Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Wrexford & Sloane #5

Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens

Rate this book
The upcoming marriage of the Earl of Wrexford and Lady Charlotte Sloane promises to be a highlight of the season, if they can first untangle--and survive--a web of intrigue and murder involving the most brilliant scientific minds in Regency London...


One advantage of being caught up in a whirl of dress fittings and decisions about flower arrangements and breakfast menus is that Charlotte Sloane has little time for any pre-wedding qualms. Her love for Wrexford isn't in question. But will being a wife--and a Countess--make it difficult for her to maintain her independence--not to mention, her secret identity as famed satirical artist A.J. Quill?

Despite those concerns, there are soon even more urgent matters to attend to during Charlotte and Wrexford's first public outing as an engaged couple. At a symposium at the Royal Botanic Gardens, a visiting botanist suffers a fatal collapse. The traces of white powder near his mouth reveal the dark truth--he was murdered. Drawn into the investigation, Charlotte and the Earl learn of the victim's involvement in a momentous medical discovery. With fame and immense fortune at stake, there's no shortage of suspects, including some whose ruthlessness is already known. But neither Charlotte nor her husband-to-be can realize how close the danger is about to get--or to what lengths this villain is prepared to go...

353 pages, Hardcover

First published September 28, 2021

About the author

Andrea Penrose

19 books1,747 followers
Andrea Penrose is the USA Today bestselling author of Regency-era historical fiction, including the acclaimed Wrexford & Sloane mystery series, as well as Regency romances written under the names Cara Elliott and Andrea Pickens. Published internationally in ten languages, she is a three-time RITA Award finalist and the recipient of numerous writing awards, including two Daphne Du Maurier Awards for Historical Mystery and two Gold Leaf Awards.

A graduate of Yale University with a B.A. in Art and an M.F.A. in Graphic Design, Andrea fell in love with Regency England after reading Pride and Prejudice and has maintained a fascination with the era’s swirling silks and radical new ideas throughout her writing career. She lives in Connecticut and blogs with a community of historical fiction authors at WordWenches.com. She also can be found at AndreaPenrose.com and on Instagram @AndreaPenroseBooks.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2,416 (37%)
4 stars
2,710 (41%)
3 stars
1,187 (18%)
2 stars
150 (2%)
1 star
31 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 592 reviews
Profile Image for Juliet.
Author 79 books11.6k followers
October 13, 2021
I'm really enjoying this series of romantic historical mysteries. In this novel the botanical details are in keeping with this author's meticulous research - a feature of the whole series. It's always fun to follow the adventures of these intriguing characters.
Profile Image for Randi Annie Framnes.
146 reviews244 followers
September 3, 2021
Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens is book 5 in the Wrexford and Sloan series by Andrea Penrose, published by Kensington. The story is set in London 1812 and continues the story of the Earl of Wrexford and Charlotte Sloane this time taking part in a symposium when a prominent botanist is found dead. The victim was about to make a huge medical invention public without planning to make a fortune off of it which might have enticed any present member of the symposium to commit the murder and steal the needed papers to produce the medicine. Wedding planning is put on hold while the couple investigates and Charlotte is worrying about what marrying and becoming Countess of Wrexford might do to her independence and secret identity as satirical artist A.J.Quill.

Main character is Lady Carlotte Sloan works as satirical artist A.J. Quill and the secrecy of this activity seems to have made her independent, but somewhat lonely. She takes care of two orphan street urchins, which shows she has a good heart. I find her relatable and my favorite character.

Supporting main character Anthony, Earl of Wrexford, is the hot tempered scientist with connections which helps conjure up information which helps the investigation, but has a lethal tongue that frightens people who don’t know him. I find his character relatable in his own way as I have met quite a few similar personalities.

I have feel quite familiar with the characters of this series as I have read several. Starting this story felt a bit like coming home to family with the housekeeper mothering Charlotte’s two orphan street urchins making sure they behaved well while Charlotte and Wrexford were off on their investigation. I enjoyed the continued storyline of the series and felt happy for Charlotte to have found her “Mr. Right”. I am excited to learn what the future might look like for them.

I found the plot stood out as interesting and quite a novelty as I have not read any murder mysteries with a similar plot before and certainly not one set in a botanical garden. How a humble element like a medicinal plant might become the dramatic element in a murder mystery was something I have never considered before, but greed for money is a motive very well known.

