Jump to content

Wikipedia:Dispute resolution noticeboard: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Line 112: Line 112:
*I'm a DRN volunteer and am awaiting opening statements. [[User: Electriccatfish2|Electric]] [[User talk: Electriccatfish2|Catfish]] 21:14, 14 August 2012 (UTC)
*I'm a DRN volunteer and am awaiting opening statements. [[User: Electriccatfish2|Electric]] [[User talk: Electriccatfish2|Catfish]] 21:14, 14 August 2012 (UTC)
::The parties have not yet discussed this matter on the article's talk page (see [[Talk:Felice_Bauer]]). The DRN instructions at the top of the DRN page state that DRN is ''"not a substitute for the talk pages: the dispute must have been discussed extensively on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) before resorting to DRN."'' Recommend that the parties be instructed to try to resolve this on the article Talk page; and if a week goes by without resolution, then start a case here at DRN. --[[User:Noleander|Noleander]] ([[User talk:Noleander|talk]]) 21:18, 14 August 2012 (UTC)
::The parties have not yet discussed this matter on the article's talk page (see [[Talk:Felice_Bauer]]). The DRN instructions at the top of the DRN page state that DRN is ''"not a substitute for the talk pages: the dispute must have been discussed extensively on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) before resorting to DRN."'' Recommend that the parties be instructed to try to resolve this on the article Talk page; and if a week goes by without resolution, then start a case here at DRN. --[[User:Noleander|Noleander]] ([[User talk:Noleander|talk]]) 21:18, 14 August 2012 (UTC)
:::The [[Felice Bauer]] page is a collateral: the main issue is vandalism on my own page. I will, however, discuss that side of the issue there, as instructed.


== Aliya Mustafina ==
== Aliya Mustafina ==

Revision as of 21:24, 14 August 2012

    Welcome to the dispute resolution noticeboard (DRN)

    This is an informal place to resolve small content disputes as part of dispute resolution. It may also be used as a tool to direct certain discussions to more appropriate forums, such as requests for comment, or other noticeboards. You can ask a question on the talk page. This is an early stop for most disputes on Wikipedia. You are not required to participate, however, the case filer must participate in all aspects of the dispute or the matter will be considered failed. Any editor may volunteer! Click this button to add your name! You don't need to volunteer to help. Please feel free to comment below on any case. Be civil and remember; Maintain Wikipedia policy: it is usually a misuse of a talk page to continue to argue any point that has not met policy requirements. Editors must take particular care adding information about living persons to any Wikipedia page. This may also apply to some groups.

    Noticeboards should not be a substitute for talk pages. Editors are expected to have had extensive discussion on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) to work out the issues before coming to DRN.
    Do you need assistance? Would you like to help?

    If we can't help you, a volunteer will point you in the right direction. Discussions should be civil, calm, concise, neutral, objective and as nice as possible.

    • This noticeboard is for content disputes only. Comment on the contributions, not the contributors. Off-topic or uncivil behavior may garner a warning, improper material may be struck-out, collapsed, or deleted, and a participant could be asked to step back from the discussion.
    • We cannot accept disputes that are already under discussion at other content or conduct dispute resolution forums or in decision-making processes such as Requests for comments, Articles for deletion, or Requested moves.
    • The dispute must have been recently discussed extensively on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) to be eligible for help at DRN. The discussion should have been on the article talk page. Discussion on a user talk page is useful but not sufficient, because the article talk page may be watched by other editors who may be able to comment. Discussion normally should have taken at least two days, with more than one post by each editor.
    • Ensure that you deliver a notice to each person you add to the case filing by leaving a notice on their user talk page. DRN has a notice template you can post to their user talk page by using the code shown here: {{subst:drn-notice}}. Be sure to sign and date each notice with four tildes (~~~~). Giving notice on the article talk page in dispute or relying on linking their names here will not suffice.
    • Do not add your own formatting in the conversation. Let the moderators (DRN Volunteers) handle the formatting of the discussion as they may not be ready for the next session.
    • Follow moderator instructions There will be times when the moderator may issue an instruction. It is expected of you to follow their instruction and you can always ask the volunteer on their talk page for clarification, if not already provided. Examples are about civility, don't bite the newcomers, etc.
    If you need help:

    If you need a helping hand just ask a volunteer, who will assist you.

