-
Near-horizon properties of trajectories with finite force relevant for Bañados-Silk-West effect
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
According to the Banados-SIlk-West (BSW) effect, two particles moving towards a black hole, can collide near the horizon with an unbounded energy in the center of mass frame. This requires one of particles to have fine-tuned parameters in such a way that the time component of generalized momentum is zero $X=0$. Thus the existence of such trjectories is a necessary condition for the BSW effect. How…
▽ More
According to the Banados-SIlk-West (BSW) effect, two particles moving towards a black hole, can collide near the horizon with an unbounded energy in the center of mass frame. This requires one of particles to have fine-tuned parameters in such a way that the time component of generalized momentum is zero $X=0$. Thus the existence of such trjectories is a necessary condition for the BSW effect. However, it is insufficient since the forward-in-time condition requires $X>0$ outside the horizon. We examine this condition for different types of partricles and horizons and find configurations for which the BSW effect is possible. In doing so, we take into account a finite force of unspesified nature exerted on particles. It includes relationships between numbers characterizing the rate with which four-velocity, acceleration and metric functions change near the horizon. For some aforementioned relations, parameters of a system control the sign of $X$, in other cases they are required for $X$ to be real quantity. In the simplest case of free particles the BSW effect for the Kerr or Kerr-Newman black hole is impossible if a fine-tuned particle has a negative energy, so in this sense combination of the Penrose process and the BSW effect is forbidden.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
High energy head-on particle collisions near event horizons: classifcation of scenarios
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider head-on collisions of two particles near the event horizon. Particle 1 is outgoing, particle 2 is ingoing. We elucidate, in which case the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow unbounded. If the proper time between the horizon and an arbitrary point outside it for particle 1 is finite, we deal with a white hole. If it is infinite, we deal with a black hole. Particles c…
▽ More
We consider head-on collisions of two particles near the event horizon. Particle 1 is outgoing, particle 2 is ingoing. We elucidate, in which case the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow unbounded. If the proper time between the horizon and an arbitrary point outside it for particle 1 is finite, we deal with a white hole. If it is infinite, we deal with a black hole. Particles can be either free or experience the action of a finite force. Our results are complementary to those for the standard BSW effect when particles move in the same direction. The results rely on classification of particles developed in our previous work H.V. Ovcharenko, O.B. Zaslavskii, Phys. Rev. D 108, 064029 (2023).
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 4 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
General properties of the electric Penrose process
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the Penrose process with the charged particles in the Reissner-Nordström (RN) background. Let parent particle 0 decay to particles 1 and 2. With the assumption that all three particles move in the equatorial plane, the exact formulas for characteristics of particles 1 and 2 in terms of those of particle 0 are derived. We concentrate on scenarios in which particle 1 and 2 are ejected al…
▽ More
We consider the Penrose process with the charged particles in the Reissner-Nordström (RN) background. Let parent particle 0 decay to particles 1 and 2. With the assumption that all three particles move in the equatorial plane, the exact formulas for characteristics of particles 1 and 2 in terms of those of particle 0 are derived. We concentrate on scenarios in which particle 1 and 2 are ejected along the trajectory of particle 0. It is shown that such scenarios correspond to the extrema of energies $E_{1}$ or $E_{2}$ of daughter particles with respect to the angular momentum $L_{1}$ or $L_{2}$. We derive bounds on the values of angular momenta $L_{1}$ and $% L_{2}$. We give classification of these scenarios and discuss their properties including decay in the near-horizon region. We find that the maximum of efficiency is achieved on the horizon for some of these scenarios but not for all of them and with additional constraints on particle parameters. The results are reformulated in terms of velocities of daughter particles in the center of mass frame. The approach is applicable also to collisional Penrose process, in which a combination of particles 1 and 2 is considered as one effective particle. If the mass of particle 0 $% m_{0}\rightarrow \infty $, the situation corresponds to the Bañ% ados-Silk-West effect, the results agree with the ones known in literature before. In addition, we consider special cases when decay occurs in the turning point for one or all three particles. The formalism developed in this work has a model-independent character and applies not only to the RN metric.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
BSW phenomenon for near-fine-tuned particles with external force: general classification of scenarios
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
If two particles moving towards a black hole collide in the vicinity of the horizon, the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow indefinitely if one of particles is fine-tuned. This is the Bañados, Silk and West (BSW) effect. One of objections against this effect consists in that for some types of a horizon fine-tuned particles cannot reach the horizon. However, this difficulty can…
▽ More
If two particles moving towards a black hole collide in the vicinity of the horizon, the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow indefinitely if one of particles is fine-tuned. This is the Bañados, Silk and West (BSW) effect. One of objections against this effect consists in that for some types of a horizon fine-tuned particles cannot reach the horizon. However, this difficulty can be overcome if instead of exact fine-tuning, one of particle is nearly fine-tuned, with the value of small detuning being adjusted to the distance to the horizon. Such particles are called near-fine-tuned. We give classification of such particles and describe possible high energy scenarios of collision in which they participate. We analyze the ranges of possible motion for each type of particle and determine under which condition such particles can reach the horizon. We analyze collision energy $E_{c.m.}\,$and determine under which conditions it may grow indefinitely. We also include into consideration the forces acting on particles and find when the BSW effect with nearly-fine-tuned particles is possible with finite forces. We demonstrate that the BSW effect with particles under discussion is consistent with the principle of kinematic censorship. According to this principle, $E_{c.m.}\,$cannot be literally infinite in any event of collision (if no singularity is present), although it can be made as large as one likes.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Hot spaces with positive cosmological constant in the canonical ensemble: de Sitter solution, Schwarzschild-de Sitter black hole, and Nariai universe
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
In a space with positive cosmological constant $Λ$, we consider a black hole surrounded by a heat reservoir at radius $R$ and temperature $T$, i.e., we analyze the Schwarzschild-de Sitter black hole in a cavity. We use the Euclidean path integral approach to quantum gravity to study its canonical ensemble and thermodynamics. We give the action, energy, entropy, temperature, and heat capacity. $T$,…
▽ More
In a space with positive cosmological constant $Λ$, we consider a black hole surrounded by a heat reservoir at radius $R$ and temperature $T$, i.e., we analyze the Schwarzschild-de Sitter black hole in a cavity. We use the Euclidean path integral approach to quantum gravity to study its canonical ensemble and thermodynamics. We give the action, energy, entropy, temperature, and heat capacity. $T$, $Λ$, the black hole radius $r_+$, and the cosmological horizon radius $r_{\rm c}$, are gauged in $R$ units to $RT$, $ΛR^2$, $\frac{r_+}{R}$, and $\frac{r_{\rm c}}{R}$. The whole extension of $ΛR^2$, $0\leqΛR^2\leq 3$, is divided into three ranges. The first, $0\leqΛR^2<1$, includes York's Schwarzschild black holes. The second range, $ΛR^2=1$, opens up a folder of Nariai universes. The third range, $1<ΛR^2\leq 3$, is unusual. One feature here is that it interchanges the cosmological horizon with the black hole horizon. The end point, $ΛR^2=3$, only existing for infinite $RT$, is a cavity filled with de Sitter space, except for a singularity, with the cosmological horizon coinciding with the reservoir. For the three ranges, for low temperatures, there are no black holes and no Nariai universes, the space is hot de Sitter. The value of $RT$ that divides the nonexistence from existence of black holes or Nariai universes, depends on $ΛR^2$. For each $ΛR^2\neq1$, for high temperatures, there is one small and thermodynamically unstable black hole, and one large and stable. For $ΛR^2=1$, for high temperatures, there is the unstable black hole, and the neutrally stable Nariai universe. Phase transitions can be analyzed. The transitions are between the black hole and hot de Sitter and between Nariai and hot de Sitter. The Buchdahl radius, the radius for collapse, plays an interesting role in the analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Penrose process in Reissner-Nordström-AdS black hole spacetimes: Black hole energy factories and black hole bombs
Authors:
Duarte Feiteira,
