Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Siegmund, N

A Methodology for Evaluating RAG Systems: A Case Study On Configuration Dependency Validation

Authors: Sebastian Simon, Alina Mailach, Johannes Dorn, Norbert Siegmund

Abstract: Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is an umbrella of different components, design decisions, and domain-specific adaptations to enhance the capabilities of large language models and counter their limitations regarding hallucination and outdated and missing knowledge. Since it is unclear which design decisions lead to a satisfactory performance, developing RAG systems is often experimental and ne… ▽ More Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is an umbrella of different components, design decisions, and domain-specific adaptations to enhance the capabilities of large language models and counter their limitations regarding hallucination and outdated and missing knowledge. Since it is unclear which design decisions lead to a satisfactory performance, developing RAG systems is often experimental and needs to follow a systematic and sound methodology to gain sound and reliable results. However, there is currently no generally accepted methodology for RAG evaluation despite a growing interest in this technology. In this paper, we propose a first blueprint of a methodology for a sound and reliable evaluation of RAG systems and demonstrate its applicability on a real-world software engineering research task: the validation of configuration dependencies across software technologies. In summary, we make two novel contributions: (i) A novel, reusable methodological design for evaluating RAG systems, including a demonstration that represents a guideline, and (ii) a RAG system, which has been developed following this methodology, that achieves the highest accuracy in the field of dependency validation. For the blueprint's demonstration, the key insights are the crucial role of choosing appropriate baselines and metrics, the necessity for systematic RAG refinements derived from qualitative failure analysis, as well as the reporting practices of key design decision to foster replication and evaluation. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

On Debugging the Performance of Configurable Software Systems: Developer Needs and Tailored Tool Support

Authors: Miguel Velez, Pooyan Jamshidi, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel, Christian Kästner

Abstract: Determining whether a configurable software system has a performance bug or it was misconfigured is often challenging. While there are numerous debugging techniques that can support developers in this task, there is limited empirical evidence of how useful the techniques are to address the actual needs that developers have when debugging the performance of configurable software systems; most techn… ▽ More Determining whether a configurable software system has a performance bug or it was misconfigured is often challenging. While there are numerous debugging techniques that can support developers in this task, there is limited empirical evidence of how useful the techniques are to address the actual needs that developers have when debugging the performance of configurable software systems; most techniques are often evaluated in terms of technical accuracy instead of their usability. In this paper, we take a human-centered approach to identify, design, implement, and evaluate a solution to support developers in the process of debugging the performance of configurable software systems. We first conduct an exploratory study with 19 developers to identify the information needs that developers have during this process. Subsequently, we design and implement a tailored tool, adapting techniques from prior work, to support those needs. Two user studies, with a total of 20 developers, validate and confirm that the information that we provide helps developers debug the performance of configurable software systems. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

VEER: Enhancing the Interpretability of Model-based Optimizations

Authors: Kewen Peng, Christian Kaltenecker, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel, Tim Menzies

Abstract: Many software systems can be tuned for multiple objectives (e.g., faster runtime, less required memory, less network traffic or energy consumption, etc.). Optimizers built for different objectives suffer from "model disagreement"; i.e., they have different (or even opposite) insights and tactics on how to optimize a system. Model disagreement is rampant (at least for configuration problems). Yet p… ▽ More Many software systems can be tuned for multiple objectives (e.g., faster runtime, less required memory, less network traffic or energy consumption, etc.). Optimizers built for different objectives suffer from "model disagreement"; i.e., they have different (or even opposite) insights and tactics on how to optimize a system. Model disagreement is rampant (at least for configuration problems). Yet prior to this paper, it has barely been explored. This paper shows that model disagreement can be mitigated via VEER, a one-dimensional approximation to the N-objective space. Since it is exploring a simpler goal space, VEER runs very fast (for eleven configuration problems). Even for our largest problem (with tens of thousands of possible configurations), VEER finds as good or better optimizations with zero model disagreements, three orders of magnitude faster (since its one-dimensional output no longer needs the sorting procedure). Based on the above, we recommend VEER as a very fast method to solve complex configuration problems, while at the same time avoiding model disagreement. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2023; v1 submitted 4 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 27 pages, 7 figures, 4 tables, accepted by EMSE