My favorite part of this story is how Charlotte is thinking about what changes marriage is going to make for her personal and professional life. I love that she considers more elements of her life than title and privilege. She is going to become Countess of Wrexford with a privileged, but more public lifestyle. Secrecy and anonymity needed to work as A.J. Quill might become more difficult. I find it easy as a woman to relate to this kind of thoughts.

I recommend this story to anyone who enjoys murder mysteries and fans of the author’s previous works in particular.
Similar authors to explore might be Dianne Freeman or Anna Lee Huber.
Thank you to Kensington Books and NetGalley for this opportunity to share my honest review. All opinions are completely my own.

Conclusion: Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens continues the investigations of Wrexford and Sloan as they investigate the murder of a prominent botanist who has made a momentous medical discovery, but has no plans to make money from it.
Profile Image for Linda .
1,879 reviews310 followers
April 28, 2021
Andrea Penrose is a very good writer, but I lost the connection I had with her characters in the first three stories of this series. They were just weeks away from getting married, but neither Wrexford nor Lady Charlotte had evolved. By now, the chemistry and burn I was hoping for was lukewarm at best.

The Weasels loved ginger biscuits. Aunt Allison wanted more family time. McClellan continued to act more like a mother than a housekeeper and I thought Tyler needed more page-time.

Quotes in Latin and historical facts were one of Ms. Penrose’s strong suits. Another strength was maintaining a creative atmosphere in the Regency era. There were multiple plots, twists and overall subterfuge, but it was over the halfway mark before the action kicked in. Before that, it was lots of telling, not showing. I thought the author got caught up trying to maintain numerous historical facts in connection with the mystery.

My overall rating of three stars was because of the reasonable, but sober plot. The suspenseful resolution had a nice twist, but the MCs lacked the magical spark that would have made it really good.

A big thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishers for the opportunity to read a free ARC of this story in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for fleurette.
1,534 reviews158 followers
October 7, 2021
Good historical mystery with a group of nice characters.

We have quite a large group of interesting characters here. Starting with the main ones - Charlotte Sloane and her fiancé Wrexford. There are also Charlotte's wards as well as employees and friends of her and Wrexford. I really liked the relationship between all these characters, based on deep respect and love if not family ties. As you can see clearly in the case of Sloan and Wrexford, for example. I also think that the story has been well spread between different characters, reflecting their skills and personalities.

The plot was very interesting and nicely twisted. The entire book begins with a strong scene in which the body of a scientist who was about to present his groundbreaking discovery is found. Our main characters Sloane and Wrexford are soon drawn into a search for the murderer. The action is fast-paced, and the MCs show intelligence and insight. The ending is well thought out and original.

This was my first encounter with these characters, and this is the fifth book in this series. But it was not the slightest problem. I quickly got to know all the characters and understood the relationships between them. I also have only minimal and necessary knowledge about the events in previous books, so if I decide to read them, I won't have everything spoiled.

I like the characters and would love to meet them again in the next books in this series. I recommend this book to anyone looking for a good entertainment in historical mystery, whether or not they have read any previous books in this series.

Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Books for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
2,882 reviews90 followers
September 22, 2021
Plant secrets to kill for!

The last thing you expect to come upon at an “ elegantly civilized…international symposium of botany scholars and wealthy patrons of science” with leading scientific minds at the Royal Botanic Gardens, is a body! Not just any body, but that of visiting scientist, Josiah Becton! And just as that poor man is in the conservatory breathing in the ambient, rich fragrances, “The essence of life.” Ironic!
Here’s the thing. This is the first grand social event as Wrexham’s future countess, Lady Charlotte Sloane, already anxious, is slated to attend. A death might calm her nerves, but her involvement with it might not endear herself to high society,
Although, as McLellan, that is Mac, their housekeeper cum lady’s maid points out, “ As a married lady—and one with a high-ranking title—you’ll merely be considered eccentric when you break the rules, not scandalous.”
Scandalous or not, neither the Earl of Wrexford and Lady Charlotte (secretly, the famed satirist A.J. Quill) will hold back when they realise that what seems to be a heart attack, could be murder. Any investigation might endanger their family, including the weasels, and that a prime candidate for evil deeds Justinian DeVere is back in the country, attending this symposium. What they don’t realize they’ve stumbled upon is a matter that will affects nations.
Add to this Charlotte’s reunion with her family, the arrival of an old friend from Rome, and the rumours of a possible amazing botanical medical breakthrough. This is a riveting read!
Charlotte is attuned to Wrexford, is certain this is the step she wishes to take, but still questions around her future as A.J. Quill trouble her.
The weasels, Raven and Hawk, are developing into interesting young men. The cool Wrexham is assuming more warmth, flagging to a dangerous heat when fears for his rather unusual bride-to-be. Including the ready made family he’s taking on, along of course with all his other friends that have mostly come his way since he and Charlotte (Charlie) first bumped shoulders. I love the Charlie side of Charlotte when she lets that persona rip.
I do love the banter between Wrexham and the Bow street Runner Griffon, especially around eating.
Atmospheric, believable and compelling! I couldn’t put this down!