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The Penrose process for the decay of electrically charged particles in a Reissner-Nordström-anti-de Sitter black hole spacetime is studied. To extract large quantities of energy one needs to mount a recursive Penrose process where particles are confined and can bounce back to suffer ever again a decaying process in the black hole electric ergoregion. In an asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) space…
▽ More
The Penrose process for the decay of electrically charged particles in a Reissner-Nordström-anti-de Sitter black hole spacetime is studied. To extract large quantities of energy one needs to mount a recursive Penrose process where particles are confined and can bounce back to suffer ever again a decaying process in the black hole electric ergoregion. In an asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime, two situations of confinement are possible. One situation uses a reflecting mirror at some radius, which obliges the energetic outgoing particles to return to the decaying point. The other situation uses the natural AdS property that sends back at some intrinsic returning radius those outgoing energetic particles. In addition, besides the conservation laws the decaying process must obey, one has to set conditions at the decaying point for the particles debris. These conditions restrain the possible scenarios, but there are still a great number of available scenarios for the decays. Within these, we choose two scenarios, scenario 1 and scenario 2, that pertain to the masses and electric charges of the final particles. Thus, in the mirror situation we find that scenario 1 leads to a black hole energy factory, and scenario 2 ends in a black hole bomb. In the no mirror situation, i.e., pure Reissner-Nordström-AdS, scenario 1 leads again to a black hole energy factory, but scenario 2 yields no bomb. This happens because the volume in which the particles are confined increases to infinity along the chain of decays, leading to a zero value of the extracted energy per unit volume and the bomb is demined. The whole treatment performed here involves no backreaction on the black hole mass and electric charge, nevertheless we speculate that the end state of the recursive process is a Reissner-Nordström-AdS black hole with very short hair, i.e., with one particle at rest at some definite radius.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Dynamics of redshift/blueshift during free fall under the Schwarzschild horizon
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider a free-falling observer who crosses the event horizon in the Schwarzschild background. In the course of this fall, he/she can receive signals from an object (like a star surface) that emits radiation. We study how the frequency received by an observer changes depending on the proper time on his/her trajectory. The scenarios are classified depending on whether the frequency is infinite,…
▽ More
We consider a free-falling observer who crosses the event horizon in the Schwarzschild background. In the course of this fall, he/she can receive signals from an object (like a star surface) that emits radiation. We study how the frequency received by an observer changes depending on the proper time on his/her trajectory. The scenarios are classified depending on whether the frequency is infinite, finite or zero near the singularity and the horizon. This depends crucially on the angular momenta of an observer and a photon. In this work we consider also emission process, and, as we show, conditions of emission strongly influence parameters of a photon, and thus received frequency. As one of our main results, we present numerical calculations showing evolution of the received frequency during the process of diving into a black hole, depending on parameters of an observer and emitter. We also analyze how a falling observer will see a night sky as he/she approaches the singularity. We show that there appear several blind zones, which were not analyzed previously.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
General properties of the Penrose process with neutral particles in the equatorial plane
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the background of a rotating axially symmetric black hole. Let particle 0 decay to two fragments 1 and 2 in the direction parallel to that of particle 0. It is shown that if decay occurs inside the ergoregion, both particles 1 and 2 move in the same direction as particle 0. For the scenario, when decay happens in the turning point of all three particles, we find the condition when angu…
▽ More
We consider the background of a rotating axially symmetric black hole. Let particle 0 decay to two fragments 1 and 2 in the direction parallel to that of particle 0. It is shown that if decay occurs inside the ergoregion, both particles 1 and 2 move in the same direction as particle 0. For the scenario, when decay happens in the turning point of all three particles, we find the condition when angular momenta of both particles 1 and 2 have the same sign. We elucidate the relation between the approach of Wald that imposes constraint on maximum and minimum energies of fragments and our approach. In doing so, we express the results in terms of characteristics of particle 0 and all particle masses. The conditions of the maximum efficiency depending on the relation between masses is discussed. We find an explicit expression for angular momenta of particles 1 and 2. We discuss also particle decay for static black holes, when the Penrose process is impossible. Because of the absence of the ergoregion in the static case, scenarios of decay for static black holes can significantly differ from those in the rotating background.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Quantum phenomena inside a black hole: quantization of the scalar field iniside horizon in Schwarzschild spacetime
Authors:
Pawel Gusin,
Andrzej Radosz,
Andy T. Augousti,
Janos Polonyi,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii,
Romuald J. 'Sciborski
Abstract:
We discuss the problem of the quantization and dynamic evolution of a scalar free field in the interior of a Schwarzschild black hole. A unitary approach to the dynamics of the quantized field is proposed: a time-dependent Hamiltonian governing the Heisenberg equations is derived. It is found that the system is represented by a set of harmonic oscillators coupled via terms corresponding to the cre…
▽ More
We discuss the problem of the quantization and dynamic evolution of a scalar free field in the interior of a Schwarzschild black hole. A unitary approach to the dynamics of the quantized field is proposed: a time-dependent Hamiltonian governing the Heisenberg equations is derived. It is found that the system is represented by a set of harmonic oscillators coupled via terms corresponding to the creation and annihilation of pairs of particles and that the symmetry properties of the spacetime, homogeneity and isotropy are obeyed by the coupling terms in the Hamiltonian. It is shown that Heisenberg equations for annihilation and creation operators are transformed into ordinary differential equations for appropriate Bogolyubov coefficients. Such a formulation leads to a general question concerning the possibility of gravitationally driven instability, that is however excluded in this case.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Bañados-Silk-West effect with finite forces near different types of horizons: general classification of scenarios
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
If two particles move towards a black hole and collide in the vicinity of the horizon, under certain conditions their energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow unbounded. This is the Bañados-Silk-West (BSW) effect. Usually, this effect is considered for extremal horizons and geodesic (or electrogedesic) trajectories. We study this effect in a more general context, when both geometric…
▽ More
If two particles move towards a black hole and collide in the vicinity of the horizon, under certain conditions their energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame can grow unbounded. This is the Bañados-Silk-West (BSW) effect. Usually, this effect is considered for extremal horizons and geodesic (or electrogedesic) trajectories. We study this effect in a more general context, when both geometric and dynamic factors are taken into account. We consider generic axially symmetric rotating black holes. The near-horizon behavior of metric coefficients is determined by three numbers $p,~q,$ $k$ that appear in the Taylor expansions for different types of a horizon$.$ This includes nonextremal, extremal and ultraextremal horizons. We also give general classification of possible trajectories that include so-called usual, subcritical, critical and ultracritical ones depending on the near-horizon behavior of the radial component of the four-velocity. We assume that particles move not freely but under the action of some unspecified force. We find when the finiteness of a force and the BSW effect are compatible with each other. The BSW effect implies that one of two particles has fine-tuned parameters. We show that such a particle always requires an infinite proper time for reaching the horizon. Otherwise, either a force becomes infinite or a horizon fails to be regular. This realizes the so-called principle of kinematic censorship that forbids literally infinite $E_{c.m.}$ in any act of collision. The obtained general results are illustrated for the Kerr-Newman-(anti-)de Sitter metric used as an example. The description of diversity of trajectories suggested in our work can be of use also in other contexts, beyond the BSW effect. In particular, we find the relation between a force and the type of a trajectory.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2023; v1 submitted 25 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Black holes and hot shells in the Euclidean path integral approach to quantum gravity
