you to Edelweiss, Park Row, NetGalley, Harlequin - Hanover Square Press - Park Row, and Mary Kubica for an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
Published on NetGalley, Goodreads and Twitter on 9.8.18.
WOW! Whether intentional or not this book definitely has an ending that has caused some controversy... for me the ending was absolute PERFECTION! It made every piece of the puzzle in this book fall into place and make complete sense....I’ve read other reviews and people described their reaction to the twist as a gasp, or frustration, or pure hatred... not me... my reaction was.... AHA! now I understand..... now I get what ____ was,And why ____ happened! This is not to say I don’t understand why this ending did not appeal to everybody, because I do... but I think everyone needs to read the book and figure out if it works for them or not....
This was my very first Mary Kubica Book... and I’m not sure why, but I can guarantee I will remedy that real quick.... her writing was so beautiful and smooth, almost lyrical.... even though this was a slow burning suspense I found the pacing perfect... The characters were so well drawn and relatable... I empathized with Eden’s struggles and felt Jessie’s grief.... all the little hints sprinkled throughout this book that made that ending so perfect for me, were just brilliant....
Told from Jesse’s point of view in the present and Eden’s point of view in 1996.... Jesse is a young 20-year-old grieving the loss of her mother and trying to figure out who she really is... literally trying to figure out who she is, after finding out that her Social Security number belongs to a dead girl... eden is a young wife struggling with infertility.... my mind ran through so many scenarios as to who Jesse really was and what Eden had done.... both mother and daughter had tremendous love and respect for one another... you just wanted there to be a good answer for all of your questions....
Absolutely recommend to those who enjoy a good suspense thriller filled with some surprising twists....
*** many thanks to Harlequin for my copy of this book ***
WOW! I was riveted as I read this book. My mind was racing and suspicions were at an all time high. This book is definitely a slow burn. It simply simmers as you read. You are seeped into anxiety right alongside the main character, Jessie.
The story is told from two main viewpoints and alternating timelines. We experience Jessie's story firsthand, in the present. While also uncovering her mother, Eden's story, told from the past. Their's is a relationship built on a secret. Secrets always have a way of finding their way into light, don't they? It's the journey to the revelation that Kubica so expertly pens. She opens us up to so many questions, so many possibilities.
Then, we get to the big reveal. I'm almost sorry to admit what a letdown it was for me. After all those enticing possibilities - it was the lamest of them all! I truly enjoyed the book - right up until the ending! Personally, it didn't work for me but I will say it was unexpected and different. I just felt there was so much more potential for the ending. Given all the twists the book took, I was simply expecting a much juicer culmination to it all.
Thank you to Mary Kubica, Harlequin - Hanover Square Press & NetGalley for the advance copy.
Mary Kubica has taken a foray in an unusual direction from her usual psychological thrillers with this mystery featuring Jessie Sloane set in Chicago. She is a young woman who has spent so much of her life caring for her dying mother, Eden, afflicted with a debilitating form of cancer. There has only been her mum and Jessie, for as long as Jessie can remember, with her mother being less than forthcoming as to the identity of her father. Before she dies, her mother tells her to find herself and forge a new path in her life. Jessie has found somewhere new to live, with plans to enrol on a college course, a path that is derailed when the college contacts her to inform her that her social security number belongs to a long dead 3 year old child called Jess. Along with a story narrated by Jessie, there is a parallel narrative from Eden in a journal from the 1990s, with a happy home and marriage to Aaron, but racked by a desperate plight, her inability to have children. Where will her terrible predicament take her?
Burdened by a grief and sorrow that is tearing her apart, a shell shocked Jessie embarks on a mystery quest to determine who she is, as she questions every aspect of her life. She is further hampered by a never ending insomnia, resulting in chronic sleeplessness, her mind wanders, her memory is atrocious, her emotions are all over the place and she is suffering from hallucinations. Her escalating paranoia makes Jessie an unreliable narrator as indeed is Eden. Jessie and Eden's stories run separately through the book until they finally connect in the end. There are twists, some exasperating, leaving you feeling up in air, wondering whether it was worth reading this book, but in a tale of family, love, loss and what it is to be a woman experiencing the urgent primeval need for a child, these themes are paramount in making this a thought provoking read. Mary Kubica's writing is beautiful and engaging, sustaining my interest throughout, alleviating my disappointment in other more flawed aspects of the storytelling. Many thanks to Harlequin for an ARC.
Having read all of Mary Kubica’s books to date and enjoyed them, I jumped at the chance of reading her latest, When the Lights Go Out. She is a go-to author of mine and always has me eagerly awaiting for her next release.
