Abstract
The development of efficient Weigh In Motion (WIM) systems with the aim of estimating the axle loads of railway vehicles in motion is quite interesting both from an industrial and an academic point of view. This kind of systems is very important for safety and maintenance purposes in order to verify the loading conditions of a wide population of vehicles using a limited number of WIM devices distributed on the railway network. The evaluation of the axle load conditions is fundamental especially for freight wagons, more subjected to the risk of unbalanced loads which may be extremely dangerous both for the vehicle safety and the infrastructure maintenance.
In this work the authors present the development, the simulation and the validation of an innovative WIM algorithm with the aim of estimating the axle loads \(\widehat{N}\) of railway vehicles (the axle loads include the wheelset weights). The new estimation algorithm is a general purpose one; theoretically it could be applied by considering as input different kinds of track measurements (rail shear, rail bending, sleepers with sensors, etc.) and could be easily customized for different kinds of signals. In the paper a benchmark case based on rail bending measurements is proposed in which the longitudinal deformations ε xx measured on the rail foot through strain sensitive elements are used as input. The considered input is affected by noise and bandwidth limitations and, consequently, is a good benchmark to test the robustness of the new algorithm.
To estimate the axle loads, the algorithm approximates the measured physical input through a set of elementary functions calculated by means of a single fictitious load moving on the track. Starting from the set of elementary functions, the measured signal is then reproduced through Least Square Optimization (LSO) techniques: in more detail, the measured signal is considered as a linear combination of the elementary functions, the coefficients of which are the axle loads to be estimated.
Authors have also developed a physical model of the railway track. The model consists of the planar FEM (finite elements method) model of the infrastructure and of the two-dimensional (2D) multibody model of the vehicle (the effects of lateral dynamics are treated as disturbances) and takes into account both the coupling between adjacent loads moving on the track and the vehicle dynamics. The physical model of the track and the innovative WIM algorithm (both considering possible measurement errors) have been validated by means of the experimental data kindly provided by Ansaldo STS and have been implemented in the Matlab and Comsol Multiphysics environments. In particular the model of the railway track has been developed expressly to test the WIM algorithm with a suitable simulation campaign when experimental data are not available; in other words it provides simulated inputs to test the WIM algorithm when there are no experimental inputs.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Abbreviations
- WIM::
-
Weigh in motion
- FEM::
-
Finite elements method
- DOF::
-
Degree of freedom
- ODE::
-
Ordinary differential equations
- QLH::
-
Quasi-linearity hypothesis
- LSO::
-
Least squares optimization
- WLSO::
-
Weighted least squares optimization
- NLSO::
-
Nonlinear least squares optimization
References
Bracciali A, Ciuffi R, Piccioli F (2001) Progetto e validazione di un sensore estensimetrico multifunzionale per il binario ferroviario. In: Proceedings of XXX congresso AIAS, Alghero, Italy
Del Prete C, Rosso C (2009) An easy instrument and a methodology for the monitoring and the diagnosis of a rail. Mech Syst Signal Process 23(3):940–956
(2012) Official site of Kistler. http://www.kistler.com
(2012). Official site of Tagmaster. http://www.tagmaster.com
Kolakowski P, Sekula K (2010) Piezo-based weigh-in-motion system for the railway transport. Struct Control Health Monit. doi:10.1002/stc.416
(2012) Official site of Stock Equipment Company. http://www.stockequipment.com
(2012) Official site of Cardinal. http://www.cardinalscale.com
(2012) Official site of The MathWorks. http://www.mathworks.com
Iwnicki S (2006) Handbook of railway vehicle dynamics. Taylor & Francis, London
Esveld C (2001) Modern railway track. Delft University of Technology, Delft
Kisilowski J, Knothe K (1991) Advanced railway vehicle-system dynamics. Wydawnictwa Naukowo-Techniczne, Warsaw
Bracciali A, Ciuffi R, Piccioli F (2001) Soluzione numerica del modello PDE della dinamica verticale di un binario. In: Proceedings of XXX congresso AIAS, Alghero, Italy
Dahlberg T (2001) Some railroad settlement models—a critical review. Proc Inst Mech Eng, F J Rail Rapid Transit 215:289–300
Senyansky DM (2003) Problem of increasing the accuracy of railway carriages weighing in motion. In: VII IMEKO world Congress on metrology in the 3rd millennium, Dubrovnik, Croatia
Da Costa Marques Pimentel RM, Beirão Barbosa MC, Silva Costa NM, Ferreira Ribeiro DR, De Almeida Ferreira LA, Moita Araújo FM, Bártolo Calçada RA (2008) Hybrid fiber-optic/electrical measurement system for characterization of railway traffic and its effects on a short span bridge. IEEE Sens J 8(7):289–300
Bracciali A, Piccioli F (2001) Attenuation of rail vibration: analysis of experimental data. In: Proceedings of WCRR 2001 World Congress on Railway Research, Köhln, Germany
Zakeri JA, Xia H, Fan JJ (2009) Dynamic responses of train-track system to single rail irregularity. Lat Am J Solids Struct 6(2):183–204
(2012) Official site of Comsol Multiphysics. http://www.comsol.com
Mazzino N, Parente G (2012) Dati sperimentali per la verifica preliminare di algoritmi WIM per la pesatura dinamica. In: Internal technical documentation Ansaldo STS, Genova, Italia
Shampine LF, Reichelt MW (1997) The Matlab ODE suite. SIAM J Sci Comput 18:1–22
Kelley C (1995) Iterative methods for linear and nonlinear equations. SIAM, Philadelphia
Nocedal J, Wright S (1999) Numerical optimization. Springer series in operation. Research, Berlin
Garcia JCY, Garcia YSM, De Gracia Santos J (2009) Trans-ID: automatic ID and data capture for rail freight asset management. IEEE Internet Comput 13(1):22–30
Ferreira AJM, Castro LMS, Bertoluzza S (2011) Analysis of plates on Winkler foundation by wavelet collocation. Meccanica 46(4):865–873
Zenkour AM, Radwan AF (2012) On the simple and mixed first-order theories for functionally graded plates resting on elastic foundations. Meccanica. doi:10.1007/s11012-012-9680-9
Acknowledgements
Authors would like to thank Eng. Nadia Mazzino and Eng. Giuseppe Parente of Ansaldo STS for providing and giving the permission to edit the experimental data needed for the validation of both the physical model of the railway track and the new WIM algorithm.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Meli, E., Pugi, L. Preliminary development, simulation and validation of a weigh in motion system for railway vehicles. Meccanica 48, 2541–2565 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-013-9769-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11012-013-9769-9