What do you think?
Rate this book
Sixteen Short Novels
The short novel according to Wilfrid Sheed "is a form which the greatest masters find essential for certain effects." The masters are here in abundance, from Dos- toevsky to Faulkner, Chekhov to Fowles, Mark Twain to Philip Roth. In his perceptive critical in- troduction, Mr. Sheed explains why these stories had to be exactly this length and no longer, and what part they played in their au- thors' careers. Presenting a splen- did group of writers at their best, this volume perfectly illustrates Mr. Sheed's bravura defense of a literary form that offers "such drama as can be taken at one sit- ting—a scale that literature can hardly afford to forfeit."
Andrea - John O'Hara
The Old Maid - Edith Wharton
Tortilla Flat - John Steinbeck
Mario and the Magician - Thomas Mann
Pudd'nhead Wilson - Mark Twain
Ward No. 6 - Anton Chekhov
Notes From Underground - Fyodor Dostoevsky
The Fall - Albert Camus
Old Man - William Faulkner
Youth - Joseph Conrad
The Lesson of the Master - Henry James
My Mortal Enemy - Willa Cather
The Ghost Writer - Philip Roth
The Ebony Tower - John Fowles
Catholics - Brian Moore
The Blacking Factory - Wilfrid Sheed
Andrea - John O'Hara
The Old Maid - Edith Wharton
Tortilla Flat - John Steinbeck
Mario and the Magician - Thomas Mann
Pudd'nhead Wilson - Mark Twain
Ward No. 6 - Anton Chekhov
Notes From Underground - Fyodor Dostoevsky
The Fall - Albert Camus
Old Man - William Faulkner
Youth - Joseph Conrad
The Lesson of the Master - Henry James
My Mortal Enemy - Willa Cather
The Ghost Writer - Philip Roth
The Ebony Tower - John Fowles
Catholics - Brian Moore
The Blacking Factory - Wilfrid Sheed
1067 pages, Hardcover
First published June 3, 1985
About the author
Wilfrid Sheed
31 books14 followersSheed was born in London to Francis "Frank" Sheed and Mary "Maisie" Ward, prominent Roman Catholic publishers (Sheed & Ward) in the United Kingdom and the United States during the mid-20th century. Wilfrid Sheed spent his childhood in both England and the United States before attending Downside School and Lincoln College, Oxford where he earned BA (1954) and MA (1957) degrees.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews
April 20, 2018
over 3 years reading this cavalcade of classics!
rather sad to see you end; now off you go, to a friend.
1 star: I did not like it and really did not enjoy it. Doesn't mean that it's badly written but probably means I want to smack this story upside its head.
2 stars: It was okay. Eh.
3 stars: I liked it but no interest in rereading now that the fun's over. Good narrative. Maybe some interesting ideas.
4 stars: I really liked it. Probably due to challenging themes and/or impressive prose and/or deep characterization. I could reread this.
5 stars: It was amazing to me personally; a favorite.
links are to reviews
00. Introduction by Wilfred Sheed
Sheed is rather full of himself and prone to making insulting generalizations; despite that, he has an interesting take on many of the novels. even better, the more passionate he gets about the superiority of the "short novel" over more bloated works, the more I became convinced.
01. Andrea by John O'Hara - 4 stars
02. The Old Maid by Edith Wharton - 4 stars
03. Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck - 3 stars
04. Mario and the Magician by Thomas Mann - 3 stars
05. Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twin - 3 stars
06. Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov - 3 stars
07. Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky - 1 star
08. The Fall by Albert Camus - 4 stars
09. The Old Man by Mutherfukin' William Faulkner, Boss
- rated it 4 stars but probably should be 5
my favorite of the lot although The Old Maid is a close second. two Old favorites, huh. they should get married.
10. Youth by Joseph Conrad - 4 stars
11. The Lesson of the Master by Henry James - 3 stars
12 .My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather - 4 stars
13. The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth - 4 stars
14. The Ebony Tower by John Fowles - 3 stars
15. Catholics by Brian Moore - 3 stars
16. The Blacking Factory by Wilfred Sheed - 2 stars
rather an embarrassing overreach for the editor to include his own novel in the collection. but at least he warned me about it - with becoming humility and humor - within his introduction.
despite no 5 stars in the collection, overall this book was (mainly) an awesome, 5 star experience. it brought back memories of my high school and college years, where I first met many of these fascinating authors. I loved how these novels had me thinking about the world and all of the different kinds of people in it, and how I engaged with those differences. most resonantly, it had me contemplating my own life, my family, my purpose, my past, present, and future. such a rewarding experience!
rather sad to see you end; now off you go, to a friend.
1 star: I did not like it and really did not enjoy it. Doesn't mean that it's badly written but probably means I want to smack this story upside its head.
2 stars: It was okay. Eh.
3 stars: I liked it but no interest in rereading now that the fun's over. Good narrative. Maybe some interesting ideas.
4 stars: I really liked it. Probably due to challenging themes and/or impressive prose and/or deep characterization. I could reread this.
5 stars: It was amazing to me personally; a favorite.
links are to reviews
00. Introduction by Wilfred Sheed
Sheed is rather full of himself and prone to making insulting generalizations; despite that, he has an interesting take on many of the novels. even better, the more passionate he gets about the superiority of the "short novel" over more bloated works, the more I became convinced.
01. Andrea by John O'Hara - 4 stars
02. The Old Maid by Edith Wharton - 4 stars
03. Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck - 3 stars
04. Mario and the Magician by Thomas Mann - 3 stars
05. Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twin - 3 stars
06. Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov - 3 stars
07. Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky - 1 star
08. The Fall by Albert Camus - 4 stars
09. The Old Man by Mutherfukin' William Faulkner, Boss
- rated it 4 stars but probably should be 5
my favorite of the lot although The Old Maid is a close second. two Old favorites, huh. they should get married.
10. Youth by Joseph Conrad - 4 stars
11. The Lesson of the Master by Henry James - 3 stars
12 .My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather - 4 stars
13. The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth - 4 stars
14. The Ebony Tower by John Fowles - 3 stars
15. Catholics by Brian Moore - 3 stars
16. The Blacking Factory by Wilfred Sheed - 2 stars
rather an embarrassing overreach for the editor to include his own novel in the collection. but at least he warned me about it - with becoming humility and humor - within his introduction.
despite no 5 stars in the collection, overall this book was (mainly) an awesome, 5 star experience. it brought back memories of my high school and college years, where I first met many of these fascinating authors. I loved how these novels had me thinking about the world and all of the different kinds of people in it, and how I engaged with those differences. most resonantly, it had me contemplating my own life, my family, my purpose, my past, present, and future. such a rewarding experience!
June 29, 2021
Another book I pulled off of my shelves. I started last night with "Andrea" by John O'Hara. If I've read any O'Hara before it must've been a short story. I haven't read any novels thus far though I do have some on my shelves. This is a rescued hardbound book in excellent condition. Of the sixteen stories I have only read two before("Mario and the Musician" by Thomas Mann and "Youth" by Conrad). Both great stories.
1 - "Andrea" by John O'Hara. A startling end causes one to wonder about the "other" side of the story. Makes one wonder about that old problem of communication in relationships. How well can we ever know another person? Also reminds of the ending of "Jules et Jim."
2 - "The Old Maid" by Edith Wharton. Looking for classy soap opera? Look no further than Edith Wharton. This story was the source for a play and then a 1939 Hollywood movie with Bette Davis and Miriam Hopkins, who teamed up again with "Old Acquaintance." I'm not sure who played who in "The Old Maid." I'm not quite done with this, but I needed to hit the sack after a long day yesterday. Shoveling snow - UGH! Finished this up last night. be prepared to get out your handkerchiefs. The ending was textbook bitter-sweet. More bitter than sweet, of course. One quibble - would it have been so difficult for people to speculate/figure out that Charlotte was the bio-mom of Tina? Seems kind of obvious, actually.
3 - "Tortilla Flat" by John Steinbeck. More weird prose decisions by JS. WHY did he choose to write this in that way that he did? ... I'm wondering about the purpose of this story as get further along in it. So far it's been nothing but a lot of wine-drinking and goofing off. Almost a hundred more pages to go, and I assume that JS has something more substantial in mind. I hope so.
Looks like I'll be finishing this tonight. Basically it's just a bunch of semi-humorous episodes linked by the author. Still can't see the point of it all, though it is mildly amusing. I THINK I've solved the puzzle of all the thees, thys, thous and thines. It could be that it's translated Spanish and JS is merely going along with the local linguistic convention. I.E. he's using the language the way the paisanos used it.
- this is a pretty nice book, but I came across a gross typo last night: "guradianship" for "guardianship"
- in the quarters/candlestick chapter ... what sick dog are they referring to?
Now finished and possessed of a higher opinion of this than when I started. Typically uneven Steinbeck, but worth reading. He DID have real writing chops.
4 - "Mario and the Magician" by Thomas Mann - Read this last night for the second time. Great story. I still say it has something to do with the rise of Der Fuhrer and Fascism in Europe. Wiki agrees ...
5 - "Pudd'nhead Wilson" by Mark Twain - Started this last night and I'm already loving that clear, user-friendly Twain prose. I wonder what he thought of Henry James? Slavery seems to be the central topic so far.
Not a whole lot going on here. Why are the twins in Dawson's Landing? One GR reviewer says it gets better later - I hope so.
Finished last night and I must say this was BARELY a 3* story. 2.75* based a lot on the fame of the author. The ending was interesting and the last line was a hoot. This story seemed to me to be heavily padded so that the author could sell it as a novel.
6 - "Ward No. 6" by Anton Chekhov - I started earlier today and I expect this to be better than the previous story. The story kind of rambles along and suffers a bit at times due to the translated Russian. Sounds a bit stilted.
Well ... THAT was pretty depressing. About as "down" as AC gets. Next up is ...
7 - "Notes from (the) Underground" by Dostoevski - Since I'm currently in the middle of The Bros. K. I'll take a break from this book and read some other stuff. Or skip over this to Faulkner.
So ... I DID start to read this just to see how it might be different from The Brothers Karamazov. I only read a couple of pages and discovered that indeed, it is different and possibly easier to read. I did, however, run into a couple of mighty lengthy paragraphs. Don't like to see that. Give me a break(literally)!
WHY!? am I torturing myself with even more Dostoevski while I struggle with "The Br. K"? Because it's the next "story" up, that's why. Sigh ...
Still struggling through this minor word-pile by the great piler-upper. It's actually becoming a bit easier to read now as the perspective has shifted a bit. Still ... when I'm done with this and The Brothers Karamazov, I SWEAR! no more Dostoevski for me. If this actually qualifies as a "short story" it does so by the skin of it's teeth.
I've gotten reasonably close to the end with this due to an outbreak of story and dialogue. Our "hero" has made a fool of himself with some non-friends and lucked into a sort-of relationship with a young prostitute. We'll see how that goes. I wonder if FD was as obnoxious in his "real" life as Raskolnikov/Dmitri/Underground man. Asberger's Syndrome? Bipolar? Is this a self-portrait?