I have seen some mixed reviews for this one and some not so favorable thoughts on that ending but for me that ending totally worked. I was tickled pink that Mary Kubica totally shocked and floored me with that unexpected ending! These types of books are what I seek and when little snippets of the mystery are hidden so well in the narrative, when the reveal comes and falls all into place, leaving me gasping out loud in awe, then I’m pretty much elated and totally satisfied.
WHEN THE LIGHTS GO OUT by MARY KUBICA is a riveting, suspenseful, and an emotionally gripping tale that had me totally glued to those pages and swiping at breakneck speed. I was immediately drawn into this story and totally intrigued in the storyline which had me totally bewildered pretty much right up to the very end.
MARY KUBICA delivers a clever, twisty, unpredictable and thought-provoking story here with well-developed and interesting characters told between Jessie’s perspective in present tense and Eden, Jessie’s mother in past tense. I enjoyed both of these characters perspectives equally and had empathy for both of them, especially Jessie as some things that Jessie endured with her insomnia was very relatable and scary for me to read. The path that Eden’s character chose wasn’t without some pondering on my part though.
Publishing Date: September 4, 2018
Norma’s Stats: Cover: Intriguing and a fitting representation to storyline. Title: Love the title! Extremely fitting and brilliantly ties into plot. Writing/Prose: Well-written, beautiful and engaging. Plot: Interesting, held my attention, and a little different Ending: Totally unexpected and shocking! But, maybe a little controversial but in my opinion fit the story well and ended just the way I wanted it to. Overall: A fantastic and an all-consuming read! Would recommend but my advice is to go into this one blind as I did and always do.
Thank you so much to NetGalley, Harlequin/Park Row, and Mary Kubica for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a review. Thoughts in this review are all mine!
Unpopular opinion here…this book was not it. Full unleashed opinions on my blog
Long story short–I wanted to throw this book against a wall when I finished it. It is unreal how such a fantastic premise could be torpedoed so badly! I know tons of people loved this book so please check out other reviews too. For me, this was a 4 star book with a -1 star ending. Like a truly terrible ending. I do think that books that give a passionate response did something right in some ways. Nothing worse than a book that I don’t have strong feelings about–being forgetable is worse than be hated.
I actually thought the premise was great and held so much promise. Jessie realizing that her birth certificate isn’t hers–and that she essentially doesn’t have an identity–was a shocking and brilliant premise. This was a unique idea and I applaud Kubica for coming up with it and executing the first part of it well. Truly the first half was hard to put down, and I mean that.
Here is where Kubica started to lose me. Jesse also develops crippling insomnia. Understandable. However, this part was such a drag to read. I felt like I was just living in the worst, most unhealthy, bleak, depressing spiral. It got repetitive–there were so many descriptions of her insomnia that just weighed down the story. It became an anchor that we are chained to and I was dying to surface and get some air.
And then that twist… It absolutely ruined the book for me. This was a terrible ending–absolutely atrocious.
Now, I have seen plenty of people who loved the ending and I’ll say that I would never want my review to be the reason you don’t read a book. Every reader is different.
Let’s just be frank–I am not the right reader for this book. I am still angry when I think about the ending, to be honest.
4 smoldering, shocking stars to When the Lights Go Out! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Mary Kubica is a go-to author of mine for a smoldering, slow-burning fix. I can rely on her storytelling to be emotive and easy to fall into. When the Lights Go Out has a rather controversial ending! Read on to see how I felt about it (without spoilers, of course!).
When the Lights Go Out is told in alternating timelines: Jessie in the present day and Eden in 1996.
Eden desperately wants to be a mother. Her narrative is focused on that side of things. Jesse, Eden’s daughter, in the present time is struggling with caring for her mother and in the aftermath of her loss, as Eden has been diagnosed with terminal cancer and is nearing the end of her life.
After years of caretaking for her mother, Jessie is faced with rebuilding her life. On a leap of faith, she applies to college but quickly discovers there might be a problem with her registration due to identity. What does this mean for Jessie? The mystery of figuring out just who she is takes her down an unbidden path. She is extremely fatigued and overwhelmed with insomnia, and it is affecting every aspect of her life while she also tries to figure out who she is. The lines between truth and fiction become blurred, and the fact that Jessie’s judgment is unclear makes it even harder for her to see straight.
I quickly came to know Eden and Jessie because Kubica’s character-building is on point, and not only did I know them, I empathized with each of them and truly felt emotional about the issues they were individually facing.
As for that ending, I did not see it coming. Even with all of the reviews I had read, I never expected that. And I have to say, in all the thrillers I’ve read, I’ve never witnessed that before, so it was completely original. I was so shocked, I remember gasping out loud. I think that fit with the storyline, though it was a big risk.