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We study a spherical black hole surrounded by a hot self-gravitating thin shell in the canonical ensemble, i.e., a black hole and a hot shell inside a heat reservoir acting as a boundary with its area and temperature fixed. To work out the quantum partition function, from which the thermodynamics of the system follows, we use the Euclidean path integral approach to quantum gravity that identifies…
▽ More
We study a spherical black hole surrounded by a hot self-gravitating thin shell in the canonical ensemble, i.e., a black hole and a hot shell inside a heat reservoir acting as a boundary with its area and temperature fixed. To work out the quantum partition function, from which the thermodynamics of the system follows, we use the Euclidean path integral approach to quantum gravity that identifies the path integral of the gravitational system with the partition function. In a semiclassical approximation, one needs only to compute the classical action of the system. Then, one finds that the total entropy, i.e., the sum of black hole and matter entropies, is a function of the gravitational radius of the system alone. So, the black hole inside the shell has no direct influence on the entropy. One also finds the free energy, the thermodynamic energy, and the temperature stratification. The reservoir temperature is composed of a free function of the gravitational radius of the system divided by the redshift. Upon specification of the reduced temperature free function, the solutions for the gravitational radii compatible with the data are found. The black hole inside has two possible horizon radii. It is shown that there is a first law of thermodynamics for the system, another for the hot shell, and yet another for the black hole. A thermodynamic stability analysis is performed. By specifying for the free function the Hawking temperature for the gravitational radius of the system, which is not a black hole, one finds a remarkable exact thermodynamic solution. With it one establishes that pure black holes, hot shells with a black hole, pure hot shells, and hot flat spaces are phases that cohabit in the ensemble, with some acting as thermodynamic mimickers. This exact solution is a model to situations involving black holes and hot gravitons. The high temperature limits reveal important aspects.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
On particle dynamics near the singularity inside the Schwarzschild black hole and T-spheres
Authors:
A. Radosz,
A. V. Toporensky,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The problem of the speed of the objects inside the Schwarzschild black hole is considered. The general result is that the value of the relative speed of the objects following their non-zero angular momentum trajectories, both of geodesic and non-geodesic character, when approaching the ultimate singularity, tends to the value of speed of light. There is only one exception when both objects move in…
▽ More
The problem of the speed of the objects inside the Schwarzschild black hole is considered. The general result is that the value of the relative speed of the objects following their non-zero angular momentum trajectories, both of geodesic and non-geodesic character, when approaching the ultimate singularity, tends to the value of speed of light. There is only one exception when both objects move in the same plane and have parallel angular momenta. This outcome appears to have a deeper sense: it reflects the anisotropic character of the dynamics of interior of this particular black hole. The result in question means that near the singularity, collisions of two particles lead to an indefinitely large energy in the center of mass frame. Aforementioned properties have their counterpart in the phenomenon of an indefinitely large blueshift near the singularity. Thus the angular momentum of a particle turns out to be an important feature that affects the final behavior of particle near the singularity. Motivated by this fact, we generalize the Lemaître frame under the horizon in such a way that reference particles themselves have nonzero angular momentum. Our results apply not only to the Schwarzschild singularity but also to other space-like ones for which the scale factor $g\rightarrow \infty $. We also analyze another type of singulairites for which the circumference radius vanishes but $g$ remains finite.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2023; v1 submitted 27 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Axially symmetric rotating black hole with regular horizons
Authors:
H. V. Ovcharenko,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the metric of an axially symmetric rotating black hole. We do not specify the concrete form of a metric and rely on its behavior near the horizon only. Typically, it is characterized (in the coordinates that generalize the Boyer-Lindquist ones) by two integers $p$ and $q$ that enter asymptotic expansions of the time and radial metric coefficients in the main approximation. For given…
▽ More
We consider the metric of an axially symmetric rotating black hole. We do not specify the concrete form of a metric and rely on its behavior near the horizon only. Typically, it is characterized (in the coordinates that generalize the Boyer-Lindquist ones) by two integers $p$ and $q$ that enter asymptotic expansions of the time and radial metric coefficients in the main approximation. For given $p,$ $q$ we find a general form for which the metric is regular, and how the expansions of the metric coefficients look like. We compare two types of requirement: (i) boundedness of curvature invariants, (ii) boundedness of separate components of the curvature tensor in a free falling frame. Analysis is done for nonextremal, extremal and ultraextremal horizons separately.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The Bañados-Silk-West effect with immovable particles near static black holes and its rotational counterpart
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The BSW effect implies that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame of two particles colliding near a black hole can become unbounded. Usually, it is assumed that particles move along geodesics or electrogeodesics. Instead, we consider another version of this effect. One particle is situated at rest near a static, generally speaking, distorted black hole. If another particle (say, coming…
▽ More
The BSW effect implies that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame of two particles colliding near a black hole can become unbounded. Usually, it is assumed that particles move along geodesics or electrogeodesics. Instead, we consider another version of this effect. One particle is situated at rest near a static, generally speaking, distorted black hole. If another particle (say, coming from infinity) collides with it, the energy of collision $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame grows unbounded (the BSW effect). The force required to keep such a particle near a black hole diverges for nonextremal horizons but remains finite nonzero for extremal one and vanishes in the horizon limit for ultraextremal black holes. Generalization to the rotating case implies that a particle corotates with a black hole but does not have a radial velocity. In doing so, the energy $E\rightarrow 0$, provided the angular momentum $L=0$. This condition replaces that of fine-tuning parameters in the standard version of the BSW effect.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2022; v1 submitted 7 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Confined Penrose process and black-hole bomb
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the decay of a particle with some energy $E_{0}>0$ inside the ergosphere of a black hole. After the first decay one of particles with the energy $E_{1}<0$ falls towards a black hole while the second one with $% E_{2}>E_{0}\,\ $moves in the outward direction. It bounces back from a reflecting shell and, afterwards, the process repeats. For radial motion of charged particles in the Reiss…
▽ More
We consider the decay of a particle with some energy $E_{0}>0$ inside the ergosphere of a black hole. After the first decay one of particles with the energy $E_{1}<0$ falls towards a black hole while the second one with $% E_{2}>E_{0}\,\ $moves in the outward direction. It bounces back from a reflecting shell and, afterwards, the process repeats. For radial motion of charged particles in the Reissner-Nordstöm metric, the result depends strongly on a concrete scenario. In particular, an indefinitely large growth of energy inside a shell is possible that gives rise to a black-hole bomb. We also consider a similar multiple process with neutral particles in the background of a rotating axially symmetric stationary black hole. We demonstrate that, if particle decay occurs in the turning point, a black-hole bomb in this case is impossible at all. For a generic point inside the ergoregion, there is a condition for a black-hole bomb to exist. It relates the ratio of masses before and after decay and the velocity of a fragment in the center of mass frame.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022; v1 submitted 26 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Decay of charged particles near naked singularities and super-Penrose process without fine-tuning
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the Penrose process near the naked singularity in the Reissner-Nordström metric. Particle 0 falls from infinity and decays to two fragments at some point $r_{0}$. We show that the energy extraction due to this process can be indefinitely large in the limit $r_{0}\rightarrow 0$. In doing so, the value of the particle charge can remain bounded, in contrast to the previously known example…
▽ More
We consider the Penrose process near the naked singularity in the Reissner-Nordström metric. Particle 0 falls from infinity and decays to two fragments at some point $r_{0}$. We show that the energy extraction due to this process can be indefinitely large in the limit $r_{0}\rightarrow 0$. In doing so, the value of the particle charge can remain bounded, in contrast to the previously known examples of the Penrose process in the electric field with unbounded energy extraction. The effect persists even in the limit of the flat pace-time.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2022; v1 submitted 7 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Notes on extraction of energy from an extremal Kerr-Newman black hole via charged particle collisions