A Kensington Books ARC via NetGalley
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
Profile Image for Morgan .
925 reviews219 followers
November 8, 2021
The Earl of Wrexford and Charlotte and now engaged to be married.
While attending a fancy affair at the Royal Botanical Gardens an esteemed scientist is found dead and of course Wrexford and Charlotte are again embroiled in a murder investigation on the eve of their nuptials.
There was a bit too much scientific mumbo jumbo for my taste and by 200+ pages I had lost interest. I read to the end but didn’t much care who the killer was by that point.
Charlotte is reunited with her long estranged brother and I thought more could have been made of that.
Also, one wonders as a married Countess how will Charlotte continue her secret identity as A.J. Quill?
Perhaps the author has left these scenarios for the next book. (??)
The “Weasels” as usual were good for entertainment.
Being #5 in the series I was a bit disappointed as this did not have the same spunk as the previous books. It felt tame in comparison.
Profile Image for Merry .
773 reviews225 followers
December 30, 2021
I have read the Wrexford & Sloane books in order and have enjoyed some (5*) more than others (3*). This book falls into the less category. The book starts out with a murder, then turns to updating the reader with the characters history so it could be read as a standalone book. The action doesn't start till well over the halfway mark in the book. Charlotte is a very strong well written character in the previous books. I felt in this book she comes across as anxious and not ready for her upcoming marriage. There is little chemistry with the main couple. The side characters really shine in the last half of the book. Captain Daggertt was an interesting twist. It was a thought-out plot that took too long to engage me.
Profile Image for Kathy.
3,653 reviews262 followers
February 10, 2022
That wraps it up for me, with the fourth book I have now read from this series through Kindle Unlimited. There are two others where the price is too high for me. I was lucky enough to get in on the wedding of the Earl and his Lady, so that was a satisfying reward. This book includes botanical research for treatment of malaria and those of evil intent who would steal and kill to profit from the hard work and research of others. Wrexford, Charlotte and the whole crew join forces against evil.

Kindle Unlimited
Profile Image for JoAn.
2,257 reviews1 follower
June 16, 2021
Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens by Andrea Penrose may be the fifth book in the series but the mysteries are always fresh. From the first page to the last I did not want to put the book down.

A swiftly paced plot, diabolical villains, suspects that were from all social levels within England and Europe and deft twists and turns that kept me guessing as to who was behind the evil deeds. I loved how Ms. Penrose allowed me to see how Kit has turned his life around and the doubts that are now clouding Charlotte's mind as the wedding looms closer. It was interesting to see how Wrex's devotion to Charlotte, Raven and Hawk has grown as they become his family. Murders, trust issues, friends, family and a touch of romance kept the story moving at just the perfect pace to the exciting rescue. I have read every book in this series and find that each one becomes my favorite until the next one comes out.

I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book from Kensington via NetGalley. All of the above opinions are my own.
5,622 reviews66 followers
August 24, 2021
I won this book in a goodreads drawing.

Wrexford and Sloane are trying to plan their wedding when a botanist is murdered at, you guessed it, the Royal Botanical Gardens. The duo reluctantly investigate. An old enemy shows up. Wrexford acts like Rex Harrison in My Fair Lady. If he weren't a Lord, somebody would punch him in the face.

