Jump to content

Van, Turkey: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Back at it again, Murat? Perhaps it was reverted because it was not a rebellion in the first place.
Reversed the undo by a pov editor seemingly engaged in ethnic struggle on these pages. If "armed revolt" was not correct in your mind, then please make an argument, suggest alternative before wholesale delete.
Line 145: Line 145:
The province's Armenian population was devastated during [[World War I]] by Ottoman troops in the opening phases of the [[Armenian Genocide]].<ref>Akcam, Taner. ''A Shameful Act'', p. 140. New York:Henry Holt Co. 2006. ISBN 0-8050-8665-X</ref> The regional administrator, [[Cevdet Bey|Jevdet Bey]], was reported to have said that "We have cleansed the Armenians and Syriac [Christian]s from Azerbaijan, and we will do the same in Van.<ref name="Akçam, 201">Akçam, 201</ref> Numerous reports from Ottoman officials, such as a parliament deputy, the governor of Allepo as well as the German consul in Van, suggested that deliberate provocations against the Armenians were being orchestrated by the local government.<ref name="Akçam, 201"/> In Mid-April 1915, Cevdet Bey ordered the execution of four Armenian leaders<ref>Morgenthau, Henry. ''Ambassador Morgenthau's Story'', p.205. Wayne State University Press, 2003. ISBN 0-8143-2979-9</ref><ref>Ussher, Clarence Douglass. ''An American Physician in Turkey'', p.236. Houghton Mifflin Company, 1917.</ref> resulting in an uprising in Van on April 20, 1915, against the Turks and in favor of the Russians. On the other hand, Turkish historian and genocide scholar Taner Akçam acknowledges that in the case of Van, the deportations may have been driven by military necessity<ref>Akçam, 202</ref> and states the resistance in Van should be examined as a separate case.<ref>Akçam, 200</ref> Another quote from Professor Eleanor Bisbee shows that there is no scientific consensus: "When the Russians and the Turks became enemies at war in 1914, the Armenians sided with the Russians. As soon as word spread that the Armenians were massacring Moslem Turks and Kurds and were setting up an Armenian government in Van, the Young Turks passed a law to disarm and deport them. This turned into the 1915-1916 migrations and massacres of Armenians, and was followed by counter-massacres of Muslims by Russo-Armenian forces occupying eastern Turkey n 1917-18.".<ref>Bisbee, Eleanor. ''The New Turks'', University of Pennsylvania, 1951, p. 49</ref>
The province's Armenian population was devastated during [[World War I]] by Ottoman troops in the opening phases of the [[Armenian Genocide]].<ref>Akcam, Taner. ''A Shameful Act'', p. 140. New York:Henry Holt Co. 2006. ISBN 0-8050-8665-X</ref> The regional administrator, [[Cevdet Bey|Jevdet Bey]], was reported to have said that "We have cleansed the Armenians and Syriac [Christian]s from Azerbaijan, and we will do the same in Van.<ref name="Akçam, 201">Akçam, 201</ref> Numerous reports from Ottoman officials, such as a parliament deputy, the governor of Allepo as well as the German consul in Van, suggested that deliberate provocations against the Armenians were being orchestrated by the local government.<ref name="Akçam, 201"/> In Mid-April 1915, Cevdet Bey ordered the execution of four Armenian leaders<ref>Morgenthau, Henry. ''Ambassador Morgenthau's Story'', p.205. Wayne State University Press, 2003. ISBN 0-8143-2979-9</ref><ref>Ussher, Clarence Douglass. ''An American Physician in Turkey'', p.236. Houghton Mifflin Company, 1917.</ref> resulting in an uprising in Van on April 20, 1915, against the Turks and in favor of the Russians. On the other hand, Turkish historian and genocide scholar Taner Akçam acknowledges that in the case of Van, the deportations may have been driven by military necessity<ref>Akçam, 202</ref> and states the resistance in Van should be examined as a separate case.<ref>Akçam, 200</ref> Another quote from Professor Eleanor Bisbee shows that there is no scientific consensus: "When the Russians and the Turks became enemies at war in 1914, the Armenians sided with the Russians. As soon as word spread that the Armenians were massacring Moslem Turks and Kurds and were setting up an Armenian government in Van, the Young Turks passed a law to disarm and deport them. This turned into the 1915-1916 migrations and massacres of Armenians, and was followed by counter-massacres of Muslims by Russo-Armenian forces occupying eastern Turkey n 1917-18.".<ref>Bisbee, Eleanor. ''The New Turks'', University of Pennsylvania, 1951, p. 49</ref>