Overall, I found When the Lights Go Out to be another page-turning suspense novel from Mary Kubica, more on the domestic suspense side than thriller. It is well-written, slow-burning, and I don’t think I’ll ever forget that ending.
Thank you go Harlequin/Park Row for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
I’ve heard so many fantastic things about Mary Kubica. This was my first experience reading her work and it definitely lived up to the hype!
This story revolves around Jessie Sloane, a young woman who loses her mother to cancer after many exhausting years battling the disease. Jessie feels alone in the world and needs to push herself to focus and move forward. While applying for college, Jessie stumbles across a mysterious detail from her past that she can’t understand or accept. She becomes solely focused on figuring out the missing pieces of her childhood hoping to get answers that will help her move forward in life.
This suspenseful and twisty thriller packed quite the punch! Not only did this book have me sitting on the edge of my seat, hanging on every word, it had me an emotional wreck! On one page I would be holding my breath in tension-filled anticipation of what would happen next, and then the next page had me with tears streaming down my face, broken hearted at what the characters were facing. Wow! This was a fantastic mix of perfection!
This was a Traveling Sister read. There were a mix of reactions to that ending. For me, it was fantastic and suited the story fabulously. To find this review, along with the other Traveling Sister reviews, please visit our blog at:
Mary Kubica gets so much right: the effects of sleep deprivation, the manifestations of grief, the physical symptoms of impending death in a person with a terminal illness, as well as the emotional turmoil of infertility and its detrimental effects on a marriage. I appreciate how much she researches her topics and gives her readers an accurate portrayal of these issues.
Told in a dual narrative, I found both story lines compelling. The current day story revolves around Jessie who is grieving her mother’s death. She has plans to move forward with plans to go to college, but finds out she has no birth certificate or valid social security number. Mired in grief, and suffering from chronic insomnia, she goes days without sleep. As she investigates this turn of events, her mental state deteriorates and the line between reality and imagination blurs. The reader is left wondering if what is happening is real or is she hallucinating due to lack of sleep?
The second narrator is set in the past and tells the story of Jessie’s mother, Eden, who is grieving her inability to carry a baby to term. The devastation and the desperation she feels is palpable. Her inability to have a baby weighs on her mind constantly and her marriage suffers. The author does a great job detailing the emotional toll and consequences of infertility. I was also left unsettled and wondered just how far Eden would go in her quest to have a child.
By now, most readers have heard about The Ending. Some readers were surprised in a good way and loved it. Others felt cheated and hated it. Me? I had to mull it over for a while and decided I liked how there were hints throughout the story which made sense once I got to the end. I thought I had the story line all figured out multiple times but then as more pieces of the story were revealed I’d change my mind again. Was it my favorite ending of all time? No. But neither was it the worst. I fall somewhere in the middle. I was definitely surprised!
I can understand why some people weren’t happy with it. It did remind me of
* many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Kinda like "last call" at your local bar. You feel definitely woozy as you slide off that bar stool, but there's never been a drop of liquor in your glass after all.
Mary Kubica has truffled with our truffles here.
Kubica presents the story of Jessie Sloane, a young twenty year old, who faces the heaviness of her mother's last days after a diagnosis of cancer. Jessica fights sleep with a troublesome case of insomnia. In a zombie-like state, she keeps watchful vigil over her mother. The nurse encourages Jessie to take a sleeping pill that the doctor has prescribed for her. Jessie battles the on-coming slumber, but it soon envelopes her. Hours later, she is awake. In a shocked state, Jessie realizes that her mother has passed away without a last goodbye.
When the Lights Go Out is told from two alternating perspectives: one being Jessie and the aftermath of her mother's death; the other is the voice of Eden from 1997 who tends to fill in gaps in which there are plenty. Kubica's writing style is not the truffle-shaker here. She delivers her usual page-turning flow. I've been a fan for years and will still be.
But it's the skeletal bones that don't quite fit together as the anatomy dictates. As you near the final ending, it will become apparent that this engaging storyline has become disjointed. The desired twist that Kubica was going for curves off the highway in smouldering flames......more smoulder than flames. The exit ramp came too soon and too abruptly and the engine stalled.
I would encourage you to take this one out for a spin. You may have a totally different reaction. The reviews are split and are varied like so many of those aforementioned truffles. As in all things, let your inner truffle be your guide.
This novel had an unexpected ending which you may love or hate. In my case, it upset me but then I made peace with it. It is the kind of ending that will make you say to the book: Are you serious? you cannot possibly do this to me!
And after all those emotions I concluded it was still worth the read.
