Platonic love: Difference between revisions
m robot Adding: ar:حب أفلاطونى |
m converted all links to reference section... deleted SPAM link |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Close Relationships}}{{Love table}}'''Platonic love''' in its modern popular sense is an [[affection]]ate relationship into which the [[sex]]ual element does not enter, especially in cases where one might easily assume otherwise. A simple example of platonic relationships is a deep, non-sexual [[friendship]] between two [[Heterosexuality|heterosexual]] people of the opposite sexes |
{{Close Relationships}}{{Love table}}'''Platonic love''' in its modern popular sense is an [[affection]]ate relationship into which the [[sex]]ual element does not enter, especially in cases where one might easily assume otherwise. A simple example of platonic relationships is a deep, non-sexual [[friendship]] between two [[Heterosexuality|heterosexual]] people of the opposite sexes[http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/Platonic%20love]. |
||
At the same time, this interpretation is a misunderstanding of the nature of the [[Platonic idealism|Platonic ideal]] of [[love]], which from its origin was that of a [[chaste]] but passionate love, based not on uninterest but virtuous restraint of sexual desire. In its original Platonic form, this love was meant to bring the lovers closer to wisdom and the Platonic [[Form]] of Beauty. It is described in depth in Plato's [[Phaedrus (Plato)|''Phaedrus'']] and ''[[Symposium (Plato)|Symposium]]''. In the ''Phaedrus'', it is said to be a form of divine madness that is a gift from the gods, and that its proper expression is rewarded by the gods in the afterlife; in the ''Symposium'', the method by which love takes one to the form of beauty and wisdom is detailed. |
At the same time, this interpretation is a misunderstanding of the nature of the [[Platonic idealism|Platonic ideal]] of [[love]], which from its origin was that of a [[chaste]] but passionate love, based not on uninterest but virtuous restraint of sexual desire. In its original Platonic form, this love was meant to bring the lovers closer to wisdom and the Platonic [[Form]] of Beauty. It is described in depth in Plato's [[Phaedrus (Plato)|''Phaedrus'']] and ''[[Symposium (Plato)|Symposium]]''. In the ''Phaedrus'', it is said to be a form of divine madness that is a gift from the gods, and that its proper expression is rewarded by the gods in the afterlife; in the ''Symposium'', the method by which love takes one to the form of beauty and wisdom is detailed. |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
==History== |
==History== |
||
The term '''''amor platonicus''''' was coined as early as the [[15th Century]] by the [[Florence|Florentine]] scholar [[Marsilio Ficino]] as a synonym for ''amor socraticus''. Both expressions signify a love focused on the beauty of a person's character and intelligence rather than on their physical charms. They refer to the special bond of affection between two men [[Plato]] had highlighted in a [[Dialogues of Plato|dialogue]], and exemplified by the affection between [[Socrates]] and his young male pupils, in particular to the one between Socrates and [[Alcibiades]]. |
The term '''''amor platonicus''''' was coined as early as the [[15th Century]] by the [[Florence|Florentine]] scholar [[Marsilio Ficino]] as a synonym for ''amor socraticus''. Both expressions signify a love focused on the beauty of a person's character and intelligence rather than on their physical charms. They refer to the special bond of affection between two men [[Plato]] had highlighted in a [[Dialogues of Plato|dialogue]], and exemplified by the affection between [[Socrates]] and his young male pupils, in particular to the one between Socrates and [[Alcibiades]].[http://www.chs.harvard.edu/_/File/_/plato_symposium_lesher.pdf On Ficino and the Symposium] |
||
The English term dates back as far as Sir [[William Davenant]]'s ''Platonic Lovers'' ([[1636]]). It is derived from the concept in Plato's ''[[Symposium (Plato)|Symposium]]'' of the love of the idea of good which lies at the root of all virtue and truth. |
The English term dates back as far as Sir [[William Davenant]]'s ''Platonic Lovers'' ([[1636]]). It is derived from the concept in Plato's ''[[Symposium (Plato)|Symposium]]'' of the love of the idea of good which lies at the root of all virtue and truth. |
||
==Paradox== |
==Paradox== |
||
Ironically, the very [[eponym]] of this love, Plato, as well as the forementioned Socrates and Ficino, all belong to the community of men who desire boys, and they all engaged in chaste but erotic pedagogic friendships with youths. The concept of platonic love thus arose within the context of the debate pitting mundane sexually expressed [[pederasty]] against the philosophic – or chaste – pederasty elaborated in Plato's writings (''Symposium, Phaedro, Laws,'' and others). |
Ironically, the very [[eponym]] of this love, Plato, as well as the forementioned Socrates and Ficino, all belong to the community of men who desire boys, and they all engaged in chaste but erotic pedagogic friendships with youths. The concept of platonic love thus arose within the context of the debate pitting mundane sexually expressed [[pederasty]] against the philosophic – or chaste – pederasty elaborated in Plato's writings (''Symposium, Phaedro, Laws,'' and others). |