Not bad, but perhaps I should have started this series at the beginning.
Profile Image for Barbara Rogers.
1,681 reviews192 followers
September 12, 2021
Barbara’s rating: 4.5 of 5 Stars
Series: Wrexford & Sloane #5
Publication Date: 9/28/21
Period: Regency London
Number of Pages: 304

I love this series because of the unique characters, their myriad backgrounds, how they came together, and how their relationships have developed – not to mention the great mysteries they solve. Your enjoyment of this book, and this series, would be enhanced, I believe, if you read at least the first book in the series first. Our characters have grown and evolved so much since that first book – and it would help you to know where they all began. I’ve read and loved each of the books in the series and I’ve loved how the characters have grown.

The setup for the mystery and investigation takes a little while, and to some, it might seem to be a bit too slow-paced at first. However, I thought it was perfect because all of the characters had to be introduced, the crime had to occur, the background set, etc. so the investigation could really take off. This one was a real doozie – there were red herrings aplenty, co-conspirators within co-conspirators, and motives within motives. You’ll definitely not figure this one out until the end. There are clues, but picking them out and putting them together is best left to the experts – Wrexford and Sloane.

Wrexford and Charlotte are looking forward to their wedding in less than a month and they are choosing their social engagements very carefully. The purpose of those social engagements is to ease Charlotte into the ton before she becomes a countess. Charlotte is already Lady Charlotte, but with her history, they’ll have to be very astute in how they answer questions and gain acceptance. That is doubly true when it comes to explaining the existence of the Weasels – Charlotte’s wards – Raven and Hawk. Since Wrexford is known for his cool scientific interests and logic, they have chosen a series of events sponsored by the botanists of the Royal Society at the Royal Botanic Gardens as their initial foray into society. How taxing can a series of lectures and dinners with a bunch of botanists be? Well, when Mr. Becton, one of America’s representatives at the event, is found dead and it wasn’t from natural causes, things get taxing indeed.

According to Mr. Becton’s friend, Mr. Hosack, leader of the American delegation, Becton was set to make the keynote speech that evening and he was to announce a major scientific breakthrough that would save thousands of lives. No one knows what that breakthrough is, what the formula is, or where any of Becton’s papers are kept. Charlotte and Wrexford are ready to stay out of the investigation and let Bow Street handle it until an old enemy (from the last book) rears his ugly head and threatens the Weasels.

As the investigation continues and the suspects are being narrowed down – more deaths occur – and motives blur – and suspects become allies – and – well, it is just very busy with suspects, crimes, motives, governments who aren’t on particularly friendly terms at the time – especially with the nuptials looming and neither Charlotte nor Wexford intend to put those off. The final revelation and resolution is exciting and dangerous and yet it wraps up the case nicely. You’ll be turning the pages faster and faster to see what happens next and how they manage to thwart the bad guys.

I can definitely recommend this book and this series. I will say I got a little tired of Charlotte’s angst. It just seemed out of character for her. She’s usually much more pragmatic. She may have a nagging worry, but she decides on a course of action and moves straight forward. She did have a good bit to be angsty about – her re-entry into society after years away, her upcoming wedding, and her reconciliation with her brother and other members of her family. However, that angst could have been mentioned less often. Our Charlotte just didn’t seem quite like our normal Charlotte.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Barb in Maryland.
1,992 reviews160 followers
November 18, 2021
4.5 stars for the latest mystery/adventure with Lady Charlotte Sloane and the Earl of Wrexford.

The plot is almost too complicated to explain in under 5 pages, so I won't even try. We start with the suspicious death of a famous botanist and end with a boat chase on the Thames. In between we have several known baddies come to a bad end, a mysterious American naval officer who seems to be a baddie, and various bewildered botanists. As well as a rare, quite valuable plant that has gone missing--the object of searches (clandestine and open) by quite a number of the book's characters.

On the personal front, Charlotte and Wrexford are soon to be wed. Neither wants to get involved in the original investigation, yet here they are, along with all of their family and friends. working to find out who was doing what to whom and why. It was great fun for this reader.
There are several quiet, emotionally satisfying moments to give a break in all the action. I was especially happy to meet Charlotte's brother. The book ends on a high note--with the wedding, and our loving couple looking forward to their future.
This book reads like the wrap-up to the series; the way the author worked in so many of the secondary characters, giving each a generous bit of time on the page. However, I won't consider this 'The End' until the author says so.
Profile Image for Sophia.
Author 5 books374 followers
June 15, 2023
Could matters grow more fraught as Charlotte readies not only for a wedding, but a reunion with her brother after years of estrangement from her family? A murder at a society event with political and scientific ramifications transpires drawing Wrexford and Charlotte into the case when dangers whispers close to their family. Andrea Penrose’s pen continues to draw me into the world of her stories in this new favorite series.