Jessica Sloane is a 17-year old who applied for college and was informed her social security number does not belong to her. From then on we follow the main character trying to unravel the mystery of her identity. There’s also alternating timelines and point of views.
I picked up this book because I enjoyed the author’s other two books THE GOOD GIRL and DON’T YOU CRY. Just like this novel, those were absolutely engaging page-turners.
The author has a talent for writing relatable characters that make you want to root for them, at least that’s how I’ve felt about them. They have been put in difficult situations which keeps you wondering how are you going to get out of this one?
Overall, I had a good time reading this novel and recommend it to readers of thrillers, mysteries, and contemporary fiction.
Having read two of Mary Kubica's previous books and thinking that they were fantastic, I was excited to have an opportunity to read her latest, "When the Lights Go Out." I finished it a few days ago but needed time to digest the book and it's ending. I am torn. I feel that Kubica gives us the makings of something great but misses the mark at the end. It reminds me of people that rave about an amazing meal they had a particular restaurant you want to go to. Your excited and anticipate a mouth watering meal from the first course until dessert. It starts off superb and smooth, followed by a satisfying main course but when the dessert comes, the waiter tells you that the dessert you wanted is not available but offers a substitution that is nice but reduces the perfect meal from outstanding to good. The mystery of Jessie Sloane is the crux of the storyline. Jessie Sloane is a young woman who has spent several years caring for her cancer-stricken mother, Eden. It's only been the two of them and after her mother dies, Jessie has to start a new path alone. Jessie must not only find her path now, she also has to find out her identity as well, since she finds out that her social security number belongs to a dead three year old named Jess. While Jesse's story dominates the book, Eden's story is paralleled. Kubica's writing is smooth and effortless. She reels you into Jesse and Eden's lives, as you are anxiously turning the pages to see what happens next. I truly felt like that passenger on the rollercoaster as it made that gradual creeping along climb inching closer and closer to the top, scared for the drop you know is coming. Only this time the drop isn't that terrifying stomach in your throat feel. It's the feeling of "oh that's all this ride is, are you sure there isn't anymore?" I received an advance copy of this book from Netgalley. #Netgalley #WhentheLightsGoOut
I'm a huge fan of Mary Kubica and this is the fourth book of hers that I have read. While it's not my favorite of hers, it still kept me awake all night with the familiar chant of "just one more chapter" until I found myself at the end of the book as the sun was rising. From the beginning you know what's happening as it doesn't appear that the author is trying to hide a twist from you... or is she? This could have been a five star from me if not for the out-of-the-blue plot twist towards the end of the book. I don't get it, I don't understand why Kubika decided to go this route and, in my opinion, ruin an incredibly paced story that had so much potential to end in an extraordinary climax.
I was provided an ARC of this book by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Mary Kubica is one of my favourite authors and I was delighted to receive an advanced copy of her latest book When The Lights Go Out. I have read all her previous books and loved them and this book was excellent. I was hooked from the first page to the last. I read this book in one day because I could not put it down. I felt great sympathy for the characters and Eden's story was extremely emotional. I would never have predicted the ending. I can't wait for her next book. I would like to thank NetGalley and HQ for my e-copy in exchange for an honest review.
SUMMARY Jessica Sloan’s mother has just died of cancer. She spent the past several years caring for her mother and now it’s time to move on. She puts their house up for sale, rents a carriage house apartment and applies for college. But her Social Security number has raised a red flag with her college application. Jesse is mystified and begins a crusade to determine who she really is. With the shock of her mother’s death and the question of her identity she finds herself unable to sleep. As days pass and her insomnia continues Jessie‘s judgment is blurred. She begins to have trouble telling the difference between what’s real and what’s imagined. In the meantime, twenty years earlier and miles away another woman, Eden, struggles with infertility. A split second decision by Eden may hold the key to Jesse identity.
REVIEW The writing was good and easy to read, but the story failed to hold my attention. It lacked substance and interest. Part of the story’s focus is on a woman’s struggle with infertility and a miscarriage and the devastating impact it has on her behavior and her life. Chapter after chapter we read about an overwrought woman who becomes obsessed and repeatedly reacts irrationally. Wouldn’t it have been nice to read about a woman who is strong in the face of adversity and turns her struggle into something good. Both Jesse and Eden were weak, self-centered and immature characters. Perhaps it’s just me, but I really don’t enjoy books that characterize women in a negative light. Such books are certainly not conducive to enhancing society’s perceptions of women in general. Thanks to Netgalley for an advance reading copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Publisher Harlequin Books Published September 4, 2018 Review www.bluestockingreviews.com
I was drawn in right away into the lives and struggles of our two main characters here with Jessie in the present dealing with insomnia and grief from losing her mother and Eden in the past with Eden dealing with infertility issues that start to unravel her life.