ACM Class: D.2; K.6.3

White-Box Performance-Influence Models: A Profiling and Learning Approach

Authors: Max Weber, Sven Apel, Norbert Siegmund

Abstract: Many modern software systems are highly configurable, allowing the user to tune them for performance and more. Current performance modeling approaches aim at finding performance-optimal configurations by building performance models in a black-box manner. While these models provide accurate estimates, they cannot pinpoint causes of observed performance behavior to specific code regions. This does n… ▽ More Many modern software systems are highly configurable, allowing the user to tune them for performance and more. Current performance modeling approaches aim at finding performance-optimal configurations by building performance models in a black-box manner. While these models provide accurate estimates, they cannot pinpoint causes of observed performance behavior to specific code regions. This does not only hinder system understanding, but it also complicates tracing the influence of configuration options to individual methods. We propose a white-box approach that models configuration-dependent performance behavior at the method level. This allows us to predict the influence of configuration decisions on individual methods, supporting system understanding and performance debugging. The approach consists of two steps: First, we use a coarse-grained profiler and learn performance-influence models for all methods, potentially identifying some methods that are highly configuration- and performance-sensitive, causing inaccurate predictions. Second, we re-measure these methods with a fine-grained profiler and learn more accurate models, at higher cost, though. By means of 9 real-world Java software systems, we demonstrate that our approach can efficiently identify configuration-relevant methods and learn accurate performance-influence models. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

White-Box Analysis over Machine Learning: Modeling Performance of Configurable Systems

Authors: Miguel Velez, Pooyan Jamshidi, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel, Christian Kästner

Abstract: Performance-influence models can help stakeholders understand how and where configuration options and their interactions influence the performance of a system. With this understanding, stakeholders can debug performance behavior and make deliberate configuration decisions. Current black-box techniques to build such models combine various sampling and learning strategies, resulting in tradeoffs bet… ▽ More Performance-influence models can help stakeholders understand how and where configuration options and their interactions influence the performance of a system. With this understanding, stakeholders can debug performance behavior and make deliberate configuration decisions. Current black-box techniques to build such models combine various sampling and learning strategies, resulting in tradeoffs between measurement effort, accuracy, and interpretability. We present Comprex, a white-box approach to build performance-influence models for configurable systems, combining insights of local measurements, dynamic taint analysis to track options in the implementation, compositionality, and compression of the configuration space, without relying on machine learning to extrapolate incomplete samples. Our evaluation on 4 widely-used, open-source projects demonstrates that Comprex builds similarly accurate performance-influence models to the most accurate and expensive black-box approach, but at a reduced cost and with additional benefits from interpretable and local models. △ Less

Submitted 13 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication at ICSE'21

Predicting Performance of Software Configurations: There is no Silver Bullet

Authors: Alexander Grebhahn, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel

Abstract: Many software systems offer configuration options to tailor their functionality and non-functional properties (e.g., performance). Often, users are interested in the (performance-)optimal configuration, but struggle to find it, due to missing information on influences of individual configuration options and their interactions. In the past, various supervised machine-learning techniques have been u… ▽ More Many software systems offer configuration options to tailor their functionality and non-functional properties (e.g., performance). Often, users are interested in the (performance-)optimal configuration, but struggle to find it, due to missing information on influences of individual configuration options and their interactions. In the past, various supervised machine-learning techniques have been used to predict the performance of all configurations and to identify the optimal one. In the literature, there is a large number of machine-learning techniques and sampling strategies to select from. It is unclear, though, to what extent they affect prediction accuracy. We have conducted a comparative study regarding the mean prediction accuracy when predicting the performance of all configurations considering 6 machine-learning techniques, 18 sampling strategies, and 6 subject software systems. We found that both the learning technique and the sampling strategy have a strong influence on prediction accuracy. We further observed that some learning techniques (e.g., random forests) outperform other learning techniques (e.g., k-nearest neighbor) in most cases. Moreover, as the prediction accuracy strongly depends on the subject system, there is no combination of a learning technique and sampling strategy that is optimal in all cases, considering the tradeoff between accuracy and measurement overhead, which is in line with the famous no-free-lunch theorem. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