Authors:
Filip Hejda,
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The so-called BSW effect is an idealised scenario for high-energy test particle collisions in the vicinity of black holes; if the black hole is extremal and one of the particles fine-tuned, the centre-of-mass collision energy can be arbitrarily high. It has been recently shown that the energy of escaping particles produced in this process can also be arbitrarily high in the given approximation, as…
▽ More
The so-called BSW effect is an idealised scenario for high-energy test particle collisions in the vicinity of black holes; if the black hole is extremal and one of the particles fine-tuned, the centre-of-mass collision energy can be arbitrarily high. It has been recently shown that the energy of escaping particles produced in this process can also be arbitrarily high in the given approximation, as long as both the black hole and the escaping particles are charged, regardless of how small the black-hole charge might be. We revisit these results and show that they are also compatible with properties of microscopic particles for the case of motion in the equatorial plane of an extremal Kerr-Newman black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Regular frames for spherically symmetric black holes revisited
Authors:
A. V. Toporensky,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider a space-time of a spherically symmetric black hole with one simple horizon. As a standard coordinate frame fails in its vicinity, this requires continuation across the horizon and constructing frames which are regular there. Up to now, several standard frames of such a kind are known. It was shown in literature before, how some of them can be united in one picture as different limits o…
▽ More
We consider a space-time of a spherically symmetric black hole with one simple horizon. As a standard coordinate frame fails in its vicinity, this requires continuation across the horizon and constructing frames which are regular there. Up to now, several standard frames of such a kind are known. It was shown in literature before, how some of them can be united in one picture as different limits of a general scheme. However, some types of frames (the Kruskal-Szekeres and Lemaître ones) and transformations to them from the original one remained completely disjoint. We show that the Kruskal-Szekeres and Lemaître frames stem from the same root. Overall, our approach in some sense completes the procedure and gives the most general scheme. We relate the parameter of transformation $e_{0}$ to the specific energy of fiducial observers and show that in the limit $% e_{0}\rightarrow 0$ a homogeneous metric under the horizon can be obtained by a smooth limiting transition.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2022; v1 submitted 18 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Particle decay, Oberth effect and a relativistic rocket in the Schwarzschild background
Authors:
Yu. V. Pavlov,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We relate the known Oberth effect and the nonrelativistic analogue of the Penrose process. When a particle decays to two fragments, we derive the conditions on the angles under which debris can come out for such a process to occur. We also consider the decay and the Oberth effect in the relativistic case, when a particle moves in the background of the Schwarzschild black hole. This models the proc…
▽ More
We relate the known Oberth effect and the nonrelativistic analogue of the Penrose process. When a particle decays to two fragments, we derive the conditions on the angles under which debris can come out for such a process to occur. We also consider the decay and the Oberth effect in the relativistic case, when a particle moves in the background of the Schwarzschild black hole. This models the process when a rocket ejects fuel. Different scenarios are analyzed depending on what data are fixed. The efficiency of the process is found, in particular, near the horizon and for a photon rocket (when the ejected particle is massless). We prove directly that the most efficient process occurs when fuel is ejected along the rocket trajectory. When this occurs on the horizon, the efficiency reaches 100% for a photon rocket. We compare in two ways how a rocket can reverse its direction of motion to a black hole near the event horizon by restoring the initial energy-to-mass ratio: (i) by a single ejection or (ii) in the two-step process when it stops and moves back afterwards. For a nonphotonic rocket, in case (ii) a larger mass can be taken out from the vicinity of a horizon. For a photonic one, there is no difference between (i) and (ii) in this respect. We also consider briefly the scenario when a rocket hangs over a black hole due to continuous ejection of fuel. Then, the fuel mass decays exponentially with the proper time.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2023; v1 submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Extraction of energy from an extremal rotating electrovacuum black hole: Particle collisions in the equatorial plane
Authors:
Filip Hejda,
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The collisional Penrose process received much attention when Banados, Silk and West (BSW) pointed out the possibility of test-particle collisions with arbitrarily high center-of-mass energy in the vicinity of the horizon of an extremally rotating black hole. However, the energy that can be extracted from the black hole in this promising, if simplified, scenario, called the BSW effect, turned out t…
▽ More
The collisional Penrose process received much attention when Banados, Silk and West (BSW) pointed out the possibility of test-particle collisions with arbitrarily high center-of-mass energy in the vicinity of the horizon of an extremally rotating black hole. However, the energy that can be extracted from the black hole in this promising, if simplified, scenario, called the BSW effect, turned out to be subject to unconditional upper bounds. And although such bounds were not found for the electrostatic variant of the process, this version is also astrophysically unfeasible, since it requires a maximally charged black hole. In order to deal with these deficiencies, we revisit the unified version of the BSW effect concerning collisions of charged particles in the equatorial plane of a rotating electrovacuum black hole spacetime. Performing a general analysis of energy extraction through this process, we explain in detail how the seemingly incompatible limiting cases arise. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the unconditional upper bounds on the extracted energy are absent for arbitrarily small values of the black hole electric charge. Therefore, our setup represents an intriguing simplified model for possible highly energetic processes happening around astrophysical black holes, which may spin fast but can have only a tiny electric charge induced via interaction with an external magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2022; v1 submitted 9 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Super-Penrose process for nonextremal black holes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider particle collisions in the background of nonextremal spherically symmetric static black holes. It is shown that debris of collision can have indefinitely large energy at infinity, i.e. the super-Penrose process (SPP) can occur. This property is sharply contrasted with that of rotating black holes for which it is already established that the SPP is forbidden. The Reissner-Nordstrom blac…
▽ More
We consider particle collisions in the background of nonextremal spherically symmetric static black holes. It is shown that debris of collision can have indefinitely large energy at infinity, i.e. the super-Penrose process (SPP) can occur. This property is sharply contrasted with that of rotating black holes for which it is already established that the SPP is forbidden. The Reissner-Nordstrom black hole serves as an example. If an external central force exerts on particles, even the Schwarzschild background is suitable for the SPP.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2021; v1 submitted 3 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
New scenarios of high-energy particle collisions near wormholes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We suggest two new scenarios of high-energy particle collisions in the background of a wormhole. In scenario 1 the novelty consists in that the effect does not require two particles coming from different mouths. Instead, all such scenarios of high energy collisions develop, when an experimenter sends particles towards a wormhole from the same side of the throat. For static wormholes, this approach…
▽ More
We suggest two new scenarios of high-energy particle collisions in the background of a wormhole. In scenario 1 the novelty consists in that the effect does not require two particles coming from different mouths. Instead, all such scenarios of high energy collisions develop, when an experimenter sends particles towards a wormhole from the same side of the throat. For static wormholes, this approach leads to indefinitely large energy in the center of mass. For rotating wormholes, it makes possible the super-Penrose process (unbounded energies measured at infinity). In scenario 2, one of colliding particles oscillates near the wormhole throat from the very beginning. In this sense, scenario 2 is intermediate between the standard one and scenario 1 since the particle under discussion does not come from infinity at all.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2020; v1 submitted 24 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Can a nonextremal black hole be a particle accelerator?