Murder at the Royal Botanical Gardens is the fifth of the Wrexford and Sloane Regency Era mystery series.

Art and science, romance, family, and friendship provide exciting and engaging elements to mysteries set against the sparkling world of Regency London from the height of grand society to the murky back alleys and dockyards.

Many times, once the ‘I love you’s are voiced, the story seems to have little further advancement relationship-wise, but that is not the case here. Charlotte and Wrexford may share love and a partnership in the pursuit of justice, but their pasts, particularly Charlotte’s continue to require they put the hard work into making their relationship work. I enjoy getting the story from both their perspectives as they ponder their own selves, each other, and this amazing circle of friends and family they now have.
Charlotte’s great-aunt, the Weasels and the rest of their eclectic band are there to help them not only with this latest case with a rare plant at the heart of it all, but also help Charlotte and Wrexford navigate their lives.

The story starts with the murder, then the investigation, a few great twists and wraps up with a thrilling climax action scene before a delightful and long awaited denouement scene. Satisfying and triumphant and left me wanting more. Historical Mystery fans really need to reach for this series.



My full review will post at The Reading Frenzy on June 5th.

COYER Buddy Read with Lark at The Bookwyrm's Hoard.
Profile Image for Teresa.
651 reviews174 followers
July 29, 2021
It was great to be back with Wrexford, Sloane and the Weasels plus all the recurring side characters. This story was a complicated one. There were two strands to it and at times it got a bit confusing. The plot was well done though and as usual the research was meticulous.
There was quite a bit, in fact a lot about botany in it and it got tiresome at times.
The romance between Wrexford and Sloane has always been understated but I had expected it to be more to the fore this time because of the wedding but other than being mentioned now and again it wasn't until the end it came more into the story.
There were some great 'bad guys' and it was a darker story than she normally writes. It was very slow at the start and I was well into it before it picked up but the actual tie up of the mystery was brilliantly done.
I would like to have seen more of Sheffield and Cordelia as they were great additions to the last book. Sheffield has been there from the start but hardly featured in this one.
All in all very enjoyable and the descriptive writing was beautiful as usual.

Grateful thanks to Kensington Books for the chance to read an early copy of this book.
Profile Image for Ira.
1,110 reviews119 followers
February 24, 2022
4.5 stars.

This one was really good 😍.
I have to admit I like historical mystery with romance in it, more than just historical romance.
The story certainly much more exciting! 😜

The topic for this one regarding plant which could help to cure malaria is an interesting reading.
Unfortunately it took almost two centuries before the vaccines to help the victims became real.

Anyway, if you don’t start this series yet, you should start it now.
Very interesting couple, and the supporting casts were fabulous too! 😘

❤️❤️❤️
Profile Image for Patty Killion.
256 reviews44 followers
September 27, 2021
4 Stars

First I must mention that this book is to released September 28, 2021.

What a wonderful surprise to to win Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens written by Andrea Penrose. I won this ARC on Goodreads! Thank you Goodreads.

What was so great about winning THIS book is that it is the fifth book in A Wexford and Sloane Historical Mystery Series. I have already read the first four books. In fact it is one of my most dearest series I have ever read.

In this fifth installment we are able to peek over the shoulders of my most favorite cast of characters. You will root for Charlotte Sloane, the Earl of Wrexford and an adorable pair of street urchins (the Weasels) solving murders and mysteries during the early days of the industrial revolution in regency/science technology as a main element in the mystery. It highlights the upcoming marriage of the Earl of Wexford and Lady Charlotte Sloane that is...if they can stop tripping over dead bodies!

What a better setting than Regency London, from the slums of St. Giles to the mansions of Mayfair.

I could not recommend this series more! It is my utmost favorite!

#MurderAtTheRoyalBotanicGardens
Profile Image for Patricia Rice.
Author 165 books505 followers
May 10, 2021
Another in the wonderful historical mystery series featuring Wrexford and Sloane, the earl and the satirical artist. In this one, the intrepid pair set out to find who murdered a scientist who had found a cure for malaria—and for the plant that might save millions. And they really need to solve this case before their wedding! The familiar cast of characters grows in depth and interest and are just as fascinating as the mystery.
Profile Image for ☼Bookish in Virginia☼ .
1,253 reviews61 followers
November 13, 2021

I'm vacillating between a 2 and 3 Star rating. On the plus side there were moments that delighted me. Mostly having to do with the Weasels.