ConfigCrusher: Towards White-Box Performance Analysis for Configurable Systems

Authors: Miguel Velez, Pooyan Jamshidi, Florian Sattler, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel, Christian Kastner

Abstract: Stakeholders of configurable systems are often interested in knowing how configuration options influence the performance of a system to facilitate, for example, the debugging and optimization processes of these systems. Several black-box approaches can be used to obtain this information, but they either sample a large number of configurations to make accurate predictions or miss important performa… ▽ More Stakeholders of configurable systems are often interested in knowing how configuration options influence the performance of a system to facilitate, for example, the debugging and optimization processes of these systems. Several black-box approaches can be used to obtain this information, but they either sample a large number of configurations to make accurate predictions or miss important performance-influencing interactions when sampling few configurations. Furthermore, black-box approaches cannot pinpoint the parts of a system that are responsible for performance differences among configurations. This article proposes ConfigCrusher, a white-box performance analysis that inspects the implementation of a system to guide the performance analysis, exploiting several insights of configurable systems in the process. ConfigCrusher employs a static data-flow analysis to identify how configuration options may influence control-flow statements and instruments code regions, corresponding to these statements, to dynamically analyze the influence of configuration options on the regions' performance. Our evaluation on 10 configurable systems shows the feasibility of our white-box approach to more efficiently build performance-influence models that are similar to or more accurate than current state of the art approaches. Overall, we showcase the benefits of white-box performance analyses and their potential to outperform black-box approaches and provide additional information for analyzing configurable systems. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2020; v1 submitted 6 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Finding Faster Configurations using FLASH

Authors: Vivek Nair, Zhe Yu, Tim Menzies, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel

Abstract: Finding good configurations for a software system is often challenging since the number of configuration options can be large. Software engineers often make poor choices about configuration or, even worse, they usually use a sub-optimal configuration in production, which leads to inadequate performance. To assist engineers in finding the (near) optimal configuration, this paper introduces FLASH, a… ▽ More Finding good configurations for a software system is often challenging since the number of configuration options can be large. Software engineers often make poor choices about configuration or, even worse, they usually use a sub-optimal configuration in production, which leads to inadequate performance. To assist engineers in finding the (near) optimal configuration, this paper introduces FLASH, a sequential model-based method, which sequentially explores the configuration space by reflecting on the configurations evaluated so far to determine the next best configuration to explore. FLASH scales up to software systems that defeat the prior state of the art model-based methods in this area. FLASH runs much faster than existing methods and can solve both single-objective and multi-objective optimization problems. The central insight of this paper is to use the prior knowledge (gained from prior runs) to choose the next promising configuration. This strategy reduces the effort (i.e., number of measurements) required to find the (near) optimal configuration. We evaluate FLASH using 30 scenarios based on 7 software systems to demonstrate that FLASH saves effort in 100% and 80% of cases in single-objective and multi-objective problems respectively by up to several orders of magnitude compared to the state of the art techniques. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2018; v1 submitted 7 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