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider particle collisions in the background of a nonextremal black hole. Two particles fall from infinity, particle 1 is fine-tuned (critical), collision occurs in its turning point. The first example is the Reissner-Nordström (RN) one. If the energy at infinity $E_{1}$ is big enough, the turning point is close to the horizon. Then, we derive a simple formula according to which…
▽ More
We consider particle collisions in the background of a nonextremal black hole. Two particles fall from infinity, particle 1 is fine-tuned (critical), collision occurs in its turning point. The first example is the Reissner-Nordström (RN) one. If the energy at infinity $E_{1}$ is big enough, the turning point is close to the horizon. Then, we derive a simple formula according to which $E_{c.m.}\sim E_{1}κ^{-1/2}$, where $κ$ is a surface gravity. Thus significant growth of $E_{c.m.}$ is possible if (i) particle 1 is ultrarelativistic (if both particles are ultrarelativistic, this gives no gain as compared to collisions in flat space-time), (ii) a black hole is near-extremal (small $κ$). In the scenario of multiple collisions the energy $E_{c.m.}$ is finite in each individual collision. However, it can grow in subsequent collisions, provided new near-critical particles are heavy enough. For neutral rotating black holes, in case (i) a turning point remains far from the horizon but large $E_{c.m.}$ is still possible. Case (ii) is similar to that for collisions in the RN metric. We develop a general theoretical scheme, direct astrophysical applications can be a next step to be studied.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2020; v1 submitted 18 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Compact objects in general relativity: From Buchdahl stars to quasiblack holes
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
A Buchdahl star is a highly compact star for which the boundary radius $R$ obeys $R=\frac98 r_+$, where $r_+$ is the gravitational radius of the star itself. A quasiblack hole is a maximum compact star, or more generically a maximum compact object, for which the boundary radius $R$ obeys $R=r_+$. Quasiblack holes are objects on the verge of becoming black holes. Continued gravitational collapse en…
▽ More
A Buchdahl star is a highly compact star for which the boundary radius $R$ obeys $R=\frac98 r_+$, where $r_+$ is the gravitational radius of the star itself. A quasiblack hole is a maximum compact star, or more generically a maximum compact object, for which the boundary radius $R$ obeys $R=r_+$. Quasiblack holes are objects on the verge of becoming black holes. Continued gravitational collapse ends in black holes and has to be handled with the Oppenheimer-Snyder formalism. Quasistatic contraction ends in a quasiblack hole and should be treated with appropriate techniques. Quasiblack holes, not black holes, are the real descendants of Mitchell and Laplace dark stars. Quasiblack holes have many interesting properties. We develop the concept of a quasiblack hole, give several examples of such an object, define what it is, draw its Carter-Penrose diagram, study its pressure properties, obtain its mass formula, derive the entropy of a nonextremal quasiblack hole, and through an extremal quasiblack hole give a solution to the puzzling entropy of extremal black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020; v1 submitted 1 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Special case of the Bañados-Silk-West effect
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
If two particles collide near the rotating extremal black hole and one of them is fine-tuned, the energy in the center of mass frame $E_{c.m.}$ can grow unbounded. This is the so-called Bañados-Silk-West (BSW) effect. Recently, another type of high energy collisions was considered in which all processes happen in the Schwarzschild background with free falling particles. If the Killing energy $E$ o…
▽ More
If two particles collide near the rotating extremal black hole and one of them is fine-tuned, the energy in the center of mass frame $E_{c.m.}$ can grow unbounded. This is the so-called Bañados-Silk-West (BSW) effect. Recently, another type of high energy collisions was considered in which all processes happen in the Schwarzschild background with free falling particles. If the Killing energy $E$ of one of particle is sufficiently small, $E_{c.m.}$ grows unbounded. We show that, however, such a particle cannot be created in any precedent collision with finite energies, angular momenta and masses. Therefore, in contrast to the standard BSW effect, this one cannot be realized if initial particles fall from infinity. If the black hole is electrically charged, such a type of collisions is indeed possible, when a particle with very small $E$ collides with one more particle coming from infinity. Thus the BSW effect is achieved due to collisions of neutral particles in the background of a charged black hole. This requires, however, at least two-step process.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2020; v1 submitted 20 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Negative energy states in the Reissner-Nordström metric
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider electrogeodesics on which the energy $E<0$ in the Reissner-Nordström metric. It is shown that outside the horizon there is exactly one turning point inside the ergoregion for such particles. This entails that such a particle passes through an infinite chain of black-white hole regions or terminates in the singularity. These properties are relevant for two scenarios of high energy colli…
▽ More
We consider electrogeodesics on which the energy $E<0$ in the Reissner-Nordström metric. It is shown that outside the horizon there is exactly one turning point inside the ergoregion for such particles. This entails that such a particle passes through an infinite chain of black-white hole regions or terminates in the singularity. These properties are relevant for two scenarios of high energy collisions in which the presence of white holes is essential.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Super-Penrose process for extremal rotating neutral white holes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of two particles 1 and 2 near the horizon of the extremal rotating axially symmetric neutral generic black hole producing particles 3 and 4. We discuss the scenario in which both particles 3 and 4 fall into a black hole and move in a white hole region. If particle 1 is fine-tuned, the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the centre of mass grows unbounded (the Bañados-Silk-West effect). Then…
▽ More
We consider collision of two particles 1 and 2 near the horizon of the extremal rotating axially symmetric neutral generic black hole producing particles 3 and 4. We discuss the scenario in which both particles 3 and 4 fall into a black hole and move in a white hole region. If particle 1 is fine-tuned, the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the centre of mass grows unbounded (the Bañados-Silk-West effect). Then, particle 3 \ can, in principle, reach a flat infinity in another universe. If not only $E_{c.m.}$ but also the corresponding Killing energy $E$ is unbounded, this gives a so-called super-Penrose process (SPP). We show that the SPP\ is indeed possible. Thus white holes turn out to be potential sources of high energy fluxes that transfers from one universe to another. This generalizes recent observaitons made by Patil and Harada for the Kerr metric. We analyze two different regimes of the process on different scales.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020; v1 submitted 28 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Super-Penrose process for extremal charged white holes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of two particles 1 and 2 near the horizon of the extremal Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole that produce two other particles 3 and 4. There exists such a scenario that both new particles fall in a black hole. One of them emerges from the white hole horizon in the asymptotically flat region, the other one oscillates between turning points. However, the unbounded energies $E$…
▽ More
We consider collision of two particles 1 and 2 near the horizon of the extremal Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole that produce two other particles 3 and 4. There exists such a scenario that both new particles fall in a black hole. One of them emerges from the white hole horizon in the asymptotically flat region, the other one oscillates between turning points. However, the unbounded energies $E$ at infinity (super-Penrose process - SPP) turn out to be impossible for any finite angular momenta $L_{3.4}$. In this sense, the situation for such a white hole scenarios is opposite to the black hole ones, where the SPP is found earlier to be possible for the RN metric even for all $L_{i}=0$. However, if $L_{3,4}$ themselves are unbounded, the SPP does exist for white holes.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2020; v1 submitted 22 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Gravitational field of a pit and maximal mass defects
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
A general relativistic solution, composed of a Zel'dovich-Letelier interior made of radial strings matched through a spherical thin shell at radius $r_0$ to an exterior Schwarzschild solution with mass $m$, is presented. It is the Zel'dovich-Letelier-Schwarzschild star. When the radius $r_0$ of the star is shrunk to its gravitational radius $2m$, the solutions have interesting properties. There ar…
▽ More
A general relativistic solution, composed of a Zel'dovich-Letelier interior made of radial strings matched through a spherical thin shell at radius $r_0$ to an exterior Schwarzschild solution with mass $m$, is presented. It is the Zel'dovich-Letelier-Schwarzschild star. When the radius $r_0$ of the star is shrunk to its gravitational radius $2m$, the solutions have interesting properties. There are solutions with $m=0$ and $r_0=0$ that obey $\frac{2m}{r_0}=1$. The solutions have a horizon, but are not black holes, they are quasiblack holes, though atypical. The proper mass $m_p$ of the interior is nonzero and made of one string. Hence, a Minkowski exterior space hides an interior with matter in a pit. These are the pit solutions and show a maximal mass defect. There are two classes of pit solutions, one a finite string and the other a semi-infinite one. These pits are really string pits, that can be seen as Wheeler bags of gold, albeit squashed bags. There is another class, which is a compact stringy star at the $\frac{2m}{r_0}=1$ limit with $m$ nonzero. It is a typical quasiblack hole and it has maximal mass defect. Generically pit solutions with $\frac{2m}{r_0}=1$ and $m=0$ can exist with maximal mass defects. The Zel'dovich-Letelier-Schwarzschild star at the $r_0=2m$ limit is an instance of it. These three classes of static solutions yield the same spectrum of solutions that appear in critical gravitational collapse, there are solutions that yield naked null singularities, which here are the two string pit classes, there are solutions that yield black holes, which here are represented by the compact stringy stars at the quasiblack hole limit, and the solutions that disperse away in critical collapse here are the static Zel'dovich-Letelier-Schwarzschild stars. Thermodynamics of the string pit and stringy star quasiblack hole solutions is provided, and other connections are mentioned.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2020; v1 submitted 13 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Schwarzschild black hole as accelerator of accelerated particles