When both women's lives start to unravel they both become unreliable leaving me with so many questions as the suspense and tension increased. I raced through the story as fast as I could, entertained and excited to get to that final reveal. Well wow, that was an ending to talk about. So many mounting questions and tension built up and that ending left me cheering.
Thank you so to NetGalley, Harlequin/Park Row, and Mary Kubica for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a review.
Jessie Sloane's mom has passed away, but before doing so, she encouraged Jessie to find herself. Jessie decides to apply to college, but the college flags her social security number. Apparently it belongs to someone who is deceased. As Jessie attempts to unravel the bureaucracy behind her application, she becomes more and more convinced that something is up with her past. Even worse, her thoughts are jumbled by the fact that she hasn't slept well since her mother's death. She's no longer able to tell what's truly happening around her. What's the story with her identity? And is she crazy or is something sinister going on in her life?
"Find yourself, Mom told me. One of two wishes she had for me before she died. Maybe she didn't mean for me to apply to college. Maybe it was far less esoteric than that. Maybe it was quite literal. Find yourself, she said, because Jessie Sloane isn't you."
Well, I'm not so sure about this one. The novel goes back in forth in time between present-day Jessie and her story and a woman named Eden, whose story mainly takes place in the 1990s. Eden's timeline varies a bit though, which makes it hard to keep track of. (At least for me.) A lot of Eden's storyline revolves around infertility, which I thought was handled very well. As someone who has struggled with that, I identified with her and probably liked the book a bit more just because of that.
As for Jessie and her tale, it was definitely creepy at times, which is something Mary Kubica can do very well. With her sleep deprivation, Jessie is the ultimate unreliable narrator, and it's very hard to tell if she's crazy or what on earth is happening. At times, it seems as if the book is leading you down a particular path, but you're never exactly sure who or what to trust.
And then, of course, there's that twist. I'd heard a lot about it, so I was expecting something, but with Kubica, it's hard to know what. I'll admit, it wasn't this. I had sort of figured out where things were leading, but it didn't diminish how cheated I felt by the ending. I've seen a lot of reviews where folks loved it and others where they didn't--I just felt letdown. I won't go further so as to avoid spoilers, but know that it did diminish my overall enjoyment of the book. And while I wasn't loving it entirely--it's sort of a jumble of confusion and weird characters--the ending deflates what I did enjoy.
Overall, this is a creepy book in many ways, with a story that befuddles but intrigues you. It's compelling but the ending diminishes a lot of the early drama and excitement. 3 stars.
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher and Netgalley/Edelweiss in return for an unbiased review (thank you!).
When the Lights Go Out by Mary Kubica is a thriller that is told through again using alternating timelines and alternating points of view. Jessie is our character from the present timeline and Eden from the past.
The story begins with Jessie at her mother’s bedside as it seems along battle with cancer is coming to an end. Jessie has put her whole life on hold to be with her mother in these last few years as the battle went back and forth and now that it’s coming to an end Jessie needs to find out who she is on her own.
In the past Eden is a newly married wife with whom she and her husband are excited to begin working on their own family. However, as the months begin to pass without that second little line Eden starts feeling the pressure of not being able to conceive a child.
First I would start with there’s no doubt that Mary Kubica is a talented author even if my rating for this one doesn’t necessarily show that well. The story is one that is easy to read and follow along and I did find myself engaged rather quickly. However, the downside for me with this particular title really came with the wrap up. I had a feeling it was going to go where it did and I wasn’t a huge fan. Really though some may like this one and I would definitely still read more from this author.
I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley.
In this well written drama, Mary Kubica confronts two issues that have plagued women, that of infertility and that of insomnia. Statistics say that 12.1% of women suffer with infertility problems while 6.7% are actually infertile. Sixty million people suffer from some level of sleep disorder. While there is medical treatment for infertility, it can cost in upwards of one hundred thousand dollars. Insurance will cover some of the costs but most insurances have a maximum amount that they will cover. For women who so want a child, and will try anything to conceive, they and their partner encounter an enormous amount of debt trying to become pregnant.
In the book, When the Lights Go Out, Ms Kubica introduces us to Eden, a young girl happily married to her spouse who decide to have a child. However, they experience much difficulty and explore all options, acquiring massive debt and eventually wrecking their marriage. Years later, Eden's daughter, Jessie Sloane, confronts her own problems. She is an insomniac, her mother is dying of cancer, and after Eden's death, Jessie needs to find out about herself. She tries to enroll in college but then finds out her social security number belonged to a three year old child who had died. Jessie embarks on a mission to find out who she is, but her insomnia plagues her, opening her up to chronic sleeplessness, memory issues, and hallucinations. She is on a road to paranoia.