On the negative side were what I would call ridiculous assumptions that supposedly drove the characters actions. This is carried over into some silly plotting elements which took a light weight, but fun, mystery series into goofy-land.

Honestly, it makes me want to go back to re-read the other books to see if I was overly enthusiastic. I'll wait awhile though and if they are still fun I will just pretend this last book doesn't exist.
Profile Image for The Sassy Bookworm.
3,776 reviews2,825 followers
November 14, 2021
⭐⭐⭐⭐

I enjoyed this one quite a lot. I found it to be well written and well paced (mostly...It dragged a bit towards the end). I loved the setting and time period. The plot was intriguing and kept me guessing. The characters were well developed and likable. My only complaint, and this may be because I have read none of the other books in the series, but I found the "romance" between Charlotte and Wrexford to be dull. They had zero on page chemistry. 🤷🏻‍♀️ However, as I said, that could be because I have not read the previous books.

**ARC Via NetGalley**
Profile Image for Susan in NC.
996 reviews
November 7, 2021
3.5-4 stars for a rather overloaded conclusion to a fun series - as usual, we get a bang-up, exciting ending, this one particularly satisfying as the rats turn on each other and literally desert the disabled, if not sinking, ship. The long-awaited happy personal event comes at the end, and draws this series to a close.

I can’t really sum up the convoluted plot, but it starts with a dead American botanist about to make a big announcement of a discovery at a symposium at the Royal Botanic Gardens. There’s plenty of murder and intrigue among the international scientific set gathering in Regency London, involving botany, shipping, the slave trade, international exploration for healing plants…all against the backdrop of Wrexford and Lady Charlotte’s upcoming nuptials, and her re-entry into society. Also the secret of her identity as political satirist AJ Quill, and the true background of The Weasels, her young wards. A touching reunion with her brother, sweet inclusion of all the recurring cast of characters in this cozy series, and an unbelievably modern outlook on female strength of character and ability from several male characters, but fun to suspend reality and enjoy the ride! I look forward to reading whatever new series Penrose writes next.
54 reviews2 followers
August 25, 2021
Sadly, this series is going downhill for me. I really enjoyed the first 3 books but the last one and now this one were just...dull. The mystery was convoluted and there were so many obvious red herrings. For a couple who have been solving murders for a while, both Wrexford and Charlotte are really quick to jump to conclusions about people, based on nothing much more than appearances.

It also wasn't entirely obvious why they got involved with this case. Just because one of her wards happened to be nearby when the murder happened? It seemed very contrived.

And the constant navel gazing by both main characters, though more so with Charlotte, was tremendously tedious. Yes, we get it. You're getting married. Life will change. Ugh.

At least the villains weren't referred to as "dastards" every few lines.

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my review.
Profile Image for Susan.
6,347 reviews60 followers
August 14, 2021
The marriage of the Earl of Wrexford and Lady Charlotte Sloane is approaching. But at their first public engagement, at the Royal Botanic Gardens, a body is discovered. Dr. Hosack, head of the American delegation asks Wrexford to investigate. But will they be able to tell friend from foe.
An entertaining and well-written historical mystery with its cast of likeable characters.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Shifra ♕.
243 reviews59 followers
May 31, 2021
Partners in Love & Murder Solving in the Regency Era.
description
Synopsis:

Josiah Becton, an expert botanist on the precipice of sharing a cure for malaria that promises to bring him professional acclamation, is poisoned by a glass of sparkling wine. A fate that could have been prevented if Becton did not succumb to drinking peer pressure; don’t become a statistic kids, just say no! This has been a P.S.A.

Lord Wexford's reputation as a sardonic dabbling chemist, and murder investigator precede him, and thus he is brought into the fray early on by Dr Hosack who knows this was no accident. Wexford, together with his fiancée and partner in solving crime, Lady Charlotte Sloane- creator of satirical comics, that shed light on social injustice under a pen name- will have to ferret out the culprit before they are wed.
description
What Charmed:
♡ The Weasels.
description
♡Lady Charlotte has an interesting backstory and her qualms about marriage after being independent and rejoining the 'beau monde' after her long absence I found refreshing in a HR heroine.
description
♡The villain and motive.