    • This is not a court with judges or arbitrators that issue binding decisions: we focus on resolving disputes through consensus, compromise, and advice about policy.
    • For general questions relating to the dispute resolution process, please see our FAQ page.

    We are always looking for new volunteers and everyone is welcome. Click the volunteer button above to join us, and read over the volunteer guide to learn how to get started. Being a volunteer on this page is not formal in any respect, and it is not necessary to have any previous dispute resolution experience. However, having a calm and patient demeanor and a good knowledge of Wikipedia policies and guidelines is very important. It's not mandatory to list yourself as a volunteer to help here, anyone is welcome to provide input.

    Volunteers should remember:
    • Volunteers should gently and politely help the participant fix problems. Suggest alternative venues if needed. Try to be nice and engage the participants.
    • Volunteers do not have any special powers, privileges, or authority in DRN or in Wikipedia, except as noted here. Volunteers who have had past dealings with the article, subject matter, or with the editors involved in a dispute which would bias their response must not act as a volunteer on that dispute. If any editor objects to a volunteer's participation in a dispute, the volunteer must either withdraw or take the objection to the DRN talk page to let the community comment upon whether or not the volunteer should continue in that dispute.
    • Listed volunteers open a case by signing a comment in the new filing. When closing a dispute, please mark it as "closed" in the status template (see the volunteer guide for more information), remove the entire line about 'donotarchive' so that the bot will archive it after 48 hours with no other edits.
    Open/close quick reference
    • To open, replace {{DR case status}} with {{DR case status|open}}
    • To close, replace the "open" with "resolved", "failed", or "closed". Add {{DRN archive top|reason=(reason here) ~~~~}} beneath the case status template, and add {{DRN archive bottom}} at the bottom of the case. Remember to remove the DoNotArchive bit line (the entire line).
    Case Created Last volunteer edit Last modified
    Title Status User Time User Time User Time
    Face masks during the COVID-19 pandemic Closed Randomstaplers (t) 29 days, 2 hours Robert McClenon (t) 3 days, 1 hours Robert McClenon (t) 3 days, 1 hours
    List of musicals filmed live on stage Closed Wolfdog (t) 10 days, 15 hours Robert McClenon (t) 4 days, 2 hours Wolfdog (t) 2 days, 14 hours
    Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, Zsa Zsa Gabor New PromQueenCarrie (t) 9 days, 5 hours Robert McClenon (t) 3 days, Beshogur (t) 21 hours
    Genocides in history (before World War I) New Jonathan f1 (t) 4 days, 11 hours Robert McClenon (t) 4 days, 2 hours Cdjp1 (t) 3 days, 17 hours
    List of prime ministers of Sri Lanka New DinoGrado (t) 2 days, 22 hours None n/a DinoGrado (t) 2 days, 22 hours
    Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf New Titan2456 (t) 1 days, 15 hours None n/a SheriffIsInTown (t) 1 days, 15 hours
    Ryan T._Anderson New Marspe1 (t) 1 days, 8 hours None n/a Marspe1 (t) 1 days, 8 hours

    If you would like a regularly-updated copy of this status box on your user page or talk page, put {{DRN case status}} on your page. Click on that link for more options.
    Last updated by FireflyBot (talk) at 19:46, 15 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]


    Cold Fusion

    – General close. See comments for reasoning.
    Closed discussion

    User_talk:Complainer, Felice_Bauer

    – Discussion in progress.


    Have you discussed this on a talk page?

    Yes, I have discussed this issue on a talk page already.