However, most historians agree that the Armenian residents, hoping to avoid the slaughter inflicted on the rural populations surrounding Van, defended themselves in the Armenian quarters of the city against the Turks.<ref name="gens">The Banality of Indifference: Zionism and the Armenian Genocide - Page 42 by Yaïr Auron</ref> The [[Anti-Turkism|anti-Turkish]] and pro-Russian sentiments were in the hopes of being rescued from Turkish massacres. The Russians finally relieved the Armenian defenders of Van in late May 1915. In August, a victory over the Russian army allowed the Ottoman army to retake Van. In September 1915, the Russians forced the Turks out of Van for the second time. Russian forces began to leave the area after the [[Russian Revolution of 1917]], and by April 1918, it was recaptured by the Ottoman army. According to Taner Akçam, citing Osmali Belgelerinde Ermeniler 1915-1920, after the Turks took back the city from the Russians they killed all Armenians in the city.<ref>Akçam, Taner. "A shameful Act." Translated by Paul Bessemer. Metropolitan Books, New York. 2006, 140</ref> However, the end of World War I forced the Ottoman army to surrender its claim to Van, although it stayed in Turkish hands following the Turkish War of Independence.
However, most historians agree that the Armenian residents, hoping to avoid the slaughter inflicted on the rural populations surrounding Van, defended themselves in the Armenian quarters of the city against the Turks.<ref name="gens">The Banality of Indifference: Zionism and the Armenian Genocide - Page 42 by Yaïr Auron</ref> The [[Anti-Turkism|anti-Turkish]] and pro-Russian sentiments were in the hopes of being rescued from Turkish massacres. The Russians finally relieved the Armenian defenders of Van in late May 1915. In August, a victory over the Russian army allowed the Ottoman army to retake Van. In September 1915, the Russians forced the Turks out of Van for the second time. Russian forces began to leave the area after the [[Russian Revolution of 1917]], and by April 1918, it was recaptured by the Ottoman army. According to Taner Akçam, citing Osmali Belgelerinde Ermeniler 1915-1920, after the Turks took back the city from the Russians they killed all Armenians in the city.<ref>Akçam, Taner. "A shameful Act." Translated by Paul Bessemer. Metropolitan Books, New York. 2006, 140</ref> However, the end of World War I forced the Ottoman army to surrender its claim to Van, although it stayed in Turkish hands following the Turkish War of Independence.


===Turkish War of Independence and Republic===
===Turkish War of Independence and Republic===

Revision as of 00:03, 29 May 2011

Van
City
A view from the Dabbağoğlu Park, with the Hazreti Ömer Mosque in the background.
A view from the Dabbağoğlu Park, with the Hazreti Ömer Mosque in the background.
Government
 • MayorBekir Kaya (BDP)
Elevation
1,730 m (5,680 ft)
Population
 (2010)
 • Total367,419

Van (Turkish: Van, Armenian: Վան Van,[1] Kurdish: Wan) is a city in eastern Turkey and the seat of Van Province, and is located on the eastern shore of Lake Van. The city's official population in 2010 was 367,419,[2] but many estimates put this as much higher with a 1996 estimate stating 500,000[3] and former Mayor Burhan Yengun quoted as saying it may be as high as 600 000.[4]

History

File:Vancity 04.jpg
Castle of Van
Inscription of Xerxes the Great on the walls of the Van Citadel.
Lake Van

Archaeological excavations and surveys carried out in Van province indicate that the history of human settlement in this region goes back at least as far as 5000 B.C. The Tilkitepe Mound, which is on the shores of Lake Van and a few kilometres to the south of Van Castle, is the only source of information about the oldest culture of Van.

