View source for Victoria v Commonwealth (1957)

← Victoria v Commonwealth (1957)

You do not have permission to edit this page, for the following reasons:

This IP address has been blocked from editing Wikipedia.
This does not affect your ability to read Wikipedia pages.
Most people who see this message have done nothing wrong. Some kinds of blocks restrict editing from specific service providers or telecom companies in response to recent abuse or vandalism, and can sometimes affect other users who are unrelated to that abuse. Review the information below for assistance if you do not believe that you have done anything wrong.

The IP address or range 44.202.0.0/16 has been blocked by ‪ST47‬ for the following reason(s):

The IP address that you are currently using has been blocked because it is believed to be a web host provider. To prevent abuse, web hosts may be blocked from editing Wikipedia.
You will not be able to edit Wikipedia using a web host provider because it hides your IP address, much like a proxy or VPN.
We recommend that you attempt to use another connection to edit. For example, if you use a proxy or VPN to connect to the internet, turn it off when editing Wikipedia. If you edit using a mobile connection, try using a Wi-Fi connection, and vice versa. If you are using a corporate internet connection, switch to a different Wi-Fi network. If you have a Wikipedia account, please log in.
If you do not have any other way to edit Wikipedia, you will need to request an IP block exemption.

How to appeal if you are confident that your connection does not use a web host's IP address:
If you are confident that you are not using a web host, you may appeal this block by adding the following text on your talk page: {{unblock|reason=Caught by a web host block but this host or IP is not a web host. My IP address is _______. Place any further information here. ~~~~}}. You must fill in the blank with your IP address for this block to be investigated. Your IP address can be determined here. Alternatively, if you wish to keep your IP address private you can use the unblock ticket request system. There are several reasons you might be editing using the IP address of a web host (such as if you are using VPN software or a business network); please use this method of appeal only if you think your IP address is in fact not a web host.

Administrators: The IP block exemption user right should only be applied to allow users to edit using web host in exceptional circumstances, and they should usually be directed to the functionaries team via email. If you intend to give the IPBE user right, a CheckUser needs to take a look at the account. This can be requested most easily at SPI Quick Checkuser Requests. Unblocking an IP or IP range with this template is highly discouraged without at least contacting the blocking administrator.

This block will expire on 07:35, 6 August 2027. Your current IP address is 44.202.83.136.

Even when blocked, you will usually still be able to edit your user talk page, as well as email administrators and other editors.

For information on how to proceed, please read the FAQ for blocked users and the guideline on block appeals. The guide to appealing blocks may also be helpful.

Other useful links: Blocking policy · Help:I have been blocked
This IP address range has been globally blocked.
This does not affect your ability to read Wikipedia pages.
Most people who see this message have done nothing wrong. Some kinds of blocks restrict editing from specific service providers or telecom companies in response to recent abuse or vandalism, and can sometimes affect other users who are unrelated to that abuse. Review the information below for assistance if you do not believe that you have done anything wrong.

This block affects editing on all Wikimedia wikis.
The IP address or range 44.202.0.0/16 has been globally blocked by ‪EPIC‬ for the following reason(s):

Open proxy/Webhost: See the help page if you are affected

This block will expire on 17:25, 20 September 2027. Your current IP address is 44.202.83.136.

Even while globally blocked, you will usually still be able to edit pages on Meta-Wiki.

If you believe you were blocked by mistake, you can find additional information and instructions in the No open proxies global policy. Otherwise, to discuss the block please post a request for review on Meta-Wiki. You could also send an email to the stewards VRT queue at stewards@wikimedia.org including all above details.