What Marred:
✗ I never connected to the characters, I felt they lacked chemistry.
description
✗ I wasn't overly enthralled with the story, I had to focus to finish.

The Brass Tacks:
➭It is perfectly suitable for any fan of historical fiction and whodunnits, and although I count myself in that camp, and found the writing up to par, it never managed to capture my focus or heart. It crawled in the first half and although the second half was more exciting, and even at times thrilling, by then the lot of it could be categorized in my mind as sluggish.

I received an ARC of this book from the publisher through NetGalley for an honest review.
Profile Image for Sarah-Hope.
1,268 reviews165 followers
December 26, 2021
Andrea Penrose's Wrexford and Sloane series is composed of what I would call "Historical Cozies." There are villains, people (at least one per book) die, but the novels don't contain anything graphic—and the point of these novels is as much to give readers time as observers of an unusual and deeply connected group of amateur detectives as to provide a puzzle to be solved.

There's lord Wrexford, known as a short-tempered man who doesn't suffer fools gladly (and who sees a great many people around him as being foolish). There's Lady Charlotte, rejected by her family and earning a living producing satirical political drawings. We also have "the weasels" and their many friends—Raven and Hawk have been adopted by Lady Charlotte, but remain in contact with their guttersnipe friends, several of whom have found a place to live at Wrexford's country estate. There's a remarkable valet who's also an expert in chemistry and a lady's maid/cook/sharp-shooter. And a dowager who wields a dangerous cane. Who wouldn't want to spend time with this crowd?

The mystery around which Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens is built is satisfyingly complex, with several threads that are gradually pulled closer and closer together and that include a botanical convention, a possible cure for malaria, the illegal slave trade, and tensions between Britain and the U.S.

Penrose does a nice job of slipping in backstory at appropriate moments, so you can easily read this volume even if you aren't familiar with the series. If you like your mysteries a) historical and b) cozy, you have a treat in store if you pick up Murder at the Royal Botanic Gardens. I received a free electronic review copy of this title from the publisher via NetGalley; the opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
2,759 reviews40 followers
October 13, 2021
This was the fifth and perhaps final installment to this series. I have always found the relationship between Charlotte and Wexford interesting. While the mystery was okay, it felt like nothing new or interesting occurred. It was almost like this series has stalled. I enjoyed the ending and will never regret my time in this world.

Thank you to Kensington Publishing Corporation and NetGalley for my review copy.
Profile Image for Lisa C.
415 reviews
December 23, 2021
I did make it to the end, but this installment was thoroughly disappointing in terms of character arcs. It's as if once hitting the Cinderella moment, Sloane lost all ability to think for herself. Even during a late scene where she has a clear intention of taking action, she waits to see her maid's response (approval). In the words of an Austen critic, the character has become "insipid." Such a shame, as the realistic independence was such an advantage of the series.
Profile Image for Fred.
1,010 reviews64 followers
September 28, 2021
Murder At The Royal Botanic Gardens is the fifth book in the Wrexford and Sloane series by Andrea Penrose.

The wedding of Lady Charlotte and Earl of Wrexford is just weeks away, and there are last-minute tasks to be taken care of. But Wrexford has received an invitation from the Royal Society to attend a symposium they are sponsoring at the Royal Botanical Gardens. Heading the meeting will be Dr. Becton, an American scientist, presenting his paper on a medical breakthrough that may end up saving lives all over the world.

When Dr. Becton is found dead in one of the gardens, his friend Dr. Hosack asks Wrexford to check the body of Becton. The last thing Wrexford wants to do is get involved in an investigation that might interfere with his and Charlotte’s wedding. He reluctantly agrees when he finds a suspicious white powder on Becton’s lips. This decision is reinforced when Wrexford learns that Raven hid in some nearby plants in one of Charlotte’s wards. Plus, someone who nearly caused Charlotte’s death earlier has issued a threat on the lives of Raven and Hawk.

Charlotte and Wrexford will be looking into several suspects. These involve an American Naval officer and a couple of unscrupulous shipping companies. Charlotte will have to don her street-urchin clothes, and Raven and Hawk will engage their friends to go undercover to find the killer. Even Charlotte’s housekeeper is involved in the thrilling ending.

Besides her wedding and the investigation, Charlotte is looking forward with mixed emotions to meeting with her estranged brother. She hasn’t had contact with her family since her first marriage, except for Aunt Allison.