Urartu

Under the ancient name of Tushpa, Van was the capital of the Urartian kingdom in the 9th century BC. The early settlement was centered on the steep-sided bluff now known as Van Castle (Van Kalesi), close to the edge of Lake Van and a few kilometers west of the modern city. Here have been found Urartian cuneiform inscriptions dating to the 8th and 7th centuries BC. In the trilingual Behistun inscription, carved in the order of Darius the Great of Persia, the country referred to as Urartu in Babylonian is called Armenia in Old Persian.

From the Orontids to the Kingdom of Armenia

The region came under the control of the Armenian Orontids in the 7th century BC and later Persians in the mid 6th century BC. In 331 BC, Van was conquered by Alexander the Great and after his death became part of the Seleucid Empire. By the early 2nd century BC it was part of the Kingdom of Armenia. It became an important center during the reign of the Armenian king, Tigranes II, who founded the city of Tigranakert in the 1st century BC.[5] This region was ruled by the Arsacid Dynasty of Armenia before 4th century AD. In the History of Armenia attributed to Moses of Chorene, the city is called Tosp, from Urartian Tushpa.[6]

The Byzantines and the kingdom of Vaspurakan

The Byzantine Empire briefly held the region from 628 to 640, after which it was invaded by the Muslim Arabs, who consolidated their conquests as the province of Ermeniye. Decline in Arab power eventually allowed local Armenian rulers to re-emerge, with the Artsruni dynasty soon becoming the most powerful. Initially dependent on the rulers of the Kingdom of Ani, they declared their independence in 908, founding the kingdom of Vaspurakan. The kingdom had no specific capital: the court would move as the king transferred his residence from place to place, such as Van city, Vostan, Aghtamar, etc. In 1021 the last king of Vaspurakan, John-Senekerim Artsruni, ceded his entire kingdom to the Byzantine empire, who established the Vaspurakan theme on the former Artsruni territories.

The Seljuk Empire

Incursions by the Seljuk Turks into Vaspurakan started in the 1050s. After their victory in 1071 at the battle of Manzikert the entire region fell under their control. After them, local Muslim rulers emerged, such as the Ahlatshahs and the Ayyubids (1207). For a 20 year period, Van was held by the Anatolian Seljuk Sultanate until the 1240s when it was conquered by the Mongols. In the 14th century, Van was held by the Kara Koyunlu Turks, and later by the Timurids.

The Ottoman Empire

The first half of the 15th century saw the Van region become a land of conflict as it was disputed by the Ottoman Empire and the Persian Safavid Empire. The Safavids captured Van in 1502. The Ottomans took the city in 1515 and held it for a short period. The Safavids took it again in 1520 and the Ottomans gained final and definite control of the city in 1548. They first made Van into a sanjak dependent on the Erzurum eyalet, and later into a separate Van eyalet in about 1570.

Towards the second half of the 19th century Van began to play an increased role in the politics of the Ottoman Empire due to its location near the borders of the Persian, Russian and Ottoman Empire, as well as its proximity to Mosul.

During the period leading up to the breakup of the Ottoman Empire, Armenians were well represented in the local administration.[7]

City life

The rock and walled city of Van in 1893, per H. F. B. Lynch.

During the early 1900s, the city of Van had eleven Armenian schools and ten Turkish.[8] Armenian churches within the walled city included Saint Tiramayr (Armenian: Սուրբ Տիրամայր), Saint Vardan (Armenian: Սուրբ Վարդան), Saint Poghos (Armenian: Սուրբ Պողոս), Saint Nshan (Armenian: Սուրբ Նշան), Saint Sahak (Armenian: Սուրբ Սահակ), and Saint Tsiranavor (Armenian: Սուրբ Ծիրանաւոր); in Aygestan (Armenian: Այգեստան), Haykavank (Armenian: Հայկավանք), Norashen (Armenian: Նորաշէն), Arark (Armenian: Արարք), Hankoysner, and other quarters each had a church.[8]