Told in two concurrent voices, that of Eden's and Jessie, this story confronts the issue of family love, the overwhelming desire for a child, and finding oneself among the chaos of life and its many problems. It is a sensitive story, one that is written about so well, by the author. At times, the two unreliable narrators of this story relate things that seem murky and at times some of the details are slightly unrealistic. However, I do recommend this book as a worthwhile read and one many will enjoy as you ponder the issues these two women faced.
Thank you to Mary Kubica, Herlequin-Hanover Square Press and NetGalley for providing an ARC of this thought-provoking novel.
Thank you also to the Traveling Sisters group on Goodreads who read along with me. We had quite a discussion about this book and as always, it made the story ever more intriguing.
I have to say this first to get it out of the way: I hated the twist at the end. It made everything not worth it and honestly, it felt cheap. That being said, I still didn’t find the story that compelling. I thought it would be more psychological thriller, but what I got were two women in transitional phases stories with a hint of suspense. I couldn’t care less about Jessie or Eden. They were both immature, naive, obsessive...a lot of negative qualities and no redeeming ones in my mind. There were a few interesting parts but that was it.
I’ve been interested in reading Kubica for a while, but after this book I’m hesitant to pick up another.
When the lights go out is the second book by Mary kubica that I've read and I'm not sure why I've missed a couple because this is better than the first book I read. It's page flipping addictive, but saying that it's a slow pace book which when you reach the ending you can't quite believe you've finished but then has one of those endings which makes you feel 'OH MY GOD' that just did not happen,you can proberly finish in one sitting (which I wish I had the time to do 🙁) I highly recommended this book.
Jessie Sloane is sitting vigil next to her mother who has reached the final stage of her terminal cancer. For all of her life, it’s been just the two of them and questions regarding her father remain unanswered. As the final moment arrives, Jessie begins her descent into the search for her identity as she learns she may not legally exist. Further complicating matters is her inability to sleep as her insomnia stretches into days. We’re also given her mother’s point of view, beginning in 1996, as the two stories transition back and forth, leading to a convergence at some point.
This is a tricky story, one you need to pay close attention to from the first page. When Jessie learns her social security number is assigned to a child who died 17 years ago, I immediately jumped to a theory that I held onto for most of the story, smugly believing I knew the path it would take. The effects of the insomnia make Jessie an unreliable narrator, smoothed by the insertion of her mother’s point of view at key intervals. But, I paid attention and that ending was the ONLY one it could have been for the story to be true to itself. It wasn’t controversial at all to me, though I get why so many feel otherwise.
The narrators were excellent, both capturing the essence of their characters, especially as they reached their most desperate points. They fit them better than gloves.
It’s a clever story and I like clever. What gave me trouble was Jessie’s almost incoherent musings as the number of days of her insomnia grew. Being inside of her head was painful and uncomfortable. But, I LOVED that ending, one I actually guessed before the big reveal. I liked this story, a lot, but those later chapters had me begging for the end. I highly recommend this book but it may not be for everyone. If you like tricky, as I do, then by all means indulge. 3.5 stars
I told her that we’re trying. Trying to have a child, trying to start a family. An odd choice of words for creating a baby, if you ask me. Trying is how one learns to ride a bike. To knit, to sew. To write poetry.
The frustration over my identity boils inside me until I feel myself begin to lose it. All this red tape preventing me from getting what I need, from proving who I am. I’m starting to question it myself. Am I still me?
It’s an insidious way to die, I think, from lack of sleep because there is nothing gory about it, no blood, no guts, and yet the effects are just as gruesome. I know because I’m living it. As the sun begins to rise on the eleventh day, it’s only a matter of time until I die. This is what it feels like knowing you’re about to die.
My Review:
What clever sleight of hand, and I totally fell for it. This engrossing book was a minefield of intriguing and heart squeezing storylines. Ms. Kubica’s excellent storytelling was expertly woven with flawless word choices, bringing forth vivid and sharp visuals and several instances of chicken skin. I was quickly under the influence of her powerful word voodoo and keenly felt the characters’ frustrations, discomforts, confusion, and fatigue.
Written from a dual POV, the two main characters and narrators were difficult to hold in positive regard, as they were often exasperating and repellent. Jessie was struggling with a conundrum while she was also not the brightest bulb in the pack. And as Jessie was suffered from extreme sleep deprivation and experiencing hallucinations, her observations and thoughts were untrustworthy and increasingly erratic; while her mental and physical decline and descent into madness were fascinating. I steadily grew to despise the character of Eden and found her obsessive and all-consuming drive to reproduce to be horrendously irresponsible and selfish.
