-
Coarse computability, the density metric, Hausdorff distances between Turing degrees, perfect trees, and reverse mathematics
Authors:
Denis R. Hirschfeldt,
Carl G. Jockusch, Jr.,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
The coarse similarity class $[A]$ of $A$ is the set of all $B$ whose symmetric difference with $A$ has asymptotic density 0. There is a natural metric $δ$ on the space $\mathcal{S}$ of coarse similarity classes defined by letting $δ([A],[B])$ be the upper density of the symmetric difference of $A$ and $B$. We study the resulting metric space, showing in particular that between any two distinct poi…
▽ More
The coarse similarity class $[A]$ of $A$ is the set of all $B$ whose symmetric difference with $A$ has asymptotic density 0. There is a natural metric $δ$ on the space $\mathcal{S}$ of coarse similarity classes defined by letting $δ([A],[B])$ be the upper density of the symmetric difference of $A$ and $B$. We study the resulting metric space, showing in particular that between any two distinct points there are continuum many geodesic paths. We also study subspaces of the form $\{[A] : A \in \mathcal U\}$ where $\mathcal U$ is closed under Turing equivalence, and show that there is a tight connection between topological properties of such a space and computability-theoretic properties of $\mathcal U$.
We then define a distance between Turing degrees based on Hausdorff distance in this metric space. We adapt a proof of Monin to show that the distances between degrees that occur are exactly 0, 1/2, and 1, and study which of these values occur most frequently in the senses of measure and category. We define a degree to be attractive if the class of all degrees at distance 1/2 from it has measure 1, and dispersive otherwise. We study the distribution of attractive and dispersive degrees. We also study some properties of the metric space of Turing degrees under this Hausdorff distance, in particular the question of which countable metric spaces are isometrically embeddable in it, giving a graph-theoretic sufficient condition.
We also study the computability-theoretic and reverse-mathematical aspects of a Ramsey-theoretic theorem due to Mycielski, which in particular implies that there is a perfect set whose elements are mutually 1-random, as well as a perfect set whose elements are mutually 1-generic.
Finally, we study the completeness of $(\mathcal S,δ)$ from the perspectives of computability theory and reverse mathematics.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Asymptotic Density and the Theory of Computability: A partial survey
Authors:
Carl G. Jockusch Jr.,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
In this article we survey the development of generic and coarse computability and the main results on how classical asymptotic density interacts with the theory of computability.
In this article we survey the development of generic and coarse computability and the main results on how classical asymptotic density interacts with the theory of computability.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Computational complexity and the conjugacy problem
Authors:
Alexei Miasnikov,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
The conjugacy problem for a finitely generated group $G$ is the two-variable problem of deciding for an arbitrary pair $(u,v)$ of elements of $G$, whether or not $u$ is conjugate to $v$ in $G$. We construct examples of finitely generated, computably presented groups such that for every element $u_0$ of $G$, the problem of deciding if an arbitrary element is conjugate to $u_0$ is decidable in quadr…
▽ More
The conjugacy problem for a finitely generated group $G$ is the two-variable problem of deciding for an arbitrary pair $(u,v)$ of elements of $G$, whether or not $u$ is conjugate to $v$ in $G$. We construct examples of finitely generated, computably presented groups such that for every element $u_0$ of $G$, the problem of deciding if an arbitrary element is conjugate to $u_0$ is decidable in quadratic time but the worst-case complexity of the global conjugacy problem is arbitrary: it can be any c.e. Turing degree , can exactly mirror the Time Hierarchy Theorem, or can be $\mathcal{NP}$-complete. Our groups also have the property that the conjugacy problem is generically linear time: that is, there is a linear time partial algorithm for the conjugacy problem whose domain has density $1$, so hard instances are very rare. We also consider the complexity relationship of the "half-conjugacy" problem to the conjugacy problem. In the last section we discuss the extreme opposite situation: groups with algorithmically finite conjugation.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Asymptotic density and the coarse computability bound
Authors:
Denis R. Hirschfeldt,
Carl G. Jockusch, Jr.,
Timothy H. McNicholl,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