Demographics

The demographics of Ottoman Van are a debated and contentious point as they relate directly to claims of ownership by either side prior to the outbreak of World War I. Based on the official 1914 Ottoman Census the population of Van province consisted of 179,422 Muslims and 67,797 Armenians.[9] The Ottoman Census figures include only male citizens, excluding women and children. According to a more recent research, the corrected estimates for Van province (including women and children) was; 313,000 Muslims, 130,000 Armenians, and 65,000 others, including Syriac Christians and Nestorians.[10] The demographics of Van are a greatly debated point given the changing of provincial borders. For example, in 1875 the province was divided and Van and Hakkari separated, only to be rejoined in 1888 which drastically changed the make up of any census, and some writers argue that this merging was done to keep the Armenians from forming a majority.[11] In 1862 it was estimated that in Van there were 90,100 Christians (including Nestorians) and 95,100 Muslims.[12] The French Consul in Van reported that in Van and Bitlis 51.46% were Kurds, 32.70 were Armenians and 5.53% were Turks.[13] On the other hand, the Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople estimated 185 000 Armenians in Van, 18000 Assyrian Jacobites, 72 000 Kurds, 47 000 Turks, 25 000 Yezidis and 3 000 Gypsis.[14] Both sides have been accused of overcounting the numbers at the time given the revival of the Armenian Question and population statistics became important during the Berlin Conference.[15]

World War I and the Armenian Genocide

Ruins of the old city of Van seen from the castle rock.

The province's Armenian population was devastated during World War I by Ottoman troops in the opening phases of the Armenian Genocide.[16] The regional administrator, Jevdet Bey, was reported to have said that "We have cleansed the Armenians and Syriac [Christian]s from Azerbaijan, and we will do the same in Van.[17] Numerous reports from Ottoman officials, such as a parliament deputy, the governor of Allepo as well as the German consul in Van, suggested that deliberate provocations against the Armenians were being orchestrated by the local government.[17] In Mid-April 1915, Cevdet Bey ordered the execution of four Armenian leaders[18][19] resulting in an uprising in Van on April 20, 1915, against the Turks and in favor of the Russians. On the other hand, Turkish historian and genocide scholar Taner Akçam acknowledges that in the case of Van, the deportations may have been driven by military necessity[20] and states the resistance in Van should be examined as a separate case.[21] Another quote from Professor Eleanor Bisbee shows that there is no scientific consensus: "When the Russians and the Turks became enemies at war in 1914, the Armenians sided with the Russians. As soon as word spread that the Armenians were massacring Moslem Turks and Kurds and were setting up an Armenian government in Van, the Young Turks passed a law to disarm and deport them. This turned into the 1915-1916 migrations and massacres of Armenians, and was followed by counter-massacres of Muslims by Russo-Armenian forces occupying eastern Turkey n 1917-18.".[22]

However, most historians agree that the Armenian residents, hoping to avoid the slaughter inflicted on the rural populations surrounding Van, defended themselves in the Armenian quarters of the city against the Turks.[23] The anti-Turkish and pro-Russian sentiments were in the hopes of being rescued from Turkish massacres. The Russians finally relieved the Armenian defenders of Van in late May 1915, and the Tashnak Armenians who were leading the armed revolt welcomed the invading Russian general Yudenich in a ceremony where they offered him the keys to this ancient Ottoman city (see Van Resistance). In August, a victory over the Russian army allowed the Ottoman army to retake Van. In September 1915, the Russians forced the Turks out of Van for the second time. Russian forces began to leave the area after the Russian Revolution of 1917, and by April 1918, it was recaptured by the Ottoman army. According to Taner Akçam, citing Osmali Belgelerinde Ermeniler 1915-1920, after the Turks took back the city from the Russians they killed all Armenians in the city.[24] However, the end of World War I forced the Ottoman army to surrender its claim to Van, although it stayed in Turkish hands following the Turkish War of Independence.