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of two particles near the horizon of a nonextremal static black hole. At least one of them is accelerated. We show that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass can become unbounded in spite of the fact that a black hole is neither rotating nor electrically charged. In particular, this happens even for the Schwarzschild black hole. The key ingredient that makes it possible…
▽ More
We consider collision of two particles near the horizon of a nonextremal static black hole. At least one of them is accelerated. We show that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass can become unbounded in spite of the fact that a black hole is neither rotating nor electrically charged. In particular, this happens even for the Schwarzschild black hole. The key ingredient that makes it possible is the presence of positive acceleration (repulsion). Then, if one of particles is fine-tuned properly, the effect takes place. This acceleration can be caused by an external force in the case of particles or some engine in the case of a macroscopic body ("rocket"). If the force is attractive, $E_{c.m.}$ is bounded but, instead, the analogue of the Penrose effect is possible.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2020; v1 submitted 9 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Redshift/blueshift inside the Schwarzschild black hole
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider an observer who moves under the horizon of the Schwarzschild black hole and absorbs a photon. There are two different situations when (i) a photon comes from infinity, (ii) it is emitted by another observer under the horizon (say, by a surface of a collapsing star). We analyze the frequency change for absorption near the event horizon, in an intermediate region and near the singularity…
▽ More
We consider an observer who moves under the horizon of the Schwarzschild black hole and absorbs a photon. There are two different situations when (i) a photon comes from infinity, (ii) it is emitted by another observer under the horizon (say, by a surface of a collapsing star). We analyze the frequency change for absorption near the event horizon, in an intermediate region and near the singularity and compare the results for both scenarios. Near the singularity, in both scenarios infinite redshift (in the pure radial case) or infinite blueshift are possible, depending on angular momenta of a photon and an observer. The main difference between both scenarios manifests itself, if photons from the star surface are emitted near the horizon and received in the intermediate region or near the singularity by the observer with a nonzero angular momentum.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2020; v1 submitted 1 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
On strategies of motion under the black hole horizon
Authors:
A. V. Toporensky,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
In this methodological paper we consider two problems an astronaut faces with under the black hole horizon in the Schwarzschild metric. 1) How to maximize the survival proper time. 2) How to make a visible part of the outer Universe as large as possible before hitting the singularity. Our consideration essentially uses the concept of peculiar velocities based on the "river model". Let an astronaut…
▽ More
In this methodological paper we consider two problems an astronaut faces with under the black hole horizon in the Schwarzschild metric. 1) How to maximize the survival proper time. 2) How to make a visible part of the outer Universe as large as possible before hitting the singularity. Our consideration essentially uses the concept of peculiar velocities based on the "river model". Let an astronaut cross the horizon from the outside. We reproduce from the first principles the known result that point 1) requires that an astronaut turn off the engine near the horizon and follow the path with the momentum equal to zero. We also show that point 2) requires maximizing the peculiar velocity of the observer. Both goals 1) and 2) require, in general, different strategies inconsistent with each other that coincide at the horizon only. The concept of peculiar velocities introduced in a direct analogy with cosmology, and its application for the problems studied in the present paper can be used in advanced general relativity courses.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2020; v1 submitted 6 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Center of mass energy of colliding electrically neutral particles and super-Penrose process
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collisions of electrically neutral particles in the background of axially symmetric rotating space-times. For reactions of the kind 1+2$% \rightarrow $3+4 we give full classification of possible scenarios based on exact expressions for dynamic characteristics of particles 3 and 4 depending on particles 1 and 2. There are five nonequivalent scenarios valid for different types of space-t…
▽ More
We consider collisions of electrically neutral particles in the background of axially symmetric rotating space-times. For reactions of the kind 1+2$% \rightarrow $3+4 we give full classification of possible scenarios based on exact expressions for dynamic characteristics of particles 3 and 4 depending on particles 1 and 2. There are five nonequivalent scenarios valid for different types of space-time (black hole, naked singularity, etc.). We are mainly interested in the situations when particle collisions can give unbounded outcome for (i) the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the center of mass frame and (ii) Killing energy $E$ at infinity. If (i) is fulfilled, this may or may not lead to (ii). If (ii) holds, this is called the super-Penrose process (SPP). For equatorial particle motion, we establish close relation between the type of behavior of $E_{c.m.}$ depending on the lapse function $% N $ in the point of collision and the possibility of the SPP. This unites separate previous observations in literature in a unified picture as a whole. In doing so, no explicit transformations to the center of mass frame and back are needed, so all consideration is carried out in the original frame. As a result,we suggest classification of sub-classes of scenarios that are able (or unable) to give rise to the SPP particle collision, super-Penrose process, center of mass frame.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019; v1 submitted 9 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Extraction of energy from an extremal rotating electrovacuum black hole: Particle collisions along the axis of symmetry
Authors:
F. Hejda,
J. Bičák,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
High-energy collisions can occur for radially moving charged test particles in the extremal Reissner-Nordström spacetime if one of the particles is fine-tuned and the collision point is taken close to the horizon. This is an analogy of the Banados-Silk-West (BSW) effect, first described for extremal Kerr black holes. However, it differs significantly in terms of energy extraction: unlike for the o…
▽ More
High-energy collisions can occur for radially moving charged test particles in the extremal Reissner-Nordström spacetime if one of the particles is fine-tuned and the collision point is taken close to the horizon. This is an analogy of the Banados-Silk-West (BSW) effect, first described for extremal Kerr black holes. However, it differs significantly in terms of energy extraction: unlike for the original BSW process, no unconditional upper bounds on mass and energy of an escaping test particle produced in the collision were found for the charged version. We show that these results can be replicated for the motion of charged test particles along the axis of a general extremal rotating electrovacuum black hole, also including the Schnittman-type process with reflected fine-tuned particles. This brings the possibility of high-energy extraction closer to astrophysical black holes, which can be fast spinning and have a small "Wald charge" due to interaction with external magnetic fields. Nevertheless, we find numerous caveats that can make the energy extraction unfeasible despite the lack of unconditional kinematic bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2019; v1 submitted 3 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Zero-momentum trajectories inside a black hole and high energy particle collisions
Authors:
A. V. Toporensky,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider properties of the trajectory with the zero momentum inside a spherically symmetric black hole. We work mostly in the Painlevé% -Gullstrand frame and use the concept of the "river model of black hole". This consept allows us to decompose (in a "cosmological manner") the geodesic motion of a test particle into a "flow" of the frame and a peculiar motion with respect to this frame. After…
▽ More
We consider properties of the trajectory with the zero momentum inside a spherically symmetric black hole. We work mostly in the Painlevé% -Gullstrand frame and use the concept of the "river model of black hole". This consept allows us to decompose (in a "cosmological manner") the geodesic motion of a test particle into a "flow" of the frame and a peculiar motion with respect to this frame. After this decomposition the application of standard formulae of special relativity for kinematic processes becomes possible. The present paper expands the notion of peculiar velocities to the region under the horzion and exploits it for the description of two physical processess - high energy collisions and redshift. Using this approach we (i) present a novel description of particle collisions occuring near black hole horizons inside the event horizon. In particular, we show that the trajectory under discussion is relevant for ultra-high energy collisions. (ii) In the framework of the river model, we derive a simple formula (both outside and inside the horizon) for the redshift in the case of radial motion. It represents the product of two factors. One of them is responsible for pure gravitational part whereas the other one gives the Doppler shift due to peculiar motion with respect to the "flow".
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2019; v1 submitted 15 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Super-Penrose process and rotating wormholes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of particles in a wormhole near its throat. Particles come from the opposite mouths. If the lapse function is small enough there, the energy $E$ of debris at infinity grows unbounded, so we are faced with the so-called super-Penrose process. This requires the existence of the ergoregion, so a wormhole should be rotating.