Other useful links: Global blocks · Help:I have been blocked

You can view and copy the source of this page:

{{Use dmy dates|date=February 2018}}
{{Use Australian English|date=February 2018}}
{{refimprove|date=February 2018}}
{{Infobox court case
| name=Victoria v Commonwealth
| court=[[High Court of Australia]] 
| image=Coat of Arms of Australia.svg
| date decided=23 August 1957
| full name=The&nbsp;State&nbsp;of&nbsp;Victoria &&nbsp;another v The&nbsp;Commonwealth; The&nbsp;State&nbsp;of&nbsp;NSW &&nbsp;another v The&nbsp;Commonwealth
| citations={{cite AustLII|HCA|54|1957|parallelcite=(1957)&nbsp;99&nbsp;[[Commonwealth Law Reports|CLR]]&nbsp;575}}
| judges= [[Owen Dixon|Dixon]] [[Chief Justice of Australia|CJ]], [[Edward McTiernan|McTiernan]], [[Dudley Williams (judge)|Williams]], [[William Webb (judge)|Webb]], [[Wilfred Fullagar|Fullagar]], [[Frank Kitto|Kitto]] and [[Alan Taylor (Australian judge)|Taylor]] [[Justices|JJ]]
| prior actions=
| subsequent actions=
|Overruled=
|Overturned previous case=[[South Australia v Commonwealth]]<br>(First Uniform Tax case)
| opinions=
'''(7:0)''' The State Grants Act 1942 was valid under the taxation power

'''(4:3)''' Section 221 of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act is not a valid exercise of the taxation power <small>(per Dixon CJ, McTiernan, Kitto and Taylor JJ)</small>
}}

'''''Victoria v Commonwealth''''',<ref name="Vic v Cth">{{cite AustLII|HCA|54|1957|litigants=Victoria v Commonwealth (Second Uniform Tax case) |parallelcite=[http://eresources.hcourt.gov.au/downloadPdf/1957/HCA/54 (1957) 99 {{abbr|CLR|Commonwealth Law Reports}} 575] [[File:Icons-mini-file_acrobat.gif]] |date=23 August 1957 |courtname=[[High Court of Australia|High Court]]}}.</ref> ("the Second Uniform Tax case") is a [[High Court of Australia]] case that affirmed the Commonwealth government's ability to impose a scheme of uniform income tax, adding to [[Fiscal imbalance in Australia|Australia's vertical fiscal imbalance]] in the spending requirements and taxing abilities of the various levels of government.

==Overview==
{{see also|South Australia v Commonwealth}}
The Uniform Tax system was implemented in 1942 and relied upon 4 pieces of legislation, all held to be constitutionally valid in the [[South Australia v Commonwealth|First Uniform Tax case]].<ref name="1st Uniform Tax case">{{cite AustLII|HCA|14|1942|litigants=[[South Australia v Commonwealth]] (First Uniform Tax case) |parallelcite=[http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/1942/14.pdf (1942) 65 {{abbr|CLR|Commonwealth Law Reports}} 373] |date=23 July 1942 |courtname=[[High Court of Australia|High Court]]}}.</ref> Some of the laws were justified under the defence power, but the scheme was not dismantled after the end of wartime conflict.

It was held that the ''Income Tax Act 1942'',<ref>{{cite Legislation AU|Cth|num_act|ita1942231942143|Income Tax Act 1942}}.</ref> could not be challenged because it was within the Commonwealth's taxation power. The ''Income Tax (Wartime Arrangements) Act 1942'',<ref>{{cite Legislation AU|Cth|num_act|itaa1942211942348|Income Tax (Wartime Arrangements) Act 1942}}.</ref> was not an issue because it had already been repealed.

In the first Uniform Tax case the High Court decided that the Commonwealth Parliament had the power to tax incomes. The Commonwealth had passed legislation that allowed them to nationally tax incomes. Prior to this each state had their own income tax laws. The new Commonwealth taxation was so high that people could not effectively pay both taxes. The states challenged this in the High Court and argued that; Taxation was a concurrent power; the Commonwealth tax was so high that people would not be able to pay both taxes and therefore the states would no longer be able to tax incomes. The High Court disagreed and held that section 109 ensured that Commonwealth law overrode inconsistent state laws on concurrent powers, the Commonwealth could impose income Taxation.

==Decision==
The High Court affirmed the position of the First Uniform Tax case, with some exceptions.