8 - "The Fall" by Albert Camus. I put down the overbearing "Absalom, Absalom" a couple of night s ago and picked this up ... as well as "The Taming of the Shrew." Both seem like a walk in the park compared to reading Faulkner.
This one is bordering on the tedious(the over-examined life), but it is a short one - will finish tonight.
- I've been to Marken - it's pretty cool - you can drive there now.
And done with this bore-fest. WAY too many words. "Notes from Underground" is back-to-back with this = 150 pages of dense philosophical word sludge. Too much for my poor brain!
9 - "Old Man" by William Faulkner: as if I hadn't had enough Faulkner prose already, I picked this up last night because I haven't been "in" this "still reading" book for a while. Anyway, what we have here is a whale of an apocalyptic tale. Man versus nature ... Our "hero" is a mostly clueless survivor who just won't go down for the count when caught up in the middle of the flood of the century. There seems to be a distinctly ironic tone to the telling and one needn't go far to find a parable of man's dicey existence in this world. Finish tonight I suppose, but I already know that he survived.
- This story is part of a two-part(interwoven chapters) novel first titled "The Wild Palms"(the title of the first story) and then "If I Forget Thee Jerusalem."
- Faulknerism leads directly to (Cormac) McCarthyism. Strong suggestions of "The Orchard Keeper" here.
And now done as the man who takes a lickin' an' keeps on a-tickin' winds up majorly screwed by fate, the authorities and his own rather limited hillbilly perspective on life. Back on the "farm"(Parchman) and content, for the most part. At least it's safe!
10 - "Youth" by Joseph Conrad. This is either a long short story or a VERY short novel. I think the former. Anyway, this was my second read and it was just as good as the first. Conrad! One of the four(five) instances of a literary deployment of the phrase "handful of dust." The others? Eliot, Tennyson and Waugh. The latter three wrote "a/A handful of dust while in this story it's "the handful of dust" ... AND! I just discovered another one by re-reading my review of "A Glastonbury Romance." John Cowper Powys used it in that one too. That makes five ...
11 - "The Lesson of the Master" by Henry James. From the battlefields of upstate New York in 1777(Rabble in Arms) I've moved on in time to a lovely old near-London country estate and the wordy world of Henry James. I'm NOT a fan, but it's the next story in this book. Pretty typical Henry James so far: a lot of poshy people sitting around talking, strolling and chatting in the gardens, having sideways conversations on couches in front of massive 18th century portraits. You know the drill ... it'll likely turn out to be about love and misunderstanding(s).
- Paul gets the message about art vs. money or, as Rothko liked to put it to his NYC painting pals" "How's business, boys?"
- and who is the master? Thackeray ... Trollope ...
- this is a nicely mounted hardbound collection, but it contains a baffling number of misprints: "world" instead of "word' ... "quesiton" instead of "question" ...
11(revisited, apparently) - "The Lesson of the Master" by Henry James. A typically intricate and subdued tale by HJ that despite the sometimes challenging and twisty prose delivers a typically bitter and ironic(though moderately predictable) jolt at the end. What does that title mean anyway??? Who are the winners? Who are the losers? Which is more important, Love or Art? Is this story a lot about sex?
- other stories about rival-friends writers = "The Information," "Old Acquaintance"(a movie)
12 - "My Mortal Enemy" by Willa Cather. More excellence from one of my favorite writers. About how a persistent defect of character can alter a life/lives. Like Henry James w/o the often off-putting prose scrambulations.
13 -"The Ghost Writer" by Philip Roth. So ... here we have ANOTHER old writer-young writer story with a young woman in the middle. Sounds a lot different coming from Roth of course. Pretty good so far. Seems like there's a bit of a connection to Salinger and his child-wife Joyce. The 23-year old Nathan sounds pretty well-spoken(literature-wise) for his age. Is The old guy based on a real writer?
- Roth's a "you-see"-er in this story.
- The tone gets a bit snarky when the sex talk evens everything out.
- All that tuna reminds of Mother's stash in "The Ram in the Thicket.'
Still reading this long story/novella. It's the most interesting one so far, but PR betrays a bit of 40's/50's stylish stuffiness in his word choices at times. Like using "fellow" instead of "guy" or "man." Plus the "you see-ism." Meanwhile this is a compelling "Breaking Away" story as Nathan must fight for his artistic independence from the fear-based clutchings of his parents and their cultural and family allies. He understands that America, though far from free of anti-semitism, is a different kind of place kind of place. Good stuff ...
- Just read the wiki entry for this book and it says that Malamud might be the model for Lonoff. I was thinking that. Mainly because I just read "The Magic Barrel." Also, it says that this book was in line for a Pulitzer only to have it snatched away and given to Norman Mailer for "The Executioner's Song." From what I've read I'd have to say that Mailer deserved it.
Done as of last night. The Anne Frank thing is typically Rothian: funny or horrifying(or both) depending. I thought it was just weird and distracting. The ending WAS funny, though. Looked like Nathan was set to take the place of Amy! And ... the typos continue unabated.
14 - "The Ebony Tower" by John Fowles. Haven't read much Fowles, though "The Collector" might be on my "read" list. This one's one of the least interesting so far, though I admit the author's descriptive gifts are notable. In this story we get another older-younger artist theme, in this case it's painting instead of writing. The whole art-world milieu is just not interesting to me. I love art, and have been a painter in the past and possibly the future(just not right now). I DON'T love all the blah-blah. Matisse said that artist's must first cut out their tongues, or something like that, anyway. In other words, shut up and paint, and, in other words, those who can, paint, and those who can't talk(and/or) write about it. Also, the sexual backdrop of an old man artist with money screwing almost-teenage young women strikes me as offensive. Not sure why ...
- Who's "Chagell"?
Finished this one last night and was NOT happy about the direction the author chose for his endgame. Frustrated love? Really? Pages and pages of aethereal(thanks Donna Tartt) blather(the guy even uses the word "daren't"!!!) about whether to do "it" ... you know, "the thing" or not despite the fact that one is happily MARRIED and the little wifey is to be picked up the very next day at the airport in Paris? I had to unexpectedly shift into skip-skim mode to finish. I had to get above the word muck. It was like getting stuck in that "slough of despair" from "A Pilgrim's Progress"! Now ... about ten years or so ago I met a gal that I really liked. I mean REALLY, and it wasn't that much about sex. But ... not only was she young enough to be my daughter, she was MARRIED. The most incredibly sexy, gorgeous, attractive woman(age appropriate this time and a nice gal to boot) I ever met was MARRIED though, in any case I was too messed up to function in a relationship, even if she hadn't been. And ... she liked me too. But ... she was MARRIED! Anyway, I appreciate that Mr. Fowles tailored his prose, particularly his physical descriptions very nicely to fit the art-scene milieu and the castle in the country(Brittany) setting, and that was enough to sustain my interest for a while, but once the love piffle, the goofy guy-girl goop, got unpacked, things went all to hell.
- more egregious typos
- The old guy did get to the "shut up and paint" mantra eventually.
- This book's blatant similarity to another book struck me, but the title was gone from my mind almost as quickly as it had appeared there. It does resemble "The Magus" as well.
- A very self-consciously bad sentence = "Summer had died. Autumn was." UGH!
- And, BTW, this story continues the old guy - young guy - gal in the middle motif of many of the stories in this book.
15 - "Catholics" by Brian Moore - Not of much interest to me, though the author described the physical setting of his story very well. Not really sure what it's about.
16 - "The Blacking Factory" by Wilfred Sheed - The editor chose one of his own stories to finish things out. It's the account of a troubled teen-aged boy who winds being a grown-up asshole. I wanted to finish last night, but ran out of time and went to bed. Apparently a nervous breakdown will be coming on in the final pages. Certainly the lad was let down big time by his parents - I can relate. This kind of childhood/teenager-hood is definitely a set-up for later problems in life, with the potential for real catastrophe and life-failure. Again, I can relate. One thinks of the Patrick Melrose novels, for instance. While there are many choice moments in the story, it seems to ramble on somewhat aimlessly. Sheed himself lived in the USA and England in his youth, and that experience probably informs the content and point of the story. The title is a reference to Dickens and a nightmare period of his young life.
- Finished with the last, sad bit last night and find that all-in-all I liked this story because I could identify with poor Jimmy's "parent" problem. Been there and suffered for it. The somewhat forgotten premise that Jimmy's adult persona was dramatically shaped by his "lost" teenager-hood seems a bit lost in the shuffle. It's overwhelmed by the ending dramatics. "The Catcher in the Rye" is an obvious close cousin to this.
- Of all the many typos in this book the best was saved for last ... "cheeds" in stead of "cheeks."
- A solid 4* book.
1 - "Andrea" by John O'Hara. A startling end causes one to wonder about the "other" side of the story. Makes one wonder about that old problem of communication in relationships. How well can we ever know another person? Also reminds of the ending of "Jules et Jim."
2 - "The Old Maid" by Edith Wharton. Looking for classy soap opera? Look no further than Edith Wharton. This story was the source for a play and then a 1939 Hollywood movie with Bette Davis and Miriam Hopkins, who teamed up again with "Old Acquaintance." I'm not sure who played who in "The Old Maid." I'm not quite done with this, but I needed to hit the sack after a long day yesterday. Shoveling snow - UGH! Finished this up last night. be prepared to get out your handkerchiefs. The ending was textbook bitter-sweet. More bitter than sweet, of course. One quibble - would it have been so difficult for people to speculate/figure out that Charlotte was the bio-mom of Tina? Seems kind of obvious, actually.
3 - "Tortilla Flat" by John Steinbeck. More weird prose decisions by JS. WHY did he choose to write this in that way that he did? ... I'm wondering about the purpose of this story as get further along in it. So far it's been nothing but a lot of wine-drinking and goofing off. Almost a hundred more pages to go, and I assume that JS has something more substantial in mind. I hope so.
Looks like I'll be finishing this tonight. Basically it's just a bunch of semi-humorous episodes linked by the author. Still can't see the point of it all, though it is mildly amusing. I THINK I've solved the puzzle of all the thees, thys, thous and thines. It could be that it's translated Spanish and JS is merely going along with the local linguistic convention. I.E. he's using the language the way the paisanos used it.
- this is a pretty nice book, but I came across a gross typo last night: "guradianship" for "guardianship"
- in the quarters/candlestick chapter ... what sick dog are they referring to?
Now finished and possessed of a higher opinion of this than when I started. Typically uneven Steinbeck, but worth reading. He DID have real writing chops.
4 - "Mario and the Magician" by Thomas Mann - Read this last night for the second time. Great story. I still say it has something to do with the rise of Der Fuhrer and Fascism in Europe. Wiki agrees ...