We consider collision of particles in a wormhole near its throat. Particles come from the opposite mouths. If the lapse function is small enough there, the energy $E$ of debris at infinity grows unbounded, so we are faced with the so-called super-Penrose process. This requires the existence of the ergoregion, so a wormhole should be rotating.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2018; v1 submitted 29 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Pure electric Penrose and super-Penrose processes in the flat space-time
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
Let a particle move in the flat space-time under the action of the electric potential. If it decays to two fragments, the energy of debris can be larger than the original energy and, moreover, the efficiency of such a process can be unbounded. This effect can be considered as a limit of the Denardo-Ruffini process near the Reissner-Nordström black hole when the gravitational constant and/or black…
▽ More
Let a particle move in the flat space-time under the action of the electric potential. If it decays to two fragments, the energy of debris can be larger than the original energy and, moreover, the efficiency of such a process can be unbounded. This effect can be considered as a limit of the Denardo-Ruffini process near the Reissner-Nordström black hole when the gravitational constant and/or black hole mass tend to zero. There are scenarios in which the energy of debris at infinity is much larger than the initial one. Comparison with other close but distinct effects is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2018; v1 submitted 16 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Black hole thermodynamics with the cosmological constant as independent variable: Bridge between the enthalpy and the Euclidean path integral approaches
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
Viewing the cosmological constant $Λ<0$ as an independent variable, we consider the thermodynamics of the Schwarzschild black hole in an anti-de Sitter (AdS) background. For this system, there is one approach which regards the enthalpy as the master thermodynamic variable and makes sense if one considers the vacuum pressure due to the cosmological constant acting in the volume inside the horizon a…
▽ More
Viewing the cosmological constant $Λ<0$ as an independent variable, we consider the thermodynamics of the Schwarzschild black hole in an anti-de Sitter (AdS) background. For this system, there is one approach which regards the enthalpy as the master thermodynamic variable and makes sense if one considers the vacuum pressure due to the cosmological constant acting in the volume inside the horizon and the outer size of the system is not restricted. From this approach a first law of thermodynamics emerges naturally. There is yet another approach based on the Euclidean action principle and its path integral that puts the black hole inside a cavity, defines a quasilocal energy at the cavity's boundary, and from which a first law of thermodynamics in a different version also emerges naturally. The first approach has affinities with critical phenomena in condensed matter physics and the second approach is an ingredient necessary for the construction of quantum gravity. The bridge between the two approaches is carried out rigorously, putting thus the enthalpic thermodynamics with $Λ$ as independent variable on the same footing as the quasilocal energy approach.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Regular frames and particle's rotation near a black hole
Authors:
Yu. V. Pavlov,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider a particle moving towards a rotating black hole. We are interested in the number of its revolution $n$ around a black hole. In our previous work (Pavlov and Zaslavskii in Gen Relativ Gravit 50: 14, 2018. arXiv:1707.02860) we considered this issue in the Boyer-Lindquist type of coordinates with a subsequent procedure of subtraction. Now, we reconsider this issue using from the very begi…
▽ More
We consider a particle moving towards a rotating black hole. We are interested in the number of its revolution $n$ around a black hole. In our previous work (Pavlov and Zaslavskii in Gen Relativ Gravit 50: 14, 2018. arXiv:1707.02860) we considered this issue in the Boyer-Lindquist type of coordinates with a subsequent procedure of subtraction. Now, we reconsider this issue using from the very beginning the frames regular on the horizon. For a nonextremal black hole, regularity of a coordinate frame leads to the finiteness of a number of revolutions around a black hole without a subtraction procedure. Meanwhile, for extremal black holes comparison of $n$ calculated in the regular frame with some subtraction procedures used by us earlier shows that the results can be different.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2019; v1 submitted 19 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Kinematic censorship as a constraint on allowed scenarios of high energy particle collisions
Authors:
Yu. V. Pavlov,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
In recent years, it was found that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the centre of mass frame of two colliding particles can be unbounded near black holes. If collision occurs exactly on the horizon, $E_{c.m.}$ is formally infinite. However, in any physically reasonable situation this is impossible. We collect different scenarios of such a kind and show why in every act of collision $E_{c.m.}$ is indeed fi…
▽ More
In recent years, it was found that the energy $E_{c.m.}$ in the centre of mass frame of two colliding particles can be unbounded near black holes. If collision occurs exactly on the horizon, $E_{c.m.}$ is formally infinite. However, in any physically reasonable situation this is impossible. We collect different scenarios of such a kind and show why in every act of collision $E_{c.m.}$ is indeed finite (although it can be as large as one likes). The factors preventing infinite energy are diverse: the necessity of infinite proper time, infinite tidal forces, potential barrier, etc. This prompts us to formulate a general principle according to which the limits in which $E_{c.m.}$ becomes infinite are never achieved. We call this the kinematic censorship (KC). Although by itself the validity of KC is quite natural, its application allows one to forbid scenarios of collisions predicting infinite $E_{c.m.}$ without going into details. The KC is valid even in the test particle approximation, so explanation of why $E_{c.m.}$ cannot be infinite, does not require references (common in literature) to the non-linear regime, backreaction, etc. The KC remains valid not only for free moving particles but also if particles experience the action of a finite force. For an individual particle, we consider a light-like continuous limit of a time-like trajectory in which the effective mass turns into zero. We show that it cannot be accelerated to an infinite energy during a finite proper time under the action of such a force. As an example, we consider dynamics of a scalar particle interacting with a background scalar field.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2019; v1 submitted 19 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Distorted vacuum black holes in the canonical ensemble
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider a vacuum static spacetime in a finite size cavity. On the boundary, we specify a metric and a finite constant local temperature $T$. No spherical or any other spatial symmetry is assumed. We show that (i) inside a cavity, only a black hole or flat spacetime are possible, whereas a curved horizonless regular space-time is excluded, (ii) in the limit when the horizon area shrinks, the Ha…
▽ More
We consider a vacuum static spacetime in a finite size cavity. On the boundary, we specify a metric and a finite constant local temperature $T$. No spherical or any other spatial symmetry is assumed. We show that (i) inside a cavity, only a black hole or flat spacetime are possible, whereas a curved horizonless regular space-time is excluded, (ii) in the limit when the horizon area shrinks, the Hawking temperature diverges, (iii) for the existence of a black hole, $T$ should be high enough. When $T\rightarrow \infty $, a black hole phase is favorable thermodynamically. Our consideration essentially uses the coordinate system introduced by Israel in his famous proof of the uniqueness theorem.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2019; v1 submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
On regular frames near rotating black holes
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider the metric of a generic axially symmetric rotating stationary black hole. The general approach is developed that enables us to construct coordinate frame regular near the horizon. As explicit examples, the Kerr and Kerr-Newmann-(anti-)de Sitter metrics are considered. It is shown how the rotational versions of the Painleve'-Gullstrand and Doran coordinates appear in this scheme as part…
▽ More
We consider the metric of a generic axially symmetric rotating stationary black hole. The general approach is developed that enables us to construct coordinate frame regular near the horizon. As explicit examples, the Kerr and Kerr-Newmann-(anti-)de Sitter metrics are considered. It is shown how the rotational versions of the Painleve'-Gullstrand and Doran coordinates appear in this scheme as particular cases. For the 2+1 version of the metric the direct generalization of the Lemaître coordinate system is obtained. It is shown that the possibility of introducing a regular frame is indirectly related to the constancy of a black hole angular velocity and the rate with which the metric coefficient responsible for the rotation of spacetime, tends to it.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2018; v1 submitted 20 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Black hole mass formula in the membrane paradigm
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
The membrane paradigm approach adopts a timelike surface, stretched out off the null event horizon, to study several important black hole properties. We use this powerful tool to give a direct derivation of the black hole mass formula in the static and stationary cases without and with electric field. Since here the membrane is a self-gravitating material system we go beyond the usual applicabilit…
▽ More
The membrane paradigm approach adopts a timelike surface, stretched out off the null event horizon, to study several important black hole properties. We use this powerful tool to give a direct derivation of the black hole mass formula in the static and stationary cases without and with electric field. Since here the membrane is a self-gravitating material system we go beyond the usual applicability on test particles and test fields of the paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2018; v1 submitted 8 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Unified approach to the entropy of an extremal rotating BTZ black hole: Thin shells and horizon limits
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Masato Minamitsuji,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
Using a thin shell, the first law of thermodynamics, and a unified approach, we study the thermodymanics and find the entropy of a (2+1)-dimensional extremal rotating Bañados-Teitelbom-Zanelli (BTZ) black hole. The shell in (2+1) dimensions, i.e., a ring, is taken to be circularly symmetric and rotating, with the inner region being a ground state of the anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime and the outer…
▽ More
Using a thin shell, the first law of thermodynamics, and a unified approach, we study the thermodymanics and find the entropy of a (2+1)-dimensional extremal rotating Bañados-Teitelbom-Zanelli (BTZ) black hole. The shell in (2+1) dimensions, i.e., a ring, is taken to be circularly symmetric and rotating, with the inner region being a ground state of the anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime and the outer region being the rotating BTZ spacetime. The extremal BTZ rotating black hole can be obtained in three different ways depending on the way the shell approaches its own gravitational or horizon radius. These ways are explicitly worked out. The resulting three cases give that the BTZ black hole entropy is either the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, $S=\frac{A_+}{4G}$, or it is an arbitrary function of $A_+$, $S=S(A_+)$, where $A_+=2πr_+$ is the area, i.e., the perimeter, of the event horizon in (2+1) dimensions. We speculate that the entropy of an extremal black hole should obey $0\leq S(A_+)\leq\frac{A_+}{4G}$. We also show that the contributions from the various thermodynamic quantities, namely, the mass, the circular velocity, and the temperature, for the entropy in all three cases are distinct. This study complements the previous studies in thin shell thermodynamics and entropy for BTZ black holes. It also corroborates the results found for a (3+1)-dimensional extremal electrically charged Reissner-Nordström black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2017; v1 submitted 25 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
On white holes as particle accelerators
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We analyze scenarios of particle collisions in the metric of a nonextremal black hole that can potentially lead to ultrahigh energy $E_{c.m.}$ in their centre of mass frame. Particle 1 comes from infinity to the black hole horizon while particle 2 emerges from a white hole region. It is shown that unbounded $E_{c.m.}$ $\ $require that particle 2 pass close to the bifurcation point. The analogy wit…
▽ More
We analyze scenarios of particle collisions in the metric of a nonextremal black hole that can potentially lead to ultrahigh energy $E_{c.m.}$ in their centre of mass frame. Particle 1 comes from infinity to the black hole horizon while particle 2 emerges from a white hole region. It is shown that unbounded $E_{c.m.}$ $\ $require that particle 2 pass close to the bifurcation point. The analogy with collisions inside the horizon is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2018; v1 submitted 25 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Number of revolutions of a particle around a black hole: Is it infinite or finite?