||
[[Image:Plato i sin akademi, av Carl Johan Wahlbom (ur Svenska Familj-Journalen).png|thumb|left|Plato and his disciples.]] |
[[Image:Plato i sin akademi, av Carl Johan Wahlbom (ur Svenska Familj-Journalen).png|thumb|left|Plato and his disciples.]] |
||
Regarding Socrates, [[John Addington Symonds]] in his ''A Problem in Greek Ethics'' states that he "...avows a fervent admiration for beauty in the persons of young men. At the same time he declares himself upon the side of temperate and generous affection, and strives to utilize the erotic enthusiasm as a motive power in the direction of philosophy." According to |
Regarding Socrates, [[John Addington Symonds]] in his ''A Problem in Greek Ethics'' states that he "...avows a fervent admiration for beauty in the persons of young men. At the same time he declares himself upon the side of temperate and generous affection, and strives to utilize the erotic enthusiasm as a motive power in the direction of philosophy." According to Linda Rapp, Ficino, by platonic love, meant "...a relationship that included both the physical and the spiritual. Thus, Ficino's view is that love is the desire for beauty, which is the image of the divine." |
||
Because of the common modern definition, platonic love can be seen as paradoxical in light of these philosophers' life experiences and teachings. Plato and his peers did not teach that a man's relationship with a youth should lack an [[erotic]] dimension, but rather that the longing for the beauty of the boy is a foundation of the friendship and love between those two. However, having acknowledged that the man's erotic desire for the youth magnetizes and energizes the relationship, they countered that it is wiser for this eros to not be sexually expressed, but instead be redirected into the intellectual and emotional spheres. |
Because of the common modern definition, platonic love can be seen as paradoxical in light of these philosophers' life experiences and teachings. Plato and his peers did not teach that a man's relationship with a youth should lack an [[erotic]] dimension, but rather that the longing for the beauty of the boy is a foundation of the friendship and love between those two. However, having acknowledged that the man's erotic desire for the youth magnetizes and energizes the relationship, they countered that it is wiser for this eros to not be sexually expressed, but instead be redirected into the intellectual and emotional spheres. |
||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
When the term "Platonic love" is used today, it generally does not describe this aspect of Plato's views of love. |
When the term "Platonic love" is used today, it generally does not describe this aspect of Plato's views of love. |
||
The understanding that ''Platonic love'' could be interpreted as masculine eros is alleged by some socio-historical critics to be linked with the [[Social_constructionism|social construction]] of a homosexual identity, and the cultural model of platonic friendship / pederasty was supposedly used by educated gay men since the early Renaissance. |
The understanding that ''Platonic love'' could be interpreted as masculine eros is alleged by some socio-historical critics to be linked with the [[Social_constructionism|social construction]] of a homosexual identity, and the cultural model of platonic friendship / pederasty was supposedly used by educated gay men since the early Renaissance. |
||
[[Image:Alcibiades from www-livius-org.jpg|thumb|Alcibiades – beloved of Socrates, a love given as an example of what was later named ''Platonic love'']] |
[[Image:Alcibiades from www-livius-org.jpg|thumb|Alcibiades – beloved of Socrates, a love given as an example of what was later named ''Platonic love'']] |
||
| Line 30: | Line 31: | ||
*{{1911}} |
*{{1911}} |
||
*Gould, T. (1963) Platonic Love. New York: The Free Press. |
*Gould, T. (1963) Platonic Love. New York: The Free Press. |
||
<div class="references-small"> |
|||
<references/> |
|||
</div> |
|||
==External link== |
==External link== |
||
Revision as of 20:28, 30 November 2006
 Relationships (Outline) |
|---|
| Part of a series on |
| Love |
|---|
 |
Platonic love in its modern popular sense is an affectionate relationship into which the sexual element does not enter, especially in cases where one might easily assume otherwise. A simple example of platonic relationships is a deep, non-sexual friendship between two heterosexual people of the opposite sexes.[1]
At the same time, this interpretation is a misunderstanding of the nature of the Platonic ideal of love, which from its origin was that of a chaste but passionate love, based not on uninterest but virtuous restraint of sexual desire. In its original Platonic form, this love was meant to bring the lovers closer to wisdom and the Platonic Form of Beauty. It is described in depth in Plato's Phaedrus and Symposium. In the Phaedrus, it is said to be a form of divine madness that is a gift from the gods, and that its proper expression is rewarded by the gods in the afterlife; in the Symposium, the method by which love takes one to the form of beauty and wisdom is detailed.