5 - "Pudd'nhead Wilson" by Mark Twain - Started this last night and I'm already loving that clear, user-friendly Twain prose. I wonder what he thought of Henry James? Slavery seems to be the central topic so far.
Not a whole lot going on here. Why are the twins in Dawson's Landing? One GR reviewer says it gets better later - I hope so.
Finished last night and I must say this was BARELY a 3* story. 2.75* based a lot on the fame of the author. The ending was interesting and the last line was a hoot. This story seemed to me to be heavily padded so that the author could sell it as a novel.
6 - "Ward No. 6" by Anton Chekhov - I started earlier today and I expect this to be better than the previous story. The story kind of rambles along and suffers a bit at times due to the translated Russian. Sounds a bit stilted.
Well ... THAT was pretty depressing. About as "down" as AC gets. Next up is ...
7 - "Notes from (the) Underground" by Dostoevski - Since I'm currently in the middle of The Bros. K. I'll take a break from this book and read some other stuff. Or skip over this to Faulkner.
So ... I DID start to read this just to see how it might be different from The Brothers Karamazov. I only read a couple of pages and discovered that indeed, it is different and possibly easier to read. I did, however, run into a couple of mighty lengthy paragraphs. Don't like to see that. Give me a break(literally)!
WHY!? am I torturing myself with even more Dostoevski while I struggle with "The Br. K"? Because it's the next "story" up, that's why. Sigh ...
Still struggling through this minor word-pile by the great piler-upper. It's actually becoming a bit easier to read now as the perspective has shifted a bit. Still ... when I'm done with this and The Brothers Karamazov, I SWEAR! no more Dostoevski for me. If this actually qualifies as a "short story" it does so by the skin of it's teeth.
I've gotten reasonably close to the end with this due to an outbreak of story and dialogue. Our "hero" has made a fool of himself with some non-friends and lucked into a sort-of relationship with a young prostitute. We'll see how that goes. I wonder if FD was as obnoxious in his "real" life as Raskolnikov/Dmitri/Underground man. Asberger's Syndrome? Bipolar? Is this a self-portrait?
8 - "The Fall" by Albert Camus. I put down the overbearing "Absalom, Absalom" a couple of night s ago and picked this up ... as well as "The Taming of the Shrew." Both seem like a walk in the park compared to reading Faulkner.
This one is bordering on the tedious(the over-examined life), but it is a short one - will finish tonight.
- I've been to Marken - it's pretty cool - you can drive there now.
And done with this bore-fest. WAY too many words. "Notes from Underground" is back-to-back with this = 150 pages of dense philosophical word sludge. Too much for my poor brain!
9 - "Old Man" by William Faulkner: as if I hadn't had enough Faulkner prose already, I picked this up last night because I haven't been "in" this "still reading" book for a while. Anyway, what we have here is a whale of an apocalyptic tale. Man versus nature ... Our "hero" is a mostly clueless survivor who just won't go down for the count when caught up in the middle of the flood of the century. There seems to be a distinctly ironic tone to the telling and one needn't go far to find a parable of man's dicey existence in this world. Finish tonight I suppose, but I already know that he survived.
- This story is part of a two-part(interwoven chapters) novel first titled "The Wild Palms"(the title of the first story) and then "If I Forget Thee Jerusalem."
- Faulknerism leads directly to (Cormac) McCarthyism. Strong suggestions of "The Orchard Keeper" here.
And now done as the man who takes a lickin' an' keeps on a-tickin' winds up majorly screwed by fate, the authorities and his own rather limited hillbilly perspective on life. Back on the "farm"(Parchman) and content, for the most part. At least it's safe!
10 - "Youth" by Joseph Conrad. This is either a long short story or a VERY short novel. I think the former. Anyway, this was my second read and it was just as good as the first. Conrad! One of the four(five) instances of a literary deployment of the phrase "handful of dust." The others? Eliot, Tennyson and Waugh. The latter three wrote "a/A handful of dust while in this story it's "the handful of dust" ... AND! I just discovered another one by re-reading my review of "A Glastonbury Romance." John Cowper Powys used it in that one too. That makes five ...
11 - "The Lesson of the Master" by Henry James. From the battlefields of upstate New York in 1777(Rabble in Arms) I've moved on in time to a lovely old near-London country estate and the wordy world of Henry James. I'm NOT a fan, but it's the next story in this book. Pretty typical Henry James so far: a lot of poshy people sitting around talking, strolling and chatting in the gardens, having sideways conversations on couches in front of massive 18th century portraits. You know the drill ... it'll likely turn out to be about love and misunderstanding(s).
- Paul gets the message about art vs. money or, as Rothko liked to put it to his NYC painting pals" "How's business, boys?"
- and who is the master? Thackeray ... Trollope ...
- this is a nicely mounted hardbound collection, but it contains a baffling number of misprints: "world" instead of "word' ... "quesiton" instead of "question" ...
11(revisited, apparently) - "The Lesson of the Master" by Henry James. A typically intricate and subdued tale by HJ that despite the sometimes challenging and twisty prose delivers a typically bitter and ironic(though moderately predictable) jolt at the end. What does that title mean anyway??? Who are the winners? Who are the losers? Which is more important, Love or Art? Is this story a lot about sex?
- other stories about rival-friends writers = "The Information," "Old Acquaintance"(a movie)
12 - "My Mortal Enemy" by Willa Cather. More excellence from one of my favorite writers. About how a persistent defect of character can alter a life/lives. Like Henry James w/o the often off-putting prose scrambulations.
13 -"The Ghost Writer" by Philip Roth. So ... here we have ANOTHER old writer-young writer story with a young woman in the middle. Sounds a lot different coming from Roth of course. Pretty good so far. Seems like there's a bit of a connection to Salinger and his child-wife Joyce. The 23-year old Nathan sounds pretty well-spoken(literature-wise) for his age. Is The old guy based on a real writer?
- Roth's a "you-see"-er in this story.
- The tone gets a bit snarky when the sex talk evens everything out.
- All that tuna reminds of Mother's stash in "The Ram in the Thicket.'
Still reading this long story/novella. It's the most interesting one so far, but PR betrays a bit of 40's/50's stylish stuffiness in his word choices at times. Like using "fellow" instead of "guy" or "man." Plus the "you see-ism." Meanwhile this is a compelling "Breaking Away" story as Nathan must fight for his artistic independence from the fear-based clutchings of his parents and their cultural and family allies. He understands that America, though far from free of anti-semitism, is a different kind of place kind of place. Good stuff ...
- Just read the wiki entry for this book and it says that Malamud might be the model for Lonoff. I was thinking that. Mainly because I just read "The Magic Barrel." Also, it says that this book was in line for a Pulitzer only to have it snatched away and given to Norman Mailer for "The Executioner's Song." From what I've read I'd have to say that Mailer deserved it.
Done as of last night. The Anne Frank thing is typically Rothian: funny or horrifying(or both) depending. I thought it was just weird and distracting. The ending WAS funny, though. Looked like Nathan was set to take the place of Amy! And ... the typos continue unabated.
14 - "The Ebony Tower" by John Fowles. Haven't read much Fowles, though "The Collector" might be on my "read" list. This one's one of the least interesting so far, though I admit the author's descriptive gifts are notable. In this story we get another older-younger artist theme, in this case it's painting instead of writing. The whole art-world milieu is just not interesting to me. I love art, and have been a painter in the past and possibly the future(just not right now). I DON'T love all the blah-blah. Matisse said that artist's must first cut out their tongues, or something like that, anyway. In other words, shut up and paint, and, in other words, those who can, paint, and those who can't talk(and/or) write about it. Also, the sexual backdrop of an old man artist with money screwing almost-teenage young women strikes me as offensive. Not sure why ...
- Who's "Chagell"?
Finished this one last night and was NOT happy about the direction the author chose for his endgame. Frustrated love? Really? Pages and pages of aethereal(thanks Donna Tartt) blather(the guy even uses the word "daren't"!!!) about whether to do "it" ... you know, "the thing" or not despite the fact that one is happily MARRIED and the little wifey is to be picked up the very next day at the airport in Paris? I had to unexpectedly shift into skip-skim mode to finish. I had to get above the word muck. It was like getting stuck in that "slough of despair" from "A Pilgrim's Progress"! Now ... about ten years or so ago I met a gal that I really liked. I mean REALLY, and it wasn't that much about sex. But ... not only was she young enough to be my daughter, she was MARRIED. The most incredibly sexy, gorgeous, attractive woman(age appropriate this time and a nice gal to boot) I ever met was MARRIED though, in any case I was too messed up to function in a relationship, even if she hadn't been. And ... she liked me too. But ... she was MARRIED! Anyway, I appreciate that Mr. Fowles tailored his prose, particularly his physical descriptions very nicely to fit the art-scene milieu and the castle in the country(Brittany) setting, and that was enough to sustain my interest for a while, but once the love piffle, the goofy guy-girl goop, got unpacked, things went all to hell.
- more egregious typos
- The old guy did get to the "shut up and paint" mantra eventually.
- This book's blatant similarity to another book struck me, but the title was gone from my mind almost as quickly as it had appeared there. It does resemble "The Magus" as well.
- A very self-consciously bad sentence = "Summer had died. Autumn was." UGH!
- And, BTW, this story continues the old guy - young guy - gal in the middle motif of many of the stories in this book.
15 - "Catholics" by Brian Moore - Not of much interest to me, though the author described the physical setting of his story very well. Not really sure what it's about.
16 - "The Blacking Factory" by Wilfred Sheed - The editor chose one of his own stories to finish things out. It's the account of a troubled teen-aged boy who winds being a grown-up asshole. I wanted to finish last night, but ran out of time and went to bed. Apparently a nervous breakdown will be coming on in the final pages. Certainly the lad was let down big time by his parents - I can relate. This kind of childhood/teenager-hood is definitely a set-up for later problems in life, with the potential for real catastrophe and life-failure. Again, I can relate. One thinks of the Patrick Melrose novels, for instance. While there are many choice moments in the story, it seems to ramble on somewhat aimlessly. Sheed himself lived in the USA and England in his youth, and that experience probably informs the content and point of the story. The title is a reference to Dickens and a nightmare period of his young life.
- Finished with the last, sad bit last night and find that all-in-all I liked this story because I could identify with poor Jimmy's "parent" problem. Been there and suffered for it. The somewhat forgotten premise that Jimmy's adult persona was dramatically shaped by his "lost" teenager-hood seems a bit lost in the shuffle. It's overwhelmed by the ending dramatics. "The Catcher in the Rye" is an obvious close cousin to this.
- Of all the many typos in this book the best was saved for last ... "cheeds" in stead of "cheeks."
- A solid 4* book.
January 10, 2017
A collection of classics both well known and somewhat obscure. All of the short novels are excellent and entertaining; being examples of the genre. Authors range from Camus to Twain with room for some of my favorites including Mario and the Magician (Mann), The Old Maid (Wharton), The Ghost Writer (Roth), and Pudd'nhead Wilson (Twain). Delightful short reads that any reader should welcome.
