Abstract
Various objects and systems in intransitive relations of superiority (“rock-paper-scissors” relations) are described (intransitive sets of sticks, dice, chess positions, machines, biological species etc.). The concept of meta-intransitivity of superiority is introduced. Meta-intransitivity is a property of systems, which are in intransitive relationships between one another, and, at the same time, each of them contains its own internal, nested intransitive cycles of superiority. The nested cycles�� number is its meta-intransitivity level. We distinguish between two types of meta-intransitivity: qualitative (ordinal, lexicographic), and quantitative. Respectively, we describe two examples of meta-intransitive systems of both types. The first example deals with combinatorics of geometrical shapes in meta-intransitive machines “beating” one another like in a rock-paper-scissors game, and the second one—with combinatorics of numbers in meta-intransitive dice (meta-dice). We show that the formerly known intransitive sets (e.g. intransitive dice) can be considered as intransitive sets with zero-level of meta-intransitivity. A way to build multi-level meta-intransitive sets based on nested Condorcet-like compositions is introduced. Meta-intransitivity of various objects can become a new interesting sub-area of logic and mathematics of intransitive relations. Interactive multiple, intertwining, “rhizomatic” (from the “rhizome” metaphor) intransitivities and meta-intransitivities of dominance in real complex systems seems worthy of special interest in future inter(trans)-disciplinary studies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Akin, E.: Rock, paper, scissors, etc.—Topics in the theory of regular tournaments (2018). arXiv:1806.11241
Akin, E.: Generalized intransitive dice: mimicking an arbitrary tournament. J. Dyn. Games 8(1), 1–20 (2019)
Akin, E., Saccamano, J.: Generalized intransitive dice II: partition constructions. J. Dyn. Games 8(3), 187–202 (2021)
Beardon, T.: Transitivity (1999/2018). http://nrich.maths.org/1345 Accessed 26 August 2022
Bednay, D., Bozóki, S.: Constructions for nontransitive dice sets. In: Proceedings of the 8th Japanese-Hungarian Symposium on Discrete Mathematics and its Applications. Veszprem, Hungary, June 4–7, 2013, pp. 15–23 (2013). https://eprints.sztaki.hu/7623
Bozóki, S.: Nontransitive dice sets realizing Paley tournaments for solving Schütte’s tournament problem. Miskolc Math. Notes 15(1), 39–50 (2014)
Buhler, J., Graham, R., Hales, A.: Maximally nontransitive dice. Amer. Math. Monthly 125(5), 387–399 (2018)
Butler, D., Blavatskyy, P.: The voting paradox ... with a single voter? Implications for transitivity in choice under risk. Econ. Philos. 36(1), 61–79 (2020)
Chamberland, M., Herman, E.A.: Rock-paper-scissors meets Borromean rings. Math. Intelligencer 37(2), 20–25 (2015)
Conrey, B., Gabbard, J., Grant, K., Liu, A., Morrison, K.E.: Intransitive dice. Math. Mag. 89(2), 133–143 (2016)
Deshpande, M.N.: Intransitive dice. Teach. Stat. 22(1), 4–5 (2000)
Gardner, M.: Mathematical games. The paradox of the nontransitive dice and the elusive principle of indifference. Sci. Amer. 223(6), 110–114 (1970)
Gardner, M.: Mathematical games. On the paradoxical situations that arise from nontransitive relations. Sci. Am. 231(4), 120–125 (1974)
Gardner, M.: The Colossal Book of Mathematics. W.W. Norton & Company, New York (2001)
Gehrlein, W.V.: Condorcet’s Paradox. Springer, Berlin (2006)
Gorbunova, A.V., Lebedev, A.V.: Nontransitivity of tuples of random variables with polynomial density and its effects in Bayesian models. Math. Comput. Simul. 202, 181–192 (2022)
Grime, J.: The bizarre world of nontransitive dice: games for two or more players. College Math. J. 48(1), 2–9 (2017)
Hązła, J., Mossel, E., Ross, N., Zheng, G.: The probability of intransitivity in dice and close elections. Probab. Theory Related Fields 178(3–4), 951–1009 (2020)
Hulko, A., Whitmeyer, M.: Game of nontransitive dice. Math. Mag. 92(5), 368–373 (2019)
Kirkegaard, J.B., Sneppen, K.: Emerging diversity in a population of evolving intransitive dice. Phys. Rev. E 106(5), 054409 (2022)
Klimenko, A.Y.: Complex competitive systems and competitive thermodynamics. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A 371(1982), 20120244 (2013)
