-
Over-rotation coherent error in quantum gates subjected to pseudo twirling
Authors:
Tanmoy Pandit,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Quantum error mitigation schemes (QEM) have greatly enhanced the efficiency of quantum computers, specifically focusing on reducing errors caused by interactions with the environment. Nevertheless, the presence of coherence errors, typically arising from miscalibration and inter-qubit crosstalk, is a significant challenge to the scalability of quantum computing. Such errors are often addressed usi…
▽ More
Quantum error mitigation schemes (QEM) have greatly enhanced the efficiency of quantum computers, specifically focusing on reducing errors caused by interactions with the environment. Nevertheless, the presence of coherence errors, typically arising from miscalibration and inter-qubit crosstalk, is a significant challenge to the scalability of quantum computing. Such errors are often addressed using a refined Pauli twirling scheme called Randomized Compiling (RC) that converts the coherent errors into incoherent errors that can then be mitigated by conventional QEM. Unfortunately for multi-qubit gates, RC is restricted to Clifford gates such as CNOT and CPHASE. However, it has been demonstrated experimentally that a direct implementation of multi-qubit non-Clifford gates, i.e. without using multi-qubit Clifford gates, has reduced the depth of the circuit by a factor of four and more. Recently, a framework called pseudo-twirling (PST) for treating coherent error in multi-qubit non-Clifford gates has been introduced and experimentally demonstrated. We show analytically that a higher order correction to the existing PST theory yields an over-rotation coherent error generated by the PST protocol itself. This PST effect has no analogue in RC. Although the small induced over-rotation can amount to a significant coherent error in deep circuits, we explain why it does not degrade the performance of the gate.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Pseudo Twirling Mitigation of Coherent Errors in non-Clifford Gates
Authors:
Jader P. Santos,
Ben Bar,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
The conventional circuit paradigm, utilizing a limited number of gates to construct arbitrary quantum circuits, is hindered by significant noise overhead. For instance, the standard gate paradigm employs two CNOT gates for the partial CPhase rotation in the quantum Fourier transform, even when the rotation angle is very small. In contrast, some quantum computer platforms can directly implement suc…
▽ More
The conventional circuit paradigm, utilizing a limited number of gates to construct arbitrary quantum circuits, is hindered by significant noise overhead. For instance, the standard gate paradigm employs two CNOT gates for the partial CPhase rotation in the quantum Fourier transform, even when the rotation angle is very small. In contrast, some quantum computer platforms can directly implement such operations using their native interaction, resulting in considerably shorter and less noisy implementations for small rotation angles. Unfortunately, coherent errors stemming from qubit crosstalk and calibration imperfections render these implementations impractical. In Clifford gates such as the CNOT, these errors can be addressed through Pauli twirling (also known as randomized compiling). However, this technique is not applicable to the non-Clifford native implementations described above. The present work introduces, analyzes, and experimentally demonstrates a technique called `Pseudo Twirling' to address coherent errors in general gates and circuits. Additionally, we experimentally showcase that integrating pseudo twirling with a quantum error mitigation method called `Adaptive KIK' enables the simultaneous mitigation of both noise and coherent errors in non-Clifford gates. Due to its unique features pseudo twirling could become a valuable asset in enhancing the capabilities of both present and future NISQ devices.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2024; v1 submitted 17 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Realization of robust quantum noise characterization in the presence of coherent errors
Authors:
Pavel Penshin,
Tamara Amro,
Ty Zabelotsky,
Amir Abramovich,
Tanmoy Pandit,
K. I. O Ben 'Attar,
Amir Hen,
Raam Uzdin,
Nir Bar-Gill
Abstract:
Complex quantum systems and their various applications are susceptible to noise of coherent and incoherent nature. Characterization of noise and its sources is an open, key challenge in quantum technology applications, especially in terms of distinguishing between inherent incoherent noise and systematic coherent errors. In this paper, we study a scheme of repeated sequential measurements that ena…
▽ More
Complex quantum systems and their various applications are susceptible to noise of coherent and incoherent nature. Characterization of noise and its sources is an open, key challenge in quantum technology applications, especially in terms of distinguishing between inherent incoherent noise and systematic coherent errors. In this paper, we study a scheme of repeated sequential measurements that enables the characterization of incoherent errors by reducing the effects of coherent errors. We demonstrate this approach using a coherently controlled Nitrogen Vacancy in diamond, coupled to both a natural nuclear spin bath (non-Markovian) and to experimentally controlled relaxation through an optical pumping process (nearly Markovian). Our results show mitigation of coherent errors both for Markovian and Non-Markovian incoherent noise profiles. We apply this scheme to the estimation of the dephasing time ($T_2^*$) due to incoherent noise. We observe an improved robustness against coherent errors in the estimation of dephasing time ($T_2^*$) compared to the standard (Ramsey) measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 16 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Scalable evaluation of incoherent infidelity in quantum devices
Authors:
Jader P. Santos,
Ivan Henao,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Quantum processors can already execute tasks beyond the reach of classical simulation, albeit for artificial problems. At this point, it is essential to design error metrics that test the experimental accuracy of quantum algorithms with potential for a practical quantum advantage. The distinction between coherent errors and incoherent errors is crucial, as they often involve different error suppre…
▽ More