Want to read
December 4, 2011I bought this book some 25 years ago and never read it because it has more than 1,000 pages. I picked it up recently and am slowly working my way through the book. I will discuss each novel it as I finish it.
Andrea by John O'Hara
I have never read anything by O'Hara. This is a story of a love affair between a man and a woman over a period of years while they had other lovers and spouses. The story is told through the eyes of the male and has a surprising ending.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton
Wharton is another author I have not read. This is the story of two cousins, one of who is an old maid. I felt it started slow, but found I was soon enjoying it. The story is set in a different time when having a baby out of wedlock was life destroying. Great story worth reading.
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck
I have read several of Steinbeck's novels but not this one. I have been to Monterey, CA and to the Steinbeck museum in Salinas, CA. Tortilla Flat was an excellent story. I enjoyed it immensely.
Andrea by John O'Hara
I have never read anything by O'Hara. This is a story of a love affair between a man and a woman over a period of years while they had other lovers and spouses. The story is told through the eyes of the male and has a surprising ending.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton
Wharton is another author I have not read. This is the story of two cousins, one of who is an old maid. I felt it started slow, but found I was soon enjoying it. The story is set in a different time when having a baby out of wedlock was life destroying. Great story worth reading.
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck
I have read several of Steinbeck's novels but not this one. I have been to Monterey, CA and to the Steinbeck museum in Salinas, CA. Tortilla Flat was an excellent story. I enjoyed it immensely.
Want to read
September 29, 2023Contains the stories:
Andrea by John O'Hara - 4/5 - The story of a long love affair between the title character and the narrator, a thought-provoking examination of how well we really know other people, even the ones to whom we become close. Much of the story is told through dialogue and the ending will make you re-examine everything you'd previously read.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton -
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck -
Mario and the Magician by Thomas Mann -
Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twain -
Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov -
Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky -
The Fall by Albert Camus - 4/5 - You will get no quick and easy plot summations here; the text is a one-sided conversation from our narrator who sidles up to the reader at a seedy bar in Amsterdam and begins to ruminate on his life which in turn leads to some very deep explorations of various themes, not the least of which include good vs evil, guilt vs innocence, and of course the meaning - or meaningless - of life.
The Old Man by William Faulkner -
Youth by Joseph Conrad -
The Lesson of the Master by Henry James -
My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather -
The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth -
The Ebony Tower by John Fowles -
Catholics by Brian Moore -
The Blacking Factory by Wilfrid Sheed -
Andrea by John O'Hara - 4/5 - The story of a long love affair between the title character and the narrator, a thought-provoking examination of how well we really know other people, even the ones to whom we become close. Much of the story is told through dialogue and the ending will make you re-examine everything you'd previously read.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton -
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck -
Mario and the Magician by Thomas Mann -
Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twain -
Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov -
Notes from Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky -
The Fall by Albert Camus - 4/5 - You will get no quick and easy plot summations here; the text is a one-sided conversation from our narrator who sidles up to the reader at a seedy bar in Amsterdam and begins to ruminate on his life which in turn leads to some very deep explorations of various themes, not the least of which include good vs evil, guilt vs innocence, and of course the meaning - or meaningless - of life.
The Old Man by William Faulkner -
Youth by Joseph Conrad -
The Lesson of the Master by Henry James -
My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather -
The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth -
The Ebony Tower by John Fowles -
Catholics by Brian Moore -
The Blacking Factory by Wilfrid Sheed -
November 30, 2016
“Death is a personal matter, arousing sorrow, despair, fervor, or dry-hearted philosophy. Funerals, on the other hand, are social functions. Imagine going to a funeral without first polishing the automobile. Imagine standing at a graveside not dressed in your best dark suit and your best black shoes, polished delightfully. Imagine sending flowers to a funeral with no attached card to prove you had done the correct thing. In no social institution is the codified ritual of behavior more rigid than in funerals. Imagine the indignation if the minister altered his sermon or experimented with facial expression. Consider the shock if, at the funeral parlors, any chairs were used but those little folding yellow torture chairs with the hard seats. No, dying, a man may be loved, hated, mourned, missed; but once dead he becomes the chief ornament at a complicated and formal social celebration.” - John Steinbeck, Tortilla Flat.
"When there was room on the ledge outside of the pots and boxes for a cat, the cat was there--in sunny weather--stretched at full length, asleep and blissful, with her furry belly to the sun and a paw curved over her nose." - Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson
"He was a fairly humane man towards slaves and other animals; he was an exceedingly humane man toward the erring of his own race." - Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson
"He is useless on top of the ground; he ought to be under it, inspiring the cabbages." - Pudd'nhead Wilson's Calendar
" Possibly, I even regret, myself, that I have given so few slaps in the face during my life." - Fyodor Dostoevsky, Notes from Underground
“Above all, don't believe your friends when they ask you to be sincere with them. They merely hope you will encourage them in the good opinion they have of themselves by providing them with the additional assurance they will find in your promise of sincerity.” - The Fall, Albert Camus
"Now was acutely itself: yesterday and tomorrow became the myths." - John Fowles, The Ebony Tower
This is the first book from my friend Mary I've finished and I loved it. I found I love short novels(20,000 - 30,000 words) in general. Longer than short stories, the author can go into more depth and detail and the reader has more to get ahold of. Being shorter than a full length novel the author is forced to be economical and write a tight story. No detracting filler in a novella. And collections of short novels like this one give the reader a variety of writers to experience between one pair of covers.
This volume offers a wide variety of well respected authors. The editor chose excellent examples of the short novel while avoiding selections over-represented elsewhere. I only out-right disliked one(Fowles' The Ebony Tower) and most of the rest make me want to explore more.
I've avoided Faulkner since high school, too thick, but I found Old Man like a delicious Southern gumbo. Steinbeck's Tortilla Flat is light and fun. Ward No. 6 gives us Chekov at the height of his short story powers before he switched to plays. O'Hara's Andrea gives us an interesting study in point of view. The main character is enjoying his unencumbered life and his long-running affair, but suddenly the ending makes it clear it was very different for her. And I discovered a love for Joseph Conrad and Willa Cather.
"When there was room on the ledge outside of the pots and boxes for a cat, the cat was there--in sunny weather--stretched at full length, asleep and blissful, with her furry belly to the sun and a paw curved over her nose." - Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson
"He was a fairly humane man towards slaves and other animals; he was an exceedingly humane man toward the erring of his own race." - Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson
"He is useless on top of the ground; he ought to be under it, inspiring the cabbages." - Pudd'nhead Wilson's Calendar
" Possibly, I even regret, myself, that I have given so few slaps in the face during my life." - Fyodor Dostoevsky, Notes from Underground
“Above all, don't believe your friends when they ask you to be sincere with them. They merely hope you will encourage them in the good opinion they have of themselves by providing them with the additional assurance they will find in your promise of sincerity.” - The Fall, Albert Camus
"Now was acutely itself: yesterday and tomorrow became the myths." - John Fowles, The Ebony Tower
This is the first book from my friend Mary I've finished and I loved it. I found I love short novels(20,000 - 30,000 words) in general. Longer than short stories, the author can go into more depth and detail and the reader has more to get ahold of. Being shorter than a full length novel the author is forced to be economical and write a tight story. No detracting filler in a novella. And collections of short novels like this one give the reader a variety of writers to experience between one pair of covers.
This volume offers a wide variety of well respected authors. The editor chose excellent examples of the short novel while avoiding selections over-represented elsewhere. I only out-right disliked one(Fowles' The Ebony Tower) and most of the rest make me want to explore more.
I've avoided Faulkner since high school, too thick, but I found Old Man like a delicious Southern gumbo. Steinbeck's Tortilla Flat is light and fun. Ward No. 6 gives us Chekov at the height of his short story powers before he switched to plays. O'Hara's Andrea gives us an interesting study in point of view. The main character is enjoying his unencumbered life and his long-running affair, but suddenly the ending makes it clear it was very different for her. And I discovered a love for Joseph Conrad and Willa Cather.
October 27, 2015
Some stories good, some very good, some so-so. The Russian authors were difficult.
June 26, 2016
The definition of a short novel, as put forth by the editor, Wilfrid Sheed, indicates a length of somewhere between 20,000 and 50,000 words, such that the prose is sparer than for a novel, Also, in this collection, the editor chose more obscure stories by popular authors. So I will be giving brief reviews of the stories as I read ‘em: FYI, I have found that most of these stories are listed and reviewed independently on Goodreads.
1. “Andrea,” by John O’Hara (author of “Butterfield 8” and “From the Terrace,”)-tells of a young woman’s progress from loss of virginity at age 15 through several marriages and affairs, from the point of view of Paul, deflowerer and occasional lover/friend. He describes her as a free spirit, emotionally, socially and sexually, and he is clueless about what’s really going on inside her. Thus the “surprise ending” is a real shocker. Extremely well done.
2. “The Old Maid,” by Edith Wharton (“The Age of Innocence;” “Ethan Frome,”) tells of two cousins and a child born out of wedlock; one cousin gives legitimacy to the child, and the remainder of the story is what happens to the relationship over the next number of years. Sad, hopeful, intriguing.
3. “Tortilla Flat,” by John Steinbeck, who appears to have a fondness for the fishing industry of Southern California, and the colorful characters that people it. The action takes place sometime after World War I. While “Cannery Row” concentrates on the workers, “Tortilla Flat” centers on a group of hoboes in the poor section of Monterey. These are a somewhat diverse lot, who beg, steal, fight, drink, seduce the ladies (sometimes to obtain their wine), and in general lead a shiftless life. I liked the story, even though Mr. Steinbeck came under criticism for alleged racism against poor Mexicans. For me the strength of the relationships among these characters was the theme, which is described very well. This book was made into a movie in the 1940’s, starring Spencer Tracy, John Garfield, Hedy Lamarr and Frank Morgan. Although I liked it, the characters lacked the “edge” of those of the book, and therefore were not as believable. Three stars for the movie, four for the novel.
4. “Mario and the Magician” (1929) by Thomas Mann (“Death in Venice”) is described as an allegory of the coming of Hitler and his mesmerizing seduction of the German populace. The plot involves a German writer and his family on holiday in Italy, staying in a small villa. The small town hosts a performance by “Cippola,” a conjurer, magician and hypnotist. Cippola maintains a ruthless control over the audience and spouts numerous insults to those who volunteer to be his “victims.” The Mario of the title is a kind waiter who becomes quite enraged when Cippola pretends to be a young woman with whom Mario is enamored. The ending is shocking but, in some ways, satisfying. I must admit that I would not have figured out the story’s allegorical nature if I hadn’t re-read that section of the Introduction, or various Internet sites including Wikipedia. I also learned that there is a German-language film from 1994.