Ms. Kubica’s well-crafted storylines and writing style were compelling yet taut with tension and angst. I was so caught up in their apprehensions that I am in dire need of a relaxing spa day. Until I can work one of those into my schedule, the next best plan would be a generous scoop of Ben and Jerry’s while trolling my TBR in search of an amusing comedy and lighter fare for my next read.
Check out my fascinating Q&A Elevator Ride with Mary Kubica My first interview with one of my very favorite authors! I am thrilled for everyone to dive into WHEN THE LIGHTS GO OUT. Get all the behind the scenes exclusives and more about this talented author.
An avid fan, from her smashing debut, THE GOOD GIRL (acquired for film), PRETTY BABY, DON’T YOU CRY, EVERY LAST LIE to her latest, psychological thriller—WHEN THE LIGHTS GO OUT. Everything this bestselling author (a favorite), Mary Kubica writes is solid gold.
A slow-burning twisty psychological suspense. A heart-pounding, a tale of one woman's desperate search for answers from an array of emotions —grief, disbelief, anger, fear, and confusion.
WHEN THE LIGHTS GO OUT is yet another superb addition to her "collection of girls." (cover crush). As I have mentioned previously, she deserves her own Chicago billboard. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. I was drawn into this tale on many levels.
In her fifth novel, a woman is forced to question her own identity in this riveting and emotionally charged psychological suspense thriller. Unpredictable. THAT ENDING! Talk about "the twist!" Cleverly crafted, an ending you do not see coming.
Set in Chicago and Wisconsin, WTLGO is written from two women’s perspectives (mother and daughter) as well as dual timelines and locations. I enjoy this style, allowing the reader to experience the character’s emotions first-hand. The author gets into their heads.
From the past: Eden is a young wife obsessed with having a baby. They are in love. She is desperate. She has hidden secrets. She wants those secrets to remain buried. Time is running out.
Jessie is her grown daughter in a desperate search of her true identity. She is sitting with her mom in a hospital room. Her mom Eden is dying of terminal cancer. Her mom sleeps next to her in a drug-induced daze that keeps her both pain-free and fast asleep.
Jessie has severe insomnia. What she would give to sleep like her mom. With the lack of sleep, brings emotional instability. Crying and laughing for no reason and behaving erratically and losing the concept of time and seeing things. Hallucinating.
She is unable to take sleeping pills, and she does not want to miss a thing. Her mom is so close to the end. There are still unanswered questions. She is running out of time. She continues to run into dead ends.
It has always been just she and her mother. They are close. There are things Jessie wants to know. Who is her father? Her mom never wanted to discuss it.
The author takes us back to 1996 where we meet Eden and Aaron. Egg Harbor, WI. (a beautiful idyllic area). A young couple deeply in love. They purchased a lovely cottage overlooking the bay. Their dreams. A garden and high hopes for a family.
Aaron wants a family, and at 28 and 29, they decide they are ready. However, soon their dreams turn into a nightmare. Miscarriages. Invitro. Their relationship is strained. They are draining their finances for a chance at having a baby. Aaron is busy working at a restaurant, and he wants Eden to stay home (since she soon would be pregnant). They soon grow apart.
However, staying at home brings more time for Eden to dwell on her situation and obsess. She stalks other mothers and daughters. If only she could be a mother. Plus, her neighbor (Miranda and Jack) have kids, and she is pregnant again. She does not even want to be a mother.
How could fate be so cruel? Soon, her marriage is destroyed due to the obsession to conceive. She thinks of kidnapping a child. She is selfish. Aaron thinks they should stop the madness.
Now at the end of her life, she only has a daughter. A secret life. A mysterious photo and journal. A lone wolf. She was diagnosed with cancer when Jessie was fifteen. Jessie has taken care of her.
Jessie's mom always wanted her to find herself. However, what did this mean? Soon she discovers she may not be the person she thought she was. When she goes to apply for a community college, her social security number belongs to a deceased person.
From past to present, now her mom is gone, and she is left with insomnia and unanswered questions. She is losing her mind. Determined to find her true identity.
Surely there are clues somewhere. Eleven days with hardly any sleep, she feels like she may go mad. What is her mom hiding, and who is the mysterious man in the photo? Will she be able to find the answers she desperately needs?
INTENSE! A page-turner you cannot put down— until you learn the mystery behind Jessie and Eden. (I loved Aaron and Jessie).