The ''States Grants Act 1942'',<ref>{{cite Legislation AU|Cth|num_act|sga1942461942199|States Grants Act 1942}}.</ref> was held to be valid, despite a section 96 issue. The Commonwealth can use the section 96 grants power to induce a state to exercise its own powers as well as abstain from using its powers. Hence the Commonwealth can do such things to encourage or discourage a state from exercising its powers. However, while it can induce such things, it cannot coerce a state into accepting a grant. Nonetheless, indirect compulsion is constitutional. While the ''Income Tax Act 1942'' raised Commonwealth income tax rates to a level that made it politically impossible for the states to impose their own, this was not at the level of coercion that was prohibited. 

The decision in the First Uniform Tax case was overruled in relation to section 221 of the ''Income Assessment Act 1942''. Section 221 required taxpayers to meet their Commonwealth tax liabilities before state tax liabilities and this section was held to be invalid. The majority (Dixon CJ, McTiernan, Kitto and Taylor JJ) thought that it was not pursuant to the taxation power. Dixon CJ held that it could only possibly be a valid exercise of the implied incidental taxation power. However, the scope of section 51(ii) is federal taxation for federal purposes. Hence any taxation law made pursuant to the incidental power must also be federal taxation for federal purposes. Dixon CJ saw the purpose of the legislation as the exclusion of the state's ability to impose income tax, which is not a federal purpose. Although this section was challenged and overturned, it was not important because in a practical sense the states could no longer impose income taxes.

The Commonwealth cannot restrain states in terms of their governmental functions. Dixon CJ inferred from this principles that there should be some restraints on interpretation of section 96 of the constitution. Section 96 grants must be confined to grants of money, and is not a power to make laws with respect to general subject matter. It must be concerned with state finance and must not be coercive. The power to attach conditions to section 96 grants is broad but they must be within the state's constitutional competence to fulfil.

== See also ==

* [[Constitutional basis of taxation in Australia]]
* [[Australian constitutional law]]

== References ==
{{reflist}}
* [[George Winterton|Winterton, G.]] et al. ''Australian federal constitutional law: commentary and materials'', 1999. LBC Information Services, Sydney.

[[Category:High Court of Australia cases]]
[[Category:1957 in Australian law]]
[[Category:Australian constitutional law]]
[[Category:Taxation in the Australian Constitution cases]]
[[Category:Grants power in the Australian Constitution cases]]
[[Category:1957 in case law]]

Pages transcluded onto the current version of this page (help):

Template:Abbr (view source) (protected)
Template:Ambox (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Cite AustLII (view source) (semi-protected)
Template:Cite Legislation AU (view source) (semi-protected)
Template:DMCA (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Date (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Dated maintenance category (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Dated maintenance category (articles) (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:FULLROOTPAGENAME (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Find sources mainspace (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:If empty (view source) (protected)
Template:Infobox court case (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Infobox court case/styles.css (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Main other (view source) (protected)
Template:More citations needed (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Ns has subpages (view source) (protected)
Template:Pluralize from text (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Refimprove (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Reflist (view source) (protected)
Template:Reflist/styles.css (view source) (protected)
Template:See also (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Use Australian English (view source) (template editor protected)
Template:Use dmy dates (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Arguments (view source) (protected)
Module:Category handler (view source) (protected)
Module:Category handler/blacklist (view source) (protected)
Module:Category handler/config (view source) (protected)
Module:Category handler/data (view source) (protected)
Module:Category handler/shared (view source) (protected)
Module:Check for unknown parameters (view source) (protected)
Module:Detect singular (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Find sources (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Find sources/config (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Find sources/links (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Find sources/templates/Find sources mainspace (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Format link (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Hatnote (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Hatnote/styles.css (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Hatnote list (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:If empty (view source) (protected)
Module:Infobox (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Infobox/styles.css (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:InfoboxImage (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Italic title (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Labelled list hatnote (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Message box (view source) (protected)
Module:Message box/ambox.css (view source) (protected)
Module:Message box/configuration (view source) (protected)
Module:Namespace detect/config (view source) (protected)
Module:Namespace detect/data (view source) (protected)
Module:Ns has subpages (view source) (protected)
Module:String (view source) (protected)
Module:Text (view source) (template editor protected)
Module:Unsubst (view source) (protected)
Module:Yesno (view source) (protected)

Return to Victoria v Commonwealth (1957).

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victoria_v_Commonwealth_(1957)"