5. “Pudd’nhead Wilson,” by Mark Twain, is a combination of social commentary on slavery in small-town Missouri in the 1830’s (the phrase, “Being sold down the river” takes on immediate meaning throughout this tale), intriguing character study, and an early use of fingerprinting. A slave woman, Roxy, switches her child, “Chambers,” with that of her benefactor to give him a better future. “Chambers becomes “Tom Driscoll,” and vice versa. “Tom” becomes a nasty fellow with a sense of entitlement who treats “Chambers” poorly. He’s also a roué and a gambler. The title character, David Wilson, called “Pudd’nhead” after an unfortunate incident, is an attorney by training with a hobby of fingerprinting everyone in the community. Wilson makes his way as a bookkeeper, since no one trusts his legal skills. Actually, Wilson makes only sporadic appearances in this story, making the reader wonder why the title refers to him at all. Ha! He redeems himself, dusting off his legal abilities in defending twin immigrants accused of murdering “Tom’s” uncle, who had taken Tom in after his “father” had died. Thus, the last part of the story is a courtroom drama which I would trust Scott Turow and John Grisham had read in preparation for their own fictional procedurals. I enjoyed this story very much and would recommend it. I was able to obtain a copy of the 1983 TV movie from the Library. It stars Ken Howard ("The White Shadow;" "In Her Shoes"). Follows the story quite well, although condensed. Overall, I'd rate it four stars.
6. “Ward No. 6,” by Anton Chekhov (1892), is a story reminiscent of Solzhenitsyn’s book “The First Circle.” Andrei Yefimich is a physician assigned to a small ward for the insane at a hospital in a small town. Andrei isn’t much of a doctor, letting his assistant do most of the work. However, he does take an interest in the personalities of his patients, especially Ivan Dimitrich Goronov, age 33, formerly a Court process server but now a likeable philosophical ranter. In one of their discussions, Andrei tells Ivan, “Once prisons and insane asylums exist, there must be someone to sit in them.” Andrei becomes more deeply invested in these discussions, to the detriment of his medical duties. He is finally dismissed, with no pension or other benefits, but his friend Mikhail Averyanich, town Postmaster, takes him on a cross-country trip, supposedly to ease his mind; however, Mikhail turns out to be an obnoxious gambler, borrowing all of Andrei’s savings for his debts. Nonetheless, they remain friends, even through Andrei’s process of descent into madness and social isolation. Eventually, he is lured back to the hospital and incarcerated in Ward No. 6. He again meets up with Ivan Dimitrich, who says to him, “Aha, they’ve shut you up here too, darling! I’m very glad. First you drank other people’s blood and now they’ll drink yours. Splendid!” Andrei petitions Nikita, the guard, to go out for a walk and is beaten by Nikita, dying the next day, with Mikhail and Darushka, the cook, the only attendees at his funeral. This was a very engrossing story, of a number of levels, depicting not only the vulnerability of the doctor but also the poor conditions that people with mental illness were put into and treated, and the indifference of the populace and indeed the medical bureaucracy has towards them. Five stars.
This story was made into a Russian movie in 2009. The setting is more contemporary, but the issues remain the same. It’s in the form of a documentary on the hospital and ward, and follows the Andrei and other characters in the novella. I was very impressed at the bleak conditions depicted and the hopelessness of the patients. Andrei’s descent into madness is very well depicted, but there is a major change from the novella, in that Andrei doesn’t die, but recovers from his injuries. The ending scene is of a Christmas party held with the patients from the female ward. One of the women asks Andrei to dance; nice, positive end in a still-depressing environment. I highly recommend it.
7. “Notes from Underground,” by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, has been described as “the first existential novel.” I must say that I was quite put off at first, because it read like the political/philosophical ramblings of a 40 year old madman, who was for some 20 years a civil servant but who is now living in idle poverty, having squandered an inheritance. However, that’s only the first half of the story. The rest depicts two events in the narrator’s life when he was in his mid-20’s, which give the reader insight into the protagonist’s personality. One is his attempts to reconcile with several old friends, with disastrous results, due to his egocentric nature, poor judgment, alcohol abuse and virtually no insight. The other entails his relationship with a young prostitute, whom the narrator tries to convince to give up that life and spend it with him. Again, his lack of interpersonal skills, total self-focus and rather mean ways doom what could have been a nice relationship. He learns nothing from these events and ends up sad and lonely without really knowing why. Be patient with the first part and you’ll find a very deep character study.
8. “The Fall, by Albert Camus, a French existentialist and nihilist, describes, in first-person narrative, a narcissistic former attorney who had plied his trade well, but the motive was to heap adulation upon himself, rather than any true concern for the client or the needs of society. He is now a self-described “judge-penitent” who abases himself to others to elicit their sympathy and draw out their own foibles and weaknesses, with the motivation being power and control. He “holds court” in a seedy bar called “Mexico City,” in Amsterdam; he lives fairly simply and spouts pessimistic opinions about society, for example: A single sentence will suffice for modern man; he fornicated and read the papers.” While I would say that my philosophy courses helped me get through this story, I found the going rather plodding at times, and had to reread many paragraphs; worth it, though.
9. (some spoilers) “Old Man,” by William Faulkner was apparently initially designed to flesh out his novel, “The Wild Palms,” but was published as a work in its own right. The story tells of a “convict” (no name) who, with other convicts, is dispatched to aid in controlling a flood of the Mississippi River in 1927. He and another convict are put into a skiff, and assigned to pick up stranded people on the river. The skiff becomes swept away by the current; his companion saves himself by catching onto a low branch. The “convict” is presumed dead, but survives and picks up a pregnant woman. The “convict’s” goal is to save the woman and, really, find his way back to the penitentiary and return both himself and the skiff. Along the way, the child is born, they take up with a “Cajan” whom the “convict” helps in killing and skinning alligators, and the skiff itself becomes sort of a talisman or even teddy bear for the “convict” as he refuses to let it go, holding onto it by its rope almost in desperation throughout his adventure. Our hero is a very simple man, but with a great deal of integrity and persistence. I must admit that many of the sentences (some paragraph-long) were challenging to get through, but all in all, this was a very interesting story. As for the story’s title, I would recommend you give a listen to the soundtrack to “Show Boat.”
10. “Youth,” by Joseph Conrad, is an account by an attorney in his adulthood, of his first assignment as Second Mate on a sailing ship, the “Judea,” taking a load of coal from England to Thailand. The tale is told, much like “Lord Jim,” as an extended quote, with the narrator and his grown friends (all former seamen) hanging around discussing their youths. It turns out, the narrator, Charles Marlow, was also the narrator for “Lord Jim.” In this story, from 1868, Marlow describes the harrowing, perilous sea voyage not only to obtain the coal, but weathering a destructive storm at sea, having to refit, then having to get a new crew because even the ship’s rats abandoned her, the coal spontaneously combusting and the captain eventually having to agree to scuttle her, and finally making their way to land in the three ship’s boats, giving Marlow his first assignment as “Captain.” This is loosely based on a similar event in Conrad’s life, and I must say I enjoyed this story a great deal.
11. “The Lesson of the Master,” by Henry James, has more of a “drawing-room” setting in England. It tells of a young, successful author, Paul Overt, who is invited to a party at a country estate, where he meets Henry St. George, his literary hero, who has of late fallen on hard times and is not as productive as he once was. Paul also meets a mutual friend, General Farcourt, and his daughter Marian, who appears to be impressed with the works of both Paul and Henry. Over the next few weeks Henry and Paul meet, sometimes at the Farcourts’, and Henry confides to Paul that he himself has been an admirer of Paul’s works and also that Henry’s wife, to whom he is extremely devoted, had once forced him to burn a book, but doesn’t reveal its title. Henry deplores his current station, saying that his response to the public for more frequent publications has sabotaged the true art of literature, which takes much more time. Henry goes on to say that marriage and children are distractions from one’s art and should be avoided. Well, by this time Paul has fallen hard for Marian and has plans to marry her. But, reflecting on Henry’s advice, he decides to take an extended trip abroad to work on his next book, and when he returns…Well, I’ll not spoil the surprise… I certainly found the going slow, but quite worthwhile.
12. “My Mortal Enemy,” by Edith Wharton, tells of a long-term relationship between Nellie, the narrator, 12 at the beginning of the story, and her aunt’s friend Myra Henshawe. Nellie had met Myra only briefly, and when Nellie is older Myra comes to their home town of Parthia, Illinois, to visit. She has by this time married Oswald Henshawe in a whirlwind elopement and had moved to New York. Nellie is taken by Myra’s freewheeling personality, and she in turn sees Nellie as a sort of protégé. Accordingly, she invites Nellie and her aunt Lydia for an extended visit to New York. Myra exposes Nellie to a cultural and social world she’s never experienced before, including some infidelity by Oswald, some of Myra’s other relationships, some with famous artistic and musical personalities of the day, and Myra’s declining health. The story follows the relationship into Nellie’s adulthood and Myra’s death. This is the “bare bones” of this story, which is quite rich with characterization and narrative, describing the deepening relationship between two women separated mostly by age. Very nice, poignant story.
13. “The Ghost Writer,” by Philip Roth, tells of a young writer, Nathan Zuckerman, who is invited to the home of his hero and mentor, E.I. Lonoff. Lonoff is in a loveless, conflictual marriage, which culminates in the final scene. Also at the home is a young intern, Amy Bellette, to whom Nathan becomes infatuated. Ms. Bellette alleges that she is the surviving Anne Frank, with some credible “evidence.” The unraveling of this mystery combined with Nathan’s having to accept the flaws of his hero make up the plot of this story, which is rich in detail and character. I have learned that this story is one of a trilogy, “Zuckerman Bound, consisting also of “Zuckerman Unbound” and “The Anatomy Lesson,” as well as a follow-up novel, “Exit Ghost.”
14. “The Ebony Tower,” by John Fowles (“The Magus;” “The French Lieutenant’s Woman”), tells of a young painter/art critic, David Williams, who is commissioned to write the text accompanying a retrospective of the art of Henry Breasley. Mr. Breasley is now long in the tooth and described as not only brilliant but also a curmudgeon. Indeed, the title refers to Breasley’s cynical view of academia. When David arrives at Breasely’s residence, he makes the acquaintance of two young women, former art students, who are quite the free spirits and who also have a vaguely sexual/companionship/caretaker relationship with Breasley. These are the only four characters in this story (well, save for David’s off-screen wife Beth). David becomes intrigued by Diane, dubbed “The Mouse” by Breasley (the other, Anne, is dubbed “The Freak.”} The theme appears to be a search by David for the meaning of his life, identity and career, but this story is much richer than that. The relationships among the characters was fascinating, with Henry and David coming to know and appreciate each other, as well as David’s relationship with Diane And, as I have previously indicated, my appreciation of modern art took a quantum leap when I read Chaim Potok’s “My Name is Asher Lev,” and its sequel. That education has continued with my reading of this story, as there are references to at least twenty modern artists; Google got worn out with my gleeful searches! I found out this story had been made into a movie, but it is not available at either Public Library system in St. Louis, nor on Amazon Prime.