Quantum processors can already execute tasks beyond the reach of classical simulation, albeit for artificial problems. At this point, it is essential to design error metrics that test the experimental accuracy of quantum algorithms with potential for a practical quantum advantage. The distinction between coherent errors and incoherent errors is crucial, as they often involve different error suppression tools. The first class encompasses miscalibrations of control signals and crosstalk, while the latter is usually related to stochastic events and unwanted interactions with the environment. We introduce the incoherent infidelity as a measure of incoherent errors and present a scalable method for measuring it. This method is applicable to generic quantum evolutions subjected to time-dependent Markovian noise. Moreover, it provides an error quantifier for the target circuit, rather than an error averaged over many circuits or quantum gates. The estimation of the incoherent infidelity is suitable to assess circuits with sufficiently low error rates, regardless of the circuit size, which is a natural requirement to run useful computations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2024; v1 submitted 30 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Adaptive quantum error mitigation using pulse-based inverse evolutions
Authors:
Ivan Henao,
Jader P. Santos,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Quantum Error Mitigation (QEM) enables the extraction of high-quality results from the presently-available noisy quantum computers. In this approach, the effect of the noise on observables of interest can be mitigated using multiple measurements without additional hardware overhead. Unfortunately, current QEM techniques are limited to weak noise or lack scalability. In this work, we introduce a QE…
▽ More
Quantum Error Mitigation (QEM) enables the extraction of high-quality results from the presently-available noisy quantum computers. In this approach, the effect of the noise on observables of interest can be mitigated using multiple measurements without additional hardware overhead. Unfortunately, current QEM techniques are limited to weak noise or lack scalability. In this work, we introduce a QEM method termed `Adaptive KIK' that adapts to the noise level of the target device, and therefore, can handle moderate-to-strong noise. The implementation of the method is experimentally simple -- it does not involve any tomographic information or machine-learning stage, and the number of different quantum circuits to be implemented is independent of the size of the system. Furthermore, we have shown that it can be successfully integrated with randomized compiling for handling both incoherent as well as coherent noise. Our method handles spatially correlated and time-dependent noise which enables to run shots over the scale of days or more despite the fact that noise and calibrations change in time. Finally, we discuss and demonstrate why our results suggest that gate calibration protocols should be revised when using QEM. We demonstrate our findings in the IBM quantum computers and through numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Probing The Unitarity of Quantum Evolution Through Periodic Driving
Authors:
Alaina M. Green,
Tanmoy Pandit,
C. Huerta Alderete,
Norbert M. Linke,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
As quantum computers and simulators begin to produce results that cannot be verified classically, it becomes imperative to develop a variety of tools to detect and diagnose experimental errors on these devices. While state or process tomography is a natural way to characterize sources of experimental error, the intense measurement requirements make these strategies infeasible in all but the smalle…
▽ More
As quantum computers and simulators begin to produce results that cannot be verified classically, it becomes imperative to develop a variety of tools to detect and diagnose experimental errors on these devices. While state or process tomography is a natural way to characterize sources of experimental error, the intense measurement requirements make these strategies infeasible in all but the smallest of quantum systems. In this work, we formulate signatures of unitary evolution based on specific properties of periodically driven quantum systems. The absence of these signatures indicates a break either in the unitarity or periodicity condition on the evolution. We experimentally detect incoherent error on a trapped-ion quantum computer using these signatures. Our method is based on repeated measurements of a single observable, making this a low-cost evaluation of error with measurement requirements that scales according to the character of the dynamics, rather than the system size.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Catalytic leverage of correlations and mitigation of dissipation in Information erasure
Authors:
Ivan Henao,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Correlations are a valuable resource for quantum information processing and quantum thermodynamics. However, the preparation of some correlated states can carry a substantial cost that should be compared against its value. We show that classical correlations can be catalytically exploited, which enables to mitigate heat and entropy dissipation in information erasure. These correlations are natural…
▽ More
Correlations are a valuable resource for quantum information processing and quantum thermodynamics. However, the preparation of some correlated states can carry a substantial cost that should be compared against its value. We show that classical correlations can be catalytically exploited, which enables to mitigate heat and entropy dissipation in information erasure. These correlations are naturally generated by the erasure process, and thus can be considered free. Although we also show that maximum erasure with minimum dissipation and no correlations is theoretically possible, catalysts are always useful in practical erasure settings, where correlations are expected to take place.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Methods for measuring noise, purity changes, and entanglement entropy in quantum devices and systems
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
We present methods for evaluating the rate of change in quantities during quantum evolution due to coupling to the environment (dissipation hereafter). The protocol is based on repeating a given quantum circuit (or quantum operation) twice, thrice, and so on, and measuring an expectation value after each number of repetitions. We start by applying this method for measuring the rate of purity chang…
▽ More
We present methods for evaluating the rate of change in quantities during quantum evolution due to coupling to the environment (dissipation hereafter). The protocol is based on repeating a given quantum circuit (or quantum operation) twice, thrice, and so on, and measuring an expectation value after each number of repetitions. We start by applying this method for measuring the rate of purity changes in quantum circuits. This provides direct information on the quality of the circuit. Furthermore, the presented scheme enables to distill the dissipative contribution in the changes of quantities such as energies and coherence. In particular, this can be applied to the local Hamiltonians of specific qubits. Thus, our approach can be used to locate "hotspots" where the dissipation takes place. A variant of this method can be used to measure the entanglement buildup in quantum circuits. These methods are scalable as they involve only a few observables which are relatively easy to measure in NISQ devices.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Detecting heat leaks with trapped ion qubits