For $r \in [0,1]$ we say that a set $A \subseteq ω$ is \emph{coarsely computable at density} $r$ if there is a computable set $C$ such that $\{n : C(n) = A(n)\}$ has lower density at least $r$. Let $γ(A) = \sup \{r : A \hbox{ is coarsely computable at density } r\}$. We study the interactions of these concepts with Turing reducibility. For example, we show that if $r \in (0,1]$ there are sets…
▽ More
For $r \in [0,1]$ we say that a set $A \subseteq ω$ is \emph{coarsely computable at density} $r$ if there is a computable set $C$ such that $\{n : C(n) = A(n)\}$ has lower density at least $r$. Let $γ(A) = \sup \{r : A \hbox{ is coarsely computable at density } r\}$. We study the interactions of these concepts with Turing reducibility. For example, we show that if $r \in (0,1]$ there are sets $A_0, A_1$ such that $γ(A_0) = γ(A_1) = r$ where $A_0$ is coarsely computable at density $r$ while $A_1$ is not coarsely computable at density $r$. We show that a real $r \in [0,1]$ is equal to $γ(A)$ for some c.e.\ set $A$ if and only if $r$ is left-$Σ^0_3$. A surprising result is that if $G$ is a $Δ^0_2$ $1$-generic set, and $A \leq\sub{T} G$ with $γ(A) = 1$, then $A$ is coarsely computable at density $1$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Coarse Reducibility and Algorithmic Randomness
Authors:
Denis R. Hirschfeldt,
Carl G. Jockusch Jr.,
Rutger Kuyper,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
A coarse description of a subset A of omega is a subset D of omega such that the symmetric difference of A and D has asymptotic density 0. We study the extent to which noncomputable information can be effectively recovered from all coarse descriptions of a given set A, especially when A is effectively random in some sense. We show that if A is 1-random and B is computable from every coarse descrip…
▽ More
A coarse description of a subset A of omega is a subset D of omega such that the symmetric difference of A and D has asymptotic density 0. We study the extent to which noncomputable information can be effectively recovered from all coarse descriptions of a given set A, especially when A is effectively random in some sense. We show that if A is 1-random and B is computable from every coarse description D of A, then B is K-trivial, which implies that if A is in fact weakly 2-random then B is computable. Our main tool is a kind of compactness theorem for cone-avoiding descriptions, which also allows us to prove the same result for 1-genericity in place of weak 2-randomness. In the other direction, we show that if A is a 1-random set which Turing-reduces to 0', then there is a noncomputable c.e. set computable from every coarse description of A, but that not all K-trivial sets are computable from every coarse description of some 1-random set. We study both uniform and nonuniform notions of coarse reducibility. A set Y is uniformly coarsely reducible to X if there is a Turing functional Phi such that if D is a coarse description of X, then Phi^D is a coarse description of Y. A set B is nonuniformly coarsely reducible to A if every coarse description of A computes a coarse description of B. We show that a certain natural embedding of the Turing degrees into the coarse degrees (both uniform and nonuniform) is not surjective. We also show that if two sets are mutually weakly 3-random, then their coarse degrees form a minimal pair, in both the uniform and nonuniform cases, but that the same is not true of every pair of relatively 2-random sets, at least in the nonuniform coarse degrees.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Multipass automata and group word problems
Authors:
Tullio Ceccherini-Silberstein,
Michel Coornaert,
Francesca Fiorenzi,
Paul E. Schupp,
Nicholas W. M. Touikan
Abstract:
We introduce the notion of multipass automata as a generalization of pushdown automata and study the classes of languages accepted by such machines. The class of languages accepted by deterministic multipass automata is exactly the Boolean closure of the class of deterministic context-free languages while the class of languages accepted by nondeterministic multipass automata is exactly the class o…
▽ More
We introduce the notion of multipass automata as a generalization of pushdown automata and study the classes of languages accepted by such machines. The class of languages accepted by deterministic multipass automata is exactly the Boolean closure of the class of deterministic context-free languages while the class of languages accepted by nondeterministic multipass automata is exactly the class of poly-context-free languages, that is, languages which are the intersection of finitely many context-free languages. We illustrate the use of these automata by studying groups whose word problems are in the above classes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2015; v1 submitted 29 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Asymptotic Density and Computably Enumerable Sets