Turkish War of Independence and Republic

In the Treaty of Sèvres, the Entente Powers decided to cede the city to the Democratic Republic of Armenia. Turkish revolutionaries, led by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk rejected the terms of the treaty and instead waged the Turkish War of Independence. However the idea of ceding Van to the Armenians was flouted, and Ismet Inonu was said to have surveyed army officers on 14 October 1919 on the issue of ceding Van and Bitlis. However the parliament in Ankara rejected any compromise on this issue.[25][page needed]By 1920, Van fell under Turkish control again and its remaining Armenian inhabitants were expelled in a final round of ethnic cleansing.[23] With the Treaty of Lausanne and Treaty of Kars, the Treaty of Sèvres was annulled and Van remained officially under Turkish sovereignty.

By the end of the conflicts, the town of Van was empty and in ruins. The city was rebuilt after the war a few kilometers east of the ancient citadel, which is now known as Van Castle (Van Kalesi). The city lies at about 1,750 metres (5,570 ft) above sea level. In the 1950s Van suffered from a devastating earthquake.[26]

Climate

Van has a continental climate with strong influences of a semi-arid climate which consist of hot and dry summers and cold and snowy winters.

Climate data for Van
Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Year
Record high °C (°F) 11.0
(51.8)
13.6
(56.5)
22.7
(72.9)
27.2
(81.0)
28.3
(82.9)
33.2
(91.8)
37.0
(98.6)
35.1
(95.2)
35.0
(95.0)
27.0
(80.6)
17.2
(63.0)
15.5
(59.9)
37.0
(98.6)
Mean daily maximum °C (°F) 2.0
(35.6)
2.8
(37.0)
6.7
(44.1)
12.9
(55.2)
18.1
(64.6)
23.7
(74.7)
28.0
(82.4)
28.1
(82.6)
24.1
(75.4)
17.2
(63.0)
9.9
(49.8)
4.6
(40.3)
14.8
(58.7)
Mean daily minimum °C (°F) −7.2
(19.0)
−6.4
(20.5)
−2.3
(27.9)
3.2
(37.8)
7.3
(45.1)
11.4
(52.5)
15.2
(59.4)
15.1
(59.2)
11.3
(52.3)
6.0
(42.8)
0.5
(32.9)
−4.1
(24.6)
4.2
(39.5)
Record low °C (°F) −22.6
(−8.7)
−24.8
(−12.6)
−22.7
(−8.9)
−9.8
(14.4)
−0.8
(30.6)
3.0
(37.4)
7.0
(44.6)
7.0
(44.6)
1.4
(34.5)
−7.5
(18.5)
−12.0
(10.4)
−20.3
(−4.5)
−24.8
(−12.6)
Average precipitation mm (inches) 31.2
(1.23)
32.1
(1.26)
47.1
(1.85)
53.0
(2.09)
48.5
(1.91)
18.6
(0.73)
7.2
(0.28)
6.7
(0.26)
17.0
(0.67)
43.8
(1.72)
50.7
(2.00)
39.4
(1.55)
395.3
(15.55)
Average rainy days 10.3 10.3 12.3 12.5 11.6 5.7 2.1 1.4 2.2 8.4 9.3 10.2 96.3
Mean monthly sunshine hours 145.7 151.2 195.3 216 285.2 348 375.1 362.7 306 229.4 168 130.2 2,912.8
Source: Devlet Meteoroloji İşleri Genel Müdürlüğü [2]

Van today

File:Vancity 14.jpg
A modern apartment building in Van.

The modern city is located on the plain extending from the Lake Van, at a distance of 5 kilometers from the lake shore.

Van has often been called "The Pearl of the East" because of the beauty of its surrounding landscape. An old Armenian proverb in the same sense is "Van in this world, paradise in the next."[27] This phrase has been slightly modified in Turkish as dünyada Van, ahirette iman or "Van for this world, faith for the next."

File:Vancity 05.jpg
A park in the city center.

The city is home to Van Yüzüncü Yıl Üniversitesi (Van 100th Year University) and recently came to the headlines for two highly publicized investigations initiated by the Prosecutor of Van, one of which was focused on accusations against the university's rector, Prof. Hasan Ceylan, who was kept in custody for a time. He was finally acquitted but lost his rectorate. He is a grandson of Agop Vartovyan, an Ottoman Armenian who is accepted as the founder of modern Turkish theatre. Prof. Hasan Ceylan is also the department chairman of Environmental Engineering in the Van 100th Year University.