Authors:
Daniel Pijn,
Oleksiy Onishchenko,
Janine Hilder,
Ulrich G. Poschinger,
Ferdinand Schmidt-Kaler,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Recently, the principle of \textit{passivity} has been used to set bounds on the evolution of a microscopic quantum system with a thermal initial state. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate the utility of two passivity based frameworks: global passivity and passivity deformation, for the detection of a "hidden" or unaccounted environment. We employ two trapped-ion qubits undergoing unitary…
▽ More
Recently, the principle of \textit{passivity} has been used to set bounds on the evolution of a microscopic quantum system with a thermal initial state. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate the utility of two passivity based frameworks: global passivity and passivity deformation, for the detection of a "hidden" or unaccounted environment. We employ two trapped-ion qubits undergoing unitary evolution, which may optionally be coupled to an unobserved environment qubit. Evaluating the measurement data from the system qubits, we show that global passivity can verify the presence of a coupling to an unobserved environment - a heat leak - in a case where the second law of thermodynamics fails. We also show that passivity deformation is even more sensitive, detecting a heat leak where global passivity fails.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Thermometric machine for ultraprecise thermometry of low temperatures
Authors:
Ivan Henao,
Karen V. Hovhannisyan,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Thermal equilibrium states are exponentially hard to distinguish at very low temperatures, making equilibrium quantum thermometry in this regime a formidable task. We present a thermometric scheme that circumvents this limitation, by using a two-level probe that does not thermalize with the sample whose temperature is measured. This is made possible thanks to a suitable interaction that couples th…
▽ More
Thermal equilibrium states are exponentially hard to distinguish at very low temperatures, making equilibrium quantum thermometry in this regime a formidable task. We present a thermometric scheme that circumvents this limitation, by using a two-level probe that does not thermalize with the sample whose temperature is measured. This is made possible thanks to a suitable interaction that couples the probe to the sample and to an auxiliary thermal bath known to be at a higher temperature. Provided a reasonable upper bound on the temperature of the sample, the resulting 'thermometric machine' drives the probe towards a steady state whose signal-to-noise ratio can achieve values as high as $\mathcal{O}(1/T)$. We also characterize the transient state of the probe and numerically illustrate an extreme reduction in the number of measurements to attain a given precision, as compared to optimal measurements on a thermalized probe.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2021; v1 submitted 23 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Bounds on the recurrence probability in periodically-driven quantum systems
Authors:
Tanmoy Pandit,
Alaina M. Green,
C. Huerta Alderete,
Norbert M. Linke,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Periodically-driven systems are ubiquitous in science and technology. In quantum dynamics, even a small number of periodically-driven spins leads to complicated dynamics. Hence, it is of interest to understand what constraints such dynamics must satisfy. We derive a set of constraints for each number of cycles. For pure initial states, the observable being constrained is the recurrence probability…
▽ More
Periodically-driven systems are ubiquitous in science and technology. In quantum dynamics, even a small number of periodically-driven spins leads to complicated dynamics. Hence, it is of interest to understand what constraints such dynamics must satisfy. We derive a set of constraints for each number of cycles. For pure initial states, the observable being constrained is the recurrence probability. We use our constraints for detecting undesired coupling to unaccounted environments and drifts in the driving parameters. To illustrate the relevance of these results for modern quantum systems we demonstrate our findings experimentally on a trapped-ion quantum computer, and on various IBM quantum computers. Specifically, we provide two experimental examples where these constraints surpass fundamental bounds associated with known one-cycle constraints. This scheme can potentially be used to detect the effect of the environment in quantum circuits that cannot be classically simulated. Finally, we show that, in practice, testing an $n$-cycle constraint requires executing only $O(\sqrt{n})$ cycles, which makes the evaluation of constraints associated with hundreds of cycles realistic.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2022; v1 submitted 25 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Catalytic transformations with finite-size environments: applications to cooling and thermometry
Authors:
Ivan Henao,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
The laws of thermodynamics are usually formulated under the assumption of infinitely large environments. While this idealization facilitates theoretical treatments, real physical systems are always finite and their interaction range is limited. These constraints have consequences for important tasks such as cooling, not directly captured by the second law of thermodynamics. Here, we study catalyti…
▽ More