Authors:
Rodney G. Downey,
Carl G. Jockusch Jr.,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
We study connections between classical asymptotic density and c.e. sets. We prove that a c.e. Turing degree d is not low if and only if d contains a c.e. set A of density 1 which has no computable subsets of density 1, giving a natural characterization of non-low c.e. degrees. In contrast, we prove that every nonzero c.e. degree contains a set which is generically computable but not coarsely compu…
▽ More
We study connections between classical asymptotic density and c.e. sets. We prove that a c.e. Turing degree d is not low if and only if d contains a c.e. set A of density 1 which has no computable subsets of density 1, giving a natural characterization of non-low c.e. degrees. In contrast, we prove that every nonzero c.e. degree contains a set which is generically computable but not coarsely computable. There is a very close connection between the computational complexity of a set and the computational complexity of its density as a real number where we measure complexity of real numbers as the position of their left Dedekind cuts in the Arithmetic Hierarchy. We characterize the lower densities, upper densities and densities of both computable and computably enumerable sets. We also study "computable at density r" where r is an arbitrary real number in the unit interval. Finally, we study connections between density and classical smallness notions such as immunity and cohesiveness.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Groups, Graphs, Languages, Automata, Games and Second-order Monadic Logic
Authors:
Tullio Ceccherini-Silberstein,
Michel Coornaert,
Francesca Fiorenzi,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
In this paper we survey some surprising connections between group theory, the theory of automata and formal languages, the theory of ends, infinite games of perfect information, and monadic second-order logic.
In this paper we survey some surprising connections between group theory, the theory of automata and formal languages, the theory of ends, infinite games of perfect information, and monadic second-order logic.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
-Generic Computability, Turing Reducibility and Asymptotic Density
Authors:
Carl G. Jockusch Jr.,
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
Generic computability has been studied in group theory and we now study it in the context of classical computability theory. A set A of natural numbers is generically computable if there is a partial computable function f whose domain has density 1 and which agrees with the characteristic function of A on its domain. A set A is coarsely computable if there is a computable set C such that the symme…
▽ More
Generic computability has been studied in group theory and we now study it in the context of classical computability theory. A set A of natural numbers is generically computable if there is a partial computable function f whose domain has density 1 and which agrees with the characteristic function of A on its domain. A set A is coarsely computable if there is a computable set C such that the symmetric difference of A and C has density 0. We prove that there is a c.e. set which is generically computable but not coarsely computable and vice versa. We show that every nonzero Turing degree contains a set which is not coarsely computable. We prove that there is a c.e. set of density 1 which has no computable subset of density 1. As a corollary, there is a generically computable set A such that no generic algorithm for A has computable domain. We define a general notion of generic reducibility in the spirt of Turing reducibility and show that there is a natural order-preserving embedding of the Turing degrees into the generic degrees which is not surjective.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Coxeter Groups, 2-Completion, Perimeter Reduction and Subgroup Separability
Authors:
Paul E. Schupp
Abstract:
We show that all groups in a very large class of Coxeter groups are locally quasiconvex and have uniform membership problem solvable in quadratic time. If a group in the class satisfies a further hypothesis it is subgroup separable and relevant homomorphisms are also calculable in quadratic time.
The algorithm also decides if a finitely generated subgroup has finite index.
We show that all groups in a very large class of Coxeter groups are locally quasiconvex and have uniform membership problem solvable in quadratic time. If a group in the class satisfies a further hypothesis it is subgroup separable and relevant homomorphisms are also calculable in quadratic time.
The algorithm also decides if a finitely generated subgroup has finite index.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2002;
originally announced March 2002.