History
The term amor platonicus was coined as early as the 15th Century by the Florentine scholar Marsilio Ficino as a synonym for amor socraticus. Both expressions signify a love focused on the beauty of a person's character and intelligence rather than on their physical charms. They refer to the special bond of affection between two men Plato had highlighted in a dialogue, and exemplified by the affection between Socrates and his young male pupils, in particular to the one between Socrates and Alcibiades.[2]
The English term dates back as far as Sir William Davenant's Platonic Lovers (1636). It is derived from the concept in Plato's Symposium of the love of the idea of good which lies at the root of all virtue and truth.[3]
Paradox
Ironically, the very eponym of this love, Plato, as well as the forementioned Socrates and Ficino, all belong to the community of men who desire boys, and they all engaged in chaste but erotic pedagogic friendships with youths. The concept of platonic love thus arose within the context of the debate pitting mundane sexually expressed pederasty against the philosophic – or chaste – pederasty elaborated in Plato's writings (Symposium, Phaedro, Laws, and others).
.png)
Regarding Socrates, John Addington Symonds in his A Problem in Greek Ethics states that he "...avows a fervent admiration for beauty in the persons of young men. At the same time he declares himself upon the side of temperate and generous affection, and strives to utilize the erotic enthusiasm as a motive power in the direction of philosophy." According to Linda Rapp, Ficino, by platonic love, meant "...a relationship that included both the physical and the spiritual. Thus, Ficino's view is that love is the desire for beauty, which is the image of the divine."[4]
Because of the common modern definition, platonic love can be seen as paradoxical in light of these philosophers' life experiences and teachings. Plato and his peers did not teach that a man's relationship with a youth should lack an erotic dimension, but rather that the longing for the beauty of the boy is a foundation of the friendship and love between those two. However, having acknowledged that the man's erotic desire for the youth magnetizes and energizes the relationship, they countered that it is wiser for this eros to not be sexually expressed, but instead be redirected into the intellectual and emotional spheres.
To resolve this confusion, French scholars found it helpful to distinguish between amour platonique (the concept of non-sexual love) and amour platonicien (love according to Plato). When the term "Platonic love" is used today, it generally does not describe this aspect of Plato's views of love.
The understanding that Platonic love could be interpreted as masculine eros is alleged by some socio-historical critics to be linked with the social construction of a homosexual identity, and the cultural model of platonic friendship / pederasty was supposedly used by educated gay men since the early Renaissance.
Quotations
- "Platonic Love is a fool's name for the affection between a disability and a frost." — Ambrose Bierce
- "Platonic love is love from the neck up." — Thyra Smarter Winslow
References
- This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
{{cite encyclopedia}}: Missing or empty|title=(help) - Gould, T. (1963) Platonic Love. New York: The Free Press.
- ^ "Platonic love definition", Reference.com
- ^ "On Ficino and the Symposium", Harvard - On Ficino and the Symposium
- ^ "Modern day platonic love", Gurus of Dating
- ^ "Linda Rapp in glbtq"