The laws of thermodynamics are usually formulated under the assumption of infinitely large environments. While this idealization facilitates theoretical treatments, real physical systems are always finite and their interaction range is limited. These constraints have consequences for important tasks such as cooling, not directly captured by the second law of thermodynamics. Here, we study catalytic transformations that cannot be achieved when a system exclusively interacts with a finite environment. Our core result consists of constructive conditions for these transformations, which include the corresponding global unitary operation and the explicit states of all the systems involved. From this result we present various findings regarding the use of catalysts for cooling. First, we show that catalytic cooling is always possible if the dimension of the catalyst is sufficiently large. In particular, the cooling of a qubit using a hot qubit can be maximized with a catalyst as small as a three-level system. We also identify catalytic enhancements for tasks whose implementation is possible without a catalyst. For example, we find that in a multiqubit setup catalytic cooling based on a three-body interaction outperforms standard (non-catalytic) cooling using higher order interactions. Another advantage is illustrated in a thermometry scenario, where a qubit is employed to probe the temperature of the environment. In this case, we show that a catalyst allows to surpass the optimal temperature estimation attained only with the probe.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2021; v1 submitted 18 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
The Passivity Deformation Approach for the Thermodynamics of Isolated Quantum Setups
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Saar Rahav
Abstract:
Recently implemented quantum devices such as quantum processors and quantum simulators combine highly complicated quantum dynamics with high-resolution measurements. We present a passivity deformation methodology that sets thermodynamic constraints on the evolution of such quantum devices. This framework enhances the thermodynamic predictive power by simultaneously resolving four of the cardinal d…
▽ More
Recently implemented quantum devices such as quantum processors and quantum simulators combine highly complicated quantum dynamics with high-resolution measurements. We present a passivity deformation methodology that sets thermodynamic constraints on the evolution of such quantum devices. This framework enhances the thermodynamic predictive power by simultaneously resolving four of the cardinal deficiencies of the second law in microscopic setups: i) It yields tight bounds even when the environment is microscopic; ii) The ultra-cold catastrophe is resolved; iii) It enables to integrate conservation laws into thermodynamic inequalities for making them tighter; iv) it bounds observables that are not energy-based, and therefore do not appear in the second law of thermodynamics. Furthermore, this framework provides insights to non-thermal environments, correlated environments, and to coarse-graining in microscopic setups. Our findings can be explored and used in physical setups such as trapped ions, superconducting circuits, neutral atoms in optical lattices and more.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Experimental detection of microscopic environments using thermodynamic observables
Authors:
Ivan Henao,
Raam Uzdin,
Nadav Katz
Abstract:
Modern thermodynamic theories can be used to study highly complex quantum dynamics. Here, we experimentally demonstrate that the violation of thermodynamic constraints allows to detect the coupling of a quantum system to a hidden environment. By using the IBM quantum superconducting processors, we perform thermodynamic tests to detect a qubit environment interacting with a system composed of up to…
▽ More
Modern thermodynamic theories can be used to study highly complex quantum dynamics. Here, we experimentally demonstrate that the violation of thermodynamic constraints allows to detect the coupling of a quantum system to a hidden environment. By using the IBM quantum superconducting processors, we perform thermodynamic tests to detect a qubit environment interacting with a system composed of up to four qubits. The experiments are complemented by theoretical findings that show efficient scalability of the tests with respect to system size. Hence, they may be useful to detect an open system dynamics in situations where other methods (e.g. quantum state tomography) are practically infeasible.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2021; v1 submitted 23 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Collective operations can extremely reduce work fluctuations
Authors:
Martí Perarnau-Llobet,
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
We consider work extraction from $N$ copies of a quantum system. When the same work-extraction process is implemented on each copy, the relative size of fluctuations is expected to decay as $1/\sqrt{N}$. Here, we consider protocols where the copies can be processed collectively, and show that in this case work fluctuations can disappear exponentially fast in $N$. As a consequence, a considerable p…
▽ More
We consider work extraction from $N$ copies of a quantum system. When the same work-extraction process is implemented on each copy, the relative size of fluctuations is expected to decay as $1/\sqrt{N}$. Here, we consider protocols where the copies can be processed collectively, and show that in this case work fluctuations can disappear exponentially fast in $N$. As a consequence, a considerable proportion of the average extractable work $\mathcal{W}$ can be obtained almost deterministically by globally processing a few copies of the state. This is derived in the two canonical scenarios for work extraction: (i) in thermally isolated systems, where $\mathcal{W}$ corresponds to the energy difference between initial and passive states, known as the ergotropy, and (ii) in the presence of a thermal bath, where $\mathcal{W}$ is given by the free energy difference between initial and thermal states.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2019; v1 submitted 4 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
The second law and beyond in microscopic quantum setups
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
The Clausius inequality (CI) is one of the most versatile forms of the second law. Although it was originally conceived for macroscopic steam engines, it is also applicable to quantum single particle machines. Moreover, the CI is the main connecting thread between classical microscopic thermodynamics and nanoscopic quantum thermodynamics. In this chapter, we study three different approaches for ob…
▽ More
The Clausius inequality (CI) is one of the most versatile forms of the second law. Although it was originally conceived for macroscopic steam engines, it is also applicable to quantum single particle machines. Moreover, the CI is the main connecting thread between classical microscopic thermodynamics and nanoscopic quantum thermodynamics. In this chapter, we study three different approaches for obtaining the CI. Each approach shows different aspects of the CI. The goals of this chapter are: (i) To show the exact assumptions made in various derivations of the CI. (ii) To elucidate the structure of the second law and its origin. (iii) To discuss the possibilities each approach offers for finding additional second-law like inequalities. (iv) To pose challenges related to the second law in nanoscopic setups. In particular, we introduce and briefly discuss the notions of exotic heat machines (X machines), and "lazy demons".