    Location of dispute

    Users involved

    Dispute overview

    User Br'er_Rabbit, apparently offended at the idea that I deleted my own edit in a minor discussion with another (uninvolved) user, repeatedly vandalized my talk page with name calling and some kind of fake proposal to keep me from applying common sense policies in dealing with my own talk page. I am fairly indifferent to this; however, Br'er_Rabbit resorted to stalking and reverted an edit to Felice Bauer in spite of being explained that the text removed it is both incorrect and badly written. Assuming good faith, I am forced NOT to assume that this is an attempt at making me violate the 3RV policy; it is, however vandalism.

    Have you tried to resolve this previously?

    Applied WP:NOR, deleted vandalizing edit. The confrontational nature of the edits prevented me from discussing them with the other party involved, who seems to be very angry for some reason unknown to me. I have had no dealing with him before, neither on wikipedia or otherwise, and the nature of his hostility is unknown to me.

    How do you think we can help?

    Reprimand Br'er_Rabbit; failing that, block him and his (official) sockpuppets from editing my pagesfrom editing my pages. Reinstate the edit on Felice_Bauer (which I am prevented from doing by the 3RV rule). Suggest forum for inexperienced editors where Br'er_Rabbit can be read about the nature of trolling and the application of WP:NOR.

    Opening comments by Br'er_Rabbit

    Please limit to 2000 characters - longer statements may be deleted in their entirety or asked to be shortened. This is so a volunteer can review the dispute in a timely manner. Thanks.

    User_talk:Complainer, Felice_Bauer discussion

    Please do not use this for discussing the dispute prior to a volunteer opening the thread for comments - continue discussing the issues on the article talk page if necessary.

    The parties have not yet discussed this matter on the article's talk page (see Talk:Felice_Bauer). The DRN instructions at the top of the DRN page state that DRN is "not a substitute for the talk pages: the dispute must have been discussed extensively on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) before resorting to DRN." Recommend that the parties be instructed to try to resolve this on the article Talk page; and if a week goes by without resolution, then start a case here at DRN. --Noleander (talk) 21:18, 14 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]
    The Felice Bauer page is a collateral: the main issue is vandalism on my own page. I will, however, discuss that side of the issue there, as instructed.

    Aliya Mustafina

    – Discussion in progress.


    Have you discussed this on a talk page?

    Yes, I have discussed this issue on a talk page already.

    Location of dispute

    Users involved

    Dispute overview

    I am bringing up the fact that the Olympic Gold Medalist 2012 Aliya Mustafina is Tatar. I have tried to reflect this in the starting line of the article but faced continuous reverting. I have supplied the links, explaining the notability of this achievement for Tatars, given the fact that very few Tatars are/were Olympic Champions. I have also appealed to the fact that virtually all athletes have their ethnicity/background mentioned in the first line. In addition, I have said that Tatarstan is a sovereign entity with own constitution and president. Somebody is trying to deprive her of her Tatar identity which is clearly a breach of rights.

    Have you tried to resolve this previously?

    I have discussed the matter on user's talk page, explaining the importance and asking not to change it. I have also supplied the links (references) of notability of here being a Tatar.

    How do you think we can help?

    A person should never be deprived of his/her identity, whatever it is. You can protect the right to state the Tatar identity in the front line.

    Best Regards.

    Opening comments by Mbinebri

    Please limit to 2000 characters - longer statements may be deleted in their entirety or asked to be shortened. This is so a volunteer can review the dispute in a timely manner. Thanks.

    Aliya Mustafina discussion

    Please do not use this for discussing the dispute prior to a volunteer opening the thread for comments - continue discussing the issues on the article talk page if necessary.

    The parties have not yet discussed this matter on the article's talk page (see Talk:Aliya_Mustafina). The DRN instructions at the top of the DRN page state that DRN is "not a substitute for the talk pages: the dispute must have been discussed extensively on a talk page (not just through edit summaries) before resorting to DRN." Recommend that the parties be instructed to try to resolve this on the article Talk page; and if a week goes by without resolution, then start a case here at DRN. --Noleander (talk) 21:18, 14 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]
    He said that he has discussed it on the user's talk page. Electric Catfish 21:23, 14 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]