15. “Catholics,” by Brian Moore (who also wrote the novel and screenplay for ��Black Robe”), first published in 1971, tells of a young American priest, Father James Kinsella, who is sent from Rome by the Father General of the fictional Abelesian Order to an abbey on a small island off the coast of Ireland. The time is close to the beginning of the 21st Century, at which time there have been two further fictional Vatican Councils (Vatican IV). The monks have continued to say the Mass in Latin despite “progress” in ecumenical areas by the Church; the Latin Mass is considered passé and the Mass itself is considered more of a ritual than a miracle. Father Kinsella’s mission is to order the monks to cease these traditions. The main interactions are between Father Kinsella and the Father Abbott, who has led this group of traditional, hardscrabble monks for several decades. It becomes clear during these conversations that both Father Kinsella and the Father Abbott have been struggling with a crisis of faith for some time. The resentment by the monks threatens the stability of the abbey, and the Father Abbott must take all of these dynamics into consideration before either complying or being forced to transfer elsewhere. The resolution is somewhat vague but satisfying. Those of us longer who’ve been around for awhile will appreciate the ecclesiastical background of this story. Mr. Moore also wrote the screenplay for a 1973 movie entitled “Catholics: A Fable,” starring Trevor Howard as the Father Abbott, a young Michael Gambon as one of the monks, and an even younger Martin Sheen as Father Kinsella. I’d recommend it; you can catch it, as well as “Black Robe,” on YouTube.
16. “The Blacking Factory,” by Wilfrid Sheed, the editor of this anthology, refers to a traumatic time in Charles Dickens’ life when he, at age 12, was made to leave school and work in a blacking (shoe polish) factory because of his parents’ financial irresponsibility. He did not tell anyone about this incident for many years, and had a very emotional reaction when he did so. In this context, our story is about Jim Bannister III, a Rush Limbaugh-type radio host who is unflappable under criticism or comment until a guest casually mentions that Jim had attended an English school, Sopworth College, in his adolescence. This renders Jim speechless. In the remainder of the story, Jim’s (well, Jimmy’s) father, with whom he lived after his mother’s death, who had become more and more distant as time passed. Jimmy is summarily sent to Sopworth, knowing no one, and having to adapt to the British manner of education. While never totally doing so, he manages to make some friends (one of whom is another American) and even befriend a teacher or two, as well as the Headmaster. Between school years, Jimmy spends an awkward summer trying to reconnect with his father, who remains distant, and his old friends, who seem too immature to him; an attempt to form a relationship with a girl goes awry. Thus, Jimmy is eager to return to Sopworth in the fall. But when he returns, he finds distance from both his friends and his Headmaster, with the result…well, I’ll let you read it for yourself.
Well, there you have it. I’m exhausted! Despite some slow parts, I greatly enjoyed this hefty book, and I’d recommend it. Five stars!
1. “Andrea,” by John O’Hara (author of “Butterfield 8” and “From the Terrace,”)-tells of a young woman’s progress from loss of virginity at age 15 through several marriages and affairs, from the point of view of Paul, deflowerer and occasional lover/friend. He describes her as a free spirit, emotionally, socially and sexually, and he is clueless about what’s really going on inside her. Thus the “surprise ending” is a real shocker. Extremely well done.
2. “The Old Maid,” by Edith Wharton (“The Age of Innocence;” “Ethan Frome,”) tells of two cousins and a child born out of wedlock; one cousin gives legitimacy to the child, and the remainder of the story is what happens to the relationship over the next number of years. Sad, hopeful, intriguing.
3. “Tortilla Flat,” by John Steinbeck, who appears to have a fondness for the fishing industry of Southern California, and the colorful characters that people it. The action takes place sometime after World War I. While “Cannery Row” concentrates on the workers, “Tortilla Flat” centers on a group of hoboes in the poor section of Monterey. These are a somewhat diverse lot, who beg, steal, fight, drink, seduce the ladies (sometimes to obtain their wine), and in general lead a shiftless life. I liked the story, even though Mr. Steinbeck came under criticism for alleged racism against poor Mexicans. For me the strength of the relationships among these characters was the theme, which is described very well. This book was made into a movie in the 1940’s, starring Spencer Tracy, John Garfield, Hedy Lamarr and Frank Morgan. Although I liked it, the characters lacked the “edge” of those of the book, and therefore were not as believable. Three stars for the movie, four for the novel.
4. “Mario and the Magician” (1929) by Thomas Mann (“Death in Venice”) is described as an allegory of the coming of Hitler and his mesmerizing seduction of the German populace. The plot involves a German writer and his family on holiday in Italy, staying in a small villa. The small town hosts a performance by “Cippola,” a conjurer, magician and hypnotist. Cippola maintains a ruthless control over the audience and spouts numerous insults to those who volunteer to be his “victims.” The Mario of the title is a kind waiter who becomes quite enraged when Cippola pretends to be a young woman with whom Mario is enamored. The ending is shocking but, in some ways, satisfying. I must admit that I would not have figured out the story’s allegorical nature if I hadn’t re-read that section of the Introduction, or various Internet sites including Wikipedia. I also learned that there is a German-language film from 1994.
5. “Pudd’nhead Wilson,” by Mark Twain, is a combination of social commentary on slavery in small-town Missouri in the 1830’s (the phrase, “Being sold down the river” takes on immediate meaning throughout this tale), intriguing character study, and an early use of fingerprinting. A slave woman, Roxy, switches her child, “Chambers,” with that of her benefactor to give him a better future. “Chambers becomes “Tom Driscoll,” and vice versa. “Tom” becomes a nasty fellow with a sense of entitlement who treats “Chambers” poorly. He’s also a roué and a gambler. The title character, David Wilson, called “Pudd’nhead” after an unfortunate incident, is an attorney by training with a hobby of fingerprinting everyone in the community. Wilson makes his way as a bookkeeper, since no one trusts his legal skills. Actually, Wilson makes only sporadic appearances in this story, making the reader wonder why the title refers to him at all. Ha! He redeems himself, dusting off his legal abilities in defending twin immigrants accused of murdering “Tom’s” uncle, who had taken Tom in after his “father” had died. Thus, the last part of the story is a courtroom drama which I would trust Scott Turow and John Grisham had read in preparation for their own fictional procedurals. I enjoyed this story very much and would recommend it. I was able to obtain a copy of the 1983 TV movie from the Library. It stars Ken Howard ("The White Shadow;" "In Her Shoes"). Follows the story quite well, although condensed. Overall, I'd rate it four stars.
6. “Ward No. 6,” by Anton Chekhov (1892), is a story reminiscent of Solzhenitsyn’s book “The First Circle.” Andrei Yefimich is a physician assigned to a small ward for the insane at a hospital in a small town. Andrei isn’t much of a doctor, letting his assistant do most of the work. However, he does take an interest in the personalities of his patients, especially Ivan Dimitrich Goronov, age 33, formerly a Court process server but now a likeable philosophical ranter. In one of their discussions, Andrei tells Ivan, “Once prisons and insane asylums exist, there must be someone to sit in them.” Andrei becomes more deeply invested in these discussions, to the detriment of his medical duties. He is finally dismissed, with no pension or other benefits, but his friend Mikhail Averyanich, town Postmaster, takes him on a cross-country trip, supposedly to ease his mind; however, Mikhail turns out to be an obnoxious gambler, borrowing all of Andrei’s savings for his debts. Nonetheless, they remain friends, even through Andrei’s process of descent into madness and social isolation. Eventually, he is lured back to the hospital and incarcerated in Ward No. 6. He again meets up with Ivan Dimitrich, who says to him, “Aha, they’ve shut you up here too, darling! I’m very glad. First you drank other people’s blood and now they’ll drink yours. Splendid!” Andrei petitions Nikita, the guard, to go out for a walk and is beaten by Nikita, dying the next day, with Mikhail and Darushka, the cook, the only attendees at his funeral. This was a very engrossing story, of a number of levels, depicting not only the vulnerability of the doctor but also the poor conditions that people with mental illness were put into and treated, and the indifference of the populace and indeed the medical bureaucracy has towards them. Five stars.
This story was made into a Russian movie in 2009. The setting is more contemporary, but the issues remain the same. It’s in the form of a documentary on the hospital and ward, and follows the Andrei and other characters in the novella. I was very impressed at the bleak conditions depicted and the hopelessness of the patients. Andrei’s descent into madness is very well depicted, but there is a major change from the novella, in that Andrei doesn’t die, but recovers from his injuries. The ending scene is of a Christmas party held with the patients from the female ward. One of the women asks Andrei to dance; nice, positive end in a still-depressing environment. I highly recommend it.
7. “Notes from Underground,” by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, has been described as “the first existential novel.” I must say that I was quite put off at first, because it read like the political/philosophical ramblings of a 40 year old madman, who was for some 20 years a civil servant but who is now living in idle poverty, having squandered an inheritance. However, that’s only the first half of the story. The rest depicts two events in the narrator’s life when he was in his mid-20’s, which give the reader insight into the protagonist’s personality. One is his attempts to reconcile with several old friends, with disastrous results, due to his egocentric nature, poor judgment, alcohol abuse and virtually no insight. The other entails his relationship with a young prostitute, whom the narrator tries to convince to give up that life and spend it with him. Again, his lack of interpersonal skills, total self-focus and rather mean ways doom what could have been a nice relationship. He learns nothing from these events and ends up sad and lonely without really knowing why. Be patient with the first part and you’ll find a very deep character study.
8. “The Fall, by Albert Camus, a French existentialist and nihilist, describes, in first-person narrative, a narcissistic former attorney who had plied his trade well, but the motive was to heap adulation upon himself, rather than any true concern for the client or the needs of society. He is now a self-described “judge-penitent” who abases himself to others to elicit their sympathy and draw out their own foibles and weaknesses, with the motivation being power and control. He “holds court” in a seedy bar called “Mexico City,” in Amsterdam; he lives fairly simply and spouts pessimistic opinions about society, for example: A single sentence will suffice for modern man; he fornicated and read the papers.” While I would say that my philosophy courses helped me get through this story, I found the going rather plodding at times, and had to reread many paragraphs; worth it, though.
9. (some spoilers) “Old Man,” by William Faulkner was apparently initially designed to flesh out his novel, “The Wild Palms,” but was published as a work in its own right. The story tells of a “convict” (no name) who, with other convicts, is dispatched to aid in controlling a flood of the Mississippi River in 1927. He and another convict are put into a skiff, and assigned to pick up stranded people on the river. The skiff becomes swept away by the current; his companion saves himself by catching onto a low branch. The “convict” is presumed dead, but survives and picks up a pregnant woman. The “convict’s” goal is to save the woman and, really, find his way back to the penitentiary and return both himself and the skiff. Along the way, the child is born, they take up with a “Cajan” whom the “convict” helps in killing and skinning alligators, and the skiff itself becomes sort of a talisman or even teddy bear for the “convict” as he refuses to let it go, holding onto it by its rope almost in desperation throughout his adventure. Our hero is a very simple man, but with a great deal of integrity and persistence. I must admit that many of the sentences (some paragraph-long) were challenging to get through, but all in all, this was a very interesting story. As for the story’s title, I would recommend you give a listen to the soundtrack to “Show Boat.”