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Global passivity in microscopic thermodynamics
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Saar Rahav
Abstract:
The main thread that links classical thermodynamics and the thermodynamics of small quantum systems is the celebrated Clausius inequality form of the second law. However, its application to small quantum systems suffers from two cardinal problems: (i) The Clausius inequality does not hold when the system and environment are initially correlated - a commonly encountered scenario in microscopic setu…
▽ More
The main thread that links classical thermodynamics and the thermodynamics of small quantum systems is the celebrated Clausius inequality form of the second law. However, its application to small quantum systems suffers from two cardinal problems: (i) The Clausius inequality does not hold when the system and environment are initially correlated - a commonly encountered scenario in microscopic setups. (ii) In some other cases, the Clausius inequality does not provide any useful information (e.g. in dephasing scenarios). We address these deficiencies by developing the notion of global passivity and employing it as a tool for deriving thermodynamic inequalities on observables. For initially uncorrelated thermal environments the global passivity framework recovers the Clausius inequality. More generally, global passivity provides an extension of the Clausius inequality that holds even in the presences of strong initial system-environment correlations. Crucially, the present framework provides additional thermodynamic bounds on expectation values. To illustrate the role of the additional bounds we use them to detect unaccounted heat leaks and weak feedback operations ("Maxwell's demons") that the Clausius inequality cannot detect. In addition, it is shown that global passivity can put practical upper and lower bounds on the buildup of system-environment correlation for dephasing interactions. Our findings are highly relevant for experiments in various systems such as ion traps, superconducting circuits, atoms in optical cavities and more.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Experimental demonstration of quantum effects in the operation of microscopic heat engines
Authors:
James Klatzow,
Jonas N. Becker,
Patrick M. Ledingham,
Christian Weinzetl,
Krzysztof T. Kaczmarek,
Dylan J. Saunders,
Joshua Nunn,
Ian A. Walmsley,
Raam Uzdin,
Eilon Poem
Abstract:
The heat engine, a machine that extracts useful work from thermal sources, is one of the basic theoretical constructs and fundamental applications of classical thermodynamics. The classical description of a heat engine does not include coherence in its microscopic degrees of freedom. By contrast, a quantum heat engine might possess coherence between its internal states. Although the Carnot efficie…
▽ More
The heat engine, a machine that extracts useful work from thermal sources, is one of the basic theoretical constructs and fundamental applications of classical thermodynamics. The classical description of a heat engine does not include coherence in its microscopic degrees of freedom. By contrast, a quantum heat engine might possess coherence between its internal states. Although the Carnot efficiency cannot be surpassed, and coherence can be performance degrading in certain conditions, it was recently predicted that even when using only thermal resources, internal coherence can enable a quantum heat engine to produce more power than any classical heat engine using the same resources. Such a power boost therefore constitutes a quantum thermodynamic signature. It has also been shown that the presence of coherence results in the thermodynamic equivalence of different quantum heat engine types, an effect with no classical counterpart. Microscopic heat machines have been recently implemented with trapped ions, and proposals for heat machines using superconducting circuits and optomechanics have been made. When operated with standard thermal baths, however, the machines implemented so far have not demonstrated any inherently quantum feature in their thermodynamic quantities. Here we implement two types of quantum heat engines by use of an ensemble of nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond, and experimentally demonstrate both the coherence power boost and the equivalence of different heat-engine types. This constitutes the first observation of quantum thermodynamic signatures in heat machines.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2018; v1 submitted 24 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Markovian heat sources with the smallest heat capacity
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Simone Gasparinetti,
Roee Ozeri,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
Thermal Markovian dynamics is typically obtained by coupling a system to a sufficiently hot bath with a large heat capacity. Here we present a scheme for inducing Markovian dynamics using an arbitrarily small and cold heat bath. The scheme is based on injecting phase noise to the small bath. Several unique signatures of small bath are studied. We discuss realizations in ion traps and superconducti…
▽ More
Thermal Markovian dynamics is typically obtained by coupling a system to a sufficiently hot bath with a large heat capacity. Here we present a scheme for inducing Markovian dynamics using an arbitrarily small and cold heat bath. The scheme is based on injecting phase noise to the small bath. Several unique signatures of small bath are studied. We discuss realizations in ion traps and superconducting qubits and show that it is possible to create an ideal setting where the system dynamics is indifferent to the internal bath dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2017; v1 submitted 9 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Additional energy-information relations in thermodynamics of small systems
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
The Clausius inequality (CI) form of the second law of thermodynamics relates information changes (entropy) to changes in the first moment of the energy (heat and indirectly also work). Are there similar relations between other moments of the energy distribution, and other information measures, or is the Clausius inequality a one of a kind instance of the energy-information paradigm? If there are…
▽ More