This series is one of my favorite historical mysteries. The stories are well-written, and there were plenty of red herrings that kept me guessing until the end of the book as to who the killer was. The characters are all excellent and believable. I enjoy the banter between Charlotte and Wrexford when she feels that Wrexford is too protective. As always, Raven and Hawk are a delight. I also appreciated the Authors Notes which proved helpful in understanding the book’s setting.

I’m eagerly awaiting the next book in this informative and exciting series.



Profile Image for ☕️Kimberly  (Caffeinated Reviewer).
3,293 reviews734 followers
July 5, 2023
Despite being worried about maintaining her secret identity as the famed satirical artist A.J. Quill, Charlotte Sloane is excited about marrying Wrexford. Wedding dress fittings and their first outing as an engaged couple at the Royal Botanic Gardens, are soon complicated when a botanist suffers a fatal collapse. Was it murder?

The tale that unfolds offered an engaging murder-mystery. When they learn the botanist was on the verge of a significant medical discovery, they soon deal with a long list of suspects. I love watching Wrexford & Sloane work their way through them as they used their skills of deduction.

Of course they have Raven, Hawk and Henning along with Griffin, the bow street runner, to aid them. As well as Sheffield and Cordelia, whom I would really like to get to know more. This motley crew of misfits delight me.

The mystery had darker tones and quickly pulled me in. Penrose touched on social injustices while we skirted the ton and had a few moments with our couple. The romance despite the upcoming nuptials took a backseat to the demanding mystery, but I delighted in their conversations.

The Wrexford & Sloan mysteries have quickly become a favorite. The audiobooks narrated by James Cameron Stewart are wonderful. He captures the tone wonderfully and has become the voices of these characters. I highly recommend listening.

Fans of historical murder-mysteries with romance and strong characters will delight in these tales. The mysteries are well honed and will keep you engaged, but it’s the characters themselves that will have you devouring the series. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
September 25, 2021
The Story: Josiah Becton, a visiting botanist is found dead at the Royal Botanic Gardens. White traces of powder was found near his mouth. Both Lady Charlotte and her fiancé, Earl of Wrexford inadvertently found themselves embroiled in this mystery.

My thoughts: I have no idea that this is the fifth instalment in this series but the good thing is, it can totally be read as a standalone. There was just enough backstories that I did not feel that I miss out on anything at all!

In fact, the characters are so well-written that I could connect with them instantly! I find both Hawk and Raven (Charlotte's young ward) are such endearing characters. I liked how they played a role in the investigations too, working together with other street urchins. They remind me of Sherlock's Baker Street Irregulars. I loved it!

The plot was a pretty complex one and did feel like a lot is going on but the investigations part make it interesting. I liked how each twist and clue slowly unravels the mystery that turned out to be so good!

Overall, I enjoyed this book more than I expected! As always, I recommend reading the author's note. Some of the characters in this story were actually based on real life historical figures who had made significant contributions to botanical medicine during the Age of Enlightenment.


Pub. Date: Sep 28, 2021

***Thank you Kensington Books for this gifted copy to read and review. All opinions expressed are my own.***
Profile Image for Ami.
6,041 reviews491 followers
August 16, 2022
As I said in my thoughts for Murder at Queen's Landing, my attention for the later books in this series is more about the characters rather than the mystery. And in this one, oh my, so much happy feelings that I have for them!

From Charlotte meeting her estranged brother (Hawk worries that Lord Wolcott will not like him and Raven and Charlotte assures Hawk that her brother WILL, awww) to this band of chosen family gather their wits and strengths TOGETHER to save Tyler (Wrexford's valet) from the clutch of the villains. I ADORED that scene in the last chapters SO MUCH.

I loved that Raven and Hawk bloomed into smart young boys. I loved that Sheffield and Cordelia still dancing around their attraction (they needed to sort our their feelings quickly!). I loved that Tyler and McCellan didn't feel like "servants" - they were more like confidants for Wrexford and Charlotte. And I loved that Wrexford and Charlotte finally seal the deal to legally become family.

I was a bit annoyed with Charlotte's constant worries about the future, but at the same time being a Countess did bring certain tasks and she had the identity of A.J. Quill that she didn't want to let go. So Charlotte had to balance between keeping that part of herself, to not indirectly hurting those she loved dearly.

I cannot wait to see their new life as family in the next book...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 592 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.