On the Relation of External and Internal Feature Interactions: A Case Study

Authors: Sergiy Kolesnikov, Norbert Siegmund, Christian Kästner, Sven Apel

Abstract: Detecting feature interactions is imperative for accurately predicting performance of highly-configurable systems. State-of-the-art performance prediction techniques rely on supervised machine learning for detecting feature interactions, which, in turn, relies on time consuming performance measurements to obtain training data. By providing information about potentially interacting features, we can… ▽ More Detecting feature interactions is imperative for accurately predicting performance of highly-configurable systems. State-of-the-art performance prediction techniques rely on supervised machine learning for detecting feature interactions, which, in turn, relies on time consuming performance measurements to obtain training data. By providing information about potentially interacting features, we can reduce the number of required performance measurements and make the overall performance prediction process more time efficient. We expect that the information about potentially interacting features can be obtained by statically analyzing the source code of a highly-configurable system, which is computationally cheaper than performing multiple performance measurements. To this end, we conducted a qualitative case study in which we explored the relation between control-flow feature interactions (detected through static program analysis) and performance feature interactions (detected by performance prediction techniques using performance measurements). We found that a relation exists, which can potentially be exploited to predict performance interactions. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2018; v1 submitted 20 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Transfer Learning for Performance Modeling of Configurable Systems: An Exploratory Analysis

Authors: Pooyan Jamshidi, Norbert Siegmund, Miguel Velez, Christian Kästner, Akshay Patel, Yuvraj Agarwal

Abstract: Modern software systems provide many configuration options which significantly influence their non-functional properties. To understand and predict the effect of configuration options, several sampling and learning strategies have been proposed, albeit often with significant cost to cover the highly dimensional configuration space. Recently, transfer learning has been applied to reduce the effort… ▽ More Modern software systems provide many configuration options which significantly influence their non-functional properties. To understand and predict the effect of configuration options, several sampling and learning strategies have been proposed, albeit often with significant cost to cover the highly dimensional configuration space. Recently, transfer learning has been applied to reduce the effort of constructing performance models by transferring knowledge about performance behavior across environments. While this line of research is promising to learn more accurate models at a lower cost, it is unclear why and when transfer learning works for performance modeling. To shed light on when it is beneficial to apply transfer learning, we conducted an empirical study on four popular software systems, varying software configurations and environmental conditions, such as hardware, workload, and software versions, to identify the key knowledge pieces that can be exploited for transfer learning. Our results show that in small environmental changes (e.g., homogeneous workload change), by applying a linear transformation to the performance model, we can understand the performance behavior of the target environment, while for severe environmental changes (e.g., drastic workload change) we can transfer only knowledge that makes sampling more efficient, e.g., by reducing the dimensionality of the configuration space. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: To appear in 32nd IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE 2017), 12 pages

Transfer Learning for Improving Model Predictions in Highly Configurable Software

Authors: Pooyan Jamshidi, Miguel Velez, Christian Kästner, Norbert Siegmund, Prasad Kawthekar

Abstract: Modern software systems are built to be used in dynamic environments using configuration capabilities to adapt to changes and external uncertainties. In a self-adaptation context, we are often interested in reasoning about the performance of the systems under different configurations. Usually, we learn a black-box model based on real measurements to predict the performance of the system given a sp… ▽ More Modern software systems are built to be used in dynamic environments using configuration capabilities to adapt to changes and external uncertainties. In a self-adaptation context, we are often interested in reasoning about the performance of the systems under different configurations. Usually, we learn a black-box model based on real measurements to predict the performance of the system given a specific configuration. However, as modern systems become more complex, there are many configuration parameters that may interact and we end up learning an exponentially large configuration space. Naturally, this does not scale when relying on real measurements in the actual changing environment. We propose a different solution: Instead of taking the measurements from the real system, we learn the model using samples from other sources, such as simulators that approximate performance of the real system at low cost. We define a cost model that transform the traditional view of model learning into a multi-objective problem that not only takes into account model accuracy but also measurements effort as well. We evaluate our cost-aware transfer learning solution using real-world configurable software including (i) a robotic system, (ii) 3 different stream processing applications, and (iii) a NoSQL database system. The experimental results demonstrate that our approach can achieve (a) a high prediction accuracy, as well as (b) a high model reliability. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2017; v1 submitted 1 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: To be published in the proceedings of the 12th International Symposium on Software Engineering for Adaptive and Self-Managing Systems (SEAMS'17)