The Clausius inequality (CI) form of the second law of thermodynamics relates information changes (entropy) to changes in the first moment of the energy (heat and indirectly also work). Are there similar relations between other moments of the energy distribution, and other information measures, or is the Clausius inequality a one of a kind instance of the energy-information paradigm? If there are additional relations, can they be used to make predictions on measurable quantities? Changes in the energy distribution beyond the first moment (average heat or work) are especially important in small systems which are often very far from thermal equilibrium. The generalized Clausius inequalities (GCI's), here derived, provide positive answers to the two questions above and add another layer to the fundamental connection between energy and information. To illustrate the utility of the new GCI's, we find scenarios where the GCI's yield tighter constraints on performance (e.g. in thermal machines) compared to the second law. To obtain the GCI's we use the Bregman divergence - a mathematical tool found to be highly suitable for energy-information studies. The quantum version of the GCI's provides a thermodynamic meaning to various quantum coherence measures. It is intriguing to fully map the regime of validity of the GCI's and extend the present results to more general scenarios including continuous systems and particles exchange with the baths.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2017; v1 submitted 19 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Speed limits in Liouville space for open quantum systems
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
One of the defining properties of an open quantum system is the variation of its purity in time. We derive speed limits on the rate of purity change for systems coupled to a Markovian environment. Our speed limits are based on Liouville space where density matrices are represented as vectors. This approach leads to speed limits that are always tighter compared to their parallel speed limits in Hil…
▽ More
One of the defining properties of an open quantum system is the variation of its purity in time. We derive speed limits on the rate of purity change for systems coupled to a Markovian environment. Our speed limits are based on Liouville space where density matrices are represented as vectors. This approach leads to speed limits that are always tighter compared to their parallel speed limits in Hilbert space. These bounds depend solely on the generators of the nonunitary dynamics and are independent of the particular states of the systems. Thus, they are perfectly suited to investigate dephasing, thermalization, and decorrelation processes of arbitrary states. We show that our speed limits can be attained and are therefore tight. As an application of our results we study correlation loss, and the speed of classical and quantum correlation erasure in multi-particle system.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Quantum heat machines equivalence and work extraction beyond Markovianity, and strong coupling via heat exchangers
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Amikam Levy,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
Various engine types are thermodynamically equivalent in the quantum limit of small 'engine action'. Our previous derivation of the equivalence is restricted to Markovian heat baths and to implicit classical work repository (e.g., laser light in the semi-classical approximation). In this paper all the components, baths, batteries, and engine, are explicitly taken into account. To neatly treat non-…
▽ More
Various engine types are thermodynamically equivalent in the quantum limit of small 'engine action'. Our previous derivation of the equivalence is restricted to Markovian heat baths and to implicit classical work repository (e.g., laser light in the semi-classical approximation). In this paper all the components, baths, batteries, and engine, are explicitly taken into account. To neatly treat non-Markovian dynamics we use mediating particles that function as a heat exchanger. We find that on top of the previously observed equivalence there is a higher degree of equivalence that cannot be achieved in the Markovian regime. Next we focus on the energy transfer to the work repository. A condition for zero entropy increase in the work repository is given. Moreover, it is shown that in the strong coupling regime it is possible to charge a battery with energy while reducing its entropy at the same time.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Collective operation of quantum heat machines via coherence recycling, and coherence induced reversibility
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Collective behavior where a set of elements interact and generate effects that are beyond the reach of the individual non interacting elements, are always of great interest in physics. Quantum collective effects that have no classical analogue are even more intriguing. In this work we show how to construct collective quantum heat machines and explore their performance boosts with respect to regula…
▽ More
Collective behavior where a set of elements interact and generate effects that are beyond the reach of the individual non interacting elements, are always of great interest in physics. Quantum collective effects that have no classical analogue are even more intriguing. In this work we show how to construct collective quantum heat machines and explore their performance boosts with respect to regular machines. Without interactions between the machines the individual units operate in a stochastic, non-quantum manner. The construction of the collective machine becomes possible by introducing two simple quantum operations: coherence extraction and coherence injection. Together these operations can harvest coherence from one engine and use it to boost the performance of a slightly different engine. For weakly driven engines we show that the collective work output scales quadratically with the number of engines rather than linearly. Eventually, the boost saturates and the scaling becomes linear. Nevertheless, even in saturation, work is still significantly boosted compared to individual operation. To study the reversibility of the collective machine we introduce the 'entropy pollution' measure. It is shown that there is a regime where the collective machine is N times more reversible while producing N times more work, compared to the individual operation of N units. Moreover, the collective machine can even be more reversible than the most reversible unit in the collective. This high level of reversibility becomes possible due to a special symbiotic mechanism between engine pairs.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2016; v1 submitted 21 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Quantum Equivalence and Quantum Signatures in Heat Engines