Komisarski, A.: Nontransitive random variables and nontransitive dice. Amer. Math. Monthly 128(5), 423–434 (2021)
Lebedev, A.V.: The nontransitivity problem for three continuous random variables. Autom. Remote Control 80(6), 1058–1068 (2019)
Lee, J.A.: Measurement scale. In: Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/measurement-scale Accessed 26 August 2022
Liow, L.H., Reitan, T., Voje, K.L., Taylor, P.D., Di Martino, E.: Size, weapons, and armor as predictors of competitive outcomes in fossil and contemporary marine communities. Ecol. Monogr. 89(2), e01354 (2019)
Pegg Jr., E.: Tournament dice (2005). https://www.mathpuzzle.com/MAA/39-Tournament%20Dice/mathgames_07_11_05.html Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A.: Intransitive machines (2018). arXiv:1809.03869. Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A.N.: Learning intransitivity: from intransitive geometrical objects to “rhizomatic” intransitivity. In: Shvarts, A. (ed.) Proceedings of the PME and Yandex Russian Conference: Technology and Psychology for Mathematics Education. Moscow, Russia, HSE Publishing House. pp. 178–185 (2019). Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A.: Comprehension of intransitivity of superiority, and objects of experimental interest in different areas and paradigms. Paper presented at the 67th Seminar “Formal philosophy”. HSE University; June 30, 2021. Presentation: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352856372 (in Russian). Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A.: A method to build \(n\)-component intransitive cycles of mechanical constructions (2022). https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.31894.42564 Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A.: Intransitively winning chess players’ positions (2022). https://www.researchgate.net/publication/362246891 Accessed 26 August 2022
Poddiakov, A., Valsiner, J.: Intransitivity cycles and their transformations: How dynamically adapting systems function. In: Rudolph, L. (ed.) Qualitative Mathematics for the Social Sciences: Mathematical Models for Research on Cultural Dynamics, pp. 343–391. Abingdon (2013)
Polymath, D.H.J.: The probability that a random triple of dice is transitive (2017). https://gowers.files.wordpress.com/2017/07/polymath131.pdf Accessed 26 August 2022
Precoda, K., Allen, A.P., Grant, L., Madin, J.S.: Using traits to assess nontransitivity of interactions among coral species. Amer. Nat. 190(3), 420–429 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1086/692758
Southwell, R.: Borromean rings of Borromean rings—new fractal (2014). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dh9s1vyzy7s Accessed 26 August 2022
Thangavelu, K., Brunner, E.: Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test for stratified samples and Efron’s paradox dice. J. Stat. Plan. Inference 137(3), 720–737 (2007)
Timofeeva, A.: Solving Problems on Intransitivity and Attitudes to Them. HSE University, Diploma work (2022) (in Russian)
Transitive law. https://www.britannica.com/topic/transitive-law Accessed 26 August 2022
Trybuła, S.: On the paradox of three random variables. Appl. Math. 5, 321–332 (1961)
Van Deventer, O.: That is not art, it is a puzzle! In: Proceedings of Bridges 2019: Mathematics, Art, Music, Architecture, Education, Culture. Linz, Austria. 16–20 July 2019. Phoenix, Arizona: Tessellations Publishing. pp. 1–8. http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2019/bridges2019-1.pdf Accessed 26 August 2022
Weisstein, E.W.: Efron’s dice. From MathWorld—A Wolfram web resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/EfronsDice.html Accessed 26 August 2022
Acknowledgements
The authors are very thankful to anonymous reviewers for their commentaries and recommendations.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Poddiakov, A., Lebedev, A.V. Intransitivity and meta-intransitivity: meta-dice, levers and other opportunities. European Journal of Mathematics 9, 27 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40879-023-00618-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40879-023-00618-z
Keywords
- Intransitive cycles
- Condorcet paradox
- Qualitative meta-intransitivity
- Quantitative meta-intransitivity
- Deterministic meta-intransitive geometrical objects
- Stochastic meta-intransitive objects