10. “Youth,” by Joseph Conrad, is an account by an attorney in his adulthood, of his first assignment as Second Mate on a sailing ship, the “Judea,” taking a load of coal from England to Thailand. The tale is told, much like “Lord Jim,” as an extended quote, with the narrator and his grown friends (all former seamen) hanging around discussing their youths. It turns out, the narrator, Charles Marlow, was also the narrator for “Lord Jim.” In this story, from 1868, Marlow describes the harrowing, perilous sea voyage not only to obtain the coal, but weathering a destructive storm at sea, having to refit, then having to get a new crew because even the ship’s rats abandoned her, the coal spontaneously combusting and the captain eventually having to agree to scuttle her, and finally making their way to land in the three ship’s boats, giving Marlow his first assignment as “Captain.” This is loosely based on a similar event in Conrad’s life, and I must say I enjoyed this story a great deal.
11. “The Lesson of the Master,” by Henry James, has more of a “drawing-room” setting in England. It tells of a young, successful author, Paul Overt, who is invited to a party at a country estate, where he meets Henry St. George, his literary hero, who has of late fallen on hard times and is not as productive as he once was. Paul also meets a mutual friend, General Farcourt, and his daughter Marian, who appears to be impressed with the works of both Paul and Henry. Over the next few weeks Henry and Paul meet, sometimes at the Farcourts’, and Henry confides to Paul that he himself has been an admirer of Paul’s works and also that Henry’s wife, to whom he is extremely devoted, had once forced him to burn a book, but doesn’t reveal its title. Henry deplores his current station, saying that his response to the public for more frequent publications has sabotaged the true art of literature, which takes much more time. Henry goes on to say that marriage and children are distractions from one’s art and should be avoided. Well, by this time Paul has fallen hard for Marian and has plans to marry her. But, reflecting on Henry’s advice, he decides to take an extended trip abroad to work on his next book, and when he returns…Well, I’ll not spoil the surprise… I certainly found the going slow, but quite worthwhile.
12. “My Mortal Enemy,” by Edith Wharton, tells of a long-term relationship between Nellie, the narrator, 12 at the beginning of the story, and her aunt’s friend Myra Henshawe. Nellie had met Myra only briefly, and when Nellie is older Myra comes to their home town of Parthia, Illinois, to visit. She has by this time married Oswald Henshawe in a whirlwind elopement and had moved to New York. Nellie is taken by Myra’s freewheeling personality, and she in turn sees Nellie as a sort of protégé. Accordingly, she invites Nellie and her aunt Lydia for an extended visit to New York. Myra exposes Nellie to a cultural and social world she’s never experienced before, including some infidelity by Oswald, some of Myra’s other relationships, some with famous artistic and musical personalities of the day, and Myra’s declining health. The story follows the relationship into Nellie’s adulthood and Myra’s death. This is the “bare bones” of this story, which is quite rich with characterization and narrative, describing the deepening relationship between two women separated mostly by age. Very nice, poignant story.
13. “The Ghost Writer,” by Philip Roth, tells of a young writer, Nathan Zuckerman, who is invited to the home of his hero and mentor, E.I. Lonoff. Lonoff is in a loveless, conflictual marriage, which culminates in the final scene. Also at the home is a young intern, Amy Bellette, to whom Nathan becomes infatuated. Ms. Bellette alleges that she is the surviving Anne Frank, with some credible “evidence.” The unraveling of this mystery combined with Nathan’s having to accept the flaws of his hero make up the plot of this story, which is rich in detail and character. I have learned that this story is one of a trilogy, “Zuckerman Bound, consisting also of “Zuckerman Unbound” and “The Anatomy Lesson,” as well as a follow-up novel, “Exit Ghost.”
14. “The Ebony Tower,” by John Fowles (“The Magus;” “The French Lieutenant’s Woman”), tells of a young painter/art critic, David Williams, who is commissioned to write the text accompanying a retrospective of the art of Henry Breasley. Mr. Breasley is now long in the tooth and described as not only brilliant but also a curmudgeon. Indeed, the title refers to Breasley’s cynical view of academia. When David arrives at Breasely’s residence, he makes the acquaintance of two young women, former art students, who are quite the free spirits and who also have a vaguely sexual/companionship/caretaker relationship with Breasley. These are the only four characters in this story (well, save for David’s off-screen wife Beth). David becomes intrigued by Diane, dubbed “The Mouse” by Breasley (the other, Anne, is dubbed “The Freak.”} The theme appears to be a search by David for the meaning of his life, identity and career, but this story is much richer than that. The relationships among the characters was fascinating, with Henry and David coming to know and appreciate each other, as well as David’s relationship with Diane And, as I have previously indicated, my appreciation of modern art took a quantum leap when I read Chaim Potok’s “My Name is Asher Lev,” and its sequel. That education has continued with my reading of this story, as there are references to at least twenty modern artists; Google got worn out with my gleeful searches! I found out this story had been made into a movie, but it is not available at either Public Library system in St. Louis, nor on Amazon Prime.
15. “Catholics,” by Brian Moore (who also wrote the novel and screenplay for ��Black Robe”), first published in 1971, tells of a young American priest, Father James Kinsella, who is sent from Rome by the Father General of the fictional Abelesian Order to an abbey on a small island off the coast of Ireland. The time is close to the beginning of the 21st Century, at which time there have been two further fictional Vatican Councils (Vatican IV). The monks have continued to say the Mass in Latin despite “progress” in ecumenical areas by the Church; the Latin Mass is considered passé and the Mass itself is considered more of a ritual than a miracle. Father Kinsella’s mission is to order the monks to cease these traditions. The main interactions are between Father Kinsella and the Father Abbott, who has led this group of traditional, hardscrabble monks for several decades. It becomes clear during these conversations that both Father Kinsella and the Father Abbott have been struggling with a crisis of faith for some time. The resentment by the monks threatens the stability of the abbey, and the Father Abbott must take all of these dynamics into consideration before either complying or being forced to transfer elsewhere. The resolution is somewhat vague but satisfying. Those of us longer who’ve been around for awhile will appreciate the ecclesiastical background of this story. Mr. Moore also wrote the screenplay for a 1973 movie entitled “Catholics: A Fable,” starring Trevor Howard as the Father Abbott, a young Michael Gambon as one of the monks, and an even younger Martin Sheen as Father Kinsella. I’d recommend it; you can catch it, as well as “Black Robe,” on YouTube.
16. “The Blacking Factory,” by Wilfrid Sheed, the editor of this anthology, refers to a traumatic time in Charles Dickens’ life when he, at age 12, was made to leave school and work in a blacking (shoe polish) factory because of his parents’ financial irresponsibility. He did not tell anyone about this incident for many years, and had a very emotional reaction when he did so. In this context, our story is about Jim Bannister III, a Rush Limbaugh-type radio host who is unflappable under criticism or comment until a guest casually mentions that Jim had attended an English school, Sopworth College, in his adolescence. This renders Jim speechless. In the remainder of the story, Jim’s (well, Jimmy’s) father, with whom he lived after his mother’s death, who had become more and more distant as time passed. Jimmy is summarily sent to Sopworth, knowing no one, and having to adapt to the British manner of education. While never totally doing so, he manages to make some friends (one of whom is another American) and even befriend a teacher or two, as well as the Headmaster. Between school years, Jimmy spends an awkward summer trying to reconnect with his father, who remains distant, and his old friends, who seem too immature to him; an attempt to form a relationship with a girl goes awry. Thus, Jimmy is eager to return to Sopworth in the fall. But when he returns, he finds distance from both his friends and his Headmaster, with the result…well, I’ll let you read it for yourself.
Well, there you have it. I’m exhausted! Despite some slow parts, I greatly enjoyed this hefty book, and I’d recommend it. Five stars!
June 4, 2023
"A Combustion that Refuses to be Stifled"
In a collection of short novels that spans about 115 years, Sheed has collected a range of work that is NOT what usually appears in all the anthologies from each of these authors. It has a rather combustive effect, because of the range of emotion packed in each novel. And, there is much to be mined from each story. The writers are powerhouses, almost all towers in their profession. They appear in some random order in the anthology here, but after reading the first, I made a list by date of publication and read the rest in that order. I'll share the list below, as I think reading them chronologically allows the reader to get a feel for the decades as they pass.
The novels within are all worth reading, but some are simply phenomenal. There were only two which I didn't enjoy. (I will leave those unnamed for your own blind taste-test.) If I had to pick one big winner from the list... ohh that would be difficult, but I would have to say Pudd'nhead Wilson. I hadn't read that yet, though I do have the huge two volume set of Twain's Complete Works on my shelf to start this month. I couldn't imagine with that title that I would like the story, but Twain did something almost spectacular here. It centers around race and the whole nature vs. nurture debate. He created an infant switch situation in a Southern slave household. The slave woman's baby is raised as the Master's son, and his true heir is raised by the slave. In typical Twain style, the story resonates with ironies that would be funny if they weren't so tragically human.
I spent awhile reading these, over a course of six weeks. I can't help but feel that they left a lasting impact, each novel in its own way. It was a journey worth the ride. Note that my title comes from the Joseph Conrad story titled, Youth.
In a collection of short novels that spans about 115 years, Sheed has collected a range of work that is NOT what usually appears in all the anthologies from each of these authors. It has a rather combustive effect, because of the range of emotion packed in each novel. And, there is much to be mined from each story. The writers are powerhouses, almost all towers in their profession. They appear in some random order in the anthology here, but after reading the first, I made a list by date of publication and read the rest in that order. I'll share the list below, as I think reading them chronologically allows the reader to get a feel for the decades as they pass.
The novels within are all worth reading, but some are simply phenomenal. There were only two which I didn't enjoy. (I will leave those unnamed for your own blind taste-test.) If I had to pick one big winner from the list... ohh that would be difficult, but I would have to say Pudd'nhead Wilson. I hadn't read that yet, though I do have the huge two volume set of Twain's Complete Works on my shelf to start this month. I couldn't imagine with that title that I would like the story, but Twain did something almost spectacular here. It centers around race and the whole nature vs. nurture debate. He created an infant switch situation in a Southern slave household. The slave woman's baby is raised as the Master's son, and his true heir is raised by the slave. In typical Twain style, the story resonates with ironies that would be funny if they weren't so tragically human.
I spent awhile reading these, over a course of six weeks. I can't help but feel that they left a lasting impact, each novel in its own way. It was a journey worth the ride. Note that my title comes from the Joseph Conrad story titled, Youth.