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Amikam Levy,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
Quantum heat engines (QHE) are thermal machines where the working substance is quantum. In the extreme case the working medium can be a single particle or a few level quantum system. The study of QHE has shown a remarkable similarity with the standard thermodynamical models, thus raising the issue what is quantum in quantum thermodynamics. Our main result is thermodynamical equivalence of all engi…
▽ More
Quantum heat engines (QHE) are thermal machines where the working substance is quantum. In the extreme case the working medium can be a single particle or a few level quantum system. The study of QHE has shown a remarkable similarity with the standard thermodynamical models, thus raising the issue what is quantum in quantum thermodynamics. Our main result is thermodynamical equivalence of all engine type in the quantum regime of small action. They have the same power, the same heat, the same efficiency, and they even have the same relaxation rates and relaxation modes. Furthermore, it is shown that QHE have quantum-thermodynamic signature, i.e thermodynamic measurements can confirm the presence of quantum coherence in the device. The coherent work extraction mechanism enables power outputs that greatly exceed the power of stochastic (dephased) engines.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2015; v1 submitted 23 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Purity and entropy evolution speed limits for open quantum systems
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Eric Lutz,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
We derive generic upper bounds on the rate of purity change and entropy increase for open quantum systems. These bounds depend solely on the generators of the nonunitary dynamics and are independent of the particular states of the systems. They are thus perfectly suited to investigate dephasing and thermalization processes of arbitrary systems. We apply these results to single and multiple dephasi…
▽ More
We derive generic upper bounds on the rate of purity change and entropy increase for open quantum systems. These bounds depend solely on the generators of the nonunitary dynamics and are independent of the particular states of the systems. They are thus perfectly suited to investigate dephasing and thermalization processes of arbitrary systems. We apply these results to single and multiple dephasing channels, to a problem of quantum control in the presence of noise, and to cooling.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Universal features in the efficiency of ultra hot quantum Otto engines
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
We study internal work optimization over the energy levels of a generic hot quantum Otto engine. We find universal features in the efficiency that resembles the classical external power optimization over the coupling times to the thermal baths. It is shown that in the ultra hot regime the efficiency is determined solely by the optimization constraint, and independent of the engine details. We show…
▽ More
We study internal work optimization over the energy levels of a generic hot quantum Otto engine. We find universal features in the efficiency that resembles the classical external power optimization over the coupling times to the thermal baths. It is shown that in the ultra hot regime the efficiency is determined solely by the optimization constraint, and independent of the engine details. We show that for some constraints the radius of convergence of the perturbative approach used in the classical analysis is zero even for very arbitrarily low efficiencies at small temperature difference.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
The multilevel four-stroke swap engine and its environment
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Ronnie Kosloff
Abstract:
A multilevel four-stroke engine where the thermalization stokes are generated by unitary collisions with bath particles is analyzed. Our model is solvable even when the engine operates far from thermal equilibrium and in the strong system-bath coupling. Necessary operation conditions for the heat machine to perform as an engine or a refrigerator are derived. We relate the work and efficiency of th…
▽ More
A multilevel four-stroke engine where the thermalization stokes are generated by unitary collisions with bath particles is analyzed. Our model is solvable even when the engine operates far from thermal equilibrium and in the strong system-bath coupling. Necessary operation conditions for the heat machine to perform as an engine or a refrigerator are derived. We relate the work and efficiency of the device to local and non-local statistical properties of the baths (purity, mutual coincidence etc.). In particular, we relate the Clausius inequality to the symmetrized relative entropy of the baths (Jefferys divergence). Other Clausius-like inequalities are derived as well. Finally, in the ultra-hot regime we optimize the work of the multilevel engine and obtain simpler forms for the work and efficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Time-energy tradeoff in unambiguous state discrimination POVM
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Omri Gat
Abstract:
Unambiguous non-orthogonal state discrimination has fundamental importance in quantum information and quantum cryptography. The discrimination is carried out by POVM generalized measurements. For this process, we find a tradeoff between the needed energy resources and the evolution time, and express it in terms of action-like cost inequality. We find the realization that minimizes this action-like…
▽ More
Unambiguous non-orthogonal state discrimination has fundamental importance in quantum information and quantum cryptography. The discrimination is carried out by POVM generalized measurements. For this process, we find a tradeoff between the needed energy resources and the evolution time, and express it in terms of action-like cost inequality. We find the realization that minimizes this action-like cost and show that in this case the cost is determined by the maximal population transfer from the system to the ancilla needed for the POVM implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
The role of singular values in entanglement distillation and unambiguous state discrimination