Jessie is experiencing acute, chronic insomnia. I enjoyed this topic and her character, especially the mystery behind her mother’s past and how this impacted her daughter Jessie. I was drawn to her storyline for many personal reasons and recently tore through my mom’s house after her death (cancer) — searching for clues about her secrets and my own identity. Plus. I have experienced insomnia my entire life. It is horrible. I also loved the cottages. I have lived in some quaint historic cottages over the years and carriage homes. They have so many stories.
Kubica explores many highly-charged female themes. From marriage, motherhood, in vitro, a stolen identity, abduction, obsession, grief, cancer, death, insomnia, financial, moral ambiguity, and of course, dark secrets of the past.
Throughout all her books—the author is in tune with powerful and provocative issues of women and the human mind. She is attracting women of all ages to the ever-growing intriguing domestic suspense genre. Each of her books is unique. The characters have an urgent need to belong —allowing society to dictate their version of happiness.
All her books are plot-driven as well as character-driven, and WHEN THE LIGHTS GO OUT is another perfect example. As well as addictively suspenseful and tautly written. Among her signature qualities, is the uncanny ability to write "hypnotic" thrillers about women placed in stressful situations and their intensely inner turmoil.
When reviewing my favorite books over the years, Mary Kubica and Karin Slaughter are the only two authors landing on my Top Books of the year for five consecutive years! (started my blog in 2014).
I loved WTLGO on so many levels! I realize the ending is quite controversial; however, in this genre, it would be quite dull if everything was tied up in a neat bow. I liked it! Highly Recommend. I would have to agree with Kirkus Reviews. “Kubica is a helluva storyteller."
A special thank you to Park Row Books and #NetGalley for an advanced reading copy. Also, I purchased the hardcover and audiobook.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin/Hanover Square Press for the ARC of When the Lights Go Out. I struggled with giving this book a one-star rating, but decided on two because I liked the premise, and I was enjoying the book for until about the 30% mark. Then the book just went round and round until the mid 90% point. Then came the ending, so beyond belief, and to me, a really lazy way to end a novel.
Did you know...The longest recorded time without sleep is approx. 264 hours or just over 11 consecutive days. Although it's unclear exactly how long humans can survive without sleep, it isn't long before the effects of sleep deprivation start to show and after only 3 or 4 nights without sleep, a hallucinatory state can set in. And that’s what the majority of this book is about. It’s what’s making 18 year old Jessie Sloan’s crazy and it’s making the reader crazy because we don’t know what’s real, what’s not and what’s a hallucination. And that can be very confusing and anxiety provoking.
Jessie is a mess. Always close and caring to her mother, Eden, until Eden passes away from cancer. Jessie does not know anything of her father. There are no other relatives or friends in the picture.
We know Eden was once married to Aaron and their ongoing, unsuccessful infertility problems led to a pregnancy obsession/madness, financial strain, separation and ultimately divorce. Eden became a totally different person after all this. She even thought, more than once, about kidnapping someone else’s baby/child.
The reader is led to wonder about all this. We are also wondering about Jessie’s lack of a valid social security number, birth certificate, etc when applying for college. She has no drivers license or other ID and it’s hard to imagine a person living in todays world without some kind of proof of identity, unless there was some funny business. That the social security number her mom gave to her belonged to a dead girl, sends red flags waving.
I liked reading the passages for Eden, the mother. What her life was like before and after, what was going on in her head, the tough, unrelentless infertility issues she went through, how she lost her husband along the way, how she and Jessie came to be. Eden so desperately wanted to have a baby, she’s practically lost her mind.
Jessie, now though, is pretty much barely functioning without sleep, suffering the loss of her mother and home, questioning her life. It was very hard to read these passages as they were pretty unnerving. She imagines things. She sees things that are not there - hallucinations aregetting worse and worse as time goes by - as sleep evades her. She hears things. She loses track of days, time. She forgets to eat and take self care. She “sees” her dead mother but is trying to figure out if she even IS her mother. And works herself up into an even more distressed state, if that’s possible. Yes, it’s possible and it’s horrible. And it made me anxious too.
I did not know if Jessie was going to die from a lack of sleep (I never knew this was possible)or die from her “floating in air” hallucinations or get run over by a car as she walked aimlessly down a street. I know how I feel when I have one sleepless night (luckily that rarely happens) and I’m of absolutely no good to myself or anyone else that next day. So I can’t even imagine the pain and suffering and torment of this long term insomnia of Jessie’s. And it’s so extremely painful to read about because it goes on for sooooo long in this book. Maybe a little too long for some readers?
Jessie’s hardships and especially her resultant anxieties, irrational thoughts and hallucinations at times, were very odd. I did understand her strong need to find herself and some kind of family history/connection. I did not fully understand why she did not approach someone / anyone for help. The ending of this story was unexpected and disappointing after that ride.