Using Bad Learners to find Good Configurations

Authors: Vivek Nair, Tim Menzies, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel

Abstract: Finding the optimally performing configuration of a software system for a given setting is often challenging. Recent approaches address this challenge by learning performance models based on a sample set of configurations. However, building an accurate performance model can be very expensive (and is often infeasible in practice). The central insight of this paper is that exact performance values (… ▽ More Finding the optimally performing configuration of a software system for a given setting is often challenging. Recent approaches address this challenge by learning performance models based on a sample set of configurations. However, building an accurate performance model can be very expensive (and is often infeasible in practice). The central insight of this paper is that exact performance values (e.g. the response time of a software system) are not required to rank configurations and to identify the optimal one. As shown by our experiments, models that are cheap to learn but inaccurate (with respect to the difference between actual and predicted performance) can still be used rank configurations and hence find the optimal configuration. This novel \emph{rank-based approach} allows us to significantly reduce the cost (in terms of number of measurements of sample configuration) as well as the time required to build models. We evaluate our approach with 21 scenarios based on 9 software systems and demonstrate that our approach is beneficial in 16 scenarios; for the remaining 5 scenarios, an accurate model can be built by using very few samples anyway, without the need for a rank-based approach. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2017; v1 submitted 19 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 11 figures

Faster Discovery of Faster System Configurations with Spectral Learning

Authors: Vivek Nair, Tim Menzies, Norbert Siegmund, Sven Apel

Abstract: Despite the huge spread and economical importance of configurable software systems, there is unsatisfactory support in utilizing the full potential of these systems with respect to finding performance-optimal configurations. Prior work on predicting the performance of software configurations suffered from either (a) requiring far too many sample configurations or (b) large variances in their predi… ▽ More Despite the huge spread and economical importance of configurable software systems, there is unsatisfactory support in utilizing the full potential of these systems with respect to finding performance-optimal configurations. Prior work on predicting the performance of software configurations suffered from either (a) requiring far too many sample configurations or (b) large variances in their predictions. Both these problems can be avoided using the WHAT spectral learner. WHAT's innovation is the use of the spectrum (eigenvalues) of the distance matrix between the configurations of a configurable software system, to perform dimensionality reduction. Within that reduced configuration space, many closely associated configurations can be studied by executing only a few sample configurations. For the subject systems studied here, a few dozen samples yield accurate and stable predictors - less than 10% prediction error, with a standard deviation of less than 2%. When compared to the state of the art, WHAT (a) requires 2 to 10 times fewer samples to achieve similar prediction accuracies, and (b) its predictions are more stable (i.e., have lower standard deviation). Furthermore, we demonstrate that predictive models generated by WHAT can be used by optimizers to discover system configurations that closely approach the optimal performance. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2017; v1 submitted 27 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 26 pages, 6 figures

CoinCalc -- A new R package for quantifying simultaneities of event series

Authors: Jonathan F. Siegmund, Nicole Siegmund, Reik V. Donner

Abstract: We present the new R package CoinCalc for performing event coincidence analysis (ECA), a novel statistical method to quantify the simultaneity of events contained in two series of observations, either as simultaneous or lagged coincidences within a user-specific temporal tolerance window. The package also provides different analytical as well as surrogate-based significance tests (valid under diff… ▽ More We present the new R package CoinCalc for performing event coincidence analysis (ECA), a novel statistical method to quantify the simultaneity of events contained in two series of observations, either as simultaneous or lagged coincidences within a user-specific temporal tolerance window. The package also provides different analytical as well as surrogate-based significance tests (valid under different assumptions about the nature of the observed event series) as well as an intuitive visualization of the identified coincidences. We demonstrate the usage of CoinCalc based on two typical geoscientific example problems addressing the relationship between meteorological extremes and plant phenology as well as that between soil properties and land cover. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.