-
Amicus Plato, sed magis amica veritas: There is a reproducibility crisis in COVID-19 Computational Fluid Dynamics studies
Authors:
Khalid M. Saqr
Abstract:
There is overwhelming evidence on SARS-CoV-2 Airborne Transmission (AT) in the ongoing COVID-19 outbreak. It is extraordinarily difficult, however, to deduce a generalized framework to assess the relative airborne transmission risk with respect to other modes. This is due to the complex biophysics entailed in such phenomena. Since the SARS outbreak in 2002, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) has b…
▽ More
There is overwhelming evidence on SARS-CoV-2 Airborne Transmission (AT) in the ongoing COVID-19 outbreak. It is extraordinarily difficult, however, to deduce a generalized framework to assess the relative airborne transmission risk with respect to other modes. This is due to the complex biophysics entailed in such phenomena. Since the SARS outbreak in 2002, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) has been one of the main tools scientists used to investigate AT of respiratory viruses. Now, CFD simulations produce intuitive and physically plausible colour-coded results that help scientists understand SARS-CoV-2 airborne transmission patterns. In addition to validation requirements, for any CFD model to be of epistemic value to the scientific community; it must be reproducible. In 2020, more than 45 published studies investigated SARS-CoV-2 airborne transmission in different scenarios using CFD. Here, I systematically review the published CFD studies of COVID-19 and discuss their reproducibility criteria with respect to the CFD modeling process. Using a Weighted Scoring Model (WSM), I propose a novel reproducibility index for CFD simulations of SARS-CoV-2 AT. The proposed index $(0 \leq R^{CFD}_j \leq 1)$ relies on three reproducibility criteria comprising 10 elements that represent the possibility of a CFD study (j) to be reproduced. Frustratingly, only 3 of 23 studies (13%) achieved full reproducibility index $(R^{CFD}_j\geq 0.9)$ while the remaining 87% were found generally irreproducible $(R^{CFD}_j<0.9)$. Without reproducible models, the scientific benefit of CFD simulations will remain hindered, fragmented and limited. In conclusion, I call the scientific community to apply more rigorous measures on reporting and publishing CFD simulations in COVID-19 research.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Physiologic Blood Flow is Turbulent: Revisiting the Principles of Vascular Hemodynamics
Authors:
Khalid M. Saqr,
Simon Tupin,
Sherif Rashad,
Toshiki Endo,
Kuniyasu Niizuma,
Teiji Tominaga,
Makoto Ohta
Abstract:
Contemporary paradigm of vascular hemodynamics considers normal blood flow to be pulsatile laminar flow. Transition to turbulence can cause diseases such as atherosclerosis or brain aneurysms. Recently, we demonstrated the existence of turbulence in experimental models of brain aneurysm; in the aneurysm sac as well as in the main artery. Thus, we were intrigued to explore if such a long-standing a…
▽ More
Contemporary paradigm of vascular hemodynamics considers normal blood flow to be pulsatile laminar flow. Transition to turbulence can cause diseases such as atherosclerosis or brain aneurysms. Recently, we demonstrated the existence of turbulence in experimental models of brain aneurysm; in the aneurysm sac as well as in the main artery. Thus, we were intrigued to explore if such a long-standing assumption of the laminarity of blood flow could be challenged. We have used methods and tools from chaos theory, hydrodynamic stability theory and turbulence physics to explore the existence of turbulence in normal vascular blood flow. We used Womersley exact solution of the Navier-Stokes equation with the HaeMed database of physiologic blood flow measurements, to offer reproducible evidence for our findings, as well as evidence from Doppler ultrasound measurements from healthy volunteers. The tools we used to investigate the properties of blood turbulence are well established in the fields of chaos theory, hydrodynamic stability and turbulence dynamics. We show, evidently, that blood flow is inherently chaotic and turbulent and not laminar. We propose a paradigm shift in the theory of vascular hemodynamics which requires rethinking the hemodynamic-biologic links governing physiologic and pathologic processes.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2020; v1 submitted 10 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
A Novel Kuhnian Ontology for Epistemic Classification of STM Scholarly Articles
Authors:
Khalid M. Saqr,
Abdelrahman Elsharawy
Abstract:
Thomas Kuhn proposed his paradigmatic view of scientific discovery five decades ago. The concept of paradigm has not only explained the progress of science, but has also become the central epistemic concept among STM scientists. Here, we adopt the principles of Kuhnian philosophy to construct a novel ontology aims at classifying and evaluating the impact of STM scholarly articles. First, we explai…
▽ More
Thomas Kuhn proposed his paradigmatic view of scientific discovery five decades ago. The concept of paradigm has not only explained the progress of science, but has also become the central epistemic concept among STM scientists. Here, we adopt the principles of Kuhnian philosophy to construct a novel ontology aims at classifying and evaluating the impact of STM scholarly articles. First, we explain how the Kuhnian cycle of science describes research at different epistemic stages. Second, we show how the Kuhnian cycle could be reconstructed into modular ontologies which classify scholarly articles according to their contribution to paradigm-centred knowledge. The proposed ontology and its scenarios are discussed. To the best of the authors knowledge, this is the first attempt for creating an ontology for describing scholarly articles based on the Kuhnian paradigmatic view of science.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Non-Kolmogorov Turbulence and Inverse Energy Cascade in Intracranial Aneurysm: Near-Wall Scales Suggest Mechanobiological Relevance
Authors:
Simon Tupin,
Khalid M. Saqr,
Sherif Rashad,
Kuniyasu Niizuma,
Makoto Ohta,
Teiji Tominaga
Abstract:
The genesis, growth and rupture of intracranial aneurysm (IA) are open questions in neurovascular medicine until the present moment. The complexity of aneurysm mechanobiology and pathobiology staggeringly combine intertwining biological and physical processes that are tightly connected. Recently, transition to turbulence in IA blood flow is thought to play a central role in IA growth and rupture a…
▽ More
The genesis, growth and rupture of intracranial aneurysm (IA) are open questions in neurovascular medicine until the present moment. The complexity of aneurysm mechanobiology and pathobiology staggeringly combine intertwining biological and physical processes that are tightly connected. Recently, transition to turbulence in IA blood flow is thought to play a central role in IA growth and rupture as it can be directly linked to endothelial dysfunction. However, the problem of turbulence brings unprecedented complications to the topic. We found turbulence in IA to be of non-Kolmogorov type. For the first time, we detected inverse kinetic energy cascade in blood flow and in non-Kolmogorov turbulence. Here, we hypothesize that the near-wall turbulence undergoing inverse energy cascade have scales that could affect the mechano-signaling of endothelial cells. Our findings could be a paradigm shift in the contemporary theory of aneurysm hemodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.