Authors:
Yu. V. Pavlov,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider a particle falling into a rotating black hole. Such a particle makes an infinite number of revolutions $n$ from the viewpoint of a remote observer who uses the Boyer-Lindquist type of coordinates. We examine the behavior of $n$ when it is measured with respect to a local reference frame that also rotates due to dragging effect of spacetime. The crucial point consists here in the observ…
▽ More
We consider a particle falling into a rotating black hole. Such a particle makes an infinite number of revolutions $n$ from the viewpoint of a remote observer who uses the Boyer-Lindquist type of coordinates. We examine the behavior of $n$ when it is measured with respect to a local reference frame that also rotates due to dragging effect of spacetime. The crucial point consists here in the observation that for a nonextremal black hole, the leading contributions to $n$ from a particle itself and the reference frame have the same form being in fact universal, so that divergences mutually cancel. As a result, the relative number of revolutions turns out to be finite. For the extremal black hole this is not so, $n$ can be infinite. Different choices of the local reference frame are considered, the results turn out to be the same qualitatively. For illustration, we discuss two explicit examples - rotation in the flat spacetime and in the Kerr metric.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2018; v1 submitted 10 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Thermodynamics of extremal rotating thin shells in an extremal BTZ spacetime and the extremal black hole entropy
Authors:
José P. S. Lemos,
Masato Minamitsuji,
Oleg B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
In a (2+1)-dimensional spacetime with a negative cosmological constant, the thermodynamics and the entropy of an extremal rotating thin shell, i.e., an extremal rotating ring, are investigated. The outer and inner regions are taken to be the Bañados-Teitelbom-Zanelli (BTZ) spacetime and the vacuum ground state anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime, respectively. By applying the first law of thermodynamic…
▽ More
In a (2+1)-dimensional spacetime with a negative cosmological constant, the thermodynamics and the entropy of an extremal rotating thin shell, i.e., an extremal rotating ring, are investigated. The outer and inner regions are taken to be the Bañados-Teitelbom-Zanelli (BTZ) spacetime and the vacuum ground state anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime, respectively. By applying the first law of thermodynamics to the extremal shell one shows that its entropy is an arbitrary function of the gravitational area $A_+$ alone, $S=S(A_+)$. When the shell approaches its own gravitational radius $r_+$ and turns into an extremal rotating BTZ black hole, it is found that the entropy of the spacetime remains such a function of $A_+$. It is thus vindicated, that extremal black holes, here extremal BTZ black holes, have different properties from the corresponding nonextremal black holes, which have the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy $S(A_+)= \frac{A_+}{4G}$, where $G$ is the gravitational constant. It is argued that for the extremal case $0\leq S(A_+)\leq \frac{A_+}{4G}$. Thus, rather than having just two entropies for extremal black holes, as previous results debated, 0 and $\frac{A_+}{4G}$, it is shown that extremal black holes may have a continuous range of entropies, limited by precisely those two entropies. Surely, the entropy that a particular extremal black hole picks must depend on past processes, notably on how it was formed. It is also found a remarkable relation between the third law of thermodynamics and the impossibility for a massive body to reach the velocity of light. In the procedure, it becomes clear that there are two distinct angular velocities for the shell, the mechanical and thermodynamic angular velocities. In passing, we clarify, for a static spacetime with a thermal shell, the meaning of the Tolman temperature formula at a generic radius and at the shell. (Abridged version).
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2017; v1 submitted 9 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Collisional super-Penrose process and Wald inequalities
Authors:
I. V. Tanatarov,
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of two massive particles in the equatorial plane of an axially symmetric stationary spacetime that produces two massless particles afterwards. It is implied that the horizon is absent but there is a naked singularity or another potential barrier that makes possible the head-on collision. The relationship between the energy in the center of mass frame $E_{c.m.}$ and the Killin…
▽ More
We consider collision of two massive particles in the equatorial plane of an axially symmetric stationary spacetime that produces two massless particles afterwards. It is implied that the horizon is absent but there is a naked singularity or another potential barrier that makes possible the head-on collision. The relationship between the energy in the center of mass frame $E_{c.m.}$ and the Killing energy $E$ measured at infinity is analyzed. It follows immediately from the Wald inequalities that unbounded $E$ is possible for unbounded $E_{c.m.}$ only. This can be realized if the spacetime is close to the threshold of the horizon formation. Different types of spacetimes (black holes, naked singularities, wormholes) correspond to different possible relations between $E_{c.m.}$ and $E$. We develop a general approach that enables us to describe the collision process in the frames of the stationary observer and ZAMO (zero angular momentum observer). The escape cone and escape fraction are derived. A simple explanation of the existence of the bright spot is given. For the particular case of the Kerr metric, our results agree with the previous ones found in M. Patil, T. Harada, K. Nakao, P.S. Joshi, and M. Kimura, Phys. Rev. D 93, 104015 (2016).
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2017; v1 submitted 17 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Maximum efficiency of the collisional Penrose process
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
We consider collision of two particles that move in the equatorial plane near a general stationary rotating axially symmetric extremal black hole. One of particles is critical (with fine-tuned parameters) and moves in the outward direction. The second particle (usual, not fine-tuned) comes from infinity. We examine the efficiency $η$ of the collisional Penrose process. There are two relevant cases…
▽ More
We consider collision of two particles that move in the equatorial plane near a general stationary rotating axially symmetric extremal black hole. One of particles is critical (with fine-tuned parameters) and moves in the outward direction. The second particle (usual, not fine-tuned) comes from infinity. We examine the efficiency $η$ of the collisional Penrose process. There are two relevant cases here: (i) a particle falling into a black hole after collision is heavy, (ii) it has a finite mass. We show that the maximum of $η$ in case (ii) is less or equal to that in case (i). It is argued that for superheavy particles, the bound applies to nonequatorial motion as well. As an example, we analyze collision in the Kerr-Newman background. When the bound is the same for processes (i) and (ii), $η=3$ for this metric. For the Kerr black hole, recent results in literature are reproduced.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2016; v1 submitted 3 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Schwarzschild black hole as particle accelerator of spinning particles
Authors:
O. B. Zaslavskii
Abstract:
It is shown that in the Schwarzschild background there exists direct counterpart of the Bañados-Silk-West effect for spinning particles. This means that if two particles collide near the black hole horizon, their energy in the centre of mass frame can grow unbounded. In doing so, the crucial role is played by so-called near-critical trajectories when particle's parameters are almost fine-tuned. Di…
▽ More
It is shown that in the Schwarzschild background there exists direct counterpart of the Bañados-Silk-West effect for spinning particles. This means that if two particles collide near the black hole horizon, their energy in the centre of mass frame can grow unbounded. In doing so, the crucial role is played by so-called near-critical trajectories when particle's parameters are almost fine-tuned. Direct scenario of the collision under discussion is possible with restriction on the energy-to-mass ratio \thinspace $E/m<\frac{1}{2\sqrt{3}}$ only. However, if one takes into account multiple scattering, this becomes possible for $E\geq m$ as well.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2016; v1 submitted 30 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