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Unambiguous (non-orthogonal) state discrimination (USD) has a fundamental importance in quantum information and quantum cryptography. Various aspects of two-state and multiple-state USD are studied here using singular value decomposition (SVD) of the evolution operator that describes a given state discriminating system. In particular, we relate the minimal angle between states to the ratio of the…
▽ More
Unambiguous (non-orthogonal) state discrimination (USD) has a fundamental importance in quantum information and quantum cryptography. Various aspects of two-state and multiple-state USD are studied here using singular value decomposition (SVD) of the evolution operator that describes a given state discriminating system. In particular, we relate the minimal angle between states to the ratio of the minimal and maximal singular values. This is supported by a simple geometrical picture in two-state USD. We apply our result to study what states can undergo entanglement distillation in a given system.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2013; v1 submitted 3 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
On the equivalence of lossy evolution and POVM generalized quantum measurements
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Loss induced generalized measurements have been introduced years ago as a mean to implement generalized quantum measurements (POVM). Here the original idea is extended to a complete equivalence of lossy evolution and a certain widely used class of POVM. This class includes POVM used for unambiguous state discrimination and entanglement concentration. One implication of this equivalence is that una…
▽ More
Loss induced generalized measurements have been introduced years ago as a mean to implement generalized quantum measurements (POVM). Here the original idea is extended to a complete equivalence of lossy evolution and a certain widely used class of POVM. This class includes POVM used for unambiguous state discrimination and entanglement concentration. One implication of this equivalence is that unambiguous state discrimination schemes based on PT-symmetric and non-Hermitian Hamiltonians have the same performance as those of standard POVM. After discussing several key points of this equivalence we illustrate our findings in two elementary physical realizations. Finally, we discuss several implications of this equivalence.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Resources needed for non-unitary quantum operations
Authors:
Raam Uzdin
Abstract:
Non-unitary operations generated by an effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian can be used to create quantum state manipulations which are impossible in Hermitian quantum mechanics. These operations include state preparation (or cooling) and non-orthogonal state discrimination. In this work we put a lower bound on the resources needed for the construction of some given non-unitary evolution. Passive s…
▽ More
Non-unitary operations generated by an effective non-Hermitian Hamiltonian can be used to create quantum state manipulations which are impossible in Hermitian quantum mechanics. These operations include state preparation (or cooling) and non-orthogonal state discrimination. In this work we put a lower bound on the resources needed for the construction of some given non-unitary evolution. Passive systems are studied in detail and a general feature of such a system is derived. After interpreting our results using the singular value decomposition, several examples are studied analytically. In particular, we put a lower bound on the resources needed for non-Hermitian state preparation and non-orthogonal state discrimination.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
A third-order exceptional point effect on the dynamics of a single particle in a time-dependent harmonic trap
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Emanuele Dalla Torre,
Ronnie Kosloff,
Nimrod Moiseyev
Abstract:
The time evolution of a single particle in a harmonic trap with time dependent frequency omega(t) is well studied. Nevertheless here we show that, when the harmonic trap is opened (or closed) as function of time while keeping the adiabatic parameter mu = [d omega(t)/dt]/omega(t)^2 fixed, a sharp transition from an oscillatory to a monotonic exponential dynamics occurs at mu = 2. At this transition…
▽ More
The time evolution of a single particle in a harmonic trap with time dependent frequency omega(t) is well studied. Nevertheless here we show that, when the harmonic trap is opened (or closed) as function of time while keeping the adiabatic parameter mu = [d omega(t)/dt]/omega(t)^2 fixed, a sharp transition from an oscillatory to a monotonic exponential dynamics occurs at mu = 2. At this transition point the time evolution has a third-order exceptional point (EP) at all instants. This situation, where an EP of a time-dependent Hermitian Hamiltonian is obtained at any given time, is very different from other known cases. Our finding is relevant to the dynamics of a single ion in a magnetic, optical, or rf trap, and of diluted gases of ultracold atoms in optical traps.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Time-dependent Hamiltonians with 100% evolution speed efficiency
Authors:
Raam Uzdin,
Uwe Guenther,
Saar Rahav,
Nimrod Moiseyev
Abstract:
The evolution speed in projective Hilbert space is considered for Hermitian Hamiltonians and for non-Hermitian (NH) ones. Based on the Hilbert-Schmidt norm and the spectral norm of a Hamiltonian, resource-related upper bounds on the evolution speed are constructed. These bounds are valid also for NH Hamiltonians and they are illustrated for an optical NH Hamiltonian and for a non-Hermitian…
▽ More
The evolution speed in projective Hilbert space is considered for Hermitian Hamiltonians and for non-Hermitian (NH) ones. Based on the Hilbert-Schmidt norm and the spectral norm of a Hamiltonian, resource-related upper bounds on the evolution speed are constructed. These bounds are valid also for NH Hamiltonians and they are illustrated for an optical NH Hamiltonian and for a non-Hermitian $\mathcal{PT}-$symmetric matrix Hamiltonian. Furthermore, the concept of quantum speed efficiency is introduced as measure of the system resources directly spent on the motion in the projective Hilbert space. A recipe for the construction of time-dependent Hamiltonians which ensure 100% speed efficiency is given. Generally these efficient Hamiltonians are NH but there is a Hermitian efficient Hamiltonian as well. Finally, the extremal case of a non-Hermitian non-diagonalizable Hamiltonian with vanishing energy difference is shown to produce a 100% efficient evolution with minimal resources consumption.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