Cuisine

In culinary terms, as some cities in Turkey became renowned for their kebap culture or other types of traditional local dishes, Van has distinguished itself with its breakfast culture.

Transport

At present, Van is connected with Tatvan, which is 96 km away on the opposite shore of Lake Van, by a train ferry that helps to avoid the necessity to build a 250 km railway through difficult mountainous terrain. The railway will be constructed when traffic increases sufficiently.

Van is connected with the rest of Turkey through the Ferit Melen Airport.

Media

Near Van, there is a longwave broadcasting station with a 250 metres tall guyed mast. It went in service in 1990 and operates on 225 kHz with 600 kW.

The Van cat

Van cat

The Van Cat (Van Kedisi) is a breed of cat native to this town and named after it. The Van Cat is noted for its white fur, having different coloured eyes, and enjoying swimming and rain.

Notable residents

Armenians
Turks, Kurds, and others

Sister cities

See also

References

  1. ^ Slovar sovremennikh geographicheskikh nazvaniy (in Russian) / Ed. by acad. V.M. Kotliakov, Yekaterinburg, U-Faktoria, 2006
  2. ^ [1]
  3. ^ David McDowall, "Modern History of the Kurds," I.B. Tauris, 1996, pg 440
  4. ^ TESEV. "An Assessment of the Van Action Plan for the Internally Displaced" Accessed at http://www.tesev.org.tr/UD_OBJS/PDF/DEMP/TESEV_VanActionPlanReport.pdf.
  5. ^ The Journal of Roman Studies - Page 124 by Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies
  6. ^ http://rbedrosian.com/Classic/kvan1.htm
  7. ^ Hewler, 39
  8. ^ a b Hewsen, Robert H. (2000), "Van in This World: Paradise in the Next: The Historical Geography of Van/Vaspurakan", in Hovannisian, Richard G. (ed.), Armenian Van/Vaspurakan, Historic Armenian Cities and Provinces, Costa Mesa, California: Mazda Publishers, p. 40, OCLC 44774992
  9. ^ Values as printed on File:Proportions des populations en Asie Mineure statistique officielle d1914.png
  10. ^ Muslims and Minorities, Justin McCarthy, New York University Press, 1983, pp. 110-111
  11. ^ Hewsen, 35
  12. ^ Anahide Ter Minassian. "The city of Van at the Turn of the Twentieth Century." Armenian Van/Vaspurakan. Richard G. Hovannisian Ed. Mazda Publishers, inc. 2000 Pg 179.
  13. ^ Minassian, 180
  14. ^ Minassian, 181
  15. ^ Sarkis Y. Karayan. "Demography of Van Province, 1844-1914. Armenian Van/Vaspurakan. Richard G. Hovannisian Ed. Mazda Publishers, inc. 2000 Pg 196
  16. ^ Akcam, Taner. A Shameful Act, p. 140. New York:Henry Holt Co. 2006. ISBN 0-8050-8665-X
  17. ^ a b Akçam, 201
  18. ^ Morgenthau, Henry. Ambassador Morgenthau's Story, p.205. Wayne State University Press, 2003. ISBN 0-8143-2979-9
  19. ^ Ussher, Clarence Douglass. An American Physician in Turkey, p.236. Houghton Mifflin Company, 1917.
  20. ^ Akçam, 202
  21. ^ Akçam, 200
  22. ^ Bisbee, Eleanor. The New Turks, University of Pennsylvania, 1951, p. 49
  23. ^ a b The Banality of Indifference: Zionism and the Armenian Genocide - Page 42 by Yaïr Auron
  24. ^ Akçam, Taner. "A shameful Act." Translated by Paul Bessemer. Metropolitan Books, New York. 2006, 140
  25. ^ Akçam, Taner. "A shameful Act." Translated by Paul Bessemer. Metropolitan Books, New York. 2006.
  26. ^ Van - Encyclopedia of the Orient
  27. ^ Hewsen, Robert H. (2001). Armenia: A Historical Atlas. The University of Chicago Press. p. 207. ISBN 0-226-33228-4.

Bibliography