The Chronological List of Novels:
1864 Dostoyevsky, Notes From Underground
1888 Henry James, The Lesson of the Master
1893 Mark Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson
1898 Joseph Conrad, Youth
1924 Edith Wharton, The Old Maid
1926 Willa Cather, My Mortal Enemy
1931 Thomas Mann, Mario and the Magician
1935 John Steinbeck, Tortilla Flat
1939 William Faulkner, Old Man
1956 Albert Camus, The Fall
1958 Wilfred Sheed, The Blacking Factory
1965 Anton Chekhov, Ward No. Six
1966 John O'Hara, Andrea
1972 Brian Moore, Catholics
1974 John Fowles. The Ebony Tower
1979 Philip Roth, The Ghost Writer
August 25, 2016
I have dipped into this collection from time to time over the years and finally decided to post it.
June 17, 2023
Notes from the Underground by Fyodor Dostoyevsky
A depressed (is there any Russian character who isn’t?) and retired bureaucrat rambles in his diary about philosophy, searching for the rationale to act against the system. The second half depicts his rage and his inability to realize his responsibility for his pathetic life.
The Lesson of the Master by Henry James
A struggling writer is mentored by a popular, married author. Authenticity is attained only by self-sacrifice including abandoning the woman he loves. The mentor divorces his wife and then marries the love interest while the writer tries to establish his credentials. Like most of James’s work, the reader is left dissatisfied.
Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
An intellectual doctor finds challenging conversation in an inmate at a town’s asylum. The town is upset by the doctor’s preferences and rumors spread while he is on vacation. When he returns, he discovers that he no longer has a job. He spirals into depression and becomes an inmate. Chekhov is brilliant and, although the story is depressing, it is so well written that you enjoy it!
Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twain
The stupidity of racial assumptions is displayed to the world when babies are switched at birth.
Youth by Joseph Conrad
The impressions left upon a young seaman by a crew handling a cursed ship. The ship is an average Joe beset with problems not of his making who struggles until the end. There is no rhyme nor reason. Only life as it is.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton
Two sisters living together pose the question: What makes a mother? She who gave her birth or she who raised her?
My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather
An unexpected conclusion to a wonderfully written story.
Mario and the Magician by Thomas Man
An entire small Italian town is the audience mesmerized by an outrageous, deformed, ugly, midget of a man with hypnotic power. Europe beguiled by the brass of Fascism.
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck
One of his earliest is easily one of his worst. A group of drunken bums and their antics. Unremarkable.
Old Man by William Faulkner
Old Man is the Mississippi. A convict recruited for levee duty during the catastrophic flood in 1927 is presumed dead while he saves a pregnant woman, delivers her baby and, with a small skiff tries to get them back up river while caught in the current for New Orleans. Although there are some obvious problems with the story, it is still a great read.
The Fall by Albert Camus
The confessions of a once proud, selfish soul that finds itself alone with regrets. No one is free from himself and he alone is responsible for everything.
Andrea by John O'Hara
The relationship between a promiscuous beauty and a confirmed bachelor attorney over years of seeing each other a day or week at a time over twenty years. Fear of commitment dominates the narrator’s life.
The Blacking Factory by Wilfrid Sheed
Memories recounted by a cynical radio personality of his life as a tender American boy in a Sparta-like British public school.
Catholics by Brian Moore
Eucharistic tradition – the heart of Catholicism – is threatened by ecumenicism promoted from Rome. How will an ancient abbey in Ireland react?
The Ebony Tower by John Fowles
Similar in tone to Fowles’s work, The Magus, in depicting sexual tension, immoral longing within a luxurious estate inhabited by an old, prominent painter, his two exhibitionistic ingénues and a visiting artist/writer. Folwes must like dissipation.
The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth
A writer intrudes within the life of his idol and fantasizes about the idol’s student being Ann Franke while the idol’s wife tries to leave him because he’s impossible to live with. Nothing redeeming here.
A depressed (is there any Russian character who isn’t?) and retired bureaucrat rambles in his diary about philosophy, searching for the rationale to act against the system. The second half depicts his rage and his inability to realize his responsibility for his pathetic life.
The Lesson of the Master by Henry James
A struggling writer is mentored by a popular, married author. Authenticity is attained only by self-sacrifice including abandoning the woman he loves. The mentor divorces his wife and then marries the love interest while the writer tries to establish his credentials. Like most of James’s work, the reader is left dissatisfied.
Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
An intellectual doctor finds challenging conversation in an inmate at a town’s asylum. The town is upset by the doctor’s preferences and rumors spread while he is on vacation. When he returns, he discovers that he no longer has a job. He spirals into depression and becomes an inmate. Chekhov is brilliant and, although the story is depressing, it is so well written that you enjoy it!
Pudd'nhead Wilson by Mark Twain
The stupidity of racial assumptions is displayed to the world when babies are switched at birth.
Youth by Joseph Conrad
The impressions left upon a young seaman by a crew handling a cursed ship. The ship is an average Joe beset with problems not of his making who struggles until the end. There is no rhyme nor reason. Only life as it is.
The Old Maid by Edith Wharton
Two sisters living together pose the question: What makes a mother? She who gave her birth or she who raised her?
My Mortal Enemy by Willa Cather
An unexpected conclusion to a wonderfully written story.
Mario and the Magician by Thomas Man
An entire small Italian town is the audience mesmerized by an outrageous, deformed, ugly, midget of a man with hypnotic power. Europe beguiled by the brass of Fascism.
Tortilla Flat by John Steinbeck
One of his earliest is easily one of his worst. A group of drunken bums and their antics. Unremarkable.
Old Man by William Faulkner
Old Man is the Mississippi. A convict recruited for levee duty during the catastrophic flood in 1927 is presumed dead while he saves a pregnant woman, delivers her baby and, with a small skiff tries to get them back up river while caught in the current for New Orleans. Although there are some obvious problems with the story, it is still a great read.
The Fall by Albert Camus
The confessions of a once proud, selfish soul that finds itself alone with regrets. No one is free from himself and he alone is responsible for everything.
Andrea by John O'Hara
The relationship between a promiscuous beauty and a confirmed bachelor attorney over years of seeing each other a day or week at a time over twenty years. Fear of commitment dominates the narrator’s life.
The Blacking Factory by Wilfrid Sheed
Memories recounted by a cynical radio personality of his life as a tender American boy in a Sparta-like British public school.
Catholics by Brian Moore
Eucharistic tradition – the heart of Catholicism – is threatened by ecumenicism promoted from Rome. How will an ancient abbey in Ireland react?
The Ebony Tower by John Fowles
Similar in tone to Fowles’s work, The Magus, in depicting sexual tension, immoral longing within a luxurious estate inhabited by an old, prominent painter, his two exhibitionistic ingénues and a visiting artist/writer. Folwes must like dissipation.
The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth
A writer intrudes within the life of his idol and fantasizes about the idol’s student being Ann Franke while the idol’s wife tries to leave him because he’s impossible to live with. Nothing redeeming here.
April 7, 2020
Liked very few of the novels chosen. Seemed like he collected the most morbid ones by any of the authors used, and some of them struck me as just plain horrible. The proofreaders apparently didn't much care for it either, because there were a fair number of very bad printing mistakes!
Andrea - *** O.K. until the end, then totally depressing
Old Maid - ***
Tortilla Flat - *
Mario and the Magician - ***
Pudd'nhead Wilson -****
Ward No. 6 - **
Notes from Underground - **
Camus - Fall - *
Faulkner - Old Man - *****
Conrad - Youth - *****
James - Lesson of the Master - ***
Cather - My Mortal Enemy -***
Roth - Ghost Writer - ***
Fowles - Ebony Tower - *****
Moore - Catholics - ****
Sheed - Blacking Factory - **** - until the very end, which I hated
Andrea - *** O.K. until the end, then totally depressing
Old Maid - ***
Tortilla Flat - *
Mario and the Magician - ***
Pudd'nhead Wilson -****
Ward No. 6 - **
Notes from Underground - **
Camus - Fall - *
Faulkner - Old Man - *****
Conrad - Youth - *****
James - Lesson of the Master - ***
Cather - My Mortal Enemy -***
Roth - Ghost Writer - ***
Fowles - Ebony Tower - *****
Moore - Catholics - ****
Sheed - Blacking Factory - **** - until the very end, which I hated
September 21, 2011
There are some really great reads in this volume, notably the one by the editor "The Blacking Factory," which recounts the experiences of an American boy sent to an English public school, and the astonishing "Youth," by Joseph Conrad. It had been a long time since I read the others, but I am sure that the Camus is outstanding, and "Notes frome the Underground" took my breath away when I read it at age 20. Others, like the Henry James, I plodded through, wishing I hadn't bothered when I finished. John O'Hara seem gratingly superficial and mercenary to me. But as I say, the volume is worth it for several authors and I value owning it.
Want to read
June 18, 20121) Andrea; O'Hara, John
2) The Old Maid; Wharton, Edith
3) Tortilla Flat; Steinbeck, John
4) Mario and the Magician; Mann, Thomas
5) Pudd'nhead Wilson; Twain, Mark
6) Ward No. 6; Chekhov, Anton
7) Notes from Underground; Dostoevsky, Fyodor
8) The Fall; Camus, Albert
9) Old Man; Faulkner, William
10) Youth; Conrad, Joseph
11) The Lesson of the Master; James, Henry
12) My Mortal Enemy; Cather, Willa
13) The Ghost Writer; Roth, Philip
14) The Ebony Tower; Fowles, John
15) Catholics; Moore, Brian
16) The Blacking Factory; Sheed, Wilfrid
2) The Old Maid; Wharton, Edith
3) Tortilla Flat; Steinbeck, John
4) Mario and the Magician; Mann, Thomas
5) Pudd'nhead Wilson; Twain, Mark
6) Ward No. 6; Chekhov, Anton
7) Notes from Underground; Dostoevsky, Fyodor
8) The Fall; Camus, Albert
9) Old Man; Faulkner, William
10) Youth; Conrad, Joseph
11) The Lesson of the Master; James, Henry
12) My Mortal Enemy; Cather, Willa
13) The Ghost Writer; Roth, Philip
14) The Ebony Tower; Fowles, John
15) Catholics; Moore, Brian
16) The Blacking Factory; Sheed, Wilfrid
Currently reading
November 20, 2021O'Hara - Andrea***** 22 Jul 21
Mann - Mario and the Magician***** 23 Jul 21
Cather - My Mortal Enemy***** 25 Jul 21
Moore - Catholics***** 20 Nov 21
Mann - Mario and the Magician***** 23 Jul 21
Cather - My Mortal Enemy***** 25 Jul 21
Moore - Catholics***** 20 Nov 21
Read
August 12, 2007How do I review such a classic ? Writers read so far, O hara, Dostoyevsky,Roth,Conrad, Camus, etc
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews